Lam Rim — lamrim 2

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — lamrim 2
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: lamrim 2.mp3

UUID: 3e516d5f-85d1-4167-a190-24a76a511f4f

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)

Duration: 1h 39m

Words: 4,420

So as is said in Maitreya’s Uttara Tantra, within the three first trainings, the ordinary praised as having the opportunity to practice generosity. And here, this verse of Uttara Tantra does not refer so much to the three first perfections as to the three practices thereof. And it is said that the ordinary have the possibility to practice generosity to attain happiness. And therefore, these two verses of Uttarotantra refer to the practice of the three first perfections, the perfections of generosity, of ethics, and of forbearance. And when the Uttarotantra says that it is the laypeople in the majority who are praised as having the opportunity to practice generosity, what is implied is that this is not a practice for which the Sangha has the opportunity to engage in.

And, you should from your side analyze why this is the case. Why is it the case that, lay people have the opportunity to engage in the practice of generosity? Now when you engage in this analysis is precisely what I teach in Tibetans since the majority of you do not speak Tibetan. Do you understand? So here, when one refers to the perfection of the generosity, Dana paramita, it is subdivided, as you know, into three.

And it is to the totality of these three that references made. The generosity of giving material objects as well as that of giving dharma and that of giving the protection from fear or fearlessness. And here when states that the majority of laypeople should engage in this, then clearly, this is implied or this implies that it’s a majority, but not the totality which necessarily must. So in your opinion, within these three types of generosity, which is the main one laypeople should engage in? So therefore, the term majority or principle here refers to the principle form of generosity lay people, householder should practice.

And as you said, this is a generosity of making material offerings. This is not the case for those who are ordained. Then what is the principal obstacle to the practice of the generosity of making material offerings? It’s stinginess or avarice. Now what is stinginess or avarice?

It is preferring wealth or money over dharma. Now this is something which does not arise for people who are ordained. They do not have the opportunity. Then what does it mean to be ordained? To be ordained means to be satisfied with whatever happiness one has to train in contentment and to use this as a foundation for study.

Then it is also said that ethics is praised as a practice for householders. Then within these three subdivisions of ethics, the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues, the ethics, of the, practice of the Bodhisattva, and the ethics of enacting the wheel of others, which precisely is the ethics, which is the main practice of lay people or householders. The main practice of for lay people or householders is the abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. As a householder, one has numerous opportunities to do this. Then this obviously refers to the first subdivision of ethics, which is restraining from wrong behavior, which is a euphemism for abstaining from the 10 non virtuous deeds.

And clearly, this is a practice with which laypeople have a strong connection. Laypeople have the opportunity to abstain from killing, stealing, sexual misconduct, lying, and so forth. Then if we take, for instance, non virtuous deeds like stealing, this arises frequently as an issue for lay people precisely because they have large family responsibilities. They have responsibility responsibilities for their relatives and so forth. So at present, I have a question for you.

As far as the practice of forbearance is concerned, why is it said that this is the best practice for laypeople? Do you understand? Why? Yeah. Yet.

And So forbearance Forbearance has three subdivisions. You should be thinking of these three subdivisions. So as you remember, forbearance has three divisions. The first is the forbearance of putting up with those who harm us. The second is the forbearance of accepting suffering.

And the third is the forbearance of generating certainty with respect to dharma. Now the quote of Uttara Tantra implies that one does not necessarily have to generate all of these forbearances, but a majority, therefore, a proportion of these, probably mainly the first one. So when it is said that we should meditate or practice on forbearance of patience, what is referred to is probably mainly training or practicing in the forbearance with respect to those who wish to harm us. So the reason for which the type of forbearance, householders or laypeople should train in principally is forbearance with respect to those who wish to harm us is precisely because as householders or lay people, one functions in society and in communities. And in societies or communities, one encounters people who wish to harm us, angry people.

