Awakening Heart — 2016-04-27

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)
Awakening Heart — 2016-04-27
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2016-04-27 – KR.mp3

UUID: 43305d70-7f21-4f95-ab52-4895bff2b1cf

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Awakening Heart (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2016-04-27

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 26m

Words: 3,525

As Chitung Dopa says in the Three Principles of the Path, albeit endowed with renunciation excuse me, with definite emergence in bodhicitta, should one not have the wisdom which realizes the mode of abiding. Now the meaning of these two verses is probably that even though definite emergence and bodhicitta have been generated within one’s own mind stream, if one lacks the wisdom which realizes, in other words which has ascertained emptiness, then one will be unable to attain liberation or full enlightenment. Sometimes it is beneficial to proceed to the whole Namib, meditating on point by point and trying to generate a sensation, a feeling for the topic. At other times, it is more beneficial to analyze and to investigate given topics. Now here, our topic is the path of the being of the great scope.

The preliminaries for the path of the being of the great scope are the paths which are shared with the being of the small and the middling scope. This verse or these two verses of Jetsongkhapa intimate that even though one has generated within one’s mind stream what is required for the paths of the middling and of the great scope, in other words definite emergence and bodhicitta, nonetheless without the wisdom realizing emptiness one will be unable to attain liberation or full enlightenment. For beginners such as ourselves, it is very helpful to engage in an overview meditation to try to generate an experience. For instance, when we focus on the path shared with the being of the small scope, initially we meditate mainly on death and impermanence. And at this point, after realizing that death is certain, the time of death is uncertain, we focus on the suffering of the lower realms.

Wondering what precisely can protect us from the suffering of the lower realms. That which can protect us is a triple gem whose main instructions are none other than abandoning non virtue and training in virtue, in other words, ethics. Then once one engages in the path shared with it being of the middling scope, as is said, if one does not put effort at abandoning the truths of suffering and the origin of suffering, one initially trains in seeing the thoughts of cyclic existence and independence on this in training at the noble truth of the path and of cessation. So this is how we should proceed. Now, as was said, it becomes clear that there are beings in whose mind stream both definite emergence and bodhicitta have been generated but who have not gained a realization or an ascertainment of emptiness.

So setting bodhicitta aside, let us take definite emergence, this means that there are beings in whose mind stream uncontrived definite emergence has been generated, but such beings do not have the realization of emptiness. So in other words, this means that there are beings who have not gained definite ascertainment of emptiness. In other words, who have not a realization of emptiness by means of a valid cognizer, and who have nonetheless generated definite emergence and contrived definite emergence and therefore are beings of or following the path shared with the being of the small scope. Then at this point, if we analyze and ask ourselves what is the specificity of Buddhism, then clearly the path shared with the beings of the small scope is not the specificity of Buddhism since other great religious traditions have something very similar. And perhaps neither is the path shared with the beings of the great scope since we do find elements of this in the other traditions.

Then I would like to ask you, if we say that the path shared with the being of the middling scope is the uncommon feature of Buddhism and on this path there are beings who have generated uncontrived definite emergence but do not have an experience of emptiness. How can this path be the specificity of Buddhism? There is questions, so can you ask one? So if you’re going to say that uncontrived renunciation is the uncommon feature of Buddhism, it’s uncommon characteristics, then you have to explain how it is. It’s generating great compassion or not is not really relevant.

Lily. The object of attainment is moksha or liberation. Is it to fit? There’s dangerous lines of reasoning you have there. A new Taliban.

Andre. The non Buddhist religious traditions of ancient India assert the existence of psychic existence and they assert the existence of Nirvana. They seem to identify psychic existence with something akin to the contaminated aggregates and they are seeking for a Nirvana or a Moksha which is identical to ours. There is only disagreement regarding the means. So that’s precisely it.

The difference between the Buddhist and non Buddhist traditions hinges exclusively on emptiness. But that is not the question I am asking. I am asking why do we say or can we say that the path shared with the being of the middling scope is a Buddhist specificity? According to your line of reasoning, every being on the path shared with the being of the middling scope would have to realize emptiness. But we know that’s not the case.

