1 h 32 min · 2,177 words · 4 March 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching distinguishes physical happiness and suffering, which arise from the five sense consciousnesses and worldly conditions, from mental happiness and suffering, which arise within the mind. It explains that Lamrim practice aims to eliminate mental suffering by eradicating self-cherishing and its root, ignorance grasping at the self. The talk includes a question and answer session on related points such as self-cherishing, compassion and the difference from desire.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 33m
UUID: 366201ab-77ba-4bac-a792-5aa16fb1b1a6
Date: 2015-03-04
Words: 2,173
Mhmm. So it is important to think about things in these terms. Having been born in this world, we engage in action. The goal of action is to actualize our happiness and to free us from suffering. Then any action we engage in by definition is for dispelling suffering and actualizing happiness.
This is the reason for which we listen, in other words study the Lamrim. We study the Lamrim to put it in practice and that practice is to dispel suffering and to actualize happiness. When we say that Dharma practice enables one to actualize happiness and to dispel suffering, why is this the case? This calls for careful analysis. There are actually two types of happinesses and there are two types of suffering.
The two types of happinesses are physical and mental happiness and the two types of suffering are physical and mental suffering. Then through careful analysis we can clearly differentiate these two. Dharma practice enables one to realize mental happiness and to dispel mental suffering. Worldly activities enable us to realize physical happiness and to dispel physical suffering. Their spheres, their realms of operation are completely different and there is nothing else but these two.
Very important, this situation, this subject. Then this distinction is critical. Let us take an example to show what happens if this distinction is not made and there is confusion. Let us imagine someone who has heard that Dharma practice is a way of being happy and of eliminating suffering. And this person suffers, let us say, from diabetes, which as you know is incurable.
Then this person to heal himself from diabetes practices Dharma. Then one does encounter a lot of those people, doesn’t one? So this such a person will study the Lamrim thinking that through studying the Lamrim and meditating on it, he or she will be able to cure himself or herself from diabetes. And the years pass and obviously, you know, he or she is not cured from diabetes. And at a certain point, this person stops in their tracks and says, well, I was told that dharma enabled one to actualize happiness and eliminate suffering.
That’s absolute nonsense. I still have diabetes. Such a situation does happen, doesn’t it? So diseases such as, diabetes and so forth are physical diseases. There is probably no relation at all with dharma.
It is therefore extremely important to be able to differentiate clearly between mental happiness and physical happiness on the one hand and mental suffering and physical suffering on the other hand. This is critical to study Lamrim correctly. Therefore, I would like to ask you a question. I would like you to define in terms of your own understanding the nature of mental happiness, the nature of mental suffering, the nature of physical happiness, and the nature of physical suffering and the difference. Then can you explain to me how physical happiness arises?
And then can you explain to me how mental happiness arises? It is really important to be able to make this difference. Then if you can’t make this difference, all our work so far on the path of the being of the small and the middling scope is completely wasted. This one has to understand. You have an answer.
Then in that case, it will be good to think about this for a couple of minutes. Mhmm. Can you remember? Oh, yeah. I’m so dizzy.
Would say that physical happiness is being healthy, having adequate shelter, adequate food, pain free, the resources to maintain that state. Physical suffering would be without those conditions. And another, 18 meg, is it? And mother? Yeah.
And Hiro? Physical happiness. Oh, that’s good. And another? Therefore, all of us have both physical and mental happiness and suffering.
However, because we are unable to differentiate between them, we get confused. It is therefore extremely important to differentiate between these two. So the way to understand it is as follows, and some of you have mentioned it. Physical mental excuse me, physical suffering and physical happiness arise in dependence on the consciousnesses of the five senses, the five doors. In other words, the visual, auditory, olfactory, gustatory, and tactile consciousness.
And these consciousnesses mediate the experience of the five sense objects. In other words, forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile sensations. Therefore, in dependence on seeing or not seeing an attractive visual object, visual pleasure arises. In dependence on hearing or not hearing beautiful sounds, auditory pleasure arises. In dependence on smelling or not smelling pleasant smells, olfactory pleasure arises.
In dependence on tasting, pleasant tastes or not, gustatory pleasure arises. In dependence on feeling coarse or soft contact, tactile pleasure arises. And a very helpful way to think about this if one studies is to view tactile and gustatory sensations as dominant and to view the sensations mediated by the visual organ, the auditory organ, and the olfactory organ as subsidiary. And therefore, the pleasant and unpleasant physical sensations arise in dependence on exterior objects. This is unrelated to the mind.
Let let us take the example of someone who gains Australian citizenship and gets an Australian passport. Then, obviously, this creates ecstasy for the first couple of days. Now this ecstasy arises from a physical happiness, which is receiving one’s citizenship certificate and one’s passport. In dependence on this physical happiness, mental happiness arises. Unfortunately, after two, three days, when one realizes what this all means, this mental happiness turns into mental suffering.
Passportless citizenry. Citizenshipless citizenry. Oh, yeah. Yeah. So this is how one should think about physical and mental happiness.
Therefore, mental happiness does have a relationship with exterior or physical objects. Let us take an example. Let us take someone we would say a professor or a scholar who is very learned, and this person encounters someone who does not show respect or a correct attitude towards you. Then as a result of this, this person experiences considerable mental suffering. This suffering is mental since it arises within the mind.
Do you understand? Then what does this mental suffering arise from? It arises from expected respect and validation, which isn’t there. Why does this give rise to mental suffering? Because of pride and arrogance.
What is the source of pride and arrogance? self-cherishing. Let us take another example. Let us take the example of someone who is very wealthy and who basically normally should be happy. This wealth is of benefit to him.
