Grounds and Paths — 13092016Salam 3 – KR

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)
Grounds and Paths — 13092016Salam 3 - KR
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 13092016Salam 3 – KR.mp3

UUID: 849d983c-5dea-41e8-95eb-96205fca2a98

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Grounds and Paths (Khensur Rinpoche)

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 11m

Words: 2,961

So basically, have covered the path of accumulation of preparation and of seeing and it is important here to understand the meaning of these three paths. Otherwise, there’s no benefit. So an abbreviated definition of the path of accumulation is the manifest realization of dharma, dharma abhisamaya. Then what exactly is referred to here by dharma? Probably liberation.

And therefore, we can consider that the generation of the uncontrived mind striving for liberation. In other words, an uncontrived mind of definite emergence is the hallmark of entering the path of accumulation. The path of preparation, is a path which is defined as the manifest realization of meaning. Then here meaning is nothing else but emptiness. And therefore, one enters the path of preparation by means of an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight.

Then the definition of the path of seeing is the manifest realization of truth. And here, the manifest realization of truth refers to the direct realization of emptiness. Now the etymology of the path of accumulation, the first path is that it is called a path of accumulation because it is after one has generated for the first time uncontrived definite emergence and entered the path that would engages in the accumulation to attain liberation. A path of preparation is called path of preparation etymologically because it prepares the attainment of a path of seeing, which is the of which it is a direct cause and of which it is also the substantial cause since the path of seeing refers to the attainment of a direct yogic valid cognizer focused on emptiness, which arises in dependence on an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness at the level of the path of preparation. Then the etymology of the path of seeing, in Sanskrit, is that it is called a path of seeing because for the first time, one sees as one sees an object with the eyes, nakedly emptiness directly.

So it is very good to reflect in this way on the etymologies of the paths of accumulation, preparation and seeing. So this therefore is the mode of progression from path to path and I shall not explain them all because if I were to do so, we would eventually become confused and bored and this leads to laziness. And then obviously we are important and busy people, so we don’t have the time to study and therefore we have to focus on the essentials. Really? Okay.

So So one refers to the progression or the promotion from the state of not having entered the path to that of being on the path of accumulation, in other words to having entered the path. Then the term here, progression or promotion is the same as that used in graduate affairs when you’re told that you’re promoted to a position or something. Obviously, the meaning is different. So then when we have generated uncontrived or unfabricated definite emergence, we are said to have entered the path of accumulation. We can just refer here casually to being on the path of accumulation.

Then here clearly, it’s not the case that’s when one’s mind is here and the path of accumulation is there. One mind one’s mind has become the path of accumulation, then there are numerous difficulties here involving minds and mental factors. Then having attained the path of accumulation, there is a profound interior transformation and a great experience of happiness, but this is a mental happiness. As for one’s exterior form, one’s body, there is no change of really any significance. And this experience of uncontrived definite emergence is definitely a mind which has arisen from meditation.

So, at the level of the path of accumulation, one has not attained an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. However, once one has attained this inseparable union of calm abiding insight focused on emptiness. It is also said once one has attained an insight focused on emptiness, at that point, one is said to have entered the path of preparation. So at the level of path of preparation, since one has generated a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, such a focus on emptiness is effortless and spontaneous to the difference of the focuses on emptiness previously. However, even though it is effortless and spontaneous, it is conceptual.

In other words, at the level of the path of preparation, one one’s realization of emptiness relies on a meaning generality of emptiness, and emptiness is imputed on the basis of that meaning generality. This does not mean that one has not realized emptiness, One has realized emptiness, but by means of a meaning generality. At the level of the passive preparation, therefore even though one has a realization of emptiness, in as much as it is conceptual, it is a realization which is mixed with a meaning generality. And here you must understand what a meaning generality is. Generally speaking, meaning generalities can be linked to past or to future events.

So if we take the case of a conception induced by a past object, let’s imagine for instance that someone is asking us today what we did yesterday, all day, then we have to conceptually project ourselves back in time to an image of what we did yesterday, and on the base of that image, we can explain what we did. This is not difficult to understand. Now regarding the transition or the progression from the path of preparation to the path of seeing, Whereas both at the level of preparation and at the level of the path of seeing, one has generated minds arisen from meditation which are focused on emptiness. The mode of reliance of this mind is different. At the level of the path of preparation, this realization of emptiness is conceptual.

