Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2012.08.15_00.00_01.MP3
UUID: 9ac94a39-9385-4d94-b572-c1719c69239f
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Four Noble Truths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2012-08-15
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 48m
Words: 3,585
Day one, session one. Long weekend teachings. Though I suspect that the terminology of these 37 facets of enlightenment is a new one for all of you. Nonetheless, the meaning of the 37 facets of enlightenment encompasses the very essence of appropriating virtue and abandoning knowledge. If we summarize the meaning of the 37 facets of enlightenment, they can be summarized into seven subdivisions.
Now generally speaking this is closely connected to the presentation of grounds and paths of Salam. There are two types of Salam. Salam from the standpoint of Sutra and Salam from the standpoint of secret mantra. It would be good for you to take careful notes and to memorize what you do not know. And definitely, if you have any doubts, you should raise questions.
Easter indeed is a period of the year, the Easter break during which it is very pleasant to relax, to go on walks and so forth. It is not that this is unpleasant, but if we reflect on it, we can see that basically it is rather meaningless. And at this point, we should generate delight at the prospect of spending three of those days engaging in virtue. Studies of a topic such as the 37 facets of enlightenment. Since these, when they are summarized, are none other than the presentation of the formal truths, this will be extremely beneficial for us.
If we were to reflect on the alarming of the graduated stages of the past during one day, in reality, all of this reflection could be summarized within these 37 facets of the path. For that matter, all the alarming, from its inception to its conclusion can be summarized within these 37 facets of the path. She can study how the totality of the lamrim can be subsumed in the 37 branches of enlightenment and how these can be subsumed into the formal truths. Gone forth from the lay life. They have gone forth for what?
They have gone forth first to abandon all of the activities and mindsets of a lay person and to engage intensively in the practice of virtue. What specifically is this practice of virtue? None others than the fornomer truths and in dependence on this, the practice of the great situation, then one can just as an ordained person engage in the practice of virtue and as Kinsulin Burchie emphasized over and again, meditate, meditate. One should meditate. In this sense, there is no difference between those who are ordained and those who are not ordained.
It is important to understand the meaning of ordination, which is the practice of virtue and not wearing some strange yellow clothing. Then even if one does not have leisure as a layperson one has responsibilities such as taking care of children and family responsibilities. Nonetheless it is important that this time not go to waste and one should use every opportunity to study. Study the four noble truths. Here when we refer to hearing, hearing in Buddhist terminology means to study.
Then when one attends teachings, one should focus on the meaning and try to remember them. Otherwise, it would be a great waste if after let us say two or three days of teachings, one should think I really haven’t learned anything and I didn’t go on walks and didn’t watch television either. Now regarding the 37 facets of enlightenment, in Tibetan. This topic is presented within Sutra and specifically within Abhidharma, But it is presented most extensively within What do the 37 facets of enlightenment refer to? Here the term Jano enlightenment actually does not refer to enlightenment itself but to liberation.
And to attain liberation, to attain the state of an Arhat, eight qualities or eight things are required. So here, the 37 facets of meditation are the basis of meditation. That which is meditated upon or the object of meditation is the four noble truths. So when we meditate on the four noble truths, we meditate on the four noble truths by the means of mentally the 37 facets of enlightenment. So at present, are these 37 facets of enlightenment present within our mind stream or not?
They are not, almost certainly not. However, they can be generated in the future at the condition that we initially generate renunciation, which is a gateway to the path as a demon’s admitting scope. Now regarding the noble truths, we are all familiar with the terminology of the four noble truths. The words are easy to utter, but it is a very different matter regarding the meaning. This is something we must think over again and again.
So what did the Canopus of yours say regarding the Four Noble Truths? They considered that the first of the four noble truths, the noble truths of suffering and of the origin of suffering are psychic existence. Therefore, they asserted that when cyclic existence is presented in a succinct format it is none other than the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering. When the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering are developed these are none other than the thoroughly afflicted the 12 Now what is the opposite of psychic existence? It is Nirvana or liberation.
