Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2017-06-14 – LamRim.mp3
UUID: 6cbe4b37-a493-4b90-87f7-67e0ad4ffab8
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2017-06-14
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 31m
Words: 4,045
Okay. As Śāntideva says in his Bodhicharyavatara, all the recitations and mantras are of no use if the mind is distracted. And indeed, one may recite mantras for years. If the mind is distracted, there is no benefit. Undeniably, it does induce, physical and verbal virtue, but one does not derive from these recitations potency.
And, therefore, once the mind is not distracted elsewhere and in addition is stable, this could qualify as meditation. Then to say that our mind should not be distracted elsewhere might sound a little bit awkward since after all, we do have to eat for the sake of our bodies. We do have to drink and so forth. However, what is being said here is that when the occasion arises or in the requisite context, one’s mind should not be distracted elsewhere and should be stable. So here, the mind is something which is nonmaterial unlike table, for instance.
And as a result, it can be transformed, whereas a table and object resist transformation. This is why the ancient injunction of the Kadampas was when alone protect your mind. And as a result, it is of great benefit for us to reflect on topics such as this, leisure and endowment, which we have obtained, this human rebirth of leisure and endowment, which is so important, as well as death and impermanence. So Geshe was asking me who exactly, gave this injunction. I thought it might be a Kadampa Geshe, but, Geshe was said it might also be an Indian master of yore we’re not quite sure of any way.
This injunction, when alone, protect your mind, finds an exact pendant in Śāntideva’s Bodhicharyavatara. And, therefore, we should examine our minds when we are alone. And, if our minds have scattered towards something which is meaningful, then why not? If our minds are focused on what is relevant to this life that is barely acceptable, And otherwise, if our minds are scattered towards something nonproductive, then, we should restrain them. And reflecting in this way and subduing our minds, we should reflect on the importance of this physical base which we have obtained, a base of leisure and endowment, and also reflect on the fact that all of us definitely will will die.
Every one of us in this room is familiar with the uncertainty of the time of death. And this is why Je Tsongkhapa says in his three principles of the path very succinctly, through familiarizing the mind with the fact that, leisure and endowment are difficult to obtain and short lived, turn away from the vanities of this life. So this is very beneficial advice, and we should proceed in this fashion giving advice to ourselves. This is not a difficult topic unlike emptiness. It is something which is easy for us to understand.
And our goal here is to become masters of our own mind, to control our own minds. It is precisely because people lose control of their own minds that all the mental diseases which are so prevalent nowadays occur. It is because the mind falls under the sway of the afflictions. So here, what should proceed in this fashion, giving advice to oneself and reflecting on the fact that we have obtained, an extraordinary, physical base, this human rebirth of leisure and endowment, and that it is fleeting. It is transient.
And we have received, vast swathes of advice regarding this from our teachers, and this advice goes all the way back to Buddha Śākyamūni himself. So when precisely do we intend to put all of this in practice, if at all? It is definite that we will die. There is no doubt about this. And this in turn leads to, a conviction in the existence of past and future lives, which, most of you probably have.
Now here, we function on the basis of a conviction, but this has to be bolstered by reasoning. Why exactly do future lives exist and so forth? Then even though all of us are convinced that we will die, that it is certain that we will die, nonetheless, due to the grasping at our own permanence, we think that it will not be now. It will not be anytime soon. Now, the fact that this opportunity for death, this occasion of death is deferred indefinitely is due precisely to grasping at one’s own permanence, and one thinks one will live one hundred, two hundred, three hundred years.
Then because we’re beings of the desire realm, we are overwhelmed by desire, perhaps not totally 100%, but certainly a full 90%. Then it is precisely due to grasping at one’s own permanence that the time of death is deferred indefinitely. And that at the as a result, we make vast and elaborate projects for our lives. We will do this. We will work at that.
We will travel here without realizing precisely that death can occur at any moment. And whenever the thought that the time of death is uncertain arises, it is immediately discarded by this grasping at one’s own permanence. It is a. So here, when one speaks of giving up the body of this life, of giving up this life, in other words, I do not mean by that that you should abandon your car, you should abandon your house, you should abandon your girlfriend, your boyfriend, your children, your money, and go out and live in the woods somewhere. That is not what I am saying.
This is not what I’m saying. This is stupid. You’ve got to change your mind. I’m not saying one has to give up one’s car and one’s house and so forth. So once one has this conviction in the existence of past and future lives, there will be no great fear at the time of death simply because just as, let us say, when oneself falls, one’s car falls in a house, one does not experience great fear because there is a foundation on which it will fall.
