50 min · 2,986 words · 2002 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 50-minute commentary on Atisha’s Lamp for the Path, Kyabje Rinpoche presents Nāgārjuna’s three principal factors for enlightenment: bodhicitta (altruistic intention), compassion with responsibility, and wisdom of emptiness. He outlines the Buddhist path structure across five paths, ten bodhisattva levels, and three innumerable eons, then addresses a central discouragement: Why undertake this lengthy bodhisattva path when Vajrayāna promises faster attainment? Using Nāgārjuna’s Precious Garland, he explains that bodhicitta itself becomes the engine for all progress, fulfilling both immediate and ultimate aims. Drawing on his own teenage doubts and Kadampa masters’ teachings, Rinpoche shows how dedicated practitioners transcend the time factor through their commitment to others’ welfare. Pitched at serious Buddhist practitioners.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 5A – Atisha's Melb 2002 May – KR.mp3
UUID: 951d2a66-21fd-4ff8-af62-eee378c0c4ba
Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche
Collection: Lamp for the Path
Date: 2002 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~2,986
Great teacher Nāgārjuna, who is in fact considered as the second teacher in this era of Buddha Śākyamūni’s teachings, he states in his precious garland, Ratnāvali, that those who aspire to attain the state of full enlightenment, they must seek the three principal factors for the attainment of such realization. And these three principles, he says that anyone who aspires to attain the full enlightenment must seek its means, seek its causes, the correct causes. And what are these correct causes? He identifies three principal factors. The first is bodhicitta, which is the altruistic aspiration to attain Buddhahood for the benefit of all beings.
Thus, the generation of that altruistic intention is one principal cause. And however, this principle cause, which is the altruistic aspiration to attain Buddhahood for the benefit of all beings, is rooted in the compassion, great compassion, which he describes as compassion with infinite compassion. Infinite here referring to the infinity of the number of sentient beings to or for whom one cultivates the wish to be free of suffering. And sentient beings are said to be infinite, equal to the expanse of space. So one needs to cultivate compassion, not only wishing the other sentient beings to be free of suffering, but in fact, a more powerful compassion which has a sense of responsibility or commitment involved in it where not only does the not only do you wish others to be free of suffering, but in fact would shoulder upon oneself the responsibility to bring about that freedom from suffering.
So this is the second principle cause. And then the third principal cause that he identifies is he calls it the nondual wisdom. Nonduality here referring to the wisdom of emptiness, which is which transcends the the two extremes of absolutism and nihilism. So it is the the wisdom that penetrates into the ultimate nature of reality, the way things really are, which is described as suchness or the ultimate nature of reality. And So we find in the bodhisattva scriptures the process of the path that is the process that is involved in attaining full enlightenment described as being a very long process.
And it is described in terms of the 10 bodhisattva bhūmis, the 10 bodhisattva levels, and also in terms of within the framework of the five paths. So and this whole process begins from the instant the individual practitioner generates, gains a realization of genuine bodhicitta, the altruistic intention. And this altruistic intention, so for an intelligent practitioner, a practitioner with a higher cognitive faculty, he or she begins the path first by cultivating the wisdom of emptiness, and the wisdom of no self, or wisdom of emptiness. And this wisdom of emptiness, this wisdom realizing emptiness, then gives rise to realization of great compassion towards all sentient beings. And this compassion that aspires other to be free of suffering then gives rise to a sense of responsibility, a sense of commitment to bringing about that release of other sentient beings from the suffering.
So this is called the extraordinary attitude or extraordinary sense of responsibility, which then culminates in the realization of bodhicitta, the altruistic intention. So at that instant, the individual has become a bodhisattva. The individual has entered the first of the five paths, which is known as the path of accumulation. And and then as he or she progresses on that path and deepens his or her realization of emptiness, that individual will reach a point where the understanding of emptiness does not remain merely at the level of the intellect, but in fact, acquires a meditative experiential dimension. And at that point, the understanding of emptiness becomes derived from meditation rather than derived from understanding.
And that is the point when individual has entered the second path, which is the path of preparation or a path of linking. And then, as he or she progresses further, deepening the insight into emptiness, then we’ll reach a point where the experience of emptiness becomes direct. The realization of emptiness becomes direct and no longer cognitive or conceptual. It becomes direct. At that point, the person has entered the third path, which is the path of seeing.
And also the individual has attained the first bodhisattva level, the bodhisattva level. And then from the second bodhisattva level onwards, the individual attains the path of meditation. And then within the 10 bodhisattva bhūmis, the levels, the first seven are referred to as the impure levels, where the individual is still not free from afflictions and the defilements. And then the last three, the eighth, ninth, and tenth, are described as the pure bodhisattva levels. And it is through this process the individual, from the moment of generation of bodhicitta, goes through the process and reaches the highest stage.
