51 min · 3,209 words · 2002 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche’s 51-minute commentary on Atisha’s Lamp for the Path opens with a key question: how does the mind transform? Not through imposed rules, but through reflection, understanding, and voluntary discipline that grows from genuine conviction. He teaches two methods—critical analysis and single-pointed absorption—both requiring steady focus on a chosen object. Most of the commentary concerns śamatha, tranquil abiding, the bedrock of Buddhist meditation. What conditions allow it to arise? Solitude, dedicated time, short repeated sessions through day and night, appropriate diet, minimal worldly duties. What blocks it? Mental excitement and laxity—Rinpoche teaches how to identify and counter each. Two meditation methods: visualizing a small Buddha, or turning inward to observe the mind itself as in the Mahāmudrā tradition. The nine stages of mental development gradually extend one’s focus, eventually yielding physical and mental pliancy that marks genuine śamatha. He concludes with why wisdom of emptiness is essential for liberation. For practitioners with foundational Buddhist background.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 9A – Atisha's Melb 2002 May – KR.mp3
UUID: 4a896acd-171d-4971-84d5-512741f81ebc
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Lamp for the Path
Date: 2002 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,205
So when we speak about bringing about transformation of mind, it is something that can take place if we continue to sort of reflect upon whatever the point is and reflect deeply into it, on it, and then try to develop a deep sense of conviction and then ground it upon understanding. And then on the basis of that, then it is possible to voluntarily embrace that discipline upon oneself. And it is through that kind of voluntary embracing of the practice that the transformation can take place. Otherwise, one cannot expect the transformation of mind to take place simply by imposing some kind of discipline or rule from outside. So So as the actual method for bringing about the transformation of mind, this transformation that we spoke about, generally there are two primary methods that are involved.
One is to utilize the critical analysis, the critical faculty to try to analyze things and then try to develop understanding through analysis. So that is one method. And the other method is to, once you have arrived at a certain conclusion as a result of this analytic process, then one should place one’s mind single pointedly upon that conclusion that one has arrived at and maintaining some kind of placing one’s mind absorbed upon this conclusion. So it is through the combination of these two methods, one analysis and the other more of absorption or placement, one should bring about the change and the transformation that we are seeking. So during both of these application of both aspects of these two methods, it is important to maintain one’s focus upon the chosen object of meditation.
Whether it be an analytic meditation, where you are analyzing, where you are applying your analytic faculty upon a chosen object of meditation, or whether you are placing your mind single pointedly upon that arrived conclusion. In both of these cases, it is very important to maintain one’s focus undiverted from the chosen object of meditation. Because if your mind becomes diverted, distracted by some other object extraneous to your own practice, then your mind would not have the strength or the force that it would otherwise have. Therefore, the cultivation of the single pointedness of mind, as explained in the teachings of tranquil abiding, is very important. Generally speaking, as for the object of one’s meditation on tranquil abiding, śamatha, one can choose external objects or internal objects such as one’s mind and so on.
So the object of that tranquil abiding could be anything that one can choose. However, depending upon what kind of meditative process that you engage in, one can describe that object as the object of tranquil abiding or object of penetrative insight or Vipassana. Because if the chosen object upon which when you engage with it, if your engagement is primarily that of analytic, where you are using your analytic faculty, then sort of probing into the deeper nature of it, then your meditation becomes Vipassana or penetrative insight. Whereas if your meditation is primarily focused for cultivating the single pointedness of mind and maintaining that single pointedness of mind, then that meditation is the meditation on tranquil abiding or śamatha. Of course, one can also take emptiness as the object of one’s meditation of both tranquil abiding and a penetrative insight or special insight.
But generally this is the case for practitioners who already have the realization of emptiness. So in the text we find such expressions as seeking meditation by means of the philosophical view, a view of emptiness, or seeking the view by means of meditation. Generally speaking, are both cases where an individual practitioner may have first have gained the realization of emptiness and from there cultivates the single pointedness, a tranquil abiding focused on emptiness. Or there could be instances where the individual practitioner first cultivates the tranquil abiding and then applies that to focus on emptiness. For us, however, for most of us, it is very difficult to first have the realization of emptiness and then seek tranquil abiding focused on it.
