Lam Rim — 2016-11-29

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2016-11-29
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 29112016salam 2.mp3

UUID: 8c7f4bad-3f3f-4345-a736-67c38df1ac63

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2016-11-29

Duration: 1h 37m

Words: 3,807

Come. At the level of the path of meditation, after having brought to mind the recollection of emptiness at the level of the path of seeing, one reenters into meditation motivated as from the beginning by Bodhicitta. And through the continuous application of the wisdom realizing emptiness, one eliminates, one severs the obstructions to omniscience. When these are completely severed or eliminated, one has attained the state of omniscience. In brief, as is taught in the treatises, once the darkness which obscures the objects of knowledge is dispelled through wisdom, at that point, the mind or the awareness encounters the objects of wisdom.

In other words, the objects of knowledge. In other words, it knows or understands them, and one has attained omniscience. Then at that point, one has attained the state of Buddhahood in Tibetan, in Sanskrit. This corresponds to the attainment of the fifth path, the path of no more learning, in Sanskrit, means no more training.

In other words, there is nothing superior to this. It is important here to understand that, both collections, the collections of merit and of wisdom are required for the attainment of full enlightenment. One needs, naturally, the collection of merit and the motivation of bodhicitta, but fundamentally, one needs the wisdom realizing emptiness, albeit not alone. It is not sufficient to understand that one needs both collections to attain full enlightenment. One must also understand the mode of relying on both collections.

And, therefore, one needs both collections to be able to dispel the fog or the benightedness of ignorance which covers the mind. Now here, obviously, upon the attainment of full enlightenment, there is a profound radical inner transformation. But, the question is from the standpoint of Pāramitāyāna, what precisely occurs at the exterior level regarding one’s world and one’s body upon the attainment of full enlightenment? Do you understand? So, obviously, once one has generated bodhicitta and great compassion, one experiences great mental happiness and any form of mental disturbance or distress, which really is of the nature of the afflictions, has disappeared.

But that is not the issue. The issue is from the standpoint of Sūtrayāna, what precisely happens as far as exterior physicality, physical behavior the body is concerned? Then as is said, as you know, at the level of the first, ground on the path of seeing, one attains a mental body. What precisely this means is awkward. Now this is better explained in the context of tantra, but we cannot enter into that here.

In reality, just as one should engage in a practice which is a union of bodhicitta and the wisdom realizing emptiness. Likewise, one should engage in a practice which is the union of sūtra and tantra. And here, So one, therefore, must train both in bodhicitta and in the wisdom realizing emptiness. The mind must actually be transformed or turned into bodhicitta. Whereas as far as the realization of the wisdom understanding emptiness, it is more a case of the mind engaging in repeated analysis using logic and reasoning of its object to gain its realization.

Then here, obviously, the totality of the Lam Rim is really means to give rise to bodhicitta. And once bodhicitta is generated, this bodhicitta in turn induces the wisdom realizing emptiness. Then here, one really must understand that it is not the case that the Salam is separate from the Lam Rim and somehow on top of it. Instead, the totality of the Lam Rim is a prelude, is included within the Salam. Then we often say the is vast, but what matters is generating bodhicitta.

No. Bodhicitta is not generated rapidly. It is a weighty, heavy topic. Whoever’s phone is ringing, if you could put it off, please. So once one has generated bodhicitta, at that instant, one has entered the path of accumulation.

And at that point, there is no definiteness regarding whether one has generated a realization of emptiness or not. Both cases are possible. However, at the level of the middling path of accumulation of the Mahāyāna, one will definitely have generated a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer. Now whether this is based on scripture or not, on investigation, we find it is not. There are, however, numerous lines of reasoning which support this.

And the same is true for the middling path of accumulation of hearers and solitary realizers. A realization of emptiness is necessary. So here, upon reflection, we can definitely understand that through repeated habituation, we can generate bodhicitta, and we can generate a mind or a wisdom which realizes emptiness. And these are the uncommon causes of the attainment of full and utter enlightenment. Then regarding the generation of the wisdom realizing emptiness, this is not easy.

But in the case of bodhicitta, it it is clear and we know that should we be able to generate bodhicitta, great compassion and love, then we will experience extraordinary happiness even if we were to generate them for one minute of time. Then even though the goals for enlightenment or liberation are distant, and we need numerous topics to be able to reach them reach them. In brief, this is how one proceeds.

So to attain a full and utter enlightenment, we need both method and wisdom. They help or benefit each other. It is not possible to attain full and utter enlightenment with either one of them alone. Then the question which arises is how they help each other. How, for instance, does the wisdom realizing emptiness benefit the generation of bodhicitta and reciprocally?

