1 h 31 min · 4,174 words · 11 March 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues the Mind Training teaching on its preliminaries: the preciousness of human rebirth, death and impermanence, and karma. It stresses the need for a personal conviction in past and future lives and karma before practice. It explains the three sufferings and four untrustworthy features of cyclic existence, then analyzes the origin and impermanence of the mental continuum. The talk closes with questions from the audience.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 32m
UUID: 1087d207-5ffb-4033-ba49-d65e9694810e
Date: 2012-03-11
Words: 4,170
So if we analyze the motivation in these terms we can see that the reason for which we have assembled today to receive these teachings is respectively the motivation of listening and explaining the teachings. Then the purpose is to listen and to explain the teachings. Now regarding the object in general for our topic today which is mind training like the rays of the sun, the object is full and utter enlightenment. More generally speaking in the context of the graduated stages of the path lam rim, the object is full enlightenment or liberation or at least the attainment of higher status in future lives. It is with this object of full enlightenment in the context of our text that we have assembled today.
Then from our standpoint to analyze whether a requisite motivation has been generated or not we must analyze our behavior in the light of the three factors Geshe la explained, the reasons for the motivation, the purpose and the object of this motivation. So it will be good then reflecting in these terms to meditate for two minutes or so. As is said in the root text which underlies mind training like the rays of the sun, Geshe Chekhawa’s text, first train in the preliminaries. What are the preliminaries for mind training in the context of the Mahāyāna? These preliminaries are the paths of the beings of small and middling scope.
Specifically, they are training in the realization of the preciousness and rarity of a human rebirth with the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments, the realization of death and impermanence, of the functioning of karma and causality and of the faults of cyclic existence. Generally speaking, the last of these realizations, the realization of the faults of cyclic existence should be subsumed within the practice of the being of middling scope. These are trained in as a preliminary for the great scope. Now the intended trainees of the graduated stages of the path, the disciples for whom these texts were composed were trainees of whom it was assumed that they believed in the existence of past and future lives and that they accepted karma and causality. The totality of the Lam Rim rests on this premise.
If however the trainees accept karma and causality and the existence of past and future lives only verbally which is probably the case for most of us then it is very difficult to practice the Lam Rim and it is very difficult for the realizations of the Lam Rim to take hold in the mind. For this reason, one should analyze oneself carefully and generate a strong conviction from one’s own side in the existence of past and future lives and the operativeness of karma and causality. And if one is ordained, one should do this relying on the treatises of reasoning and on pramāna, on valid cognizers. As said, all is rooted in terms of realization in the accumulation of virtue. Regarding in this context meditation on death and impermanence, meditation on death and impermanence should lead us to the realization that at the time of death there are only two paths, one path leading to the higher realms and to happiness and the other path leading to the lower realms and to unhappiness.
It is on the basis of this realization that we generate the wish to strive for happiness in future lives. However, such meditation on death and impermanence can only yield its fruits if we are convinced that past and future lives are linked by karma and causality. If we lack that conviction, these meditations on death and impermanence cannot yield their fruit.
In the case of the great Lambrem treatises, whether it is Tsongkhapa’s great treatise on the stages of the path, Lam Rim Chenmo, or Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the Palm of Your Hand, Nam Thar Lag Chang. All of these Lam Rim treatises were composed with Tibetans as their intended trainees. The audience was Tibetan. It was therefore it could be basically taken for granted that everyone in the audience believed in the existence of past and future lives and of karma and causality. In Tibet with the exception of a very small minority of practice practitioners of Bon, the ancient shamanism, perhaps all Tibetans were Buddhist.
Now it is not for this reason in Lam Rim Chenmo and in the Lam Rim treatises there are no special explanations regarding the existence of past and future lives. It is taken for granted. These explanations are provided in Dharmakīrti’s Pramāna Vartika in the second chapter thereof. So this presentation of karma and causality can be understood at its best in terms of Dharmakīrti’s Pramāna Vartika, the second chapter thereof but if one is unable to engage in these profound logical reasonings, nonetheless one gains a conviction of the existence of past and future lives in karma and causality in traditional Buddhist societies through one’s parents, one’s father and mother, through one’s relatives, through one’s siblings and friends. Now this belief in causality Geshe la is convinced is of tremendous benefit if it is practiced correctly for peace and harmony in our world.
So how do we engage in these analyses? Probably within the context of causes in general, the cause of every single cause necessarily has to be either a substantial cause or operative condition. There are no other sets of causes than these. So if we analyze taking ourselves as an example, Geshe la will in this context take himself as an example to try to understand where he comes from. The person we call Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen is a nominal designation on the basis of the composite of Geshe-la’s body and his mind.
