1 h 28 min · 3,587 words · 15 July 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching explains that anger and envy arise from desire, which is rooted in self-grasping and self-cherishing, and so should be traced to their source rather than only countered temporarily. It then examines how the I appears to self-grasping as existing within the five aggregates, shows it cannot be found there, and concludes that the I is a mere imputation, so that afflictions can be weakened. A question and answer session follows.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 28m
UUID: 23aea275-0356-4d74-9172-e7cb14624c47
Date: 2015-07-15
Words: 3,583
As Je Rinpoche, Je Tsongkhapa says in his Compendium of Realizations, If one does not strive at understanding the thoughts of the truth of suffering, how can one generate How can one wish for a wish for liberation? And indeed, an understanding of the thoughts of the noble truth of suffering is the goal of the path of the being of the middling scope. So when it is said if one does not strive at reflecting on the noble truth of suffering, what is referred to here is an identification of the noble truth of suffering and its defects. And this can simply be put as the afflictions. So in this context, we can see for ourselves that when our mind is under the sway of afflictions such as anger or envy for instance, our mind is not at ease.
So when our mind falls under the sway of anger or envy, then it is clear that our mind is troubled and afflicted. And the difficulties which we encounter can be in general twofold. They can be physical or mental. Now clearly, physical difficulties do not concern us in this context. When anger arises within our mind, probably it does not harm our body or physical aggregates.
Now when anger arises within our mind, in other words, within our mental consciousness, how does it harm our mind? It harms it through troubling it. So when we look at the basis of imputation of the person or the I, in other words the five aggregates. The first aggregate is the form aggregate and the remaining four aggregates are mental or consciousness. What can harm precisely the first aggregate or the form aggregate?
It is impediments to food, to good sustenance, and so forth, which harm directly the form aggregate. In other words, exterior phenomena harm the form aggregate. So in brief, dharma is unrelated to, any attempts to eliminate difficulties or harm to one’s form aggregate or one’s body. This is related to exterior material objects. So how does one precisely eliminate mental hardship or mental problems?
This is something all of us understand clearly. As a root of these problems are afflictions such as anger or envy, jealousy. Then if we eliminate anger or envy, we eliminate these problems. It is extremely important to be aware of the fact that anger or envy for that matter are not continually present within our mental continuum. They arise occasionally incidentally.
This is extremely important. All of us are fully aware of the thoughts of anger, of envy, or of desire. Then are you yourselves aware of the thoughts of anger, envy, or desire within your minds? If you are, the wish to be free from them, to be liberated from them will arise naturally. All of us therefore have firsthand experience of anger, of envy and so forth.
And when they are present from the depths of our mind, we have a natural wish to be free freed from them. Now it is difficult to generate a wish to be freed from cyclic existence in general for us. But it is quite straightforward to generate a wish to be freed from anger or from envy. All we need to do is to see the faults of these afflictions and to see these faults as faults. Then in dependence on this, a wish to be liberated will arise.
It is difficult for us to generate the mind which wishes to be freed from the totality of cyclic existence. There is an immeasurable, innumerable number of afflictions, but it is much more straightforward for us to generate the wish to be freed from anger and envy within our own mental continuum. These are very coarse afflictions and all living beings from insects upwards are fully aware of their thoughts. It is a very different affair to see the thoughts of desire since desire focuses on the five objects of the five senses, and one must see the thoughts of these five objects to see the thoughts of desire. So this is something one hears, I myself hear quite frequently.
Yes, yes, this liberation. How precisely do we strive for liberation? Then to strive for liberation, one must see the faults of desire. Who sees the faults of desire? Desire focuses on the five exterior sense objects.
Who sees the thoughts of the five exterior sense objects? We all love them. Then instead, we should focus on the thoughts of anger, the thoughts of envy. This is simple and evident. This is very clearly explained in Buddhist scriptures in which desire is compared to oil which infuses a piece of fabric.
