Lamp for the Path

50 min · 3,156 words · 2002 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lamp for the Path (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lamp for the Path (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lamp for the Path
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 51-minute commentary on Atisha’s Lamp for the Path, Kyabje Rinpoche clarifies the inseparable link between emptiness and dependent origination—and why understanding this prevents the common pitfall of treating emptiness as mere nothingness. He explains that phenomena lack intrinsic, self-sufficient reality but exist through dependent origination: caused by conditions, conceptually interrelated, or designated by the labeling mind. Through detailed analysis of Nāgārjuna’s arguments, he shows how this understanding avoids both nihilism (denying all reality) and absolutism (positing intrinsic existence). He contrasts the Madhyamaka approach, which applies emptiness across all phenomena, with the Mind Only school, which contextualizes the Buddha’s emptiness teachings differently. A rigorous exploration of the philosophical foundations of Buddhist practice.

Flags: []

File metadata (for organising)

File: 9B – Atisha's Melb 2002 May – KR.mp3

UUID: e1b27cfc-8015-4795-a462-c9d2b810116c

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Lamp for the Path

Date: 2002 (exact day not recorded)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~3,156

I shall make clear the difference between skillful means and wisdom. Apart from the perfection of wisdom, all virtuous practices such as the perfection of giving are described as skillful means by the victorious ones. Whoever, under the influence of familiarity with skillful means cultivates wisdom, will quickly attain enlightenment, not just by meditating on selflessness. And then the question is, if one needs to cultivate the wisdom, unified with skillful means, what kind of wisdom must one cultivate? Because generally speaking, there are many different types of wisdoms.

For example, the scriptures speak of the wisdom of understanding the conventional reality, such as the five fields of knowledge, and wisdom understanding the ultimate reality. So here, the text identifies what is meant by wisdom. So we read, understanding emptiness of inherent existence through realizing that the aggregates, constituents, and sources are not produced is described as wisdom. So the question is, if the wisdom realizing the absence of inherent existence of aggregates and so on is the wisdom that needs to be cultivated here. How do we understand this wisdom of emptiness?

So here the text explains that so when we look at aggregates and the constituents and the elements and so on, sources and so on, Do they have origination? Do they come into being from causes? And if so, how can they be said to be devoid of inherent existence? So here, the point being made is that one is not denying that these phenomena, such as aggregates, elements, and sources, and so on, do not possess any origination. And they do not come into being as a result of causes.

Rather, what is being rejected is that their coming into being, their origination is somehow intrinsic to them or somehow possesses an intrinsic existence. For example, when we conventionally make the claims that from such and such cause, such and such effects ensue, from such and such factors, such and such results will come about. When we make such claims, we are making it at the level of conventional reality without probing, without going deeper into the ultimate nature of things. Whereas if we are unsatisfied by the understanding of the operations of cause and effect at the mere level of appearance, at the mere level of conventional truth. If we were to seek for some kind of inherent existence of these cause and effects, then the more we search for it, we will fail to find anything that can really withstand that kind of critical search.

Therefore, this unfindability is described as suggesting the absence of inherent existence. And this mode of looking beyond what we perceive, looking for some kind of ultimate nature of things, ultimate mode of being of things, is described as seeking their ultimate truth or seeking their true mode of being. And this true mode of being is their nature, which is described in the scriptures as emptiness. And the realization of that emptiness is what is meant by wisdom in the context here. So as I explained earlier, that we should not have the notion that somehow there is an isolated emptiness that is independent of everything that exists out there on its own, not dependent upon any object or any basis.

Because when we speak of emptiness, we are speaking about the ultimate nature of things. Therefore, emptiness can only be understood in relation to things and events. So therefore, it has to be always explained on the basis of some objects or some basis. And what is involved here is the quest, is the search to understand whether or not things and events exist in the manner in which we tend to perceive them. So when we are seeking to cultivate the wisdom of emptiness, what we are seeking is to really understand what is the ultimate mode of being of these things.