Body and mind are effects therefore they have causes. They both must have substantial causes and cooperative conditions without which they could not mature. If we take Geshe la’s coarse body, his physical body, what is the substantial cause of Geshe la’s body? If we try to point it out, we can find it is actually the union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother at the time of Geschelas conception which gives rise to that first cell which is Geshe la’s the substantial cause of Geshe la’s body. Now regarding Geshe la’s mind, Geshe la’s mind also must have substantial causes in cooperative conditions.
If we eliminate the wrong perspectives on this and try to retain the good ones, then we can see that we must go back to earlier moments of Geshe la’s mind. So in our case as westerners, the very big problem is Geshe la thinks if we are asked bluntly, what do we think is our substantial cause not the substantial cause of our body but the substantial cause of us as persons chances are we will say our substantial cause is the union of the sperm, the spermatozoa of the father and the egg of the mother that first cell. So we must be very clear about this from the beginning. Such a view is completely wrong. The union of spermatozoa and ovum, in other words, the egg which is the first cell of our body is not the substantial cause of us as a person, but only the substantial cause of our body.
We ourselves are a composite of body and mind. If we try to posit a substantial cause of both body and mind, we face some difficulties. What we can do is posit substantial causes of the body on the one side and substantial causes of the mind on the other side. So Geshe la explained that the substantial cause of our physical body is that first cell following the instant of conception. Now regarding the mind, much depends on what one posits as an instance of the person.
In other words, that which transmigrates from life after life from a Buddhist standpoint. Bhāvaviveka posits as an instance of the person in keeping with his Svatāntrika Madhyamaka school mental consciousness which transmigrates from life to life. Geshe la himself has considerable sympathy for this view even though it is not the view of the Prāsaṇgika school which assert that the person is a mere nominal designation on the basis of the composite of the aggregates. The reason Geshe la has sympathy for this Svatāntrika Madhyamaka view is that it enables us very easily to demonstrate the existence of past and future lives. So returning to our question, what are the substantial causes of body and mind?
Regarding the mind, if we ask what the substantial cause of the mind is, it is that first instant of subtle consciousness which is present within the cell at the instant of conception. And therefore we ourselves are a composite of body and mind in other words of matter and consciousness. The substantial cause of the first instant of our body, the matter which composes us can be adequately posited as the union of the spermatozoa from the father and the ovum of the mother. Now regarding consciousness, we have said that it is that subtle instant of consciousness within the first instant of the egg which can be posited as our substantial cause of our mind. The question which arises then is what precisely is the substantial cause of this first instant of consciousness?
And here when we speak of substantial cause, the technical term refers to causality within a continuum, within the continuum of a phenomenon. So one might think that the substantial cause of the first instant of consciousness at conception are the minds of both our fathers and our mother. Now this is a view, Geshe-la, that I suspect nobody defends since it is a very coarse view which is open to widespread logical fallacy and repudiation. Should we think that our consciousness in this life is a result of the minds of our father and our mother, then the mind of our father and mother becomes substantial causes of the conscious the first instance of consciousness in this life and all three become one substantial continuum which means that we should be able to remember everything which our father and mother think which is obviously not the case. A second possible viewpoint is presented in Dharmakīrti’s Pramāna Vartika in the second chapter thereof in which the view of the Cārvākas, the materialists, the nihilists of ancient India is presented.
The Cārvākas or the Yang Dagpa in Tibetan assert that there is no substantial cause of the first instant of mind. In other words, they deny the existence of both a mental continuum and of karma and causality. Then if we analyze more carefully this process of conjunction of the first cell, the fertilized egg on the one hand and consciousness which has entered within that cell, it is clear that that first cell can act as a substantial cause for our coarse body and consciousness can act as a substantial cause for our consciousness in this life. However, it seems difficult to posit a connection between that first instant of consciousness and our coarse body without drawing on concepts which are not developed in the Pāramitāyāna, specifically the concept of a subtle energy, prana vayu, which is intimately connected with mind and which will be present with the subtle consciousness at the instant of conception and which actually facilitates the connection between the mind and the body. This viewpoint is not explained in the Pāramitāyāna and for ease of explanation we have to draw on Anuttara Yoga Tantra in this context.
Now let us therefore take that first instant of our person which is the conjunction of the egg with subtle consciousness. The question which arises at present is what is there before that first instant at the period of time immediately preceding that first instant? The period of time immediately preceding that first instant refers actually to the intermediate state of the previous life and to the previous rebirth. The previous rebirth starts for being such as us which are born from the womb from within the four types of rebirth which are being born from an egg, womb, from warmth and moisture and by emanation, birth from the womb. This starts at the instant when we leave our mother’s womb and that rebirth lasts until the point at which the impelling karma which has initiated that rebirth is exhausted and the causes of death take over.