Once a piece of fabric is stained with oil, you basically can’t clean it and have to toss it in the fire. The other afflictions such as anger and envy are compared to dirt or dust which can easily be cleaned from a piece of fabric. cyclic existence or the afflictions, I would like to propose to you anger and envy. I assume all of you understand the thoughts of anger and envy. When anger arises, we face difficulties, don’t we?
When powerful anger arises, one becomes almost inarticulate. One what one should say first, one says last. When one should say last, one says first. One becomes inarticulate. Then anger and envy probably are not present continually within our mind streams.
Unfortunately, it is perhaps the opposite for desire. There are numerous forms of desire, coarse and subtle, and desire suffuses our mind stream. So anger and envy are present within the mind streams of every single one of us. And even though they might not be present right now, we would be unable to decide now. I will not allow them to arise later since they will arise by themselves As is said in the root text of Vinaya, out of inappropriate behavior arise afflictions like anger.
Then having decided that we wish to get rid of anger and of envy, we have to analyze the nature of anger and envy. Are they permanent or are they impermanent? In as much as they are occasional and arise from time to time, they are impermanent. They are impermanent because they are occasional. If they were permanent, they could not be eliminated.
We would just have to give up. Then it is a given since they are transitory that they are impermanent, and this is the way one should think about them. It is the way someone who studies things as opposed to someone who just folds his hands and prays out of faith, which leads nowhere. So once we understand that envy and anger are impermanent, then we can see they arise from causes and conditions. So we have to examine the origin, the source of anger and of envy.
And when I say the origin and the source, I refer to the origin and the source within ourselves, not some sort of strange origin and source out there. Then you even find in some scriptures a comments to the effect that anger and envy can be traced back to previous lives. This is very far indeed. Anger and envy are present within our mind streams in this life. To take an example, it is similar to the situation of a country which is experiencing huge floods.
When a country experiences huge floods, instead of addressing the problem at the end, in other words, in the area experiencing the floods and trying to evacuate the water which is almost inexhaustible as a process since more water keeps coming in, one should instead trace the source of the floods and act at the source. Likewise, with anger and envy, it is important to trace anger and envy back to their source. And in as much as they are contingent, they can be eliminated. It is important to understand that if we just apply temporary remedies such as forbearance to eliminate anger and reflecting on the qualities of other to eliminate envy, we will never eradicate them from the root. It is the root which must must be eradicated.
When we try to find the origin of anger and of envy, its source is desire. Now it is a bit awkward to say that desire is the direct cause of anger and envy. It is definitely the indirect cause. So I have no doubt that you understand what anger and envy are based on personal experience. And if we trace them back to their source, which is desire, then we can understand the thoughts of desire, can’t we?
So we can see therefore that anger and envy find their source in desire. What in turn is source of desire? The source of desire is self-cherishing and grasping at a self. How does this proceed? Through grasping at a self, in turn, we grasp at the mine.
And the mine includes our relatives and our friends, our family. That which is close to us gives rise to desire and that which is the opposite of this, which harms us, gives rise to anger and animosity. Then the fact that anger and envy find their root in self grasping and the view of the transitory composite is something which is asserted by all of the scholars of ancient India. We find this in Dharmakīrti’s Pramanavartika. We find this in Candrakīrti’s Madhyamakāvatāra.
We find this in Āryadeva’s Chatuhshataka. These great beings understood this not through scripture, but through experience combined with reasoning. And for ourselves, these passages must be analyzed carefully in the light of our own experience to see whether they are concordant with experience and reality or not. We have to reflect over and again. So the mode of generation of the afflictions, I shall not enter in detail into it as explained in Lamrim Chenmo.
One passes from self grasping to desire, which eventually gives rise to anger and envy. So having traced the root of anger and envy to desire, we now have to find within our own continuum the root of desire, which is none other than self grasping, self-cherishing, or the sense of I and mine. It is important for us to understand at present the mode of abiding of this state of mind. What is it exactly? Is it a form?