However, this person meets someone else, another party, who is even wealthier than he is. Then because of jealousy, because of envy, because of competitiveness, great suffering arises in this person’s mind. And as a result of this suffering, food loses its taste, they cannot sleep, they cannot eat. All of us have direct experience of this. So these difficulties, this hardship, that arises from mental suffering.
This is mental suffering. So this hardship arises from competitiveness and envy. These in turn arise from self-cherishing. self-cherishing arises from the ignorance which grasps at itself. So one must, therefore, make the distinction between the happiness and suffering, which are mental on the one hand, and the happiness and suffering, which are physical on the other hand.
And it is through making such a distinction that one is able to benefit from the studies of the Lamrim. And therefore, the goal of the Lamrim is to eliminate mental suffering. In other words, suffering which is related to the mind. And this is done through understanding the causes for its arising. And therefore, the principal object of abandonment for the being of the middling scope is the origin of self-cherishing, which is the ignorance which grasps at itself.
This is the root of anger, desire, and so And therefore, at present, generating while generating the motivation, we should initially distinguish clearly between physical suffering and happiness on the one hand and mental suffering and happiness on the other hand and understand that this study of the Lamrim is completely unrelated and useless for the elimination of physical suffering and generating physical happiness, and understand how it enables one to generate mental suffering mental happiness, excuse me, and to eliminate mental suffering through eradicating self-cherishing and its root, which is ignorance grasping at itself. Let us therefore generate the motivation. What happened? So, today, since we have time, please ask in a relaxed and open fashion the questions you have. So there’s a powerful relationship since self-cherishing is cherishing of oneself and the oneself which we see is the aggregates.
It can be the form aggregate, the aggregate of sensation, the aggregate of discriminations, of compositional factors, or of consciousness. So generally speaking, self-cherishing is a great attachment to one’s own body, for instance, or to oneself. My question is about transitioning from worldly motivation, you know, motivation for this life, straight into the medium scope. So what it is true that to an ordinary person looking at Buddha’s life, it would seem that he passed directly from the state of a worldly being to its that of a being of the small scope, Buddha Śākyamūni actually had gained full enlightenment before manifesting in this world and merely manifested the so called 12 deeds for the sake of disciples. It is impossible to directly enter into the path of the being of the middling scope without initially having gained the realizations of the being of the small scope since it is indispensable to have renounced the vanities of this life before being able to renounce all lives.
No. For Theravada, it is the same thing. There is no possible progression from an ordinary being to a being of the middling scope if one jumps the realizations of a being of the small scope. Then passing from the state of the being of the middling to the great scope is not something which Theravada is interested in. For instance, is no difference in Theravada or Mahāyāna as far as the presentation of the Four Noble Truths and the 37 factors of enlightenment are concerned.
And within the four noble truths, the first noble truth, the noble truth of suffering has four characteristics. They are the same in Theravada and in Mahāyāna, suffering impermanence, selflessness, and emptiness. Simple. So you seem to be referring at times to the person, which is said to be a substantially existent autonomous entity and which is refuted and at times to the, inherently established self. The best thing would be to accumulate merit, to focus, and reflect on these topics to until you are able to identify what the object of negation is.
The practice of Pö Lha is not a practice exclusively for or only for the attainment of long life and health. Instead, it is a practice of the Kriyā tantra, which is associated with increase. As it is associated with increase in enhancement, when we engage in it as a byproduct, it generates long life and health. This is the ordinary siddhi one gains as a result. Andy?
So in the context of we make a difference between self-cherishing and the ignorance which grasps at the self. The ignorance which grasps at the self is a source of self-cherishing. However, generally speaking, and specifically in the context of mind training, one considers self-cherishing as very similar to the view of the disintegrating aggregates, which is precisely ignorance. For instance, there is self-cherishing in the mind stream of an arhat but there is no ignorance apprehending a self. This is probably the main difference between self-cherishing and the ignorance which grasps at the self.
Another question? So regarding the presence of afflictions in other people, we know this through signs. But regarding the presence of the afflictions and self-cherishing within ourself, this we know through experience through the powerful attachment to ourself and so forth. Another? Another?
Mhmm. No, I don’t think that you should just let it be since this state of mind which finds the suffering of others insupportable is a very beneficial state of mind. It’s a root of compassion. It’s similar to compassion. The incapacity to bear the suffering of others.
You should examine the place of origin of compassion. Compassion is not the same thing as desire. Then in the case you give, that incapacity to bear the suffering of others is very close to compassion. Yes, that’s exactly it. As a result of the practice of bodhicitta, of compassion, of empathy, one’s happiness becomes immeasurable.
This immeasurable happiness, which is mental, leads as a byproduct to physical happiness. Since we can see, for instance, when we look at someone’s face that we say, oh, this is a very happy person or someone else has a very dark and gloomy face. But just just one. When I was a child, I couldn’t, support the suffering of insects that were partially dead. And so I used to go Then through the deed of killing, you have accumulated non virtue.
We’ll stop here for today. Yes. Yes. Stop tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- Kriya Tantra ja gyü (Tib)
- The first of four classes of tantra, also called Action Tantra, because it emphasizes external activities, such as prayers, mudras and so forth. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- siddhi ngö drub (Tib)
- A realization or attainment, either common or supreme. Common siddhis refer to psychic powers acquired as a by-product of the spiritual path; supreme siddhi refers to great liberation or enlightenment. LYWA
- Theravada Sthaviravada (Skt); nätenpa (Tib)
- A tradition of Buddhism that upholds the Pali Canon and the noble eightfold path, which leads practitioners to liberation (nirvana), a state free from the suffering of conditioned existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.