1 h 38 min · 3,820 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Teaches that contentment with little happiness is the foundation of the path, and that dharma means inner mental transformation rather than outer forms such as ordination. Explains that afflictions are impermanent consciousnesses that can be abandoned, and compares Vaibhashika, Sautrantika and Madhyamaka views on whether cyclic existence ends, the fate of arhats, and the mind basis of all. Much of the talk answers students’ questions on substantial and cooperative causes, emptiness and deep sleep.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 38m
UUID: 2f705116-6bd2-46d3-887c-a64bbaaf9c15
Words: 3,816
So let us look at it this way. When we get up in the morning, let us ask ourselves why precisely we plan on engaging in the activities we will be engaging in that day. Then it’s going to be mainly for this body. And for our wealth, it is mainly going to be the accumulation of money, isn’t it? Then if we look back on what we have done in previous years and most of our life, then the goal of all of our work and activities has been this body, these aggregates.
Then it’s a little bit strange, isn’t it, when we start thinking about it? Then when we wondered what it takes to increase body’s health and to further our body, Basically, it depends mainly on food and drink. So if we start looking at our life in these terms, then it feels quite strange, doesn’t it? It’s good to look at things like this. Then we have been born in this world.
And when we ask ourselves what it takes to make this life meaningful and happy, obviously, it is not only dependent on the body, is it? Then when we think of the amount of labor which we have expended in this life, we should ask ourselves what for. Then in our own case, we have only one mouth. We can only eat that much food. We don’t have a large number of mouths.
We have only one body to close. We don’t have a large number of bodies. Then through thinking in this way, it will not happen at once, but over time, we will be able to give rise to contentment with little happiness. Then our situation is exactly the opposite. We have great happiness, but it is never enough.
We are insatiable. Contentment with little happiness is the foundation of everything. It is the foundation of health. For instance, it is precisely because we lack contentment with little happiness that we overeat and periodically face intestinal disorder or disruption. So it is a foundation for everything.
As says in his epitome of realization, his concise Lamrim, seeing all affairs of this life as the peel to be discarded, make this life meaningful. Then, how do we make this life meaningful at the level of the path shared with the being of the small scope indeed, one does need to focus on ethics, the abandonment of non virtue. But more fundamentally, one needs this contentment with little happiness. Then in our own case, the situation is exactly the opposite of this. We see exterior physical objects, in other words, material objects as the source of our happiness.
Not just the source, but the sole, the exclusive source of our happiness. And as a result, we put tremendous effort in exterior material objects. This is strange, isn’t it? Then I am in no way saying that exterior material objects are unnecessary. What I am saying is that they are unable to make us completely happy or completely satisfied.
And once we understand this and we have generated contentment with little happiness, then I think we are close to the realizations, of the path shared with the being of the small scope. And then after this, one progresses quietly over time on the path shared with the being of the middling scope and so forth. Then when we speak of the Lam Rim, as a matter of fact, the root of the Lam Rim is Atisha’s lamp for the path, his Bodhipatha Pradipa, which comprises only a couple of pages. Although its meaning is very difficult and each verse is pregnant with meaning. Then the which have arisen later comprise thousands of pages, and they overwhelm us sometimes.
Then there are numerous texts thereafter. Obviously, everything depends on, one’s own constituents and one’s own focus. Then even though we have fancy clothes, we have good food, and we have a luxurious house, This alone will not make us happy. What we need is mental happiness. With mental happiness, even if we are bereft of all of this, we shall be happy.
Then when we speak of dharma, there is a misconception that one has to be somehow ordained. One has to be a monk or a nun to practice dharma. This is not the case. Dharma is about mental transformation. It is not through putting monastic robes on that one’s mind is transformed.
If that were the case, things would become very strange indeed. Things have changed a lot in Tibet. There was there was a category of people who were not ordained but studied very intensely, neither monks nor nuns. So this is what is meant by dharma. Dharma means that our happiness is not contingent on exterior phenomena, but it is contingent on inner transformation.
Then to be happy, we therefore need interior mental happiness. What troubles our mind and prevents us from attaining this interior mental happiness? It is the afflictions. Then the afflictions are to be examined. Are they permanent or impermanent?
Sometimes they are present, sometimes they are absent. Therefore, they are impermanent. They are occasional. And as such, they could be one of three categories of phenomena. Form, non associated compositional phenomena, or consciousness.
And they are not form or matter. They are not non associated compositional phenomena. They are consciousness. Then they’re obviously not formed. If they will form, it would be easy to get rid of them.
One could just cast them outside. So they don’t form.
Then, we must at present examine what these afflictions under the sway of anger are and what the means are to reduce them. So then if we look at what has happened in the last last ten or fifteen years, most things, houses, cars, and so forth have changed tremendously. But if we look within ourselves, it is interesting to see that the afflictions have not changed at all. They are always there, and they are our true enemy. Then if we look for instance at clothing and fashion, in the last ten, fifteen years, clothing and fashion have completely changed.
