Lam Rim – T20 – Tape 20 – KR

51 min · 5,212 words

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - T20 - Tape 20 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk teaches on the suffering of samsara, explaining the three types of suffering: suffering of suffering, suffering of change, and the pervasive suffering of conditioned existence. It covers the sufferings of the demigods, gods and formless realms, then explains how seeing these faults develops renunciation, the wish for liberation, through reflection on impermanence and the Four Noble Truths.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 51 min

UUID: d72f72e5-dc9b-4de5-8ae5-a4b6d381f481

Words: 5,208

She says there are many forms of suffering, aren’t there? I am covered covered with the. When officer officials investigate, they think their citizens are happy, but they are not. Their food is plain. Their clothes are torn.

They are taxed on their property, so have no freedom over it. They may be insulted, whipped, and so on. Some have no food or clothes at all and are forced to go to their parents, to relatives, or even strangers. Some not even have the means for making barley flour, yet they are still taxed. Disaster can befall them.

They can be heavily punished and so on. In short, they are under pressure day and night. And these citizens may think the officials are happy, but it is not so. Says, the high have mental suffering, the ordinary have physical suffering. These two sufferings conquer the world every single day.

In other words, You may be a great king, but you still suffer. You carry the burden of the country’s suffering because the country’s disputes and other unpleasant topics are usually brought before you. You fear any enemies still unsubdued. You fear for any unprotected friends. You fear the people the law cannot suppress.

You worry about loss of power, and so on. We, ordained people, only eat at lunchtime, yet we have to wear ourselves out with a great deal of work. In short, even if you only have one horse, you could claim that having a horse is a form of suffering. When people first meet, they say nice things to each other no matter who they are. Not much later, they will not only argue and make sarcastic remarks.

Kelsang Gyatso, the seventh Dalai Lama said, whoever you see the high and low ordained and lay men and women, whether their surroundings are impressive or not, their share of human suffering is the same. They appear unhappy to their friends and equals. In other words, externally, may have good or bad clothes and surroundings, but internally, all experience suffering equally. Our living place may be unsatisfactory, there may be various other things wrong. We may have no furniture, friends, and so on.

Yet even if we have the best of places, friends, and amenities, we still have not transcended suffering. Even if we replace all our hundreds or thousands of servants, pupils, and friends, still they will all be unsatisfactory. Not one will be truly like minded, and this is a sign that whoever we befriend will increase our suffering. Whatever you use, even tea, you open yourself to suffering. Wherever you stay, even monasteries, it is a place of suffering.

When we first stay in a monastery, we were unhappy, then we go to a hermitage. Kunzang Yeshe says, wherever the body is, it is a place of suffering. Wherever the mind is, it is a mind of suffering. Wherever we stay, whatever the place we are is, it is a place of suffering. When we first stay in a monastery, we’re turning to the text, we are unhappy.

Then we go to a hermitage hoping this will be better, but even there we don’t get along with someone, so we go on a pilgrimage. Even this doesn’t make us happy. So we go back to our homeland thinking this might be better, and then we get impatient. When we talk with others, we only argue about such tiresome things as food, fashion, and people’s reputation, and this is the very damage that saṃsāra does. I have acquainted you with human suffering.

When you do not have such a teaching, there is a danger that you might think that it is your particular location of friends that create your suffering, or that saṃsāra is something occupying a large amount of space. So you must understand the problems of saṃsāra and know the root of suffering as I’ve already explained. Until you turn away from saṃsāra, you will only experience infinite sufferings no matter what happens. Secondly, thinking about the suffering of the demigods. You may think still if I’m reborn as a demigod, won’t I have some happiness?

But even in this rebirth, you experience only suffering. From Nāgārjuna’s letter, the demigods by nature have great suffering for they are jealous of the glory of the gods. Though they are discerning, they will not see the truth for this migration is obscured. The demigods are located on the part of Mount Mero that lies under the ocean. They have four cities, Bright, Moon Garland, Noble Place, and Immutable.