They are, in this respect, like the two wings of a bird. With one wing alone, it is not possible to fly off. Both wings are necessary. And the question is, how do they help or benefit each other? There’s a marvelous example in in which he says, just as the bird needs two wings to cross the ocean, the children of the conquerors need two wings, method and wisdom, to cross the ocean of psychic existence.

Couldn’t fly with one wing. Then in Buddhist scriptures, the technical term in Tibetan used when one speaks of bodhicitta and the wisdom realizing emptiness is upheld by each other. Then what exactly this means must be analyzed. Then in my opinion, it is important here not just to pay lip service to the notion that both method and wisdom are necessary, that both bodhicitta and the wisdom realizing emptiness are necessary. Because then if someone asks just how precisely is this is this the case, then we fall silent and can’t answer.

Instead, one should ask oneself, how does bodhicitta benefit the wisdom realizing emptiness? How does the wisdom realizing emptiness benefit the generation of Bodhicitta? So in your opinion, why or how does Bodhicitta benefit the wisdom realizing emptiness in the attainment of enlightenment? Can you answer? Another.

And in this case, you know, one who generates bodhicitta means we generate the bodhicitta so that they can close the suffering, the portion of suffering safely. So, yeah, I need other people. I depend on other people to kindness. So that would naturally generate the this compassion, and then later that compassion will transform into The realization of emptiness induces bodhicitta or the other way around?

Realization Good. Thank you. Very good. Thank you, So, yes. All your answers are good.

In my personal opinion, the relation between bodhicitta and the wisdom realizing emptiness is as follows. Initially, one generates great compassion, and that great compassion enables one to behold the suffering of others. Upon beholding the suffering of others and in dependence on this, one generates bodhicitta the wish to attain full and utter enlightenment for their sake. And once bodhicitta has been generated, understanding that without the wisdom realizing emptiness, there is no attainment of full and utter enlightenment, one puts tremendous effort in meditating on emptiness. Therefore, the greater the great compassion in the bodhicitta, the greater the effort put in meditation on emptiness.

Take a mundane example of studies in this world. If one wishes, for instance, to become a doctor, then the effort one puts in one’s studies is contingent on the motivation for becoming a doctor. The greater the motivation, the greater the effort. In the way in which the wisdom realizing emptiness benefits Bodhicitta is as follows. As you remember, the objects of observation of Bodhicitta are twofold.

They are first full and utter enlightenment, and secondly, for the sake of others. Now the wisdom realizing emptiness is that which becomes full and utter enlightenment itself. Therefore, in dependence on this, the wisdom realizing emptiness benefits bodhicitta. Then let’s set this explanation aside. In your opinion, how does the wisdom realizing emptiness benefit the generation of bodhicitta?

Enjoy. That’s nice. Thank you. Good example. You know?

It’s a very nice example. If one’s mother is drowning in the ocean and one’s self doesn’t know how to swim and one ventures forth to help her, one will just drown and die as well. So one must know how to swim. They need you, Wendy. Very nice.

Very nice. Then in the, there is an example which is given of the difference between

Fathers and mothers. Fathers may perhaps, I don’t know, love their children a little bit less, and mothers love their children a lot more since after all they they care of them and they clean them when they go to use the toilets and so forth. But when the child is drowning in the ocean, if the mother doesn’t know how to swim and lacks strength, it is the father’s strength and swimming capacity which helps. And, therefore, it is said in the that the compassion of hearers and solitary realizers is akin to that of a mother. It is compassion, but it lacks power or potency.

Whereas the compassion of bodhisattvas, excuse me, is akin to that of a father. It is a forceful, powerful compassion. And what do you think of this? Race. There has to be a couple.

Yeah. No. 100%. You know? Just joking.

And the goal here is to explain the distinction and how bodhicitta helps in the generation of emptiness. So these lines of reasoning about how bodhicitta helps the wisdom realizing emptiness and how the wisdom realizing emptiness helps bodhicitta are very important, and they’re really beneficial when we study. Otherwise, our study is ineffectual and weak, and we just doze off whenever we want to study. And therefore, in brief, these are the five paths, the path of accumulation, preparation, seeing meditation, and normal learning, the 10 grounds. And the reason for which 10 grounds are presented in addition to the five paths is to underline just how vast and distant the realization of full and utter enlightenment is and how many steps and realizations are necessary to reach it.

Then every single step on these five paths from the middling level of the path of accumulation up to the path of no more learning hinge on a repeated habituation with meditation on emptiness over and over and over again. This is perhaps not the case with Bodhicitta since Bodhicitta is the background motivation which is generated from the beginning. So here, the way to proceed in studying emptiness since it is a topic which we do not understand understand and have little familiarity with is to study the great texts on emptiness. And when one speaks of the great texts here, I’m really referring to the works of Nāgārjuna and his sons. In other words, Ariadeva.

