1 h 46 min · 3,907 words · 23 February 2011
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues an earlier session on the motivation and posture for listening to the Dharma. Teaches karma and causality, including the three timings of karmic maturation, the role of causes and conditions, and shared versus unshared karma. Then comments on verses of the Queen of Sharp Weapons on taking others’ suffering, explaining Lojong as training in other-cherishing and abandoning self-cherishing through tonglen.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 47m
UUID: b8004586-c625-41cb-a869-911b06300b99
Date: 2011-02-23
Words: 3,903
Okay. So regarding the manner of explaining and listening to the Dharma, Rinpoche has explained last time and on former occasions the motivation with which one has to listen as well as the bodily position with which one must listen to the Dharma teachings. So when we refer to the motivation to listen to the teachings, what is this motivation we are speaking of? It is not a motivation of self-cherishing, where we value ourselves alone, instead it is a motivation of cherishing others, which cherishes others in infinite numbers, reflecting on the fact that all sentient beings without exception, who are precious mothers of former lives, wish for happiness and wish to be separated from suffering. However, even though they wish to be happy and wish to be separated from suffering, they do not understand how to create the causes for happiness and how to create or how to eliminate the causes for suffering.
For that matter, they are so, ignorant, that not only do they do they not understand this, they actually think that non virtue which is the cause of suffering is the cause of happiness and that virtue which is the cause of happiness is the cause of suffering. With this as an approach, what else could there be but suffering? Then reflecting on this from our side, we generate the wish that all these sentient beings be free from suffering and the causes of suffering, and we generate the motivation to set them in a place of unalloyed bliss, and reflecting on the fact that at present we are unable to do so, we generate the motivation to attain the great enlightenment, a state where all qualities are accomplished and all thoughts are eliminated to place all sentient beings in that state. With this as a motivation, we engage in the fourfold activities of hearing, contemplating, thinking and meditating on these teachings. So as Buddha Śākyamūni said in a famous quote of which we will translate translate to the first verse at present, which is an oral instruction regarding karma and causality.
The embodied affected by the twofold categories of Karma. Now, in this verse, the term the embodied actually refers to sentient beings. Sentient beings are said to be embodied. In general, sentient beings have body and mind and sentient beings can be imputed on either. When the concept is imputed on an entity with the body, it is said to be an embodied creature and this is a term which is used here.
All in general sentient beings are said to have five aggregates and sentient beings can be imputed on any of the five aggregates. In this specific context they are imputed on the basis of the form aggregate. The term the embodied does not apply for sentient beings of the formless realms who do not have a coarse physical body, although they do have subtle bodies. Now in this context Buddha is speaking of interdependence, dependent origination. What is interdependence?
Interdependence is the arising of an effect in dependence on a cause. We have to make a distinction between karma and causality on the one hand and interdependence on the other hand. Karma and causality are included within interdependence which has a larger scope, while karma and causality have a smaller scope. For instance, karma and causality can be understood to refer to new deeds which are performed under the impulse of a motivation by one actor. This is something which refers specifically to karma and causality, but we have many instances for instance of dependent origination or interdependence which are not karma and causality.
For instance, a seed can give rise to a crop or to a tree. This is a case of interdependence, this is not a case of karma and causality. So a famous example one could give of karma and causality in operation would be when an actor, a subject under the influence of faith in the Buddha makes a prostration to the Buddha. In so doing, he or she accumulates virtuous karma. An example of non virtuous karma would be motivated by the desire to eat fish, to kill a fish and then eat it.
This would be a case of non virtuous karma. Likewise, motivated by the desire to eat fowl to kill a bird and then to eat its flesh would be a case of non virtuous karma. So there are three different categories of karma, a virtuous karma, non virtuous karma, and neutral karma. The two first categories are powerful, the third category neutral karma is not able to give rise clearly to an effect. When we say that the two first categories virtuous and non virtuous karma are powerful, we mean that they give rise to powerful effects which in the case of virtuous karma are happiness and in the case of non virtuous karma are non happiness.
Therefore, all virtue without exception gives rise to happiness and all non virtue without exception gives rise to suffering. As Nāgārjuna said, from a non virtue arises suffering and thereby all of the lower realms. The lower realms here refer to these three lower realms of the animals, the pretas and the hell realms. And the quote continues and reads, from virtue arises all the happiness of the higher realms. This refers to the higher realms of human beings, demigods and gods.
