Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2013-05-15 – KR.mp3
UUID: 3b30622b-40af-4e12-be5a-4582a2d2d169
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Mind Training (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2013-05-15
Duration: 1h 46m
Words: 5,125
As Āryadeva says, at the beginning accumulate merit, in the middle keep the precepts and at the end practice intensely. Each of these few verses refers to the practice of one of the beings of the three scope. The first verse at the beginning accumulate merit refers to the practice of the being of the small scope. The second verse to the practice of the being of the middling scope and the last verse to the practice of the being of the great scope striving for full enlightenment. So the first verse at the beginning, Merit refers to in non virtue and specifically not to engage in the non virtue of the 10 non virtuous deeds.
This maintenance of ethics is the means to obtain higher rebirth either as a human being or as a god. Therefore, to abandon the 10 non virtues, one must initially be acquainted with what the 10 non virtues are. One must know what they are. One cannot know what they are without having studied. Therefore, study is indispensable.
And since all of us must understand what this ethics of abstaining from the 10 on virtues is, I shall explain that today. So what is the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues? It’s an ethics of the abandonment of the three non virtues of the body, the four of the speech and the three of the mind. The three non virtues of the body are killing, stealing and sexual misconduct. The four of the speech are lying, divisive speech, harsh words and gossip and the three of the mind are covetousness, ill will, and wrong views.
All of us would like to be reborn as human beings or as gods, but if we do not abstain from the 10 non virtuous deeds, it is impossible to attain these rebirths. It is critical to abandon these non virtuous deeds because the rebirth they impel us in is contingent on whether they are a smaller, a middling or a greater non virtuous deed. A smaller non virtuous deed would cause rebirth as an animal, a middling as a preta and a higher as a hell being. These must be abandoned therefore. So if we take the example of the first non virtuous deed, killing, it is important to understand what killing is.
The importance of killing is contingent on the base. Killing, for instance, a god or a human being is much more severe as a non virtue than killing an animal. However, in this context, Geshe-la would prefer to explain these in terms of the four components of a complete deed which are the base, the thought, the connection or the accomplishment and the conclusion of the deed. If all four of these are present, the deed becomes a heavy deed. If all four are not present, but let us say three are present, it becomes a middling deed.
If only one is present, it becomes a deed of light karmic weight. So if we take the deed of killing for this deed to be complete all four components, the base, the thought, the deed and the completion of the deed must be present. In the case of a deed of killing, the base would be for instance the animal which is to be killed. The thought would be the intent to kill this animal. The deed would be the actual deed of performance of killing and the conclusion would be the death of the animal concerned.
Now regarding the two firsts, it is pretty evident, the base and the thought. However, regarding the deed, the deed of killing does not have to be performed by oneself. It can be performed by another whom we have enjoined to kill this being or which we have incited to kill the being by various means. If all four of these components of the deed are present, the base of thought, the deed and the completion, the deed becomes a very heavy sin. For instance, if we kill even an insect with these four components present, that deed of killing becomes very heavy.
If we kill a human being, generally speaking, the human base is an important base. But if having generated the intent to kill that human being, we do not lead the deed to conclusion that sin will be lighter because not all four components are present. Likewise, for the second non virtue and the non virtue of stealing, all four components, the base, the thought, the deed and the completion of the deed must be present. In the case of the base of stealing, it is the possessions of another. The thought is the intent to appropriate them or to steal them.
The deed is stealing them either oneself or having another steal them for oneself. And the conclusion is the thought these are at present mine. All four of these components must be present for each of the 10 non virtuous deeds. So regarding the third non virtuous deed, sexual misconduct likewise all four must be present. In this case, the base might be a person who is not one’s wife but that of another.
The thought is the intent to engage in sexual relations with that person. The deed is any type of sexual relation and the conclusion is the bliss experienced through this. The fourth non virtuous deed is the first non virtuous deed of speech, which is lying. The base of lying is asserting that something which exists does not exist or that something which does not exist exists. The thought is the intent of deceiving another.
The deed is either saying this oneself or causing another to say this. And the conclusion is when the other party has understood this. Then the fifth non virtuous deed, the second of speech is divisive speech. Divisive speech means to separate people who get along. The base of divisive speech is two persons who have harmonious relations.
