1 h 31 min · 3,652 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This session continues the Lam Rim teaching on the path of the middling scope, moving to the second noble truth, the origin of suffering. It explains the six root afflictions, led by ignorance, and how afflictions give rise to karma and link with death and conception. The talk ends with a question and answer session on selflessness, tenets, doubt and the role of prostrations.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 31m
UUID: 964c52de-25dc-411d-93c0-1e529a8b94de
Words: 3,648
So we will generate during a minute or so the motivation to listen to these teachings of Lam Rim, which are the essence of the teachings of the Buddha. And the motivation to be generated is a motivation which realizes that future lives are more beneficial than this life and that in turn, liberation is more beneficial and more worthy than working for future lives. But that attaining the state of full enlightenment, not for one’s own sake, but for the sake of other mother sentient beings which are as vast as space, is in turn itself even more worthy of pursuit than striving for one’s own individual liberation. This is the motivation we should create. And we will, at present, do the short meditation, meditation, which we have done during every one of the previous teachings on Dutsi Ningpo.
We will, for the sake of all sentient beings and ourselves, request the Buddha Śākyamūni, who is the manifestation of all the Buddhas to settle on our crown. And then we will make strong supplications to the Buddha Śākyamūni for three specific purposes this time. The first is to eliminate all wrong views and interferences regarding the teacher, the spiritual teacher. The second is to attain all qualities, and the third is to thoroughly pacify all interferences and obstructing conditions. And after making these three requests, we must imagine from the heart of the Buddha and his body that light and the nectar descend within our body, and as was explained previously, that first they purify all of the afflictions and non virtuous karma connected with the body, which leave our bodies through the lower orifices as sooty water.
Then they purify all of the non virtuous karma accumulated through speech, and in this case our body is filled from the bottom up with light and nectar which leaves through our mouth, and then finally, all of the non virtuous activities engaged in by the mind are purified, and to do this we visualize that when the light and nectar enter within our body, instantaneously all of these non virtues which are visualized as a black heap at the heart are completely purified. And after doing these three visualizations, we then recite the mantra of the Dharani of Buddha Śākyamūni. At this point, there’s a great benefit in visualizing that the Buddha on our crown shrinks, becomes very small, descends to a central central channel, and fuses entirely with our mind at the heart.
And then the So at present, we will go further in the explanation of the practice of the being of middling scope. The general meaning of the beings of the three scopes has been explained already. The practice of the being of small scope, specifically taking refuge as protection against the lower realms has been explained, and the key points of the practice of the being of middling scope have been explained. The various divisions of suffering which characterize cyclic existence, the eightfold, sixfold, and threefold division of suffering have been explained. And in this context as well, the faults of the higher rebirths of a rebirth as a human being or as a god.
And at present, having explained, the general characteristics of suffering and specifically the threefold division of suffering, we want to enter into the details of the cause of suffering and of the suffering of suffering in particular, and the cause of these are the afflictions. So the second outline at present, we enter into an explanation of the afflictions. And therefore, having explained the first of the noble truth, which is a noble truth of suffering, we are at present approaching an explanation of the second of the noble truth, which is a noble truth of the origin of suffering. Now this in Tibetan is called. Means all.
Means all, means to originate. All here refers to the totality of the afflictions. Excuse me, the totality of suffering, and the origination refers to the source of the suffering, the origin of the suffering, which is the mental afflictions. And this outline in turn is divided into three. The mode of generation of the afflictions, how karma is accumulated, and how in turn it is connected with the death process and the process of conception.
So this is not explained in detail in your text, the essence of nectar. It is, however, explained in great detail in the outline of the swift path, which Geshe la is also relying, which encapsulates teachings from many Lamrims. And therefore, Geshe la will enter into detail at present on this topic. And the key to our practice to behave in a way according with the teachings is the Lam Rim. So therefore, these points are very important.
Now with respect to the threefold division we talked about, the mode of arising of the afflictions, which is the first of the subdivisions, is itself divided into four. The first of the four subdivisions is identifying what is an affliction. And with respect to this first outline identifying the afflictions, these are actually or this refers to the six root afflictions and the 20 branch afflictions, which will be explained in the context of Lorig. However, specifically here, it refers to the six root afflictions, which are desire, anger, ignorance, and pride, doubt, and wrong views. And of these six, the third, ignorance is actually the root of the remaining six.