There are in addition three divisions of karma from the standpoint of how the effect matures. These can be understood as the mode of maturation of the effect in which the effect matures within this life. This is said to be karma which is seen within one lifetime. Then karma which does not mature in one life, but matures in the following life. And the third category of karma is karma which matures in some future life other than the immediately following life.
The first category of karma is karma which arises from deeds performed with respect to the heaviest objects. For a worldly being this would be one’s parents, whereas for a Dharma practitioner this would be one’s spiritual teacher or the Buddha. One’s parents for a worldly being are the heaviest karmic object because it is thanks to the kindness of one’s parents that we have obtained this body, that all interfering conditions have been eliminated and all beneficial conditions have been created. It is actually thanks to the kindness of our parents that we survive. Without this kindness we would not be here.
If we were to, harm, let alone to kill our parents, then the non virtuous deed would be extraordinarily heavy and would lead to maturation, karmic maturation within this very life. Likewise, for a being which is a Dharma practitioner, any harm inflicted to the spiritual teacher or the Buddha would have the same type of result within one lifetime. The second category of karmic deed are deeds which are not able to mature within one lifetime, but which would mature in the following life. This would for instance be cases of virtuous deeds which have been accumulated and which in the next life would lead us to obtain a human rebirth. The third category of deeds are deeds which are too weak to mature in the following life, but which will most definitely mature quietly over time in future lives.
It is not the case that they will not mature, we will definitely experience them at some point in the future. And therefore it is not the case that when karma has been accumulated, its effect does not arise. Its effect will arise eventually after numerous years, even after eons. If the cause has been accumulated, it will not be destroyed and it can give rise to an effect. So here when we speak of karma, we are speaking of causes.
For causes to give rise to their effects, both the cause itself and the conditions are necessary. If both are absent, the effect cannot arise. However, once the cause is created and the effect, the conditions have been assembled, then the effect will necessarily arise. If we take the two fold division of karma into virtuous and non virtuous karma, virtuous karma can actually be destroyed through powerful anger. Anger therefore is extremely powerful in this respect.
Non virtuous karma on the other hand can be destroyed through the powerful application of its antidotes. Otherwise, if it is not actually destroyed, it will survive for countless eons. If you were to take the example of a field in which seeds have been planted, the seed are actually the cause of the crop, but without the conditions of water, of warmth and of manure, in other words among others of rain, then even if the seed is present, it cannot give rise to a crop, to its effect. However, it will stay in the ground for centuries and when the conditions are assembled, the seed will give rise to a crop. So the conditions which lead to the maturation of virtuous karma are for instance, faith or conviction.
The convict conditions which lead to the maturation of non virtuous karma are, for instance, anger or desire. And therefore it is capital for us to understand clearly, karma and causality from which all arise and specifically from which all events in future lives arise. This is the core of the Lamrim presentation. For instance, we very casually commit minor infraction, minor non virtuous deeds, without reflecting that a minor non virtuous deed can give rise to a huge result. This is something we do not understand.
Likewise, very small virtuous deeds can in turn give rise to a huge result. So when we accumulate small non virtues, it is capital to confess them. Otherwise, when they grow important, they can impel a rebirth in the hell realms or a preta realm. We talk frequently and casually about bodhicitta and about the view of reality. It is difficult for these however to be generated independently of karma and causality.
In India, anciently one of Atisha’s guru was Avadhutipa, and when Avadhutipa and Atisha were travelling together as guru and disciple, Avadhutipa addressed Atisha whose view was a Prāsaṇgika view, and he said to him, Atisha, in dependence on a space-like view, many scholars and noble ones were reborn in the hell realms. They were reborn in the hell realms in dependence on karma and causality. So we will now continue with the root text of the Queen of Sharp Weapons. So, Rinpoche, we’ll now continue on page 17 of your English text, the middle, the meaning of the stanza. When suffering arises in one’s mind, since it is definitely through having troubled the mental continuum of others that the sword of evil karma has revolved back upon me.
At present, may I take all dukkha without exception upon myself. At which he says that it will not be possible for him to go in detail through commentary, which would be extraordinary, but it is very long. Taught from experience, and therefore will focus mainly on the root text, which is in bold letters here. When suffering arises in one’s mind, the first verse, suffering here refers to a feeling of discomfort or unease, and one’s mind is a mind of one’s own self, the I, which is referred to here. Since it is definitely through having trouble the mental continuum of others, Others here refer to the Guru, to the spiritual teacher, to one’s parents, to one’s friends, or to sentient beings in general.
