1 h 37 min · 4,133 words · 5 September 2012
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches that self-cherishing underlies suffering, pride and difficulty, and that faith in the spiritual teacher is the foundation of the path. It says this faith should be built through study of the Lamrim and reasoning, not blind belief. A question-and-answer session follows, covering what a valid cognizer is.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 38m
UUID: 6d656a9b-e434-418c-a7be-ccdbe3f16768
Date: 2012-09-05
Words: 4,129
The sequence of the seasons is the same. They are just separated. You have a six month interval between the North and the South hemisphere. Generally Tibetans consider that their fall starts in the seventh month. Otherwise, directions and so forth are the same.
This is a good way of thinking about things. If we reflect on our lives, we can see that irrespective of the job we have, whether we are, for instance, farmers or we work in retail, we tend to focus mainly on our welfare for this life. Now in this world of ours, there are numerous different religious systems, different dharma systems, but probably without exception, they all teach focusing on what happens after, specifically in the aftermath of this life. You are lucky Geshela says. He has emphasized the luckiness.
You are lucky because most people, whether they engage in the lives of lay holders or for instance are in commerce and trade have to focus mainly on this life and to fulfill the welfare of this life they must put tremendous effort. It is often not effort which leads to consequences even for this life. In this country you have extraordinary conditions. What you do with them is another question, but your conditions are exceptional. Geshela reflects on the situation in Tibet when he was younger and he remembers people had to work from morning till evening and collapse exhausted on their bed.
And even with that, they hadn’t really fulfilled what is necessary for this life. So you were very lucky. Geshela has been observing Australia on his trips downtown to the market and so forth. And he has noticed that it is a very clean country, very tidy. The houses are well kept and well maintained and are very cute.
Sometimes you see large Australians living in rather small houses. Then when he was in Tibet, he remembers small Tibetans living in rather large houses. In India nowadays, one builds more and more in the Western fashion and one can see this in Bangalore or in Mysore with modern looking houses which are probably designed for the comfort of their inhabitants. And clearly, far as the matters of this life is concerned, your conditions are exceptional. You live in comfort and wealth.
Geshela can see that. And this is a result of great roots of virtue since you cannot only focus on this life but also on future lives. Today that he is weak again. Sometimes a good cup of tea. Sometimes I don’t know.
Today. We like tea very much, Geshela says. Conditions are really excellent. Geshela can see for the rest of us just how good they are. He has direct experience of this.
So we must realize that we have exceptional conditions, great comfort and prosperity. Then difficulties and problems there will always be. It is said that apart from the state of an arhat there is no state in psychic existence in which there are no difficulties and problems. This is the lot of life in saṃsāra or psychic existence. And at present, we can take it for granted that we will experience all of us without exception problems and difficulties at some point in our life.
Here we should take on board the advice Śāntideva gives in Bodhisattvacharyavatara in which he says, irrespective of what happens, do not let it trouble your mind. In other words, we should not allow our minds to be troubled. How do we handle these problems and difficulties which arise? It is most important this case and here Geshela can speak in terms of his personal practice and his own experience. To think when difficulties beset us, I am not alone in this situation.
And to check around us and ask people to see if there are other people who are experiencing the same problems that we do. And when we see that other people are experiencing the same difficulties, the same problems we do, our mind loosens up and we think, I am not all alone in this affair, in this predicament. Others experience the same thing. It makes the whole situation much easier to bear. On the other hand, if we are convinced that we are all alone and fate has turned its face away from us, then we would experience ever greater hardship and there is an inner process of drying up which goes with this, which can lead to tremendous misery.
Eventually the face of the person darkens, they become blank. To avoid this, one must reflect on the fact that other experience these difficulties. And then ultimately we can see that for ourselves ordinary beings, we follow our bodies. Our bodies in turn follow our minds. Our minds follow delusions and delusions follow self cherishing.
This is a little bit difficult for us to understand, but we should reflect on it. We all have experience in this matter. For myself, she hopes there is hope, benefit for you. We are different in our ways of thinking, aren’t we? And all of this clearly arises from self cherishing or egotism.
Egotism is something all of us in this room have without exception to a greater or lesser degree. Whether egotism itself is a state of mind or not is to be analyzed, but it is clearly closely correlated with the apprehension of the true existence of a self. What is egotism or self cherishing? This is this idea that I am number one. Apart from me, nobody else counts.
And therefore, there is great benefit for us in reflecting on the fact that all of us without effect exception are egotistical, have egoism, and quietly over time, we are able to eliminate it. If we examine the actual situation of the egotism within our minds in function of our age, we can see clearly that egotism or self cherishing is the dominant emotion, the dominant state of mind within our minds between the ages of 20 and 40. This is a case probably for all of us in this room. In that age group, we are convinced that we are totally self sufficient. We don’t need others, we don’t depend on others.