So and these stages are also they correspond to period of accumulation of merits. And in the bodhisattva scriptures, it is said that attainment of Buddhahood requires accumulation of merits over a period of three innumerable eons. So the period of path of accumulation and path of preparation or path of linking constitutes the first innumerable eon. And then the first seven bodhisattva bhūmis, the impure bodhisattva levels, constitutes the second innumerable eon of accumulation. And then the final three levels of bodhisattva bhūmis corresponds to the accumulation of the last of the last eon, innumerable eon.
And in fact, it is said that this attainment of Buddhahood during the period of three innumerable eons is said to be, in fact, a faster framework. Because in some scriptures, there’s also mentions of attaining Buddhahood as a result of 30 odd innumerable eons and 40 odd innumerable eons and and so on. So the the point being made is that the attainment of enlightenment, attainment of Buddhahood is not a matter of an instantaneous event. Although in some Vajrayāna texts, there are references to attainment of Buddhahood within a single instance. For example, there is a passage which says that by whose kindness one attains the Buddhahood within a single instance and so on.
So sometimes people may get the impression that there might be some special practice that if you enter into a meditation session, and then during that meditation session by within a single instant, like saying reciting the mantra, whom something happens and you come out of the session fully enlightened, that is however not the case. And that is a very unrealistic expectation because the the Buddhahood is a process that involves a transformation of our mental continuum. And our mental continuum a continuum of our mental state of mind, which is, one could almost say, permeated in sort of through and through with the pollutants of the afflictions. And that pollution of the affliction needs to be gradually removed layer after layer, which is a gradual process. And it is through this gradual process the one’s mental continuum becomes more and more purified, more and more refined, eventually culminating in the attainment of Buddhahood.
Then the question might be raised that if the attainment of Buddhahood takes such a long period of time, then one might get the impression that, oh, this is too much. One might feel discouraged. Here, it is worth reflecting upon some of the passages we find in Nāgārjuna’s Precious Garland, where Nāgārjuna says that the length of the period time that takes in attaining Buddhahood should not be any grounds for discouraging the practitioner or any grounds for making one feel kind of exhausted or kind of incapacitated. He said that in fact, if the person, the practitioner is such that he or she possesses the skillful method and also the wisdom and union of the two, then the time factor should not make any difference to his or her sense of commitment and endeavor. And he compares to our day to day experience.
He says that if we are undergoing a painful experience, then generally, it is the case that even that period may be very short for us, for the individual, that you know, because of the painfulness of the experience, it feels as if it is very long. In contrast, if the experience is pleasurable and pleasant, then even if the process the the period that the experience is taking place is very long, that you know, we feel as if it it was too short. So that is generally the case. If this is so, then he says that for a genuine practitioner who possesses both a method of the skillful method, which is the compassion and bodhicitta, and the union of that with the wisdom, realizing, emptiness, then at the initial stage, at the beginner stage, although the practitioner may encounter painful experiences at the physical level, may experience pain and suffering and so on, but given the strength of his or her inner realization, one can endure the hardships that are entailed. And as he or she progresses further, then at a certain level of realization, that individual practitioner becomes invulnerable to physical hardships pain and so And if that is the case, then the person no longer feels pain and suffering.
And therefore, when he or she is engaging in the path towards attainment of Buddhahood, then time should not make any difference to the individual because there is no experience of pain. So that is one reason. Another reason he says that furthermore, the the bodhisattva practitioners are individuals who have dedicated their entire being for the benefit of other sentient beings. For example, Nāgārjuna expresses the sentiments in his precious garland that may I be like like the earth, like the like the great elements, like the earth, water, fire, and and so on. May I be may all parts of my being be of service to other sentient beings.
And similarly, we find in Śāntideva’s guide to the Buddhist Way of Life, Bodhicaryāvatāra, where he expresses the sentiment that for as long as space remains, for as long as sentient beings remain, may I too remain, until then may I too remain and dispel the sufferings of the beings. So if one can understand these sentient beings properly, then one will understand that the practitioner, a bodhisattva practitioner, is someone who has dedicated his or her entire life, entire being, for a sole purpose. That is to bring about others’ well-being and serve others. And if that is the case, then the the period that the time it takes to become fully enlightened, again, has no relevance. Because even whether even if the person is fully enlightened, the only task that will remain is is to serve other sentient beings, which the practitioner is doing anyway while he or she is on the path.
So furthermore, when he or she is engaged in the path and uses his or her dedicates his or her entire being for the service of the other sentient beings, then in a sense, one is fulfilling the pledge that one has made when generating the bodhicitta, the altruistic intention, and also when taking the Buddhist vows. And one is living the the the pledge that one has the the ideal that one has adopted and the pledge that one has accepted. And when you think along these lines, then you will understand that, you know, this notion of someone who’s working for others’ well-being, but somehow he or she has some other sort of interest called self interest is in fact quite in fact false because the only task that he or she has is the service of others, is is bringing about the well-being of the sentient beings. So in these ways, Nāgārjuna explains that the the time that involved in the attainment of Buddhahood really has no relevance so far as the practitioner is concerned. Yeah.