The mind relies on a meaning generality. At the level of the path of seeing for the first time, the mind does not rely on a meaning generality, but perceives emptiness nakedly as an eye perceives a shape. Then please from your side, reflect and meditate on these topics, otherwise there is no point in presenting such material. Now regarding the impact of meditation on emptiness on the mind and this is my own private position, I don’t believe that the mere realization of emptiness affects the mind. It is only at the level of the path of preparation when one realizes emptiness by means of an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight that the mind is transformed.

Otherwise, there would not be such a profound transformation of the mind due to the uncontrived experiences of definite emergence, great compassion or bodhicitta. Since these experiences are experiences where the mind is mind is transformed from the inside to the difference of the realization of emptiness, where one relies on an exterior object which is analyzed. And this is why the holy beings have always said that even as far as the practice of secret mantra is concerned, ideally one would have a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer. But if that is not possible, at least one needs an understanding of emptiness. Then, from your side, you should reflect on the meaning of emptiness.

I should not have to repeat this continually. Otherwise, we’d all fall asleep. Right? Now at present regarding the transition or the progression from the path of seeing to the path of meditation, What is the meaning of the term path of meditation here? The term meditation is used because one is focusing on the abandonment of the innate grasping at the self.

Then at present, at the level of the path of meditation, one obviously must have the accumulation of merit. I shall not enter in details in the presentation of this. And one is driven by the mind which is wishing for liberation. Then driven by such a mind, one meditates continually. Just as when one wishes to enter into a retreat, before entering a retreat, one accumulates all the requisites and then one enters into the retreat and meditates.

Likewise, before entering in the path of meditation, one accumulates all the requisites to focus on meditation. So at present, when one is engaged in meditation, the path of meditation, one is focused on emptiness. The emptiness of what? The emptiness of the eye or the mind. I think it is probably one and the same.

Then, when there is a severance at the very end of the path of seeing, at that point, I believe one can say one has entered the path of meditation. The definition of the path of meditation or Bhavanamarga is the subsequent manifest realization. Subsequent to what? Subsequent to a path of seeing. In other words, subsequent to the direct realization of emptiness on the path of seeing.

So this is therefore the mode of progression from the level of the path of seeing to the path of meditation when one is focused on emptiness. Therefore the path of meditation is defined as subsequent manifest realization and one could say that it is the path which is subsequent to the path of seeing. Probably appropriate. Now at present, once one has attained the path of seeing, is it the case after attaining the path of seeing that one is continually realizing emptiness? Probably not.

But I think one can say that one is continually reflecting on the meaning of emptiness. So, at the level of the path of meditation, one has one is meditating on emptiness and probably in the mind or the mental continuum of someone in the path of meditation, there is no conceptuality whatsoever. Since the direct valid cognizer focused on emptiness is non conceptual. Then during the path of meditation, if one were to try to find what the minds of the path of meditation are within the sevenfold subdivision of mind in Lorig, probably it would be subsequent cognizers. As you know, subsequent cognizers are subdivided into two, conceptual and non conceptual subsequent cognizers.

And here these would be non conceptual subsequent cognizers. Substantial continuum of the mind realizing emptiness at the level of the path of meditation, it is non conceptual. And if we move backwards at the level of the path of seeing, it is still non conceptual, but at the level of the path of preparation, it is conceptual. It is actually both a valid cognizer and a subsequent cognizer since the in Prasanika, there is an intersection between these two. Geshe was asking me if you knew what the subsequent cognizer was.

So therefore, at the level of the path of preparation, we are dealing with a subsequent cognizer. In other words, here a conceptual mind, which is a very powerful conceptual mind since it is an insight focused on emptiness. And if we move further back, then at whichever point one might have realized for the first time emptiness, it can be on the path of accumulation. But as we mentioned, it can also be before one has entered the path. In either case, this mind would be an inferential valid cognizer realizing emptiness.

So whatever the situation might be regarding inferential valid cognizers and conceptual minds, if we focus on our own minds, we can see that within our own minds, definitely have conceptual minds. And we also have non conceptual minds which are overwhelmingly sense direct perception. Then if we try to posit instances of non conceptual minds, are non sense direct perceptions within the continuum of ordinary beings, this is very complicated, such as mental direct perceptions. In our minds, there are definitely conceptions and there are also definitely inferential valid cognizers. Whether every conceptual valid cognizer is necessarily an inferential valid cognizer is something which is to be examined.

