50 min · 2,965 words · 2002 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 51-minute teaching on Atisha’s Lamp for the Path, Kyabje Rinpoche unpacks the Three Jewels by starting with the root of all afflictions: delusion—a fundamental misconception about how things exist. He traces how grasping at independent, true existence contradicts dependent origination, moving through different Buddhist schools’ views of selflessness to the Madhyamaka position that the self is mere designation. The heart of the teaching is the gap between reality and perception: all phenomena arise interdependently, yet our minds grasp them as independent, generating attachment, aversion, and ignorance. The wisdom of no-self directly counters this delusion. Rinpoche then connects this philosophy to the possibility of liberation, Buddha-nature, and the four kayas, grounding going-for-refuge in understanding one’s own inner path to enlightenment.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 3B – Atisha's Melb 2002 May – KR.mp3
UUID: 1a4eda9c-3c4f-4997-b32e-b537d15a0c2e
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Lamp for the Path
Date: 2002 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,964
So the question is if underlying all the afflictions is this delusion which really underpins them, how do we on what grounds do we understand this delusion to be this grasping at the true existence of things? Here we go back to the Four Hundred Verses of the Middle Way where immediately after the verse that I cited, Āryadeva writes that it is by gaining insight into the truth of the dependent origination one will bring about the cessation of delusion. So the point being made here is that he is saying that if when the individual develops deep insight into subtle aspects of the teachings on dependent origination, then he or she will bring about the cessation of the delusion. So here the delusion is being identified or defined as a misconception or a state of mind which perceives the world and the self in contrary to the principle of dependent origination. Because according to the principle of dependent origination, all things come into being as a result of dependence upon other factors.
And so it’s the opposite of that would be to accord status of independence and independent existence to things and events. Because if things possess independent status, if things possess independent existence, then of course they cannot have the nature of dependence upon others. And this status, this projected status of independence is what is being referred to as self in the context of the teaching on selflessness. And so the teaching on by teaching selflessness what is being taught is the absence of the independent existence of things because all things come into being as a result of depending upon other causes and conditions or other factors. Sorry.
So the aryadeva concludes by saying that whatever is dependently originated Āryadeva concludes by saying that that which is dependently originated cannot possess the nature of independence. And this absence of independent existence is what I call dependent origination. As to whether or not this delusion grasping on to things and events as possessing true existence. Whether or not this is considered to be a defilement of the category of afflictions or subtle objects, subtle obstructions to knowledge, among the Nāgārjuna’s disciples, there is a divergence of opinion on this. On the one hand are such commentators of Nāgārjuna like Bhāvaviveka who understood this delusion, this grasping at true existence of things to be a subtle obstruction to knowledge rather than a defilement of affliction while based upon Nāgārjuna’s own 70 stanzas on the middle way, there were other commentators of Nāgārjuna who maintained that it is actually part of the afflictions, afflicted states of mind.
And they argued that even to attain the state of arhathood, which is freedom from saṃsāra, cyclic existence, one needs to eliminate this grasping at true existence. And it is on the basis of that understanding then the assertion is made that the insight into emptiness is the sole path to liberation. There is no second path other than second path or second door other than the wisdom of no self, wisdom of selflessness. And here the wisdom of selflessness or no self is understood in terms of what is called the three doors to liberation or three doors to thorough liberation where the the insight into the emptiness of things and events is cultivated on the basis of understanding its nature from the point of view of its causes and from the point of view of its effects as well. So when speaking about this teaching on the no self and understanding of selflessness, here we need to relate back to the teachings of the four noble truths in the first public sermon that the Buddha gave.
When the Buddha taught the four noble truths, he taught them in terms of 16 characteristics of the four noble truths, four in relation to each. And the four characteristics of the first noble truth of suffering are impermanence, unsatisfactoriness, and emptiness, and no self. So all the different schools of Buddhism, all the followers of the Buddha in one way or another understand the key teaching of the Buddha to be embodied in this teaching on no self or anātman, no self or absence of selfhood. Of course, there are divergent interpretations as to what that no self means. In fact, if you look at the history of philosophical thought in India, we see a very long tradition of analysis on this nature of selfhood, nature of the individual, nature of being.
The fact that when we experience pain and pleasure, there’s the question of who is it that experiences it? Who is it that undergoes that experience? When we speak of accumulating karma, who is it that accumulates the karma? Who is it that who is the agent of the karmic act? When we speak of experiencing the fruits fruits of one’s karma, again the question is who is it that experiences the fruits of karma?
