1 h 39 min · 5,175 words · 11 September 2013
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk comments on Tsongkhapa’s Canticle of the Stages of the Path, explaining the precious human rebirth with its eight freedoms and ten endowments. It covers why such a rebirth is rare and how it should be used for practice toward liberation and full enlightenment. The recording ends with a brief question about helping a depressed friend and a short discussion of respect.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 40m
UUID: 3e882a58-dc43-44e0-a6b0-56a8a64ce5a4
Date: 2013-09-11
Words: 5,171
So as Je Tsongkhapa says, I will translate the quote in detail as Geshela comments it. The first verse reads, there is no contentment in the pleasures of cyclic existence and this refers to the fact that cyclic existence as a whole is profoundly unsatisfactory. Hence, it is the gateway of all suffering. In other words, the source or the origin of all suffering. Its qualities are unsuitable to be called the perfections of cyclic existence.
Whatever perfections cyclic existence might have are not perfections in reality since they cannot be relied upon. And hence I beseech the spiritual teacher to bless me to understand the faults of psychic existence. These faults are to be understand through reasoning and analysis. In our cases we can see this is true since we migrate within cyclic existence through desire for the so called marvels of psychic existence which we see as marvels because we do not understand their faults. Then we can see in our own case that if we rise regularly in the morning to go to work it is precisely because we understand the qualities of work and we wish to go to work to earn money, this is something we naturally engage in.
And this is why it is said sarcastically that it is when one understands the marvels of this life that one starts talking of a precious human rebirth. Such a life however is nothing extraordinary since we will have to give up our bodies in other words we’ll have to die and none of us will make an exception to this rule. In the Four Reliences, one speaks of relying on dharma and specifically on the dharma of definitive meaning. The term relying or reliance which is used refers here to pure dharma. It is pure dharma one must rely upon.
10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition and the first of these is to focus the mind on dharma. This focusing the mind on dharma is a focusing the mind on pure dharma. And the dharma one focuses upon must in addition be a definitive dharma not an interpretable dharma. And one should do this until the time of death. And one should in addition practices dharma unto the death in an empty aromatic location literally on the cliff of a mountain.
So these are the four reliances from within the 10 jewels of the Kadampa tradition and if one does not have these four first reliances then one cannot practice dharma purely since one will not be able to relinquish this life. This means that it will be impossible for us to generate renunciation which is a striving for liberation from the suffering of all lives. Then the following three Kadampa jewels is as a result of the four reliances. One is expelled from the ranks of men, one enters the society of dogs, and one attains the status of a god. Clearly, having abandoned all work and all activities in this life and having turned into a beggar, one is expelled from the ranks of society or the ranks of men.
And then one will have become as a result Then one will have become like a dog. In this matter, one must imitate dogs who only preoccupy themselves with their food for the day and never wonder where they will sleep the next day. A true practitioner becomes like a dog. And as a result of being expelled from the ranks of men and entering the ranks of dogs, one attains the rank of a god. This refers here to the attainment of full enlightenment.
Without such type of practice, enlightenment is not possible. And the final of the 10 jewels entail first rejecting all family and friends without turning behind. In other words, rejecting one’s parents, one’s children, or one’s friends and family and focusing exclusively on attaining full enlightenment. Without allowing the tears and the intreaties of one’s family and friends as well as their scoldings from diverting us from one single purpose which is meditation. And then one attains the Vajra of liberation, which is the continuous unchanging meditation single pointed on attaining liberation.
Here one should understand that it is not so much a case of living destitute on the streets as of having that attitude. One must be satisfied with what one has, whatever accommodation one has. Even Milarepa needed some type of accommodation. And then one should stop at that and cease worrying about food and money since it is said food comes naturally to one who meditates. So the practice of pure dharma is difficult, isn’t it?
