1 h 17 min · 6,767 words · 1 May 2009 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 77-minute afternoon session at Harvard Medical School, HH the Dalai Lama explores wisdom and compassion alongside leading Western psychologists. He begins by distinguishing wisdom as mental clarity that operates beyond sensation—prajna, a faculty that can be either distorted by ignorance or grounded in valid reality. Key to this is understanding selflessness: the self appears independent but investigation reveals it cannot exist separately from body and mind. This insight undermines the grasping that fuels destructive emotions like hatred and attachment, while compassion and dedication to others can loosen egocentrism without denying the self-confidence needed for practice. The Dalai Lama then addresses suffering with striking realism—not all hardship resolves, but perspective shifts meaning; he illustrates this through personal loss, tragedy’s role in building resilience, and the necessity of seeing the interconnected nature of all phenomena rather than clinging to absolute categories of good and bad. The conversation emphasizes that compassion flows from human biology itself: infants depend entirely on maternal care, making gentleness our base nature, and scientific evidence shows compassion sustains health and peace. The session brings Buddhist psychology into direct dialogue with psychiatry, behavioral therapy, and cognitive science.
File metadata (for organising)
File: and Psychotherapy Developing Wisdom and Compassion; 1 May 2009 (Afternoon) Vi….mp3
UUID: 9262d492-8c72-4011-ada6-68b2014ed8e2
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Meditation
Date: 2009 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~6,763
So thank you, and welcome back. Wisdom, I think, a kind of human intelligence that actually, I think, the one of the unique thing about human brain. The other animals, I think some have a very low degree of intelligence, but we humans or the brain is something really much advanced. So then I think now better do if you used Tibetan. In the Buddhist understanding Oh, I think ancient a classic ancient Indian thought.
Yeah. So a in a classical Indian thought, any cognitive event or any cognitive faculty is recognized as having the capacity to know, to be aware. So, however, a distinction is strong between how we acquire knowledge or understanding or awareness with relation to our sensory faculties, we’ve engaged with the world, and also mental experience, experience at the level of mind itself. So when we speak about prajna, which is a Sanskrit term in Tibetan, that is translated as wisdom, we are really talking about our ability to know at this second mental level, not at the sensory level. So this faculty So although there is an understanding that any mental activity has this capacity to be aware of, to to engage with object.
However, when we speak of this particular faculty translated as wisdom, this prajna, then we are really talking at the level of mental experience. So that kind of faculty need not be present present in all cognitive experiences. So this morning, we had discussion about how there are two primary types of mental processes. One tends to be more in the form of aspiration, yearning, and wish, and compassion belongs to that class. And there is the other category of mental engagement that tends to be more cognitively oriented, and wisdom and intelligence and insight belongs to that category.
So within this domain where our mental engagement is much more cognitively oriented where the role of insight and understanding and and intelligence plays a greater role. And they can be both distorted forms. You know, some sometimes we can be very sure of a certain, you know, understanding that we develop, but it may have no basis in reality. Those are kind of forms of wisdom, but they are kind of distorted forms of wisdom or understanding. But then there could be other forms of understanding which are really more in tune with reality, which are grounded in reality.
These are the correct forms of understanding, which are referred to as prajna or or wisdom. So I think when we carry investigation, then the wisdom side is now implementing, utilizing. So in our daily life, it’s that intelligence or wisdom, you see, every time is used. And dream time also, sometimes subject to which we much involve in daytime to investigate. That same sort of kind of investigation may carry in dream.
So so the So this indicates that this faculty of wisdom or is active even in our state? Oh, in fact, I think the dream state, the basic mind more subtler than the state of awakening state. Waking state. Waking state. So the if someone is a I think some sort of technique, then maybe the dream state mind may be more sharper for further investigation.
So these these are the mind or intelligence by itself, just neutral. Neutral. Neutral. Can be either constructive and destructive. It must develop motivation.
Other factor. Factor. And similarly, wishing. Similarly, those forms of more aspiring and yearning type of mental states are also very much dependent upon the motivation whether they can be constructive or negative. Oh, actually, I just want you to see the exact meaning of because of psychology.