On the other hand, when it comes to the afflictions within ourselves, there has been no change at all. Then, the mode of generation and the mode of existence of the afflictions is what leads us into the path shared with the being of the middling scope. Generally speaking, there are numerous subdivisions and sections of the path shared with the being of the small and the middling scope. But if we are unable to determine them, then thinking in this general way is adequate. Let us then meditate during a couple of minutes in this way on the relevance of dharma to ourselves.
Then at present, let us address the topic of whether cyclic existence has a boundary or not. Then when we speak of the boundary of cyclic existence and the cyclic existence, it is not the exterior world we are referring to. It is our own continuum of consciousness. And whether this has a boundary or not must be understood in two terms, whether there is a beginning or not and whether there is an end or not. Now it is clear there is no beginning.
Whether there is an end or not, that is open to debate. In Buddhist text. So as to whether cyclic existence has a beginning or not, there is no debate. Past lives are beginningless in number, and here, one is talking in the Buddhist context. Now whether cyclic existence has an end or not is another issue altogether.
And here, we’re not talking of the end which death provides. We’re talking of the end of the continuum of consciousness. So what exactly happens when the afflictions are abandoned? So now from the standpoint of the Buddhist schools of tenets, the Vaibhāṣika and the Chitamatra as well as, excuse me, the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika, as well as some Chitamadra assert that an arhat at the time of death experiences a severance or the end of his continuum. There’s only a couple of scholars in those schools who have a very interesting position and who say that that is not the case, but that he remains in a meditative equipoise.
Now Madhyamaka asserts that there is no severance of the continuum. The continuum is indefinite or eternal, if you wish, and the end of cyclic existence does exist. This end of psychic existence is the abandonment of the afflictions. So the Vaibhāṣika and the Sautrāntika, therefore, assert that hearer and Pratyekabuddha arhats, when they die after attaining arhathood, experience the severance of their continuum because the afflictions ceased to exist. Then as you know, both Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika assert the existence of only one Buddha, the historic Buddha, and do not assert the existence of pure lands.
Then in the Mahayana system of tenets, we assert the existence of the Pure Lands. So if you ask then what or where are the Arhats reborn when they have abandoned the afflictions? And obviously, are not reborn in this world of ours. They’re reborn in the pure lands.
Then regarding the Pure Lands, in my own opinion, these are not like some sort of a heaven which is above us with houses and cars and roads and so forth. Instead, what happens is that as the afflictions are abandoned, our mind becomes more and more subtle. And this subtle mind is no longer dependent on the coarse aggregates. Then it is this subtle mind which can be reborn in a pure land. Then this topic of the subtle mind leads directly to that of past and future lives.
If I take my own case, my first memories can be traced back to age three or four. Then I do not have continuous memory from that point onwards. The first manifest memories go back to that age. Then these memories and karmic imprints need some sort of a base, and this base is precisely the subtle mind. This is what has led the Cittamātra, for those of you who follow the Tuesday class, to develop the concept of a mind basis of all or an alaya which is present also during sleep as a receptacle for karmic imprints.
Therefore, such a subtle mind is indispensable as a receptacle for karmic imprints and memories. Whether it actually functions completely in the sense Cittamātra ascribed to the mind basis of all is another question altogether. But such a subtle mind is a receptacle of memories which go back to the age of three or four. Then by the age of one or two, it is unclear that we remember anything. So let us at present meditate a little bit on the benefits and the object of bodhicitta.
Page one. Page five. Number six, Mandalu free. So the teach that during deep sleep and when one falls unconscious, there is nonetheless a subtle consciousness which is still present, which they call the mind basis of all. This is not the position of either the Vaibhāṣikas or the Sautrantikas for which in deep sleep and when one falls unconscious, there is no consciousness.
And regarding the, this is probably a similar position as well. Then please ask your questions in the present. Gisela, what is the meaning of the phrase the affliction, the afflictions under the sway of anger? The meaning is angers excuse me. Afflictions such as anger.
There are numerous forms of afflictions, numerous instances of afflictions. Does the Buddha belong in the formless realm? Means and does does Buddha belong in the formless realm? Is that where he Now in Buddhist teachings, one does not teach that Buddha dwells in the formless realm. saṃsāra is subdivided into three.
Mhmm. The desire realm, the form realm, and the formless realm. Instead, Buddha dwells or Buddhas dwell in the pure lands. You can pass pass pass her Don’t. We’ve been talking about substantial causes and cooperative conditions in recent teachings.
And it made me wonder substantial causes and cooperative conditions synonymous or different with causes and conditions?