It is this pure dharma which we should practice. This is not easy. And therefore one should not be preoccupied with this life or saddle one’s mind with worries concerning this life. And instead adopt the attitude that if things happen very good, and if they don’t happen just as well. And focus therefore mainly on future lives, progressing life after life to the point where one can generate a true liberation from cyclic existence and move onwards until full enlightenment.
Then if one gains full enlightenment in this life, so much the better. Otherwise, one continues progressing in this way life after life. And therefore whatever practice we engage in, whatever meditations we engage in, whatever we do, we should focus on the attainment of full enlightenment wishing to reach this state. Instead at present, pretty much everything we do, every meditation we do is influenced by non-virtuous states of mind. The thought, oh, he or she harmed me, he or she isn’t my friend and so So, truly, most of us do not think of future lives too much.
We think overwhelmingly of the happiness of this life and focus overwhelmingly on the happiness of this life. Trying to attain the means for happiness in this life and not thinking at all of the future lives which are coming. Then among the few who think of the future lives, even fewer think of attaining a liberation from those lives, let alone full enlightenment. So when we focus in this way, that little children on this life, then we are like somebody who is building a castle of sand with his hands and destroying it with his feet. And therefore, let us generate the motivation that the dharma we hear turn into pure dharma.
And since the dharma we are hearing is a dharma of the Mahāyāna of the great vehicle, then for this to turn into pure Mahāyāna dharma, bodhichitta must be generated. Therefore, let us generate the motivation of bodhichitta for couple of minutes. So we have now reached the presentation of the human rebirth of leisure and endowment, the so called precious human rebirth after a presentation of how to rely on the spiritual teacher. This is on stanza 13 of the translation of the Canticle of the Stages of the Path. This base of leisure is superior to a wish fulfilling jewel obtaining the like will occur just this one time.
It is akin to lightning in the sky both rare and easily destroyed. Contemplating in this way having realized that all mundane activities are akin to winnowed chaff day and night continuously, you must take the essence the noble gurus have practiced in this way. You too, who wish for liberation, should wish to act thus. Generally, topic of the human rebirth of leisure and endowment is subdivided into three. The first is identifying or recognizing such a rebirth.
The second is how profoundly meaningful this rebirth is. And the third is how rare or how difficult to obtain it is. So the first verse, this base of leisure is superior to a wish fulfilling jewel corresponds to the first outline identifying the human rebirth of leisure and endowments. This base of leisure here refers to such a human rebirth which is a basis or a foundation for the practice of dharma. Such a rebirth is said to be superior to a wish fulfilling jewel.
So this base of leisure refers to our present human rebirth. However, let us be clear not all human rebirths are bases of leisure or precious human rebirths. A base of leisure or a human rebirth with leisure and the endowments must necessarily have the eight leisure or the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments. So when one says that this base of leisure is superior to a wish fulfilling jewel, this refers exclusively to a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. Not all human rebirths are superior to a wish fulfilling jewel, far from them.
Most human rebirths are merely the base for the generation of future suffering and are not superior to a wish fulfilling jewel. Only a human rebirth with the eight leasures and the 10 endowments which is used for the practice of dharma is superior to a wish fulfilling jewel because at its best it enables one to attain full enlightenment. Alternatively, it enables one to attain liberation. At the very least, it enables one to attain happiness in future lives. For that matter, happiness in this life.
A wish fulfilling jewel is unable to do all of these things. Therefore, such a human rebirth is superior to a wish fulfilling jewel. Generally speaking, most human rebirths do not qualify as a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. In addition, the four broad categories of rebirth, rebirth as a hell being, rebirth as a preta, rebirth as an animal, and rebirth as a long lived god are also known as the four states of non human leisure. These are four states in which one simply is unable to practice dharma because one lacks the leisure to do so.
