Karma – 2015-04-04 – KR

1 h 23 min · 2,845 words · 4 April 2015

Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma (Khensur Rinpoche)
Karma - 2015-04-04 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Continues a teaching on the twelve links of dependent origination, examining which links are present in the mind stream now and how karma ripens through craving, appropriation and existence into rebirth. It covers the fourfold division of karma by maturation, debates about impelling karma in arya beings, and how the links relate to cyclic existence and liberation. Much of the session is taken up with answering students’ questions.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 23m

UUID: 92941b56-fd3f-4164-9f17-5c1883db6175

Date: 2015-04-04

Words: 2,841

You don’t want to get started in education and grammar. It’s a no time. So past participle. Just joking. And it’s a light.

Yeah. Could you open the window? Could you open the window, please? Hot in Chinese is Right? It’s very helpful when one analyzes the 12 links to check which of the 12 links are present within our mind stream.

So the first three projecting limbs, ignorance, compositional factors, in other words karma and consciousness are present within our mind stream. So ignorance is definitely present since the limb of ignorance from within the 12 limbs, which is the apprehension of an I or of a self is present within our mind stream. Compositional factors are definitely present And as the second instant after the implantation of a compositional factor occurs within the mind stream, then consciousness is also definitely present. And the final limb present in our mind stream is the twelfth limb of aging and death. And this twelfth limb, the last limb begins at the second instant after birth and covers the rest of one’s life.

So the first, second and third as well as the twelfth limb are present nowadays or are present in our continuum. Then the remaining limbs, the limb of name and form, the six sources, contact and sensation, to be posited after conception. However, I would explain them tomorrow in an easily understandable fashion. Regarding the mode of accumulation of impelling karma, From the second instant onwards, this is implanted as a karmic imprint within the mind stream. It is therefore not simultaneous with it.

From the second instant onwards, this is implanted in the mind stream. It is therefore not simultaneous with it. It doesn’t occur at the same time. This is a bit difficult for you to understand. In Jetsun Chokyi Gyaltsen’s treatise on the 12 links, a passage of Vasu Bandu is quoted in which Vasu Bandu says, once one has seen truth, there is no impelling.

Seeing truth refers to the direct realization of emptiness. Impelling is interpreted by Jetsunpa as referring to impelling karma. Therefore, Vasubando would be asserting that after the direct realization of emptiness, no impelling karma is present in the mind stream. And this is understood by saying that from the second instance of impelling karma onwards, it has transformed into a karmic imprint. Drepung Loseling’s manual author, Pänchen Sönam Drakpa, however, has a different assertion and there’s a rationale behind this assertion.

Pänchen Sönam Drakpa asserts that there is impelling karma within the continuum of arya beings and interprets the stanza of Vasubando from Vasubando’s commentary on the 12 links, one who has seen truth no longer accumulates, no longer is impelled, as referring to the fact that for an arya being, whereas previously accumulated impelling karma is still present within the mind stream, such a being will no longer accumulate new impelling karma The rationale behind Pänchen Sönam Drakpa’s assertion is that it is asserted that Arya beings are reborn in the realm of the fourth concentration. And the karma to be reborn in the realm of the fourth concentration cannot be accumulated by ordinary beings. For this reason, Pänchen Sönam Drakpa and Drepung Loseling consider that there does exist impelling karma within the continuum of an arya being. It doesn’t matter. Don’t worry.

It doesn’t matter. This is a very fine analysis. So from the standpoint of maturation, karma is subdivided into four: karma, which matures visibly, karma, which matures in the next life, karma, which matures in a future life, and uncertain karma. So the first subdivision of karma, karma which matures visibly is karma which is accumulated at the beginning of this life and whose maturation occurs within this life. Karma, which matures in the next life is karma whose or which is accumulated in this life and which matures in the immediately subsequent life.

Karma, the third subdivision, karma which matures in another life is karma which is accumulated in this life but does not mature in the next life and matures in a later life, after the next life. The fourth subdivision, uncertain karma, is karma which has been accumulated, but against which the four opponent forces have been applied. As a result, its maturation becomes uncertain. Alternatively, this is karma which has been accumulated before one becomes an arhat. There are numerous subdivisions of Karma, but this fourfold subdivision is the most famous.

Then if we accumulated karma which matures in the next life, in other words, karma accumulated now which matures in the immediately subsequent life, Then in that case, let us say we accumulated the karma to be reborn as a human being, and it is a karma in addition which matures in the immediately subsequent life. At whatever point we accumulated that karma in this life, at the point of our death under the power of craving and appropriation, it turns into the tenth limb of existence. So if we consider to make things simple, one cycle of the 12 limbs. This one cycle will include all 12 limbs, ignorance from within the 12 limbs, compositional from within the compositional factors from within the 12 limbs, consciousness, name and form, the six sources, contact from within the 12 limbs, sensation, craving, appropriation, existence, birth, aging and death. This is one cycle.

