1 h 31 min · 3,401 words · 9 September 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains that mental suffering, unlike physical suffering, must be addressed by subtle means rather than coarse remedies. It presents meditation as settling the mind single-pointedly on an object such as a deity’s body, withdrawing it from afflictions, and notes that calm abiding follows from this training. Questions cover the path of the middling scope, the nature of mental suffering, and choosing a visualization object.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 31m
UUID: 2d9ed937-8091-4918-af17-2f88f49b7184
Date: 2015-09-09
Words: 3,397
Mhmm. So the goal of receiving Lamrim teachings is to eliminate suffering and to create happiness. For this we must be able to identify what suffering is. As has been mentioned many times there are two types of sufferings. There is physical and mental suffering.
It is difficult by the means of Lamrim to eliminate physical suffering. Now specifically, it is important to understand this distinction between physical and mental sufferings and the means to eliminate physical and mental suffering. If we assume that the means to eliminate mental suffering are the same as those to eliminate physical suffering we will be heavily in error. Now when we speak of physical suffering, we are speaking for instance of hunger and of thirst and this is obviously a type of suffering which apart from human beings, animals as well experience. Now within the activities engaged in, in this world of ours, let us say within 100% of activities, certainly 70 or 80% focus on eliminating physical suffering.
Now clearly, if we look at poor countries and cities, the greater proportion of suffering will be physical suffering and I would suspect that there is proportionately less mental suffering. Then for those of us who have a good house, good clothing, good facilities, a reasonable financial situation, suffering still arises and the suffering arises through lack of reflection. Such a suffering is mental suffering. Now mental suffering, in other words, mental pain is something which is similar actually which arises from the afflictions. Now even when we have the best physical facilities and the best conditions for our health, nonetheless we seem to hope that they will continually increase in the future.
Now as mentioned within this two fold subdivision of suffering into physical and mental suffering, we must eliminate both. Physical suffering is something which we address very well in our society but how do we address the great waves of mental suffering? Clearly, mental suffering cannot be eliminated through taking some drug or receiving an injection. I suspect the reason for which we believe that mental pain, mental suffering can be eliminated through means such as medicines or injections is precisely because we identify mental and physical suffering that incapacity to make the distinction is our downfall. So when we wish to counter a coarse disease such as a disease of physical suffering then coarse means are indeed requisite such as drugs, injections and so forth.
But when we wish to counter a subtle disease such as mental suffering, these coarse means are not effective and we need subtle means which are the antidotes to the afflictions. So how precisely do we then counter this mental suffering, these mental diseases? Ideally, we would counter them by attacking the very root of mental suffering, the very root of the afflictions which is self grasping and doing this through the wisdom realizing emptiness but this is very difficult. So how precisely do we address situations in which these mental disturbances arise? We must understand the nature of these states of mind, their presentation and then as it were flip them over.
So ideally, therefore, we should sever these mental disturbances when they arise. Now how precisely do they arise? They arise when the consciousness is not dwelling within its nature. When for instance, we hear something being said and it is misunderstood, consciousness no longer dwells within its nature. We have to return to a state in which consciousness dwells in its nature.
So setting aside physical suffering, the cause of mental suffering is precisely this the fact that the mind does not dwell within but is focused outwards and the means to eliminate such mental suffering is to withdraw the mind back inwards. And therefore, in the process of eliminating these fancies — in Tibetan, which afflict us and withdrawing the mind inwards, how do we proceed? We proceed by a technique which is known as meditation, gom in Tibetan. Meditation is not difficult. It is not the case that when we meditate, we must meditate on emptiness and therefore on coarse and subtle selflessness which are profound topics.
Meditation is just setting one’s mind at ease on an object of observation. This is meditation. And therefore setting this mind at ease on an object of observation is what is meditation whether it be for one minute, two minutes, one hour, one month, one year, there are numerous durations of meditation. Once the mind dwells at ease on an object, we say it is focused single pointedly on an object. At this point, fancies cease and when the fancies and imagining cease, the mind is no longer troubled.
