1 h 41 min · 4,164 words · 4 April 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk continues an earlier session on the path of the middling scope, explaining liberation as the complete abandonment of afflictions and how to investigate whether it is attainable. It covers the afflictions, the distinction between ignorance and beginningless ignorance in the twelve links, and how virtuous and non-virtuous impelling karma accumulate through intention and motivation. Questions from students are addressed in the second half.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 42m
UUID: 3ff01416-ef7b-431e-9b1e-b86bee5f998c
Date: 2015-04-04
Words: 4,160
So the goals of the paths of the beings of the three scopes are respectively for the being of the small scope, the attainment of higher state, in other words, higher rebirth in future lives, for the being of the middling scope, liberation, and for the being of the great scope, the state of full attain full enlightenment. Now in the context of this teaching, we are focusing on the teachings of the Four Noble Truths and the 12 limbs of dependent origination whose goal is the attainment of liberation, which are therefore part of the path of the being of the middling scope. The question here would be, what precisely is this liberation? So liberation is an object of attainment. This is, in other words, something one attains.
Two questions arise here. First, does it exist or not? This is something one must investigate carefully through study. Secondly, is it suitable to attain it or not? What is liberation?
Liberation is an abandonment, which is an abandonment of all of the afflictions without exception headed by anger. Does such an abandonment of all the afflictions headed by anger exist or not? And if we investigate in our mind stream to see whether or not there is potentially such an object of attainment as liberation and whether it is attainable or not, we will end up by probably saying there probably is such a thing. It probably can be attained. At this point, one has to wonder just how long it will take to attain it.
Otherwise, if one does not engage in these investigations and will remain purely at the verbal level of things, saying liberation, liberation, this is rather odd. So liberation is therefore the utter abandonment. In other words, the situation where afflictions are no more ever created again. And the object of abandon abandonment, which is abandoned here, are the afflictions. Then we have to ask ourselves, is it possible to abandon anger, envy, jealousy, desire, and so forth?
In other words, to enter a situation where never again they will be generated. Then if we can abandon anger, we can abandon every single other affliction since they are basically similar. So this is a question. If we are able to generate the certainty that these can be abandoned through reasoning, then we are in a very powerful situation. Let us take an example.
Let us take the example of the prime minister of Australia. Now the prime minister of Australia is elected. In other words, no one has been prime minister forever. There is no truly established prime minister. Then if you want to become prime minister, you have to ask yourself if this is possible.
It is possible. Then what do you need to do to become prime minister? You must study. You must gain the required experience. You must have the necessary contacts, and you will eventually be elected.
It is therefore possible to become prime minister. The same lines of reasoning must apply to liberation. Is it possible to attain liberation or not? If it is possible, what must be done to attain it? One must study, one must gain experience, and so forth.
If one thinks about it in this way, this is very powerful. Otherwise, mere talk about liberation, blah blah, is meaningless. So let us take the example of anger. Anger is temporary. It is not permanently present within our mind.
Sometimes anger is present, sometimes it is not. We do experience peace and happiness. It is temporary. What is meant by temporary is that it is not permanently present. It arises in dependence on causes and conditions.
Then it is obvious that anger arises from self cherishing and ignorance. This ignorance is the apprehension of the I, which is countered by the direct opposite to its object of apprehension, which is the realization or the wisdom of realizing non selfless selflessness, non I. This is what must be realized. And for this, one must identify the afflictions. To identify the afflictions, one must understand their nature, which is explained in detail in numerous treatises such as the Abhidhamma Samuchaya and so forth.
In brief, what is the nature of the afflictions? Whenever the afflictions are present within our mind, our mind becomes unsuitable, inappropriate. Then if we take the case of anger, we are all aware of the dangers, the risks of anger in society, in the community. When someone is of a choleric nature, everyone avoids this person. It is not the case that the person is anger since if this were the case, the anger would be continually present and there are numerous lines of reasoning in Shantideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, countering this.
Instead, anger is within the person. It is not the physical aspect of the person which is anger. If I ask you, is the person anger, what do you answer? So if you look at the person and the person’s face is bright red and their whole complexion is red and they can’t control themselves, you still say they are not anger. Why?
That man is angry, really? A woman, actually. What do you mean? So you are basically saying, most of you, that the person is not anger, which is indeed the way it is. However, the person does become the slave of anger, and there are stanzas in Bodhisattvacharyavatara regarding this.
Then anger is a mental factor. In other words, not only is it consciousness, but in addition, it is a part of consciousness. Just as anger, the other afflictions have thoughts which have to be identified. This is extremely important. So the foremost object of abandonment at the level of the path of the middling scope is cyclic existence and the afflictions.
