1 h 36 min · 4,815 words · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen unpacks the temporal structure of dependent origination in this 97-minute teaching, focusing on how the twelve limbs unfold across multiple lives. He begins with a core question: what is the minimum number of lives required to complete one cycle? Drawing on the Golden Rosary of Eloquence, he establishes that two lives suffice, though three are possible—the first three limbs (ignorance, compositional factors, consciousness) plant karmic seeds in one life, while craving, appropriation, and existence ripen at life’s end, triggering rebirth in the next. Geshe-la then anchors his students in their own position: right now, in this very life, they are simultaneously experiencing the twelfth limb of a past cycle while accumulating the initial causes of future cycles. He addresses persistent questions on karma storage, the role of virtuous mind at death, the Bardo being’s status among the twelve limbs, and how to understand rebirths for Aryas and Bodhisattvas. Throughout, he uses the metaphor of planting seeds in spring to clarify how causes lie dormant until ripening conditions arrive. Suited to practitioners with some familiarity with Buddhist philosophy and dependent origination.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 12 Limbs D2PM – KR.mp3
UUID: 0d0b31ca-2da3-4ece-bbb5-e41a8dd6189b
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Death and Rebirth
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~4,812
What? So regarding the period of time required to complete one cycle of the 12 limbs, Golden Rosary of Eloquence states that at the minimum, it takes two separate lives and at the maximum, three separate lives. How was your lunch? Regarding completing the 12 limbs in three lives, the first three limbs, in other words, ignorance, compositional factor, and consciousness must occur within the first life. Then the eighth, ninth, and tenth limbs, in other words, the manifestly establishing limbs must necessarily occur all within one life.
Craving cannot occur within one life, appropriation in within another, and existence within a third. They must occur within the same life. And the six results, in other words, the fourth, fifth, sixth, and seventh limb, as well as the eleventh and the twelfth limb must all occur within one single life. Do you have any doubts about this? Is that clear?
Alright. Do you understand? Do you have any doubts about this? This is where doubts should arise. Yeah, you can ask.
Is it Is the one life long enough for all these 12 limbs to occur in the one life? No. That’s completely impossible. The 12 limbs never occur within one life. What happens is that at present for instance, we are in the in the period of the limb of aging and death.
That is what we are in right now. Transmigrator saṃsāra. saṃsāra being, So we are saṃsāra being, you know, all. So we’re all samsaric beings, transmigrators. Within the way the 12 limbs, where do we stand right now?
Which of them are we in right now? Twelfth. You. Thank you. Yep.
That’s you know clean, you know, you can use it. Secondhand cup of tea. We said at one time yesterday that in exceptional circumstances such as in the case of where there’s extraordinarily powerful impelling karma, parricide, matricide, killing one’s teacher were examples where Okay, keep going. Where the results could be Don’t. Could mature in the one lifetime.
That was positive. No. You cannot have an impelling karma of that nature which matures within one life. It’s not possible. If you kill you, heaven forbid, you kill your parents when you were young, then that can only mature in a future life, as in a future life.
So the other doubt you might have is we are accumulating powerful virtuous karma during these two days. Then what is this connected to? This is connected to a limb, a group of the 12 links, which will mature in a future life. So therefore, the 12 limbs can mature at the minimum in two lives and at the maximum in three separate lives. Now if they mature in two lives, we will have for instance accumulated during these teachings powerful roots of virtue.
Those are the three first impelling limbs. In other words, the limbs of ignorance compositional factors and consciousness. And at the end of this life, if a powerful virtuous state of mind arises within our mind stream at the time of death, That causes the maturation of the three manifestly Actualizing. Actualizing. The three established the three manifestly actualizing limbs, which are the limbs of craving appropriation and existence.
And they will give rise to an actualizing karma, which will impel the next life for instance, the human being. So am I telling the are you starting to get it? Do you understand? What I’m not sure about is we have the first three limbs in one life. But in that life, are we are we experiencing end of another cycle of the other limbs being the four, fifth, sixth, seventh, and tenth, and eleventh.