Now, what object precisely should we focus the mind single pointedly upon? The object of meditation ideally would be the body of a deity. It could be the body of Buddha Śākyamūni, of Avalokiteśvara, of Ārya Tārā, of Mañjuśrī and so forth. But before focusing our mind single pointedly on an object of a meditation such as the body of a deity, we must be thoroughly familiarized, acquainted with this object of meditation. Otherwise, how can we hope to concentrate on it?
To give you an example, when we focus or concentrate on an object of meditation such as the representation or the body of Buddha Śākyamūni, we accumulate vast collections of merit. Then ideally, you would focus on an object of meditation which induces great bliss within you whether it is the body of a deity, of a being or whatever in every case, this leads to concentration. Now, when we proceed to visualize or concentrate upon the body of a deity, it should appear clearly. If it does not appear clearly and our mind is scattered by fancies, then we must try to bring the mind back on the object of meditation and this is done as you probably are familiar with through focusing on the outward and inward flow of breath. If we are able to focus in this way, let us say on the representation of the body of Buddha Śākyamūni for one minute, two minutes or longer, then even if our mind had been disturbed previously by the afflictions, through this process of concentration, our mind will be pacified and in addition, it will be withdrawn inwards as it was previously.
So this is meditation. Meditation is not difficult. However, to engage correctly in meditation, one should be physically at ease. Otherwise, if one is physically ill at ease, ready to fall asleep or whatever, meditation is difficult and one does not have to meditate on profound and difficult topics such as subtle impermanence, the four noble truths, selflessness and so forth. When we refer here to the mind being troubled, we are referring to the mind falling under the sway of the afflictions under the power of the afflictions and the afflictions here can refer to desire, to anger, to pride, to jealousy, to envy and so forth.
In every single case, when the mind falls under the sway of these afflictions, it is troubled. And to counter this, we have to withdraw the mind inwards. Now, clearly here, our mind, once it is focused in this way on the object of meditation becomes stable and such a stable mind will not be troubled. This stability is extremely important. For instance, when we study, if our mind is not stable but is distracted outwards then this harms the very essence of study.
Now, here, when we affirm to a stable mind within the context of study, we actually also mean a swift mind and clearly there is a very important difference in the capacity to study any topic. Study is just an example here for one who has meditated and for one who has not meditated. I would estimate that what it takes one hour to study for someone who has not any training in meditation, someone who has training in meditation can accomplish within five or six minutes. Definitely. Likewise, when one speaks, if one has these capacities of concentration then one speech will be clear and stable and what one expounds will be expounded in sequence.
As one continues to develop one’s capacities in meditation, eventually one attains a state of calm abiding or śamatha. At this point, the mind enters directly the object of meditation without any stages of preparation into this. The mind focuses single pointedly on the object of meditation and at this point, one no longer depends on one’s physical body. Someone who has attained calm abiding actually, can survive by means of pure concentration. Then through familiarity, with meditating on one object of meditation throughout one’s life at the time of death, it will be possible to engage in what is known as the mental image meditations, the meditations of the death process focusing on whichever deity one has chosen to focus upon in this life.
Then proceeding in this way, one will be able to train one’s mind since as is said in many scriptures, we are totally unaware of what the future has in hold for us. Very important. Very important. Health is extremely important. Clearly, if at the time of our death we are dying from a wasting disease, it will be very difficult to engage in these practices.
It is therefore while we are healthy that we must train our minds and then we should accumulate the conditions to die as if we were falling asleep. At this point, it will be possible to engage in an accumulation of virtue within the dying process. Do you understand? Really? Okay.
Okay. There’s no worry, you know. So training our minds in this way and focusing them upon an object of meditation with clarity is what meditation is all about. Then eventually through increasing the power of a meditative capacities, we will reach calm abiding. At this point, during meditation, we are no longer dependent upon our coarse physical body.
At present, this is not our state. At present, whether it is our sensory or mental consciousnesses both depend heavily upon our sensory consciousnesses which in turn depend upon exterior physical objects. In our own cases at present, we depend very heavily upon exterior sensory objects. They are the main source of sensations. As a result, when we are not exposed to exterior sensory stimuli, we fall in a state of unconsciousness.