So these six in general are said to be root afflictions because they are the root of all the other afflictions, which generally speaking are considered to be 84,000 in number. So we will explain first from within the six root afflictions, the affliction of ignorance. Now what we translate as ignorance in English is actually in Tibetan. Is non. Is to know, so it might be better translated as unknowing or.
It is an unknowing of what? It is an unknowing of the ultimate nature of phenomena, which is both the coarse and the subtle selflessness of persons and the coarse and subtle selflessness of phenomena. Now, this unknowing is a mental process which apprehends the person and phenomena as existing inherently or from their own side, whereas in actuality, they do not exist inherently or from their own side. Knowing is to understand that they exist as noninherently existing phenomena. So all the highest presentation of ignorance or the most encompassing one is the one where ignorance is understood to be the apprehension of the person and phenomena as truly existing.
Nonetheless, the presentation which is adopted in the lower schools, the Hīnayāna schools in other words, which is one where ignorance is considered to be the apprehension of the person as a substantially existing phenomenon, which is autonomous, is also acceptable. Now what is meant here when one speaks of an autonomous substantially existing phenomenon is that the person is seen as existing independently of the body and mind on which basis it is imputed and is seen as existing by its own characteristics, which is not the case. Second of the root afflictions is the root affliction of desire. Desire can be desire for any of the five sense objects. In other words, for forms seen by the eye consciousness, sounds, smells, tastes, or bodily sensations.
In every single case, these five sense objects which are perceived as pleasing are inflated by desire. They, in other words, perceived as more pleasant than they actually are. And independence on this affliction, craving in turn arises, and this craving is the principal cause of the process of taking aggregates, which is the mechanism of the motor of cyclic existence. So desire is one of the principal causes of cyclic existence. And the third root affliction is anger or hatred.
Anger actually is an affliction which arises with respect to unpleasant objects, whereas desire arose with respect to pleasant objects. But the unpleasantness is inflated or exaggerated. Even though there may be some initial unpleasantness, the mind of anger sees it as far greater than it is. And when anger arises in the mind, it becomes the principal cause for rebirth in the lower realms and specifically in the hell realms. So this is one of the major afflictions.
It also destroys the roots of virtue previously accumulated. And the fourth root affliction is pride pride or arrogance, and this is the affliction which through observing whatever qualities we may have and the qualities there may be indeed, nonetheless exaggerates or inflates them, and the mind in turn becomes full, literally in Tibetan full of oneself, And one then has not only a very high opinion of oneself, but a very low opinion of others. So this is the fourth root affliction. And then the fifth affliction is the affliction of doubt, which is an affliction which arises through doubt with respect to the triple gem or doubt with respect to karma and causality, doubt with respect to something which exists and which is suspected to be a non existent. And this is one of the main obstacles, Geshe la says, to attaining liberation.
So then the sixth root affliction is the root affliction of wrong view, which is itself divided into five. And the first of these is the view of the it is often called the composite aggregate, the aggregate which destroy, which disintegrates. This is specifically the view of the person which sees the person as established from its own side or as a substantially established autonomous phenomenon. And the second is the view of permanence. The view of permanence is a view which sees the self, but which sees specifically the aggregates as permanent, stable, and unchanging.
It sees them as true. So whereas the main focus of the first view of the composite or disintegrating self is of the person or the self, the main view of the second is a view of permanence tends to be the aggregates. And the third is the view wrong views, which actually includes the view of annihilation. It is a view that the self or the person have no existence of their own right. And the fourth is partial or sectarian views.
This actually refers to all wrong or bad views in general. And the fifth wrong view is the wrong view which takes particular behavior as a valid form of ethics. Now this refers to certain practices in ancient India which were those of the yogis or the who believed that for instance, through mortifying the body or harming the body, one could could purify oneself of wrong views or that through bathing in a river, it was possible to purify oneself of wrong views. In every single case, taking a very limited or debased type of behavior as supreme ethics is what is referred to here. The root of these six afflictions remains the affliction of ignorance, which is that apprehension of the person or the self as not arising independence on its parts, body, and mind, but as being something that came to the owner or the proprietor of these.
