1 h 31 min · 4,127 words · 18 November 2015
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk teaches meditation on death and impermanence as a remedy for laziness, then explains turning the mind away from sense objects. It explains that ignorance grasping at a self is the root of suffering, that its antidote is the wisdom realising emptiness, and that the self is a mere conceptual imputation on the aggregates. It ends with a question and answer session on the three trainings, the Prasangika view and cessation.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 32m
UUID: bde80ec8-78fc-4244-b104-b2805e4bc592
Date: 2015-11-18
Words: 4,123
So it is excellent if from one’s own side with energy and delight, one can strive to practice, in other words, to engage in virtue. Then under the influence of the laziness which engages in bad behavior, we find it difficult to practice. It is true that practice, study, meditation and so forth call for effort. The best way to counteract such laziness is meditation on death and impermanence. Now in the context of meditation on death and impermanence, one normally meditates on it in terms of the three roots.
In other words that one’s death is certain, the time of one’s death is uncertain and at the time of death, the only thing which is of benefit is dharma practice. Regarding the first root, all of us are probably aware, fully aware of the fact we will die. At the very same time, we are profoundly convinced that somehow we’re going to live for a very long time. This is known as grasping at permanence. These two states of mind coexist together.
The most beneficial in this case is to reflect on the second root. In other words, that the time of our death is completely uncertain. As is said, for one who is unable to enter in the path, it is best to meditate on death and impermanence. So all of the topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope have been explained in detail and if from our side, we reflect and meditate on them even if we are unable to generate fully qualified realizations of the being of the small scope. Nonetheless, we will give rise to contrived experiences, a form of sensation regarding these topics, a feeling and over time this will turn into a fully, full realizations of the path of the being of the small scope.
And from one’s own side, if one can become accustomed to these topics of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope, even though it is perhaps not possible to do this continually because many have to work. Nonetheless, over time, it is definite that this habituation will lead to experiences, fully characterized experiences of the path of the being of the small scope. So the practice of the path of the being of the small scope has been explained many times. In a nutshell, it refers to a process of training where the mind which initially at present for most of us is focused outside and by outside we refer to a mind focused on the five sense objects. In other words, visual forms, sounds, smells, tastes and tactile objects, such a mind which is distracted outwards is brought inwards.
And this process of bringing the mind inwards leads in turn to a reduction in desire for exterior sense objects. This reduction in desire for exterior sense objects is what is known as turning the mind away from the vanities of this life. So whether we refer to this process of turning the mind inwards and away from the five sense objects as the path of the being of the small scope or as turning the mind away from the vanities of this life, the meaning is the same. However, having done this, we yet are not at the point of one who has attained liberation. All of us in this room probably wish for liberation.
What is liberation? Liberation is a durable state of interior happiness uncontaminated by ignorance. Now, all of us know when we examine our own minds that the main obstacle to generating this durable inner mental happiness is none other than what is known as the three poisons. In other words, desire, anger and ignorance, the afflictions under the sway of anger if you prefer. How is one to eradicate this?
One has to find the origin of these afflictions And this origin can be traced all the way back to the ignorance which grasps at an I, at a self, which is present within the mind stream of all of us. Now since the Four Noble Truths are the central topic of the path of the middling scope, such a presentation of the two first truths, the truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering is very beneficial, especially when we trace it back to the root of the noble truth of the origin of suffering, which is that ignorance grasping at a self. As the ancient Kadampa said, take revenge on the source of all harm, which is none other than this ignorance. Then since the root of all of our suffering is this ignorance grasping at our self, we have it to find a way to counter it, to abandon it, in other words, to destroy it. What is the antidote to this ignorance grasping at a self?
It is none other than the wisdom which realizes emptiness. Now we have to be very clear at this point. In our minds, we’re not present, the ignorance which grasps at itself exists. The wisdom realizing emptiness does not exist at all. So if we want to generate this wisdom, we must actually understand first what emptiness is, and for this we have to study it.
If we study it, eventually we will understand. So we must therefore understand emptiness but it is of limited benefit to explain what emptiness is for the understanding of emptiness. What is much more helpful is to explain what the object of negation of emptiness is. What is this object of negation? It is none other than the grasping at an I.
Now, the I exists. There is a person who is the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant experiences and of the maturation of karma. This mode of existence of this I, which is problematical. We ourselves, and for that matter, all of the lower schools of tenets from the Vaibhāṣika all the way up to Sautrāntika Mādhyamika intuitively feel that the person or the I exists from the standpoint of the aggregates. Now speaking from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, this is not the case.
So, I would like to ask you something rather strange and awkward. Please don’t allow your mind to be distracted to anything else, but focus it exclusively on this I. Try to understand what the mode of existence of this I which is the experiencer of happiness and of unhappiness is. So, it is obvious that since we are physical beings, we can be physically present in a building such as this temple. But if our mind is someplace else, then there is no advantage, no benefit in our being physically present in the temple and attending the teachings.
