1 h 23 min · 6,984 words · 1 May 2009 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 83-minute panel discussion held at Harvard Medical School, His Holiness the Dalai Lama speaks with leading neuroscientist Richard Davidson, psychologists Judith Jordan, George Vaillant, and Christopher Germer about the intersection of meditation practice, psychotherapy, and compassion cultivation. Davidson presents research showing that sustained mental training measurably changes brain activity, while the Dalai Lama explains how the mind, unlike the body, can sustain gains in mental qualities once achieved through repeated practice. The conversation addresses self-compassion and why people become self-critical precisely when suffering most; the role of understanding and intention in developing unbiased, genuine compassion; and the importance of balancing insight into impermanence with broader Buddhist perspectives like the Four Noble Truths to avoid despair. He distinguishes between biased compassion rooted in attachment and universal compassion grounded in reasoning, describes how to cultivate the latter through religious faith, the law of causality, or secular ethics, and emphasizes that meaningful mental transformation requires sustained, diverse practice rather than simple techniques. The discussion blends Buddhist psychology with contemporary Western therapeutic concerns, appropriate for healthcare practitioners and those interested in evidence-informed contemplative training.
File metadata (for organising)
File: and Psychotherapy Developing Wisdom and Compassion; 1 May 2009 (Morning) Vide….mp3
UUID: 35096864-8a2b-4b21-9c1a-d5e33457d338
Teacher: Ilia S. Durovic
Collection: Meditation
Date: 2009 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~6,979
# and Psychotherapy Developing Wisdom and Compassion; 1 May 2009 (Morning) Vide…
**Collection:** Audio Recordings — Meditation
**Duration:** 83.3 minutes
**Words:** 6,977
**Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
**Corrections applied:** 0
**Transcribed:** 2026-03-09 19:59
—
Your Holiness, you have reminded us to be kind whenever possible. You have also reminded us that it is always possible. Despite chaos and turmoil and exile, your life has been a beacon of fulfillment, serenity, and inspiration. In honor of your visit, we would like to present you with a commemorative plaque, and the text reads as follows. To His Holiness, the Dalai Lama, Tenzin Gyatso, for his pioneering and tireless efforts in cultivating compassion and wisdom in health care and medical science.
Your Holiness, on behalf of Harvard Medical School and the Cambridge Health Alliance and its Department of Psychiatry, we thank you for gracing this conference. May we all have peace in our hearts and the courage to live our values as Your Holiness has done. You are an example for us all. Thank you.
Your Holiness, I’d like to introduce to you the other panel members who are up here. You certainly know your interpreter, Dr. Thupten Jinpa, who is the principal English translator for the Dalai Lama and a leading Tibetan scholar. You’re also no stranger to Doctor Richard Davidson from the University of Wisconsin in Madison.
He’s a foremost scientist working on the neurobiology of compassion and empathy. Some of his seminal work involves research on the brain and how it relates to meditation. And Time Magazine has named Doctor Davidson as one of the world’s top 100 most influential people. I’d like to introduce you to Doctor Judith Jordan. She’s one of the founders of the Stone Center, the Jean Baker Miller Training Center at Wellesley College, which has been on the forefront of the study of the psychology of women. She studied the process of empathy and the role of culture in treatment. Her work has recently focused on the shift in psychology from a focus on the separate self to a psychology of relational well-being. To my right is Doctor George Vaillant. He’s a senior psychiatrist and professor at Harvard Medical School. His award-winning work has focused on the meaning of compassion through his research on adult development and on the recovery process from addiction and mental illness. His recent research is on successful aging and his most recent book is on spiritual evolution. And finally, I’d like to introduce to you my colleague, Doctor Christopher Germer. He’s on the faculty of Harvard Medical School at the Cambridge Health Alliance, and he’s a fellow course director of putting this together. And you have met him at Emory. He came to Dharamsala to invite you to come. He’s the author of a soon to be published book, The Mindful Path to Self-Compassion, and he teaches nationally about mindfulness and psychotherapy and self-compassion. So what we thought we would have here is a discussion between you and some of these people, and I was going to invite Doctor Davidson to begin.
Thank you, Your Holiness. It’s wonderful to be with you again on this occasion. As you know, Your Holiness, I’m a simple psychologist and neuroscientist. And I have been conducting research on the brain and emotion for many, many years. And since we have had the opportunity to interact when I first met you in 1992, we have been very vigorously pursuing research on the brain mechanisms that are associated with various kinds of meditation practice.