And then one must study these texts and then compare what one finds in these texts with what one experiences in one’s mind. Is it compatible or not? And if this compatible, proceed further. If not, check again. Said one must blend or mix hearing or understanding and experience as far as emptiness is concerned and rely on the works of Nāgārjuna and Ariadeva.

So it is said that there are realizations of emptiness before one has entered the path, and likewise, that it is not definite or certain that upon entering the path of accumulation, one will have a realization of emptiness. The reason on of this hinges on analysis of emptiness. Then in my personal opinion, from the path of preparation onwards, the afflictions are blocked. They are blocked because from the path of preparation onwards, one is generating an inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness, and this would be present continually in the mind, continually targeting the ignorance which grasps at itself, which therefore could not manifest. And this is the root of the afflictions.

And here, one refers from the level of the greater path of accumulation onwards to the attainment of a samadhi concentrated on phenomena. This dharma samadhi is a concentration which eliminates forgetfulness. Let us therefore now meditate during a couple of minutes on the definition of Bodhicitta, which is a special mind endowed with both aspirations and on how necessary this is. Mhmm.

So it is not only important, therefore, to understand Bodhicitta and to understand the wisdom realizing emptiness, but to understand how in the progression from the path of accumulation to the path of preparation, seeing, meditation, normal learning, bodhicitta acts as a prod which impels the meditation and emptiness ever forwards. So in brief, therefore, the definition of the path of accumulation is the clear manifestation of dharma. And here, during the path of accumulation, one is training in hearing and thinking. Once the object which is heard, in other words, emptiness, is realized by a mind arisen from meditation, then one has entered the path of preparation. Now minds arisen from meditation are of two types, conceptual and non conceptual.

The conceptual mind that is in for meditation focused on emptiness is prevented or present during the path of preparation. Once that mind becomes non conceptual, one has entered the path of seeing. Once one reenters non conceptual meditation on emptiness after having interrupted it at the end of the path of seeing, one has entered the path of meditation and then through repeated habituation with emptiness, one eventually reaches a point where one is able to abandon all of the obstructions to omniscience. At this point, one has entered the path of no more learning. And therefore, both the wisdom realizing emptiness and bodhicitta must be present.

Then bodhicitta acts as the backdrop for the wisdom realizing emptiness, impelling it forwards and enabling it to eliminate the obstructions to omniscience. Bodhicitta alone cannot eliminate the obstructions to omniscience. It cannot target them. Today is the last teaching of grounds and paths of the Salam for the year. And if you have the time, and I think you do, and you have the requisite physical and mental health, then it would be good to reflect over and again on the method and wisdom component of the path, bodhicitta, and the wisdom realizing emptiness and their relationship.

Then regarding Bodhicitta, there is no difference whatsoever in the presentation of Bodhicitta in the four schools of tenets. On the other hand, if we take emptiness, when we range from the non Buddhist, do not accept emptiness, all the way up to, there are a variety of modes of assertion of selflessness in the various schools of tenets. And, obviously, first, there are issues involving the ambiguities between the presentations of selflessness and world as it is. And then I suspect from your side, because there are so many different presentations of selflessness, there is a fair bit of confusion. So next year, when we resume in early February, we will continue this deep presentation of Buddhist philosophy, and Geshe la will present the Alaya Vijñāna or the mind basis of all within the eight collections of consciousness.

So this topic was broached when Geshe la taught the Chitamatra school in Tenet, but he was not able to go into it in the depths he wished and would like to do so for all of next year. Then this is not really closely related to the view. It is the uncommon position of Chitamatra. We understand the six collections of consciousness, but in addition, Chitamatra posits two other consciousnesses, the mind basis of all or the and the afflicted mind. And then in this context, you would allow me to present non nonduality according to Chitamatra.

Then Geshe-la will rely on a short text which is called in Tibetan the foundation of Alaya Vijñāna. It is translated in English under the title ocean of reasoning. You can get it from Indian publishers by get translated by Geshe Sopa. And as it is quite short, if you can, it would be ideal if you could memorize it since this is a very profound text composed by Jetsün Chökyi Gyaltsen himself. It’s, like, five, six, and it’s very short.

And in the great monasteries, it’s indispensable when one studies this text to memorize it, and then one proceeds when one studies, it studies it page by page. And in the monasteries, it’s not like here. You don’t go to the debate courtyards with volumes and kilos of books. You go with what’s in your mind. If you haven’t memorized it, you’re in trouble.

Different ways of study. And then it is a very rare opportunity in the West to receive teachings on the Chitamatra view of the eight collections of consciousness. So we are lucky enough to have a translator who can answer your questions and translate this topic. Please use the opportunity. Then this topic of consciousness is a difficult one.