Because even we may have quite a deep understanding of, sort of intellectual understanding of the emptiness of inherent existence. And then when we meditate upon it, we may feel as if we are cultivating a single pointedness of mind focused on emptiness. But it is very difficult at the beginner stage to ensure that your ascertainment of emptiness remains vibrant and also firm. Often in the process of cultivating the single pointedness of mind, we tend to lose the vibrancy of our understanding of emptiness. So generally speaking for general practitioners, one must first cultivate the tranquil abiding, seek the view by means of meditation, and then from there learn to apply that faculty of single pointedness onto emptiness.
So we now read from the text from verse 32 onwards, explains first the need for cultivating tranquil abiding. Then also explains the method for doing so. So we read, when those observing the vow of their active altruistic intention have trained well in the three forms of discipline, their respect for these three forms of discipline grows, which causes purity of the body, speech, mind. Therefore, through effort in the vow made by Bodhisattvas for pure, full enlightenment, the collections for complete enlightenment will be thoroughly accomplished. All Buddhas say the cause for the completion of the collections, whose nature is merit and exalted wisdom, is the development of higher perception.
Just as a bird with undeveloped wings cannot fly in the sky, those without the power of higher perception cannot work for the good of living beings. The merit gained in a single day by those who possess higher perception cannot be gained even in a 100 lifetimes by one without such higher perceptions. Those who want swiftly to complete the collections for full enlightenment will accomplish higher perception through effort, not through laziness. Without the attainment of calm abiding, higher perceptions will not occur. Therefore, make repeated effort to accomplish calm abiding.
While the conditions for tranquil abiding are incomplete, meditative stabilization will not be accomplished, even if one meditates strenuously for thousands of years. Thus maintaining well the conditions mentioned in the collections of meditative stabilization chapter place the mind on anyone, virtuous focal object. When the practitioner has gained calm abiding, higher perception will also be gained. But without the practice of perfection of wisdom Sorry, up to this point. Since the achievement of tranquil abiding depends upon whether or not one is successful in gathering the right conditions for its realization, we find in the scriptures various conditions mentioned for the practice of tranquil abiding, such as seeking solitude and also one needs to set aside a specific time for a deliberate, concerted, prolonged practice of single pointedness of mind.
And when you engage in the practice, you should have as many sessions as possible, but very short sessions. And the practice should be undertaken in such a way that there is no break during day and night. So as if there is a whole cycle of short sessions one after another, but many short sessions. And also one needs to do that over a sustained period of time. Whereas the single pointedness of mind, the attainment of achievement of tranquil abiding is not something that is going to occur by practicing single pointedness of mind once in a while when you have the time.
But one needs to set aside a specific time and undertake it over a sustained period of time during that specific period that you have set aside. And in addition, one needs to ensure the right kind of way of life and environment. One needs to make sure that one has as little chores as possible and also as little concerns as possible. And also one needs to maintain a sound ethical discipline. And also dietary conditions also make a big difference.
One needs to ensure that the diet one observes is something that is suitable and appropriate to that kind of sustained cultivation of single pointedness of mind. So the realization of tranquil abiding is something that is not likely to occur through simple practice of single pointedness here and there. For those who are practitioners of Vajrayāna Buddhism, however, in the context of the practice of generation stage, which is the sādhana practice, although generally many of these practices require the practitioners having gained the realization of tranquil abiding before, But also, there is an allowance in these sādhana practices, generation stage practices, where as part of one’s meditation, there are specific means for cultivating a tranquil abiding within the context of the Vajrayāna meditation. And given the various factors that are part of the Vajrayāna meditation practice, it is said that in some cases the realization of tranquil abiding could be easier in the context of Vajrayāna practice. So when actually cultivating tranquil abiding, we need to choose an object of meditation.