One of the important observations that has come out of this work on the impact of meditation on the brain is that practice makes a difference in terms of the enduring quality of changes that we see in the brain as well as in the body. To give just two examples of that, in our work with long-term meditation practitioners, we have observed that the longer—the greater the number of hours lifetime practice among our group of long-term practitioners—the greater the enhancement in a certain brain signal that we have found to be very prominent during compassion meditation. In this case, it’s gamma oscillations from particular parts of the brain. And there’s a very strong correlation between the number of hours of practice and the magnitude of change in this signal.
In work that we have done with novice practitioners, beginners who are instructed in Jon Kabat-Zinn’s mindfulness-based stress reduction, we have found that the more minutes of practice that the participants engage in when they’re learning, the greater the change in certain biological signals associated with health and with reductions in inflammation.
Now, since we are in New England in the Boston area, I was reflecting on this question of practice, and I came across a wonderful quote from Henry David Thoreau, who was a great American poet and contemplative who wrote Walden. And I would just like to—it’s very short—I would just like to read it. He said, “As a single footstep will not make a path on earth, a single thought will not make a pathway in the mind. To make a deep physical path, we walk again and again. To make a deep mental path, we must think over and over the kinds of thoughts we wish to dominate our lives.”
And so the question that I have for you, Your Holiness, and the issue about which I would very much like you to speak is the issue of practice and how it relates to psychotherapy, which is the topic of this meeting. In most Western countries today, many believe that physical exercise is good for their health, and they engage in regular physical exercise several times a week. The traditional way of practicing psychotherapy is that a client will go to a therapist typically once per week for a relatively short period of time. And the work from our own lab and the quote from Thoreau suggests that to make changes in the mind takes more enduring practice. And so I wonder if you could comment. So I wonder if you can just give us some suggestions for how we can better incorporate this element into Western ways of addressing therapy and how the issue of practice is relevant?
That’s a difficult question for me. I think first, let me say that as far as the psychotherapist’s work—my knowledge about that is almost zero. So it’s difficult to say. But one thing, of course, I think physical action usually—we call physical action as well as mental action. Both are a kind of familiarization. The more you repeat, it goes stronger and stronger.
And then between physical action and mental action, physical action is based on the physical body, so there is limitation. Even if you get used to something for a long period, there is a limit. Whereas when mental action is concerned, and the physical action—I think there are two factors. One, the basis of that action is physical, somewhat rather rough. There’s limitation.
Then also, by nature, the physical action—if you do not carry that exercise for a certain period, then next time you need a new effort. Now when mental action is concerned, firstly, its basis is mind itself, not solid. And also, that basis—I mean, mind itself as a basis—is continuous. Of course, the physical also at the particle level has continuation right from the beginning. I don’t know. But the subtle level, the particle level, is continuously changing, changing, changing like that. Although from the perspective of a very subtle level of matter, there is, like in the domain of mind, a continuum—but at a grosser level, a kind of macroscopic level, the body has certain limitations it imposes.
Now mind—here, as you know, it is important to make distinction. The sensory level, or a certain mind which is based on sensory organs—that’s very much a physical thing. Then we call the mental level. Mental level is not based on the physical, but based on the continuity of previous mind. So that is, firstly, more subtle, almost like simply subtle energy. And then secondly, it continues.
Then by nature, a certain mental quality—through training, once you achieve a certain level, then even after a certain duration without familiarizing that—if you achieve a certain level, then no need for new effort. As soon as you remember it, it’s completely there. So then, basically, in the Buddhist tradition, there is an understanding that the more you cultivate familiarity with a certain way of thinking or certain way of being, the more effortless and natural and habitual it becomes. And that is the way the mind works.
Then within the mental domain, basically, two categories. One can identify two main categories. One type of engagement with the object that is more cognitively oriented and can lead to greater sense of ascertainment and understanding. So these are in the Buddhist tradition understood as more cognitive states of mind. When we talk about wisdom versus other factors, it’s the wisdom that belongs to that category.
