47 min · 2,923 words
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk explains the seven cause-and-effect technique for developing bodhichitta, then introduces the second technique of equalizing and exchanging oneself with others. It covers equanimity, the faults of self-cherishing, the benefits of cherishing others, and why exchanging attitudes is necessary for enlightenment. It ends by introducing the tonglen practice of giving and taking.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 47 min
UUID: a6e8ced9-a7e2-497b-9387-d806a0771e9c
Words: 2,919
But rather taking the responsibility of actually doing that upon oneself. So when one develops the superior intention, come one to this point one wishes to actively do something to to bring about happiness for all human beings and freedom from all suffering. So taking that personal responsibility is the superior intention. After having developed the superior intention in one’s mind, one would find however that one does not have the ability and the ability and in particular the ability to free all beings from suffering and lead them to the ultimate state of happiness right now. One finds that one lacks that ability.
One does not have it. So when one then considers who has this ability, how can I get this ability, then referring to the teachings, one finds that one comes to know that it is the Buddha who has this full potential and ability to free all beings from suffering and lead them to supreme happiness? And that state of enlightenment or Buddhahood can be achieved by oneself. So therefore, after recognizing that, then to develop a very strong intention to to to achieve enlightenment, the very strong wish to achieve enlightenment for the benefit, for the sake of all sentient beings, to free all beings from suffering. When that is developed in one’s mind, the spontaneous wish to achieve enlightenment for the sake of all sentient beings, that is called bodhichitta, which is the seventh within the seven cause and effect, which is the effect.
So so far I have given a brief explanation of the seven cause and effect sequence of developing bodhichitta mind. Now we come into the next technique which is called equalizing and exchanging oneself with others. Last night I I read from the text to the point where it was explaining the the way of how to develop the seven cause and effect technique. So now I will, refer to that text again and the the the teaching, the text, and read, read onwards where it explains the the second technique. So so as for you to get that old transmission from of the text.
The technique of equalizing oneself equalizing and then exchanging oneself with other technique of developing bodhichitta comes down from the Buddha to Mañjuśrī, and then from Mañjuśrī onwards to the great masters Nāgārjuna, Āryadeva, and so forth, Candrakīrti and down to Adisha. Then Adisha, so therefore Adisha has got both techniques received, the lineage has been received in Atisha, and he brought both lineages to Tibet, which was passed down to his disciples down to Lama Tsongkhapa. And so so then therefore Lama Tsongkhapa passes down the lineage to our time. So just to again, Adi from Atisha that this this technique was passed down to his the first his main dis his chief chief disciple, Dromtönpa, and then all the way down to the Kadampa masters, down to Lama Tsongkhapa. So therefore we find in the teachings these two different techniques of developing bodhichitta.
Now whatever technique one uses, it is suitable for us to obtain bodhichitta mind. So whatever technique one uses is okay. There’s a difference how however, in how these lineages was passed down. The the lineage on the of the teachings on the seven the technique of the seven cause and effect to develop bodhichitta was passed on more sort of generally to the to the disciples who are in the general way, what we call, for the general disciples. However, the seven cause and effect, sorry, excuse me, the equalizing and exchanging oneself with other technique is passed down more more sort of like selectively to to to those beings who have a higher intelligence.
So so in the beginning, this lineage was passed down more secretly because it is a more a more advanced technique, a more advanced technique of developing bodhichitta. So therefore, it was handed down to selected disciples. So so first we we the the this technique is presented in the teaching by first again with the category of first making the supplication to the to the lama to the lama deity to make the supplication of please grant me the blessings to be able to actualize this technique in one’s mind equalizing and exchanging oneself with others technique of developing bodhichitta. So may this be actualized in my mind. So making this supplication.
So in the process of meditating on this technique, one first develop what is called, one first has to meditate on what is called equanimity. Equanimity is a state of mind where one develops a state of mind, an even mind, sort of even mindedness towards all sentient beings, sort of not regarding them not distinguishing between sentient beings as being friends or enemies or strangers, but having an equal equal sort of attitude towards all sentient beings. That is developing the equanimity mind. So the next point is to recognize the self cherishing attitude as being what we call the cause for all our problems, and preventing us from experiencing happiness. So therefore to identify, to be able to identify the self cherishing mind or self cherishing attitude as being the the cause or what we call that as seeing the self cherishing mind in as a great fault.