Now the reason for which this is the main practice for householders, kimpa in Tibetan, is because as the term householder indicates, householders have houses with families. In other words, they have houses with husbands or wives, parents, children, And in this context, the opportunity for harm of this nature arises. This is not the case for those who are ordained who have abandoned their families. And therefore, this is why Candrakīrti in Madhyamakāvatāra says, the lay people or the householders should principally practice the three first generosity, ethics, and forbearance. Then this is not only something which is said, this is something which we can think along with.

Yes or no? Yes.

So when we refer here to what is discordant or disharmonious with the trainings in generosity, ethics and forbearance, one refers principally to exterior phenomena or entities which are discordant with this training. For instance, what is discordant with the generosity of giving material things? Stinginess or avarice. Stinginess or avarice arises independent on exterior things. Likewise, the first subdivision of ethics, the ethics which subdues wrong behavior, in other words, the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues occurs principally dependent on exterior phenomena.

Likewise, the first subdivision of forbearance, the forbearance of tolerating those who harm or wish to harm us has as incompatible component anger, and anger arises dependent on exterior persons or beings who induce it. Now regarding the nature of forbearance, the nature of forbearance is said to be an untroubled mind. Now forbearance is subdivided into three. The forbearance of supporting those who wish to harm us, the forbearance of accepting suffering, and the forbearance of generating certainty with respect to dharma. So now within human society, we have a particularly strong connection with the first practice of forbearance.

The forbearance of supporting or tolerating those who wish to harm us. And forbearance in general is important for society. So when we speak of practicing forbearance, what do we mean? We mean to meditate on forbearance. So when we speak of practicing forbearance, actually, how do we practice forbearance?

We need an opponent, a target. Then all of us, we have an opponent, a target, don’t we? So Geshe was asking me if I have one, and I said I definitely do. So here, when we speak of meditation or of practice of forbearance as opposed to studying forbearance, we need a target. We need an opponent.

We need someone who is at odds with us. Without an opponent, someone who is at odds with us, there is no possibility to practice forbearance. Forbearance is not practiced in the void. So before practicing or training in forbearance, we must understand the faults of that which is antithetical to forbearance, which is anger. Otherwise, to practice or to train in forbearance without understanding the faults of anger is a bit like loosing an arrow, shooting an arrow without having seen the target.

As Śāntideva says in Bodhicharyavatara, one must analyze the force of anger through numerous gates of reasoning. And therefore, as Śāntideva says, therefore, through numerous gates of reasoning, analyze the key points of forbearance. Now the key points of forbearance here refer both to the advantages of forbearance and to the faults of anger, and this must be analyzed carefully before training in forbearance. And therefore, the way we should practice is from the very moment we get up in the morning, we should think, will train in forbearance. I shall not allow anger to arise in our mind stream.

Now we have numerous opportunities as householders to train in forbearance through difficulties with our wives, with our husbands, with our children and so forth. And therefore, there are two steps to be trained in. The first is, to reflect on the thoughts of anger and then to engage in the practice of forbearance. Now clearly, once anger has arisen within our mind stream, we have been unable to prevent it from arising, we must at any cost prevent physical or verbal manifestation of anger. Once we lash out with our fists or with our words then the damage is done.

And after that, once the anger has subsided, all that is left is shame. So for instance, if we have children and we are unable to control our temper and, speak brutally, to the children, then the children will never understand the, damage caused by harsh speech. Then even if we don’t have children, we may have parents or other relatives, and anger does arise in relation to our parents or our relatives. Anger sometimes arises in the context of empathy or love. So this is therefore the reason for which it is said that the practice of forbearance is so important for laypeople.

In Geshe la’s own case, he does not have the opportunity to give rise to anger or jealousy simply because he lives alone. Then in the cases of the students, they go all over society and have numerous opportunities to deal with anger and jealousy. And I would imagine that Jampa Triple, and don’t experience a lot of occasions to practice the forbearance of dealing with someone who wishes to harm them. Is it great? Oh, oh, She has a we must create opportunities for practice.