That’s precisely it. In other words, in this life right now, we are accumulating the first three limbs of one cycle of dependent origination. But this life itself is the twelfth limb of another cycle of dependent origination, another cycle. So generally speaking, the presentation of the 12 limbs beginning with ignorance, compositional factors, consciousness, name and form, the six sources and so forth is a general presentation. But when they unfold, they unfold in the sequence of the first three followed by craving appropriation and existence, followed by the remaining six.
So how does it look for you within the 12 limbs? Are you comfortable with the presentation? So is each act of that impels each and every impelling set of three going to set the wheel in motion. So effectively every act of karmic consequence that I perform will in turn have lead to eight, nine and ten and then again. So it’s it’s a whole series of interlock interlocking 12 limbs.
That’s exactly it. So each impelling karma is part of one cycle of the 12 limbs and they are interconnected, right? Yes, Geshe-la, just a couple of clarifications. I did hear this morning that the 12 limbs can only be completed in two, three or countless lives. So I’m hearing now that the countless should be crossed out.
Good. Thank you. So he did say that. He’s gonna have to explain it. And my second question Okay, okay, that’s okay.
So when one speaks of the 12 links maturing over countless lives, this refers to a situation in which the three first impelling limbs. In other words, ignorance, compositional factors and consciousness have been accumulated. But at the time, let’s say of death, no virtuous thought is present. And as a result, they cannot mature. And let us say one is reborn in the lower realms, life after life after life after life after life, and these three initial limbs are continually suppressed.
They never have matured. So until they mature, it is referred to as a countless cycle of 12 limbs. It’s referred to a cycle of 12 limbs over countless lives. Because the impelling limbs and the result limbs are separated in this What do you plant? Would you plant?
Bali or wheat in Australia? Wheat? You have barley? You have? It’s the Eyre Peninsula.
They grow a lot of barley and that’s why we get a lot of hay fever in Adelaide. Okay. That’s okay. So it’s the example of a field will make this very simple. If we have a grain of wheat, then that grain of wheat is a substantial cause of other grains of wheat.
It has all that is required for those grains of wheat to arise. But if we put it in the ground, it needs cooperative conditions such as water, manure, and so forth to give rise to a sheaf of wheat. Otherwise, this is not gonna happen. My second one. My second one was just really clarification that those two or three lives that the 12 limbs are completed in are not necessarily consecutive lives.
No, not at all. There is no certainty that if you accumulate the causal limbs during one life, the resulting limbs will be present in the immediately succeeding life. So this is the meaning of the statement that there are countless or there can be countless lives between the impelling and the resulting limbs. The divisions of the 12 limbs in terms of the noble truth of origin and of suffering, the third limb, the limb of consciousness falls within the division of the noble truth of suffering, yet it’s one of the causal limbs. So it seems to me to be both the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering.
Could Geshe-la clarify that for me please? So within the 12 limbs, the limb of consciousness is an establishing limb and both the impelling and the establishing limbs are included within the noble truth of the origin of suffering. The remaining six limbs are included within the noble truth of suffering. What did I say? That puts consciousness in the limb of suffering.
Then that may be a mistake. Okay. I Don’t worry. I think it’s not not necessary, you know. Okay.
I’m getting a sense now that I’m living like two lives. Like, this life is to me now that I’m living a past life and and now the life I’m my past life that I’m but anything that I’m creating in this life is gonna be for the future life. So, yeah, I’m getting a real sense that it’s different than I perceived it before. Yes, that is more than appropriate. In this life, we are experiencing what we accumulated in previous lives and we are accumulating causes for future happiness, future enjoyment.
It just seems very clear after this weekend’s teaching. So thank you, Geshe-la. Yeah. Yeah. So we are effectively creating a new cycle every life?
