1 h 37 min · 3,989 words · 3 September 2014 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen leads a detailed exploration of what transforms physical and verbal actions into authentic Buddhist practice, grounded in proper motivation. In this 97-minute teaching, he establishes that mental problems require mental solutions—love and forbearance to counter anger, for instance—and that genuine dharma practice begins when delight in the teachings arises. He then systematically walks through the refuge in the Triple Gem: the three objects of refuge (Buddha, Dharma, Sangha), their four essential qualities, and how practitioners distinguish between causal refuge—taking external refuge in these objects—and resulting refuge, where one’s own transformed mind becomes the triple gem. Throughout, he stresses that our minds, controlled by afflictions and ignorance, achieve independence only through realization of emptiness. He fields questions from lay practitioners on unchanging happiness, the mental afflictions, how Ārya beings perceive emptiness, and how to develop conviction in future lives through reasoning and example.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2014-09-03 – KR.mp3
UUID: 77dc12ce-7757-4b2f-9fa8-9b42f1f7b10e
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Mind Training
Date: 2014-09-03
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,984
So for something to become religious practice, Dharma in other words, there must be a specific motivation. And for a practice to become Buddhist, refuge must be present. For a practice to become a practice of the Mahāyāna or the great vehicle, in addition, the wish to help others is indispensable. Therefore, we need an introduction or a commentary on the motivation to be generated. So regarding dharma, we have to advise or counsel ourselves.
And if we examine whether, for instance, physical prostrations or verbal recitations alone are dharma, and clearly they are not. If they were, it would be very odd. Then since one’s mental problems, one’s mental difficulties come from the innermost depths of one’s own mind, Likewise, the solution to one’s mental problems must come from the innermost depths of one’s own mind. Note here that I do not speak of physical problems that is completely unrelated. So if one understands that the solution to one’s mental problems comes from the innermost depths of one’s own mind, then one has started to advise oneself on dharma.
Then, in the sort of same way as one’s mental problems do not arise from one’s body, one’s physical problems do not arise from one’s mind. The foundation of one’s physical problems are the constitutive elements of the body. It is not the mind. Therefore, very difficult to eliminate physical problems with mental responses. And since, therefore, one’s innermost mental problems can only be solved by the mind, the mind has all the means at this its disposal to eliminate or to dispel these problems.
Such problems can only with great difficulty be dispelled by physical means. Just take the case of anger. Anger is a mental phenomenon, and the means to dispel anger are mental means, such as love and forbearance. It can be very difficult to dispel anger through modification of the physical elements. Then once one has seen this, one has begun to counsel or to advise oneself in matters pertaining to Dharma.
When this happens, one will take delight in Dharma. Delight here is nothing else than enthusiasm or perseverance, And at this point, there is no difficulty facing one in one’s practice since our main obstacle is the sloth or the laziness of evil deeds. And this is why we outline in the Lamrim teaching the importance of the Dharma through teaching the importance of the instruction is so important since it is designed to foster delight in the Dharma. So this is a very pleasant way of looking at things. The physical deeds of prostration, the verbal deeds of recitation, ritual, and so forth are not dharma.
They are important, but they are not dharma as such. It is whatever impacts one’s mind, which is dharma. And this mental impact occurs through motivation. There are numerous forms of motivation. Among the mental factors involved, one can consider bodhicitta, compassion, renunciation, and so and so forth.
And then when this delight in the teachings arises, a desire to engage in the teaching is fostered. This desire to engage in the teachings is none other than the motivation. And among the numerous forms of motivation, one then engages in the teaching. This gives rise to enthusiasm. And this enthusiasm, when one focuses single pointedly on the teachings, gives rise to concentration, not calm abiding since we are beginners, but concentration.
And then in dependence on this concentration, one analyzes carefully the teachings, and this is the wisdom component. And, therefore, realizing that the means to eliminate mental problems are mental and that we have them at our disposal, since after all, in this country, there are very few physical problems comparatively. Then we generate from the very depths of our mind the wish to listen to the teachings, and this is nothing else than the motivation. And then it is indeed said that one’s Dharma practice begins with the mind which holds a motivation striving for future lives and beyond. Then for many of us who do not believe in future lives, this is very far away indeed.