So this is why it is said in Uttara Tantra that the practices of generosity, ethics and forbearance are placed for a majority of householders in opposition to those who are ordained. And this statement is one which is born out of experience. And therefore, it is extremely important as is taught in Bodhicharyavatara to reflect over and again on the faults and the defects of anger and to ask ourselves, what will I do if it arises? How should I prevent it from arising? This is how one should proceed.

So one of you, actually, mother of one of the students said last time, I am my own enemy. This is very true. Actually, there is a stanza in which Buddha Śākyamūni says, I am my own teacher alone. Whose teacher could I be? I am my own foe alone.

Whose foe could I be? So the stanza reads, I am my own enemy. Who else could be my enemy? And therefore, when, Buddha Śākyamūni when he said, we are our own enemies, this can be understood the we can be understood as referring to self cherishing because self cherishing is different from us. And self cherishing, obviously, the Lam Rim, we presented as different from the ignorance which grasps at a self, but they are in affiliation.

Self cherishing arises from the ignorance which grasps at a self. And therefore, since anger arises from the ignorance which grasps at a self, if we are able able to eliminate the ignorance which grasps at a self, we will eliminate anger as well. Now what precisely is the antidote to the ignorance which grasps at itself? The wisdom realizing emptiness. So now how precisely can we eliminate anger?

To actually eliminate anger from the root, it is necessary to generate the wisdom realizing emptiness, but this is very difficult. And actually, if I were to explain this in detail, all of us would probably doze off happily. So instead, it is possible to eliminate anger contingently or occasionally through the application of forbearance. And for forbearance, we need to train in forbearance when someone else is generating anger within our mind stream. So, basically, if we analyze anger, anger has a set of causes and conditions.

Anger’s main cause is the self grasping or the self cherishing within our mind stream. But anger also has conditions. One of the conditions of anger is an opponent, someone whose mental continuum is different from us and who is our opponent. Then how do we counter anger when we deal with such a person? We must get closer to that person.

If we move further away, the anger will increase. So as Śāntideva says, therefore, one should meditate on forbearance after having analyzed carefully its key points. And here, the crux is to try to become closer, mentally closer to those who are opponents or who are hostile to us. Then we have to find means to become closer to them. And if we manage to do so, then anger will decrease and this will be a very pleasant state of affairs.

Do you understand? So therefore, how should one handle situations which might generate anger in which someone insults us or, for instance, strikes us with a stick or a stone? We have to reflect. If we, for instance, let’s say, are hit by someone with a stick or a stone, we would not get angry with the stick or the stone, would we? Because you would say, they have no autonomy.

They are being wielded by someone else, the person. But actually, the person themselves have no autonomy. They are under the sway of anger. They are actually driven insane by anger. So it is through analyzing the thoughts of anger and viewing the anger as opponent that we should proceed.

Then there’s a lot of food for thought here. Then when we are dealing with an opponent or someone with whom we are at odds, we should think, my goodness, and generate compassion within ourselves thinking he or she has fallen under the sway of anger. So let us now reflect during a couple minutes as follows. All of us have anger and jealousy within our mindstream. Then if we analyze, probably the root of anger, of jealousy, and of envy are the same.

If the one arises, the other will arise as well. And reflecting like this, we should think that all of us in this room are the same in experiencing suffering from anger, jealousy, and envy, and give rise to compassion for each other. And then wonder what means we can find to eliminate this. Please open the page one, which shall recite 1B, two, three, four and also page five number six, offering, both one and three. Thank you.

So when we speak of the study of forbearance, we are referring to the study of the faults of anger. And through studying the faults of anger over and again, one will definitely generate the wish to realize forbearance. Then if independent of this, one has the good fortune of meeting someone who gets angry once with oneself and wishes to hit one with a stick or to insult one and hurt one’s feelings and one’s mind remains at peace, then the practice of forbearance has definitely occurred. So the best here is savage insults, which pierce to the core. Then, obviously, if someone draws a gun or a sword, I would suggest taking your legs to your neck.