We fall asleep. Then as we deepen our training in meditation, our bond with exterior sensory objects dwindles and around perhaps the ninth level of mental concentration before calm abiding, it is pretty much severed. At this point, the mind has become more and more subtle and autonomous from exterior sensory objects. Such a mind becomes a possible object of imputation of the person And such a mind is then able to know what happens at a distance, to read the thoughts of others and so forth. Let’s imagine at present that you’re devoured by curiosity and you wish to know what precisely the house of your neighbors across the street over there is.
What type of chairs they have? What tables they have? What beds they have? Then at present with our coarse minds because we have the obstacles of walls, we are unable to know what their furniture is like. However, once, we have developed these subtle minds associated with calm abiding then through mental power alone we are able to know this since our mind will go over there and will be accompanied by a wind or an energy.
Times have changed a lot. Some two or three centuries ago, because material development was so low, we had beings who had these extraordinary powers of concentration and had the capacity to see what was happening in other buildings and the minds of others and so forth. Nowadays, oddly enough with material development, these inner capacities, this inner power has dwindled. Exactly. That’s it.
That’s all I have to say. Then these aren’t fairy tales. There really were such beings. I mean, this is something we can ascertain based on reasoning. Oddly enough nowadays, it’s precisely because of the extraordinary level of mental, excuse me, of material development that remaining in retreats has become almost impossible.
Then as a result of this extraordinary level of material development, what one has to study to understand the world has skyrocketed. For instance, now in the monasteries, monks have to study a lot of scientific disciplines totally unrelated to their practice. As Sakya Pandita said, the objects of worldly study are almost innumerable. And therefore as I said, one should be able to separate water from milk as the pelican is said to do so and further one’s own interests. Just for instance, a couple decades ago in the great monasteries, people, monks focused exclusively on studying the Buddhist texts and scriptures and didn’t even learn how to write.
As a result, the deepening of their understanding was extraordinary and they did this during twenty or thirty years. Imagine how much higher the level must have been two or three centuries ago. For sure, as a result, they attained the paranormal powers and the clairvoyances through developing ever more subtle levels of mind. But this is irrelevant. What matters is the explanation of meditation which involves focusing upon an object of meditation and training in that while trying to generate some type of bliss as a result of the process.
So, the main topic today therefore was a presentation of meditation and the object of observation. Now regarding meditation, the context of generating the motivation, we should generate this motivation during a couple seconds. And meditation is impossible if the body is ill at ease. Therefore, one’s body must be relaxed and at ease. And then irrespective of the object of observation one chooses, this depends on the person.
One should focus on this object of observation, generate clarity and try to generate an experience of bliss associated with this. Now when you think of an object of observation like the body of the Buddha, does it appear clearly or not? Xia? Sam? James? Chris?
What I’m asking you is when you focus on the Buddha’s body, do you see it in your mind’s eye or not? So this is really important. When you visualize the Buddha’s body, obviously to keep it continually present in the mind that is difficult. But let’s say within one minute, sixty seconds, you should be able to visualize it for twenty or thirty seconds. And then once you are able to visualize the Buddha’s body for let’s say twenty or thirty seconds, you decide that you will work up to one minute and you strive to visualize it for one minute and then you move upwards in your meditation.
Doesn’t matter, however. Let us do these visualizations for a couple minutes. So I don’t have a lot left to add regarding the path of the being of the middling scope which is our topic. We must identify the object of attainment of the path of the being of the middling scope, the means to attain that object of attainment. Likewise, we must identify the subject of the path of the being of the middling scope and the object of abandonment.
So I’d like to ask you at present, what is the object of attainment of the path of the being of the middling scope? Yeah liberation, that’s called, yeah liberation. And the means to attain liberation? Sorry? Sami?