Another category of mental engagement belongs more to the class of what the Buddhist tradition identifies as more in the form of wish, aspiration, interest, and so on. So these types of mental states do not lead to greater ascertainment or cognition. Therefore, they are recognized to be not cognitively oriented. Of course, they do belong to cognitive events—they are all part of the mental domain. So if you compare between these two primary types of mental engagement, those that belong to the more aspirational, the wish element and interest—although in themselves, they do not engage specifically with the object in the cognitive manner, but when you cultivate them, you do require the aspects of intelligence, aspects of understanding to ground them and to enhance them.
So with relation to those categories of mental engagement that tend to be more cognitively oriented, in Buddhist language we call belonging to the wisdom dimension. There, the way to cultivate greater familiarity is to deepen one’s understanding of the object, whatever it is that this mind is relating to. And the greater your understanding of that object, then the greater the familiarity becomes. But also sometimes the subjective element of that wisdom also naturally increases as you come to understand whatever it is relating to in a deeper way. So, therefore, we speak of cultivating familiarity with the object of our understanding and cultivating the experience of the wisdom, the arising of the wisdom in us, in our mind itself.
So even from this subjective perspective, when we are talking about cultivating a certain kind of understanding like wisdom, it is only in relation to an understanding of something that we can increase that wisdom or understanding. So in both of these cases, the role of what the Buddhist tradition calls the faculty of mindfulness and application of that plays a very crucial role. So since both of these engagements involve maintaining certain degree of focus upon a chosen object of one’s practice, there are two ways in which this is done.
One is by applying the faculty of mindfulness so that the practitioner learns to guard himself or herself from wavering away from the chosen object of meditation. So that’s one process. The other approach involves not so much deliberately applying the mindfulness. Of course, there needs to be a presence of mindfulness. But then besides that, the focus is to really somehow deal with the energy of that mental state because the understanding is that every mental—here, energy means certain physical particles, but very subtle, formless, almost formless, I think.
So the idea is that a mental process is going on. And the mental processes are accompanied by a process of energy activation. A very subtle, but although it’s understood to be physical, but in a very subtle sense. So the second type of practice involves somehow finding a way of reducing the fluctuating energy fluctuation in the subtle process of energy. And that way, the mind is able to stay focused on the chosen object.
So then, in the Buddhist text, there’s this relation—this is Vajrayāna. In Vajrayāna text, this relationship between the cognitive process, the mental process, and the energy that accompanies it is compared to this analogy of a blind person who has feet and legs and can move but cannot see. And another person who can see but is crippled. Cannot move but can see. So these must combine, go together. So now here, at that level, physical exercise and breathing control are related. So these are how the system works.
Your Holiness, I wonder if you’d permit me to ask Doctor Germer to introduce himself and ask you a question.
Thank you. Yes. Your Holiness, my question is about compassion and particularly about self-compassion. Self-compassion. Yes. I’m a psychotherapist in full-time private practice, and I’ve been interested for about twenty years in the application of mindfulness in psychotherapy. And mindfulness has within it the qualities of acceptance and compassion. But it seems to me that the more we suffer, the more we need to intentionally bring kindness and compassion into the picture, into mindfulness. In other words, awareness is often just not enough. And we, in particular, need to bring compassion to ourselves.
As a therapist, and I know that most of the people in the audience—we have a lot of patients who have been suffering for a long time with intense emotional pain from depression, anxiety, childhood abuse, or they might be going through crisis in their lives right now such as the breakup of a marriage or the death of a loved one or serious illness. But what I’ve noticed is a strange phenomenon. That is precisely at the time when we need to be kind to ourselves, when things go really wrong, we become our own worst enemy. People tend, at least in this culture, when things get really bad, to criticize themselves, to hide from others in shame, and get kind of absorbed in rumination about themselves and their problems. And so I’m wondering, Your Holiness, have you noticed that? And if so, what would you say to such a person or recommend?
This has come up on many occasions. This topic came up, the need for self-compassion. Actually, in order to develop genuine sense of concern for others’ well-being, firstly concern for one’s own well-being must be there. So if someone is hating oneself, such a person, I think, will find it very difficult to develop genuine sense of concern for others. But then here, I have the view that the very reason why you develop some kind of self-hatred—in deep insight, you want perfection, and you fail at that. So there’s some kind of judgment and then hatred based upon that.
So His Holiness was saying that in his understanding, the mechanism that we see here is that although on the conscious level, the mental state is that of a criticism and hatred towards oneself, but underlying that, there must be some kind of expectation of something good for you, some kind of ideal for perfection. And when you see yourself failing, then you are being overly critical and hateful towards yourself.