And then in turn this life begins or the birth of this life begins at the instant when we leave the womb of the mother and it extends until the impelling karmic causes which have initiated this life are exhausted at which point our bodily aggregate dies and one actually enters into the intermediate state or the bardo leading to a future life. The self same lines reasoning which can demonstrate the existence of past lives can be used to demonstrate the existence of future lives. Therefore it is not the case that at death in this life our physical and mental continuum are severed or destroyed. Our mental continuum continues. And then in turn if there are future lives and if we reflect on the possibilities of these future lives it becomes evident to us that there are such a thing as higher and lower rebirths.
The question which then arises is whether such rebirths are caused or causeless. This calls for analysis. In keeping with the quotation from virtue all happiness and from non virtue all suffering, it seems evident that these future rebirths have causes and that the happiness in these rebirths is caused by virtue and the unhappiness is caused by non virtue. We then have to ask ourselves what precisely virtue and non virtue are. If we were to take the example of one of the 10 non virtues, for instance a non virtue of speech, harsh words or offensive words, then what are offensive words?
Offensive words are words which hurt another and which are pronounced without any care for the well-being of another person. This is a non virtuous deed. So when we pronounce these words, as a result down the line, we think we ourselves will experience suffering. Then reflecting upon this, we turn away from pronouncing these words. We counter this and this probably Geshe la thinks is none other than virtue.
It is very difficult to posit any other type of virtue than this. And then in turn it becomes obvious to us that one must engage in the practice of virtue and one must abandon sin. This practice of engaging in virtue and abandonment of sin is none other than Dharma. It is difficult to posit any other type of Dharma than this. Then the question which does arise is, is there such a thing as Dharma practice among non Buddhists?
The answer is evidently yes. There are numerous non Buddhists who engage in the practice of virtue and the abandonment of sin of non virtue and this therefore would qualify as Dharma. On the other hand, as Geshe-la mentioned a couple of weeks ago, can one speak of a realization of death and impermanence among non Buddhists referring in this case specifically to the Hindu schools? This is very difficult. There are a lot of debates about this.
Geshe la from his side suspects not and most of the great scholars of the three seats also feel that such a realization is not possible for non Buddhists. However these doubts are important and when such doubts arise they are very beneficial to us because as a result of the doubt we actually engage in greater study, our understanding deepens and our practice becomes faster. And therefore we can see certainly that non-Buddhist spiritual traditions have a very clear understanding of the preciousness of the human rebirth and the importance of taking the essence of such a rebirth. And in terms of practice, they have some components of the realization of death and impermanence, not all. The question which then arises, which is a difficult question, is how do we posit a difference between Buddhists and non Buddhists?
Generally speaking, within the monastic texts of the three seats, the yiktas, the difference between Buddhists and non Buddhists is posited in terms of refuge. This, however, is a delicate point and a difficult point since it is not obvious that non Buddhists have no refuge. On the other hand, His Holiness has over and again posited the difference between Buddhists and non Buddhists in terms of the view. This is His Holiness’ personal emphasis and one finds this also in texts on tenets from Gomang Monastery in which it is said that the difference between a Buddhist and non-Buddhist by view excuse me, the difference a Buddhist and non-Buddhist by tenets depends on the view. Then if we analyze really carefully, Geshe la feels we have to posit this difference in terms of the view and this leads us naturally to an analysis of the view, the views of the four schools of tenets ranging from the Vaibhāṣika at the bottom of the ladder all the way up to the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka.
The common view which is shared by all of the schools of tenets is that of a selflessness of persons which is an emptiness of a substantially existing autonomous self.
Therefore, we must put great effort in generating a conviction, a strong sense of the existence of past and future lives on the one hand and of the operativeness of karma and causality on the other hand. On this basis, we can practice. The question which arises is when we practice on this basis, are we Buddhists or non Buddhists? To be able to answer this question, we must be able to clearly the difference between being Buddhists and being non Buddhists. In the context of an acceptance of karma and causality on the one hand and past and future lives on the other hand.
This is a very difficult question. Proof of the fact is that Atisha himself said that at his period there were apart from him only one great scholar in India, Shantipa, probably, who could explain clearly the difference between Buddhism and non Buddhism. Now if we ourselves cannot do this, then when we say we are Buddhist, it is just words, empty words. There is no meaning behind it. We must be able to formulate a criterion, a measure for being a Buddhist.
A Geshe la from his side has put put much effort in his studies to be able to do this and what he would suggest to us is that we study the Lamrim carefully so that we can practice and try progressively to gain an understanding of what it means to be a Buddhist. And now returning to our core text, which is mind training like the rays of the sun. As you remember, in the root verses which underlie this by Geshe Chekawa. It is said initially trained in the preliminaries and Geshe la explained the preliminaries as the practices of the being of small and middling scope. The practice of the being of small scope was training in understanding the preciousness and rarity of a human rebirth with the leisures and endowments, meditating on death and impermanence and on causality.