So how does one proceed? A mind which is focused on taming the unsuitable, the inappropriate states of mind amounts basically to Dharma. So this would be sufficient. Gateway to the teachings is refuge. There are numerous types of refuge.
However, it is said in Buddhist scriptures that what is held or upheld by refuge is a Buddhist practice. Then Buddhist teachers teach three different categories of refuge. The refuge of the practitioner of small, of middling, and of great scope. It is nowhere said that a practice being upheld by refuge means a practice being upheld by the mere refuge of a practitioner of the small scope. Then if we analyze the situation from the standpoint of tenets, a practitioner is said to be a propounder of Buddhist tenets if that person accepts or endorses one of the four categories of tenets.
If in addition, such a person has refuge, he or she is a Buddhist who is a propounder of tenets, Buddhist tenets. So what is required for Buddhist teachings to become a Buddhist practice? Just reading the Lamrim is not a Buddhist practice. Reading the Lamrim becomes a Buddhist practice under certain conditions. What are these conditions?
If we analyze our situation, we can see that while our body is independent. Our mind is not independent. Our mind from the very in its very innermost depth is controlled by other forces. What do we mean by independence of the mind? By independence of the mind, we refer to a state of profound and immutable happiness, unchanging happiness.
This is to be our goal. So how do we obtain such an immutable and indestructible happiness? Once we understand that there is not a single rebirth within the six rebirths of cyclic existence in which such an immutable, unchanging happiness is present, the wish to be freed from such a cyclic existence arises. This wish to be freed from cyclic existence is the wish for liberation. However, to attain liberation, we need a perfect body such as this one as a basis.
However, if this is our goal, what would happen if we were reborn in the lower realms and experienced the truly immeasurable sufferings of the lower realms? At present, we ourselves experience mental suffering, but as far as our body is concerned, we have independence. However, once one is reborn in the lower realms, we can see with our own eyes that set aside or let alone mental suffering, beings who are reborn in the lower realms have no physical independence. The physical suffering they experience is inconceivable through, for instance, devouring each other as we can see in documentaries, on television, and so forth. And therefore, although our goal is liberation from cyclic existence, this fear from the sufferings of cyclic existence in general must be conjoined with a specific fear of the sufferings of the lower realms.
And then realizing that if one is reborn in the lower realms, what hope is there for any attainment of liberation, one searches for a means to be protected from such a rebirth. And this is the cause which leads us to taking refuge and the existence of three objects of refuge, which are able to protect us from such a lower rebirth. Then in which way does the Buddha jewel protect from a lower rebirth? The Buddha jewel does not protect from a lower rebirth in a causeless or conditionless fashion. It protects from a lower rebirth through study.
And it is through this study that we are protected from rebirth in the lower realms. In this context, we can understand the Dharma jewel through the famous passage from sūtra, I do not bestow blessings by my hand, nor do I cleanse the thoughts of beings with water. It is through teaching selflessness that I benefit beings. And, therefore, this is what could be understood as the Dharma jewel. As to the Sangha jewel, it is those who follow the Buddhist teachings such as, for instance, Ārya Nāgārjuna’s, Nāgārjuna, father and son.
For this reason, three objects of refuge are indispensable for the attainment of liberation. The last object of refuge in this sequence is the aryasangha, which accompanies those who engage in practice. And every practice is the Dharma, and this Dharma is taught by the teacher himself, Buddha Śākyamūni. Reflecting on the fact that Buddha Śākyamūni taught the Dharma, tremendous conviction arises in Buddha Śākyamūni, and this conviction is of the nature of faith. And this is therefore the meaning of the first outline in taking refuge, in dependence on which causes does one take refuge.