The great Indian master, Śāntideva, has mentioned in his works, That all all suffering all suffering within sentient beings comes from wishing merely oneself to be happy, And all happiness that that sentient beings experience comes from the comes comes as a result of the attitude of wishing others to be happy. So as Śāntideva indicates in his teachings, it is mentioned in the it is further clarified in the teachings that how all the problems that we experience, every kind of problem, any kind of misfortune or any kind of undesirable experience that we go through comes as a result of just focusing on our self and cherishing ourselves while neglecting others. To explain how the self cherishing attitude becomes a cause for all our problems, we need to first consider how the how it is through the self cherishing attitude that we create all the negative karmas. So to clarify, because of the self cherishing attitude, which is an attitude which wishes oneself to be happy and neglects the others’ welfare and wishes only oneself to be happy, that thought, which is called a self cherishing attitude, would lead one to engage in non virtuous actions of killing, stealing.
One kills because one wishes to be get some derive some some benefit of pleasure thinking only about oneself, one engages in killing, stealing, or even sexual misconduct, and then lying, and all the rest of the non virtuous actions of speech as well as the mind. So it’s all created due to wishing only oneself to be happy. So in this way, by one creates a neg one engages in the non virtuous actions, thereby creating negative karma, which becomes then the cause for us to experience the results of suffering. So So so therefore, the teachings indicate that we need to discard the self cherishing attitude just as we would discard poison. Just as we would avoid poison, we need to discard the self cherishing attitude as that is the cause for us to experience all undesirable things.
And then we need to adopt that attitude of cherishing other beings. As again referring back to Śāntideva’s to quote Śāntideva again, as he says that in his teachings, that all happiness for sentient beings come from the attitude of wishing others to be happy. So as as described by Śāntideva, it is the case that when we think about other beings, then that leads us into engaging in virtuous deeds because by thinking about others we do actions which are only beneficial, only a benefit for other beings. So in this way, we create the virtuous karma, which then becomes the cause for ourselves to experience the result of happiness. So as mentioned earlier, there are the five points of the of practicing this technique.
The first, as mentioned earlier, is the developing the equanimity mind. And the second point is seeing the faults of cherishing oneself. And then the third point is seeing the advantage of cherishing other beings others other beings cherishing other beings. So then the fourth point is exchanging what is called exchanging oneself with others. Now this what this means is exchanging actually the attitude of cherishing oneself to the attitude of cherishing other beings.
Now that is done when one has developed a total conviction that cherishing oneself is the cause for all problems and misery for oneself and cherishing other beings is the cause for all happiness for oneself and others, then after being convinced of that, then the next step we take is exchanging our attitude. Where and that means that where we have been so habituated in thinking only about ourselves, our own welfare earlier, now we start adopting the attitude of cherishing other beings. So therefore so thereby exchanging the the attitude of cherishing oneself, which we had in all previous times, to now to the attitude of cherishing other beings. So that is the exchange. So one develops the very strong intention, the very strong what we call one makes the decision that one has to exchange the attitude of exchange these attitudes from cherishing oneself to the attitude of cherishing other beings.
Why? Because if one does not change his attitude, then there’s no possibility whatsoever of becoming a Buddha, enlightened. There’s no possibility of becoming enlightened if we maintain the attitude of cherishing oneself and not having the attitude of cherishing other beings. So therefore, it is mentioned clearly in the teachings that there’s no possibility for oneself to achieve enlightenment if one does not change his attitude. So therefore, one must, there’s there’s as one wishes to achieve enlightenment, one must and one needs to one must exchange this attitude.
To refer to the the the technique which is called equalizing and exchanging oneself with others, that, of course, then one does not take that literally to to mean that we exchange ourselves, our body or something else with someone else’s or other beings’ bodies or possessions, whatever. It does not mean literally that we exchange, you know, we make this exchange of giving something and taking something from, giving giving something to others and taking something from from others for oneself. So exchanging oneself with others, exchanging oneself and others refers to the attitude, which is as mentioned earlier, is the attitude where we are so habituated in in having is the attitude of cherishing merely oneself, which means that everything that one does is done in the interest of just bringing happiness or benefit for oneself and disregarding other beings. Now so so therefore, we need to change the attitude to to the attitude where we are are cherishing other beings, which means that the interest that that when when when whatever we do, the the interest is in for other sentient beings. The interest is for other sentient beings.
And how how this how whatever one does will how to see how it will bring a benefit for other sentient beings. So in this way, when we change that attitude from from cherishing oneself to cherishing other beings, that is when that that is what it means to to exchange oneself to others. So in in the in the the guru, what we call the guru puja, it is it is mentioned in the verse of how cherishing cherishing oneself is the door to all suffering, while cherishing other sentient beings is the doorway to all happiness. So as indicated in the Guru Puja as well, it is indicating that as long as one cherishes oneself and does any actions and activity with that self interest, then it one would be only creating the causes to experience further suffering. While while we while the if we develop the attitude of cherishing other beings, then whatever actions and deeds that we do with that attitude, the attitude of cherishing other beings, will be then a cause for us to experience only happiness.