Since there are beings which have generated uncontrived renunciation, but do not have emptiness, realization of emptiness within their mind stream. So what is the difference? So Gesheera’s question is, why can we say that the path shared with the being of the middling scope is the uncommon characteristic of Buddhism? The means. Okay.

Teacher? Molly? Molly? No? You haven’t come close to the answer.

Chris? Yes, that’s liberation. And another? Yeah. Definite emergence has no particular relation with Bodhicitta since hearers and solitary realizers generate definite emergence and do not generate Bodhicitta.

Bodhicitta itself has a relation with definite emergence since definite emergence is a preliminary to the eventual generation of bodhicitta. Yeah, yet. Yes, but that’s not a question, So your answers are good. You’re trying to think of the problem. It is clear, we all agree that the difference between Buddhist and non Buddhist is the wisdom realizing emptiness.

But when we say that the path shared with the being of the middling scope is specific to Buddhism, what exactly do we mean? Why is it specific to Buddhism? If someone has generated uncontrived renunciation, they have entered the path shared with the being of middling scope. But there are beings who have generated uncontrived renunciation who have entered the path shared with the being of the middling scope who have no ascertainment of emptiness. Then don’t you think it’s easy to create uncontrived definite emergence since you don’t need any realization of emptiness?

So however, it is possible for beings to generate a realization of emptiness without having generated definite emergence. Now here when we refer to the Prasangika view, we are referring to subtle interdependence. So then what is the issue? Once one has generated uncontrived definite emergence as some of you pointed out, one then trains in the four noble truths. One trains initially in the noble truth of suffering which leads to an understanding of the noble truth of the origin of suffering.

This abuts on the noble truth of cessation. To generate the noble truth of cessation, one then trains in the noble truth of the path. What is the noble truth of the path? None other than the wisdom realizing emptiness. Now there are numerous presentations of selflessness and emptiness in Buddhist teachings.

We have the selflessnesses and emptinesses of the schools of tenets from Svatankhamadhyamika downwards, as well as the subtle interdependence which is a presentation of emptiness specific to Prasankhamadhyamika. Now, once one has generated a fully characterized, uncontrived definite emergence within one’s mind stream, one will have necessarily generated a sense of one of the selflessnesses from prasanika downwards. This is impossible for the non Buddhist Indian philosophers since they explicitly assert the existence of a self which is permanent one and independent. Do you understand? If you understand this, it’s extremely good.

Then obviously there are numerous presentations of selflessness and emptiness, numerous in terms of subtleness within the Buddhist teachings. The best is to understand subtle emptiness according to prasankika. Then once one starts study, one engages in the process of analysis and one analyzes a lot, can guarantee you’ll spend a lot of time at it. Now, in brief, once one has generated uncontrived fully characterized renunciation, one has the realizations of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. One does have, however, to proceed from the path shared with the being of the middling scope up to the path of the great vehicle, the Mahayana.

And this is done through generating great compassion. Now there are numerous debates about this. For instance, some say, well, there cannot be compassion in the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers, since obviously there is no great compassion and then by extension they go much further and they say, actually the four immeasurables cannot exist within the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers. There are numerous debates, very sharp debates like this. Then there were some very good debates in the old days about this for instance.

One very sharp debate was, but basically, there can’t be anything like compassion in the mind stream of hearers, since they’re exclusively focused on their own liberation. This is a very sharp debate. Another debate is that hearers do not understand or appreciate the qualities of a fully enlightened being. And the answer to this is naturally they do appreciate the qualities of a fully enlightened being since they have received their teachings from a fully enlightened being, Gurus Akemoni. To which one answers yes, but they do not wish to endorse the robes of the qualities of a fully enlightened being.

So these are very sharp and helpful debates for us because otherwise, if one doesn’t study and reflect in this way, then if one meditates, one’s meditation is empty, what exactly is one going to meditate about? Do you understand? Now these are very very helpful lines of reasoning. If we think in this way, our understanding will deepen. This is why it is extremely important for us to receive teachings and understand the qualities, the benefits, the potency of altruism of the mind which wishes to help others and to focus on it.

