TBI Recordings — 2012-04-07 – KR (2)

TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)
TBI Recordings — 2012-04-07 - KR (2)
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2012-04-07 – KR (2).mp3

UUID: 42bcf980-1546-4f87-b5f3-8903e36031dd

Teacher: —

Collection: TBI Recordings (Khensur Rinpoche)

Duration: 1h 22m

Words: 3,696

How was lunch? So full. Italian food is tasty, isn’t it? Good. The flowers come recently.

Oh, in the park. Yes. Yes. Additional notice that there are new flowers in the park over there. They arrived on Tuesday.

It’s a beautiful set up, little plane. People can play. They can gather. It’s very pleasant for twenty, thirty minutes when it’s empty to go for a walk there or have a meal. The body has to be relaxed a bit, doesn’t it?

Dharma is really of benefit, isn’t isn’t it? And even those who do not accept any dharma, if they were to reflect a little bit, might perhaps see this benefit. Last year when Geshela went for a lunch by the seaside with Tenzin, a gentleman came up to them and noticing Geshela was a monk and asked him to pray for his wife who was in a terminal phase of cancer of the throat and was expected to die within the next two or three days. Then Geshela from his side, naturally, prayed for her. Unfortunately, he heard she had died.

Such prayers seldom are of any benefit since it is from the side of the person that there has to be this foundation on which the prayers can build. But he feels it shows that when the opportunity arises, which means when people face tremendous hardship, then they understand the benefit of the dharma. So for that reason, it is now when we all in this room are in good health that we should prepare for those moments and put effort. So don’t become uptight when Geshela explains these difficult topics such as impermanence and this profound dharma and feeling overwhelmed. We are preparing for later on.

Gesheera thinks probably you don’t get uptight. He thinks you’re quite courageous as a group. So yesterday evening after Carol was gone, the doorbell rang and Geshela wasn’t quite sure who it was. He opened the doorbell the door and it was a lady called Em who comes from time to time. And she said to Geshela that a Sri Lankan nun had just passed on at the hospital two hours ago, and she asked Geshela to make some prayers for her, which Geshela naturally did.

Then he asked this lady just how far she lived from the center, and she said fifteen minutes away. And he thought to himself, if she lives fifteen minutes away, how come she doesn’t come to the center when she’s healing and healthy? I think you should have made these prayers and the hospital’s name as you understood was Andra Hospital. When Geshe went to the hospital and he saw the body, he was very surprised because the body had become completely white and the hand was tilted at an angle with the arms crossed like this on the chest. Gesheera checked the body’s temperature.

The body was completely cold. And he noticed that pictures had been put around the body of his son and his son and his his his said, you can stay if you want. I myself will do some prayers for fifteen minutes. He recited. Then what has Kurgeshira do but recite Lama Chöpa?

Then everyone left the room and he was alone with his dead body. Then it was completely white and Geshela felt a bit odd. So generally speaking, this sort of experiences of benefit for oneself. How beneficial it is for the departed person is open to question, but we ourselves will definitely go this road. There’s no doubt whatsoever about it.

We will end up like that lady. Then Gesheera saw many cases of people before the death process had started and after death. He has firsthand experience in this. So in her case, one of her legs was stretched out. The other leg’s leg was bent in.

Generally, the bending of the legs can be a signature of death. So when Geschilla’s maternal uncle passed on, he was present, and he was trying to ascertain whether his uncle was still alive or not. He checked the breath. There was no breath. He said something in the ear of his uncle.

There was a contraction of the limbs, and then his uncle passed on. Then generally speaking, and this is really in keeping with the texts, the body remains warm after the eye and the ear consciousnesses have ceased to function. So it is the Tibetan tradition to mutter in the whisper in the ear of the dead person. You must think of His Holiness the Dalai Lama and meditate on him. This is a Tibetan usage.

Then those who die of old age and have practiced virtue tend to have a very quiet and smooth death. And generally speaking, when the death is very smooth, one should do one’s best not to disturb the body of the dying person because there are key points of practice which can be engaged in at that point. And this is a little talk on this. As says in the foundation of all qualities, Our body and life are like a bubble of water. They will quickly disappear.