We can do everything ourselves. If we were to need a house, we are convinced we could build it ourselves. It is at 40 that with age setting in all of us start to realize that we actually do need others. And then egotism is progressively reduced as our dependency on others increases. Our dependency on others becomes dominant from 60 onwards.
This is something we don’t need to study the great texts to understand. It is something we can see in our own experience. We only study the great texts of Buddhist philosophy to understand experiences which are beyond us and to try to attain them. And we can gain experience in this through checking ourselves first and then assessing the behavior of others. And we can see as egotism becomes more powerful, as self cherishing becomes more powerful within our minds, that pride, arrogance, anger and envy become more powerful.
They all accompany egotism. Specifically, the greater the egotism or the self cherishing, the greater the pride. Pride or arrogance in Tibetan is described by the Tibetan term, I, king. That is exactly the situation. Let us think about this.
We see this on buses and trains. I mean, the place on buses and trains belongs to everybody. All of us are equal in sharing it. And yet we see people which are very egotistical or with a lot of self cherishing, not only sitting down on a seat, but occupying a free seat with their belongings. That free seat is for a human being and yet other persons have to stand because that seat is occupied by their bag.
It’s shameful behavior, isn’t it? Yeah. That out of one’s own arrogance, out of one’s own pride, not only does one sit oneself comfortably which is legitimate, but one is so attached to one’s possessions that one’s possessions have to be comfortable too while another human being stands. Don’t do this This is very shameful behavior. It’s a sign of great egotism.
This is very important. You can see the same thing when you go through border control and so forth. Keep these things in mind. Also keep in mind at the dharma center that we should all treat each other equally with no discrimination. Some may be for instance better off than others.
Some may be more handsome than others. There should be no discrimination between people on this basis. It would be very unfortunate. And we should reflect on the fact that we are practicing the Mahāyāna and therefore it is unimportant how others or ourselves appear. Actually this emphasis on appearance is at odds with Mahāyāna practice.
We should even extend this to animals and be kind and friendly to dogs, for instance, giving them something to drink and so forth. Has direct experience of this, much experience. And Geshela can see looking at the students here that even though there is a wish to practice, they are obsessed with the affairs of this life, especially as our lives are long. And there is hardship in relationships with for instance, women spouses harassing their husbands and reciprocally. You want to be very careful that this not happen.
I can’t say if this is the case all over the world. It happened certainly in Tibet. And he believes it’s a case all over Asia where, the parents put pressure on their children, specifically their son. The son in turn puts pressure on his wife and so forth. You might think that since Geshela is a monk, he has no experience of a wife putting pressure on him or himself putting pressure on a wife, but he actually observes the behavior of the students at the center.
And on that basis, can see. Continuing this reflection on the faults of egotism or self cherishing, let us take the case of animals. Do we think that animals have self cherishing or not? Obviously, they do. Some animals have greater self cherishing or egotism than others.
Those with greater egotism typically will be proud, arrogant and solitary. Striking examples of this would be carnivorous animals, which live through devouring other animals alive. On the other hand, animals with little self cherishing or little egotism will be more humble, more quiet in their demeanor and typically will tend to function in packs because they are afraid of the situation and they lack courage. So we can see that there’s a complex of egotism or self cherishing, pride, arrogance, forcefulness on the one hand and humility on the other hand. A striking example of this would be a snake for instance, which is almost always alone.
Then it is up to ourselves to analyze this. We don’t need to study text for this. We just need to observe and analyze our own experience. And we can see that basically the greater the egotism and the self cherishing, the greater the unhappiness. The lesser the egotism and the self cherishing, the greater the happiness.
It is important therefore for us to study to be able to practice. However, we must be skillful in the means we use to study so that our study and our practice yield results. Otherwise, as Śāntideva says in his bodhisattvacharyavatara, even though we study the means for liberation and practice them, we will achieve no result. If this were to be the case, then our life will have been wasted. And therefore let us reflect for some two minutes on the lines of reasoning which Geshela has presented.
The teachings being covered at present are teachings of the Mahāyāna or the great vehicle. What is the Mahāyāna? The very foundation of the Mahāyāna is the practice of love and compassion. Now we must be very clear about one thing. There is probably not one of us in this room which is a Mahāyāna practitioner, which is a practitioner of the great vehicle.
We merely utter the words. We know very clearly for ourselves that when we make these prayers, this does not mean at all that the states of mind which are being talked about are present in our mind stream. However, one does need at the beginning faith in these topics. At the intersection of Lamrim which we have reached the practice of relying on the spiritual teacher, faith is foundational. Faith is the foundation.
So we do need faith. But the question is, what are the means to give rise to faith? The means, the foremost means to give rise to faith is study. It is through study that faith can arise within our minds. Geshela was downtown.