When one takes refuge, it is not merely in dependence on fear of the suffering of the lower realms, but possibly in dependence as well on the fear of the suffering of cyclic existence in general. The second outline, the object in which one takes refuge is the triple gem. Now within the second outline, the first sub outline is the conviction that the triple gem is able to protect us from all fear. This ability is extremely important. For instance, if we imagine two people who have both fallen together in a raging torrent, Neither is it in any state to help the other.
Secondly, such an object of refuge must be skilled in the means to help others. For instance, if we imagine a mother who has lost both hands, who has been amputated with both hands, such a mother lacks the capacity to help her child. The third characteristic is that these objects of refuge must act under the sway of great compassion. And finally, the object of refuge must benefit both those who help them and those who do not. This is extremely important.
Such objects of refuge must not be attached to material donations, but exclusively focus on the gift of practice. There are numerous examples of these four features of the objects of refuge, and you can read about them in liberation in the palm of your hand. So the third outline is the measure of having taken refuge. This measure of having taken refuge is subdivided in turn into four sub outlines. The first of which is taking refuge by means of understanding the qualities of the object of refuge.
And this in turn is subdivided into the qualities of the Buddha, of the Dharma, and of the Sangha. The Buddha’s qualities are subdivided into the qualities of the Buddha’s body, of his speech, and of his mind. The bodily qualities of the Buddha refer to the 32 major and the 80 minor marks. These are exterior signs of his qualities, and it is in dependence on this that faith arises. The qualities of speech refer to the capacity of the Buddha’s speech to address simultaneously in a variety of languages all of the trainees who come for instruction to the Buddha.
Well, the qualities of the mind of the Buddha are numerous. In a nutshell, they are the capacity to behold simultaneously the conventional and the ultimate nature of every phenomenon. Regarding the qualities of the second object of refuge, the Dharma jewel, in general, these refer to the qualities of the noble truth of cessation and the noble truth of the path. Specifically, the noble truth of the path which leads the Buddha to the attainment of all his qualities. Within the noble truth of the path, this includes the five paths and the 10 grounds.
Regarding the qualities of the Sangha jewel, these refer to the qualities of beings which are relying within their continuum on the two last noble truths, the noble truth of the path and of the cessation. And specifically, these refer to the training of insight within the continuum of a being on the path of preparation, an insight focused either on selflessness or emptiness, and the training in direct realization of emptiness for a being on the path of seeing, as well as the abandonment of the nine cycles of abandonment for a being on the path of meditation. Then we shall stop here for today, and if you have questions, please ask your questions. Geshe-la said for this reason the three objects of refuge are indispensable for the attainment of liberation. In our context here at TBI as lay student would Geshe-la in his role as our teacher fulfill the function of the Sangha jewel in protecting us from saṃsāra and the lower realms?
Generally speaking within the Lamrim, it is said that the Sangha jewel is appropriate to view as a Sangha jewel a member of any of the four classes of ordination. However, you yourselves have received many teachings, both from His Holiness the Dalai Lama and Kyabje Khensur Rinpoche, and it would therefore be appropriate to view them as the Sangha jewel. Then there are multiple ways of presenting the triple gem. At present we have presented in terms of a multiplicity of causes. If we look at it from the standpoint of one single cause, then we would say that Buddha Śākyamūni, at the time when he attained the path of seeing and the path of meditation, became the Sangha jewel.
And the noble truth of the cessation and of the path generated within his mind stream at that time were the Dharma jewel. And he himself, upon his attainment of full enlightenment, became the Buddha jewel. Then the presentation so far has been from the standpoint of the causal refuge. Frankly, this is not the essential refuge. The essential refuge is the resulting refuge, or the effect refuge, and in that context, we ourselves, when we put sufficient effort, can definitely attain the path of seeing, and upon attaining the path of seeing, we become Ārya beings and become the Sangha refuge.
Then the noble truths of cessation and of the path within our own mind stream becomes a Dharma refuge, and upon our own enlightenment, we become our own Buddha refuge. Then from the standpoint of resulting refuge, through, as was mentioned, modifying our own mind from its innermost depths will eventually become our own triple gem. Then as Buddha Śākyamūni said, I am my own teacher. Who else is there to be my teacher? I have taught you liberation.