Then the best, obviously, is to train in forbearance when dealing with insults and offenses. This is a common occurrence. Then to have the opportunity to practice when someone draws a gun or a knife, that is a rare occurrence in society. Then in the old days in Tibet, some forty years ago, there were long feuds which opposed people. And, obviously, these were marvelous occasions to train in forbearance.

Silly. You know? When I was in Tibet, that time, you know, that’s the reason. Very silly. Then we should prepare for these events.

And then if, let us say, a if someone comes and let him just take what he wants. Then the second practice of forbearance is practice of accepting suffering. And here, when this occurs in a family setting with children and so forth, then one should take the suffering on board. One should accept it, and it actually links with the practice of of giving and taking because one should pray, may all the sufferings of this world mature on me. Then the third subdivision of forbearance, the forbearance of generating certainty with respect to the dharma occurs in our case when we study the Lam Rim.

Sometimes when we study the Lam Rim, it is easy and pleasant, and sometimes it is difficult and not that pleasant. Then here, we must generate mental fortitude. Then at present, I’ll take your questions. One question per person, and please pure questions, questions on the topic. I have a number of questions, but I’ll stick to one.

The first one is cooperative causes. Could Geshe-la say something about cooperative causes where I’ve been the cause of the anger that’s come back to me. So I’ve done something to harm another, And they’ve retaliated. Uh-huh. In this life?

So your question is if you experience anger in this life, it’s because you harmed someone in a previous life. Is that it? No. No. Just something that I’ve I’ve done, and it could be at any time.

You know, I’ve been the cause of Yes. So indefinitely, in that case, if anger arose in the other person’s mind, you would have been the condition for that anger. The practice of forbearance needs an enemy, and it comes it’s a practice that is after the generation of fully characterized great compassion where one feels close to all sentient beings and feel compassion for them. So where would be the enemy in that case if you have that sense of closeness and compassion to all sentient beings? So So indeed, what you say is true.

It’s an excellent question To once you once you have generated uncontrived great compassion, you can engage in the practice of the perfection of patients without uncontrived great compassion. You cannot train in the perfection of forbearance. And once you have generated uncontrived great compassion, how could you have an enemy indeed? Then that is actually marvelous. If that was the case, we would stop there.

But, you forget that there are two other types of forbearance. There is a forbearance of accepting one’s own suffering, and there is a forbearance of generating certainty, within the dharma, and you can practice those two after generating great compassion. Mhmm. Geshe la was saying that an enemy is not autonomous because they are under the sway of their anger. It follows then that no being is autonomous because we’re all under the sway of the six root afflictions.

It follows then that without autonomy, one would not have the capacity or the self capacity to transform one’s own mind. What you say is true, but there are differences in the intensity of the afflictions. As is said, as is said in, is no sin greater than anger. There is no ascetic practice greater than forbearance. Then clearly, once we are totally overwhelmed by anger, it is difficult to speak of autonomy.

Okay. So, I feel like things are a little bit black and white, and there’s two areas that I was hoping you may be able to give options for. One of the first ones is that I don’t fall into either category of an ordained person or a householder. I’m not responsible for a family. I don’t have those issues.

So in some sense, my concerns aren’t being addressed, and I don’t know what you would call that or whether or not I’m asking for too much to extend beyond the doctrine. Maybe I am. That’s the first category. Second category I have a problem with is, although I believe it’s correct to come from the perspective of emptiness that it’s wonderful when someone has a go at you and it gives you a chance to practice. There’s a fine line between that and emotional abuse for someone trying to live in the human world.

So I feel like there needs to be some sort of beginner step, if you like, between the two because it’s a it’s quite a a big thing to jump from self cherishing to emptiness and back again and forth again. I feel like we need somewhere in the middle where we can practice forbearance without falling to pieces. Anyway, so there’s just two areas that I noticed are very stark.