Now the question may arise. It seems that it is it would be very good and very, you know, very, very good if one can one can do that practice of cherishing exchanging the self cherishing attitude towards cherishing other beings, but then the question may arise, is it possible though? Then as an answer to that, one needs to refer to how how the Buddha became enlightened, is, you know, is how he became enlightened, and there are many great bodhisattvas who are existing in the past and also in the present. So the enlightened beings and the bodhisattvas have reached the state that they are in, but having done the practice of exchanging the self cherishing attitude towards cherishing other beings. So after having described the the advantages of advantages of developing developing or of doing this practice of cherishing other beings and changing the attitude of cherishing oneself to cherishing other sentient beings.
And then after having recognized that one one has one needs to develop, one needs to do this practice, if one wishes to achieve enlightenment, one has to do this practice, then when then after having considered the fact that it is possible, it is definitely possible to do this practice because other beings have also done this practice and thereby achieve the states of becoming a Bodhisattva and eventually becoming a fully enlightened Buddha. So then the actual practice, what the practice is, is as described earlier, to begin to start cherishing other beings, which means to take others’ interest into account, to start doing actions in which one takes others’ interest into account and therefore do things which are of a benefit for other sentient beings. When one cherishes other beings, the practice that follows from cherishing other beings is doing actions in words and deeds to help other beings in whatever way it’s necessary, in whatever way whatever way it is necessary and beneficial to help other sentient beings. That is the practice that one needs to to to follow. Now if the question arises, if I start cherishing other sentient beings and and do actions and deeds only to benefit other sentient beings, then what about myself?
Would I not be left left alone somewhere? And what about my own needs? How would I be able to look after myself and take care of myself? Does that mean that I have to just completely discard myself and not take and then that I will not get any benefit myself? Then to to clear away that doubt, we need to refer again to the teachings where it says that by cherishing other beings and benefiting other beings, one will naturally, even if one does not think about oneself and takes only one’s own interest into account, even one does not do that, one will naturally be benefited oneself.
So by benefiting other sentient beings and bringing them happiness, one will experience happiness oneself. And by by bringing by removing suffering of other sentient beings, one will naturally be free of suffering oneself. That is the natural consequence, cause and effect sequence, cause and effect fact of the of the what we call fact. So so therefore, one will definitely not be disregard discarded or left left behind in where in where in where one has to suffer. So if it were the case that by cherishing other sentient beings and disregarding one’s own interest, if by doing that practice it would be the case where one will be left behind, then we would then that would have to imply that Buddha Buddha Śākyamūni is left behind somewhere where, you know, he is experiencing an unsatisfactory state.
But that is not the case. Buddha Śākyamūni is has reached a state of full enlightenment where there’s the only only happiness and bliss that he experiences. And so that that state has been achieved by actually doing this practice of of cherishing other beings. That is the the that is the main practice that Buddha in in prior to becoming the Buddha, that is the practice that he followed, cherishing other beings and disregarding oneself. Likewise, that is the same practice that all other Bodhisattvas are are following.
Same. So we our job is to follow as we wish to become the Buddha enlightened, our job is to follow the the the path or the the ways of how the Buddhas the the previous Buddhas and the Bodhisattvas are following now. So by following their example, we will then become in liberated and enlightened our oneself. So if one does not regard the disregard discard the self cherishing attitude, then let alone achieving enlightenment, one will not even be able to enter the first path of the Mahāyāna, the path of accumulation. So as indicated in the Heart Sūtra where it says, go, go, go to the first path, we will not be able to even go to the first path.
No go. No go. So when we do this practice in the form of meditation, then we we do the practice which is known as, in Tibetan, as tonglen, which literally means giving and taking. So this practice of giving and taking is done in a meditation where one, by having first developed
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- path of merit sambhara-marga (Skt); tsog lam (Tib)
- The first of the five paths leading to buddhahood. Usually translated as path of accumulation. Lama Zopa Rinpoche’s preferred term is path of merit because the activity of this path is the accumulation of merit. LYWA
- puja chö pa (Tib)
- Literally, offering; a religious ceremony, usually used to describe an offering ceremony such as the Offering to the Spiritual Master (Guru Puja). LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.