In Tibetan, volumes have been written on it, and one does need experience. To be frank, it abuts eventually on Much of this is connected to Lorig. Then this has a very close relation to these seven minds and awareness. These are the projects for next year.

In the future. You know? Then when we talk of bodhicitta and the view of emptiness, frankly, it is their relationship which defines every single step of the five paths and the 10 grounds and the different names of each of these steps. Then I’ll take a couple questions at present. Just a quick question, about next year.

As, Lorig is connected to what we’re going to be studying, will there be an overview? Because I didn’t study Lorig. Lorig. No problem. Ask your translator questions as we proceed, and try to memorize the seven subdivisions of mind and awareness.

Good. Just a practical question. Do either Geshe la or Yuli have any tips on or techniques for memorization? Because I seem to have outsourced my memory to technology these days. Then for myself, when I started memorizing, I had to memorize a short text and even one stanza

That was extremely difficult for me in my homeland. But the way one proceeds is after a good night’s sleep. So if you haven’t had a good night’s sleep, don’t bother. You will not retain anything. The moment you get up in the morning before you have breakfast, the mind is very clear.

Then whatever you have memorized in the morning, you must recite in the evening just before going to bed. If you don’t, you will definitely forget it. The next morning, you recite what you recited the previous day Mhmm. And memorize something new. Then at the beginning, memorizing just one verse is extremely difficult.

But then later on through the force of habit, you can memorize more and more. It’s a matter of habit. And the way I proceeded was when I was memorizing, for instance, the verse of generating the mind of enlightenment for the sake of others. I would look at the verse, generating the mind is for the sake of others, then close my eyes and recite, generating the mind is for the sake of others, generating the mind is for the sake of others until I had it, and then move onwards. Okay.

And? Just a little question, Geshe la. A few weeks ago, you mentioned the five root afflictions, but you didn’t mention jealousy or envy as it’s sometimes called. I wondered where that comes in. And maybe the answer is up to that is in you also called them the five afflictions, I think, not connected to the view.

And when we were debating, none of us really understood in my group what that meant, and I still don’t. The five afflictions not connected. This is a loaded question. What are we gonna do? Because there are three which are totally unrelated to the view, which are desire, ignorance desire, anger, and pride.

But you really want me to enter in this explanation now. Them. Not related. So here, when we refers to the afflicted views, the afflictions which are related to the view such as wrong views, the view of the disintegrating composite, and so forth. These are afflictions which arise as a result of wrong analysis.

Mhmm. They are I mean, you must have order. And, you know, said, obviously, not all of the afflictions are included in the list. Jealousy is not. Mhmm.

Mhmm. When one is, when a being is progressing on the paths, does one have an understanding at each part each section of each path about where they are precisely on that path? Yes. Probably, those who progress on the path do understand where they are. These are precisely described in the treatises.

The treatises describe what the path of accumulation, the path of preparation is in. When they enter the path of seeing, they have a particular experiences. But their main goal is when they train in bodhicitta and the view to reduce these afflictions as much as possible. Rinpoche, I was wondering if you could tell us about, for instance, Nāgārjuna and Śāntideva. Where were they on the path?

So for Ahiyan Nāgārjuna, there are numerous explanations. It is said he reached the first ground, or the path of the first ground. Others say he reached the eighth ground. I was just curious because, if I understood correctly, the Bodhisattva reaches liberation on the eighth ground or by this eighth ground. And then I was wondering what occurs on the ninth and tenth.

It’s a good question. So the Chitamatra and Madhyamaka systems, Prāsaṇgika systems do not say that Bodhisattvas reach liberation on the eighth ground. They say that they have abandoned the afflictions on the eighth ground. Oh, you better better the afflictions, sir. It’s a very good point.

Because both Chitamatra and Prāsaṇgika assert that Bodhisattvas abandon the afflictions on the eighth ground, but they don’t attain liberation because their goal is not liberation. Their goal is for enlightenment. Mhmm. We shall stop here. Here tonight.

For tonight.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
lorig
Awareness and knowledge, the study of mind and mental factors, in order to understand and control the delusions. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
path of no more learning ashaiksa-marga (Skt); mi lob pä lam (Tib)
The fifth of the five paths, the culmination of practice: for the Mahayana, buddhahood; for hearers and solitary realizers, the liberation of an arhat. LYWA
Sutrayana döi thegpa (Tib)
The Sutra Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Paramitayana; the non-tantric path that encompasses both Hinayana practices such as the thirty-seven wings of enlightenment and Mahayana practices such as the six perfections... LYWA
tantra gyü (Tib)
Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top