After death, our karma will follow us like a shadow follows the body in life. The meaning of this stanza is that our body and life is evanescent like a bubble of water. It is transient and fragile, quickly destroyed And as it is swiftly destroyed, we should realize that in the self same way as one’s shadow follows one when one walks in the sun, sometimes behind, sometimes in front, likewise, the virtuous and non virtuous karma which we have created in this life would follow us life after life like our shadow. And Je Tsongkhapa’s foundation of qualities continues through generating definite, stable ascertainment of this, eliminate the collection of sins and engage in the practice of virtue. Having realized this in other words, we should eliminate all of the faults we have accumulated and train in virtue.

And for this, we need to train in mindfulness, in vigilance, and in attention. And what this means is that if we have, for instance, taken the vow of abstaining from the 10 non virtuous deeds, it is not sufficient to have taken this vow. This vow must be maintained and protected through the force of recollection and of village vigilance. If we do this continuously, we would accumulate huge waves of merit. And what is referred to here is precisely the recollection referred to in Maitreya’s Abhishamaya Lankara, recollect the teachings of the Sutra.

The recollection here is therefore a recollection which protects us against breaking, the vow to protect ourselves from, engaging in any of the 10 non virtuous deeds. Now in the case of the ethics of abandoning the 10 non virtuous deeds, this ethics will only arise within our mind stream, if we have generated at the least the motivation of aspiring for betterment in future lives. If our motivation was our welfare in this life, we will not have generated this vow. So when that ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues is generated within the mind, the intention which is related to that is none other than a mental factor which participates to the chain of the 12 the 12 limbs of dependent arising. And if this is correctly generated, it is basically certain as a result that we will be reborn in a higher rebirth.

Why is this the case? Because that motivation which engages in an abandonment of the 10 non virtues for the sake of not being reborn in the lower realms and with a wish to be reborn in higher realms realms in the future initiates a karma. So if we take the example of the karma of killing an animal with a clear intention of killing it, then this will with 100% certainty produce a lower rebirth such as a rebirth as an animal. However, if wishing not to run afoul of the law and to be pursued by the police, one does not engage in deeds which are forbidden by the law such as murder, then these deeds, in as much as their motivation is maintaining one’s happiness and comfort in this life, are not virtuous deeds in the slightest. They probably are at best neutral deeds.

So one has to reflect here clearly on the differences in the motivation between striving for the wheel of this life and striving for the wheel of future lives. Now regarding further divisions of comma in terms of of contaminated comma in terms of its maturation, one can divide comma into karma whose experience is seen, comma whose, which is experienced in another life, comma which is experienced after many lives and comma whose maturation is uncertain. Comma, the first division, comma whose experience is seen refers to comma which matures immediately. The second subdivision, comma which is experienced in another life refers to karma which is accumulated in this life and which matures in the immediately subsequent life. The third subdivision comma which matures after numerous lives refers to karma which will mature after the subsequent life at least.

And the final subdivision, comma whose maturation is uncertain, refers to karma which although accumulated is followed within the following instant by the application of the antidotes and regarding whose maturation we cannot be definite. Another subdivision of karma is between comma which is meritorious comma, comma which is non meritorious comma and comma which is immutable. Immutable comma here refers to karma which is generated independence on one of the concentrations. In other words, independence on Samatha or Vipassana and above. It leads to rebirth in the form or the formless realms from the threefold subdivision of samsara in desire form and formless realms and is called immutable because its maturation can only be in those realms.

Karma which causes rebirth in the desired realm, on the other hand, is called mutable comma. It is called mutable karma because it can be transformed. For instance, if someone practices merit on a very large scale, thereby creating the cause for a higher rebirth, nonetheless, through the power of the degeneration of that person’s ethics, it is possible for that person to be reborn in a lower realm. This is for the subdivisions of contaminated karma. Now regarding uncontaminated comma, uncontaminated karma is defined as comma which does not arise under the power of the afflictions.

Such karma can only be generated within the mental continuum of Shravaka or Prateka Buddha, Arias or Mahayana, Aria beings. In the case of the Shravaka and Pratyaka, it is under the direct power of their direct realization of emptiness. In the case of the Mahayana Aryas, it is under the power of that plus their practice of cherishing others. Now in addition to the division of karma between contaminated and uncontaminated comma, there is a third category of comma. This is the karma which is accumulated by a being in meditative equipoise on the selflessness of persons.

The intention which is related to the virtuous karmic imprints accumulated by such a being in the meditative equipoise on the selflessness of persons is neither contaminated nor uncontaminated. There is a third subdivision of karma into karma of white maturation, karma of black maturation, and karma which is a mixture of the white and the black. So the first category of karma, karma of white maturation, is, karma which is performed with both a virtuous intent and a virtuous completion. The second category, is karma of black maturation, is karma which is performed with both a non virtuous intention and a non virtuous maturation. The third, karma which is a mixture of black and white, is karma which is performed with a virtuous motivation but with a non virtuous completion.