So within one cycle of the 12 links, if we consider that karma has been accrued during this life, then the craving which occurs just before the point of death, so before one has died in this life, which for instance is a wish not to be separated from one’s body, causes a maturation of this karma. This craving causes the maturation of what? It causes the maturation of the potency which was deposited by compositional factors into consciousness in our mind stream. This potency matures into the end of existence. Do you understand the coming into existence of sprout from a seed?

When you put a seed in the ground, numerous conditions such as water, manure and so forth are necessary. And when these conditions are present, the transition from seed to sprout will occur. Therefore, under the power of the eighth limb of craving, the second limb, the karmic imprint which was deposited within our consciousness, the third limb, and which has left a potency within our consciousness matures. The maturation of this potency turns into what? It turns into the tenth limb of existence.

Then the limb after the eighth limb of craving is a limb of appropriation. The limb of appropriation is of the same substantial continuum as the limb of craving. It is an intensification of craving which causes the karmic imprint which has started maturing under the power of craving to mature even further. Then under the power of the limbs of craving and appropriation, the karma which was deposited by the second limb compositional factor into the third limb of consciousness matures and becomes the completing karma which is the immediate cause of a future life. So from the standpoint of dharma, the eighth, the ninth, and the tenth limb craving, appropriation, and existence correspond to coarse death.

One should receive instructions on this. Then at this point, the subtle death occurs leading into conception. Then do you understand that at present we do not have in our continuum the eighth limb of craving, the ninth limb of appropriation and the tenth limb of existence? Then although we may not have them in our continuum at present, we are preparing to experience them. At present, these three are not present in our continuum.

So at present, what is present within our continuum? The first limb of ignorance, the second of compositional factor, the third of consciousness, and the twelfth of aging and death. Therefore, the first three projecting limbs and the last actualized limbs are occurring. And these one should study the most important limbs are these two sets of causal limbs. So I’ll take your questions at present.

Please make them concise, focus on the meaning, one question per person and after you can ask more. Because the three projecting limbs and the two actualized limbs are present in existence within our continuum. However, the seven other, or excuse me, the six other limbs, the projected limbs and the actualizing limbs are limbs which were in our continuum in a previous life. Natalie. So No.

Because the limb of sensation from within the 12 limbs is probably only present within the womb as I showed on the on the black on the whiteboard. In our continuum at present, it’s probably not present. However, we will cover these in detail tomorrow. No, there is no particular relationship. The limbs of craving and appropriation which cause the maturation of the second limb of compositional factors into the tenth limb of existence are mainly the wish not to be separated from one’s body at the time of death.

There is no particular relationship between them and virtue or non virtue. Richard. Yours is a good doubt. It’s not one which comes from the scriptures but from your own analysis. It does indeed occur that children die in the womb.

And normally in a case like that, all 12 links have to be complete. The doubt does not arise so much for the link of birth and death as for the links of contact and sensation. And Mark. Mark. Mark.

Let alone the fact that the mind which strives for liberation is not craving, it is the actual antidote, the opposite of craving. Then the only way to eliminate the limbs of compositional factor, the second limb and the limb of craving, the eighth limb, is through the application of the four forces. They will not disappear by themselves. But if you apply the four forces, this cycle will disappear. But in reality, the way to eliminate them is starting from the beginning from ignorance.

So this is the forward and the reverse order of the order of the 12 links. The reverse order is through eliminating ignorance. You eliminate compositional factors, which eliminates consciousness, etcetera. Yes, that is indeed what is said. Certainly, if one through the power of habituation has been reciting the sutra of the Medicine Buddha and the mantra of the Medicine Buddha all one’s life, then at the time of death when one recites it, because of the power of powerful virtuous habituation, the impelling karma will be virtuous.

One will definitely be reborn in a higher realm. Then whether this is actually the pure land of the Medicine Buddha or not, that I cannot say. Yes, that is it. The origin of cyclic existence is beginningless ignorance and independence on the motivation with which one engages indeed, virtuous or non virtuous impelling karma is produced. Yes.

Yes. Seeing and realizing is the same thing. This term directly means to see or to realize as with the eyes. So it’s akin to seeing. Naturally.