Follow-up. Your Holiness, it does seem in light of what you had said before and what Richie was talking about, that there needs to be a certain level of practice, of repetition, mental repetition in order to overcome the habits of criticizing oneself if we don’t live up to our own expectations. I’m wondering, Your Holiness, if you could potentially lead us in a brief meditation that the therapists in this room could practice at home to cultivate compassion for themselves as well as for their patients.
Now the mental attitude, I think, is like—even with external matters we usually call inanimate objects, inanimate material objects. Compared with our body, perhaps they are less sophisticated. But even then, if it is survival or healthy growing, there’s not one element, not one factor, but a lot of factors. And at a particular level, many things go together in a more balanced way, then it grows well and remains well. So similarly, our mind—there are so many elements. Body element is also involved, and then mind itself has so many elements.
So now here, if the basic mental attitude is healthy, then some tragic situation here and there may not disturb much. Like the immune system. If the immune system is strong, then some virus comes and may not disturb much. But if your basic immune system is weak, then even a tiny virus immediately disturbs your health. Similarly, the mind is also like that. If the basic mental state is weak, then some small tragedy really brings upset. So now the real question is how to build a basic healthy state of mind.
Now I think some of you may want just one single meditation and a simple one with 100% positive result. I think impossible. There are a lot of different whole attitudes—outlook towards oneself, towards suffering, towards even the whole world. Many things are involved. So I think as far as Buddhism is concerned, because of that, in order to transform our destructive emotion—one goal, but the meditation—so many thousands of different meditations are mentioned because our mind is so complex. So just a single one meditation, I think difficult.
Now here, on the basis of my own experience, I can say, one type of meditation, its effect is limited. So combined—now for example, meditate on impermanence. I may tell one story. The other day also I mentioned, there was a good scholar, a monk, a great scholar, and many students. I think in daily teaching, he would teach at least six, eight hours. Very good scholar and quite well known. So one day a few years ago, he came to see me, and as soon as he entered my room, my office, his face was very sad. Then I asked, “What is wrong?” Then he mentioned some kind of depression or something. He was suffering from some form of depression. And I asked, “What was the cause?” Then he mentioned that sometime back, he meditated on impermanence. So that meditation brought that miserable experience.
So then I told him, now the meditation on impermanence—not just mere impermanence, but you see the other side, some positive side. If you have clear conviction or feeling of the positiveness, then impermanence reminds you—that’s a wonderful opportunity or wonderful potential not to be wasted. So that kind of meditation—you see there are many elements, many viewpoints, many aspects.
So His Holiness reminded him that even though meditating on a single object of meditation like impermanence, you need to bring in many other dimensions as well. For example, in the Buddhist text, we speak of impermanence, the nature of suffering or dissatisfaction, no self, emptiness, and so on. Now I think of that, for example, the Four Noble Truths—not only just the first two truths, something about the nature of suffering, but the later two truths are for joyfulness. So it’s more balanced now. Seeing the possibility to achieve permanent joyfulness, and develop conviction in that, then you feel, yes. Now certain biological factors—attachment, anger—these come, but these are obstacles to achieve that wonderful goal. Then you develop enthusiasm to tackle these things.
And here, in order to reduce the intensity of attachment or self-grasping, the meditation on impermanence. So now here, you see many things are involved, isn’t it? Something like in order to build the immune system, a healthy immune system, you need variety of outlook or concept. Then that eventually develops a very healthy state of mind. Then if some problems come from this side, then you can take one particular countermeasure like that.
So if I—I think even myself, I have no complete ability. Even myself, let’s say now, I think more than sixty years I put some effort or practice, but still not adequate. So therefore, just a few explanations or simple way to transformation of your mind is impossible. There are some other companies, they always advertise—it’s just some simple thing or something very effective, something very cheap. My advertising is just the opposite. Difficult and complicated.
But one thing I can tell you, I can assure you, that no matter our disturbances in our mind, we can handle them gradually. And a person whose mental state at this moment is difficult, but through training without losing hope and self-confidence and willpower, you can overcome these difficulties. That’s quite sure.