And as this ignorance becomes very powerful, then in turn, dependent on it, whatever favors the person, whatever is to the person’s advantage becomes an object of desire. On the other hand, whatever causes any interferences or harm to the person becomes an object of anger or of hatred. As the ignorance increases in power, the person seems to exist totally from its own side and suffuses the personality, and in turn conceit, arrogance, or pride arise. And as the ignorance increases ever more, it leads to a misunderstanding or a misconception of what exists and what does not exist, and in dependence still of the ignorant of this ignorance, doubt arises and ultimately wrong views. Therefore, the five remaining of the six root afflictions all can be seen to arise from the initial root affliction of ignorance.
And then with respect to the second of the four outlines, the, mode of, actually, it’s it’s really the third outline, the cause of the afflictions here. These are six fold. The first of these are the imprints of the karmic imprints in the mind. This is what gives rise to the afflictions. The second is the object independence on which the afflictions arise.
Without an object, it is difficult for the afflictions to arise. The third are a conglomeration of factors or conceptions which can give rise to an affliction. For instance, gossip or talk which can give rise to the afflictions. And the three remaining causes are fourthly, anything which acts as a basis or an example on independence on which desire will arise. For instance, in Tibet, it might have been large stores of grain, whereas here it would more be large amounts of of money.
And this is said to be that which leads the mind from pure to impure appearances. The fifth cause is So the fifth is frequent habituation with the delusion, which in turn makes its arise very easy. The more one becomes accustomed to a delusion, the easier it is it is for it to dawn, Geshe la says. And the sixth is to think repeatedly of the object or to be exposed repeatedly to the object which gives rise to the delusion. So to encapsulate or to resume what was covered this morning, if we were to ask what exactly is a delusion or an affliction, an affliction can be defined as that which when it arises within the continuum of a sentient being, which was formerly at peace or at ease gives rise to ill at easeness and to a sense of agitation and trouble, troublesomeness within the mind of the sentient being.
So this is a characteristic of all of the delusions. And what are the thoughts of the afflictions, the fourth of this set of four outlines? The thoughts of the afflictions which are posited on the basis of oneself of another or of any collection of assorted phenomena are, as Geshe la explained, that they give rise to a sense of mental agitation, trouble, and ultimately suffering. And what is the process whereby afflictions give rise to comma, dependent on the arrival of the afflictions, the two types of karma, karma which is mental and karma which is the product of mental activity arise, and dependent on these various non virtuous deeds such as for instance, killing another being or for that matter uttering harsh words arise.
So the third outline at present, we have finished the presentation of the four subdivisions of the outline of the mode of generation of the afflictions. Third outline is the conjunction of the afflictions with death and with the time of conception. And this itself is divided into three. So this outline is divided into three parts as we were saying. The mode of dying or the death process.
After dying, the mode of taking on the body of intermediate state or the vital body, and dependent on that, the mode of taking on the link of birth, in other words, taking birth after conception. Generally speaking, Geshe la says, depending on the karma of, the being, death can be, more or less easy. For many beings, death is a mindless process. So it is very important at this point in time, the time of death, to encourage the person to recollect the triple gem or some virtuous object, so that the last thoughts in the dying process are virtuous. Now at the time of death, through the combination of the links of craving and appropriation, the conditions for taking on the next birth are gathered.
The actual time of death in this life and the birth of the being of the intermediate state are simultaneous. And the being of the intermediate state, unlike, you know, the bardo being, the being in this life, is unimpeded, unobstructed in its capacity to travel with, they say, the limitation of its future rebirth. And this being is also endowed with the supernormal powers, which enable it to know phenomena from afar. Now this being itself will incur death, and the time of its death and the time of rebirth in the next life are also simultaneous. And this is a cycle which repeats on and on.