No. Because, for instance, the environment and the beings within the environment, in other words, the container and the contained are also said to be beginningless and they have nothing to do whatsoever with ignorance. When one speaks of beginningless ignorance, one speaks of what lies at the beginning of the 12 links. Sam? So in dependence on ignorance, you can be reborn in the realm of desire.

You can be reborn in the form realm. You can be reborn in the formless realm. In the desire realm, it is through the power of the afflictions. Yes. Ignorance within the 12 limbs of dependent origination is neutral.

If at the time of death I think you are thinking of fear at the time of death. But even if fear at the time of death is not present, nonetheless, if one fully understands what death means, one will have the wish not to die and the wish not to be separated from one’s body. So certainly, the desire within our continuum amounts to craving and is non virtuous. There’s actually a passage in Abhidharma about this. One should not ask so much what virtue or non virtue is accrued in dependence on desire, but more what desire wishes to accomplish.

Susie? Beings who were reborn in the formless realm lack the first of the five aggregates, they lack form. In other words, they lack what is known as form within name and form. They only have the name link which is the four remaining aggregates, sensation, discrimination, composition of factors and consciousness. Emma?

Generally speaking, there is a difference between craving and appropriation from within the 12 links and craving and appropriation in general. Craving and appropriation from within the 12 links differ only nominally. Craving is the former instance and appropriation the later instance of greater intensity and they are only present at the time of death. This is not the case for ordinary craving and ordinary appropriation. Jean?

It’s not an easy question. So indeed, an Arya being is a being who has a direct realization of emptiness. Having the direct realization of emptiness is indeed the antidote to ignorance. So generally speaking, we can say that the grasping at a self no longer is present within that being’s mind. That does not mean that it is not present occasionally, point one.

Point two, to abandon ignorance does not entail only generating that antidote to ignorance. It also entails eliminating both the seeds and the karmic imprints of ignorance which are present in the aria’s mind. And this takes repeated habituation over a long period of time. Then to understand this fully, you must study grounds and paths, specifically the paths of Shravakas, Pratyekabuddhas and Bodhisattvas. Hopefully, at some point in the future when we have finished the presentation of tenets, we will study grounds and paths together.

Once you have studied Salam,, then the distinctions between ordinary beings and arya beings, between the path of seeing and the path of meditation becomes straightforward. Then Salam, grounds and paths becomes easier. Yes. It has to be during what is known as subsequent attainment. Otherwise, doing direct perception of emptiness is not possible.

Apart from this, Arias do become angry. Mandalas have different positions. I would say that in subsequent attainment, the ignorance grasping at a self is continually present. Good way of thinking, The way to look at it is that there is probably nothing within our continuum which is not included within one cycle of the 12 links. However, it is impossible for all 12 links of one cycle to be present within one life.

Instead, within one life, you may have the six causal limbs. In other words, the three impelling limbs and the three completing limbs. Then the six effect limbs have to be present in another life. It’s very, very good for one’s studies to proceed in the way you were doing and to ask yourself, can one have all 12 links in one life or not? If one can’t, which one should one have in one life?

Which one will one have in another life? Until we have abandoned cyclic existence, whether it is in this life or in another life, we are constantly revolving within the 12 links. Well, if you don’t realize emptiness, what hope is there to attain liberation or for enlightenment? It will continue as now. Since to attain either liberation or full enlightenment, it is necessary to eliminate the grasping at, the innate grasping at a self and for this one must generate the opposite realization, which is the realization of the non inherent, non true existence of a self.

This is what amounts to the realization of emptiness. No, that is not possible. How would it be possible since the object and the appearance of bodhichitta are totally different from those of wisdom? It’s two different things. That’s why we speak of method and wisdom.

So obviously conventional bodhichitta and ultimate bodhichitta are completely different. One is method, the other is wisdom. Then clearly from the standpoint of tantra, these two can in a certain context be seen as identical. Richard? No.

Karma which matures in this life is not necessarily not impelling karma. And, Ananda? So basically, compositional factors are neither one nor multiple. Sometimes they are one, sometimes they are multiple. Mark?

In as much as the 12 links are a composite phenomena, each of the 12 links changes instant by instant. So we shall stop here for today. The questions were good, very good. I can see that you have read and reflected. Then please read on these topics and think about them for tomorrow since tomorrow is the last day of teaching.

Then you have asked many questions on the limb of ignorance, so I suppose I should explain ignorance in detail tomorrow. Then for myself, there is no particular difficulty in explaining ignorance, but I hope you will listen carefully because otherwise, if you all fall asleep, there’s no big point.

Key terms in this teaching

completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
form realm rupadhatu (Skt); zug kham (Tib)
The second of samsara’s three realms, with seventeen classes of gods. LYWA
formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top