Psychology. Yeah. What what is the exact meaning? I quite often usually use the word psychology, but I don’t know the exact meaning. I I’m At the risk of I’m expect you see later Later discussion.
One of you Yeah. Please explain the exact meaning. Then see, in Tibetan, the psychologist Exactly, I don’t know. So you see these different mind or thought. Some may belong psychology.
Some may not. I don’t know. So in order to know that, they it is very essential to know the exact meaning of psychology. Well, the problem is is pointing out that his understanding of this mental phenomena is drawn from classical Indian and Tibetan sources. And when translating across the disciplines, across language, when we use the English term psychology, to what extent it overlaps to the phenomena that the classical text describes and his understanding is based on becomes problematic.
Yes. That’s all. Okay. Well, thank you. That is a wonderful introduction.
And if I may, I’d like to introduce our panelists this afternoon, to you. We can begin with doctor Jon Kabat-Zinn, who you know and recently saw in Dharamsala. And, for people I think probably most people in the audience know him as well. He’s the founder and former director of the stress reduction clinic at the Center for Mindfulness in Medicine, Healthcare, and and Society at the University of Massachusetts Medical School where he is also an emeritus professor of medicine. His life work has been dedicated to introducing mindfulness practice into mainstream western cultures and studying its clinical applications.
To his left is doctor Elisa Ely. She’s a psychiatrist on the faculty of Harvard Medical School who is well known for her thoughtful writings about seriously mentally ill patients in the Boston Globe and the New York Times and for her poetic descriptions of clinical work and the suffering of major mental illness on national public radio. Her compassion and wisdom around the power and mystery of listening is reflected in these stories. To my right is doctor Marsha Linehan. She’s the director of the behavioral research and therapy clinics and professor of psychology at the University of Washington in Seattle.
She’s renowned as the developer of dialectical behavior therapy, which effectively combines cognitive and behavioral techniques with acceptance and mindfulness practice to treat patients who have difficulty regulating both their emotions and their behavior. And finally, a gentleman who may be able to answer your question about what we think psychology is, is doctor Steven Pinker. He is an experimental psychologist on the faculty of Harvard College. He is world famous for his research on the acquisition and psychology of language, words, visual cognition, and how the mind works. He too has been named one of the 100 most influential people by Time Magazine.
And related to the topic of our panel, he’s interested in the psychological dynamics of war and the limitations of nonviolence. So to begin our discussion, if I can ask doctor Kabat-Zinn to lead us off. For your holiness, it’s wonderful to see you again. And, I would say wonderful to have this kind of gathering under the auspices of the Harvard Medical School. I feel that you are probably the most important figure in the world right now giving voice to the need for greater compassion and wisdom in the world.
That gives an enormous amount of inspiration to people far and wide to actually inquire deeply as to what wisdom and what compassion would require in this particular state of the world at this moment. So I just want to express my profound appreciation on the part of myself, but also I would say on the part of all of us here your willingness to take this transformational point position because the world is in so sore need of what we are inquiring about today. I also dare say that it would be something of a stretch for the Harvard Medical School to actually hold an entire two day symposium on on meditation and psychotherapy with the subtext of wisdom and compassion without your presence. That’s not to say it wouldn’t happen, but it certainly is catalytic, I would say. So I love that you just brought up the question of what psychology actually is because we’ve been sitting here this morning asking you questions about, like, what is the nature of compassion and what is we’re going to talk about the nature of wisdom.
So I think it’s only fair that it be bidirectional. And as you know, when that subject came up in Dharamsala two weeks ago around emotion, it became very, clear to all that even from the western scientific perspective, the study of emotion, that it’s very, very hard to define precisely what emotion is and how it is distinguished from cognition or from mood or anything like that. So we are swimming in a sea that is a little bit imprecise. At the same time, we always have to come back to the first noble truth, and that is the actuality of the enormity of the suffering in this world. And whether there are ways for human beings both individually and collectively to address this suffering.
