47 min · 3,149 words · 2002 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Kyabje Rinpoche explains the Three Jewels—Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha—from Atisha’s Lamp for the Path in this 48-minute teaching. He establishes Dharma (the true cessation of afflictions and the path to attain it) as the foundation from which Buddha and Sangha are understood. Buddha became enlightened through compassion, not as an eternally perfect being. The core explores how mental afflictions arise from ignorance about the true nature of phenomena. Unlike physical opposites (heat and cold), mental antidotes work by cultivating directly opposing emotional states—compassion against hatred—both focused on the same object. Rinpoche emphasizes a crucial distinction: positive and negative emotions are not equal. Negative emotions rest on false understanding and cannot develop infinitely, while compassion has infinite potential and stands on valid insight into reality.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 3A – Atisha's Melb 2002 May – KR.mp3
UUID: d2f9b515-890b-49ae-80eb-ccc743681d35
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Lamp for the Path
Date: 2002 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,143
And In the verse of salutation of this text, the object of homage was identified as the Buddha, the Dharma, and Sangha. The Buddha, the teachings, and the spiritual community. So these are the three objects of refuge. And in in Buddhism, they are known as the Three Jewels. The first is the Buddha who is defined as a being who had attained total perfection of all realizations and knowledge, and also total elimination of all the defects and limitations and afflictions of mind and so on.
So so how do we understand such a fully enlightened being? How do we understand the characteristics of such a fully enlightened being? In this respect, it is helpful to reflect upon a text written by the Indian master, Dignāgā, where he in his text on commenting on valid cognitions, he pays homage to the Buddha by pointing out that you who have become a valid being. So this the operative word, the keyword here is the word becoming. The point being made here is that the fully enlightened Buddha, the teacher, was not an eternally enlightened being, but rather someone who has become a valid teacher, someone who has become a fully enlightened.
So this word becoming has a very significant point, which is that the buddhahood come do not come about from from no cause. Buddhahood Buddhahood comes about from causes, and also that it doesn’t come out of come about from causes that are completely discordant with the result. So in other words, that the causes are themselves not permanent, and enlightenment comes about from cause, and it also comes about from causes that are commensurate with the results. And and then then Dignāgā identifies what is that key cause for attaining Buddhahood. And here, cultivation of compassion, the universal compassion, the great compassion is identified as the key factor or the key cause.
So in the salutation to the Buddha made by Dignāgā, he prays to he pays homage to the Buddha as someone who has become a valid teacher, a valid being, an authentic being through the practice of sustained practice of compassion. So so what we see here is that the fully enlightened being had attained that state of enlightenment as a result of a sustained and prolonged practice of compassion and also some of the other associated aspects of the path such as the wisdom realizing emptiness and so on. So the key here is the realizations that the Buddha has attained, which is the true Dharma. And and it is on the basis of the realization of the Dharma we define Sangha and the Buddha because those who are still on the path and had attained the path of seeing and gained direct insight into the ultimate nature of reality, they are the Sangha, true sanghas. And once you proceed in this path and attain a total culmination of this realization, that is the state when you have attained Buddhahood.
So it is on the basis of the Dharma that the other two jewels, the jewel of Sangha and the jewel of Buddha are also defined. So this is how we need to understand the nature and characteristics of the Buddh fully enlightened Buddha on the basis of understanding the nature and characteristics of the true Dharma. In terms of chronology of a particular era, then there is a a sequence between the three in terms of evolution. For example, in the case of the present Buddha, Buddha Śākyamūni, in terms of evolution of the teachings of that Buddha, First, the Buddha Śākyamūni came as a Nirmānakāya, emanation Buddha, and then Buddha then taught the teachings. Initially, the teaching was at the level of scriptural texts.
Therefore, you have the scriptures that are taught by the Buddha. And then on the basis of the scriptures taught by the Buddha, his disciples engaged in the practice and cultivated the realizations of these scriptures, thus evolved the the the Dharma as realization. And then those who have gained realizations of the ārya stage, the path of seeing, those became the Sangha. So within the context of a single era, you can say the Buddha comes first, Dharma comes second, and then Sangha evolves third. Because of this, the order in which we go for refuge or pay homage to the Three Jewels is always Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha.
So it’s because of this we find in the texts when referring to these Three Jewels, the Buddha, Dharma, Sangha, often the metaphor of medicine is used. And so the Buddha is likened to a physician, and the Dharma, the teachings, is likened to the medicine. And the spiritual community, the Sangha, is compared to a nurse. And the one who helps and looks after the patient. So what we understand from this analogy is that it is in fact the Dharma, which is the true medicine .
Sorry. That that directly counters the illness, the ailment. And it is the Buddha who who prescribes the medicine of Dharma and the one’s colleagues, companions on the path, they who are Sangha members, who act as a support while you are going through this process of therapy. Therefore, often the Three Jewels are referred to as Buddha as the true teacher, Dharma as the the the revealed teaching, and Sangha as companions who support you in your practice. So the question is, then what exactly is this Dharma jewel which defines the other two jewels, the Buddha and Sangha?