It is not gonna fall indefinitely. Likewise, at the time of one’s death, one will think
Well, I have not committed any major nonvirtues. I should be able to hope for a higher rebirth. So here, what is really important is therefore not to abandon exterior objects. Exterior objects are necessary. But what is important is to understand their limitations and to focus partly on one’s own mind and on the antidotes to the afflictions within one’s own mind.
Mhmm. So you understand the existence of past and future lives. Past and future lives must have a base or a foundation. What is the base or their foundation? The subtle mind.
Do you understand? I’m not asking you whether you your understanding is based on conviction, but whether it’s based on reason. Yes. Yes, Do you believe in past and future lives based on faith or conviction, or do you believe in them based on reasoning and logic? What are your reasons?
What’s the logic behind it? Come on. Come on, please. So it’s good that you’ve heard of the issue of consciousness, but it is not consciousness in general one can talk about here since this does not apply to sensory consciousnesses or mental consciousnesses. It must apply to a subtle consciousness.
So this is something we see during the dream state. For instance, instance, there are people who dream. And during their dream, they can project themselves in the future one week or one year in the future. And for that matter, at a latter date, see places where they were in the past. Now this is only possible, due to the existence of the subtle consciousness.
Have you had these dreams? That is the news of. You’ve got to examine, right, your dreams. So this is called experience. If you examine your dreams and you gain experience, this will happen.
And sometimes you have I’m not saying all the time, but sometimes you have special dreams and you see places in the dream. And then later on in the future, at a point in your life, you see these same places. And then you say to yourself, my goodness, I dreamt of this. Then this is once again the manifestation of the subtle consciousness, and it indicates the existence of future lives. Do you understand?
You got the point? In the past in the past. I I taught everybody in the future. You know? Deja vu is in the past, so Geshe la is teaching about the future.
Yeah. Yeah. Is talking of precognitive dreams, Dreams of the future. So it’s precisely due to these manifestations of subtle consciousness in the dream state and pre cognitive dreams that one gets a clear sense of the existence of future lives. So then regarding memories of past lives, then these are well known and well attested.
Attested. There are numerous children who have memories of their own past lives. They remember the buildings they lived in, the areas they lived in. They remember their parents, the names of their parents. In practice, they end up with two sets of parents, the parents of this life and the parents of the previous life.
Then there are numerous scriptural sources for this, but one can get a bit confused with this long stream of scripture references. One has to rely on one’s own experience. Do you understand? Yep. Okay.
So it is when one is able to generate through these experiences and reasonings a conviction in the existence of past and future lives, of one’s own past and future lives that in turn one becomes, very wary about engaging in non virtuous deeds and very keen on engaging in virtuous deeds. And such an outlook eliminates all fear at the time of death. Khensur Rinpoche was extraordinary in this respect. He said, this is my death. This is what is happening.
There was no fear at all. So here, I am not talking of mundane courage. The stupid courage of those who don’t understand what is happening in the face of death. Instead, I am talking of who listening over and again on the stages of the past, the Lam Rim, and reflecting on them, giving rise to an experience and realization from meditation, which causes us to have no fear of death. Please distinguish these two.
So be mindful of the fact that the causes, the conditions of death are very numerous, like those which cause the extinction of a flame. Then I don’t know whether you accept the existence of the four elements, earth, fire, air, and wind. But in traditional Tibetan medicine, their disruption can lead to death. If you prefer the Western metaphor of the engine, like the engine of a car, then small things can prevent the engine of the body from working. Australia.
And take care of your health. Obviously, in Australia, you have excellent material conditions. So take care of your health. Then I don’t need to say a lot about this. As Westerners, you know exactly what to do.
All does not hinge, obviously, on about around diet. There are other factors. And then independence on the excellent material conditions in this country, try to think a little bit about dharma. Try to think about bodhicitta, about the view. And then when you die after in your next life because of the karmic imprints implanted in your mind, then these lines of thinking will arise naturally.
Then when we speak of death, the main fear should actually be to fall in the lower And therefore, one should, in keeping with the verses of Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path, since a rebirth of leisure and endowment is rare and fleeting through habituating the mind to this, relinquish the vanities of this life. One should combine in one’s meditation, meditating on a rebirth of leisure and endowment and on death and impermanence inseparably. And this is the foundation of the path shared with the being of the small scope. It also ushers entrance into the path shared with the being of the middling and the path of the being of the great scope. And therefore, Paul, it is necessary to have the requisite conditions for this life that is not sufficient.
True happiness is not physical, but mental happiness. And what disturbs mental peace or mental happiness, it is what we call the afflictions. Therefore, one must identify and target the afflictions if one has time to do so. And if one doesn’t have time, then drop it. Well, there are many afflictions.