Generally speaking, whatever suffering which arises within our mind stream, and as we know, we experience a lot of mental suffering, is not causeless. This suffering is an effect and there is no such thing as an effect which does not have a cause, and what is pointed out here in verse two is the cause of the effect which was indicated in verse one. So here the effect is one’s own mind being troubled, and we experienced these extreme mental sufferings ourselves through having troubled the minds of others. The third verse, that the sword of evil karma has revolved back upon me, The term the sword actually refers to the effect which we are experiencing. This is the non virtuous karma which strikes at us as a result of what we have inflicted upon others.
Heboucher says, it is akin to terrorists who plant bombs and then themselves are the recipient of an explosion. And moving onwards to the fourth verse, at present, may I take all dukkha without exception upon myself? Dukkha refers to suffering and what is said here is that whatever suffering others are experiencing, we take upon ourselves and upon taking it upon ourselves, it actually destroys our own suffering. So, in this context, we are studying Lojong or mind training. What is meant by Lojong?
The core practice of Lojong is giving and taking or Tonglen. Generally speaking, we are afflicted by two main sources of problems, self-cherishing and the ignorance which apprehends itself as inherently existing. self-cherishing refers to that mind which wishes for us and us alone to be happy. It is that worst of all minds which wishes us and us alone to be peaceful, happy and contented And under its influence we have been revolving in samsaric existence for beginningless time. So this is the mind which we must eliminate, we must purify.
How do we do this? We do this through purifying it by other cherishing, which acts as the means whereby self-cherishing is destroyed. This is why in the Guru Puja, in the Lama Chöpa, self-cherishing is referred to as an epidemic. It is an epidemic because this is really the worst of all diseases, which destroys everything on its passage, and therefore it is the principal cause of all suffering. in dependence on it, all suffering arises.
So in our cases, what do we want? We want to be happy and we want to eliminate suffering or pain. To be happy we have to cultivate other cherishing. We experience suffering and pain under the impulse of self-cherishing. Now other cherishing and self-cherishing are directly antithetical, are antidotes.
self-cherishing like which is the target of other cherishing. It is what other cherishing is aimed at and what other cherishing destroys. Since we have been afflicted by self-cherishing since beginningless times, it is very powerful within our minds and it is difficult to destroy. It dwells within our minds in harmony with the ignorance which apprehends phenomena as inherently existing. So all of Lojong, all of mind training is nothing else but this training in other cherishing and abandonment of self-cherishing.
For this we start by training in the practice of giving and taking of Tonglen. Tonglen is a practice where we take upon ourselves the totality of the suffering of others and we use it as a bomb, as it were, to destroy the suffering within our own minds. And what is the self-cherishing we are talking about here? This cherishing is a, what is the other cherishing which we are talking about here? This other cherishing is a cherishing for all other sentient beings which are our mothers.
And if we reflect on the fact that all sentient beings are our mothers, then it is obvious that we must love and cherish our mothers. Since the kindness of our mothers is inconceivable, and that actually if we make our mothers happy, if we made in this life our mothers happy, all would be fine. So if we made all our mothers happy, the situation would be extraordinary. And this is why it is said in the Guru Puja that even if all sentient beings rose as my enemies, and I think which he comments this, seeing them as my mother, I will not harm them And even though they arise at my as my enemies, I will cherish them. So as Śāntideva says, whatever happiness there is within this world arises from others and whatever suffering there is in this world arises from cherishing one’s own self.
Śāntideva adds, I need not say much about this, merely observe the Buddha acted endlessly for the welfare of others and as a result have become enlightened. Ordinary beings focus only on their own welfare and as a result remain mired in suffering. As Śāntideva says, Rinpoche says, what need is there to add anything more? Just look. Check.
Then the people who don’t look in their sleep won’t understand anything. And then we will conclude with another verse on page 18, middle of page 18. When afflicted by fierce pangs of hunger and thirst, since it is from having swindled, stolen, plundered and from being tight fisted that the sword of evil karma has revolved back upon me. At present, may I take on all the pangs of hunger and thirst? In this verse, in this stanza, the first verse when afflicted by fierce pangs of hunger and thirst refers to the experience we are undergoing.
We all have experienced hunger and thirst to a degree. We know what it means not to have enough to eat, to feel the pangs of hunger, or not to have enough to drink and to have a dry mouth. Vasubandhu famously said, beings are afflicted by the disease of lack of food, when food is completely insufficient they die. This first verse, as we said, refers to the effect which is experienced. Ourselves, generally speaking, in a country such as this one, we are not fully aware of the extent of hunger and thirst.