Now it is up to you to attain it. There is no other teacher but ourselves. It’s oneself from ones own depth which has to turn into the triple gem. Hence, the distinction between causal and resulting refuge is a critical one. When we view the objects of refuge as outside of ourselves and go for refuge to Buddha Śākyamūni, his teachings, the Sangha, this is a causal refuge.
But when we transform our own minds and eventually reach the grounds and the paths and progress upwards on the grounds to full enlightenment, this is resulting refuge. We become our own refuge. Could Geshe-la please elaborate a bit on the nature of the happiness to be attained that is unchangeable. I’m having some difficulty imagining what that could even be that feel like The Vaibhāṣikas consider that the immutable and indestructible happiness referred to here are both the noble truths of cessation and of the path. Generally speaking, when I refer to indestructible and immutable happiness, I refer to the noble truth of cessation.
This has nothing to do, this immutable and indestructible happiness has nothing to do with our present sensation or feeling of happiness. Instead, it is the complete elimination of all of the mental difficulties which harry us at present. Geshe said our mind is not independent, it is controlled by other forces. Does he mean by those other forces, are they the afflictions? So this is really a topic related to the being of the middling scope more than to the being of the small scope, but it is something we have direct experience of.
When our mind is beset with anger, is this a pleasant state of affairs? Under whose control is our mind? Our mind is troubled. When our mind is beset by desire or by jealousy, is this a pleasant state of affairs or not? Our mind is under the sway of desire or jealousy.
Ultimately, it is under the sway of ignorance. The ignorance which apprehends a truly existing self and gives rise to self-cherishing. Then the supreme possibility for us is the attainment of the path of an ārya being. When one attains a path of an ārya being or becomes an Arhat, then at this point, there’s an extraordinary purification of mental difficulties. One perceives emptiness or one realizes emptiness directly.
Then this direct realization of emptiness is an extraordinary experience. Mhmm. Another question. Do we have another question? Mark.
You described the qualities of a Buddha’s mind and how it was characterised as simultaneously beholding the two truths. How is the mind of an Ārya characterised? Do they only behold one truth, an ultimate truth, because they’ve realized, thank goodness? Or does it alternate between the two truths at different times? Or how does that actually function?
When one attains the mere path of an ārya being, one is not able to perceive simultaneously the two truths. One becomes able to perceive simultaneously the two two truths through repeated meditative equipoise on emptiness motivated by the wish to benefit others. This eventually leads to the state of full enlightenment. Geshe-la has said that Dharma practice begins with striving for future lives which is obviously dependent on a belief in future lives and since we don’t have a conviction in that, taming the mind or restraining the mind from unsuitable states of mind amounts to Dharma practice which is sufficient, would the 10 refraining from the 10 non virtuous states of mind be what Geshe-la would be referring to as unsuitable states of mind? So when one speaks of unsuitable states of mind, one is actually referring to the afflictions.
So for instance, anything engaged in under the sway of anger. Geshe-la, I was wondering if you could elaborate on causal refuge. So my question is if the preliminary for causal refuge is fear of lower rebirth establishing that fear requires us to understand how our practices today can lead to a lower rebirth. The Lamrim provides some detail into that however the detail is I would say difficult to put into practice in our day to day lives. I’ll use the example of in Liberation there’s an example of a person in debate who used the insult and was reborn as a many headed sea dragon.
Taking that example and putting that into practice today to establish fear is difficult. Can Geshe-la suggest readings, texts or an approach to help us do that? Then you could simply rely on something we can see with our eyes and hold with our hands, which have direct experience of, which is the extraordinary suffering of animals who lack any independence and who suffer for instance from devouring each other. So I was telling, Geshe-la, there’s great benefit in studying some cases mentioned or developed by Ian Stevenson, which clearly demonstrate how these from previous lives affect the rebirth in the future life. There was one case of an Inuit fisherman, Eskimo fisherman in other words, who worked very hard for a living, this is in North America in the nineteen sixties, and over and again he said to his nephew, I’ve used my right arm so hard in this life, I don’t want to have a right arm in my next life.