The six root afflictions are foremost. These are desire, anger, ignorance, doubt, afflicted doubt, pride, and the afflicted view. Ideally, one should be able to abandon them, but this is difficult. At the very least, one should reduce their influence. When I say that it is difficult to abandon, I don’t mean we shouldn’t try.
I mean it takes time. What is really important is to focus on the thoughts of the affliction. Once one understands their thoughts, one will make effort at not falling under this way.
And then we will become beings who are wishing to be liberated or beings who are striving for liberation. To be liberated or liberation here are synonymous. At present, we are bound by the fetters of the affliction. Liberation is merely being freed from these. So here in Sanskrit, cyclic existence is called saṃsāra.
In Tibetan, the term is, literally, the wheel, which is more frequently trans translated as transmigration. Then what exactly occurs within cyclic existence? That which we are transmigrating through are the five contaminated aggregates. That which transmigrates is the person, and that which causes the transmigration is the afflictions. Then, Geshe-la has just mentioned that in October, he will be teaching the 12 limbs of dependent origination, which connects directly with this.
So it enables one to understand in detail the process of transmigration within saṃsāra. saṃsāra or cyclic existence is the five contaminated aggregates. The transmigrator is the I. That which causes transmigration is karma and affliction. The 12 limbs explain how this operates.
So here, karma and affliction are like a rope. This rope ties whom? It ties us, the person. To what? What are we bound to?
We are bound to the five contaminated aggregates. What does liberation mean? Liberation means releasing these fetters. That is the meaning of liberation. Do you understand?
This is the meaning of liberation. Do you understand? So here, what is critical is to understand the thoughts of the afflictions and of karma, and this is difficult. So it might be simpler to try to understand the thoughts of the affliction or more basically, the thoughts of these coarse aggregates of our, specifically this coarse body. As a result of which, whatever happiness we have is fleeting and turns rapidly into suffering.
So as long as we have not abandoned the afflictions, we will be reborn with these coarse aggregates, with this coarse body, which generally speaking is born from or arises from the union of the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of the mother. Then once we are reborn in such a coarse body, then there is only suffering again. At present, let us engage in meditation on the following topics. First, let us meditate on the nature of the dream consciousness and how we all understand that it is a subtle consciousness and how in dependence on such subtle consciousness, past and future lives, can be understood. Then let us reflect on the fact that we reincarnate within the contaminated aggregates in dependence on the afflictions and suffer as a result.
And that we are not alone in this, but that everybody is undergoing the same process. In so doing, we will cover the path shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope. Please open the preview page one shall be recite alarm b two three four and also page five number six man offering verse one and three
So as Ārya Asaṇga says, through extinguishing karma and the afflictions, liberation. Now here, extinguishing sepa in Tibetan means to abandon. To abandon means that through the application of the corresponding antidotes, the afflictions cease to arise. How is this possible? All existence are subdivided into two categories, permanent and impermanent phenomena.
Whatever exists is either permanent or impermanent. The afflictions are impermanent. So this is the best way to look at it. When one engages in the study of Buddhist philosophy of Tenets, then one proceeds in this fashion, and it leads to a very stable understanding. Existence.
Existed. No. So as was said, the afflictions are regrouped in the category of impermanent phenomena. Now in general, impermanent phenomena are subdivided into three, form or matter, consciousness, and nonassociated compositional phenomena. Now since afflictions are included within the category of things or impermanent phenomena, they must necessarily fall in one of the three categories.
So now the afflictions are not We must analyze this one this one. The afflictions not formed because they cannot be seen. They cannot be heard. They cannot be smelled. They cannot be tasted.
They cannot be touched. It is, however, possible to counter them. That’s easy to understand. Now what makes it a bit awkward is that afflictions can be countered. So what we might be tempted to think that they are formed, but they are not.
They are consciousness. Consciousness is divided exhaustively into two, sensory and mental consciousness. Whatever is a consciousness is necessarily one of these two. So in your opinion, within sensory and mental consciousnesses, which of the two are afflictions? Where do they fit in?
Mental. They’re not sensory consciousnesses. Right? Why? Because they’re not what?
They’re not formed. Yeah. Are you saying that sensory consciousness is a form? No. I’m asking her.
So why are they not sensory consciousnesses? So broadly speaking, to keep it simple, we’ll say that the afflictions are mental consciousnesses. So this is something you have to check within yourselves. Actually, there are nonconceptual mental consciousnesses. Good.
Thank you. Good idea. But you know? So then the afflictions are subdivided into the six root afflictions and the 20 secondary or branch afflictions. It would be inappropriate to explain them all at once.