And, certainly, psychotherapy is one of the most profound ways that the The West has developed for trying to reach out to human beings who are suffering, especially at the domain of mind. But since we don’t differentiate fundamentally between mind and body, it concerns the whole human being and address this suffering. And I might say that then there’s also the collective suffering of the planet because so much of the destructive energies of the human mind when it doesn’t know itself get replicated social environment, in the banking environment to just to pick something out of the hat, or, the, fate of the planet, the danger of the ecology of the planet to human harm. So, we’re really talking here about some things you mentioned this morning, which is can we understand something profoundly about the nature of the mind and the nature of reality? And when you were asked the question about, give us one easy meditation that we could do that would just kind of make everything a little bit better, I felt you very skillfully said, no.
Thank you. Because the human mind is so complex that we don’t want to suggest one thing. We’ll just kind of do it. So but at the same time, you did mention the meditation on impermanence, and then you also mentioned deep inquiry into anātman or the nature of the self. And so it seems to me that the the nature of the self and its relationship to impermanence and suffering are very, very important in the field of psychotherapy, whether we’re talking about an individual or we’re talking about human behavior on a global scale.
So my question to you to open up the afternoon’s discussion or dialogue is really around the nature of the self and whether when you use the word wisdom, there’s a particular way in which the perspective of prajna has to do with the nature of reality of what we think of as myself and whether there’s some kind of understanding beyond our thoughts about ourselves. In other words, are we who we think we are, or are we something else larger, more profound than who we think we are? And are there ways to come back to Richard Davidson’s question this morning to actually practice or cultivate wisdom wisdom hand in hand with compassion. Sometimes I know they’re spoken of as like the two wings of a bird, the compassion and wisdom. So are there ways that you that you can share with us that might be useful in the domain of human suffering that have to do with the actual deepening and cultivation of wisdom and how it would hold compassion.
I think, firstly, although this is very, very complicated subject, But I think one obvious thing is perhaps in in our in generally, those people who have some kind of self centered sort of equal egocentric attitude. Grasping off. I that kind of system. Then such person
Think sometimes more sensitive about the other’s attitude. Some nice word come, very happy, a little uncomfortable word come. Immediately, it’s much Then person who not that much sort of, rather strong sort of grasping. Nice word. Okay.
Good. But, no, not that much of. Excitement. Excitement. And negative word, also okay.
That that helps the thing. Feeling. Attitude. That I think happening, isn’t it? So in that case, now Buddhist explanation is, as I mentioned before, in the mind or thought, I think here we can divide two groups.
One, a negative or destructive which no basis of valid validity. Another, constructive based on valid. Right. Very valid grounds. Now the the first category, first one, because based on ultimately ignorance.
So no validity. Now ignorance, there are many many variety of ignorance. Yeah. Here, ignorance is very strong self grasping. So self is there.
Nobody can deny that. Self is there. It’s a reality. But now here, appearance and reality, there’s always gap. So now regarding self, appears something independent, which own our body and mind.
The reality, if we investigate beside the body and mind, we can’t find self as the one entity, independent separate entity. So appears, oh, there could be separate entity. Reality, no. So that’s the Buddhist concept of selflessness. So that now the other one, you see the the feeling or self grasping that self something independently exist.
That’s ignorance now. So that base that’s basis, then other attachment or fear or many things. Fear also, I think, the with reasons, that’s not based on ignorance. But much sort of exaggerated sort of thing, fear is very much with that ignorance. And then attachment, I think attachment, that also is a we need, if you did, because of that.
Precise definition. Precise definition. But generally, you see, attachment and desire, two separate thing. Desire now or reasonable. Desire.
Desire with reasons. Desire now for example, here, you see, everybody have desire to achieve happy, joyful life. That desire is right. And as a Buddhist desire to achieve Buddhahood, that desire is right, positive. And meantime now here, our desire want Buddhahood, but based on grasping, self-grasping, that also consider negative.
Right. The desire itself right, the valid basis. But the cause related, based on that grasping sort of ignorance, so it all then holds things that spoil. Yeah. So negative.