The third category of karma would refer to instance to the karma which is accrued by Buddha Shakyamuni in a previous life when as a merchant among a group of 500 other merchants, he learned that a robber was planning on slaying all 500 merchants to despoil them. And despite his attempts to prevent the robber from doing this, the robber planned to go ahead. Then weighing on the one hand the benefit which was evident for the 500 merchants if they were not slayed, And on the other hand, the fact that he himself would be reborn in the lower realms if he slayed the robber motivated by compassion, he slayed the robber. A further division of karma is the fourfold division of karma which is which has been performed but not accumulated, karma which has been accumulated but not performed, karma which has been both performed and accumulated, and a karma which has been neither performed nor accumulated. An example of the first category, karma which has been performed but not accumulated, would be for instance the karma which is performed when one performs a deed by coercion without any possibility of avoiding to do it.

It’s worth thinking about this because we may encounter these experiences. A second example would be a deed performed in a dream. Generally speaking, when a deed is performed in a dream, if we investigate, we can see that the motivation to perform the deed is present. Even though the motivation is present, actually if we dream we are killing someone, we cannot kill that person in the dream. Therefore, the completion is impossible.

And we can see that we have numerous experiences and dreams of great happiness or experiences of such intense sadness that we wake up with tears running down our face. The third category of karma here is karma which is both performed and accumulated. This would be, for instance, a deed which is intentionally performed without any coercion from another. And the final category, karma which is neither performed nor accumulated would be for instance where in a situation where we have actually the intention of killing another person, but realizing this is a 40, we turn away from this intention and moreover do not engage in the deed, then it will be the fourth category of this karma. Now we have covered the first two limbs of the 12 limbs of dependent arising, ignorance and composition of factor.

The third limb is a limb of consciousness. This limb arises at the second instant of the generation of the karmic imprint of a given deed since this karmic imprint needs a resting place so as not to go to waste. So there are some difficulties with this definition because of the famous quote of Vasubando in his praise of dependent arising. He who has realized truth no longer will be impelled. The meaning of this verse is that someone who has realized the selflessness of persons will no longer experience impelling karma.

And, therefore, what is to be analyzed clearly is within the definition of consciousness within the 12 limbs of dependent arising. The terms as soon as it has been instructed. The definition is a cognition which is a mind main mind as soon as it has been instructed by the imprint of the impending comma which is subsumed within one series of dependent arisings with itself. Here, the second instant of the karmic imprint which has been accumulated must necessarily rest someplace as Geshela explained, otherwise it would go to waste. This resting place is consciousness and it is this which is referred to in the term as it has been instructed by the imprint of the impending karma.

Then the question which arises is from within the six fold division of consciousness in the five sense consciousness, the visual, auditory, olfactory, gustrative and tactile consciousness on the one hand and the mental consciousness on the other hand, where are the karmic imprints deposited? As Chandakirti says in Mula Madhyamaka Vattara, in the dream state consciousness, the sense consciousnesses cease. This is a clear indication that the sense consciousnesses are not suitable receptacles for karmic imprints since they are interrupted by the dream state. Only the mental consciousness is a suitable receptacle. All of the 12 limbs within the 12 limbs of dependent arising, ranging from ignorance and compositional factors onwards must be placed within the context of the mental consciousness and not of the five sense consciousnesses.

Then regarding the general nature of these karmic imprints, or there are virtuous, non virtuous and neutral karmic imprints. Virtuous karmic imprints will instruct or direct the mind in a virtuous direction. Non virtuous karmic imprints will instruct or direct the mind in a non virtuous direction and neutral karmic imprints in a neutral direction. Now regarding what is posited as an instance of a person in function of the various schools of tenets, the two lower schools of tenets, the Vaibhashika and the Sautrantika School, posit as an instance or an example of the person which is what transmigrates from life to life, none other than the mental consciousness from within the six consciousnesses. Regarding the mind only or the Chitamatra school, there were two subdivisions of the Chitamatra school, The two aspectarians, which accept an eightfold subdivision of consciousness, and the fourth aspectarians, which do not.