If one is reborn in the hell realms one is overwhelmed by the suffering one experiences, overwhelmed to such a degree that one is unable to practice dharma actually let alone practicing dharma one is unable to even understand dharma. So overwhelmed is one by suffering. For this reason a hell realm rebirth is called a rebirth lacking the leisure of a human rebirth or bereft of leisure. And therefore reflecting from our side in detail on the extensive sufferings of the hells, we should think how fortunate I am at present not to have been born there and we should meditate on joy at the fact that we are not reborn in the hell Likewise for the or the hungry ghosts who crave food and drink and yet for whom food and drink are a constant source of suffering. When they ingest it or drink it, it does not satisfy their craving for food and drink or at times they are unable to ingest it or drink it or unable to find it.
Such beings lack the leisure to practice dharma, they lack the leisure to understand the teachings. In the case of animals, we can understand the condition of animals through observing our pet male and female dogs. Imagine yourself addressing your dog and telling him if you recited only one mani you would attain full enlightenment. Your dog will look at you and he will not understand. So dogs are basically controlled by anger and desire and constantly crave for food and for furthering their own goals.
They cannot practice any type of dharma. And therefore, we should generate joy within our mind stream at the thought that we are not reborn in this life as a hungry ghost or as an animal and think this is due to the activities of the fully enlightened beings and generate joy and meditation on this. The fourth category of beings who lack leisure are the gods of long life, the long lived gods. These are subdivided into two categories. Those of the form and formless realm on the one hand and those of the desire realm on the other hand.
The gods of the form and formless realm only experience the sensation of equanimity, equanimous sensations and never experience any type suffering as a direct result of the practice of meditative equipoise in Jnanas in previous lives. The gods of the desire realm on the other hand, only experienced happiness and never experienced suffering. Therefore, these two categories of gods viewed together experience exclusively happiness or equanimous sentiments, sensations. As a result, they have no motivation for practicing dharma and after that rebirth, the odds of their being reborn in the hell realms are very high. And we should rejoice in the fact that we have not we are not experiencing at present these four states of non leisure and make prayers not to experience them in future lives.
Therefore, we should make strong prayers. May I obtain in future lives a human rebirth of leisure and endowments with the full eight leisure from which these four states of non leisure have been completely eliminated. So these are the first four leasures, the four leisures which are in absence of being reborn in the states of non leisure in the lower realms and as a long lived god. The four final leasures are the four leasures of a human rebirth. The first is not being reborn where the Buddhist teachings have not been taught.
For instance, someone who is reborn in the continent of Uttarakoru would be reborn in a continent in which indeed the lifespan is very long and wealth is very great, but in which the Buddha has not taught. As a result, they would not be able to differentiate between virtue and non virtue, would engage exclusively in sin and be reborn after that rebirth in the lower realms? The following leisure in the context of a human rebirth is not being reborn in a barbaric land or not being reborn as a barbarian in a land which is peripheral. Here a peripheral land literally the hinterlands refers to a land in which the signs of the dharma are absent, specifically in which there are neither fully ordained monks and nuns nor novice monks and nuns. Barbarians refer to those who are raised in those countries.
The third human leisure which one needs is the leisure which is the absence of a state of defectiveness of either one of the sense organs or the mental sense organ. This refers to the capacity to understand the teachings. If the mental sense organ is defective and the person is mentally retarded, they lack the capacity to understand the teachings. Likewise, if any of the five sense organs is defective, in other words, if they are blind, deaf, mute and so forth, they are unable to access some aspect of the teachings. So all the five sense organs and the mental sense organ must function well.
And the fourth leisure, which we require as human beings is absence of wrong views. The wrong views include the wrong view that the triple gem do not exist, that karma and causality do not exist and more generally the wrong view which sees or which views the world as follows. Things exist the way I think them to exist. And therefore, one should make strong prayers so that in the future one has these four leasures and is freed from the four non leasures and meditate on this. So as we are free of the eight states of non leisure and we have the eight states of leisure, we are said to have a rebirth endowed with these eight states of leisure.
At present, the 10 endowments are subdivided into two subgroups, the five person endowments and the five endowments from the standpoint of the milieu or the environment. The five personal endowments are being born a human being in a central land, having all one’s faculties, not having committed the five heinous crimes and having enduring faith. So the first of these endowments is to be reborn as a human being. This we have at present, we are human beings. The second being reborn is in a central land is also fulfilled since we live in societies in which both and are present.