In this life alone, we have accumulated countless impelling karmas. In this life alone, we have accumulated countless impelling karmas. So in this life, we are living within the twelfth limb of another cycle of the 12 limbs. But we have accumulated countless impelling karmas in this life which will give rise to countless cycles of the 12 limbs. Alright.
If we are acquiring the karma now that would be manifesting in future lives, is all the karma that we’re acquiring now staying in that same continuum, it’s not being stored in another consciousness while this one is otherwise engaged? I don’t understand your question. Where is the karma that we’re not using being stored? Somewhere on our continuum? I like, you know, your question.
I. Mind. Mind. So it’s a very good question. The what is called the base of infusion of karma is the mind or according to Cittamātra, it is the mind basis of all.
According to Prāsaṇgika, it’s a mere I. Yeah. So it’s a very good question. There is no specific explanation of what the location, recipient of, or container of karmic imprints is according to Prāsaṇgika. But the third limb consciousness within a cycle of 12 limbs is merely a temporary container for karmic imprints.
So the receptacle or the place in which, for instance, karma is deposited is the I or its consciousness. The two are really synonymous. Karma in this case amounts to habit. Did enjoy it. If we acquire karma in this life and that might manifest in the next life or the next tenth life or the thousand life, what might cause that to manifest in that life or the tenth life after?
So if let us say we have deposited a virtuous karmic imprints within our mind stream during this life, what would cause it to mature countless lives from now would be something of similar type to it, which is a virtuous mind. And if we had deposited a non virtuous karmic imprint with our mind stream in this life, what would cause it to mature countless lives from now would also be a concordant type of mind, which is a non virtuous mind. So are the non, sorry, are the manifestly actualizing limbs being engaged in the immediately preceding life to the, where they are actualized? Or can there be a separation of lives between craving appropriation and existence and where they actualize? Yes.
Definitely. Yes. In other words, the three limbs craving appropriation and existence necessarily manifest at the end of the immediately preceding life before which the six causal limbs occur. So there can be a long period of time between the projecting karma or the impelling karma, the impelling limbs and the manifestly actualizing ones, But once the manifestly actualizing limbs have been engaged, then they must manifest actually, the actualized limbs must manifest in the next life. It cannot be longer than three lives.
So now Gisha is gonna give you a bit of a hard time for a change. So where do you say that the limb of aging and death begins? Does it begin at birth or does it begin within the womb of the mother? At conception. At birth.
Right. So when you posit the limb of aging and death, what is it? Is it does it begin at birth, or does it begin within the womb of the mother? Basically, does not begin in the womb of the mother. Alright?
What you’re saying is that the infant in the mother’s womb is actualizing the limb of death. Right? He’s dead. Then four twelve limbs have collapsed, have they? What is the limb?
The child in the womb of the mother is in one limb, which one? So does the limb of aging and death occur within the womb? If you’re gonna say that the limb of birth begins with birth, well, it is well known that there are children who are stillborn. So they have died in the womb. Then what are you saying that that child did not have all 12 limbs?
He had the limb of death, so where is the limb of birth in there? This is something you have to examine because there is a difference between aging and death as it is understood in the worldly sense. And aging and this death from the standpoint of Buddhist philosophy. So how do you posit the limb of aging and death? Does that limb or can that limb occur within the womb?
Okay so I am going to say yes, I’m changing my position that birth actually does occur at conception because of this issue with children beings or dying within the womb or before the actual birth process. So it’s like the birth of the Bardo being is actually, like conception is like the birth of the Bardo being into the next life. Then it is better to establish the limb of aging and birth as of aging and death as beginning after conception and the limb of birth as being conception. So Ārya Nāgārjuna says in the Ratnāvali that just as long as we have aggregates for so long does the wheel of the 12 limbs turn just like a blazing twig which turns, creates a circle of fire. Khor lo.