Otherwise, there is considerable risk when we generate for the first time definite emergence and this is why a specific advice given in the LUM RIM is that upon generating definite emergence, one should focus on the qualities of bodhicitta and altruism. So we must therefore put efforts at generating altruism within our mind stream and bodhicitta. And for this, we must strive at generating great compassion. Now once great compassion has been generated, then we have at that moment put an end to the paths of both hearers and solitary realizers. And this is why the question, but is there no compassion within the mind stream of a hearer is a very sharp one.

Then it is difficult to answer the question of whether great compassion is present or not within the minds of a hearer. Great compassion after all is the mind which wishes to free countless sentient beings or sentient beings without exception from suffering and the causes of suffering, isn’t it? So it is difficult to say for hearers and pratyeka buddhas whether or not certain states of mind are present within their mind stream or not, let alone for ourselves. So let us take ourselves to start with. When we ourselves generate the wish to be free from suffering and the causes of suffering, are we specifically referring to wishing to be free from the suffering of hunger, of cold, of civil strife, and so forth?

Is this what we are talking about? The answer is no. We are not referring to being free from physical sufferings, but from mental suffering. Then great compassion would be the wish to free all sentient beings from mental suffering and the causes of mental suffering. Is this present or not in the minds of hearers in your opinion?

Do you understand? So then are we saying that hearers and solitary realizers do not experience the wish to free all sentient beings without exception from mental suffering and the causes of mental suffering? It is difficult to assert something like this. If we examine our own minds, let us take a very simple example, and here I am not saying that we are Mahayana beings, just normal persons. If a normal person on the road sees it say in India, a little child miserable who is on the point of dying of hunger with his mouth wide open, then doesn’t such a person wish to do something to help their child?

Anything they can, Yes or no? Now, hearers and solitary realizers understand fully the nature of suffering and here we’re not talking of physical suffering. We are talking of mental suffering. They understand that it is rooted in the afflictions and they wish to be free from this and by extension, they wish other beings to be free from them. Whether the beings they encounter are rich or poor.

Now, if this is the case, how can we say that compassion is not present within their mind stream? Do you understand? Alright, thank you. On the other hand, it is explicitly asserted in Buddhist scriptures that great compassion does not exist within the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers. Because the boundary between the Hinayana and the Mahayana is bodhicitta.

And the cause of bodhicitta is great compassion. So should great compassion be present within the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers, then they would quite rapidly develop bodhicitta. So I would like us now to meditate during a couple minutes on this. Is great compassion present or not within the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers? What are the reasons for?

What are the reasons against? I explained all the points. Open the playbook, page one. Resign one b two three four in the page five, number six, of me, first one and three. Now generally speaking, the topics of the Mahayana are easy to understand.

They’re quite pleasant to think about. It is pleasant to think about bodhicitta and great compassion. It is not easy to generate them within our mind streams. This is in contrast to the topics of the path shared with the being of the small scope such as the 16 characteristics of the four noble truths which are difficult topics about emptiness and so forth. Then generally speaking in a country such as this one, really there is very little physical suffering.

The main suffering is mental suffering. And the main means to eliminate mental suffering is to generate altruism in bodhicitta. Once altruism and bodhicitta are generated, then mental suffering disappears. When mental suffering has disappeared as a result, much physical suffering disappears as well. So, the presence of bodhichitta indicates that the path is a Mahayana path.

The absence of bodhichitta indicates that one is dealing with a being which has not entered the Mahayana path but has entered the path. Now, if this is the case, what can we say about the presence of great compassion within the mind stream of hearers and of solitary realizers? In a nutshell, there is no great compassion within the mind stream of hearers and solitary realizers because great compassion is the cause of bodhicitta. And if great compassion were present within their mind stream, then quite rapidly and rather effortlessly, they would generate bodhicitta. On the other hand, if we say that great compassion is absent in their mind stream, are we saying that hearers and solitary realizers do not wish and pray for all sentient beings to be free from the suffering of all, from suffering and the causes of suffering, to have happiness and the cause of happiness do not train in joy and equanimity?