The thought is the intent to cause disagreement between them. The deed is to say oneself or to have another say something which is going to put them at odds with each other and the conclusion is when this happens. Then the third non virtuous deed of speech is harsh words or insults. The base of harsh words is another person who is a recipient of these harsh words. The thought is the intent to offend another with harsh words.
The deed is to utter these words and the conclusion is when the other person understands these and for instance gets angry. Then the fourth non virtuous deed of speech is gossip or idle talk. Its base is meaningless matters such as politics, life in general and so forth, having fun. The intent is to talk about this. The deed is to do so and the deed is complete when one thinks this is all right, this was okay, this was fun.
The first of the non virtuous deeds of mind is covetousness. Covetousness refers in other words to desire. It is within the family of desire and it has four components. If we take the case for instance of covetousness for a car, the car would be the base. Then the thought would be the wish to think about or covet the qualities or the features of the car.
The deed would be for desire to rise for that car and the conclusion would be the feeling this is something I want to get. Then the following non virtuous deed, the ninth non virtuous deed and second non virtuous deed of mind is ill will. Ill will is a wish to harm another. Its base is another person one wishes to harm. The intent is a wish to harm this person.
The deed is plotting on how to harm this person and the conclusion is the delight which arises within the mind at the thought of harm befalling that person. The tenth non virtuous deed, the third non virtuous deed of mind is wrong views. This is a particularly important non virtuous deed. If we take its four components in the case of the triple gem, the base would be the triple gem, which is being investigated. The thought would be the hostile thought of investigating the triple gem.
The deed would be investigating it and the conclusion would be the thought the triple gem does not exist. This is a presentation of the 10 non virtuous deeds in term of their four components, the base, the thought, the deed and the completion of the deed and the three possible results of these 10 non virtuous deeds in function of whether four of the components are present, all four, in which case one is reborn in a hell realm or if two or three of the components are present, one will be reborn as a preta and if only one of the components is present, one will be reborn as an effect of maturation as an animal. In every single case, the result of these 10 non virtuous deeds is only suffering, therefore they must be abandoned. In our cases, we probably reflect very little about the 10 non virtuous deeds even those who have taken refuge are often not familiar with the 10 non virtuous deeds. It is for us to investigate our own minds and see whether they are present or not.
In our own cases, we have been familiar with the Ten Non-Virtuous Deeds since beginningless time. We engage in them easily. Therefore, if upon examination we have found that we have engaged in any of the Ten Non-Virtuous Deeds, we must prevent it from leading to maturation. We must prevent its maturation effect from arising and this is done through confession and through the application of the antidotes of the four forces. It is extremely important to purify through confession and if one purifies through confession with the opponent four forces, the potency of non virtuous deeds will be completely destroyed.
So what are these four forces and how should be applied in the process of confession? They are the force of the base, the force of rejection, the force of restraint and the force of application of an antidote or a means of purification. The base is the object towards whom we purify. The force of rejection is a thought this is completely inappropriate. The force of restraint is not engaging in these deeds in the future and the process purification is for instance reciting the Vajrasattva mantra.
If we do this, non virtuous deeds can be completely purified. The counterpart or the opposite of these 10 non virtues are the 10 virtues, which are the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. And likewise, the 10 virtues can be great, middling or small. If all four factors are present, the 10 virtues are great and they lead to rebirth as a god. If two or three are present, they are middling and lead to a higher rebirth.
If one is present, they at least lead to a human rebirth. In every case, the 10 non virtues, the 10 virtues, excuse me, lead exclusively to happiness. In addition to these, one must engage to obtain a human rebirth in the practices of the six perfections and specifically the practices of generosity, ethics and forbearance. Without the practice of generosity, ethics and forbearance, one may receive as a rebirth a human base, but for instance, one will be poor, destitute, one will for instance have physical ailments and so forth. So Geshe-la has completely explained here the meaning of the first verse of Āryadeva’s stanza engage in the practice of engage in the accumulation of merit.
The second verse which refers to the attainment of liberation will be explained later. Oh, yeah. Yes. You recite the taking of refuge in Tibetan. So the following verse in the eight verses of mind training reads as follows.
Whenever I am in the company of others, may I regard myself as inferior to all and from the depths of my heart cherish others as supreme. Regarding oneself as inferior to all and cherishing others as supreme is the foremost means to counter pride. His Holiness’ commentary reads, should we engage in the practice of love and of compassion for the sake of our own happiness and welfare? Since such deeds are included within the category of egotistical deeds, their result will not be a worthy result. Geshe-la says that even though we were to engage in practices of love and compassion which are the foundation of bodhicitta, if we were to do so for egotistical purposes such practices do not enter within the scope of the Mahāyāna.