These four levels are the same distance apart as the gods, four levels on Mount Meru. The demigods cannot generally compete with the gods except in a few things where they are similar, and the gods steal the beautiful demigod women. The gods have greater riches, for instance, the ambrosia of immortality, and therefore the demigods are forever tormented by the fires of enormous jealousy. If we get so unhappy when we are jealous of the petty affluence of our enemies, need I say how unbearable the great affluence of the gods must be for the demigods? When the demigods can no less no longer stand their sickening jealousy, they go to war.

Ayaravana, the god’s great elephant hurls rocks at them with his trunk. The demigods throw weapons, but the gods die only when their necks are severed. The demigods may die when a weapon hits any part of their body, so they are always defeated, and at no time do they win. We are terrified when two armies of different strengths fight in the human realms, but the demigods must wage such a war against the gods. Does this terrify them?

They are absolutely terrified. Demigod armies must wage these wars continuously till they die, so they suffer. The demigod women back home are also tormented by suffering, for they can witness everything in the lake surface of Lake Sudarshana, the defeat of the demigod armies, the deaths of their companions, and so on. So the demigods have wisdom? Their rebirth is so veiled by karma that they are not fortunate enough to see the truth.

Thirdly, thinking about the suffering of the gods. In that case, you may ask, are these gods happy? Do the desire realm gods also experience suffering from falling when they leave that rebirth, from being intimidated, and from being maimed, killed, and banished? The first of these is as follows. Nagajuna’s letter says, their body color becomes ugly.

Their thrones do not please them. Their flower garlands fade. Their clothes pick up stains, and their body sweat for the first time. These are said to be the five omens of death. They indicate they will die and leave this high rebirth.

When this happens to gods in the celestial realms, they proclaim that even people beyond the earth will die. They are like omens of death. In other words, there are five signs of distant death and five signs of impending death. And the gods suffer when these 10 omens appear. The luster of their body fades.

They refuse to sit on their thrones. The flowers they wear fade. Their clothes pick up stains. They sweat. Their bodies give off less light.

Water adheres to their body when they wash. The jewelry on their body gives off an unpleasant sound. Their eyes blink, and they keep to one place. When these 10 signs appear, they wail in some forsaken place, writhing like fish out of water. Gods undergo this suffering for seven of their days.

In the realm of the former of the carnal directions, for instance, this lasts for three hundred and fifty human years. The gods undergo three phases, the previous birth that caused them to be reborn as gods, their present situation as gods, and wherever they will be going after they die. The gods know all three. So they know where they will be reborn next. The gods did not use the early part of their rebirth to create even one kind of virtue, such as considering their own suffering and developing renunciation or considering the sufferings of others and developing compassion.

Thus, their previously accumulated merit is running out. Suppose you wear a monk’s shawl that costs 10 sang, while other monks wear shawls that cost only 1 sang. This means you have squandered 10 times as much. Similarly, bliss in the god realm is so intense that it uses up a lot of merit. Hence, the gods are normally reborn in the noble lower realms.

This is why they say that now is the time for us to accumulate merit, now the time to squander the results of merit. The gods know they will fall, and it decreases their suffering. They see that they will be without their affluence, the celestial realms, their body, positions, friends, and so forth, and will be reborn in the lower realms. Śāntideva says this sort of rebirth just slays our merit. So this sort of rebirth with great prosperity and wealth simply destroys or burns merit.

Their mental suffering is 16 times greater than that of the hells. We have such suffering and mental anguish when we die even though we are uncertain whether our next rebirth would be good or bad. They are certain, however, for they see that they are sure to be reborn in the numeral realms. They say things like, alas, I shall not see the grove of chariots. Allay again.

The other gods and goddesses cannot even bear to look at those displaying the signs of death. They avoid them as they would shun a corpse and leave them in solitude. Those about to die, say to their companions, I give only a short while to live, and they will move on to my next rebirth, It should be miserable, so I want to see you now. They make these heartrending pleas, but the others cannot bear even to look them in the eye. Their old companions and once firm friends put flowers on the end of a pole, and keeping their distance, place these on their heads.