Broadly speaking, yes, when we say cause, we mean substantial cause. When we say condition, we mean cooperative condition. I was wondering if the arhats ever return to explain to those of the the lower scopes that they were wrong. When they find themselves not having their consciousness ended, but they are woken up by the Buddhas. I see.
That’s what you’re talking about. So when arhats leave the meditative equipoise in which they are in the pure lands under the impetus of supreme emanation body, then indeed they must enter the Mahāyāna. Now whether they explain to others or not that their paths are mistaken is another question altogether. They have understood all along that the Buddha exists. It is just they have striven for another goal.
Right. Do you understand? Correct. Yes, sir. Yes.
I understand. Your idea is they come with a lankavatara sūtra, slam it on the table, say, this is the truth. Right? Yeah. Well, that that that that would be have a great advantage to to come to come back and to teach that Mhmm.
They had been on this path, and they realized that they had the wrong view. They they understand all along that the path they are on is not the ultimate or the final path. But out of a lack of mental fortitude, out of egoism, they think that attaining their own liberation is sufficient and adequate. Mhmm. Geshe la taught that regarding the end of cyclic existence that this is open to debate in Buddhist texts.
But if cyclic existence can be described as the afflictions within our mind stream, then once the afflictions are abandoned and they cease, then psychic existence also ends. But because the consciousness isn’t the same thing as the afflictions, that does not. So I don’t understand how they can posit cyclic existence as not having an end because the end of cyclic existence is liberation. So in individual cases, cyclic existence has an end. But when we speak in general, does cyclic existence have an end for all sentient beings?
Then there is very large number of human beings and a nigh infinite number of sentient beings. Is there a point where all sentient beings have attained liberation? That is the question. Alright. Good.
Can a negative phenomenon be a substantial cause? And I’m asking that because if emptiness is a non affirming negative and it can’t be a substantial cause, then what is the substantial cause for liberation? So So to answer the first part of your question, there is no intersection between negative phenomena and substantial causes since negative phenomena such as, for instance, non affirming negatives are necessarily permanent phenomena. Then, the second part of your question, how could emptiness, which is a non affirming negative, be the cause of liberation? It’s a good question.
Emptiness is not the cause of liberation, but it is the mind which meditates in emptiness, the wisdom of meditating on emptiness, which becomes the cause of liberation. The mind is impermanent. It’s a good question. I thought it was very strange. When you first ask, is there a common locus between a non affirming negative and a substantial cause, I was very surprised by your question.
But then when you said because emptiness is the cause of liberation, then I understood your doubt. It’s a very good one. So non affirming or nonimplicative negations are permanent. Then they obviously cannot be impermanent. They cannot be causes.
Can I ask another question about substantial cause? Given the scenario of me out in my shiny new car and somebody runs into it and I get very angry, the substantial cause of my anger is is my own self grasping of the permanence of my beautiful car. Are the karmic connections, the karmic imprints the the cooperative causes, or is it something to do with the action of the other driver? You have a a very fancy new car, basically. No.
No. Okay. That’s okay. Grasping at permanent. So?
Permanent. So the substantial cause of the anger at that moment are the karmic imprints within your mind. And the cooperative conditions, there are numerous cooperative conditions. It is the driver of the other car, the accident, and so forth and so forth. So regarding your question, when one speaks of Tārā, Tārā is a goddess simply because deities manifest in male or female forms, and Tārā manifests in a female form, manifestation of the energy of the Buddhas.
Then ask you a question about 21 Taras. Actually, these are the main Taras. But just as Avalokiteśvara and other deities, they manifest in these forms for the benefit of trainees. Typically, it’s an experience induced by karma during meditation. Just, following on from about substantial causes and cooperative conditions.
Is it the case that, whenever there is a substantial cause for a phenomena that there is only one substantial cause and there are either one or many cooperative conditions? So, yes, for composite phenomena, you can say that there can be only one substantial cause. Then for composite phenomena, again, there are numerous cooperative conditions. If I heard correctly, Geshe la taught that for the Vaibhāṣikas, Sautrantikas, and possibly for the Madhyamikas, the there is no consciousness during deep sleep. If that is the case, is there no longer any self grasping during deep sleep?
And if that’s the case, what’s the difference between that and liberation?
So, yes, it’s a good doubt. Basically, whether or not there is consciousness in deep sleep according to Madhyamaka is a debatable point. Nothing is clearly said. Probably not. Probably not.
However, definitely both Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika assert that there is no consciousness during deep sleep. As you remember, Asaṇga says that there is no mental consciousness during deep sleep in Chitamatra. There is obviously an Alaya Vijñāna. Now regarding your question about attaining liberation, obviously the difference between deep sleep and liberation is that when you wake up from deep deep sleep, the afflictions come back. So you haven’t abandoned them.