And the object of meditation that is required for the practice of tranquil abiding is not something, a visual image at the sensory level, but rather it’s an image that needs to be cultivated at the mental level. So it is not that the actual object of the meditation is not a physical object, but rather the mental image of that physical object, whatever you choose. And therefore, these objects of meditation are sometimes referred to in the scriptures as meditative images or meditative reflections, reflections on the meditation, meditative state of mind. So therefore, one needs to first cultivate the familiarity with the chosen object so that one can call to one’s mind that image at the mental level without having to visually look at the chosen object. So once you have learned to call to your mind the chosen object of meditation, then one needs to make a strong kind of determination that I will retain the focus of my attention on this chosen object.
So with that determination, then you should try to maintain that attention or focus on that chosen object of meditation. So when you are placing your mind onto that object of meditation, then there are two elements that are crucial. One is the ability to retain your attention to the chosen object. The other one is the aspect of clarity and alertness of the mind. So these two needs to be present.
Because if there is no stability or the ability to sustain your focus on the chosen object of meditation, then your mind will be distracted. Your mind will get diverted by some other extraneous thoughts or objects. And on the other hand, even if you may have this ability to sustain your focus, but if there is no clarity, there is no alertness, then the quality of your single pointedness will not have that sharpness. Therefore, it is important to ensure that both these elements are present. The ability to sustain your focus, and this alertness and clarity.
Now, which undermines the ability to maintain your focus is distraction. So therefore distraction is one of the important obstacles, one of the main obstacles for your practice of tranquil abiding, and that which undermines your ability to maintain this clarity of mind and alertness. It is the mental sinking or mental laxity which undermines your ability to remain sharp and alert. Therefore, these two factors, mental excitement and mental laxity, these two are considered to be the most important obstacles, the two most important obstacles to the cultivation of tranquil abiding. Generally speaking, there are other obstacles such as mental scattering and also kind of mental dullness.
But they are gross forms of these obstacles. The two most important obstacles are mental excitement and mental laxity. And therefore, the meditator’s task is to try to identify and develop the sensitivity to really discern the arising of these obstacles within one’s mind. And that can be done mainly on the basis of one’s own personal experience by judging the thought processes in one’s own state of mind, and to really see what is at play within one’s experience. And so one will understand that mental excitement arises when your state of mind is too uplifted.
Sorry, the mental laxity arises when you notice that there is a kind of a degree of relaxedness in your mind. And when the state of your mind is too downcast, then laxity or mental sinking arises. And in order to counter this, you need to try to find a way of uplifting your state of mind, which will then counter mental sinking and laxity or laxity. On the other hand, when your mind is too uplifted, then a mental excitement arises. And then you need to find another means to try to bring that level of upliftedness down to a more kind of sober state.
So it is through this way the meditator needs to find for himself or herself subjectively, and on the basis of one’s own experience, kind of in the right balance so that your mind is neither too excited nor is it too lax so that you have the right balance. And this is something that needs to be done on the basis of one’s own personal experience and through gaining experience of the practice. Generally, for Buddhist practitioners, is actually very beneficial to take, say, the image of the Buddha as one’s object of meditation when cultivating tranquil abiding. And if you do this, it is quite helpful to try to choose an object the right size, not too large, about an inch or two in height. And try to imagine this image to be quite brilliant.
And also a kind of a rather weighty, having some kind of solidity. And then imagine this image of the Buddha in front of you. And then if you choose that as your object of meditation and then focus your mind upon it and cultivate tranquil abiding. And this is most beneficial. It is also possible to cultivate tranquil abiding on the basis of choosing one’s own mind as the object of meditation.
And this is, however, the case. This is the case in practices such as the Mahāmudrā, the great seal tradition, when cultivating tranquil abiding, the main object of meditation is chosen to be one’s own mind. Then here, if you do that, first of all, it becomes necessary to try to get some understanding of this object of meditation, which is your mind. And here, it is not sufficient simply to have a definition of mind. Mind is that phenomenon which is luminous in knowing.