We also have the third personal endowment. In other words, all our SENSE faculties are complete certainly for everyone in this room. It is more a case of our not using our faculties correctly. There is no difference whatsoever between our physical predispositions and those of Jetsün Milarepa. The difference is that Jetsün Milarepa used his physical constitution to attain full enlightenment and we do not.
Had exactly the five senses we have. He didn’t have some sixth sense nobody ever heard about. And we use our sense organs wrongly. We use them as the tools for desire, for anger, and for benightedness. We do not use them to attain full enlightenment.
Instead, what we should do is whenever our sense organs notice an object of desire, we should reflect and think this is an object of desire and discard it and turn away from it. The fourth personal endowment which we probably have is that we have not committed any of the five heinous crimes. These five heinous crimes are killing one’s own father, patricide, killing one’s own mother, matricide, killing an arhat, shedding the blood of a Buddha or causing a schism inside the Buddhist Sangha. Gesheera, I would like to think that none of you has killed father or mother. The so called five heinous crimes which are perhaps better translated as five uninterrupted crimes, sometimes translated also as five crimes of immediate retribution are extremely heavy sins.
They are called five uninterrupted crimes, because immediately after one’s death, one is reborn within the hell realms. There is no interceding life. And this occurs unless one has confessed and purified these five heinous crimes as King Ajatashatru. Then the five endowments from the standpoint of others include first that one lives in a society in which people have faith. This refers to having faith in other words liking the Tripitaka, the collection of sutras, the collection of Abhidharma and the collection of Vinaya.
Then regarding the endowments of the environment, a Buddha must have come. This certainly is the case even though technically it is true that we have not met a Buddha. Nonetheless, we have encountered the teachings of the Buddha by the intermediary of the spiritual teacher. So the meaning of the coming of the Buddha has been fulfilled. Then the Buddha must have taught the dharma.
He must in other words have taught the meaning of going beyond suffering and so forth. And the teachings must abide. This refers in general to the fact that the Buddhist scriptures are still in existence. The Buddhist scriptures are the means for attaining the state of an arya being. However, if one has attained the realizations of the Buddhist scriptures within one’s mind stream then one can say that this attainment is present within one’s mind stream.
And those who follow the Buddhist teachings must still be present in this world. This is the case because through their presence, we will then make prayers to be able to follow in their footsteps and to imitate them. And the final endowment is that others must have benevolence in their heart. This refers to the existence of sponsors who will support those who wish to engage in meditation providing them with food and so forth. And it is therefore a human rebirth which has these 18 characteristics which is said in the first verse to be superior to a wish fulfilling jewel.
In our cases, we do have such a human rebirth of leisure and endowment. The problem is that we do not use it to good avail. We are in the situation of someone as a Tibetan proverb goes, who has a horse, does not know what a horse is and therefore has to walk on foot. Then we don’t want to be ungrateful. So everything we have at present, we owe to the kindness of someone in the past life who practiced really hard and gave us the good life we have at present.
It would be a pity if we repaid his kindness by wasting this life and creating a miserable life for someone else in the future. Then if we cannot attain full enlightenment in this life, if we cannot attain liberation in this life, if we cannot even create the conditions for a higher rebirth in this life and as a result of this life, in next lives we are reborn in the lower realms then really this life would have been wasted. Such a base of leisure is truly superior to wish fulfilling jewel isn’t it? This base of leisure has 18 characteristics. Eight states of non leisure we want to be free from and 10 endowments we want to attain.
Therefore, 18 different prayers must be made to generate the 18 causes for obtaining such a state in future lives. Then if we obtain such a rebirth in the next life, the following life and life after life after life in this way then we can proceed eventually towards a state of liberation and a full enlightenment. The second verse obtaining the like will occur just this one time refers to the second second outline. The previous verse was identifying this precious human rebirth. The second verse points out how rare this human rebirth is.