Therefore, please listen with concentration, listen carefully to this attempted explanation of the nature of the I and with effort and concentration, we will be able to understand. Great scholars such as Bhāvaviveka or for that matter, Dignāgā and his disciple Dharmakīrti who were Chitamatra all believed that the I could be found within the aggregates. It was such a critically important issue that much analysis was called for. They all considered that this I which is so important since it is the actor as well as the experiencer of the fruition of karma could be found within the aggregates. When we say it could be found within the aggregates, this means it can be counted as within the aggregates.
In other words, it exists from the standpoint of the aggregates. Technically, it is said to be established from its own side. This I, which is established from its own side is from the standpoint of Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the object of refutation. The eye does exist but the I’s being established from its own side is the object of refutation. Now, the ultimate view from the standpoint of LAMRIM is the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika view.
And for Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, the I is not established from the standpoint of the aggregates. It is not established as findable within the aggregates. The eye does exist, but this I is a mere conceptual imputation out there, a mere conceptual imputation. So it is critical to try to understand what is meant here by mere conceptual imputation. So when we say that the I is a mere conceptual imputation, what precisely is meant here?
These conceptions are present within our mind. But we, if we try to understand how our own I is a mere conceptual imputation, this is a little bit difficult to understand. It is actually more straightforward to understand it on the basis of others. Others are immeasurable in number and there are therefore an immeasurable number of other I’s in as much as there are an immeasurable number of other persons. Every single one of these is a mere conception imputation.
Let us take the example of our friend Hiro. Now when Hiro is out for a walk and people meet him, whether they know Hiro or not in person, if they see him in the distance, they will say, there is this tall man coming towards us. And they might even suspect, well, maybe he’s Japanese as well. Now we can clearly see here that the conception which thinks this tall man and the person which is observed are blended, are mixed as it were. Do you understand?
Or to take another example, let us assume Hebrew was riding a big motorbike and someone saw him from the distance and said, ah, there is this Japanese gentleman on a big motorbike. Then you can clearly see that the mind which thinks there is this Japanese gentleman on a big motorbike manifest a conception which is seeking this, which is blended with the observed phenomenon. Then when one thinks upon seeing Hiro, ah, is Japanese. That conception which thinks Japanese is a conception which refers to a person. That conception on the basis of the aggregates of Hiro which appear to the sensory consciousnesses imputes the term or the name Japanese.
This is how persons are mere conceptual imputations on the basis of the aggregates. As is said by a passage in sūtra, in the self same way as a chariot is imputed on the components of the chariot likewise is a person imputed on the aggregates. Then it is fairly straightforward to understand this process of conceptual imputation regarding persons who are different or other. When one encounters a girl, a boy, one thinks this is a girl and this is a boy. One encounters a monk, a nun one thinks this is a gelong, this is an anila, but it is more difficult to understand this process when one applies it to oneself.
However, we have to analyze within oneself. Otherwise, there is little benefit in these reflections. So in brief, the person, the I, the experiencer of happiness and unhappiness is merely imputed conceptually on the basis of imputation which is the aggregates. It does not exist from the standpoint of the aggregates. It is not established from the standpoint of the aggregates.
This non establishment of the person or the I from the standpoint of the aggregates, this is emptiness. Paul, the person or the I is not established from the standpoint of the aggregates. Nonetheless, our mind apprehends it as being established from the standpoint of the aggregates. That part of our mind which apprehends it as being established from the standpoint of the aggregates, that is ignorance. Now, the eyes not being established from the standpoint of the aggregates, and the I being established from the standpoint of the aggregates are direct opposites.
In other words, as the power of the mind which realizes that the I is not established from the standpoint of the aggregates increases, the power of the ignorance which considers that the I is established from the standpoint of the aggregates decreases and eventually disappears in the same way as light causes obscurity or darkness to disappear. So it is not sufficient to verbally assert that the eyes not being established from the standpoint of the aggregates is emptiness and that the I’s being established from the standpoint of the aggregates is the object of negation. We must gain some type of experience in understanding of this and understand the mode in which the I is not established from the standpoint of the aggregates. It is important to understand that we have numerous minds, conceptions, ideations for which the I is mistakenly understood as existing from the standpoint of the aggregates. But it is the wisdom realizing emptiness which counters this.
Even though the wisdom realizing emptiness does not exist at present within our mind stream, we can generate it and as it increases the ignorance which apprehends the I or the person as existing from its own side decreases and eventually ceases. When it has ceased, one is said to have attained liberation or the noble truth of cessation. The noble truth of cessation is therefore liberation and the fourth Noble Truth, the Noble Truth of the Path is the means to attain the third Noble Truth, the Noble Truth of Cessation. The fourth Noble Truth is the Wisdom Realizing Emptiness. Now, does the wisdom realizing emptiness alone or does the experience, direct experience of emptiness alone enable us to attain liberation?