They tell them, after you die and leave these rebirths, you will be reborn in the human realm. May you then accumulate merit and so be reborn as a god. This is all they do, and it only adds to the misery of the dying gods, making their mental anguish even greater. The gods with smaller amounts of merit see the majesty and affluence of the gods with greater merits. This is intimidating as the root of their even greater suffering and mental anguish.

When the gods and demigods fight, they experience the suffering of having their limbs cut off of being maimed and of dying. The less powerful gods suffer because the more powerful gods drive them out of their dwellings. In a rebirth as a god of the higher realms, a form and formlessness, one does display any signs of death, but one is still oppressed by the suffering of all conditioned phenomena. One still has delusions and obscurations, and one will suffer by taking bad rebirths. Because one is powerless to remain in the rebirth, powerless to control one’s death or where one will go afterwards.

Vasubandhu says in his instruction for the multitudes, those in the form and formless realms transcend the suffering of suffering for a while, but these lords of single pointed concentration remain motionless for eons, so it is certain they will not be liberated and will later fall from there. In other words, when you are born as, for instance, a formless realm god, you know that you have been reborn, then you enter meditative absorption for many eons and eventually die and fall to a lower state. You therefore suffer because you are powerless to maintain your condition. These rebirths as gods use up merit. And when there is no more accumulated merit left, the gods must leave that life and are reborn in a lower state.

But because the continuity of their wisdom to conceptualize has been broken, they will be very stupid and more lacking in wisdom than other beings. Some people mistake the actual Dhyanic concentration states for liberation and think that when they attain these states, they will have gained liberation. Later, when they see they’re going to take rebirth, they deny that there is liberation, and so are reborn in the Avicii hell. This is why being reborn in these states is no different from staying in a quarter in any hell. All you have done is to have lost your way temporarily.

Far better to be some old woman reciting instead. Far better to be some old woman residing Om mani padme hum instead. Kasangyatu, the seventh Dalai Lama said, you so called three realms of saṃsāra, a house of molten iron. Go in any of the 10 directions, and you’ll be burned. Your heart frets, but these are your surroundings.

You wander in this evil place, and sad are your surroundings. In other words, you may be reborn anywhere in saṃsāra from the depths of the hell without respite to the heights of the peak of existence, but is like staying in a six story house of molten iron. You have not transcended suffering at all. Śāntideva says these are the sufferings of psychic existence. Whatever happiness there is is evanescent.

And, ultimately, this happiness ceases. So the suffering of the contaminated suffering of psychic existence is unreliable. It is evanescent. It ends quickly. This why we talk of the suffering of psychic existence as being unreliable.

Once during a famine, some children asked for barley flour, but were given seven varieties of turnip instead. The children wouldn’t touch any of them and said, ugh. They only turn it. Similarly, wherever you’re born is by nature suffering. Only certain aspects are different, and everyone is equally unhappy.

To summarize, we are endlessly tortured by the three types of suffering. So these three are said to be the length and breadth of suffering. We in saṃsāra have such thoughts as I am happy, but these thoughts in their very nature are suffering. All our thoughts of I am indifferent are in their very nature suffering. When we pour cold water on a burn, we are temporarily happy.

All our happy feelings eventually change into suffering, and thus are the suffering of change. Not only are these contaminated happy feelings, but all their concomitant primary minds and mental factors and any contaminated object that serves to develop the happy feelings, all are the suffering of change. When you first receive a burn, you are not actually tormented by heat, although the nature of the burn is heat. This is only temporary, however, so long as nothing hot or cold or cold touch comes into contact with the wound. Likewise, contaminated feelings of equanimity together with primary mind, mental factors, and the objects of these feelings are linked to the seeds of future sufferings and delusion.

They are also linked to the ever present, afflicted mental states. Feelings of equanimity are therefore the suffering that pervades conditioned phenomena. When hot water comes into contact with a burn, it develops manifest suffering from heat, and this is the worst suffering. This is like feelings of suffering, contaminated feelings of suffering that torment mind and body. Together with the concomitant primary minds, mental factors, and the objects of these feelings.