So, in fact, one of the Buddhist texts states that if someone engages in a virtuous act based on a very strong sense that I, as an independent ego, exist Mhmm. Then that pursuit may seem like virtuous, but actually it’s not virtuous. So now here, yesterday also I mentioned, I feel the faith, strong faith, unshakable, one pointed faith according to Christian religion, god, to a tremendous sort of one pointed faith. The although it’s different than the Buddhist sword of wisdom of No self. Because of no no self.
Mhmm. Some, I think, similar effect Mhmm. The faith towards god. Then at that time, the effect of self, not important. God, creator, you are totally sort of what’s today.
Disposal of all, totally sort of what’s Devoted love. Devoted. So some sense of selfless. So that I think I think, generally speaking, more or same effect effect. For example, in the Buddhist teachings, we speak of a practitioner being single pointed in his or her kind of a reverence to the Three Jewels, Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, and that has an effect of releasing this grasping itself and ego.
Similarly, a practitioner who dedicates his entire being, what is speech and mind for the relative So for example, a Bodhisattva practitioner who dedicates his or her entire being for benefit of other beings and dedicates to the service for others as articulated in Nāgārjuna’s prayer where he makes the aspiration, may I become like the elements such as earth, water, fire and so on, so that all sentient beings can utilize me in whatever way they they wish. So that kind of dedication can have an impact effect on releasing this kind of grasping at a strong sense of ego, self centeredness. So these are not wisdom’s side, but some effect on the egoistic sort of strong egoistic feeling. So now here, we need this in a very subtle way of distinction. Distinction.
Otherwise, the on the other hand, you see, in order to dedicate oneself, one’s body, minds, mind speech, totally dedicated for well-being of Of others. Entire sentient being. You need tremendous sort of will. Confidence. Tremendous sort of self confidence and strong sort of, say, feeling of what’s it?
Self. A strong of self. A Otherwise, you can’t you can’t practice such thing. So strong self. There are two, one positive or negative.
One based on wisdom, one based on ignorance. So we have to make distinction. So the real question is I lost now. Now religion, according to religion, firstly, there’s other some reasons. They said to to bring conviction.
God. Faith in God. Their wisdom worked. Right. Then bring the enthusiasm of practice of compassion and admiration of compassion.
So that way, one way. Then nontheistic, again, the knowledge, fuller knowledge about law of causality. That’s work for wisdom. So that brings conclusion that they need compassion. Then this morning, the secular way.
They are also, as we indeed utilize our common sense, our common experience, and latest scientific findings. Through that way, you should bring conviction. These positive emotions are good for oneself, for the society, for the family, like that. So wisdom or intelligence, I mean, any human sort of human thought which related with reasoning than intelligence or wisdom always now. Thank you, Your Holiness.
Thank you. Thank you very much for that. I think that has tremendous relevance to psychotherapy, and it strikes me that maybe the kind of motivation that you’re talking about for the great Bodhisattva commitment to prajna and to healing all people, serving all people, is something that we might introduce within psychotherapy and bring back into psychotherapy in terms of, like, a Hippocratic oath for for psychotherapists. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you. I’d like to give doctor Elisa Ely an opportunity to speak with you. I am a psychiatrist who sees psychotic patients in a day clinic. In two evenings a week, I travel to some of the homeless shelters around Boston and see people there. The patients that I see hear voices that speak cruelly to them.
They believe they’re being punished for crimes they haven’t committed. They believe that horrific things will happen to them that are not going to happen to them. And sometimes they can’t cannot forget the horrific things that have happened to them. I prescribe their medications. I sit with them.
I hold their hand metaphorically. I admire their strength. And I say, hold on. If you just hang on, things will change and get better. If you take your medication, if you come to the clinic, if you don’t drink, if you don’t use drugs, if you hold on, your symptoms will diminish, your lives will improve.
But that is not true. Many of the patients I see have done this for years and their lives have not improved. Their symptoms have not grown better. They’ve worsened. Their illnesses have not diminished.
They have increased. So my question for you, which I ask selfishly but hopefully, is is there something you can say to me, to us, that we can bring back to our patients to help them whose lives are so difficult, whose lives may not change, and whose lives we ourselves might not be able to endure. I think now precise answer for that question is I don’t know. Again, this morning, I mentioned the individual case. There are some individual who have some faith.