No, definitely not. Since almost certainly the first mind realizing emptiness within our mind stream when we train will be a mind of the desire realm and a mind of the desire realm cannot act as an antidote to the afflictions. So this is difficult to understand but let us try to understand it together. We at present experience mainly coarse minds of the desire realm and a coarse mind of the desire realm when it is focused on emptiness loses its object rapidly. Coarse minds of the desire realm are easily interrupted.
For instance, when we fall asleep, our coarse mind of the desire realm ceases. Likewise, when we fall unconscious and most definitely when we die. Ignorance on the other hand, is an extremely heavy and powerful state of mind. Now we need therefore a subtle mind which is continually present for such realizations. At the level of the Pāramitāyāna, what would such a mind be?
Such a mind would be the mind of calm abiding, but not calm abiding alone, a union of calm abiding and insight. You’d have probably heard this term already, which is focused on emptiness. This is what can be posited as a valid noble truth, the noble truth of the path. This is not necessarily non conceptual, it can be either conceptual or non conceptual. Then I mentioned many times that we never skip breakfast, do we?
Then in the same way, such an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. Once it applies uninterruptedly on its object. In other words, once it destroys uninterruptedly its object, which is the ignorance grasping at itself will eventually lead to its elimination. So at present, in the context of generating the motivation, let us meditate together on the four noble truths and specifically on whether we understand or not the noble truth of cessation and whether we understand or not the fourth noble truth, noble truth of the path, which is an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness. So within the outline of the path of the being of the middling scope, The outline itself is subdivided into four.
The fourth outline is ascertaining the path, the nature of the path leading to liberation and this is subdivided in terms of the three trainings. The training of ethics, the training of concentration and the training of wisdom. I have briefly explained something about calm abiding and insight, but actually the explanations on calm abiding and insight do not occur within the path of the being of the small, excuse me, within the path of the being of the middling but within the path of the being of the great scope. The first training, the training in ethics is a training in the means to subdue the mind and the subjugation of the mind occurs by means of an abandonment of the 10 non virtues. The second training, the training in concentration refers to calm abiding.
This is not mere concentration but single pointed concentration and single pointed concentration is not sufficient. It must be conjoined with analysis. Now the results of the three trainings are fairly straightforward. The result of the training in ethics is the attainment of a higher rebirth as a human being or a divine being. The result of the training in concentration in as much as it leads to calm abiding is rebirth in one of the higher realms and the result of the training in wisdom is liberation.
Then I have nothing more to explain. If you have questions, please ask your questions. Do all of the Tibetan schools agree that single pointed concentration requires to be conjoined with analysis? Must be conjoined with analysis. Yes.
Sikash has said that taught that the oh, sorry. I’m trying to read my notes. The calm abiding is not a mind of the desire realm, but it is a mind so it seems to be it’s a mind generated in the desire realm, but not of the desire realm. So what realm is it a mind of? Yes, calm abiding is a mind of the higher realms.
Does Geshela actually mean by that? Could he elaborate? High realms means there’s no roof, right? So the minds of the higher realms are minds which are in their nature happy and which in comparison with which our minds of the desire realms are very coarse, low minds which are focused on coarse desires for coarse things. So we should not think when we speak of minds of the higher realm that somehow there is a physical verticality involved.
Instead, when we generate an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight, then the mind within itself is profoundly happy. Thank you, Geshela. Geshela, could you expand on your analogy of the Japanese man on the motorbike? Is the point the same as the fact that I can be a mother, a daughter, a grandmother, a niece, and an aunt all at the same time implying that that all those labels are imputed. I’m not sure I understood what he meant.
Yes, your being mother, daughter, niece, aunt at the same time is a case of mother, daughter, niece, aunt being of one nature but different isolates. In other words, mother, daughter, niece, aunts are different names for the same thing. So in Tibetan for, in Tibet for instance, it is quite common for people to have several names. Their name as a young person, as an adult when they are ordained, it’s actually the same person which is being referred to. I was telling Geshela, in our cultures it’s the same thing.
So the example you give is a meaningful one because if we take the example of hero again, Hiro’s identification as hero when one encounters is contingent on whether or not the person meeting hero knows hero. But if someone sees hero walking towards him from a distance and says that is a tall man who is coming towards us, then that conception tall man is imputed on Hiro’s body. I just following on from that, I wondered if by extension, we also impute, as well as the name, we impute characteristics to a person that don’t inherently exist, that are not permanent. They’re more in our our minds, but we see them as permanent and this leads to a lot of the problems. As an example, one of my students grew up in Bosnia Herzegovina, so he grew up with a little boy.