Generally speaking, an inferential valid cognizer is a valid cognizer which arises independence on a correct reason. So the definition of an inferential valid cognizer is a valid cognizer which ascertains its object of ascertainment by means of a correct reason. Now, at the level of the path of preparation, apart from inferential valid cognizers, which of the other seven categories of minds from LORIC are present? All of the six are present. So at the level of the path of preparation, according to Svatantrika Madhyamika, we must distinguish between subsequent cognizers and inferential valid cognizers.

Then for Prasangika Madhyamika, all subsequent cognizers are necessarily inferential valid cognizers. Now what is the core distinction between conceptual and non conceptual minds? Conceptual minds are broadly speaking focused either on past or future events, which they perceive by means of a meaning generality, whereas non conceptual minds perceive phenomena nakedly in the present. Let us therefore reflect on conceptual and non conceptual minds for a couple of minutes. Please open the page page one.

We recite one b two three four page five. Number six, First one, page three. Then please ask a couple of questions. Gisela, I have a question about cognition within the Prasangika view. I understand that sense direct perceivers are mistaken, but inferential valid cognizers, which are conceptual can be unmistaken, and I have some confusion regarding this.

So regarding the first part of your question, in sense direct perception is mistaken, but inferential valid cognizers are also mistaken because they are conceptual and all conceptual conceptions are mistaken. Can you hear me? I think the batteries had it. I would like to know more about the difference between the path of seeing and There is no particular difference of realization between the path of seeing and the path of meditation. One enters the path of meditation after a severance or a, an interruption of the path of seeing.

There’s nothing special to add. The path of seeing is the first time one gains direct realization of emptiness. Then when one returns to that meditation after an interruption, that has become the path of meditation. Gesheel, I think several times you said the ignorance grasping at a self and the wisdom realizing emptiness have different modes of apprehension, but that their object of observation is the same, namely the self I. And that seemed fine to me.

But a couple of weeks ago, you said the reason they had a different mode of getting the word now ascertainment, apprehension was that because their object of observation was also different. And that was why they were contradictory. And I thought I’d heard wrong, but I checked the transcript. It’s a mistake in the transcripts. The object of observation is the same.

The mode of apprehension is different. It’s opposite actually. Yeah. The mode of apprehension sorry. I I said that’s the same thing.

Apprehension. Yeah. Mhmm. So it’s a mistake in the It’s a mistake in the transcript. Okay.

Good. You spoke before about sense direct perceivers. I’m just wondering whether all direct valid cognizers from the present point of view are mistaken, or is it only sense direct perceivers that are mistaken? No. It is not the case that in prasanika everything which is a valid, a direct, valid cognizer is necessarily mistaken.

For instance, a yogic direct valid cognizer focused on emptiness is unmistaken. Just asking about a comment that Geshela made tonight. It’s at the point of at the path of preparation where the mind is transformed with its understanding of emptiness. Why would Geshela say that the mind is transformed at the path of preparation with that understanding rather than at the path of seeing where it is now a non conceptual mind? No, it is at the level of the path of preparation that for the first time under the power of meditation of emptiness, the mind is transformed.

Then it continues to transform at the level of the path of seeing it has already started to be transformed. I’m going to play the devil’s advocate, and I’m gonna try to present two syllogisms. The first is the subject mental consciousness is established by its own character because its character is clear and knowing of itself. The second syllogism is the subject mental consciousness is truly established because it is a self certifying direct valid cognition or cognizer. What is the reason of the first?

This mistake Could you give your reason again? First. The reason for the first was because its character is clear and knowing of itself. Well, your syllogism would be acceptable for Sotanika Madhyamika. It would not be for Prasadika Madhyamika.

I want to get the reason why it wouldn’t be acceptable. Because does not accept the existence of establishment from its own side or establishment by its own characteristics. So what you are talking about, if you have been looking at some books, is that in Sattalikha Madhyamika, there is a reference to not to consciousness not being harmed, and the meaning of that is precisely that consciousness established by its own characteristics. Yeah. So, yeah, that that syllogism or question came about in contrast in the two positions from last week’s teaching.

So then as I understand it, the mental consciousness establishes itself independence upon imputing itself as mental consciousness. Definitely. Obviously, has a basis of imputation. Yeah. And independence on that imputation, it exists.

Yeah. The second was truly established because it is a self certifying direct valid cognizer, but I find them both to be quite similar just said in a different way. So at present, we will have a discussion as usual by peers and the two topics are number one, the meaning of the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing and meditation, and the mode of transition from path to path. And the second question is, the differences between conceptual and non conceptual consciousnesses. Okay.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
path of preparation prayoga-marga (Skt); jor lam (Tib)
The second of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top