What is the ultimate nature of these things and events? And therefore, one can never cultivate an understanding of emptiness and divorced from the world of multiplicity. Therefore, Nāgārjuna states in the Fundamentals of the Middle Way, that he says that without depending upon the conventional truth, one will fail to realize the ultimate truth. And also, we find in Śāntideva’s Śikṣāsamuccaya, Compendium of Practices, where when presenting the teaching on emptiness, he provides a profusion of citations from so many different Mahāyāna sutras, all presenting kind of enumeration of lists of various categories of the path and various taxonomy of reality. And then based upon this taxonomy, then he explains the emptiness.

So this is similar to what I said yesterday about, in a sense, what happens is that by presenting all this vast taxonomy, you’re building a kind of an edifice. And then after having done that, then the point is made that all of this are devoid of inherent existence. None of this possess inherent existence. So in a sense, there is a process of dismantling as well. So the point is that what is involved in developing the wisdom of emptiness is the analysis to determine whether or not things and events exist in the manner in which we tend to perceive them, or whether their ultimate mode of being is something that is different from the way in which we tend to perceive them.

And that really is the crux of the meditation on emptiness. So the point is that the basis upon which you are cultivating your understanding of emptiness are things and events which have direct bearing on a sentient being’s experience of pain and pleasure. So these are things whose existence you cannot deny that they are real and they have impact upon one’s experience of pain and pleasure.

And furthermore, in the scriptures, a dependent origination understanding of dependent origination is stated to be the most powerful means of arriving at the knowledge of emptiness. So dependent origination is described as the most powerful proof of emptiness. So what this suggests is that when engaged in the quest for understanding emptiness, and as a result of reductively analyzing aggregates and so on, then we do not when we fail to find some kind of entity that possess intrinsic reality, we do not then arrive at the conclusion. Therefore, it does not exist. We do not draw that conclusion.

But rather, we draw the conclusion that they exist given that they cannot be found when searched through such critical analysis. They must exist only by means of dependent origination. Therefore, a genuine understanding of emptiness must really take place where the moment you reflect upon your understanding of the emptiness of inherent existence, that very understanding will indicate that things exist. So one should feel almost as if when you hear emptiness, you should hear its implication, which is that dependently existing by means of dependent origination. So therefore, a genuine understanding of emptiness is said to be where one understands emptiness in terms of dependent origination.

A similar point can also be found raised in Nāgārjuna’s Precious Garland, where when explaining the emptiness of the person, selflessness of person, he proceeds by explaining how first reductive analysis where he explains how a person is neither the earth element nor the water element, fire element, and so on. And he approaches through this reductive process. And then he, having failed to find person, something called person that is independent of these various elements, nor having failed to find the person to be identifiable as either any of these elements, then he raises the question, if that is the case, where is the person? And then after that, he does not immediately conclude saying, therefore, a person does not exist. Rather, he then immediately brings up the idea of dependent origination.

He says that the person is therefore dependent upon the aggregation of the six elements. And so the point being raised is that person exists. And the person is real. Person undergoes experience of pain and pleasure. And also the elements that constitute a person’s existence, they are also real.

They can impact upon the person’s experience. Now, although they exist, and when we look for them, for example, although the person exists, and when we search for it, amongst the various elements that constitute the individual, which is where one would sort of, in a common sense, one would normally expect to find. Although But it exists, but we fail to find it within the elements where one would expect to find it, then the question is in what manner can we understand its existence? And there Nāgārjuna brings up the concept of dependent origination. He says, we can therefore understand person’s existence only in terms of its dependent origination.

