51 min · 3,486 words · 2002 · Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 51-minute teaching, His Holiness the Dalai Lama expands on Atisha’s Lamp for the Path, arguing that bodhicitta, the altruistic intention to achieve enlightenment for all beings, is the heart of Buddhist practice. He begins by placing bodhicitta within Atisha’s three-scope framework, showing how all preliminary practices and the six perfections serve as preliminaries to or supports for this central commitment. He then addresses a practical objection: if bodhicitta feels impossible, what alternatives exist? Through the logic of karma and afflictions, he demonstrates that lasting happiness requires deliberately ending suffering through understanding its nature. He explores the nature of mind and consciousness in depth, discussing the mind-body relationship, ancient Indian materialist objections, and why Buddhist thinkers accept rebirth based on the continuity of consciousness. He examines different levels of mental subtlety in Vajrayāna, anecdotal evidence of past-life recall, and the logical distinction between not finding something and proving its absence. He closes by noting that scientific investigation may disprove some Buddhist cosmological details, and that Buddhists must accept such findings while retaining teachings that remain unrefuted.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 5B – Atisha's Melb 2002 May – HHDL.mp3
UUID: 5daf4e30-129e-44fd-a8b9-389a3d2b7eb2
Teacher: HH Dalai Lama
Collection: Lamp for the Path
Date: 2002 (exact day not recorded)
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~3,484
# Atisha’s Lamp for the Path-Melb-5b 2002 May
**Collection:** Rinpoche Recordings — HH Dalai Lama – Australia 2002
**Duration:** 51.4 minutes
**Words:** 3,484
**Model:** Deepgram Nova-3
**Corrections applied:** 3
**Transcribed:** 2026-03-01 05:37
—
Chitta, the altruistic intention, really is the essence. It is really the main practice, the actual practice. And all the other aspects of the Buddha’s teachings and practices are really either preliminaries to it or supplements to it as supplements or as precepts. For example, we can see that within the framework of the three capacities, the three scopes that Atisha outlined, all the practices that are associated with the initial scope and the middling scope, they are, in one way or another, preliminaries to the actual practice of bodhicitta. Then you have the practice of the bodhisattvas, practice of the six perfections.
And then also you have all the practices and teachings of the Vajrayāna class. And in fact, the Vajrayāna teachings can be seen as further elaborations on the last two perfections. In other words, meditative stabilization and wisdom, or the perfection of meditation and wisdom. And so we can see that all the teachings and the practices as embodied in the six perfections and also in the Vajrayāna teachings are precepts that the practitioner of Buddhist bodhicitta must engage in. So the heart or the actual main practice really is the bodhicitta, the altruistic intention.
So when we think about these points, what is entailed in the practice of cultivating bodhicitta and the compassion and so on, if someone feels that this is completely beyond me, this is impossible, this is difficult, it’s very complicated, then, of course, one is free as an individual to choose not to engage in the practice. But then we have to ask the question, if that is so, then what are the means to bring about the cessation of suffering, the suffering that we do not desire? Then regardless of whether one accepts the notion of karma and afflictions, the fact remains that we are all conditioned by karma and afflictions. Our very existence, present existence, is a product of karma and afflictions. And so long as we remain chained to the conditions of karma and afflictions, there is no room for lasting happiness.
Calamities strike us, undesirable events befall us. This is a natural factor of our existence. And our sufferings include the very natural sufferings such as of birth, illness, aging, death, and so on. But also, various other adversities that we face in our life. So here, it is worth remembering what Kadampa master, Potowa, said.
Potowa said that when we observe deeply the nature of our suffering, including the suffering of birth, death, aging, and sickness, let us see if there is ever a possibility of exhausting, completing the suffering simply by living them out, simply by experiencing them and living them out. And this, however, doesn’t seem to be the case because since beginningless lifetimes, we have endured all these sufferings over and over again, birth, aging, death, illness, and so on. But somehow, simply by living them out, doesn’t seem to have brought them to an end. So if this is so, then one can sort of infer that even in future too, simply by living them out over a period of time is not going to bring about the end of these sufferings. So what is required is to consciously and deliberately bring about their end.