The foremost object of abandonment on the path of the being of the small scope is the 10 non-virtues. So you inquired yesterday about the distinction between the three non virtuous mental deeds and intention. These three non virtuous mental deeds are not intention. Let us take the instance, for instance, of covetousness. When we go downtown and we see something which we find really attractive in the shop, upon returning home, the desire to possess that object increases and becomes a form of craving.
At this point, overcome by craving, we decide to buy this object. This is covetousness. Covetousness is that craving. It is not the intent to buy the object, which is something else. The intent leads to a deed.
The second mental non virtue, ill will, is that state of mind which focuses upon someone with whom we are at odds, upon an opponent, and thinks if only something untowards, something evil could happen to this opponent or even if only he could die. This is ill will. So I will therefore present a subdivision of the afflictions starting with the five views. So the first five afflictions, which are non views, not views as I translated, are desire, anger, ignorance, pride, and doubt. Then there are five views..
The view of the transitory composite, the view wrong views, The view of permanence and the view of annihilation.. Then taking or holding the view as supreme and holding wrong ethics or behavior as supreme. And therefore, in brief, if one summarizes, one has five afflictions connected to the view and five which are not connected to the view. And it might therefore be good if you read in the section in the outline, there are three subdivisions to enter into the noble truth of the origin of suffering. There’s only a couple of pages.
I will give you the page numbers later. Then please read through these sections on the afflictions related, the five afflictions related to the view and the five which are not in Namrim Chemo. Otherwise, we will waste a lot of time if I have to explain them individually. Then if one inquires what is the process or the sequence of generation of the afflictions as explained in the Lambrim, This can be traced back all the way to the perfection of wisdom sutras and to Pramana Vartika. Then if we were to try to understand this without having any personal experience of afflictions, it would be difficult.
But since they are present within every one of our continuums, it’s quite straightforward. As I said in Dharmakirti’s Pramanavarttika, all of the afflictions arise from the view of the transitory composite. From that arises desire and hatred. Here’s a view of the disintegrating composite refers to the apprehension of a self. And if we check in our own experience, we can see that this is the case.
Then instead of relying on faith, we should focus on the inner reality and ask ourselves from between desire and hatred, which arises first? Then how precisely does hatred arise? Hatred here is anger, right? Then after this, this induces the generation of a countless number of afflictions. It’s very important to think about this and study these topics.
So irrespective of the amount of non virtuous karma impelling a lower rebirth which we may have accumulated, if we are able to eliminate the afflictions, this karma cannot mature just as a seed without nutrients. This is explained in a particularly easy to understand in the And therefore, understanding that the afflictions trouble the mind from its very depths, one gives rise to a powerful wish for liberation. Animated by this powerful wish for liberation, one engages in the practice of the 10 virtues in conjunction with a study of emptiness in the scriptures. On this basis, it is possible to attain liberation. This is quite important.
So animated by this desire for liberation, we investigate those components of factors which surround the mind, in other words, mental factors. And one of these is of particular importance, it is intention, SEMPA, which amounts to karma. So to repeat this because it is quite important, once one is striving for a state of liberation or a full enlightenment, it is critical to understand that component of the mind, that mental factor, which orients the mind towards deeds, or physical. This is intention. And when it orients it towards virtuous, verbal, or physical deeds, this is virtuous Then things will turn out well if the motivation becomes stable and is able to impel not only one’s body and one’s speech to virtuous deeds but one’s mind as well through, for instance, generating strong perseverance.
This is something we have direct experience of. It is really not so much dharma as life experience. When one goes to school, for instance, we know that it’s in dependence on a powerful motivation that one is able to finish one’s studies and not drop out, say. Then when one’s motivation is weak and wavering, it must be examined by recollection and vigilance. And if one notices that because of the weakness of one’s motivation, sinking has appeared and one is starting to sleep, then one must heighten the level of the mind.
It’s said in scriptures that one can do this through recollecting the qualities of the Buddha’s body, speech, and mind. Alternatively, a simpler way of doing this is to think to oneself, I’m not that bad after all. When I think about it, in this world, the majority of people have no spiritual practice. I have some spiritual practice. Most people who engage in spiritual practice practice purely based on faith.
My practice is based somewhat on reason. And even those who practice based on reason do not apply the antidotes to the afflictions, at least I try. When one does this, a certain amount of self satisfaction arises within oneself and this heightens the level of the mind. This is quite important. It is not easy to counter the afflictions which accompany anger.
And within those who verbally propound countering these afflictions, there are many who put no effort at it. So to be able to do so, to try, is really very beneficial. And therefore, it is important after reflecting on the thoughts of the afflictions, which are an object of abandonment, as I explained, to investigate whether there is such a thing as a liberation, a freedom from the aforementioned afflictions or not, and if one decides that there is, to generate the motivation which strives for this liberation from the afflictions. At this point, one would have entered the path of the being of the middling scope. So I have spent a lot of time explaining, generating the motivation for listening to these teachings.