Then having made the point of the dependent origination, he then concludes, therefore, person is devoid of intrinsic existence. So this is an important point where the transition is from the reductive analysis, not failing to find the person, then next is the dependent origination, and then as a result of understanding its dependent origination, then you arrive at the final conclusion that it is devoid of inherent existence. Similarly, in the twenty fourth chapter of Nāgārjuna’s Fundamentals of the Middle Way, we find a question or objection being raised from the Buddhist realists who charge the proponents of emptiness that they are nihilistic. And the question is objection is raised that if things and events are devoid of inherent existence, which means then the wholesome dharma and nirvana too would be devoid of inherent existence. And if this is the case, then essentially what you are saying is that nothing exists.

Everything is empty. So to this objection, Nāgārjuna makes the following response. He says that, such an understanding of emptiness as nothingness, as you present, is a misconception of my view. So the objection is raised that if you maintain that all phenomena are devoid of inherent existence, then this is tantamount to making the assertion that nothing really possesses any existence. Therefore, your view is nihilistic.

To which Nāgārjuna responds by saying that this reflects a misunderstanding of the Madhyamaka’s position. By emptiness, we do not mean mere nothingness. By emptiness, we mean dependent origination. And then he explains that whatever is dependent origination, I assert that to be empty. And that, in turn, I assert to be dependently designated or dependently labeled.

And this I call the middle way, part of the middle way. So the point being made here is that by making the statement that all dependently originated phenomena are devoid of inherent existence. Nāgārjuna is saying that he transcends the extreme of absolutism because he rejects the absolute reality of things. And by stating that these things in event, which are devoid of inherent existence, yet possesses dependent nature, they exist as dependent originations. He transcends the extreme of nihilism.

And thus, this transcendence, this freedom from extremes of nihilism and absolutism represents the true middle way. And having made that identification of the understanding of emptiness as the true middle way, then he goes on to make the following statement. There is nothing whatsoever that is not dependently originated. Therefore, there is nothing whatsoever that is not devoid of inherent existence. Then a question can be raised that if this is the understanding of Nāgārjuna’s understanding of dependent origination, that he accepts nothing whatsoever that is not dependently originated because he accepts nothing whatsoever that possesses inherent existence. Then the question is, does that imply that according to Nāgārjuna, all phenomena, both transient and also permanent phenomena, those that are not conditioned, are they all said to be dependently originated?

Here it is helpful to understand that there are different levels of meaning to the idea of dependent origination. For example, at one level we can understand the notion of dependence in terms of causes and conditions. So this meaning of dependent origination is relevant to the world of causes and effects. So here the dependence is understood in terms of dependence upon causes and conditions. However, this is a second level.

And this understanding of dependent origination will cover only conditioned things. However, there are different levels of another level of understanding of dependent origination where dependence is understood more in terms of mutual dependence. For example, in the case of the mutuality of concepts. For example, when we speak of long and short, there is a mutuality of concepts. Something is posited as long in relation to something.

Similarly, when we look at things, we can understand that thing or an event having part and whole. And whole is constituted by the parts. And parts posited in relation to the whole that is the composite of that. So in this sense, one can understand the entire world, both conditioned and unconditioned, as being dependently originated. Also, there is another level of understanding of dependent origination where dependence is understood more in terms of the subject, of the labeling mind.

For example, when we say something exists and if we were to look for its essence objectively, nothing can withstand that critical probe. And so when we search for whatever it may be, when we search for it objectively, there is nothing whatsoever that really can be referred to as the true referent of that term. And this, however, doesn’t suggest that whatever the mind labels, it becomes real. Of course, the labeling process is there. But also, what is labeled must not be invalidated by another conventional knowledge.

And also, it must not be invalidated by the critical analysis that probes into its ultimate nature. So still, when we label something as something and look for the true referent of this term objectively, there is nothing that really stands out to justify that label that is given to that thing. So, what do we conclude from this is that nothing possesses absolute objective reality. All things the existence of things can be understood and posited only as mere appellations, mere designations, and mere names. So one can therefore see that there are three, broadly speaking, three different levels of meaning to the concept of dependent origination.