The two aspectarians consider that the sixfold subdivision of consciousness is too coarse, and they say that the karmic imprints must be placed in the Alaya Vijnana, the, foundational mind, which is a subtle state of mind rather akin to the fundamental mind of tantra. So the reasonings of the two Aspectarian Chittamatrans are dangerous reasonings because they point out cogently that the karmic imprints, the Vasanas, need a firm foundation to be transmitted from life to life. And the those who assert only six, consciousnesses and posit the mental consciousness as such a foundation are faced with the fact that the mental consciousness is not such a firm foundation. Because as the true Aspectorian Chitamatra point out, the mental consciousness is interrupted in a series of events. It is interrupted in the deep state of sleep, which is dreamless deep sleep.

It is interrupted in the meditative equipoises without discrimination or the meditative equipoises on cessation. And, it is also interrupted in, the states of fainting, where one has no memory whatsoever of what happened. Therefore, the mental consciousness cannot function as a repository for karmic imprints. What has to be posited is a more subtle state of mind, the Alaya Vijnana, the mind basis of all, which is quite similar to the fundamental mind, the muxem of tantra. Now regarding the, Satrantica Svatantrika Madhyamicas, epitomized by Bava Viveka, Bava Viveka accepts only, six consciousnesses, in other words, the five sense consciousnesses and the mental consciousness, and therefore is forced to posit the mental consciousness as a basis on which the karmic imprints are planted or deposited.

The position of the Prasangika Madhyamika School is twofold. Contingently, the Prasanika Madhyamika School says that karmic imprints are deposited within the mental consciousness as the Svatantrika, but ultimately they assert that the repository of the comic imprints is the mere eye. This is sharp analysis, isn’t In the case of consciousness, consciousness changes and moves on irrespective of what we do. However, as far as motivation and the karma which is accrued to motivation is concerned, we do have control and therefore this is something we should analyze and think about carefully. We will stop here for today.

And if you have questions, Gishida will take two questions. Yes, Natalie. So don’t worry. Basically whatever deeds are performed in the dream state are indeed accompanied with an intention, but they cannot be completed. Therefore, the karma is not accumulated in keeping with the treatises on Vinaya and so forth.

For instance, you cannot if you dream of killing someone, you cannot kill that person in reality in the dream. It’d be very strange if we accumulated karma in the dream state since our dreams occur without our control. Then how could we accumulate karma? There’s no intention actually. Are there other questions?

Yes. Yes, please. No. You’re not accumulating any non virtuous karma. Nonetheless, if you have the possibility of preventing this, it would be excellent.

Yes, please. Yes. There is a contamination. You accumulate a sin through the desire of eating fish. Yes, please.

So it depends on your motivation. If your motivation is to help the other person and you give them money and without your being aware of the fact they use that money to purchase alcohol, your deed is a virtuous deed. If however, the person says, please give me some money so I can buy beer or alcohol. And knowing this, you give them money and they buy the alcohol and get drunk, then you have accumulated a non virtuous deed. Yes.

I’ve been asking a long time. Definitely, you accumulate sin. Even if you are unaware of karma and causality and do not understand it in the in the slightest, these are natural non virtues from within the various subdivisions of non virtues. Therefore, killing a fish without knowing about karma and causality still is an act of killing. So it would be very strange if if you didn’t accept comma, comma didn’t work and you could get away with everything.

But if you accepted karma, you were you were assessed in a very different standard. Yes. You accumulate non virtue. Come here, please. So the mind is immaterial and the karmic imprints themselves are immaterial.

Therefore, you have an infinite amount of immaterial things put in an immaterial thing. There is no debate. Now the problem which can arise is that the majority of karmic imprints we have accumulated are negative. And one might say one is putting a quasi infinite amount of negative phenomena within the mind. How come the mind is not colored by this?

The mind is not colored by this because the very second instant of generation of the comic imprint when it is planted in the mind, this karmic imprint can generally speaking be considered as neutral even though during the first instant it may have been virtuous, nonvirtuous, or neutral. Mhmm.

Key terms in this teaching

higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
Sautrantika do de pa (Tib)
The Sutra school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Sutra school accepts both self-knowers and external objects. LYWA
shravaka nyen thö (Tib)
A hearer; a Hinayana practitioner who strives for liberation from cyclic existence on the basis of listening to teachings from a teacher. There are four divisions: stream-enterer, once-returner, non-returner and arhat. LYWA
Vaibhashika jedrag mawa (Tib)
The Great Exposition school, one of the two main Hinayana (Lesser Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Great Exposition school asserts truly established external objects but does not assert self-knowers. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top