Then he died in a fishing accident, and a young child was born with clear memories of this life, but this young child lacked a right arm, and the Inuit considered it was because of the pledge basically he had taken. So this shows a correlation. So what your translator was saying about the relationship between past and present lives is extremely important, because once we are convinced of a relationship between past and present lives, the relationship between present and future lives is something which is pretty evident. Past lives are over and done with, but future lives are expecting us. Therefore, ideally, one would generate a valid cognizer which is convinced of the existence of future lives.
But if this is not possible, even an understanding of the existence of future lives is extraordinarily important for us. Regarding developing some conviction in former lives I was reading a book by the Dalai Lama, you talked about two types of reasoning inductive reasoning and deductive reasoning. The deductive reasoning is the example of a car made after a certain time as non lead petrol and the in, I think it was the inductive reasoning is the inference if on a smoky pass it follows there is fire. I was wondering if Geshe-la could give us a little overview of applying this kind of reasoning. I I didn’t understand about the car at all, sorry.
Oh the Dalai Lama said so if you know cars made in Europe after 1995 do not have lead petrol then you just ask a friend what year their car was made in and you’ll know whether they have it’s lead petrol or not. You don’t need to investigate the car. This topic of the proofs of the existence of past and future lives is a very difficult topic, and therefore it doesn’t seem meaningful to engage in it at present. We have little time, and you are tired. At some point in the future, if you are interested in this, we should set aside a specific time for a teaching only on this topic.
At present, if you have other questions, I’d be glad to take them. The best possible explanation comes from tantra. One considers from a worldly standpoint that the end of gross consciousness is death. However, there is a subtle consciousness which continues, and when this subtle consciousness leaves, at this point this subtle consciousness must go somewhere. And this is perhaps the best presentation of past and future lives.
Then I think there are no more questions. Probably finish it tonight. Just a couple of announcements. There’s Guru Puja tomorrow at seven and Geshe-la’s public talk this Saturday, Developing Happiness Within following on from Pamela’s question at 03:00. And then of course there’s the two day non residential retreat here in October in praise of dependent arising.
And also for those that know Maggie Ditmeier and Chris Elo, I’ve got a couple of cards. Maggie’s been in hospital and Chris has had a cochlear implant I think. Tanya, is that right? Elo. She was the lady that would sit close at the front.
Yeah. So I’ve got a couple of cards for those who know them. You can sign those. And there’s some chai and a biscuit. Thank you very much.
I’ll take I’ll take the card to Maggie. Oh, good. Yeah. I can take that for you. Yeah.
She’s I’m hoping someone She’s moved. She’s had so many in and out of hospital, and she just sort of spontaneously implodes. There’s not much there’s not much of it. Someone would bring up all the card in case anyone was gonna see her today? Yeah.
Think because I didn’t know. I knew that she you know, what her address was. I’ll I’ve got the aggregates, and I’ll take a bit tomorrow and get some flowers. Excellent. So I was gonna say, if you could just write, Dear Maggie, thinking of you, lots of love, and then then we can all have a crack at it.
When Geshe in the teachings, you referred to that outline quite at the beginning. Did anyone get what outline? I didn’t get to write it down. Which outline? Just let me turn the recording off.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- causal refuge
- The objects of refuge - the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha - existing in the mental continua of others, as opposed to resultant refuge. Only by relying upon these external refuge objects can we achieve our own internal resultant refuge. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
- Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What is the nature of the unchangeable happiness that is to be attained?
The Vaibhāṣikas consider that the immutable and indestructible happiness referred to here includes both the noble truth of cessation and the noble truth of the path. Generally speaking, though, when this immutable and indestructible happiness is mentioned, it refers to the noble truth of cessation. It has nothing to do with our present sensation or feeling of happiness. Instead, it is the complete elimination of all the mental difficulties which harry us at present.