This is because this is very important. If one just says to people you’ve got to generate the motivation without explaining how to do it, this is of no benefit whatsoever. So to generate a heavy, a weighty motivation, these explanations are necessary. Let’s generate the motivation. So it would be inappropriate not to cover and examine the material we saw yesterday on the 12 links, starting with the first link or the first limb, beginningless ignorance.
So what is beginningless ignorance? Beginningless ignorance is the grasping at a self. In whose continuum is beginningless ignorance not present? It is not present in the continuum of an aria or superior being. Why is an arya or superior being called superior?
Because he or she is superior to us. In whose continuum is the beginningless ignorance present, it is present in our continuum. So then I will raise some doubts to trouble you since it is inappropriate not to do so. So if it is said that the ignorance which is within the 12 limbs of dependent arising is not present in the continuum of an aria being, wall nonetheless, both self grasping and ignorance are present within the continuum of an arya being. Then you might wonder how is it possible since non virtuous impelling karma accrued to the power of self grasping is also present in the continuum of an arya being that such a being does not reincarnate within psychic existence.
This is how we proceed in the monasteries. Referring to arya beings who are, in other words, superior to us, but have not attained the state of an Arhat. Let’s start by this. Then who is the accumulator of impending karma under the power of ignorance which is included within the 12 links? Ourselves, ordinary beings like us, right?
Then who are the beings who are accumulating impending under the impelling karma under the power of ignorance from within the 12 links? None other than ourselves. At this point, I would like to ask you, is it the case that ordinary beings like us who are, in other words, not arya beings, are necessarily pervaded, in other words, necessarily accumulate impelling karma or not? Do you understand, everyone? That’s difficult.
I’ll translate then. Geshela is asking, is it the case that ordinary beings such as ourselves who have not attained the state of an Arya are necessarily accumulators of impending karma or not? So I have just cast a couple of doubts at you. You will be able to resolve them perhaps if you study a bit of the text. Otherwise, it will be difficult.
At this point, I’ll take questions on this. Don’t be embarrassed to ask questions. This is why you’re here, and these questions will resolve your doubts. There’s no real definition. So the meaning is an Arya being who is not an Arhat is a being who has seen directly, in other words, nakedly, the selflessness of persons, but who has not abandoned the afflictions.
And here, Natalie. It’s a very good question. There is a big difference. To put it succinctly, whatever is beginningless ignorance is ignorance, but whatever is ignorance is not beginningless ignorance. For instance, the ignorance which is present within the continuum of an arya being, which is the apprehension of a self, is ignorance, but it is not beginningless ignorance because it cannot impel impelling karma.
Lily. No. In the continuum of an arya being, there is the ignorance of self grasping, but there is no impelling karma. There is, however, a non virtuous karma as is explicitly stated in the lamrim. Yes, Sam.
While the afflictions are present within their continuum and the ignorance of self grasping is present within their continuum, it is said in the Lamrim that they do not act under the sway of the afflictions nor do they act under the sway of this ignorance precisely because they have seen nakedly or directly the selflessness of persons. Mhmm. And another? I think so. You?
That is perfectly okay. Generally speaking, our Buddhist practice is rooted in reason and analysis. But on occasion, it is perfectly appropriate to rely on faith. When we refer in the case, for instance, of arya beings to the abandonment of the afflictions, we refer to abandoning the afflictions, their seeds, their potency, and their karmic imprints. When it is said that the aryas have not abandoned afflictions, what is meant is that they have not abandoned all of this.
However, because they have seen the selflessness of persons nakedly, directly, they no longer are under the sway or under the control of the afflictions. You have read a lot which is very good, but at present our focus is on the practice of the being of the middling scope. Many I think. Liberation refers to the abandonment or the eradication of afflictions with their imprints from within our mind stream. And the difference between an Arhat and an arya is that an arya is someone who has not abandoned the afflictions in their karmic imprints but who has seen selflessness directly.
See directly what? Yes. The practitioners of the lower vehicle wish to attain liberation for their own sake alone. Then whatever one focuses or trains in depends on the motivation with which one does it. So whether one is studying and meditating on the Four Noble Truths, the 12 links, the 37 limbs of enlightenment, and so forth, if one does it with the wish to help others, this is akin similar to bodhichitta and this no longer is a practice of the Hinayana, of the lower vehicle.
Yeah. Yeah. That is correct. There are three afflictions within the 12 limbs, which are ignorance, craving, and appropriation. The reason for which I focused on anger this morning is because anger is something all of us have direct experience of, and therefore can identify easily.