Is it matter in other words? Or is it consciousness? If it’s consciousness, what type of consciousness is it? This is something we have to endeavor to understand. Now we have heard numerous teachings repeatedly on self grasping, self-cherishing, the view of the transitory composite and so forth.
So at present, in the context of generating the motivation, we should reflect on the fact that self grasping is a state of mind and our goal must be to weaken it. Now we cannot weaken it by bludgeoning it as minds do not respond well to this. Instead, we have to find its mode of abiding and understanding that envy and anger are rooted in desire and desire is rooted in self grasping and in grasping at the mine, we should try to reduce them. If we are able to abandon them, all the better, but at the very least, we should reduce them. So this is how one should proceed.
Otherwise, if one says generate the motivation and one’s not quite sure what to generate, this is of limited benefit. Therefore, we should try to weaken self grasping, weaken self-cherishing. If possible, abandon it. Whether we are able to do this or not, it is sure that in the effort we will gain a vast collection of merit. Let us generate this one.
So in a nutshell, all of the afflictions, anger, greed and so forth find their source or connect ultimately to self grasping and to the sense of the I. So when we refer to the I here, we refer to the accumulator of karma and the experience of the fruition of karma. Whereas when we refer to self grasping, we refer to the transitory composite. This is a consciousness. So since this self grasping is a mistaken mode of apprehension, its mode of grasping is at odds or discordant with the nature of the object.
I would therefore like to ask you to listen carefully to the explanations I will give during the next couple of minutes. Try not to drift off and fall asleep thinking, here we go again. It’s more of the same. Alright. I’m not gonna talk about this a long time, less than ten minutes.
So not long. I think four minutes exactly. So when we refer to self grasping or the apprehension of a self, what is this? This is a consciousness. Now how precisely does the mind to which I, I appears, understand or apprehend this mind?
This mind understands or apprehend the apprehend the I as existing within the basis of imputation of this I which are the five aggregates. Now this I is seen as the accumulator of karma and the experience of the fruition of karma, but it is thought of as existing within the five aggregates. So when we refer to self grasping, how precisely does I, I appear to the mind which experiences the I? This I appears to the mind of self grasping as if it existed from its own side within the five aggregates which are its basis of imputation. So let us examine carefully how the I appears to the mind of self grasping.
The eye appears as if it were existing within the five aggregates, which are its basis of imputation. These five aggregates are the form, sensation, discrimination, compositional factor, and consciousness aggregate. If we examine how the I seems to exist within the form aggregate, we can see that there is a contradiction in terms. This I is unfindable in any part of the form aggregate from the head to the soles of the feet. When we say for instance, I eat or I sleep, it is not the head which eats or sleeps.
Then, clearly, the I cannot be found within the form aggregate. Can it be found within the remaining four mental aggregates? Sensation, discrimination, composition of factors, and consciousness. No, it cannot. We are beings with five limbs.
These five limbs cannot be found within the four mental aggregates. Then we might think this I maybe does not exist. It cannot be found in the aggregates. It cannot be found outside of the aggregates nor can it be found within the aggregates. Yet this I, which is the imputed phenomena on the basis of imputation, definitely exists.
It exists based on our own experience. Somebody eats, somebody walks, somebody sleeps. So this I cannot be found within the five aggregates which are its basis of imputation. Yet it exists. What is its mode of existence?
Its mode of existence is that of a mere imputation out there on the basis of the aggregates. The emptiness or the absence of an I which is to be found within the five aggregates is emptiness. Self grasping the view of the transitory composite is a mistaken mind because although this I which appears to exist within the five aggregates, which are its basis of imputation, does not exist within those five aggregates, it appears to self grasping as existing within the five aggregates. Therefore, it is a mistaken mind. Therefore, the I exists as a mere imputation on the basis of imputation which are the five aggregates.
The absence of a clear lucid I within these five aggregates, that is emptiness. So all phenomena as well as the I do not exist in the way in which they appear to exist. They are therefore said to be illusion like. If they are illusion like, they are not stable. They are not something we can rely upon.