Koa is Tibetan, no? In Tibetan the wheel, right? saṃsāra in Sanskrit. So the important topic Geshe-la wanted to explain was the impelling and the completing limbs, which are established respectively during this life, and for a cycle of the 12 limbs which matures over two lives at the end of this life. So the results arise naturally without any particular effort from our side.
It is at the level of the causes, the six causes that we have control. So Geshe-la gives a very nice metaphor for this in the golden rosary of eloquence. He says, it is similar to planting seeds in the spring. When you plant seeds in the spring, let’s say seeds of wheat in the ground, then those seeds are suitable to give rise to a crop of wheat. In the self same way, when the three when the establishing causes are accumulated, these establishing causes are suitable to give rise to their result.
So then, therefore, once the seeds have been planted in the field in the spring, they remain dormant underground suitable to give rise to a crop of wheat. And in the summer, when the heavy rains come, if the rains don’t come, are no crops. Then the seedlings sprout and the fields become filled with young sheafs of wheat. Now this corresponds to the moment before death where the virtuous prayers cause the maturation of the previously implanted karmic imprints. And as you know, as the death process proceeds, virtuous minds eventually become neutral.
Then when they become neutral at this point, one enters into the state of a Bardo being. Do you understand? Then if you don’t understand, ask questions. Then what happens is that we have the positive these virtuous karmic imprints within our mind stream, and at the time of our death, a virtuous mind which is similar in type to these virtuous imprints cause them to begin to mature. Then the stainless prayers to be reborn in, for instance, Australia, which is a peaceful and quiet country, causes to gain in intensity.
And at this point, that potency implanted within the mind triggers the transition to the state of a Bardo being. Clean? Alright. Great. Okay.
Mister Dokai. Yep. Geshe-la, is that the tenth limb that is the impelling karma into a future rebirth? Is that what you’re talking about? That the tenth limb, the limb of existence is a limb which establishes the next life.
It’s not impelling. Impelling karma is a second limb. Right? The coarse mind of death is a mind in which we can still think. The coarse mind of death is a mind in which we can still think.
And there, virtuous minds are present. In the subtle mind of death, the minds are only neutral. It’s like being asleep. It’s exactly like There’s extraordinary similarity between the process of falling asleep and awakening, and the process of dying and emerging in the Bardo state. There are some minor differences.
Okay. Natalie, and second Jill and third Monica. Seeing that Bardo Beings have been touched on today, I would just like to understand a bit more what’s sort of the point of the Bardo being in a way and why does it need for What’s the point? Yes, actually yes, point. And why does the Bardo being like, is it up to seven weeks before the next rebirth?
Like why does it have to be so specific? Why can’t it be just a few days Or you know, why can’t it be more than seven weeks? I’m just a bit I’d like some more clarification on that. Okay, just a minute please, and second who? So you’d prefer if it lasted two days?
You’d prefer if it lasted two days? If if you’re now boring, you can I can teach you? You can come tomorrow, you know. And you? But I can teach in English now.
I’m I’m a bit confused about, as with Richard’s question was similar to mine about how this virtuous mind turns into a neutral mind. Presumably So then before it’s turned into the neutral mind, the limbs of one, two, three, eight, nine and ten have already occurred because otherwise if it’s a neutral mind, how can that do any impelling into a happy or unhappy rebirth? That’s it. Exactly. So it is after the eight, ninth, and tenth limbs have been established, at the point at which that virtuous mind becomes a neutral mind that the being enters the Bardo state.
I was just wondering as a Bardo being, what limb you’re experiencing. But we don’t count the 12 limbs often for the Bardo That’s a very good question. Normally, the 12 limbs are not counted for Bardo beings. It is not the case that all phenomena in cyclic existence can be included in the 12 limbs. For instance, disease and so forth can’t.
And don’t worry too much about the Bardo beings, focus on the impelling and the manifestly actualizing limbs. So Buddhist texts teach that Bardo beings actually are in a very pure state. They have the paranormal powers. They do have the paranormal powers. And in addition, they have a body which is of a very subtle type of form, which is unobstructed.