Then religious Then, accordingly, some different approach because of the different approach. Even someone who who are nonbeliever but still have some sort of respected friend, including their parent, Can we, you see, use their name? I don’t think yesterday, I think I mentioned that, For example, someone who lost Loved one. Ah. Loved one.
Loved one passed away, And too much worry. So that kind of question. So I mentioned my own case, my own experience, and my tutor, senior tutor. Passed away. Passed away.
At that time, I felt that usually I had I had a feeling I have some solid rock to lean on. To lean on. To lean on. Now that no longer there. So some great disturbances, but then I felt, now no use to keep some of this I don’t know.
It was a very grief or grief or despair of sorts of feeling. I remember my late tutor. He wish me more healthy person and something useful useful life, meaningful life. So if I too much worry, too much sadness, he also feel more sad. If I, in spite his death, I carry his instruction, his teaching sincerely and without sort of too much distance on my mind, that’s the best way to Serve.
To to serve or to present gift. To serve his wishes then offer a gift to his wishes. So it’s just someone who, I think, who may if the president has, for example, who have very kind mother or father or someone, then remember, now no longer on this planet, but still, say, if your parent, way knows your condition, You have too much worry, too much desperate sort of feeling brings more worry, more sadness to your loving parents. Things already happen. There’s no way to overcome that.
You know, just worry, worry, worry is additional suffering. I think our life, always there are different aspects. Any reality, many different aspects. So from one way, from one angle, it is disaster. But same event, if you look from another angle, maybe not that kind of disaster.
Even some positive things may be there. So that’s, I think, important. That someone who always look from one direction or sad, negative side, think negative, negative, worrying, worrying, worrying, worrying. Now I often see make example. Our own case, we lost our country.
A lot of sort of problems. If you look only that aspect, then more worry, more sadness. But if you look from another angle, because of this tragic situation,
Creates new opportunity. If I still in Lhasa, I may not participate here. Harvard University sort of some Discussion. Discussions. And we personally also you see there’s no opportunity to be deal with the right of people, and from I could learn many, many things.
So I myself consider most holy person in Potala, so remain like that. Waste waste of time and remain with distance rather distance with reality. Just fooling oneself. No use. So I think every life, I think when our life go through okay, then they are Smoothly.
Smoothly, then there is time to pretend. But when you’re passing through difficult, no time to pretend, You must be realistic. You must accept the reality. So in a life, difficulties, difficult period is very useful in order to become realistic person. I think of this country, for example.
I think your ancestors, the first sort of settlers, I think that they really worked very hard. So a lot of sort of hardship. So there, because of hardship, as a person, more tougher than those younger people. And the European con European continent also and Japan also, the younger younger generation not experience that kind of, say, difficulties. So sometimes their life more spoiled like that.
And in Tibetan community in India also, those elder people who firstly come for settlement and work hard, they are very tough. And for such people, small, small difficulties may not disturb much. Then the spoiled one, small things disturb lot. So therefore, tragedy is good. It’s really So like like the like the burning makes the earthen jar Firing.
Firing earthen jar makes it very tough and strong. In the same manner, tragedy makes you grow and become stronger. That does not mean tragedy is good. No. No.
No. No. Must avoid. But but if something happen, then take the positive side. It’s better.
Thank you for that, very valuable perspective. I’d like to give doctor Linehan an opportunity to speak with you. Well, I am extremely happy to be here. And I want to answer your question. What is psychology?
You may have a different answer. But as a scientist myself, I think of psychology as the science of behavior, including the behavior of the mind. And but I want to say and as psychologists in psychotherapy research are starting to study mindfulness, A colleague of mine that I work with, Alan Marlatt, said at a major conference, what are we doing, psychologists studying this without inviting the people who really understand it, the, spiritual leaders such as you. So I wanna I’m so grateful for you to be here and that Harvard brings together you, the Dalai Lama, with scientists and brings these two together because it is so important. But I wanna move to my question.
There’s no psychological. So so what is the meaning of psychology? Then psychology is not mind. No. Psychology is not a study of mind.