One master stated that even though a particular endeavor, a meditation practice may seem impossible at this point, but since the nature of conditioned phenomena is such that they are susceptible to change, so what may seem impossible to achieve in a hundred years may turn out to be actually something that becomes achievable and quite easy later on. That is my own experience.
This is some idea, some practice. My age, say, in my thirties—then at that time, although this is not right to mention one’s own experience, but I think in order to give you some encouragement, perhaps there is some reason to mention. After I came—of course, although I started practice with keen interest about bodhicitta, now more than sixty years. My age around 13, 14, 15, I developed some interest. Before that, as I mentioned yesterday, no interest. When my lesson time came, I felt something like, you know, the whole world became dark like that. The next day, holiday, then I feel—now today, tomorrow—I always think tomorrow, no lesson. Holiday. So then I feel, oh, sunny. Something like sunshine like that.
So then I came to India as a refugee, and I began to restudy those important texts. At my age 24, I came out. Then in my thirties, some experience—some feeling of the absence of independent existence, shunyata. That really developed, that really brought conviction. Oh, there is possibility of cessation of suffering because all suffering comes out of ignorance. So mainly here, ignorance in relation to understanding the nature of reality, the ultimate nature of reality.
So some feeling, some sense of the ultimate reality, then that brings immense conviction about that kind of ignorance. So then at that time, about infinite altruism, I felt very far. Of course, admiration was there, but felt difficult, very far. Then by the age of the forties, the more I meditated, eventually, it became something quite close, familiar—something intimate.
So this is exactly what the master was saying, that something that may seem impossible can become very close to you. So that is the positive side.
Thank you. Your Holiness, may I invite Doctor Jordan to speak with you?
I am deeply honored to be here today with you, Your Holiness. I’m a therapist, and I am particularly interested in the centrality of connection and empathy in people’s lives and also interested in the ways in which certain cultures pose challenges to that sense of connection. Traditional Western cultures and, I think, psychology actually posit that healthy human development is about getting more and more autonomy, separateness, a kind of stand on your own two feet mentality. And Einstein actually once referred to the delusion of separateness that exists in Western cultures.
The field of neuroscience and a lot of Doctor Davidson’s work is confirming actually that we are hardwired in the brain to connect with others and also that there is enormous brain plasticity, that we can alter in our lives. And a lot of that can be altered through our relationships and connections with others. I actually find profound hope and comfort in these discoveries. But we also know that social exclusion and isolation goes to the same center of the brain, the pain center in the brain, that physical pain goes to. So social exclusion and isolation is real pain, and there is real suffering throughout the world created by this isolation.
And I think in therapy, a piece of what we do is try to reestablish—yes, we have data now that suggests we need to participate in relationships, not to get or to give, but actually participate in building relationships and mutual engagement and mutual empathy with others and that this actually creates a deep sense of well-being. It doesn’t have to be compassion for self versus compassion for others. They are together. I think you once said that if you want to make others happy, practice compassion. If you want to be happy, practice compassion. They’re together.
So the dilemma that I see and I would like you to address is that our biology and neurobiology, our very being calls out for connection. While many of our Western cultures, in particular, urge us to build ever more bounded, competitive, me-first selves. So I am wondering, given this climate in Western cultures, where we’re so committed to building this separation, whether you think we face particular challenges in practicing and developing and supporting compassion both at an individual and a collective level. I don’t think we have a responsibility to enhance the compassion of the collective, not just the individual.
I don’t think there are big differences. I think, firstly, some people usually make distinction between West and East and feel some big differences. I do not think that. Just the lifestyle, these things, there are differences. But at the mental level, I don’t think there’s much difference. Even sometimes there’s discussion with some people. The Buddha’s teaching came more than two thousand six hundred years ago. So that ancient teaching, whether suitable now in the twenty-first century or not. Then I have the view—lifestyle must change from the time of Buddha to today. And similarly, Eastern, Western, Southern, Northern, there are differences. Obviously, in fact, I think modernity is essentially much concerned with external matters, material matters.
So at the physical level, I think as you mentioned, the same. And then emotional level, same. Mental level, also same. Then within the mind or within the emotion, destructive emotion, constructive emotion, neutral emotion. When we say neutral emotion—you say neutral? Yeah. Neutral. Yes. I thought emotion means some strong feeling. So then either positive or negative or destructive or constructive. No neutral. Emotions exist. That is. Yeah. Alright.