Now these three topics are completed. The topic Meditating on the Faults of cyclic existence is part of training in the practice of the being of middling scope and when one meditates on the Faults of cyclic existence one meditates specifically on the sufferings of cyclic existence of which in general there are numerous presentations. The foremost one is of six sufferings, the one we will focus upon is of three sufferings. But in a nutshell, these three sufferings can be subsumed by saying that the cycle of life, cyclic existence, does not have one single quality whatsoever. Why is this the case?
There are four features of cyclic existence which are fundamentally untrustworthy or deceptive. First, our bodies are untrustworthy. We can see for ourselves that the body we have today we will have to leave behind when we die. This is the case for every single living being. The second feature of untrustworthiness is that harming and helping are unreliable.
We are unable to know whether help will be durable or not and whether harm will be durable or not. In both cases, the harmer of today may be the helper of tomorrow. The helper of today may be the harmer of tomorrow. The third factor which is unreliable is wealth and prosperity. Our wealth, our financial means, our money are extremely unstable.
He who is rich today is a pauper tomorrow and reciprocally. The fourth feature is that friends and acquaintances are unreliable. We can see for ourselves, we at present have parents, we have children, we have many friends, we have spiritual teachers, not one will remain. And since we can clearly see that the foremost means to be freed from cyclic existence is bodhicitta then we must generate within our mind stream this bodhicitta. So as is said in Geshe Chekawa’s root text initially trained in the preliminaries.
These preliminaries were explained as a practices of the being of small and middling scope. These have been completed with the presentation of the faults of cyclic existence. Geshe la will stop here and will start presenting the Mahāyāna path next time. So we have some fifteen minutes for your questions and doubts. You oh, yes.
Yes. Yes. Continue. Not at all. The mental continuum is definitely impermanent.
This is a consensus position of all of the schools of tenets from Vaibhāṣika to Prāsaṇgika. What Geshe la was presenting last week were doubts on this topic. Generally speaking spermatozoa of the father and the egg of the mother carry their own prana but that is not the one we are talking of here. When the mind conjoins with the egg at the instant of conception, that subtle mind itself is conjoined with prana and if we ask what the cause of that is, it is previous instances of mind conjoined with subtle energy. There is not a single instant when the subtle mind is not conjoined with subtle energy, in other words, with energy. So that’s exactly it.
The subtle mind and the subtle energy or wind are said to be of one nature but of different isolates. What this means is actually mind and energy are aspects of each other. They are totally blended with each other. As Geshe la explained previously, the mind is like a rider riding on a horse and without prana, without this energy, the mind is unable to enact to effect anything. This is this is tantric discourse basically absent in Pāramitāyāna.
So I don’t understand your question. Is it about the sameness of continuum or difference of continuum? Yes, there is nothing which is truly established, established as a self therefore the mind, the mental continuum as well is non truly established. So to understand this really well, one must explain the difference between being truly established or being established as a self and not being truly established or not being established as a self. Then we don’t have too much time to do that but this will be talked about after the presentation on bodhicitta.
Michel will go into a lot of detail in this. So what Geshe la did last time was to explain that since the mental continuum, we have to be careful with these things. Since the mental continuum is beginningless and endless, there is no beginning and no end, then the question which arises is how does it change instant by instant? It is impermanent. He raised a doubt, could it be permanent?
But it is impermanent. There’s no doubt about this in any Buddhist school of tenets. It changes instant by instant.
Yes. What is it? Mental continuum. So, Geshe la, I will not explain too much about this because it seems it’s creating confusion. But, basically, the mind is beginningless and endless.
The mind is never destroyed. Then the mind is an impermanent phenomenon which changes instant by instant. It is destroyed instant by instant. The question which arises is how can we understand this mode of impermanence of the mind in comparison to the mode of impermanence of a table? In the case of a table, it’s disintegrating instant by instant can be ascertained and the eventual destruction of the table can.
In the case of the mind, when we say the mind changes instant by instant, what do we mean? If we take for instance if we take the example Geshe la gave of the egg at the instant of conception and the subtle consciousness which is associated with these. These have causes. If they did not have causes, they would automatically be permanent. They do have causes.
Other question? Alright. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- chulen
- Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- Prasangika Madhyamaka u ma thäl gyur pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Consequence school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Consequence school accepts mere consequences known to others and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- thought transformation lojong (Tib)
- Also known as “mind training” or “mind transformation”. A powerful approach to the development of bodhicitta, in which the mind is trained to use all situations, both happy and unhappy, as a means to destroy self-cherishing and self-grasping. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.