The fact that there is an individual, there is a being that we label as I, I am, is something that is commonly accepted. But the question is what exactly is the nature of that self? What exactly is the nature of that being? Here we see a very long tradition in ancient India in the analysis of what that nature of nature is, nature of the being or the person is. On the whole, among the non Buddhist schools in India, especially those schools which accept the idea of rebirth, on the whole, there was a kind of a convergence of opinion that since physical body is contingent upon a particular life and it’s transient, when the life ceases, a particular life ceases, the physical body of that individual being also comes to an end.
Therefore, self cannot be identified with the body, bodily existence and therefore on the whole the non Buddhist schools maintain that we must the self must be something that is completely independent of the physical and psychological constituents that make up that individual’s existence. There must be a self, must be an eternal principle that is enduring and that transcends individual life cycles that maintain its continuum in an eternal temporal stages. And whether or not they will characterize it as eternal, unchanging and unitary, but in the belief in this kind of self or ātman, if you probe deeper, these three key characteristics are thought to be the main characteristics of this self that it is temporarily speaking eternal, that it is unitary, indivisible, and that it is independent or in some sense self governing. And this is what is called the ātman, the self. And on the whole, all Buddhist schools reject that kind of notion of selfhood, that kind of notion of eternal self.
However, within Buddhism, there are the schools have divergent opinion as to if that kind of self cannot be posited, then how do we understand the notion of person? How do we understand the agency? Who is it that being? Here, among the Buddhist schools and there are some schools who try to identify the person or the self on the basis of the physical and the mental aggregates that make up the individual. For example, some schools maintain that it’s the totality of the five skandhas that is the being, that is the self or that is the person.
Others maintain that it is on the basis of the continuum of consciousness that one must posit the individual being or the person. And there are others like the mind only school which maintain that it is Alāyavijñāna. No, sorry. The followers of the scripture of the Yogacāra, the mind only school where they maintain that it is not just mental consciousness, but rather there is a unique continuum of consciousness called the foundational consciousness which really is must be identified as the person. Then there are the followers of Nāgārjuna, particularly those who understand it to be Nāgārjuna’s ultimate standpoint, they maintain that any attempt to identify self as something that is independent of the body and mind is untenable.
Then the question is how do you explain the relationship between the self and the transient body and mind. So that is untenable. Equally untenable is the attempt to identify self within the body and mind. So the followers of Nāgārjuna, particularly those who take the Nāgārjuna subtle view, they maintain that both these dichotomies identifying self as independent of the body and mind and identifying the self to be either one of the aggregates of the body or mind that is also problematic. So the self or the person must be understood only as a kind of a label, an appellation, a designation that is given on the basis of the aggregation of the mind and body and so we must understand the the nature of self or the person to be mere designation, something that is that has no absolute or intrinsic reality.
So if we observe things and events sort of more deeply, we will recognize that all things and events really come about as a result of aggregation of many factors. They are dependent upon many factors for their existence, that none of them enjoy any independent existence, that all things and events, their ultimate nature is mere dependence upon other factors. However, when we perceive them, when we observe them, somehow we tend to get the impression that they possess some kind of discrete independent realities of their own. We do not perceive things and events to be in this kind of interconnected, dependently originating reality. We tend to see them as each having its own independent, discreetly identifiable kind of units.
So what we see here is a gulf between the way things really are and the way we perceive them. And it is this disparity between our perception of the world and the reality of things that really underpins the various afflictive and emotional responses that we have in our dealing with with with the world. So, therefore, this suggests that the basis, the root of many of the afflictions such as anger, hatred, attachment, and so on is a distorted state of mind. It’s a distorted understanding of the world. And so the first, root of the afflictions is this distorted state of mind.
Secondly, and this understanding of this perception of world as having some kind of independent reality is groundless. It has no valid grounding. And thirdly, when one cultivates the direct antidote which is the wisdom of no self, then this wisdom of no self will directly counter this misconception of the world as having some kind of true and independent existence. So when you compare the two, this false view of the world opposed to the insight into no self. One has a very valid grounding in both experience and reason.
The other lacks valid grounding in both reason and experience. So because of this, when you compare the two and let them compete with each other, obviously the force that has valid grounding in experience and reality will be will as a result of cultivating it, as a result of developing it, and and reinforcing it, eventually you will get to a point where one will be able to totally eliminate this false view of the world. And furthermore, this insight into the no self, the wisdom of no self, because it is a quality of mind, its basis is very enduring. It’s not a characteristic like a bodily quality whose basis is limited whereas it’s a mental quality whose basis is very enduring in terms of its continuum. Therefore, another characteristic of the mental quality is that once you cultivate it to a point where it becomes spontaneous, then further development, you do not need to make an extra deliberate conscious effort to bring it to your mind.