When Nirvana or liberation is expanded it is presented as the last of the four noble truths, the number truth of cessation and of the path. And these are none other than the opposite of the thoroughly afflicted twelve days or if you prefer, they are the thoroughly purified twelve days. So the forward progression of the thoroughly afflicted 12 limbs leads to lower rebirths. When on the other hand, they are incremented in reverse progression, then they lead to higher rebirths. In other words, in the forward progression, the twelve weeks are cyclic existence, and in the reverse progression, they are liberation.
And the progression from the path of the meaning scope to the path of the great scope occurs upon understanding that just as I myself meander in cyclic existence under the power of the thoroughly afflicted 12 limbs, likewise so do all sentient beings and this generates great compassion which is a gateway The 37 facets of enlightenment are the basis of meditation and the Four Noble Truths are the object of meditation or that which is meditated upon. Now from within the three categories of beings, in other words hearers, solitary realizers, Prateka Buddhas, and bodhisattvas. Who is the foremost or which are the foremost categories which meditate on these 37 facets of enlightenment? It is principally hearers and solitary realizers. This is an important point.
It is important to understand what is meant when we say that the principle of the foremost beings who trained in the 37 facets of enlightenment or the four number twos are hearers and solitary realizers. They are the foremost beings according to Sutra but they are not the only beings. We are not saying that bodhisattvas do not train in the form of the truths. Obviously they do. So it is extremely important in this way to lay the foundations.
Otherwise, if we immediately start talking of these 37 facets of enlightenment without talking of the four noble truths, then confusion would occur. So this is from the standpoint of persons. Now from the standpoint of past, within which path are these 37 facets of enlightenment included, they are included within the path of the being of the middling scope precisely. Since most of you reflect on the past in terms of the past of the being small small building in Gradescope is very helpful to show where within these three paths the 37 facets of enlightenment must be occluded. So this is regarding the paths of the beingness of these three scopes.
Now within the three turnings of the wheel of the law, which is a subdivision of the teachings that the Buddha uttered. The first turning of the wheel of the law, the beginning, and the final, where do these 37 facets of enlightenment or where are they included? They are included within the first turning of the wheel of the law with the follower truth. Now when the teacher Buddha Shakyamuni turned the first queen of the law and first taught to the first five disciples, he taught the four noble truths. In other words, he taught the 37 facets of enlightenment.
The four noble truths are none other than the object of meditation. The 37 facets of enlightenment are the basis of meditation. Recipients of the teachings were all Hinayana practitioners, in other words hearers and solitary realizers. So the first turning of the wheel of the law, the turning of the law of the wheel of the four normal truths, is a turning of the law for Hinayana practitioners. In other words, for hearers and solitary realizers.
Here there is an important point to be made. We have to distinguish between Hinayana practitioners and propounders of Hinayana tenets. I suspect that quite a few of us confuse Hinayana practitioners and proponents of Hinayana tenets, thinking that Hinayana practitioners are necessarily proponents of Hinayana tenets or the opposite. This is not the case. I would think that a Hinayana practitioner is a practitioner who is on their way to practicing as a bodhisattva, the full enlightenment path and a Hinayana propounded tenets is one that believes that liberation is the final achievement of the path and do not hold with full enlightenment.
This distinction between Hinayana beings and propounders of Hinayana tenets is an extremely important one. Hinayana beings are definitely enumerated or definitely subdivided into two. They are either hearers or pratyaka buddhas. Hearers or pratyaka buddhas, in other words, Hinayana beings, are beings who have generated an uncontrived enunciation which strives for liberation for their own sake. So that’s for Hinayana being.
If someone is a Hinayana being, he is necessarily either a hearer or a solitary realizer. There is no third category. Propounders of Mahayana tenants are exhaustively subdivided into Vaibhashikas and Sultanica. In other words, if someone is a propounder of Hinayana tenants, he or she is necessarily either Vaivashika or a Sautrantika. And the characteristic of proponents of exterior of Hinayana tenets is that they accept that exterior physical entities are constituted of indivisible atoms.
So it’s very helpful for us to reflect on the relationship between Hinayana beings and propounders of Hinayana tenets. Is someone who is a Hinayana being necessary a propounder of Hinayana tenants or not? Is someone who is a propounder of Hinayana tenets necessarily a Hinayana being or not? In terms of Buddhist logic, we speak here of either three or four possibilities. We shall not enter into that, but we’ll waste a lot of time.