In other words, if we are not cautious at present, we will not obtain it again in the future. And it is rare in terms of its causes, in terms of the examples given for it, and in terms of its nature. The reason for which such a rebirth is difficult to obtain from the standpoint of its causes is because three different sets of causes are required to obtain or three different categories of causes. The first is the practice of pure ethics. The second is a general practice of the six perfections.
In other words, all the perfections ranging from ethics through to wisdom, ethics, generosity, forbearance, enthusiasm, and so forth. And the third is pure uncontaminated prayers to obtain such a rebirth. It is difficult to have these three. The first of these general causes for a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is pure ethics. It is very difficult to actually have pure ethics.
If we take for instance the non virtuous deed of killing, merely not having killed a human being does not qualify as having trained in the ethics of non killing. For instance, dogs and most pigs have probably never killed a human being. This does not mean that they have accumulated the ethics of non killing. Instead the ethics of non killing in the case let’s say of killing a human being means that one renounces the deed of killing, one abandons the deed of killing even though one has the capacity to do so and this must be a voluntary action. This is very rare.
The second general set of causes for obtaining a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is a practice of the six perfections in general. In other words, using ethics as a foundation, the practice of giving, the practice of forbearance, the practice of enthusiasm, the practice of concentration, and the practice of wisdom. Just as someone plants seeds in the ground, one plants the practice of these perfections in the ground of ethics. The third general cause for obtaining a human rebirth of leisure and endowment is conjoining the two preliminary causes with stainless prayers. This is very difficult.
Generally prayers themselves are not difficult to make. It is the stainless aspect of the prayer which is difficult to engage in. Because it means that all of these deeds we have engaged in a forbearance, of ethics, of generosity, must be exclusively dedicated to obtaining a human rebirth in a future life. And must not in any way be stained by the preoccupations of this life such as getting a better job, being respected by others, being seen as a good dharma practitioner, making a good marriage and so forth. So these three general sets of causes are necessary to obtain a precious human rebirth, a human rebirth with these 18 characteristics, the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments.
If one wishes to obtain a mere human rebirth, just this human body of ours, then merely protecting some type of ethics is sufficient. The third subdivision or outline of the presentation of the human rebirth of leisure and endowments is its rarity in terms of examples. Excuse me, the second outline within its rarity is its rarity in terms of examples. And this is clearly explained in the third stanza, the third verse of the Canticle of the Stages of the Path and in the example given by Geshe Potawa, in which Geshe Potawa says, rare as grass on the roof or as a turtle passing its neck through a yoke. Grass on the roof refers to the rarity of grass on the roof of a house when compared with a huge amount of grass in the field.
You can see for yourself that one does see rather seldom grass on roofs. There’s a huge amount of grass in the fields. Then we can see this for ourselves. If you take Iraq as a country for instance, there are many millions of people in Iraq, but how many Buddhists might there be in Iraq? Are they one or 2,000?
Then the situation is similar in our world. How many true Buddhists are there? And in the example of the turtle passing its neck through a golden yoke, One imagines a golden yoke floating on the ocean hither and thither and a turtle surfacing from the nether depths of the ocean every century. The odds of obtaining a precious human rebirth are akin to that of a turtle passing its neck when it surfaces after a century through a golden yoke. Here, the turtle represents ourselves, the nether depths of the ocean represent the depths of ignorance to which we have sunk.
The golden yoke represents the Buddhist teaching. And the fact that the golden yoke is floating on the ocean left and right represents the fact that the Buddhist teachings pass from world to world, from universe to universe and are not always present in the same universe. So world in general, the Buddhist teachings are present in the universe, they may be very rare in the world in which we are reborn. Finally, the third outline of the rarity of a human rebirth of leisure and endowment refers to its rarity from the standpoint of its nature. And this is understood through comparing the size of the various realms.