To identify ignorance is difficult, since to identify ignorance one must identify its object of its mode of apprehension. To identify its mode of apprehension, one must identify its object of refutation. And this is something which is hard for us to do. Then if they have attained the first ground, they are Mahayana beings, when do these beings abandon the afflictions upon full enlightenment? So my apologies.
That is the position of the says that they abandon the afflictions on the eighth ground. So the uncommon Svatantrika position is that the afflictive obscurations and the afflictions to the obscurations to omniscience are abandoned simultaneously from the first ground onwards. Therefore, all the afflictions are abandoned at full enlightenment. So the Chittamatra and the Prasangika position are similar. The Svatantrika Madhyamaka position is a little bit different.
Yeah. You. That’s good. Thank you. Here in this context, when we speak of impelling karma, it’s karma which impels samsara.
Then karma in general, there are numerous forms of karma such as the karma which enables one to attain liberation or that which enables one to attain the state of full enlightenment. So it’s important to understand that karma can be subdivided between virtuous and non virtuous karma. So we will stop here for the questions which you have addressed me. And I would like you to read the pages I will indicate to you during the break in Lamrim Chenmo. And you will find in them or you will deepen your understanding of the fact that arya beings, while they do not have impelling karma, do have within their mind stream non virtuous karma which arises from grasping at self existence.
And you will also understand that the beings which accumulate impelling karma are ordinary beings such as us. And I would like you to examine the doubt I brought up whether it is the case that all ordinary beings accumulate impelling karma or not. So when one presents the 12 limbs, if you have your chart, you can see that you have three causal projecting limbs, one, two, three. Then please bar number four here as I mentioned yesterday. You have four effect projected limbs.
Then you have three causal actualizing limbs and you have two effect actualized limbs. So if one presents the 12 links in according with the scriptures, the first is ignorance, the second is karma or compositional factors, the third is consciousness, the fourth is name and form, the fifth is the sixth loci, the sixth is contact within the 12 links, the seventh is sensation within the 12 links, the eighth is craving, the ninth is appropriation, the tenth is existence, the eleventh is birth, and the twelfth is aging and death. So it is important to reflect, and it’s something I would like to ask you, why? Since virtuous impelling karma and non virtuous impelling karma are both motivated by beginningless ignorance, they lead to such radically different results, the one to a rebirth in the higher realm and the other to a rebirth in the lower realms. So we explained yesterday the process of accumulation of karma.
If we take the case of the accumulation of virtuous karma, there are as you remember four steps. The second step is the generation of a wish which in turn impels the mind to focus on an object and on the engagement of deeds in keeping with a component of that mind, a mental factor which is the intention and in keeping with this virtuous and non virtuous karma are accrued. These virtuous and non virtuous karmas are impelling virtuous and impelling non virtuous karmas. The process whereby karma becomes virtuous is as follows. With the wish not to harm another being, one abstains from, for instance, killing that being.
That deed becomes virtuous not to the mere abstention from killing, but because it is conjoined with a motivation, the motivation to be freed in a future life from a lower rebirth. The conjunction of these two becomes a virtuous impelling karma leading to higher rebirth. Then within the context of an ethics of the abandonment of the non virtues, when one says I will not harm the body of another being, then one will have accumulated virtuous karma. Do you understand? Exactly, 100%.
It’s easy to understand, isn’t it? Then in the case of non virtuous karma motivated by the wish to harm another person. The component of the mind which is intent, a mental factor, focuses on verbal and physical deeds which can harm the body of another person. And when these deeds are performed, the non virtuous impelling karma of killing or murder will have been accrued. Then if the intent to harm, to interrupt the life force of another person is not present, the karma of killing is not accrued.
Then to accumulate the karma of killing or murder, the object of the deed must be a fully characterized living being, a human being. As was mentioned yesterday, if one is fantasizing about this or watching a video or a movie, this is not or this does not accrue the karma of killing. Then such a karma needs a dwelling or a location. The location of karma is the third limb within the 12 limbs of dependent origination: consciousness. Then since the second instant after the first instant of karma is the mental factor of intention, it would this mental factor of intention would probably be with the corresponding main mind.
To give you an example, it’s a little bit like putting money someplace. You may deposit your money in a bank, but you may choose to just put it on the table. That’s the location of the money. Likewise, karma dwells within the mind. However, we do not decide to put it in the mind.
It is naturally within the mind. Then I have some questions for you for five minutes. What is the difference between impelling virtuous karma and impelling non virtuous karma? What is the mode of accumulation of karma? The mode of accumulation of karma.
Yes. That’s exactly it. That’s how to look at it. Then if those deeds engaged in virtuous, this turns into virtuous impelling karma. And if those deeds engaged in a non virtuous, it turns into non virtuous impelling karma.
Yeah. Yeah. Here, stop. Then please read the sections. I will get them right now.
Oh, you’re down to.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
- The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.