It is the study of the mind. Oh. Yeah. You study it also, of course. Now your answer, instead of solving problem, create more confusion.
So it seems now it seems psychology is some method to investigate mind. Not mind yourself. I see. Really? But not this person is psychologically something something.
Because of psychologically. Psychologically. See these I don’t know. Ask a question. No.
I feel I’m still in kindergarten. So you have to learn many things. I don’t I don’t Might I ask a question? Yes. Thank you.
I I develop The psychology. So don’t ask about psychology. No. Yes. I develop psych I’m a psychotherapy researcher.
Psychotherapy. And in the research that I do, I treat the most stigmatized patients. Uh-huh. The ones no one else wants to treat. Oh.
Because no one sees them as wise at all. Yes. So I, in developing a treatment, told all the patients, and I told my graduate students too, that they have wise mind, the capacity for wisdom. But then and I said, you too can be wise and you can engage in wise action. And so the patient said to me, well, what is wise action?
And how do I know if my behavior is wise? My drug addicts are effective at getting drugs, and they wanna know is that wise. And I looked it in the dictionary and I couldn’t figure it out myself, myself, so I’m really asking you for my patients, how do you know if behavior or action is wise? And and how do you how do you determine with wise action? I think from Buddhist viewpoint, one event one factor.
Yeah. Whether positive or negative, sometimes difficult to sorry. Distinguish. Distinguish Distinguish. Itself.
By itself. By itself. So from the research side, look from the research side or from motivation side, from other So So open up this question a little bit because it raises the point about what action constitutes wholesome as versus unwholesome. And in the Buddhist context, there’s a recognition that some actions may be wholesome by their very nature of the act itself, But there could be other actions which are Or action or mind. Or action or a state of mind which are wholesome by their very nature.
But some can be wholesome because of the underlying motivation, the state of mind that give rise to them. So in these cases, you may not be one may not be able to actually define the act itself or the mental itself as wholesome, but rather So by itself, you cannot define one way or another, but you can define something as wholesome because of the underlying motivation that gave rise to it. And then some some mental state or action can be defined as wholesome because of the con concomitant state of mind. There might be other mental processes which are present at the same time that support it, and that’s what makes them wholesome. So then some action whether wise or not, but I think I know they should judge from the result of your point.
From the point of view of consequence? Mhmm. Otherwise, So, otherwise, it’s very difficult to, you know, pick the action itself and say this is wise versus unwise. But you look at the consequences. Yes.
For some action carried sincere motivation. Motivation. Sensitive motivation. So from the motivation viewpoint, it’s a part of that. Positive, wholesome.
But since that method become unrealistic method unrealistic method due to lack of knowledge or awareness about the reality. Mhmm. So then the result will be negative. So from the result viewpoint, that action can consider wrong. So from the result side, yes.
So therefore, this throws up the complexity of situations where the underlying motivation may be wholesome and then the act, because of the way in which it is done, may result in negative consequences. So from the point of view of consequence, this the same act is unwholesome and unwise. So that can be possible because things are relative. So this is because everything is dependent upon context and relative. So just like long and short, you can only contextually define what is long and what is short.
So good and bad. So, basically, that’s that’s that’s field. That field. Some good thing compare extremely good thing, that this is bad. The bad and the good compared with bad is good.
So like that. So all everything you see because of the interconnected. So this now this is a broad one with this important concept. No independent self. Everything related with other due to other factor.
So that, again, very helpful to loosening or grasping. Good is good. Absolute. That’s loose. Bad is absolute bad.
Of course, there’s the problem that in the end, there will be nothing left to point your finger at. What? There’s a nihilism. Nothing left to point your finger at. You don’t know who to There’s a nihilism.
So now must avoid that. And, also, the grasping, there’s another sort of absolutism. Extreme. Extreme. Between there, we call.
So the best thing is That’s why in Buddhism, the understanding of the interdependent nature of reality becomes very crucial. Therefore, one’s understanding of the reality of anything must be grounded upon appreciation of its very interconnected nature. And then this appreciation of the interdependent nature will also help us be released from our tendency to grasp at some kind of solidity and absolute reality? One thing, when I met this is some foreigner and also some Tibetans also, is it due to some tragedy? Is it very too much worry?