And this naturally leads to a weakening of the affliction desire and so forth can be put aside. What happened? It’s finished. Then let us meditate three minutes on what I explained and then I will take questions. So when we look at your translator, Lotzawa, and we say, ah, this is a Lotzawa, this is a translator, then we think somehow it is within the aggregates of the translator.
But when we examine who it is who eats, who sleeps, who walks, who meditates, we find we cannot find the Lotzawa. We cannot find him within the head. We cannot find him within the ear. It’s not the ear which eats or meditates. So where is the Lotso?
Okay. There’s no worry. So, I will take your questions at present. Make them short and concise, please. Thank you.
I’ve got no problem identifying in my mind stream what coarse desire is, but what would be an instance of subtle desire? So desire is more or less coarse in function of what its basis of generation the contaminated aggregates is. And another? Indeed. There we go.
More of an observation than a question. Please tell Geshe-la that scientists who study the mind have been looking for the self in the brain for a very long time now, and they can’t find it either. It’s not because they’re not looking hard enough. Same thing. Whatever phenomenon we consider when we try to find the imputed phenomenon within the basis of imputation, imputation, it is unfindable.
Andy? Is it possible to have that experience of the unfindability of the self within the aggregates, but immediately, the self comes back in again? How do we hold that experience? So first and foremost, the danger when one meditates on the unfindability of the I is to succumb to the wrong view that there is no I at all. In other words, that there is no basis for the performance of karma and the experience of the fruition of karma.
Therefore, one must first think there is an I and then investigate once again if the I imputed phenomenon can be found within its basis of imputation or not. There’s great significance in what you say since this is how one should look at things. Just as the I is unfindable within the aggregates which are its basis of imputation, likewise, all phenomena are unfindable within their basis of imputation and are illusion like. Then you should meditate. And between the sessions, you should study and then return to your meditation.
And this interaction of study and meditation will lead you forwards. Then when one has gained a lot of habituation with this, whatever phenomena appears to the mind is immediately seen as empty. In other words, as unstable, as unreliable, as illusion like. To use a practical example, so when Dae Chen says to me, where’s mommy? Where’s mommy?
And mommy is has left the room. She is finding the conventional existence of her mommy, Jamyang, on the basis of her imputation. She is finding the conventional existence of her mother unfindable. Conventional existence. Based on her desire for her mother’s company, she looks for her mother.
Is this correct? The understanding of emptiness is not easy. Another above emptiness. When meditating on emptiness, how can I get a sense of dependent origination at the same time? Emptiness is precisely dependent origination.
Therefore, when meditating on the unfindability of the I within the aggregates, one realizes that the eye is a mere conceptual imputation on the aggregates. In other words, the I arises as a mere conceptual imputation. That arising is the arising with dependent arising. So you’ve got to hold it to this chin. To my chin.
Okay. And table is none other than the designation is a mere designation on the form aggregate comprising the elements comprising what we designate as table. Is that correct? For the table is composed of the four elements, the four elements are not the basis of designation or imputation of the table. The table and the basis of imputation or designation are one and the same.
No. Is it appropriate to ask what is the mode of abiding of the basis of designation or the basis of imputation? In as much as the I arises in dependence on the aggregates, which are its basis of designation, the aggregates, which are the basis of designation of the eye, depend on the eye. But the idea of the idea of a basis of designation or the basis of imputation, the idea of what is its mode of abiding. There are many bases, you know, there are many bases of designation.
They’re the bases of designation of the I. There’s the bases of designation of the table. There’s the bases of designation of of the sand mandala. What is what is sort of the ontological status of a base of the idea of a basis of designation? Is it merely a concept?
Does it have any mode of abiding beyond the fact that it’s a concept? So if you take the example of your translator, when you look at the translator, you see the form aggregate of the translator and in dependence on that form aggregate, you impute translator or Lotsawa on this basis. That means that the form aggregate is one of the basis of imputation of the translator. Likewise, if we look at this little table, when we see the square of the table, we impute table on that square. Therefore, that squareness is the basis of imputation of table.
All right. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.