He met an elderly Australian who was a very devout Christian and they started talking. And between Geshela’s broken English and this elderly Australian, they were able to have a theological conversation. This elderly Australian said to Geshela that he was convinced that all of his relatives had been reborn in heaven in the pure land of Jesus Christ. And Geshela said, this sort of faith is very beneficial and a faith of that intensity is present in Buddhism. However, it is clear if we analyze that whether we call the omniscient mind Buddha, God or some type of deity, it is not possible for it to actually by its own power alone lead beings to a state of perfection.
If this were the case, it is something we would see around us and it is something which we do not see. This is the reason for which it is said in the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path, train in the foundation faith. And in this context, there’s an anecdote recounted about Atisha. Atisha was meditating and a lay Tibetan came up to him and asked in a very loud voice, Atisha, please give me some instruction to practice. Atisha did not notice him and the lay Tibetan asked again and again.
And finally, Atisha turned to him and he said, I heard you asking in your loud voice and I have only one thing to say, faith. A similar anecdote is recounted about the conqueror Wensapa. The glorious Wensapa said, all of the supreme and ordinary attainments depend on faith in the spiritual teacher. In addition to faith, we need unmistaken instructions. So Geshela does not know about this but he believes that it is probably possible to attain attainments, in other words, siddhis through the power of faith alone.
This is clearly recounted in the Lamrim. There is an anecdote in which it is said that a disciple came to a yogi who was meditating in India and begged him for an oral instruction. And this disciple was disturbing the yogi in his practice. So eventually the yogi just said to him, which meant in Indian slang of the period, get lost. And the very faithful devotees thought this was an exceptional oral instruction.
And he then went in a cave and he practiced reciting Mani. And through his faith, he obtained the power to heal many people. There’s another anecdote about once again a somewhat befuddled practitioner who thought that the mantra of the deity he had to recite was whereas in actuality the mantra was And through reciting this erroneous mantra with faith, the practitioner was eventually able to turn stones into combustible matter. The ordinary siddhis, the ordinary attainments can perhaps be obtained in this way through powerful faith. This outline to train in the root faith has three subdivisions.
The fact that one is able to train in seeing the guru as a Buddha, that one must train in seeing the guru as a Buddha, and the means of training to see the guru is as a Buddha. This must be understood to be the case irrespective of whether from his own side the guru is a Buddha or not. We have no way from our side of knowing whether from his own side the guru is a Buddha or not. What is important is to train in faith in him. For the self same reason as the old lady in the famous anecdote who became convinced that a dog’s tooth had been brought back to her by her son from a trip abroad was actually a relic of the Buddha, was able through the power of her faith to cause this dog’s tooth to replicate for the same reason through the power of faith, we ourselves will gain benefit from this practice.
It is said that when Atisha was asked the reason for which there were no Siddhas in Tibet at his period, he responded, there are no Siddhas in Tibet because the Tibetans do not have great faith in their guru. In truth, if one lacks great faith in one’s guru, even should the Buddha himself manifest for our benefit, we will derive no benefit from this. In the same same way as the Buddha’s evil cousin Devadatta was never able to see a single quality even though he was close to the Buddha. This is the reason for which Śāntideva says in his bodhisattvacharyavatara, the supreme form of dharma which is not taken to the mind will not fulfill its goal of liberating us from suffering and will become meaningless. Hence, we must train in faith which is the foundation of the path.
How do we train in this faith which is the foundation of the path through study? Through the study of what? Through the study of the Lamrim of the graduated stages of the path. And then progressively through one study of the Lamrim as one understands the reasons for which one can, one must, and the method for seeing the spiritual teacher as a Buddha one’s practice will progress and one will move upwards in the grounds and paths. And in turn, one’s faith in the transmission which has descended to us from Buddha Śākyamūni, Mahāyāna Garjuna, Atisha and so forth will increase ever more.
This is the way in which one generates immutable unshakable faith. And therefore, we must be careful not to train abstract in some sort of abstract faith in a teacher with whom we have no real relationship, whom we never consult and never meet. Instead, we should train in faith in a teacher with whom we have a real relationship and build this faith on the reasonings which are clearly expounded in the graduated stages of the path. Proceeding in this way, our faith in our spiritual teacher, in our guru, would increase progressively over time. And as a result of this, in turn our faith in the Buddha jewel from within the triple gem, which is the Buddha himself, as well as all of the enlightened masters which have succeeded him through Ārya Nāgārjuna, Asaṇga and so forth will increase.