So in many respects, their nature is almost mental. So some scholars say that completing karma is present at the level of the Bardo being because for instance, a Bardo being who is going to be reborn as a human being seeks out places where there are human beings. Now this is not out of the volition of the Bardo being. It is conditioned by karma. So a Bardo being therefore has this remarkably pure body and seeks out a place in re of rebirth in keeping with the rebirth he will obtain.
For instance, he might seek out rebirth in Australia among human beings. Then this base of us, this body, in other words, it is true that it arises from our parents, from the union of spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother. But we have it because the Bardo being Okay. About $20. Then if you have another question, not long, in a short thing.
For an eighth ground bodhisattva, is it the case that there are no 12 limbs or is it the case that ignorance is replaced by conventional ultimate bodhicitta and perhaps craving is replaced by great love and appropriation is replaced by great compassion and that would be the basis for their continued rebirth or is it that they just simply don’t apply because it’s not considered impelling? Has to be examined. According to Cittamātra mode of explanation, they do have the 12 limbs. However, according to the mainstream Pāramitāyāna explanations, Bodhisattvas in the first and the second ground have a body which is not included within the noble truth of suffering. It is a body of a mental nature.
Wants to ask you a question. Don’t answer now. Answer when we next meet. So if you take Śrāvaka Aryas, in other words, Hearer Aryas, then although they don’t accumulate any more impelling karma, they have large amounts of impelling karma within their mind stream. Then what happens precisely?
Do they continue to take rebirth like us or not? What happens? So obviously, they have. They still have, like us, craving appropriation and existence. Right?
So are they reborn like us in the womb of a mother? What happens? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
This is probably it then. I have a question, Richard. No. I was thinking that Okay. Right in the second.
So when you ask these questions about aryas, it is particularly interesting. So so far the presentation of the 12 limbs has been in terms of ordinary beings. But what happens with ārya beings? Ārya beings are samsaric beings like us. They have they don’t accumulate anymore impelling karma, but they have huge amounts of impelling karma accumulated before they became ārya beings.
So what precisely happens? So obviously, hearers who are on the stages of or the paths of seeing or of meditation still have previously accumulated impelling karma and still have afflictions. So they do take rebirth. How? Like us or differently?
And then once they have attained the state of an arhat, then if we try to understand why arhats no longer take rebirth under the power of karma and affliction, we have to look at the 12 limbs in the reverse order. So far we have presented them, or Geshe-la has presented them in the forward order. So this is understood in terms of grounds and paths. Stop here to today. Thank you, thank you so very much.
Now we should dedicate the vast amounts of merit which we have accumulated during the last two days following these teachings, and we should dedicate them to the dissemination of the Buddha’s teachings and to peace and happiness in this world without which nothing can be accomplished. In addition, Geshe-la says, we should dedicate them to the furtherance of the practice, well-being and studies of your translator, who is very helpful to the studies here, and to the we should dedicate the roots of virtue also to the well-being practice and happiness of Tenzin, of Carol, and of Mandy, who have worked very hard in the kitchen to create the meals we have all consumed. And please, if you have time, don’t waste your time. Don’t waste the opportunity. Do attend the teachings which are given at TBI on Tuesday and Wednesday as much as you can, then Geshe-la feels that it is not an issue of lack of time from your side.
You have time. It is more an issue of physical discomfort, and you just have to put effort. Do understand that true suffering is mental suffering, and that it is dharma and nothing else which counters mental suffering. Okay, that’s enough I think, is Page nine. Mandala offering.
Both verses slowly. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
So I just want to quickly say thank you to Geshe-la for a wonderful teaching again over the weekend. Thank you so much. And they say a beehive has to have a queen bee. Otherwise, the bees go crazy or they don’t know what to do. So we’re very fortunate to have a queen bee.