On the other hand, we must engage from the innermost depths of our hearts in the generation of the mindset which wishes to benefit others through striving for the happiness of others. Here Geshe-la says it is with such a mindset that we strive for the attainment of full enlightenment not for our own sake but for the sake of others. This definitely refers to the practice of altruism which is the foremost ground for us striving to attain full enlightenment. We strive to attain full enlightenment through realizing that in our present condition we cannot truly help others. However, once we have attained full enlightenment we can.
The arrogance which views oneself as supreme and through cherishing oneself views others as lower than oneself is an extremely great obstructing force to the attainment and the development of the mind which wishes to benefit others through altruism. So what is the self-cherishing or egoism which is referred to here? The self-cherishing or egoism is the root of all suffering and all unhappiness. It is naturally present within the minds of all of us except perhaps those who are Bodhisattvas. It is that mind which thinks I come first.
I should take care of number one. Therefore the meaning of this line in his holiness’s commentary is that if we can eliminate the self-cherishing or the egoism which is rooted in the overvaluation of whatever qualities we might have whether it be our wealth, our good looks, our strength, our social status and if we can eliminate this then this will definitely foster our practice of altruism. Moving on within the commentary, on the other hand, if one is humble, one’s qualities, one’s good qualities will increase whereas if one is filled with pride and arrogance, one will not experience even the slightest atom of happiness. Clearly through humility one’s qualities will increase and one will be appreciated by others whereas with pride this will not be the case. In addition under the power of pride, envy towards others, anger, a deprecating view will arise and in dependence on this there will be unhappiness both within one’s family and within society at large.
This is very true. When great pride is present within oneself, one will not be valued by others who will say this is a very haughty and arrogant person and oneself will not be happy. For that matter, one’s pride will act as a cause for the dawn of envy and jealousy when we see the qualities of others. His Holiness’s commentary moves onwards. It is in dependence on false lines of reasoning that pride arises within our continuum as well as the mind which apprehends ourselves as supreme from within others.
Here the lines of reasoning which give rise to pride, arrogance and haughtiness are actually fallacious or wrong lines of reasoning. On the other hand, we should focus on eliminating pride through reflecting on our own faults and on the qualities of others. For instance, if we were to take the example of this insect which is next to my throne buzzing away, on the one hand if we were to reflect on the situation, I am a human being and I am a bhikṣu, a fully ordained monk. I am definitely more important than this insect. Yet, on the other hand, reflecting on it differently, this insect under the power of benightedness is completely unable to engage in the practice of Dharma he is however the basis for my own practice of Dharma.
Let alone this, this insect through numerous means engages in non virtuous deeds and dwells in that state. I, on the other hand, have the totality of the capacities of a human being. Should I use my mental capacities under the influence of a wild mind wrongly and instead of taking on the burden of practice as well as the responsibilities which go hand in hand with being ordained and with being a human being and should I therefore use my human base wrongly, my situation would be far worse than that of this insect. Thinking in this way is definitely of benefit. In the case of the insect we can see that the insect is profoundly ignorant and this ignorance means that it cannot engage in the slightest in the practice of virtue.
It does not have a clue regarding the four components of a virtuous deed. On the other hand, the insect cannot engage in extreme non virtuous deeds which we as human beings because of our exceptional mental acumen can do. Human beings can engage in non virtuous deeds which are as vast as this world of ours. So we can see that there is a big difference. However, for the sake of countering pride, oneself should train in humility or such is said.
This should not be the occasion for coarse and rough behaviour. Instead, one should counter the pride which has arisen through skillful practice and through targeting it carefully. The following stanza of the eight stanzas of mind training, in all my actions, may I watch my mind and as soon as the afflictions arise, may I forcefully stop them at once since they will hurt both me and others. Here therefore we must be mindful of the very instant the afflictions arise within our mind stream and instantaneously try to eliminate them. When we engage in practices of these worthy states of mind of altruism, Should the afflictions arise spontaneously we should put great effort to counter them.