Our faith in the Dharma jewel which are the utterances of the Buddha and here we speak of a simile of the Dharma jewel since the actual Dharma jewel is the truth of cessation and the truth of the path, which are absent within our mind stream. But our faith in the dharma as we understand it will increase. And finally, our faith in the Sangha represented by these great beings will increase. In actuality, the Sangha can only be constituted of ārya beings. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has over and again pointed out that the path for mental development is to train, to meditate in what we have studied and has emphasized the importance of study.
His Holiness emphasizes this out of his great personal experience. So here what precisely is the faith we are talking about? In the context of the the faith in the triple gem is presented as the result of a long process, starting with a presentation of the two truths which leads to a presentation of the four noble truths which leads in turn to the presentation of the triple gem. Such a faith is a faith which is ascertained by a valid cognizer. It is a faith which is rooted in reason.
This is a faith which we should aspire to. Otherwise, a faith which is rooted in nothing is of no benefit to us. We will stop here for now with the presentation of the first outlines of training in faith in the spiritual teacher, which is the fact that one is able to do so and that one must do so. And if you have questions as there is some time, Geshela will answer them. Yeah.
Yes. Go ahead. What is a valid cognizer or a Pramāna? A valid cognizer or a Pramāna is first and foremost a mind. Then, if the object of this mind has an actual mode of existence, this mind perceives its actual mode of existence in an incontrovertible or a non deceptive way.
That is a valid cognizer. No. Her faith is not a faith which is ascertained by a valid cognizer because it is at odds with worldly conventions. This is a faith which is based on mistaken instructions, a mistaken statement since a dog’s tooth was obviously not the tooth of a Buddha. But even a faith which arises in dependence on such mistaken instructions can nonetheless lead to the generation of a small amount of attainments of siddhi.
Yes, they are not valid cognizers. So it is perfectly possible for mistaken minds to give rise to tremendous accumulations of virtue. For instance, in the case of bodhisattvas, there are several means of generating bodhichitta such as the shepherd like bodhichitta and the bodhichitta of the ferryman, the ferryman-like bodhichitta which are actually mistaken states of mind because it’s impossible to generate bodhichitta in this way. But nonetheless, they can give rise in the mind of a bodhisattva to a tremendous accumulation of virtue.
Yeah. So one should think of one’s spiritual teacher as the conventional Buddha gem, not as the ultimate Buddha gem. Conventional Buddha gem, yes, yes. No, because the example which is given for the conventional dharma gem would be for instance the 12 collections of scripture. Or for the ultimate dharma gem, the truth of cessation, the third noble truth and in our fourth noble truth, noble truth of the path.
It is best to rely on one and only one Lamrim text. There are numerous Lamrim treatises but it will be very difficult for one to integrate them all in our practice. The uncommon feature within the four greatnesses of the Lamrim is that all of the teachings dawn as oral instructions. So this has to be our goal in practice. It is most important that your foundation be solid.
And for this, you should dedicate a lot of time and effort to reflect on past and future lives. Once your understanding and conviction in the existence of past and future lives is sound, you should then put your effort in understanding karma and causality. Once that is sound, you can start training in the Lamrim by meditating on death and impermanence, and then move upwards. And since we train in the Mahāyāna or the great vehicle dharma, would be of great benefit if you could reflect over and again on the thoughts of egotism or self cherishing and the qualities of love and compassion. You know, self cherishing.
You know, self cherishing. In a nutshell, this is how I want you to do it. Yeah. Yeah. And in short, that’s all.
You mean you’re women is what you’re saying. I’m sorry. You could summarize your question it would be helpful. The most important thing is actually to rely on the texts, to rely on the lamrim. Read the lamrim little bit by little bit and actually think about it.
Try to understand it. So when we speak of an incontrovertible mind, that mind’s being incontrovertible means that for a given object which it is perceiving, no other mind perceiving that object can harm it or can change its perception. Then it is said to be incontrovertible or non deceptive. You have some doubts about valid cognizer but pramanas. Geshela will be teaching Lorig next year and he welcomes you to come.
Geshela feels that if we cover in detail the divisions of mind in Lorig and Buddhist psychology and then present renunciation or definite emergence and so forth, this will be of great benefit. To give you a very easy to understand example, if at present imagine your house, your kitchen, your sleeping room, and they appear very clearly to your mind, then that is a valid cognizer. Alright.
Key terms in this teaching
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- lorig
- Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- siddhi ngö drub (Tib)
- A realization or attainment, either common or supreme. Common siddhis refer to psychic powers acquired as a by-product of the spiritual path; supreme siddhi refers to great liberation or enlightenment. LYWA
- Three Jewels triratna (Skt); kon chog sum (Tib)
- Also called the Triple Gem or the Three Rare Sublime Ones. The objects of Buddhist refuge: Buddha, Dharma and Sangha. Lama Zopa Rinpoche prefers “Three Rare Sublime Ones” as a more direct translation of kon chog sum. LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.