The majority of sentient beings are present in the hell realms. Then the realms of the pretas are less populated than the hell realms and the animal realms less populated than the realms of the pretas. The human realms are less populated than the animal realms and the divine realms even less populated again. So we can see that compared to the lower realms, human rebirth in general, this does not include precious human rebirth are extremely rare. Such a rebirth is not only rare as is said in the third verse of stanza 13, it is also easily destroyed.
So this would involve an explanation of impermanence for which we do not have time today and reading the rest of the verse contemplating in this way, having realized that all mundane activities are akin to winnow chaff, day and night continually, one should take the essence. The noble gurus have practiced in this way, you too who wish for liberation should wish to act thus. So here, we winnowed chaff refers to that part of the grain which is useless and which is cast away. And it is a simile for all of the activities related to our happiness in this life which are of no meaning and should be discarded. The noble gurus have practiced in this way.
You too should wish to act. Thus, this is how we should act. Oh, yeah. So we shall stop here for today. Thank you, Geshela.
My question is regarding a friend that I know. She appears to be she is quite close to me she appears to be very depressed. And it seems that one of the characteristics of Australians when they get depressed is that they hate themselves. She’s not religious, but she’s not opposed to religion. She’s not opposed to Buddhism.
Is there a practice that I could recommend to her that doesn’t involve a belief in rebirth or in karma or in refuge that might be of help to her at least in the short term? So there is nothing she can practice. This is somebody who is irreligious therefore none of the Buddhist practices are of benefit. She should focus on the meaning of this life and she should do whatever she feels like doing. It is possible to give someone like that good mundane advice for this life.
If you do this then these will be the problems, if you do that then those will be the problems. That is a sort of advice which can be given. Then if that advice is not heeded there is nothing which can be done. Respect seems to be very respect is very important in Buddhism. So respect for the Buddha, respect for the teachings, respect for the teacher, etiquette, etcetera.
What can we do to actually increase the development of respect? One must think of the reasons for which respect is of benefit. Respect is fundamentally of benefit to oneself. For instance, if one respects someone who has qualities, then one respects those qualities as well and one self derives benefit from this. Let us say for instance, if one encounters someone who is a fully ordained monk or nun and one shows respect for this person, one is showing respect for the qualities which they epitomize and as a result of that one is showing respect for all these qualities and oneself accrues merit.
On the other hand, if one shows disrespect or contempt then oneself accrues demerit. Secondly, through reflecting on causality, one understands that through showing respect to another in this life in the future, oneself will be the recipient of respect. Through showing disrespect and contempt to a person in this life in the future, oneself will be the recipient of disrespect. That’s how it should be done. Living and Dying Meaningfully, teaching on the October, the Saturday and Sunday of the long weekend.
There are some flyers that you can obtain from Aaron and registration is now open. Thank you. Elliot, I think it was last week, did an interview, second I think it’s the second one now on RRR, which is a community station. And that will air on Monday October 28 at 07:30PM and Wednesday October 30
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- definitive meaning nitartha (Skt); ngedön (Tib)
- One of two main ways of understanding a Dharma teaching, this one is where the content is be taken literally and not open for interpretation, as opposed to the interpretive meaning. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- formless realm arupyadhatu (Skt); zug me kham (Tib)
- The highest of samsara’s three realms, with four classes of gods involved in formless meditations. The four levels are limitless sky, limitless consciousness, nothingness and the tip of samsara. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
What can we do to actually increase the development of respect?
Think about the reasons why respect is beneficial, and reflect on causality. Respect benefits oneself first of all. If one respects someone who has good qualities, one respects those qualities too, and one gains from this. For example, showing respect to a fully ordained monk or nun means respecting the qualities they epitomize, and one accrues merit. Showing disrespect or contempt, on the other hand, brings demerit. Reflecting on causality, one understands that respect shown to others in this life means one will receive respect in the future. Disrespect and contempt shown to a person in this life mean one will receive disrespect in the future.