The little boy regarded him as a neighbour, a brother, a friend. When the war started, he hadn’t changed, but his neighbor then regarded him as a Muslim and enemy. That was from the side of the neighbor. So is that also imputation or am I taking it too far? Yes precisely, this imputation, he is an enemy, he is a Muslim is something which is imputed on the person by conceptuality, the mind.
Is this what, sorry, His Holiness is referring to when he says it ties in with modern psychology. He often quotes it that when we dislike someone, 90% of it is projection, the attributes. Is that the same Yes, definitely the case of conceptual imputations. However, don’t forget that there are beneficial and harmful conceptualities as beneficial and harmful conceptual imputation. So be mindful of the fact that conceptuality can be rooted in an understanding of reality as it is or not.
And one must distinguish between valid conceptual imputation and invalid conceptual imputation. If he’s next to a tall man, then he’s a small man. And if he went to Japan, they might see him as an Australian rather than Japanese. So, it’s all relative, isn’t it? So, yes, definitely everything is relative.
If he goes stands next to someone who’s taller then he will look smaller than Geshe was saying in this room probably Hugo, myself and someone else are the tallest. I don’t know who the third party is. But yeah, that worked. Then your questions. With the ascertaining the path of three trainings, ethics, concentration, wisdom, are they part of the six perfections, or are they separate to the six perfections?
So the three trainings are subsumed within three of the six perfections, the perfection of ethics of concentration and of wisdom. But there are three perfections, the perfection of generosity, of forbearance and of enthusiasm which are not present in latency in the three trainings. Another? Okay. If there’s coarse desire on coarse things, is there a subtle desire on subtle things?
If qualities? If there is coarse desire on coarse things, is there a subtle desire on subtle things? Definitely. There are coarse and subtle minds and since there are coarse and subtle minds, there is both coarse and subtle desire. So it is difficult to give these examples because they’re difficult to identify, but if we take the case of the Prāsaṇgika madhyamika system within which we function, then that craving which arises from the ignorance grasping at a self in Prāsaṇgika is a subtle mind of desire.
This is not the same thing as coarse desire. And another question, Another, another, another. Have you question Andre? Do I have questions? But before you know, just one question then.
Sorry. I don’t know the answer to this. Why are we taught the Prāsaṇgika view, which is the most difficult view in the Lamrim? Why are we taught the Prāsaṇgika in the Lamrim, which is it’s the most difficult view and why are we taught the Prāsaṇgika view in the Lamrim and As a matter of fact, the Prāsaṇgika view is not that difficult to understand. We have covered it repeatedly.
If you try to enter in this viewpoint that is extraordinarily difficult and the viewpoint is very hard too. Yeah, Peema, second. I’m still having real difficulty thinking of a cessation as permanent and mind as impermanent. Does cessation exist apart from mind? And if so, if not, how can something that is permanent and impermanent coexist?
And what about the Heart sūtra where it says there is no suffering, no cause of suffering, no cessation of suffering, and no path which seems to indicate that all of those are dependent arisings and therefore not truly existent. I think I’ve got something messed up. So indeed, first the passage of the heart sūtra does refer to the emptiness of suffering, the origin of suffering and so forth. But regarding your main doubt on the presence of a permanent truth of cessation within an impermanent mental continuum, the truth of cessation you will attain when you attain Arhathood is none other than the vastness of your own mind. So if you understand the emptiness or the suchness of your own mind, you understand what cessation are and why they would be permanent.
We will stop here for tonight. So we will be having the last session of the year next week and even though the center will be closed over Christmas, after Christmas, there will be sessions on Tuesdays and Wednesdays where the students will gather to discuss on Tuesdays the two truths and tenets and on Wednesdays the path of the being of the small scope and the path of the being of the middling scope. If you are able to come to these group sessions, it will be highly beneficial for you.
Key terms in this teaching
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
- Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Are the three trainings of ethics, concentration and wisdom part of the six perfections, or separate from them?
The three trainings are subsumed within three of the six perfections: the perfection of ethics, the perfection of concentration and the perfection of wisdom. The other three perfections, generosity, forbearance and enthusiasm, are not present in the three trainings, not even in latency. So the three trainings are included within the six perfections, but the six perfections cover more than the three trainings do.
If there is coarse desire for coarse things, is there also a subtle desire for subtle things?
Yes, definitely. There are coarse and subtle minds, and because of this there is both coarse and subtle desire. Examples are hard to give because subtle desire is difficult to identify. Taking the Prāsaṇgika Madhyamika system, within which we function, the craving that arises from the ignorance grasping at a self, as understood in Prāsaṇgika, is a subtle mind of desire. This is not the same thing as coarse desire.