There are in Australia people who suffer from extreme hunger and thirst, but in our case this is not really something that we understand. This effect was the first verse, which is experiencing the pangs of hunger and thirst, as an effect necessarily has a cause, it arises from causes and conditions, no effect arises spontaneously, it arises in dependence on a cause and the cause is given in the second verse. The cause is in past lives to have swindled, stolen, plundered and have having been tight fisted. Here the Tibetan verb used for swindled implies an element of violence to it, whereas the verb used for stolen implies using deceit and deviousness. Plundered implies a use of extreme violence, and being tight fisted refers to situations where we ourselves are well off, but we turn our heads away from the needs of others and refuse to help them.
In every single case, we accumulate thereby non virtuous karma. The effect of that non virtuous karma is referred to in verse three, it is the sword of evil karma which revolves back upon us, and that sword which revolves back upon us inflicts on us a result similar to the cause, which is that we experience hunger and thirst. Therefore, to eliminate this, we take the resolve in the fourth verse to engage in the practice of Tonglen, of giving and taking. May I take on at present all the pangs of hunger and thirst, and which he says this refers to taking on the hunger and thirst of others, which is thereby used to eliminate our own hunger and thirst, and therefore to eliminate both our own hunger and thirst and that of others. And therefore here, since both our experience of hunger and thirst and the experience of hunger and thirst of others arise actually from our own self-cherishing and from striving from our own happiness, which in turn gives rise to others experiences of being swindled, of being robbed, of being plundered for that matter, then we can see that this self-cherishing which we have for ourselves is the worst of all possible enemies, because not only is it the cause of our own hunger and thirst, it is also the cause of the hunger and thirst of others..
So Rinpoche says that the Bodhisattvas understand clearly that self-cherishing is the enemy since it is through self-cherishing that not only we ourselves are harmed, but others are harmed as well. And they understand clearly that others and cherishing others is the ultimate friend, since it is in dependence on others and on others alone that we can give rise to our own happiness and eliminate our own suffering. These are the deeds of a friend. In dependence on cherishing one’s own self, on self-cherishing, egotism, only suffering arises. Therefore this can truly be called an enemy.
And Rinpoche says, obviously, we are small, so we don’t understand really these things. And when he says that we ourselves are an enemy, we bump ourselves on the head and say, how can I be my enemy? But when we grow up, Rinpoche says, we’ll understand better. So if you have questions, Rinpoche will take one question tonight. Yes.
So, there are two categories of karma, there is shared and specific or unshared karma. Now in the case of, for instance, the victims of the floods in Queensland who experienced their deaths, if you want, at the hands of water, they shared that karma, they shared the karma of dying underwater. Likewise, in the case of the victims of the earthquakes in New Zealand or the earthquake in New Zealand, they share the karma, both human beings and non humans, we forget too frequently the non humans, they share the karma of dying during an earthquake under the rubble. What this shared karma actually originates from, we cannot know. It is too subtle for us to know.
Only the omniscient Buddha knows the specific karmic cause for each of these beings dying in the earthquake. For this reason, the Buddha is praised with the epithet I pay homage to the omniscient one. Omniscient because he is omniscient with respect to karma and causality. The Bodhisattvas on the path of seeing, the ārya beings, have direct cognition of emptiness, they see emptiness directly, yet they do not understand the subtleness of karma and causality. So this is as far as shared karma is concerned.
Likewise, all of us in this room share the karma of receiving teachings. And if we take the case of the earthquake for instance, we can see that we frequently have situations where we have two houses side by side, and, the families in both houses have the shared karma of experiencing the earthquake, but one of the houses is intact and none have died. In the other house, there are no survivors, all have died. So they did not share the karma of dying during the earthquake. One had the karma of dying, the other did not.
So Rinpoche says the subtleties of karma and causality are incomprehensible. Karma is extremely profound and subtle, Rinpoche says, and something very, very small, something tiny can give rise to huge effects, let alone something big in the future. So for this reason he would beg us to be careful of karma and causality. Otherwise he says all this talk about emptiness, bodhicitta, it is all talk. He said it’s a little bit like people who are walking on the road and they’re looking at this huge mountain in the distance they haven’t reached, and they fall in the pit because they were not looking at the road in front of them.
Okay. I I take care very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- preta
- Hungry ghost, or spirit. The preta realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.