Are the suffering of suffering. When we feel I am suffering, it is a suffering of suffering. Your notion of happiness is itself a suffering of change. A sign that it is not happiness, but only your notion of happiness is the fact that your suffering will increase after a while. So, Geshe-la says, we can see that any happiness we have at present over time shifts.

This is actually the suffering of happiness. If we look carefully, then we see suffering pointing its hand. So this basically goes up and down. For instance, take heat and cold. When the suffering of heat goes down, the suffering of cold goes up.

When the suffering of cold goes down, the suffering of heat goes up. It is likewise with all happiness in saṃsāra. Your notion of happiness between the text is itself the suffering of change. A sign that it is not happiness, but only your notion of happiness is the fact that your suffering will increase after a while. Your suffering had at first only dropped below a threshold level.

Later, it will rise above the threshold, and the intervening period is your notion of happiness. So, likewise, Geshe-la says, the feeling of heat has decreased and the feeling of cold has increased, and this again is of the nature of suffering. Returning to the text, suppose we’re now sitting in the shade. After a while, we’ll feel cold, so we’ll move out into the sun. We seem to feel happy for a while, but this is not happiness.

When we are miserable, anything we do only increases our suffering. Similarly, if going under the sun were happiness, we would necessarily become never become unhappy. No matter how long we sat there, this is not what happens. We suffer again a little later and have to go back into the shade. Our suffering has risen above its threshold, although this is not in fact obvious.

The same happens when you go walking. When you get tired, you sit down and seem to be happy for a while, but the suffering from standing up has only dropped below its threshold. So can say, you know, we stand up, and in a while the suffering of standing up will arise. Returning to the text, the suffering from sitting is not yet apparent or will soon rise above its threshold when you are tired of sitting. Then you will say, I want to go for a walk.

When you get up again, your suffering from sitting falls below its threshold, and your suffering from standing again has not yet actually risen above its threshold, and so on. From Ariadeva’s 400 verses, You can see that no matter how much happiness increases, it will end. Similarly, suffering also increases, but there is no end to it. Because English translation here is a bit incorrect, you should add the substantial cause. In other words, the contaminated aggregates, are the substantial cause of the suffering which is all pervasive, pervade all phenomena.

The creation of these aggregates causes one to become a vessel of medium suffering. A vessel or medium of suffering. Excuse me. You experience a suffering of the heat and cold of the hells, So says, there is no suffering, and specifically, no or pervasive suffering apart from the substantial continuum of the five contaminated aggregates. Returning to the text, you experience the suffering of the heat and cold of the hells because you have received the aggregates of a hell being.

You experience the suffering of a hungry ghost’s hunger and thirst because you have received the aggregates of a hungry ghost. When you create for yourself the body of a donkey, sir, you carry a load on your back, get whipped, and so on because you have created for yourself the vessel in which to experience these sufferings. In short, even the unbearable pain of being pricked by a thorn happens because you’re afflicted with a set of aggregates. Just as a man carrying a load of brambles on his naked back will never be without suffering until he puts his load down, you will never be without any type of until you are free of the burden of the contaminated aggregates. Told of the householder and how Maudgalyayāna, the abbot, took him to the ocean shore of human bones, human corpses, and so on from people’s past lives and how was moved to develop renunciation.

These are called afflicted aggregates for three reasons. Fire issuing from brambles is called bramble fire. The afflicted aggregates come from past delusions, the afflict or cause, so the result has been named after the cause. A man dependent on the king is called the king’s man. Delusions, the afflict or substantial cause are an outcome of afflicted aggregates.

The thing being bolstered is given the name of the bolster. A tree that produces a medicine or a type of blossom is called the tree of this particular medicine or the tree of that particular blossom. You were deluded and thus became afflicted with these aggregates. The name of the result has been given to the cause. These aggregates are the suffering that pervades all conditioned phenomena because the evil states of suffering and delusion are forever adhering to them.