Anyway, at the mental level, I don’t think there is any demarcation between Eastern and Western. I don’t think. And also today’s humanity and two thousand years ago’s humanity—mental state, I can say the same. Then in the future, perhaps after a hundred thousand years or a few hundred thousand years, when the brain shape changes, then maybe emotional level, some change may happen. So the brain specialists, they can predict. The apes—how many millions of years passed from the ape, the big change of brain over millions, over millions. So that means in the future, after millions, then maybe the shape of our brain may change. So then some emotion may change. I don’t know.
Now here, this social habit, I think even within the West, I think people in big city and people in countryside, I feel some differences. I found in India, people in big city and people in rural area, there are differences among Tibetan also. So that means the environment—the influence of environment. And then also, Tibetans in the early period. Tibetan refugees in the sixties and seventies, hardly any crime. Very peaceful. And cheating money, cheating—this kind of thing, never or no significance. Then gradually, Indian neighbors sometimes found—oh, new generation of Tibetan and Tibetans who came from inside Tibet, sometimes they found little differences. So these are—I mean, same Tibetan, basically same Buddhist, but the environment made differences.
And also in our settlement, people talk more about money, money, money, money. So that also has changed the mental state. More restless. More anxious, more stress. So I always feel the poorer section of people, these destructive emotions may be comparatively less. In the upper class—more influential, then maybe jealousy. I think ordinary poor people, there’s hardly much feeling of jealousy among themselves. And also, I think a very good sense of community.
Including some scientists. I really love this scientist. This scientist is very good. Wonderful person. So since he’s a very close friend, so sometimes I am bold enough to tease. So there’s some name. My own practice is—even when more people are praising me, then I always constantly remind myself. One great practitioner in Tibet, I think a thousand years ago, he mentioned—he expressed—when you become an object of reverence, you must feel yourself the lowest person. That’s very important. Otherwise, you become arrogant. You become too much self-centered. Then even without notice, all these destructive emotions become very active. So finally, self-destruction.
So therefore, the more successful you become, the more vulnerable you become to develop this destructive emotion like that. So my answer—basically, not much difference.
The other day, I mentioned some of my American friends. Some of the result out of their practice is quite remarkable. Such an experience, quite rare among Tibetan. The level of realization is effort. So we Tibetan should feel envy or jealousy. So materially, you’re more advanced. Now, spiritually, also, it seems you’re more. So the point is, basically, we are the same.
Thank you. Your Holiness, if you permit me to ask Doctor Vaillant to speak with you.
Your Holiness, like Doctor Jordan, I was enormously impressed by the wisdom of your advice. If you want happiness, practice compassion. If you want to bring happiness to others, practice compassion. But my dilemma is really in which of these should we focus on, how do we integrate them in the profession of psychiatry? The negative emotions are what we’re all taught to deal with—grief, sadness, emotional hunger, lust. And these emotions are all about me, and we try to teach our patients how to have compassion for themselves.
In contrast, the world’s great religions are uniform in paying attention to the positive emotions, love and compassion. And, of course, the negative emotions are all about time present and all about me. The positive emotions are all about the future and all about the other. In my daily work, my job is to pay attention to the negative emotions of my patients. In my writing, I find I’m much more interested not in writing self-help books, but in trying to help people see both. This is help.
Love and compassion are rather different in that if we were run over by a truck, we would not want our mother, who loves us dearly, to come by because in her attachment, she would be unable to be fully empathic to our pain. We would much rather have the detached paramedic come by who could empathically allow us to be seen. Psychotherapists focusing on negative emotions tend to scorn the religious who focus on positive emotions. My dilemma is—in the future, should we train our psychotherapists to pay more attention to the positive emotions of the world’s great religions, or should we try to educate the world’s great religions to pay more attention to negative emotions?
I always make distinction within compassion, two levels. One level of compassion, I think, we usually use the experience or usually we get this understanding—the meaning of compassion is the first level. That compassion—you’ve already heard many times. So please don’t bother. Otherwise, you sit here. Always love to hear it again. Even yesterday, also, I mentioned this distinction. Almost whenever in my public talk about the importance of compassion, I always make distinction in these things.