And this is the case because with the exception of the Vaibashikas whose position is a bit awkward, the other schools assert that once one has attained liberation, the afflictions no longer ever arise. Just as once seeds have been scorched with fire, they can no longer ever sprout. On the topic of the Vaibhāṣika and Sattvicaramshantrika position that upon the cessation of the afflictions, consciousness is severed. That seems that they are asserting that the afflictions and consciousness are one and the same thing. This is a good doubt, but the afflictions and consciousness are obviously not one.
Now the position of Vaibhāṣika in Sautrāntika is that if one were reborn after attaining the state of an arhat at death, then what would have to be reborn in this world? Obviously, one isn’t. Where we have to take rebirth and cyclic existence. But cyclic existence isn’t a place. So there are numerous ways of understanding cyclic existence as the afflictions, as one’s contaminated aggregates.
But when we say to take rebirth in cyclic existence, it’s a metaphorical way of saying that one basically takes on these contaminated aggregates. Mount Duda. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
Okay. Question. But how can they be contaminated if you would if the afflictions have ceased? You’re thinking of the Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika system. So once according to Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika, once you attain the state of an arhat in that life, your aggregates, they don’t change.
They’re the same. Right? Mhmm. Then they are still contaminated. So you can still fall sick.
So for Vaibhāṣika and Madhyamaka, karmic imprints and memory is that Karmic imprints and memory. Yeah. Just latent. What’s what I just can’t remember their view of if consciousness is, you know, not present during deep sleep. I just can’t remember where the explanation for memory and karmic In Sautrāntika, there is no such base.
It’s it’s a good way of looking at you. As a good way of looking at things is mere because at that point, the five aggregates, form, sensation, discrimination, compositional factor, and consciousness have ceased. Natalie? Fine. You are fine.
Okay. Okay. Yeah. Thank you. My question relates to this, general end of cyclic existence for all sentient beings.
Why it’s in debate? Because His Holiness the Dalai Lama has made a strong has a strong motivation to stay until cyclic existence ends as portrayed in his beautiful prayer. As long as space remains, as long as sentient beings remains, until then may I also remain dispel the miseries of the And he’s not alone in wishing for that motivation. So there are amazing powerful beings that are working for the general ending of cyclic existence, not just individual. So it’s a good that I will answer later.
I would point out that in that prayer, it’s actually a final dedication of Śāntideva. For so long as space remains and for so long as sentient beings remain, may I remain to benefit sentient beings is exactly in keeping with the actual mode of existence of reality. But I I will be, you know, some next week. You know? Mhmm.
Okay. Okay. If the mind meditating on emptiness is the cause of liberation due to the conjunction of substantial causes and cooperative conditions and cooperative conditions, would there be an artwork like one of these in the room that would be a visual representation of emptiness that person could look at? Which person? Any person.
An art a visual artwork of emptiness. So these, they are just matter. Right? Mhmm. It’s just form.
True. But there are more than one ways to you can communicate ideas in words. Right? And you can also communicate them in pictures. And if the cooperative conditions and causes of emptiness are mind meditating on emptiness, then there may be two ways to communicate emptiness.
Hence, what I’m saying, is there a visual way? No. There is no way to understand emptiness in dependence on thangkas or paintings. The only way to understand emptiness is through relying on the study of these great texts and analyses. Okay, Jasmine.
I heard the term of people got same karma, and is it means that they both have the same substantial cause and condition? It happens that two persons have the same cooperative conditions. For instance, two children with the same parents have the same cooperative conditions, their parents. But it does not happen that two beings have the same substantial cause. Also, when people say that two people have the same karma, that is false.
It is not possible for one karmic imprint to give rise to two people. Okay. So Sunday morning, the dissolution of Tārā Mandala, and this Tenzin. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- Cittamatra sem tsam pa (Tib)
- The Mind Only school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Mind Only school does not accept external objects but does assert truly established self-knowers. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
- The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
- Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
- The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
If there is no consciousness in deep sleep, what is the difference between deep sleep and liberation?
Whether there is consciousness in deep sleep according to Madhyamaka is debatable and nothing is clearly said, though probably not. Vaibhāṣika and Sautrāntika definitely assert there is no consciousness during deep sleep. In Chitamatra, Asaṇga says there is no mental consciousness during deep sleep, though there is obviously an Alaya Vijñāna. The difference from liberation is that when one wakes from deep sleep the afflictions come back, so they have not been abandoned. By contrast, apart from the Vaibhāṣikas, whose position is a bit awkward, the schools assert that once liberation is attained the afflictions never arise again, just as seeds scorched by fire can never sprout.
When people say two people have the same karma, does it mean they share the same substantial cause and condition?
No. Two people can have the same cooperative conditions. For example, two children with the same parents share the same cooperative conditions, namely their parents. But two beings never have the same substantial cause. So when people say that two people have the same karma, that is false. It is not possible for one karmic imprint to give rise to two people.