And this can be done only by understanding the nature of suffering and seeking out what are the correct means of bringing about the end of that suffering. An acquaintance of mine, a great scholar, Geshe, once in the course of our conversation, we were actually talking about the nature of self and the absence of selfhood. And the conversation centered around the fact that self is an elusive phenomenon. That when you probe into it and search for its existence, what we find is it’s untenable. It’s not findable in the body and mind.
Then the Geshe, the scholar, remarked, he said, Yes, it is very elusive. It’s very complicated. And also, when we search for it, when we look for it, through a critical analysis, we always tend not to find it. It’s unfindable. However, if the self does not exist at all, in a sense that would make things very simple, that would make things very easy, then there would not be any subject. Much better.
Much better. He says No. Yeah. He says that if the self or the person does not exist at all, then in a sense, it’s much better because then there will be no experience of suffering and pain. There is no subject that would undergo such experience.
And everything will be much simpler. However, that is not the case. Regardless of whether we can actually pinpoint it, there is, however, an individual. There is a being who undergoes the experience of pain and pleasure, who is the subject of the experiences, who perceives things, and so based on our own experience, we do know that there is something, whatever we may call it, that makes it possible for us to undergo the experiences. We have something called discernment, ability to perceive things, ability to discern things.
And in fact, if you look at the experience of suffering, although some of the sufferings may be at the sensory level, at the level of body pain, but in fact, the very experience of pain is intimately connected with consciousness, intimately connected with mind. Because it is connected with feeling. And feeling is part of the sensation. And sensation is part of the mental world. And this is what distinguishes sentient beings from other biological organisms, like plants and trees and flowers and so on. Sentient beings have this subjective dimension, whether we call it experience, consciousness, the mental world, or whatever.
And then the question is, what exactly is this phenomenon, this mental phenomenon? And this has been whether or not this mental phenomenon or consciousness of the mind is 100% contingent upon the body, whether we can identify the mental phenomena entirely with the physical world, physical phenomena. And this is so, in other words, this is the issue of mind-body relation and the nature of mind and body. And this has been a major area of interest in the philosophical tradition. So this is not an issue that is a question that is very new.
This is a question that has been raised in ancient India for a long history of philosophical thinking tradition. For example, one of the ancient Indian schools adopted a materialist standpoint. They argued that mind is ultimately reducible to the physical body of the individual, that mind is identified with body. There is no separate phenomenon other than body. And they argue that because mind is entirely contingent upon body, that when the individual ceases to exist at the point of death, at the time of death, that his or her consciousness will also come to an end.
And they gave the analogy of mind and body are like the wall and the murals upon the wall. When the wall is knocked down, so long as the wall exists, the mural is there. When the wall is knocked down, the mural is gone. The mind and body, another analogy they gave is, the mind and body is like the wine and its potency, its alcoholic potency. When the wine is drunk, when the wine is finished, the alcohol is no longer there too.
So similarly, mind and body are related in that manner. So that when the person dies, that’s the end of consciousness. However, many other Indian philosophical traditions rejected that. And also, in modern kind of correlates of this discussion is about the relationship between body and mind and relation to the whole understanding, our cosmological understanding of the origin of the universe. For example, according to modern cosmology, the evolution, beginning of the current world system is posited as something, the event of Big Bang.
And also, the question is whether that is the very beginning of everything. Where does consciousness come from? And also, one thing that we can understand, both through scientific analysis and also from our own personal experience of perception, is that whatever experiences that we have now are consequences of conditions that has preceded. Nothing comes into being without a cause. And similarly, just as in the material world, everything must have a cause and conditions that give rise to it.
Similarly, in the mental world as well, all experiences have causes and conditions. And when we speak of the causes and conditions of consciousness or the mental world, there are two principal categories of causation or causes and conditions. One is a material cause or the substantial cause that turns something into something. And there are other conditions which are the contributory factors that makes that causation possible. So the Indian Buddhist teacher, master Dharmakīrti, points out in his Pramānavārttika, Valid Cognition.
He says that something that is not mental cannot turn into a mental phenomenon. In other words, something that is purely physical or material cannot become mental. So what he’s pointing out here is that for a consciousness, for an instance of consciousness to take place, it must have, as its preceding continuum, another instance of consciousness. And through this way, we can trace the causation to the beginning of consciousness of this life. And through this way, one posits an earlier preceding life.