What are its characteristics? How can we cultivate that within us? Here, we have to understand, as I mentioned earlier, when we speak of the Dharma jewel in the context of Buddhadharma and Sangha, The true Dharma really refers to the true cessation, which is the third noble truth. And cessation here refers to the freedom that an individual gains as a result of applying the antidotes against afflictive emotions and thoughts. Those negative aspects of the mind as a result of applying their corresponding antidotes.
When one gains a kind of a freedom that ensures that prevents their future arising, that is called the cessation. And those cessation can can be of many different levels. And that is the true Dharma. And also the path that leads to that cessation is also the true Dharma. So the true Dharma here refers to the third noble truth, the truth of cessation, and the fourth noble truth, the truth of the path.
Now the question is, if true true Dharma refers to the cessation of the negative aspect of the mind, the afflictions afflictions of thought and emotions, then the question is, what is the process or what is the procedure or what is the mechanism of bringing about such cessation? How can one cultivate the antidotes? How does the antidote work in bringing about the cessation of these negative aspects of of our mind? Here, one has to understand that in in according to Buddhism, of course, our very existence as conditioned existence itself is understood to be characterized by suffering. It is referred to as, in fact, the pervasive suffering of conditioning.
Present existence. Our present existence as a conditioned being is understood to be suffering. This is the third level of suffering, suffering of pervasive conditioning. So in this sense, yes, including our physical embodiment, our physical body is in a sense, in the nature of suffering, something that needs to be ultimately gotten rid of, something that needs to be ultimately eliminated. But in Buddhism, when we speak of our very existence as suffering, we’re not referring to we’re not implying that the mere physical existence or mere bodily existence is suffering.
For example, from the Buddhist point of view, even the Buddha Śākyamūni is seen as an embodied being. However, Buddha Śākyamūni is free of suffering. And also the Arhats who have gained freedom from negative emotions and thoughts, they also have the aggregates, the Skandhas. So what is being referred to as suffering is this conditioned existence. Condition our exist present existence conditioned by karma and delusions or karma and and afflictions.
So at the root of our conditioned existence are the causes which are the karma and the afflictions. And karma here refers to an action, an individual individual’s act, whether positive or negative. So when we speak of action, a human or a sentient being’s action, it automatically implies an agency, a motive behind, an intention. So so the acts themselves are again not the primary cause. The primary cause again is what lays behind, what motivates them, what propels these actions.
So here we’re talking about intentions, the world of intentions, the world of thoughts and emotions. So underlying many of our karma, particularly the the negative ones, are lot of afflicted states of mind. So ultimately, what we arrive at at the root of our suffering really is these afflictions, affliction afflictive thoughts and emotions. And so in in Buddhism, they are called or klesha. And the very etymology of klesha suggests that they are states of mind whose very occurrence brings about disturbance within within the individual.
And and these are the ones that defile one’s thoughts and emotions, one afflicts individual from within. And it is that those afflictions which lie at the root of our suffering, and it is those afflictions that need needed to be eliminated by applying their direct antidotes. Now the question is, how does the the the antidotes work when countering these afflictions? So here, these afflictions do not go away simply by making prayers, saying prayers, or wishing them away. These afflictions needed to be eliminated by cultivating their corresponding remedies or antidotes.
And how does this antidote, this process of applying the antidote work? Here you can observe the physical world. For example, in the physical world you have we can contrast, say, hot heat and coldness in temperature. And if you are suffering from too much heat, by increasing the coolness of the temperature, you can counter that, you can bring that down. And if you are suffering from the effects of a too cold temperature, then you increase the thermostat and adjust it so that you counter it.
So even in the physical world, you can see instances where opposing forces counter each other. Similarly, we can take another metaphor of, say, light and darkness. They oppose each other. The moment you switch on the light, the darkness is dispelled. When there is darkness, there is no light.
So there is a kind of an instantaneous relation, kind of dichotomy between the two. So however, in the world of internal emotions and thoughts, the process in which antidotes work against its you know, opposing forces is slightly different. Here, we need to cultivate in order to counteract something. We need to cultivate the right state of mind which directly opposes that particular affliction, where the way in which it does is by by focusing on the same object, but by cultivating directly opposite way of engaging with it. For example, you have hatred and you have compassion or love.
In the case of hatred and compassion, they are two different emotions, but they can be focused at a single object, an individual or a being. And then based on that, one, when you when you experience hatred or anger, you have kind of a very hostile experience or hostile feeling or attitude towards that object. On the other hand, if you have compassion towards that particular object, it’s the same object, but your attitude and your feeling towards that object is of a different kind. The phenomenological experience is of a different kind. And in fact, one could say that by reinforcing one side, you can automatically and naturally decrease the force of the other.
For example, for the sake of argument, say there is an individual who wishes to who who disliked compassion, who wishes to decrease whatever remnants of compassion there might be in him or her, then in such a case, the individual can most effectively do this by deliberately cultivating hostile attitude towards the object and try to cultivate and try to see the the downside of cultivating compassion, try to see the disadvantages of, you know, cultivating loving kindness and so on. And through this way, one could envision envision that the the the anger and hatred can be increased. However, for a spiritual practitioner, that is not the goal because anger brings the individual harm. It brings disturbance. It it brings affliction.