So at that level of compassion, very much oriented—action or attitude. That compassion is also very much mixed with attachment. Towards one’s own friend—because their attitude, their action to you is positive, helpful, so you develop a sense of closeness, feeling. And with that, a sense of concern for their well-being. That is biased—only your loved ones. That kind of love, compassion, very much goes with hatred. Those other groups of people, so-called enemy, whose action is negative to you, then hatred, anger. Even your own loved one—so long their attitude is nice, compassion. Then some slight change, hatred. So that kind of compassion is biased, basically biological factor. It’s spontaneous without training. It’s there.
But then second level of compassion. Now using reasons, training, the second level—a genuine sense of concern for the well-being of others regardless of their attitude towards you. Now oriented to the person or sentient being or person just like myself. So now, for example, to oneself, sense of concern—not developed on the basis that I myself am very kind to me. No. Just one—I have the feeling of pains and pleasure. And by nature, I have the desire to achieve happiness, joyfulness, and do not want suffering. So that’s just the basis of my right to achieve joyfulness, to overcome suffering.
Now this reason exactly can apply to others regardless of their attitude towards you, but they are sentient beings or human beings, particularly human beings. They also have the same experience, pains and pleasure, and on that basis, same right to overcome pain. So using reason, develop a sense of concern. Now that is unbiased. That kind of sense of concern can extend towards your enemy. As far as the attitude is concerned, they are enemy. So you have to make preparation to fight, a good fight. But as long as they are human being or sentient being, they also deserve our sense of concern. Clear. Now this is not mixed with attachment.
So actually, that higher level of compassion—in order to develop that higher level of compassion, it is based on detachment. Attachment makes it biased. So detachment. Then on a new basis, develop a sense of concern. Now that’s genuine compassion. That kind of compassion only through training, through reasoning.
So now here, that kind of compassion, how to develop that kind of compassion. I usually tell people three ways. Number one, according to theistic religion. Theistic religion, that means religion with the concept of God, Creator. God, Creator, I should say, has infinite love, compassion. So the more admiration, more faith towards that Creator, there is more willingness to follow his example like that. So we can find very, very compassionate people among Christians and Islam and so on. You can find there are people—such wonderful people. That’s one way.
The second way is nontheistic. That’s like Buddhism. And also one ancient Indian, I usually call Shramana religion. That’s Buddhism and Jainism. No idea of Creator, but according to their concept is law of causality, cause-effect, cause-effect, and very much similar to Darwin’s evolution theory. Cause-effect, and effect is causing another effect, another effect—go like that way. Some change, now our brain changed, not overnight, but gradually changed. This flower—when I was young, there was some flower. I loved that flower. Very, very good one. So making cuttings, transplanting—like rose. Cut and put in soil and grow. So because of too much impatience—so today, I planted. Then after two days, pick up whether root is coming or not. So that’s unrealistic expectation. It takes its own time. Takes weeks and months like that. So the law of causality—gradually changing, changing, changing like that. But significant—because of that, obvious change must take place, the momentary change. On the basis of momentary change. So therefore, that’s one way to develop compassion. I’m not going into detail.
Then now the question is, we must take care. We must look seriously about the well-being of six billion human beings. It is unfair to think only about concern for religious believers. The other nonbelievers, nonreligious people, they’re also human being. They’re also part of our community. And I think, in fact, maybe the majority. So therefore, now we must find ways and means to reach the message of compassion to these people. Now if we carry the message of compassion on the basis of religious belief, then we cannot reach these people. So there must be a third one. Usually, I call the secular way to promote these values. And actually, the compassion itself, as I mentioned earlier, is from biological factor, so that’s not come through religion but by nature. So basically, the compassion is universal value, not religious, not value which is based on religious faith. So the compassion itself is universal value, secular value. So through secular way to promote that.
So now to your patient, I think you have to judge the patient. The patient is a religious believer, then use religious method. Nonbeliever, then use secular method. Same message, message of love, compassion.
Thank you, Your Holiness. We need to change the group here. So I’m sorry to interrupt, but thank you so much.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Some people judge or even hate themselves harshly. How should we understand this, and what would you say to such a person?
Self-compassion is needed because genuine concern for the well-being of others depends first on concern for one's own well-being. Someone who hates themselves will find it very difficult to develop genuine concern for others. Self-hatred arises from a deeper expectation: underneath the conscious criticism and hatred there is an expectation of something good for oneself, an ideal of perfection. When one sees oneself failing to reach that ideal, one judges oneself, becomes overly critical, and turns anger and hatred against oneself.