And then the following outline in presentation of Lam Rim is the ascertainment of the actual nature of the path to progress to liberation. And this in turn is divided into two subdivisions. The basis on which one can turn away from psychic existence, and the path whereby one turns away from psychic existence. So the first step here is to gain an ascertainment of the first two noble truths, a noble truth of suffering and noble truth of the origination of suffering. And dependent on these two, one can in turn give rise to a mind of renunciation, a mind which wishes to be freed from cyclic existence.
The means to gain liberation from cyclic existence is actually the wisdom which realizes selflessness. But this needs as its foundation that aspiration which strives for liberation from cyclic existence. And then in turn, one has to train in these three trainings, the training of wisdom, which is that realization of selflessness, the training of concentration where the mind gains the capacity to realize selflessness, and the training in ethics or morality, which is the foundation for the training in concentration. So we have completed hereby the presentation of the path of the being of middling scope, and we will stop here for today. Next time, we will broach the presentation of the being of great scope in the context of the.
So if you have questions at present, please feel free to ask them. Yes. And here, basically, Geshe la says when we say that a person does not exist in their own right or from their own side, what is meant is that if we observe either the five aggregates of the person or the body and mind of the person, which are the two bases of imputation of the person, then we cannot find a person which is independent of the five aggregates, which exists apart from them, or a person which is independent or which exist apart from the body and mind. And generally speaking from within the four schools of tenets, the Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Chitamatra, and Madhyamaka, the three lower ones, the Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, and Chitamatra, all accept that phenomena exist from their own side. And within the fourth school of tenets, the Madhyamaka school, the Svatāntrika Madhyamaka also accept that phenomena exist from their own side.
So the only school within the Buddhist schools which are considered that phenomena do not exist from their own side is the Prāsaṇgika view. Yes. Is it the motivation that makes the difference between doubt So generally speaking, doubts when one studies texts are very good things. Skepticism, which is perhaps a better translation of the term thetsom, is that state where one is unable to decide specifically with respect to a a virtuous object, such as for instance a triple gem or so forth. Now that state of mind prevents one from accumulating virtue.
On the other hand, doubts with respect to the inherent existence of cyclic existence are profoundly virtuous since it is said that they tear cyclic existence from the root. And generally speaking, there is a big difference between the practitioner of lower and of greater capacity in this respect. The practitioner of lower capacity or the duller practitioner literally will take the resolution to attain full enlightenment for the benefit of others based purely on faith or on conviction. And this is generally a very
Thing, but the practitioner of higher capacity with a sharper mind would not be able to do that without first having established the existence of full enlightenment using a valid cognizer. It will not be sufficient for him to have conviction or faith. And then using many, many lines of reasoning, he eventually will be able to demonstrate the existence of full enlightenment of Buddhahood using pure reasoning, and then dependent on this will actually take the vow or the pledge to attain full enlightenment. Yes. So there’s no difference actually.
Both are behaviors. Bathing in the Ganges and making prostrations are activities or behaviors. The difference arises from the fact that the Hindus believe that bathing in the Ganges alone cleanses afflictions. The Buddhists do not believe that prostrations can purify afflictions. The only thing which purifies afflictions is the realization of emptiness.
Prostration is merely an aid. It is a means which enables one to then train in the view. It’s a foundation. And therefore, this is the first reason which is connected actually with the mind. The second is that when we engage in devotional activities such as making prostrations or venerating the Triple Gem, we are actually doing this to enhance our capacity to generate wisdom in turn, which is actually what does purify the mind.
And for this reason, because in the case, let’s say, of the Hindus, they do not provide any sound ground, any good justification for their activities, then we call these activities taking a mistaken mode of behavior as the supreme mode of behavior. So Geshe la says everything he’s doing right now is a Buddhist mode of behavior. Are his garments and all that? Yes. Yes.
Generally speaking, the traditional antidote to pride is to reflect on the constituents of the body from one’s toes to the top of one’s crown. And when one realizes one is completely unable to name all of the parts of the body, let alone all of the parts of the mind, then one sense of self inflatedness decreases. This is in. Yeah. So we will stop here for today.
Key terms in this teaching
- intermediate state antarabhava (Skt); bardo (Tib)
- The state between death and rebirth. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.