For instance, both anger and pride harm greatly the enhancement of altruistic thoughts. And therefore we should not allow these afflictions to arise within our mind stream but should instantaneously apply the antidotes and as swiftly as we can eliminate them. It is our own responsibility to apply the antidotes as soon as the afflictions arise within our mind. For instance, when a desire arises in our mind upon observing a beautiful car, we should counter this desire through reflecting on the faults of this car. And think for instance, just how ugly the car will look after an accident or something like that.
Likewise, regarding anger, when we are in a situation where another person and ourselves become very angry, we should reflect that it is actually through our own ignorance that anger arises in the other person’s mind that this other person wishes to be happy and wishes not to be unhappy just as ourselves, but through not understanding the situation becomes angry and that this anger harms them. Then we should reflect on the fact that we ourselves are responsible for this situation and this will lead to a great decrease in the anger in our own mind stream. Likewise, the antidote to pride, arrogance or haughtiness is the thought that whatever quality we have comes from another. For instance, we could reflect on the fact that our wealth comes from another, our education comes from another and finally ask ourselves what precisely do I have from my own side? This reduces pride and then if it is still present, one should reflect on the innumerable variety of objects of knowledge and this will reduce pride even more.
And one should treat all afflictions likewise. So in truth anger, pride, competitiveness, envy and so forth are our true enemies. So there is no time to present in detail the six root afflictions, the 20 and some branch afflictions and so forth. There is no one who has not experienced anger and there is no one who has ever been happy through anger. Nobody is happy when anger arises and there has never been a doctor who has said to his patients, you must get angry to overcome your disease.
If anger arises within our mind stream, it will never occur for our mind to be happy as a result of this. Therefore, we must find means to eliminate the afflictions. We can see for instance that, even though, it would be very difficult for someone to cut our jugular artery, nonetheless through the power of anger we ourselves are able to cut our own jugular artery and this can be seen in cases of suicide. We should become acquainted with the varieties of the afflictions and even when a slight affliction threatens to arise, we should reflect that it is unsuitable in the same way as it is advised to reflect about it. Otherwise, just as a blaze in a house starts with a small spark and leads to the whole house being engulfed with fire, we can be engulfed with the afflictions.
We can see this for instance, when great craving for an object such as a car arises. Initially, there is no particular interest from our side in the car, but through observing it again and again and thinking about reasons for which it will be attractive, our craving for the car increases ever more. The mind is unstable, isn’t it? As soon as the afflictions have arisen within our mind stream, one should immediately apply the requisite antidotes. And for this it is important to understand how precisely to counter the afflictions.
For instance, should desire just have arisen within our mind stream, one should reflect on ugliness. Alternatively, one can meditate on the close placement of mindfulness on the body or the close placement of mindfulness on the sensations. And therefore one should use various lines of reasonings to counter the afflictions in the case of desire. These lines of reasonings focus on the ugliness and the unattractiveness of the object of desire. Likewise, one could generate the wisdom which recollects the selflessness of the body.
Or in the case of a car, we recollect the fact that the car is impermanent, it is transitory and it is selfless. In the numerous lines of reasoning involving the close placement of mindfulness on sensations awareness of the impermanence of sensations. When anger arises, one should meditate on love and when pride arises, one should meditate on the 12 links of dependent origination or alternatively on the divisions of the constituents, the 18 dhatus and so forth. The root antidote to all of the wrong views is the wisdom which realizes emptiness and the final verse expounds this.
This is the presentation of the afflicted mind. And Geshe-la at present I would like to take your questions. Hi. Hello? Hello.
Can you hear me? I was just wondering if you could please give me another antidote for anger. Say, for example, when you feel it in the moment, I know I know to go home and to meditate on love and what people have given me. But say when you’re feeling anger in the moment or frustration in the moment, there’s any antidotes that you can give that I might be able to take home. The main antidote to anger is love but there are other antidotes such as reflecting on the fact that anger has no qualities, it has no benefits.
So when anger arises in our minds we should think what benefits does this have for me? It doesn’t have any benefits. Then this weakens it immediately. We are generally not aware of the fact that anger is arising within our minds. So we first have to become aware of it and then when we are aware of it, we should think there is no benefit in this anger either for myself or for others.