Furthermore, if you look at the Vajrayāna literature, there is an understanding of different levels of subtlety of the mental phenomenon, mental world, or consciousness. Normally, when we speak of mind or consciousness, we get the impression that we’re talking about one unitary kind of a single thing. This is, however, not the case. Just as the physical world is a diverse world, similarly, the mental world of consciousness is also a very diverse world with very different levels of subtlety. And it is obvious that at the most gross level of experience, our consciousness and perceptions and senses are very contingent upon our body.
But as the level of consciousness gets more and more subtle, there is a greater degree of independence from the physical body. So it is along these lines one accepts the continuity, never ending continuity of consciousness. And from the Vajrayāna point of view, on the basis of this subtle luminous nature of mind. And so it’s not the case that the ancient Indian schools, including Buddhism, those who accept the concept of rebirth, simply makes the claim on the basis that we believe in rebirth. A lot of thinking has gone into this.
A lot of analysis has gone into this. A lot of philosophical reflection has gone into this. Furthermore, we also find anecdotal evidence of very clear situations where children who are capable of recalling their past life experiences, even in some cases, in a family where the parents don’t believe in the idea of rebirth or previous existence. So they are anecdotal stories. Again, of course, we need to constantly subject this to analysis and to critical examination.
Generally, when doing so, I think it is important to bear in mind one very important logical point. The point is the following, that we must be able to distinguish clearly between cases where we haven’t found something, where we have found that to be not the case. So in other words, finding its absence and not finding are two different things. And many phenomena at present, we may not have, instead of not finding its absence, we may have not found them so far. So we need to be able to make a clear logical distinction between those instances where we have found this to be not the case.
In other words, we have disproved something, or instances where we simply haven’t found the reason or found it. So it is important to be able to make distinction between instances where we have not found to be the case and instances where simply we haven’t found it. And also when we use critical reasoning to analyze something. And then here, we have to also understand the domain of application of that particular style of reasoning. So different forms of analysis may have different domains and different scopes.
For example, we find in Pramānavārttika, Dharmakīrti’s text on logic and epistemology, many different forms of reasoning. For example, if you are establishing the absence of something, if you are proving the nonexistence of something, then you cannot simply state that this does not exist because we cannot see it. That kind of simplistic reasoning doesn’t operate. What we need to do is to use the correct form of reasoning to the correct domain of discourse. For example, he makes distinction between two primary forms of logical negation.
One is where, generally, the thesis that is being disproven, if it exists, it should be observable. Then under such circumstances, when you can show that it cannot be observed, then you can prove its absence. There are, however, other instances where what is being negated is simply not perceptible, even in normal situation. Under such circumstances, simply by stating the fact that you cannot observe it, cannot establish, cannot prove its nonexistence. So how does one go about negating something?
Then there are two ways. One is either by proving that something that is contrary to the case is so. So by establishing its contrary, then you can prove something, negate something. Or by negating something that is closely related to, or causally connected to something, then you can negate the thesis. So the point being made here is that we need to make a clear distinction between not finding something and finding its absence.
So that is, first of all, an important logical distinction. And so it is through these methods that ancient philosophical traditions like Buddhism chose to accept the notion of rebirth and previous lives. And because if you compare the two traditions, two standpoints, the standpoint which rejects which denies the existence of rebirth and previous existence, and the standpoint that accepts the never ending continuity of consciousness and accepts rebirth and previous existence, then one can argue that the standpoint that accepts rebirth has a much greater explanatory resource at its disposal. Because if you don’t accept the notion of the never ending continuity of consciousness, you don’t accept the possibility of rebirth and previous existence, then there remains a lot of phenomena that becomes completely inexplicable, and we can choose to describe them as mysterious or miraculous, which is a shorthand for ignorance. And so, in other words, basically, you have no explanation to these phenomena.