That alone is not sufficient. You must have an experiential sort of understanding of what mind is. And so the question is, how do we cultivate that experiential understanding of mind so that we can use that as an object of meditation on calm abiding and tranquil abiding. So here, one method is to do the following practice, which is to try to see if you can bring about the cessation of all past recollections, all thoughts that are directed and that dwells upon past experiences. And then you try to put an end to that.
And then also, then you try to put an end to any thoughts that are projected into the future, whether it be anticipatory thoughts or fear or whatever it is. And then try to sort of thus clearing away thoughts focused upon past experiences and thoughts projecting onto future, try to maintain that present experience and find that kind of gulf or the gap So you will experience a kind of vacuum. Because normally, in our day to day experience, not only during the active experiences of sensory faculties, even when we don’t have any sort of obvious sensory experiences, our thoughts are always colored by conceptualization. It is almost as if our mind is totally wrapped in layers of conceptualization. So what we are trying to do is to try to see if we can take these layers of the conceptualization away so that we have a kind of almost kind of an experience of the mind as it is.
And this is done by kind of differentiating thoughts as in dwelling onto the past, and thoughts projecting onto future, and trying to sort of grasp that present moment. And this initially may be experienced as a kind of a vacuum, a kind of a gulf with nothing. But this is not the emptiness that we speak about. This is basically an absence of conceptualization that directs onto the past and future. And through prolonged practice and sustained practice, if we can extend that gap, that gulf that we experience, initially it may be a very momentary one, a very fleeting one.
But gradually, as a result of practice, one will be able to extend that experience of the gap or the gulf to sort of more and more longer period, so that eventually, one will get a sense of what is truly meant by luminosity and knowing. And then we choose that as the object of meditation. So, thus as a result of cultivating this meditative absorption, which is described in the scriptures as involving nine stages of mental development. And these nine stages of mental development describes the gradual process through which the practitioner gradually acquires greater and greater ability to sustain one’s focus without distraction. So initially, when one enters a meditation session, one may experience more moments of distraction than more moments of being able to maintain one’s focus upon the object.
However, gradually, as a result of sustained practice, then this situation will change so that at least during the meditation session, one will experience more moments of single pointedness than a distraction. Still, as one pursues further into one’s practice, then one will be able to really refine one’s faculties of mindfulness and faculty of alertness. And these two faculties of meditation practice will become more and more heightened so that they will be able to counter even the arising of subtle levels of mental excitement and mental laxity. So that gradually, as a result of the increase of force of one’s mindfulness and alertness, then one will eventually get to a point where in the meditation session, one may be able to retain one’s focus upon the chosen object undistracted over a long period of time, such as up to three or four hours without distraction. And at that time, the practitioner has reached what is called the ninth stage of mental development.
And as he or she pursues further with the practice, then as a result of this heightened state of meditative absorption, then one eventually experiences a physical and mental pliancy, suppleness of body and mind, giving rise to the blissful experience, at that point, then the person has attained tranquil abiding, śamatha. Then, verse 41, line three, from that point, the text explains the necessity for cultivating the wisdom of emptiness. So we read, but without practice of the perfection of wisdom, the obstructions will not come to an end. Thus, to eliminate all obstructions to liberation and omniscience, the practitioner should continually cultivate the perfection of wisdom with skillful means.
Key terms in this teaching
- generation stage kye rim (Tib)
- The first of the two stages of Highest Yoga Tantra, during which one cultivates the clear appearance and divine pride of one’s chosen meditational deity. LYWA
- insight meditation vipassana (Pali); vipashyana (Skt); lhag tong (Tib)
- The principal meditation taught in the Theravada tradition. It is based on the Buddha’s teachings on the four foundations of mindfulness. It is sometimes called mindfulness meditation. LYWA
- Mahamudra chag ya chen po (Tib)
- The Great Seal; a profound system of meditation upon the mind and the ultimate nature of reality. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.