But I would like to ask you, so is a being who is a propounder of hinayana tenants necessarily So you have to know about the Hina nine tenets to be do liberation. And then when you progress, you want to progress to the next level and go to So the answer to the question are all propounders of Hinayana tenets Hinayana beings is no. The reason is that there are Bodhisattvas who are propounders of Hinayana tenets but who are not Hinayana beings. And the example given is dharma rakshita. It is said that bodhisattvas up to the path of accumulation can be propounders of Hinayana tenets but obviously they are not Hinayana beings.
Likewise, someone who is a Hinayana being is not necessarily a proponent of Hinayana tenets. So let me ask you what do you think? But the question is, if someone is a Hinayana being, is that person necessarily a propounder of Hinayana tenets? Hinayana by philosophy, if you prefer. Yes.
That is exactly it. You have beings who are citta mantras, but who in terms of their motivation are hearers or solitary realizers. So it doesn’t matter. Just reflect over again and again on the distinction between Hinayana beings and proponents of Hinayana tenets. So if we summarize the 37 facets of enlightenment, They are subdivided into seven.
The first of which is the close placement of recollection and you have a list of the seven on your handout, the seven subdivisions. Subdivided into seven. And the first of these subdivisions is the close placement of recollection or mindfulness. So the first thing to ask yourself is whether or not this topic, foreclosed place mindfulness, is present within the boundary. There are two modes of explanation of the close placement of recollection or the close placement of mindfulness.
The first is that after recollecting the Four Noble Truths and closely placing one’s recollection on the Four Noble Truths, As a result of this close placement of recollection, wisdom increases. So an example is given to illustrate this. If we want to cut a tree with an axe, first we must grip the axe firmly in our hand before splitting the tree. Gripping the axe firmly in our hand is the action of reconnection. The splitting is the focusing of the follower truths.
So this example is quite profound. Anyone who has any experience of splitting wood or cutting wood with an axe knows that if you hold the axe firmly and aim at one point then you will split the wood rapidly. If you hold it loosely and you keep splitting to the right, to the left, above, below, it’s a very long process. So we can see this result topics of study. If we have powerful reconnection, in other words powerful memory, then we progress rapidly in our studies and our capacity of analyzing the topic deepens swiftly.
If we have a weak memory then we must go over the topics we are studying over and again because we cannot remember them. We cannot reconnect them. And it takes a very long time for analysis to lead to wisdom. The Vaibhashikas assert that since initially through reconnection one must focus forcefully on the fold over truths in the same way as someone splitting wood must initially grip the axe firmly before splitting a log. For this reason, the first subdivision is called a closed placement of reconnection.
Indian scholar Haribhata who is the father of all Paranita literature and who gives a slightly different etymology or explanation for the close placement of recollection. Haribhata says that it is because the wisdom which analyzes the four truths when it analyzes needs strong memory that this is called a close placement of recollection. So since all of us wish to understand the four noble truths so as to attain liberation, let us generate during a couple of minutes a powerful wish or motivation to attain liberation to the study of these 37 facets of enlightenment. So now when we study a topic like this, it is inappropriate for the studies to be nearly booked. Instead, we should take ourselves as an example and reflect on the path of the meaning of the middling scope since I assume pretty much everyone in this room meditates a little longer, we know that the main topic of the path of the meaning of the middling scope is the four noble truths.
And we should investigate within ourselves. When I think on of the global truth of suffering, of the origin of suffering, of cessation of the path, is my thinking in keeping with the 37 facets of enlightenment or not. So if we study the first of the seven subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment, you find the graphic on the first page of definition here. The second is the mode of meditation. The third is the purpose of meditation.
The fourth is the nature. The fifth is the subdivisions. The sixth is the boundaries, the seventh is the etymology, and the eighth is positing the supremacy of close placement of recollection according close placement of mindfulness. The object of the close placement of mindfulness is the Four Noble Truths. Now when we hear about the Four Noble Truths, let us say about the Noble Truths of suffering, have to ask ourselves if this reflection of the four number two connects or links with the 37 facets of enlightenment and specifically the first of the seven subdivisions, the close placement of mindfulness, a reconnection, Now the specific objects of the close placement of mindfulness are fourfold.