As long as one has these aggregates, each time one does not have the feeling of suffering, one will immediately afterwards be made to develop much suffering by various means. The suffering that pervades conditioned phenomena therefore all suffering and is a root of the other two kinds of suffering. So, concern, these are the three reasons for which the afflicted aggregates are called afflicted aggregates. Returning to the text, the aggregates created the vessel for the suffering of this rebirth because they create the future rebirth that leads to suffering. Among all suffering, the aggregates are the worst.

saṃsāra is a state of helplessness in which one receives the burden of the contaminated afflicted aggregates by virtue of and delusion. This means that one takes rebirth from the peak of existence down to the Avicii Hell and circles between these over and over again. So can you remember, she says in the same way that we talk of the pith or the essence of a tree or of an object, in the same way, these contaminated aggregates are the pith or the essence of psychic existence. Returning to the text, this is why it is correct to see the contaminated afflicted aggregates themselves as saṃsāra. In order to weary of saṃsāra, one must weary of the contaminated aggregates.

Until one wearies of the suffering that pervades condition phenomena, one will not truly weary of saṃsāra. So there is no saṃsāra, saṃsāra, no psychic existence apart from the contaminated aggregates. It is liberation from these that we are striving to attain. That mind which is trying to attain liberation from the contaminated aggregates is called renunciation. These contaminated aggregates are impelled by karma and delusion.

However, the principle of these is desire. So through desire, for instance, we commit a non virtuous deed such as killing. That non virtuous deed, in turn Yeah. Creates the causes for contaminated aggregates in the future life. So we have to go to the very root of these aggregates, and the root of these aggregates is ignorance.

We must therefore endeavor to destroy ignorance. More this is difficult. Without the destruction of his ignorance, there is no freedom from psychic existence. So an act of killing, for instance, can act as impelling karma, which determines a future rebirth. And in dependence on this seed, then we will experience again an entire cycle of suffering.

From this action, its effects will unavoidably arise. So for instance, we’re abandoning the act of killing. We will then have abandoned one of the non virtuous deeds which give birth to cyclic existence. Now for this, to abandon cyclic existence, we must generate renunciation. That renunciation, which is an abandonment, a rejection of all the delusions which are at the root of psychic existence is at this level the principle road which guarantees we will not be reborn into lower realms.

So the roots of cyclic existence are the three, desire, hatred, and ignorance. The antidotes of these, the antidote of desire is meditation on ugliness, the antidote of hatred is love and generation of bodhichitta. And of the three, ignorance is the most fundamental, and it can only be eliminated through meditation So without the three principles of the path and specifically without renunciation, it will be impossible for us to avoid circling endlessly in cyclic existence. So seeing the faults, the defects of cyclic existence is therefore extraordinarily important. Day 15.

Khensur Rinpoche quoted from the great Pandita Āryadeva. O child, how could you not be afraid that you will be bound here, that there may be no end at all to the ocean of suffering in which you drown. After giving a short talk to set on motivation and naming the headings he had already covered, he revised a section developing thoughts of renunciation. He then taught how to pursue this practice. As in the preparatory rites, you should think about the sufferings of saṃsāra while meditating that your divine guru sits above the crown of your head.

So says, in addition to this, we should offer the seven limbed prayer and mandala to the guru. And make strong requests. And then on this basis, then the meditation session will go well. Returning to the text between meditation sessions refer to sutras that teach the drawbacks of saṃsāra, the Sūtra of Having Much Remembrance. So we should meditate on the impermanence of saṃsāra and principally on the sufferings of cyclic existence on this basis.

So we will not wish or desire to be have any connection with psycho existence. Then on this basis, it is possible to reject psycho existence. Otherwise, it is extremely difficult. Without meditating on the thoughts or defects of psychic existence, we will never generate within our mind streams a desire to give it up. Returning to the text.

If when you see anything samsaric, it’s happiness, power, riches, and so forth, you’re weary of them and think these are fraudulent things, they are suffering, then you have been sufficiently moved to feel renunciation. You may be moved to renounce such things when you suffer a few samsaric problems, like punishment, degradation, and so on. But this is only a superficial renunciation, only a pale reflection. So long as you are born into saṃsāra, you have not transcended suffering at all. If you never want again to undergo suffering, you must break the continuity of your rebirth.