Therefore, from a from a spiritual perspective of a spiritual practitioner, anger and hatred are something that needs to be dispelled, that needs to be relinquished. While compassion and loving kindness is something that needs to be deliberately cultivated because it brings peace and it brings benefit and help. So this is how the antidotes work in decreasing and eventually eliminating the opposing forces. Yeah. Sorry.
And this is so this is how when we speak of practicing the the teachings of the Buddha, when we speak of engaging in the Dharma practice and what is the what is the actual process, the dynamic in which the practice of Dharma works in countering our negative emotions and thoughts. This is how it is where when deliberately cultivating the the corresponding antidotes to the negative emotions and thoughts. So one can ask the question that if in the case of two opposing states of mind and two opposing emotions such as hatred on the hatred on the one hand and compassion on the other. If it is the case that by reinforcing one, one automatically diminishes the force of the other, then the question can be raised. Does that mean that there is total symmetry between the true, that there is total equality, absolute equality, that there is no difference at all by, you know, reinforcing hatred, one can completely eliminate, compassion.
And by reinforcing compassion, one can eliminate, hatred. If that is the case, is there no difference between the two? Here, it is important to have a deeper understanding of the contrast between positive emotions like compassion and loving kindness on the one hand and negative emotions like hatred and anger and attachment and so on the other. Generally speaking, if you look at the Buddhist understanding of what is meant by klesha, afflictions, broadly speaking, we observe two general categories of afflictions. On the one side, there are afflictions which tend to be instinctual such as attachment, such as anger, such as hostility.
These are although in certain circumstances, there might be some immediate catalyst which may where reason may some kind of projection and reason may play a role, but generally these emotions are more reactive, more instinctual and impulsive. So that’s one category of emotions which are more impulsive and and instinctual. Then there are there is another category of emotions which tend to be much more cognitive. Here you have the the view the the false view of a sense of selfhood. And also the false view of grasping certain extremist view as being authentic or valid.
So these are although afflictions, but they are more cognitive. They are more in the category of intellect. And in fact, this second category of afflictions are sometimes referred to also as afflicted intelligence because they are they have a much greater role of reasoning involved in them. So this is generally the Buddhist understanding of two broad classes of of afflictions. However, if you look at deeper, you will understand that if you look at the the nature of these emotions, the gross levels of emotions such as extreme hostility and anger and so on, they at the root of them is a subtler emotion, which is the delusion and particularly the the delusory mind grasping at some kind of real existence of things.
And here, we find a deeper understanding of the nature of these afflictions in the Madhyamaka writings. For example, in the Four Hundred Verses on the middle way, we find the passage where the author states that just as the bodily faculty permeates all the other sense sense sensory faculties, in the same way, delusion underpins all afflictions. So the point being made here is that when you examine carefully experience of a strong affliction like anger or attachment, you will see that underlying it is a cause which is some kind of grasping onto a particular object, whether it be deemed desirable or whether it be deemed undesirable. And depending upon how you perceive that, then there is it gives rise to an emotional response or reaction. So at the gross level, delusion serves as a cause for the occurrence of these afflictions.
However, at the subtle level, and in fact, the author of the Four Hundred Verses suggests that in fact, delusions are delusions exist as a kind of a as as coexist delusions coexist with the with the afflictions themselves. Just as the body organ permeates all the sensory faculties in the same way this delusion grasping at true existence of things really underpins all the afflictions. So and in fact, one can say that the the afflictions the arising of afflictions are dependent upon this grasping at true existence of things. So this delusionary mind grasping onto the true existence of things is, in fact, it’s it’s it’s distorted because the the the real nature of things is emptiness. However, this delusionary mind grasps onto them as having some kind of real existence or true existence.
In contrast, if you look at a positive emotion like loving kindness, although there are cases where delusionary grasping onto an object as true existence may give rise to or support loving kindness or compassion, but the arising of loving kindness and compassion is not dependent upon grasping onto the object as having some kind of true existence. In fact, loving kindness is an emotion that can be developed to an infinite potential. Whereas negative emotions like anger and hatred, because their underlying root is a distorted state of mind. They do not have any valid support or any valid ground in both reason and reality. So and because of this, by cultivating a direct insight into the true nature of things, which is emptiness, one will be able to penetrate through the delusion of this misunderstanding of reality as having some kind of true existence.
And through this way, one can eventually eliminate undercut the very basis of the arising of these afflictions. So certainly, there is a a vast difference between a positive emotions like loving kindness and compassion on the one hand and negative emotions like anger, hatred, and attachment on the other in terms of their sustainability and also in terms of their potential for infinite development.
Key terms in this teaching
- Buddhadharma
- The teachings of the Buddha. LYWA
- loving kindness maitri (Skt); yi ong jam pa (Tib)
- In the context of the seven points of cause and effect, the wish for all beings to have happiness, with the added dimension of yi ong (beautiful or affectionate)... LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- nirmanakaya emanation body; tul ku (Tib)
- The emanation body of a buddha that manifests in a variety of forms for sentient beings. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- sentient being sem chen (Tib)
- Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.