When we were talking about, the four components about killing, I missed the part where you said not all four components need to be present for a human killing. Can you just elaborate? Definitely even if all four components are not present we can accumulate the non virtue such as a partial non virtue of killing. For instance, if we meet another human being and we think this is an awful person and I wish he would die, then even if we do not perform the deed and the person does not die, then the first two components of the deed which are the basis, another human being, and intention to kill our present. As a result of this, non virtuous karma is definitely accumulated but it is a weak karma because the deed is not complete.
I have an uncle who has many, many, many, many books and yet I know that he isn’t covetous at all of them because when you go to his house, if you like a book, he just gives it to you. I have few books and I guard them like each one of them was a breath of mine. And my question is, it’s about how what is the non virtue of misjudgment of another? Often time and time again I’ve learnt that it’s very important to guard one’s own mind and not to examine another’s mind or make judgments. What non virtue is that and what is the antidote to that?
So this is this non virtue of seeing others in a lowly fashion is definitely a non virtue but it is not included within the three mental non virtues. It is not an exhaustive list. It is definitely an affliction, however. Thank you, Geshe-la. Could you just say something about the close placement of mindfulness of the body and the sensations as an antidote to One would train for instance in the close placement of mindfulness on the body through reflecting on the faults of the body such as the fact that the body is selfless, the fact that it is impermanent and so forth.
This one. Does that answer your question? Yes. Thank you. And just, we have an election coming up.
How can we avoid, the non virtue of? Discussing about your prime ministers is really idle talk. And then how to abandon it, you should try not to talk about it. Just give it up. There is no question that idle talk and gossip are afflictions.
Geshe-la says they are among the most difficult afflictions to abandon because they are terribly pleasant afflictions. So when one speaks of the abandonment of an affliction such as gossip, one can abandon the actualization of gossip or the very root of gossip. Abandoning the actualization of gossip is pretty easy. You just don’t engage in it. But abandoning it from the root entails realizing selflessness and that is difficult.
That’s the way it is. Please. Hi. Just to clarify, you said before the first non virtuous deed I think was killing. And if say, for example, in your lifetime, you reached conclusion with that deed, within your lifetime, I understand you go to a hell realm or a lesser realm in the next life.
But I think you also said you could purify or extinguish that in this life to avoid that. Is that the case with you can undo that bad karma? Yes, definitely that is the case. Even if one has accumulated the karma of killing, it can be purified through the application of the four forces. What are these four forces?
The first is the force of the base. The base can either be the Buddha or sentient beings because all the non virtuous deeds we accumulate, we accumulate either with respect to the triple gem or towards sentient beings. Killing is a non virtuous deed accumulated with respect to sentient beings. So the base we rely on is sentient beings. The second opponent force is profound repentance.
The desire never to do such a deed again and profound regret for having done it. The third opponent force is the opponent force of restraint. The resolution never to engage in such a deed again and the fourth is the application of a virtuous antidote. It might be for instance recitation of the sūtra of Confession or the mantra of Vajrasattva. Then if one does this correctly, the potency, the karmic potency of the deed of killing will be totally eliminated just as the potency of a grain of rice to give rise to a rice sprout will be destroyed if that grain of rice is put in a fire.
It can no longer give rise to a grain of rice. To tell us that what you’re doing is wrong. Yes. Definitely, is very good to do that. Because you are preventing somebody from engaging in a non virtue.
If somebody you know is engaging in a non virtue, you should tell them this is not good, this is wrong, you shouldn’t do this. Then they will not do it anymore. It will be of benefit if you tell them this was a non virtue, you should confess, you should purify, then there is benefit. And then don’t do that in the future, then there is real benefit. Hello.
Okay. I have announcement. We have sent a email. You know? This is, actually on a Friday this Friday coming.
No. No. No. This Friday coming, you know, evening. Tibetan community in South Australia, tried to make a fundraise, and, it is not fundraise for us in the community.
Really, this is you know the what situation in happening in Tibet. And we try to all the Tibetan communities in Australia and also the other organizations, we try to get globally awareness to what’s happening in Tibet so that in order to do that, this needs a lot of huge money. So and every Tibetan community has a responsibility to take that undertake. So we would really strongly it’s giving a very short notice, but, however, you know, we really want to push, you know, please come and help and support for this fundraising. And, you know, the the the situation in Tibet is is unbelievable, and you know what’s happening in Tibet.
The Dalai Lama and Tibetan exile has not so much power. But, however, we make push as much as possible globally. You know, this is a big serious gathering to bring awareness because
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- preta
- Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.