You develop a yearning for liberation when you’re weary of saṃsāra and wish to gain some certainty. In other words, renunciation. Jet Tsongkhapa said, So says in a glass that it is only when we have realized that the nature of psychic existence is suffering that we can totally reject it and on this basis develop renunciation. So that mind which projects saṃsāra is the mind which is yearning for liberation, and this is renunciation. So says that severing the roots of existence is very difficult.

And therefore, it is extremely rare. Those who desire to cut the root of psychic existence themselves are very rare. There are countless benefits to this, however. We are able to do this through meditating on the fact that the marvels of psychic existence are meaningless and futile. At the time of the being of the small scope, meditation on impermanence is central, and therefore we meditate mainly on that and on the suffering of the lower realms.

And to meditation on the suffering of the lower realms, becomes very clear to us that these sufferings exist. They appear very clearly to us, and then desire to be freed from them becomes very powerful. Then a thought of renunciation of these lower realms arises. Now at the time of the being of middling scope, it is through reflecting on the faults of all of psychic existence And through an experience of this, that the wish for liberation will arise through reflecting again and again on the thoughts of karma and psychic existence impelled by it. Then we must meditate again and again on the two first noble truths, the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origination of suffering.

And then through meditating first on these two noble truths, which are noble truths of the cause, and then the two last, which is a noble truth of the path and the effect, we can then develop within our mind streams renunciation. On this basis and on this basis alone, can we sever the root of psychic existence? Saying psychic existence is beneficial. This is mere foolishness. We must abandon suffering, and we must endeavor to attain the cessation which is an abandonment of suffering.

And then attain the nirvana, the nirvana with remainder, the nirvana without remainder, which fall under the category of the truth of cessation. So returning to our text, Je Tsongkhapa said, after such meditations, when you do not long for the splendors of saṃsāra even a moment, when your thoughts day and night always yearn for liberation, you have developed renunciation. So at the level of the of the middling path, we must meditate on the fact that cause and effect are non deceptive. And when we are talking of these, we are talking of karma and delusions. So let us be very clear in our analysis.

If the cause is not taken, if the cause is not created, then the effect will not arise. Through understanding this chain of causality, then it becomes very clear to us that it’s necessary to develop a mind striving or yearning for liberation. When your thoughts day and night yearn for liberation with your whole being, you have developed renunciation. When others construct fine thrones for me, show me deference, pay me respect, and so on, I think these are all impediments, they are all sufferings, and I am uncontrollably moved to renunciation. I have had this for some time.

No matter how much of saṃsāra’s magnificence you see, it ought to increase your weariness of this. So when we think that all the phenomena which surround us, which we perceive are of the nature of suffering, and that all these phenomena are also impermanent, then it will be quite easy to renounce to them. Then with the text, when people die, they suffer mental anguish when they realize that they will be separated from this life’s wealth, friends, and so on. But this is a superficial sense of impermanence prompted by the trivia of this life. It is vital to use some means to develop in our mind stream the pure thoughts of being moved to renunciation.

So we must endeavor earnestly to cultivate these thoughts in our minds in this night. Geshe-la says there are the bases of sufferings in this life, in this existence. They are the sufferings of this life and the suffering of future life. And these we have studied already. They are the sufferings of uncertainty, the suffering of not getting what we want, of getting what we do not want, etcetera.

Suffering of taking bodies again and again, the bodies which are prone to suffering. So the suffering, which is the fact that even the slightest happiness we have is never untainted. It is never totally free from suffering. Then when when we think, what can our friends do to help us during these sufferings? They can do anything.

So says we will stop here for today.

Key terms in this teaching

contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
pandita khäpa (Tib)
Scholar; learned person. Often referred to as pandit, (without the final a), which is the Hindi pronunciation of the Sanskrit. LYWA
samsara khor wa (Tib)
Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top