Now what is the topic or the subject of the path of the being of the middling scope? Sorry? And So now this is a bit difficult for us because we’re speaking of realizations we don’t have but when we progress from the path of the being of the small scope to the being of the middling scope, how do we progress from the realizations of the being of the small scope to the realizations of the being of the middling scope? Another. Hello?
To understand. So you’ve got to understand what the realization of the path of the being of the middling scope is. So first, what is the realization of the path of the small scope? Then what is the realization of the path of the middling scope? It’s pretty similar.
I think 99%. So the question of how one progresses from the path of the being of the small to the middling scope is identical to the question of what the realization of the path of the being of the middling scope is. The answer is it is not mere renunciation, it is uncontrived renunciation. So when we speak of contrived and uncontrived renunciation, contrived renunciation is fabricated renunciation which arises occasionally when we induce it through observing something. Uncontrived renunciation arises spontaneously whenever we observe phenomena of cyclic existence.
If you have questions at present, I’ll take two questions, concise questions. Geshe-la taught earlier on, sorry, I’m just trying to read my notes. The mental disturbances arise and how they arise is when our consciousness is not dwelling within its nature, when we have to return to a state where our consciousness dwells within its nature? What is its nature of consciousness? What is the nature?
There are numerous natures of the mind in the context of this presentation when we speak of the mind’s dwelling within its nature. It means that for instance, when someone addresses us, we understand exactly what they say. We are not mistaken with respect to this and respond appropriately to it. And another question. Thank you, Ilya and Geshe-la.
My question is about the difference between mental and physical suffering. It seems to me that whenever the form aggregate has pain, that mental suffering arises because of the omnipresent mental factors cause mental suffering to arise and that this is linked to the equating the view of equating the self with the perishable. So I’d seen in my experience, it seems like mental suffering always arises when there’s physical suffering. This kind of mental suffering, if it if my analysis is correct, is this included within the group of physical suffering or mental suffering? Yes, there are indeed cases of mental suffering which is induced by physical suffering but such mental suffering nonetheless is not included within physical suffering.
And another. 80? Geshe-la, thank you. You spoke about developing the capacity for single pointed concentration śamatha and the, resulting faculties that arise. Can you speak about some of the people that you know who have developed this?
It’s very difficult to talk about the qualities of realization of others. However, certainly Khensur Rinpoche and his teacher Khensur Ugyen Sete, most probably had calm abiding. Please hold the microphone to your chin. So Geshe la then referred to calm abiding as a realisation but is it lost at the point is the attainment of calm abiding lost at the point of death or rebirth Or can it be lost after it’s been attained? Is it is it a realization?
So regarding your first question, is calm abiding a realization? Realizations generally involve ascertainment by a valid cognizer. Probably yes, probably calm abiding is a realization since valid cognizers would be involved. Regarding your second, the second part of your question, in future lives, does one have it or not? The answer is not necessarily.
Calm abiding is a coarse mind and therefore, it does not necessarily pass on to future lives. It can degenerate. Another? Yeah, Suzie? Okay.
Thank you, Geshe-la for your teachings on meditation tonight. When I meditate, my object of visualization is Buddha Śākyamūni. You did say that we need to choose a deity, but we need to know this deity well. What would make somebody choose a different deity? Why would somebody choose Mañjuśrī or Green Tārā?
Why would that be their focus? So the reason for relying on one specific object of visualization is that it appears clearly to us. Therefore, if the body of Buddha Śākyamūni when you visualize it appears clearly, you should rely on this as an object of observation. If it is the body of Tārā, you should rely on that. It’s the body of Mañjuśrī, you should rely on that.
What you should not do is keep switching objects of visualization otherwise you will have no object of visualization. Stop here tonight.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
- One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
- pandita khäpa (Tib)
- Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is calm abiding a realization, and is it lost at death or rebirth, or can it be lost after being attained?
Realizations generally involve ascertainment by a valid cognizer. Since valid cognizers would be involved in calm abiding, it is probably a realization. As for whether one has it in future lives, the answer is not necessarily. Calm abiding is a coarse mind, so it does not necessarily pass on to future lives. It can also degenerate.