For example, there’s one, I think, person who they what’s it? The people who brought that person as you described him as a mad person. Then in in front of that person, as they quite loudly, as you mentioned, this is mentally something wrong. Unstable now. Oh, mad person.
Then I then I, as I said, told him, doesn’t doesn’t matter. In a certain level, we everybody mad. In the sense, you see, we are servant of ignorance. So ignorance dominant our our mind from the Buddhist viewpoint now. So we always get the sort of impression, distorted information.
It was a distorted Understandable. Perception. Appearance. So we take that as a real reality. So we act according to that appearance.
So, essentially, mad. Deluded. Deluded. So, you see, in order to if you tell, oh, you are mad, then his or her her mind will more discourage. Than less willingness to recover or to to be another So normal human that’s, I think, very, very important to to give any every encouragement.
Encouragement. Especially those sort of the prisoners, you see, they treat them as a part of society and part of our community and give them hope and confidence. And through that way, realize their past mistake, but potential to become a normal good human being. That I feel important. Sometimes people treat these people more because of that.
They do inferior. Inferior. Inferior. Uh-huh. Then that, I think, actually block the possibility of recover.
Thank you. Okay.
I’d like to give doctor Pinker an opportunity to perhaps tell us what psychology is or go off in a different direction. Yes. Now I’m hoping more precise for the psychology. I would define psychology as the science of mind. Both the science of thinking, how we reason, how we remember, how we imagine, how we speak and understand language, and also the science of emotion, of love and hate and fear, and the moral emotions like anger and gratitude and guilt and compassion and trust.
I’m I’m going to ask you a psychological question that is very much related to your life’s work. You are the world’s foremost symbol of nonviolent political change. You are devoted to the idea that the terrible violence and oppression in Tibet will change for the better. And in many ways, there are positive signs in history that human behavior, can change and that we can become less violent. Over many centuries, humanity has abolished barbaric practices like slavery and crucifixion and burning at the stake and human sacrifice.
Even in the past fifty years, we have seen a reduction in the number of wars between nations, and events that would have been deemed incredible just three decades ago, such as the fall of the Soviet empire without a a major war, the end of apartheid in South Africa without a bloodbath or massacre. So there are optimistic signs. By many criteria, we have become a more peaceful species. The question is, if our biological nature has not changed, we still have impulses toward violence and self deception and impulsiveness and greed. What are the positive aspects of human nature that have been engaged over the centuries and decades?
Is it a widening sense of empathy so that we don’t just feel compassion for our own, clan or family but for larger and larger groups? Is it inhibition and self control? Is it passing justice from our own biased selves to disinterested third parties like the rule of law and government? Is it trade and exchange where globalization makes it more profitable to cooperate with people than to invade them? There are many possibilities for what parts of the mind are increasingly engaged, what do you think those parts of the mind are, and how, can we best engage them to continue the progress toward, nonviolence in human history?
Correct. Okay. Okay. Oh, that’s my favorite subject today. Basically, human nature, I believe, more gentle gentleness or more compassionate.
The reason biologically at at the time of our birth, I think that the mother ready to provide milk, care. So that moment, the dominant force, dominant emotion in our mind is love. Tremendous affectionate to that person who provide us nourishment. Right? And nurturing.
Nurturing, including milk. Although that time, I I think the cognitive, more detailed cognitive, so mind not yet developed. So the the child may not have the knowledge, and this is my mother, but simply biological factor totally rely. And so long remain with that, feel happy. Separate, uncomfortable fear.
So at that time, aggressiveness, even though occasionally maybe maybe, but dominant, not dominant. Very clear. So affection, whole twenty four hours. And since our life started that way and very nature, our survival entirely depend on others care. In order to bring that energy to caring for her children, the mother’s side need some kind of tremendous will.
That brings my affection. So that’s my nature now. I often used to telling people my on my curiosity, like you see turtle, some turtle or butterfly or some other sort of fit the species of mammals whose youngsters survival not depend on mother’s care. Those animal, if we put together the youngster, for example, the youngster turtle youngster, turtle, and his mother put together, I don’t think the both sides have the capacity to show affection. It’s not necessary.