Obviously they do. In other words, there is almost no reason for which great compassion should not be present in their mind stream and there’s actually a lot of reasons for which it should be present in their mind stream. Yes or no? Just a minute, just a minute. So since our topic is the Mahayana, the great vehicle, then we must understand bodhicitta, love and great compassion.

We must also understand the process of generating bodhicitta through the sevenfold causal process and the interchange of self and others. We must understand what precisely is meant by great compassion. So in your opinion, what are the reasons for which great compassion is not present within the mind stream of Hinayana practitioners. What karma would they accumulate? The Hinayana practitioners, they don’t teach and wish for happiness for others?

No need to say a lot. Another, do you have other reasons? Only a fully enlightened being can relieve the suffering of all beings, and their aspiration is not to become enlightened to do that. That is not the reason for the not having great compassion, is it? And another?

I’m just speculating that there would be no particular reason for the hearer to ascertain the object of great compassion. In other words, all sentient beings. So while they might wish to generate immeasurable compassion, they don’t bother to expand their mind to include the objects which result in human beings. Another? Yeah.

Hiniana practitioners believe in great compassion. They value great compassion, but they believe that it is too difficult for themselves to attain, and so they focus on the smaller Because they have no suffering, they lack the common ground for empathy, so they can’t, they find it hard to develop or achieve her. You were talking Healer and solitary realizer, Achat. We are just talking about hearers and solitary realizers who have entered the path. In the mind stream of hearer and solitary realizer arhat, there is no suffering indeed.

Emma? Yeah. I’m not sure, I think a little bit like Andrew that we all have compassion in our mind stream, but great compassion doesn’t just happen. You have to really work at it. And heroes in solitary realizes have chosen to be in Ayanna’s, that they’re concerned with their own liberation.

It’s It’s too difficult to try and save everyone. Now, what are your questions? Just to clarify, when you say, is there a difference between compassion and great compassion? Yes, there is a difference. All of us have compassion or empathy within our mind stream.

We have empathy for our father, we have empathy for our mother, we have empathy for our children. But great compassion is a wish for all sentient beings without exception, to be free of suffering. Now I haven’t been able to check with the transcript with Jill because she’s away, but last week there was a quote from Sutra. The obstructions are adventitious. And I thought that the meaning of adventitious was without cause.

Or maybe I got the meaning wrong. So I just was wondering if Geshela could re quote or clarify that. So the quote was the obstructions are adventitious. The nature of the mind is clear light. So this quote actually is from the Pramana Vartika, have to correct in the transcript.

And the meaning of the quote is that the nature of the mind is clear light and the afflictions do not stain the very nature of the mind. In other words, the afflictions can be abandoned. They can be eliminated by the application of antidotes. Andre? My question is, what is the relationship if any between fully characterized definite emergence or uncontrived definite emergence and selflessness.

And I asked that question because I heard previously that you can have uncontrived definite emergence without having realised emptiness, but then I thought I heard Geshela say today that if you have fully characterised uncontrived definite emergence, then you have necessarily realized some level of selflessness. So when we have created uncontrived definite emergence within our mind stream, then we do not necessarily have a realization of emptiness in the Prasangika madhyamika sense of the term. However, we necessarily have a fully characterized understanding of coarse selflessness. This is why one can say that the path shared with the being of the middling scope is specific to Buddhism, since all beings of that path have an understanding of coarse selflessness of persons. Okay.

So, then I’d like to ask you because we spoke of the presence of the absence of great compassion. What is the meaning of great compassion? Exactly as the full immeasurable says, may all sentient beings be free from suffering and its causes. Understanding that we are one and others are many and so having compassion for many, not just for oneself. We have an understanding that all beings have been our mothers, then we wish to return their kindness and their support for the lives that we have.

Spontaneous wish to remove all suffering from all beings. Thank you.

Key terms in this teaching

bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
four immeasurables caturapramana (Skt); tsä mä zhi (Tib)
Also known as the four immeasurable thoughts or the four sublime attitudes, these are four states of mind or aspirations: loving kindness, compassion, sympathetic joy and equanimity. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top