Could you just wait? Sorry. So if we understand this point clearly, then we will avoid the following danger, which is that sometimes there may be a tendency that if when a practitioner hears sort of rather attractive sort of, you know, statements like doing a three year retreat and three month retreat. And, you know, and then giving the impression that somehow after I come out of this three year retreat that I will be enlightened or I will be you know, I will have attained great realizations. So when someone hears that one sort of immediately kind of raises up one’s ears, extends one’s ears, and becomes interested and shows tremendous enthusiasm.
But when one hears the bodhisattva scriptures, description of attainment of buddhahood requiring an effort over a period of three innumerable eons, then somehow sort of your interest kind of diminishes. So that danger will be avoided. In fact, I have I I similarly had this feeling when I was in my teens. Once, I remember very clearly when I was in my teenage at a teaching session with my teacher, Tathag Rinpoche. I made the remark to Tatha Rinpoche that having looked at the bodhisattva scriptures, the sutras, I feel as if the process or path that is entailed in described in the sūtra system is so long that it seems almost impossible.
So probably the Vajrayāna path where there is an explanation of the possibility of attaining Buddhahood within a much shorter period may be more suited to me. And Tatha Rinpoche was immediately sort of he responded back by saying, how can there be a viable Vajrayāna path without the practice of bodhicitta, without the practice of altruistic intention? And I remember that reply to this day very clearly. Also, Nāgārjuna states in the Precious Garland that if an individual practitioner or if we strive to cultivate the bodhicitta with all our efforts, and if we dedicate all our efforts into the generation of this altruistic intention within us, and also the compassion for all sentient beings, then through this dedication in our cultivation of these altruistic ideals within us, and and live according to those ideals, then we will gain a sense of deep satisfaction that, yes, I have now fulfilled the purpose of my human existence. You will gain a tremendous sense of fulfillment and tremendous sense of satisfaction.
And this sense of deep sense of satisfaction and and fulfillment really serves as a count sort of counterpoint preventing any potential for feeling of exhaustion or fatigue. So in such a person, there no room for a feeling of fatigue. And therefore, then as a result of striving in the cultivation of bodhicitta, altruistic intention and compassion, if we gain the genuine realization of bodhicitta, uncontrived, non-fabricated, and spontaneous, then you will attain a powerful state of mind where your vision transcends all limits. For example, like your your practice of compassion in bodhicitta is directed towards directed for for the purpose of infinite numbers of sentient beings. So far as the purpose of that practice is concerned, it is infinite.
The goal is, the objective of that practice is concerned, it’s infinite sentient beings. And the purpose of that practice is to attain the state of Buddhahood whose enlightened qualities are infinite. So it’s infinite enlightened qualities is your goal. And the means by which one engages in the practice is the infinite numbers of bodhisattva’s practices. So there is an infinity of bodhisattva deeds.
And then the time during which you engage in this altruistic activity is infinite, The innumerable eons. So there’s infinity of sentient beings for whose benefit you are engaging in the practice. There is an infinity of enlightened qualities, which is your objective to attain. And then there is the infinity of bodhisattva deeds that you engage in as a means. And there is infinity of time across which, during which, you cultivate these practices.
So through these when these four infinite factors come together, Nāgārjuna says that this in itself will make it possible for the accumulation of three innumerable eons to take place on its own. And this is similar to what Kadampa masters would say. The Kadampa masters would say, put all your efforts into cultivating bodhicitta, the altruistic intention. Because once you have cultivated bodhicitta, once you have generated bodhicitta, once bodhicitta arises in you, then it will take care of everything. It will take care of accumulating the merits for you.
It will take care of purifying all the negativities. So all your efforts might be must be directed towards the sole purpose of generating bodhicitta. Similarly, Tsongkhapa says in his great exposition of the path to enlightenment that the cultivation of bodhicitta, altruistic intention is such that in the when you engage in working for bringing about others’ welfare, one’s own self interest are fulfilled as a byproduct. Somebody should Sorry. Sorry.
Therefore, the practice of bodhicitta is is such that one could say that it is the source of the fulfillment of one’s both temporary aims and also ultimate aims, the long-term aims. Often when we speak of the enlightened qualities of the Buddha, one of the qualities of the Buddha we describe is the the spontaneity with which Buddha can achieve things. And in a sense, there is a similar spontaneity involved here. When you have realized bodhicitta, then it allows you to fulfill all your immediate aims, and also it helps you to fulfill your ultimate aim of attaining buddhahood. So in a sense, there is a kind of a similar similitude of a Buddha’s enlightened quality.
We also find in the aspiration prayers of Maitreya where there’s a stanza which says that it is with this the the road to the lower realms will be blocked. It is with this the doors to the higher realms will be opened. It is with this the freedom from death, aging, illness, and so on, birth will be brought about. It is this bodhicitta that I pay homage to.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
- The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- mantra ngag (Tib)
- Literally, mind protection. Mantras are Sanskrit syllables usually recited in conjunction with the practice of a particular meditational deity and embody the qualities of that deity. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.