A simple catalyst or impetus can immediately give rise to that kind of understanding or that’s that kind of mental quality to arise in you. So when you compare all of these points together, then and also when you understand that the afflictions are separable from the essential nature of mind, that they are removable because their basis is distorted state of mind and by removing this distorted state of mind, afflictions can be removed. So when you compare all of these points together, then eventually you will get to a point where the word liberation or moksha will really make have some profound meaning for you, you will also get a sense that yes, liberation is possible. And this is what is meant by liberation. So when you understand that liberation is possible, then you can extend that and then combine that understanding with the understanding of Buddha nature explained such in as the Tathāgatagarbha Sūtra that I referred to earlier, where the essential nature of mind is described as luminous, mere luminosity, that it is unpolluted and it’s mere luminosity.
And so when you understand this, then you will also come to realize that not only are the afflictions removable, but also the propensities and imprints left by these afflictions in us can also be removable. Because if the afflictions themselves can be eliminated, then of course the propensities for these afflictions and also the imprints left by these afflictions can also be eliminated. And through this way, you will get an understanding of the possibility of liberation. So in this way, one also understand the possibility of attaining Buddhahood, which is the total elimination of including not only the afflictions but also their propensities and imprints. So when we speak of the resultant state of Buddhahood, in the bodhisattva scriptures, the Mahāyāna scriptures, state of Buddhahood is defined described in terms of state of the four embodiments or full enlightenment or the four kayas.
And the understanding of the four kayas, the most profound and more detailed understanding of the four kayas can be developed on the basis of reading and studying the Vajrayāna texts where the understanding of the four kayas is presented on the basis of the subtle mind, the fundamental innate mind of clear light. And here the emptiness of the fundamental innate mind of clear light at the state of Buddhahood, that is described as the the natural embodiment of the Buddha. And the omniscient mind of the of the Buddha at that state is described as the wisdom dharmakaya, the wisdom truth body. And and the subtle energy or the prana which is inseparable from this Buddha’s dharmakaya state, the subtle energy in its most subtle form is explained as Sambhogakāya, the Buddha body of perfect resource. And when that subtle energy assumes a form that is visible to that is at the level of more visibility and grosser level, that embodiment of the Buddhahood is described as Nirmāṇakāya, the Buddha body of perfect emanation.
So we can see that the Vajrayāna explanation of the four kayas explanation is done on the base all in terms of the understanding of the fundamental innate mind of clear light. So with this, we if we if we think along these lines, then we will get a deeper understanding of what is meant by Dharma. And on the basis of Dharma, how we understand the Buddha who is the example of the total perfection of the Dharma or total realization of the Dharma and the Sangha which is those who are on the path of realization of the Dharma. So this is how on the basis of the the first verse of this text, the verse of salutation to the three jewels, that one can in fact, gain a general introduction to what is meant by Buddha Dharma. Mhmm.
So it is important for us who consider ourselves as practicing Buddhists to have these understandings so that when we go for refuge to the Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha and recite Buddham Sharanam Gacchami, Dhammam Sharanam Gacchami, Sangham Sharanam Gacchami. I go for refuge to the Buddha. I go for refuge to the Dharma. I go for refuge to the Sangha so that we know we have a a certain understanding of the object of our going for refuge. So that by cultivating a deep admiration, by reflecting upon the qualities of the Buddha.
We go for refuge to the Buddha of the past, the historical Buddhas and so on. And also cultivating a deep conviction and faith in their qualities and attainment, one goes for refuge to them. But also it is important to understand that one’s going for refuge to the three jewels must be related to one’s own inner realizations and experience of the path. So that when you go for refuge in your faith, there is also a faith of emulation. You not only do you have admiration for the three jewels, but also you emulate the examples so that you aspire for yourself the realization of the three jewels.
So derived through such kind of faith of emulation and then one engages in the path and cultivates within oneself all the various levels of realizations beginning from the minute levels of the path and so on. And then as a result of attaining the true path within oneself, one attains cessation which then makes the individual to be a Sangha, ārya Sangha, noble Sangha. And then as a result of continuing in one’s path, when the individual finally culminates in his or her realization, then one attains the state of Buddhahood. So in this way, one should be able to not only understand the act of going for refuge in relation to a historical or past Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, but also to one’s own resultant future Buddha, Dharma, and Sangha.
Key terms in this teaching
- anatman dagme (Tib)
- No-self; as opposed to atman (self); the term used for selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- clear light ö sel (Tib)
- The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- four kayas catuhkaya (Skt); ku zhi (Tib)
- The classification of a buddha’s body into four: jnanakaya (wisdom body), svabhavikakaya (nature body), sambhogakaya (enjoyment body) and nirmanakaya (emanation body). LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.