So I hope we can make lots of honey. And of course, without having Ilya to translate, we wouldn’t understand because we don’t understand Tibetans. So thank you so much Ilya. And with your wife Mandy who is helping out. Out in the back for you and Mandy.
So thank you so much for Mandy. Mandy was on the phone before I think. And of course as Geshe-la has said, Tenzin who is the director has been the epitome of humility by not only representing Rinpoche for us but serving out in the kitchen and thank you so much Tenzin. And Tenzin said he wasn’t going to be here so I gave him his little present before and I think and he’s the big giver. That’s right.
And Carol was going to be here and I’ve got something for her but she’s not. Thank you Carol who’s worked hard in the office and helping TENSEN as well. And Glenys and others who have brought things for the morning afternoon tea and for helping. And so, you know, interdependently, everybody has helped and thank you for coming. And I’ll hand you over to Tenzin.
First of all, I would like to say, you know, how wonderful this weekend and I’d like to say, Geshe-la, thank you so much. And of course, without Ilya and all we can’t can hear and all that. So thank you so much, Ilya, and all your work and your efforts and so many things here at the center. And so without you, we can also teach. So I would like to say everyone, all the participants, you know, thank you so much for participating, you know.
And and Jill, Anila, you know, people who involved for the weekend. And not only that, for in general, you know, Glennis and Mandy and Carol, you know, everyone who, know, help for the weekend is really fantastic. Thank you so much. And not only that, it’s a real in generally, you know, the at this around the center, there’s so many different tasks people taking, you know, and I would like to say thank you so much for their effort and their try accumulating their merits and which is a very, you know, you are investing so much in there. So that will be a result, that will a big one.
And I would like to share this one appropriate and I have received His Holiness office letter and that is very great news that Rinpoche is reincarnated is somewhere in a Himalayan region, but it is in a process. So we have got few poojas to be done and have already started, and a few of them is done, Hayagrīva and Rog Fur, Chenrezig, which usually very one of the protector deities of the Seraje monastery. And we’ve done that and also the Vajrayoginī self-initiation, all the Geshes in Sera at the Ramoché Street and at Lavarang, and they’ve done that. And so we have a few more Pujas have to do. And then, you know, sometime in the future, very soon, you can hear way exact, you know.
Alright. Thank you very much. I like to share that. It’s good news. And we have a small veggie pad at the back there, and my wife and Dechen planting those parsley.
And the parsley has grown so much. We cut it. They cut it today. Please, when you go home, take some. It’s a fresh, organic, and so so is there you can put it in a tomato salad.
Fantastic. Okay. I think this is about it. And thank you so much, everyone, and I really appreciate. And not only that, you know, I like to say, thank you so much, Chris.
You know, he he always says, you know, thank for everybody, but we forgot him. He’s, thank you so much, you know. Alright and Yeah. But I forgot to say thank you to Julian Drocker for the Yeah. Yeah.
Excellent. Everyone who involves, you know, there’s a lot of people, you know. And thank you so much, Geshe-la, once again, and Ilya. And please, yeah, if you like to make an offering, you know, you can do so now. And make sure take some parsley.
Alright? It’s in a basket in a in a lunch room. Take some and make it finish it off. It’s a it’s a good gesture, you know. End of the weekend.
Thank you. You want to show something?
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- self-initiation dagjug (Tib)
- A Highest Yoga Tantra meditation practice performed without the presence of an empowering lama, following initiation and completion of a long retreat and fire puja. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Is the tenth limb of dependent origination, existence, the impelling karma that sends us into a future rebirth?
No. The tenth limb, the limb of existence, is the limb which establishes the next life. It is not the impelling karma. Impelling karma is the second limb. The passage then turns to the mind at death. The coarse mind of death is a mind in which we can still think, and virtuous minds can be present there. In the subtle mind of death, the minds are only neutral, like being asleep. There is extraordinary similarity between falling asleep and awakening, and dying and emerging in the Bardo state, though there are some minor differences.