Whereas, if you accept the notion of rebirth and previous existence and the continuity of consciousness, then you have, and although you may not be able to give a 100% satisfying explanation to everybody, but at least it gives you a much more explanatory resource. Generally, when speaking of proof, it is very difficult to try to prove something that another person cannot have an experiential knowledge of. For example, imagine proving the existence of dreams to someone who claims not have dreamt at all, had any experience of dream. How would you prove that everybody experiences dream? Similarly, in the case of all of us, although from the Buddhist point of view, we all have experienced different lifetimes.
But when you change lifetimes, your body changes, and much of the memory that goes with your body also ceases to exist. So we have simply no ability to recall our past life experiences. So it is difficult to say past life exists because this is the case. So one can say that between these two standpoints, because the standpoint that accepts rebirth and previous existence has much more explanatory resource, Buddhism chose to adhere to that standpoint rather than rejecting and denying rebirth. When speaking of memory, it does seem to be the case that much of our conscious memory is really very contingent upon our present body, physical existence.
So a meditator, when he or she enters into a very deep stages of meditation, then what is happening is that the individual is able to take the level of his or her mind to a much subtler state. And as he or she goes to a more and more subtle state, then there is a greater degree of freedom from the contingency of the present body. So it seems that among some of the meditators that I know personally, there are individuals who, occasionally, when they enter very deep in their meditative state, that they get very vivid recollections of past experiences. And these, at the initial stage, remain more like kind of glimpses, kind of spontaneous glimpses, which is called nyam in Tibetan, which is more like kind of spontaneous experiences. Which eventually, if the meditator is able to progress deeper and deeper, may be turned into an actual realization.
So this suggests that as you go deeper and deeper into meditative state, the more subtle your state of mind becomes, then you have a greater ability to recall past life experiences, which reside in a much subtler state of consciousness. Because it is the subtle continuum of the subtle consciousness that connects individuals’ different lives. Related to this, I forgot something from the previous part. His Holiness was saying that if consciousness is ultimately reducible to body, then all the functions of the consciousness must be ultimately functions of the body, in which case it is only by affecting the body that it affects the mind and never the vice versa. However, these days, in fact, there is a growing interest among the scientists to undertake laboratory based experiments upon individual meditators.
And in some cases, they are beginning to find evidence of where, as a result of an individual meditator, using purely the power of cognition or power of mind, either through single pointedness meditation or some other meditative practices, they are able to effect change at the biological level. So here, we can see a kind of a reverse kind of effect that, as a result of pure thought process taking place in the mental level, one can detect manifestations of that at the biological and physiological level. And so there is now a growing interest. And in fact, laboratory based experiments are being done. Of course, these kind of experiments and these kind of investigations need to go further. So if, however, as a result of scientific or some other critical investigation, certain aspects of the Buddhist thought are shown to be, proven to be not the case, proven to be untrue, then as followers of the Buddha, as Buddhists, one must accept the consequence of that.
I have often made the comment that, for example, the cosmological description of our world we find in the Buddhist Abhidharma texts such as Abhidharmakośa, Treasury of Phenomenological Knowledge, where the size of sun and moon are described in very specific numbers and the distance between Earth and sun and moon are described. And in fact, a lot of these descriptions, including the presence of Mount Meru as the center of the universe, many of these cosmological descriptions that are found in the Abhidharma texts cannot be accepted. Because through modern cosmological study, there has been proven, actually, that there’s exact measurement of the distance from Earth to these celestial bodies. There’s exact measurement of the difference of size between the sun and moon, which according to the Abhidharma text, is not very large, but we know it is a tremendously large difference and so on. For example, in the Abhidharma text, the distance is described as 51 yojanas, and so on.
So these can no longer be accepted because we have very clear empirical evidence that suggests otherwise. And as Buddhists, we cannot, if something, if an idea or a concept has been disproven through a very clear evidence, then one must reject the concept. For example, also, Tsongkhapa states in one of his texts, Differentiation of the Definitive and Interpretable Meanings of the Scriptures, where he states that he who accepts philosophical standpoints that
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- Mount Meru
- The mythical center of the universe in Buddhist cosmology. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- Vajrayana dor je theg pa (Tib)
- The adamantine vehicle; the second of the two Mahayana paths. It is also called Tantrayana or Mantrayana. This is the quickest vehicle of Buddhism as it allows certain practitioners to attain enlightenment within a single lifetime. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.