So according to Nāgārjuna, the dependent origination really covers the entire spectrum of reality. However, Nāgārjuna’s understanding of emptiness as absence of inherent existence of all things and events is something that is, of course, not accepted by all. For example, yesterday we spoke about the third turning of the wheel of Dharma. And one of the principal texts of that being Samdhinirmochana Sūtra, which is the Sūtra Unraveling the intention of the Buddha, which is one of the primary scriptures for the mind only school. So the mind only school does not accept literally the statements found in the Perfection of Wisdom sutras where there is a categorical negation of inherent existence across the entire spectrum of reality.

And so the mind only school, the followers of mind only school does not accept that this statement should be taken literally. So what they do is they contextualize that statement by differentiating between three natures of phenomena. Designated phenomena, or imputed phenomena, or imputed nature, or the dependent nature, or the perfect nature. And in relation to these three natures, then they contextualize and interpret the Buddha’s statement that all phenomena are devoid of inherent existence. And so they contextualize and differentiate the meanings in relation to different contexts.

Whereas followers of the Middle Way school, the Madhyamaka school, accept that the teachings of the Perfection of Wisdom represent a definitive standpoint and accept this categorical rejection of inherent existence across the entire spectrum of reality. So if one can understand this principle of dependent origination in terms of this mutual dependence of concepts that I spoke about earlier, then there is a certain simplicity to one’s world view. Because one can then posit the existence of things in relation to others. For example, one can then posit define objects in relation to subjects. One can define objects of knowledge in relation to cognitions.

One can define various things in relation to others. Therefore, there will be a certain symmetry and also kind of completeness to one’s world view. And there will be no need to struggle in the way in which such as the mind only school struggles, where in order to verify the existence of objects, they posit a valid cognition. And in order to posit in order to verify the the existence of valid cognitions, then one needs to posit a further faculty called reflexive self-cognition, or this faculty of self cognition and so on. And this kind of problem arises when one fails to recognize the absence of inherent existence across the entire spectrum of reality and makes distinctions between the world of internal consciousness or mind and the world of external objects.

For example, the mind only school denies the reality of the external world of matter and maintains that the internal world of subject, such as consciousness and so on, enjoy a greater reality and accord them some kind of inherent existence. So this is completely contrary to the way in which Madhyamaka understands the nature of the world. And they understand the existence of things in terms of mutual dependence, this concept of dependent origination. Thus they are able to maintain that all things and events, including subject, object, valid cognitions, and their object of knowledge and so on, all things and events are mere designation, mere labels, mere appellations. Also, if one is not able to really understand the world in terms of this principle of dependent origination, and one feels the need to really posit some kind of objective reality to things, then one runs into all sorts of problems.

Yesterday. For example, if we are trying to search for what exactly is the nature of person or the self, then if one engages in this analysis with an underlying belief that there must be a person, something that is objectively real, that should be findable at the end of one’s search, then you are compelled to find all kinds of means of identifying what that objectively real thing, phenomenon would be. For example, in the case of Mind Only School, There was the attempt to identify a person or the self with mental consciousness. And in some cases when the mental consciousness is still found to be too transient, then there was the need to posit another faculty that is supposed to have a much enduring status called the fundamental or foundational consciousness or store consciousness, and so on. On the contrary, if you are comfortable with world view of understanding everything in terms of the principle of dependent origination, then when analyzing the nature of person, one will arrive at an understanding that person is a mere designation that exists in relation to the aggregates that constitute that person’s existence.

Key terms in this teaching

Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
conventional truth samvriti satya (Skt); kun dzob den pa (Tib)
As opposed to ultimate truth, which is the understanding of the ultimate nature of reality (emptiness), conventional truth is what is true to the valid conventional consciousness. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
selflessness of person gang zag gi dag me (Tib)
According to the Prasangika Madhyamaka school, the most subtle view of selflessness of person is the lack of inherent existence of the person or self. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top