I would like to explain them quietly over time. So can you tell me what the meaning or the definition of an affliction is? This is Aria Asaṇga’s definition. Whatever is a mental factor which induces inappropriate states of mind is an affliction. Yeah.
Of course. This is what one should understand. For example, anger. You know? Jealousy.
When they arise, they trouble the mind immediately, don’t they? That should be self evident. Whenever, anger or jealousy, envy arise, these are extremely coarse afflictions. As a result of powerful anger or bitter jealousy, we are unable to sleep. The food we eat has no taste.
Everyone in this room has experienced that. Okay. Have you questions? Few question. Yep.
Susie? What is the afflicted doubt and afflicted view? And can Geshe la give each example? So it’s a good question. Afflicted doubt would, for instance, be the doubt which wonders do past and future lives exist or not.
And the affected view would be, for instance, the view that past and future lives not exist at all. This is the view of the locayatas, the materialists of ancient India. Tell me if this is a good idea or not. I was thinking as a way of learning about the afflictions and the antidotes to make some snap cards, you know, those that card game. Would that be a terrible way to do it, to get familiar with them?
Yes. Very good. So it’s a marvelous idea, but that alone is not gonna cause the afflictions to disappear. So what is really important is to understand the meaning of the afflictions. And then it is through applying the antidotes that they will disappear.
It’s very good, however. You’re explaining this in terms of your own understanding. Yeah. Mhmm. Mhmm.
This was a yeah. So you’re thinking, for instance, of writing down these six root afflictions and their meaning on a piece of or the two two by four, whatever those cards are. That’s very good. Mhmm. I know.
Okay. Good. Could Kischler explain a little bit further about the substantial the subtle mind? And he said that an example of that was dreaming a place and then arriving at that place in the future, and that that was an example of future lives. Can you explain why that has happened in his life, not in the future life?
Why that is an example of future lives? Good question. So to start with, I would say that when we try to understand past and future lives at present, we rely on course consciousnesses, the sensory and especially the mental consciousness. Now these are coarse consciousnesses because they cease in deep sleep. Now with the dream consciousness, we have already access to a subtle consciousness, a consciousness which will move onwards after our body or physical aggregates have been cast in the flames of the funeral pyre.
Settled. Settled. Settled? I think so. There there nothing.
100%. How would one know in your dream state whether the dream and the subtle consciousness was seeing a past life or a future life? This is something which is only possible with a lot of experience. To start with, one needs a really clear dream, not just any casual dream during the night, and one must take careful notes of the dream and then examine very carefully. Some people have very dull dreams.
They’re not clear at all. Others have very clear dreams. In my place, my dreams are very clear. I’m told some people don’t dream at all. Jesus.
That’s funny. Yeah.
Sorry. Why? Okay. I was wondering about, the reincarnation of realized lamas. Is that another reason, another, indication of future lives for us to be able to understand them, having re realized lamas reincarnate.
Mhmm. And that would be based would that be based on both reason and conviction? Yes. Yes. Definitely.
Definitely. It would be raised based on the reason. Mhmm. Yes.
Yes. So if through encountering the reincarnation of a high teacher, this strong feeling arose in your mind or this proves the existence of past lives, then that would be a conviction. That would not be raised based on reasoning alone. Vishal, I wondered if clarity of dreams is just something that happens by itself with the strength of one’s meditation practice, or if there are specific practices that one would do. I remember Ralph giving a presentation on lucid dreaming.
So in the West, there are exercises or practices you can do to strengthen your dreams. Is there a Tibetan or Buddhist equivalent? So most definitely, there are meditation practices to increase, foster the clarity of dreams. They begin by recognizing the dreams as dreams. Mhmm.
It’s not easy to recognize a dream as a dream. One needs a lot of experience to do this. Well, okay. Not easy. Exactly.
Yep. This is a bit presumptuous of me. Think that quote when in company, what’s your speech and when alone, what’s your mind? Maybe a T shirt. Probably.
Yes. Most probably. You can check-in on Google. You know? On it.
Most probably. When you have a dream and you wake up and you have a clear recollection of the dream, Is that means that it’s a future you know, what what you’re talking about? Precognitive. Yeah. Precognitive.
So sort Generally speaking, that is not true. Dreams are an example of, what is false. However, when the dream is very clear, then one must examine it. One first writes it down. One notes it down.
So for instance, Tibetans for Tibetans, one often has very clear dreams of walking in plains or in mountains. And, obviously, one doesn’t dream of oceans because there are no oceans in Tibet. Then here, when if the dream is very clear, why don’t you write it down? Right? It might be important.
Okay. Maybe he has stopped. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
- One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.