Survive by itself. So we belong to the other type. Is it caring by mother? Depend entirely on mother, birds, some sort of, animal like cats, dogs, all the all these. So we broke that.
But we need milk like that. So because of that, biological factor. Now the scientist the scientist are my guru now. They said they they said they found the compassionate mind very good for our health. Good health and for our body element and peace of mind go very well.
Agitated mind not go well. So, therefore, our body, basic nature of body much more closer to calm mind. Compassion brings calm mind. Anger destroy our calm mind. Very clear.
So, therefore, appreciation of love, compassion by nature. And in fact, compassionate attitude and full of compassion, I think little chance as of the lie with compassion and motivation, brings honesty, truthful, justice. With anger motivation, cheating, lie, bully, all these negative verbal action as well as well as physical action. So, therefore, our basic nature is, I believe, more compassionate. Compassionate very much need for our health, for our life.
That’s a dominant force. Therefore, all actions, verbal action, physical action, which closer that mind is by nature we appreciate. So in the society, as a truthful, whether educated or uneducated or eastern or western or southern or poor or rich, everybody will cherish truthful, honest. So, therefore, war concept of war is a act of bully motivated, most cases, anger, hatred. I think through experiences out of war, out of violence.
During twentieth century, we human being, humanity, I think, gain much more experiences. Result, as I mentioned before, we become more mature. So we realize our own mistake. So I think tendency more towards more convergence, more peace, nonviolence. And nonviolence, of course, bound to happen because our problem is still there.
Always is a problem is bound to happen. So the that problem, not to bring violence, but some way to solve that problem, that’s nonviolence. So so long problem there, concept of nonviolence, very much relevant. Thank you. Your holiness.
So I think the last sort of the I think one encouraging sort of statement or expression, the late queen mother, The Buddhas British queen mother. Queen mother, ninety-sixth, ninety-six. Her own age, 96. So at that time, I had opportunity on audience. Since my childhood, her picture on that, the, the lady, is very, very familiar in my in in my mind.
And also her husband during the second World War, I think very I think very nice person. So in any way in any way, I had some sort of keen desire To meet her. One of the audience with her. So when I met, I asked her, since the most part of this twentieth century, you witnessed. So humanity, we becoming more better or more or less remain same or worsen.
Without hesitation, she mentioned better. Then she mentioned, when she was young, no concept of human right, no concept of self determination. Nowadays, these become universal value, she mentioned. I think I think this quite kind of a authentic statement, I think. One lady, not a politician.
Then very old. Mhmm. So not much sort of concern about her future. So I think she honestly mentioned these things. Thank you.
I I believe I believe your holiness that’s sad for us. It’s time for you to K. Move on. There are other people who are very much looking forward to meeting with you today and for speaking for the entire group. I’d like to thank you so much for coming and joining us.
Thank you. So perhaps I think oh, yes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank Thank you. You. Thank you.
Yeah. You? Thank you. You. Thank you.
Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. You. Special thank for bring bring more confusion.
Thank you so much. You. Thank you. Thank you. No.
No. You earlier, you gave me one. You Really? I’ll I’ll take you. Tough.
I’ll take back. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you, Your Holiness. Thank you for a wonderful day.
Thank you. Thank you for coming. Thank you. Bye bye. Bye bye.
Alright. Thank you so much. Bye bye. Oh, that’s very kind of you. Thank you.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- anatman dagme (Tib)
- No-self; as opposed to atman (self); the term used for selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
How do you know whether an action or behavior is wise, and how do you determine what counts as wise action?
Some actions are wholesome by their very nature, while others are wholesome because of the underlying motivation that gave rise to them, or because of supporting mental states present at the same time. Often you cannot define an act as wise or unwise by itself, so it helps to look at the consequences. An action with a sincere, wholesome motivation can still bring negative results if the method is unrealistic through lack of knowledge of reality, and from the side of results it can be considered wrong. Good and bad are relative and depend on context, like long and short. Seeing this loosens grasping at good as absolute or bad as absolute.