So before engaging in the practice of patience or forbearance, the most important step is to carefully reflect on the faults of anger and see, what the faults of anger are. And once one has reflected on that, then one can see whether one wants to practice forbearance or not. The first part of the question? Yeah. Yeah.

I asked Gisha permission to give you an example from my family history about what anger means. I don’t think you have this sort of anger in Australia. So, I come from my father’s side from a society of blood feuds. Typically, the feuds would last a couple generations. For my grandfather, the blood feud had lasted one century between my grandfather’s family and the family of his wife to be.

So people killed each other because they belonged to these two families for one century, very high families in the country. And my grandfather was married to my grandmother. It was an arranged marriage. To put an end to this feud, no one understood. Now, if you take the logic of anger to the end, which is it is taken in Montenegro, this is what it leads to.

The policy was you killed all males so that no one would come after you. So think of what anger means. If you’re going to go that route, are societies which do this like Afghanistan. Think where this leads us. My grandfather was 16 when he was married.

My grandmother was 11. 11? 11. Oh, very young. They didn’t stay together, obviously, but they were married at 14.

But if you’re going to go the logic of anger, think about it. This is what we’re talking about. And My grandfather was of Montenegro, which means he was the second man after the king of Montenegro. And in 1928, he had organized the, you know, integration of Montenegro in Yugoslavia. A young man came to him on the streets and said, I disagree with what you did, Voivode Ilya.

You know, this is nonsense. You harmed the country. And my grandfather was an older man. He said, is that so? He drew his gun.

He shot him on the street. Then he went to the police. He gave the gun to the police. He said, this young man came to me. He said this and this and this, and naturally, I killed him.

But here is my gun. If you want, you know, you can arrest me. Then, obviously, it was a different world back then. So the police said to my grandfather, if this is as you said, it was very delicate to say that to my grandfather. Then there is no reason to leave your gun with us.

It is settled. And this is how a young man died for a couple of words. This is the logic of anger. So the key, therefore, to eliminate anger or jealousy is for us to become closer to each other. And then independence of this, we can extend this in a broader sphere.

Okay. Yep. Geshe-la, when you say getting closer to people, you mean and mentally closer? Do you mean, looking at the positive traits of the other person, looking at the lovable qualities of the other person in order to feel emotionally closer to them. Is that what you’re talking about?

That’s the best way the way way you proposed. To get close to someone, you should reflect on their qualities. Geshe-la, how would we apply that thinking to the second category of accepting our own suffering? So the practice of the second category of forbearance accepting suffering would occur, for instance, when you experience suffering due to your children, due to your partner, and you accept the suffering. You take it on board.

Mhmm. And just one question. I’m just trying to reconcile two concepts. One is accepting the insults of others and then on the other side protecting or defending one’s reputation which I think is an ancillary Bodhisattva vow. So can Geshe la just help me to reconcile those two?

Do you see these as incompatible? I guess it depends on the motivation, but it can easily be confused, I guess, in terms of defending oneself for the wrong reasons. Which of the 46 ancillary vows is it? I I would have to look it up. I see.

So check and let us know next time. Okay. Yeah. Uh-huh. Just one.

Mhmm. It’s related to that in the sense of, I understand harsh speech to be defined as words that cause harm to another. Given that we’re not responsible for the karma of others and we can’t be responsible for their interpretations of our words, I find it difficult to, like Chris said, to defend oneself or to stand firm or assert oneself against insult or injury without causing similar harm to the other person. So how does one walk the tightrope of not putting up with any kind of abuse, but at the same time not engaging in harsh harsh speech? You’re asking the same question as Chris.

Understand. Now Geshe-la understands, I think, your doubt, which is a distinction between true and false criticism. So Geshe-la will give the answer next time. Yeah. Okay.

Thank you. This Saturday is the November 19 and the final in the series of three principles of the path with Ilya at 02:00. And then on Sunday, Lhabab Düchen Puja at 06:00, one of the big funds

Key terms in this teaching

bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
puja chö pa (Tib)
Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top