They are close placement of recollection of mindfulness on the body, on sensation, on the mind and on phenomena. So the second outline of this first topic of close placement of mindfulness is none other than the mode of meditation. So at present we have to see indeed whether or not the way we practice Liksa with this mode of meditation on body, on sensation, on mind or phenomena or not. So the objects, therefore, of the cross placement of the collection are body, Now when we speak of the neurotrically of suffering, what are we speaking of? We are speaking of our contaminated aggregates.
What precisely are these contaminated aggregates? Well, the simplest way of presenting them, the most accessible to the mind is this body of flesh and blood. Is this body of flesh and blood in support of suffering or not? We have to Now since this is a new topic, a new terminology for you, please do listen carefully. Otherwise, there is a considerable risk of getting lost and confused.
So the third subdivision, what is the purpose of meditating on these four subdivisions of the close placement of recollection? In other words, body, sensation, mind, phenomenon. We are all beings who strive for liberation. Striving for liberation entails understanding what is to be appropriated within the foldable truth and what is to be relinquished. The mode of apprehension of the eye of the ignorance which grasps at an eye.
And we do not understand how to posit the I merely in terms of terminology or nominally. So we must be able to make the distinction between the I which exists and the I which does not exist. So in as much as self apprehension or self grasping is the obstacle to the attainment of liberation, we have to understand how the self is mistakenly apprehended. The self is apprehended as existing within our body as if our body were its abode. Sensations which we experience are apprehended as the wealth of the self.
Precisely or where precisely is this I, we will find there is an intuitive sense that the I is within the mind. This is a viewpoint which is shared by all the schools of tenets from Atemika and Atemika downward, Now don’t worry. These topics must be listened to over and again. And after listening to the presentation of these topics, one must analyze. And if one doesn’t hear these presentations over and again, indeed one does forget.
So it is important for us to have mental fortitude and courage. So this ignorance which grasps at a self is grasping at what? It is grasping at a part of the mind. The mind is the stuff of which the self is made. And this is something we can see when we investigate within ourselves.
Exception of sensation which was covered in the second subdivision of the close placement of recollection. Well, so phenomena include as well all virtuous and non virtuous mental states present within our minds. Subdivision of these 37. The first of the sevenfold subdivision is the close placement of recollection. This in turn is subdivided into eight topics.
The first of which is the object of the close placement of recollection. The object of the close placement of recollection is fourfold. Close placement of recollection on the body, on sensations, on mind and on phenomena. Then within the other subdivisions of the presentation, one presents the reason for meditating in this way on the cross placement of recollection, and the reason is to attain liberation. Now the way in which the four noble truths are connected to this fourfold subdivision of the object of the close placement of recollection is that the body alludes to the noble truth of suffering.
Sensation alludes to the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Mind alludes to the noble truth of cessation and phenomena alludes to the noble truth of the path. So therefore when one meditates on the four noble truths, one should ask oneself is my meditation on the four noble truths in keeping with this presentation of these 37 facets of enlightenment and specifically the first of the seventh subdivisions of these 37 which is close placement of recollection. And within this, the eightfold subdivision to the object, the four focuses which are body, sensation, mind, and phenomena, the we shall stop here. Perhaps we have covered the first seven subdivisions of the 37 facets of enlightenment.
This is itself presented in terms of eight topics. The first of which is the object. The object from fourfold, body, sensation, mind and phenomena. And after that we get the other topics such as word of meditation, the purpose of meditation, and so forth. So with the presentation of these 37 facets of enlightenment, what is quite new is the presentation of the close placements of the collection.
This is something we have to focus upon. The other 37 facets of enlightenment with the remaining 33 are topics we will be familiar with. Have a good lunch, everyone. Thank you. You too, Geshela.
Key terms in this teaching
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- Secret Mantra sang ngag (Tib)
- Another name for Vajrayana, so called because it should not be revealed to those not ready. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.