1 h 38 min · 4,155 words · 4 July 2018
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. This session continues a Lam Rim teaching, covering motivation for study and analytical meditation on the self. The teacher explains that the felt self, appearing as an autonomous owner of body and mind, is the object of negation, and distinguishes coarse from subtle selflessness of persons. Students describe their experience of the self during a ten-minute meditation, and the talk closes with announcements.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 39m
UUID: d4e9c6d4-c3ad-42a1-a165-07a7a507ade5
Date: 2018-07-04
Words: 4,151
So today, Geshe la would like to cover two topics. First, the motivation, which we should generate, and secondly, the topic of meditation. Believes that it is very helpful to proceed in this way presenting subdivisions, then one can reflect on them carefully. Then it’s a bit odd to ask about the motivation since everything we do from the moment we rise in the morning is, impelled by a motivation, whether good or bad. Then in society at large, we hear regularly people asking, so what was your motivation in doing this?
This is quite common. What we never hear is generate a motivation. This is actually dharma talk. Then, when, you attend a center such as this one, you do so with a motivation. If your motivation was, I will go today to attend Lam Rim teachings to turn this life into something meaningful, then that is the best possible motivation.
Then Geshe la will not ask this, from you as a question. He’d like you to ask yourselves. The first time you went to a Buddhist center, why did you go? What was your motivation? Why did you go to the center?
Did you go to make your life human life meaningful or not? If not, what for? Why did you go? Then that is the motivation. Hello.
Easy. You know? Very easy. Sorry. Very easy.
Easy. Yeah. Easy to understand the motivation. So perhaps if you attended teachings with the motivation to make your mind, to make your life profoundly meaningful, that would be the best of motivations. Then if instead of that, you came to the center thinking, what is Geshe la?
In other words, Geshe la himself going to teach us new and exciting tonight, different and original, then that is probably not the best motivation. It’s also not the worst motivation. It is probably neutral. Then if one comes to a center to study the Lam Rim with the hope of becoming famous in the world, a famous scholar reputed and all that, then that is definitely an inappropriate wrong motivation. So Geshe-la thinks that these motivations summarize probably your motivations.
Because he can’t really see why you would come for no reason whatsoever. Then one should think that whatever experience one is able to gain as a result of studying the Lam Rim, one will use it to help others as much as one can since after all, the Lam Rim is a Mahāyāna teaching. Dharma becomes Mahāyāna or Hīnayāna dharma exclusively dependent on the motivation. The topics are the same, whether it is the four noble truths, the 37 limbs of enlightenment, or the, 12 limbs of dependent origination in the forward and the reverse order. The topics in Hīnayāna and Mahāyāna dharma are identical.
What is different is the motivation. And also, one must say that studying the Lam Rim with the motivation of gaining liberation for one’s own self alone is an inappropriate wrong motivation. Then this is not to say that there are many Lam Rim practitioners who attained the state of liberation as a result of their study of the Lam Rim simply because they practiced for their own sake and their own sake alone. That state is attained because that was their motivation. Geshe-la is not saying, however, that attaining the state of an arhat is an easy affair.
It is not. Then if one has continually generated a motivation which is linked with Bodhisattva, that will be present. If that has not been generated in the past, at the very least, one should generate a motivation related or linked to bodhicitta. Do you understand? So, this is for the first topic, motivation.
Now, Geshe-la will explain meditation. Please listen carefully. There are two types of meditation, analytical meditation and concentration of fixative meditation. At present, Geshe la will mainly explain analytical meditation. Now when one speaks of analytical meditation, one needs an object which is being analyzed.
That which is being analyzed in this presentation is the I and the mind of that I, my mind. How is So in one day, there are twenty four hours. Everything we do within those twenty four hours is for the sake of the I. It is for the sake of the I that we do this. If we the eye did not exist, then to put such effort would be madness, would be insanity.
So we do not need to demonstrate the I’s existence. The I’s existence is an experiential given. Then, Geshe la, would like you to think about the topic of meditation. We’ll be meditating for one hour tonight. Otherwise, you’re not gonna think about it at all.
But at the minimum, one minute. No. No. Ten minutes. Ten minutes.
Come on. Two. Ten minutes. Sorry. No.
One minute. Wait. Not enough. You know? And if Geshe doesn’t say this, you’re not gonna listen carefully and you’ll fall asleep.
Right? The topic of the I is investigated by both Buddhist and non Buddhist systems of tenets, It’s, existence or nonexistence and its mode of existence. Whatever we engage in, whether it is sleeping or eating, we engage in for the sake of the I. So some of you will say, well, I’m not doing it for myself, but I’m doing it for my children or my relatives. Actually, your children and your relatives are related to you.
I suspect many of you think in that way.
So at present, instead of explaining it directly, Geshe-la would like you to analyze from your own side, is your own I your body, your form aggregate, or your mind? If it is your form aggregate, what are the reasons for this? If it is not your form aggregate, what are the reasons which counter this? Likewise, if your body is your if your, I is your mind, what are the reasons justifying this? And what it’s?
If your, I is not your mind, why, is this the case? This is how one should think. Then, probably most of us, when we analyze what our I is, will equate it with our mind, with our mental consciousness. This is not faulty. But as was explained previously, when Geshe la explained the concept of being of one nature but different isolates, the mind and the person are of one nature but different isolates.
So the mind and the I accompany each other throughout the day. Then if we examine the situation from the moment we wake to the moment we go to sleep, we can see that, consciousness is uninterruptedly present. What would happen if consciousness ceased to be present at some point? So consciousness is continually present from the moment we wake until the moment we fall asleep. If the continuum of that consciousness was severed at any point, what would happen?
We would be bereft of consciousness. Now check for yourself what or where the I seems to exist when you investigate. And you will find you get a feeling or a sense that the eye is within the body and the mind inside. Check for yourself. So we have experience of ourselves every day.
This is why we can talk about these topics and investigate them. Otherwise, if we had no experience of ourselves of this high, then it would be impossible to talk about this. So now let us examine what happens when one falls asleep. There is not a single one of us in this room who can answer the question, at what time precisely did you fall asleep? At what hour?
At what minute? At what second? No one can answer that question. Why? So this is how Geshe la feels about it.
It may relate to you or not. But Geshe la would like to ask you to ask yourselves, why is it I am unable to remember or recollect the exact time, hour, minute, and second at which I fell asleep? So first, we are unable to ascertain the exact time at which we fell asleep. And then, obviously, when we sleep, we dream. Then that is self evident.
We talk in daily life of dreams and the body of the dream state and so forth. But we are actually unable to ascertain the duration of the interval between deep sleep and the dream state. Mhmm. During that interval, is there consciousness or not? So between sleep and the dream state, there is an interval which we call deep sleep.
Then we are unable to determine how long that interval is. Is there consciousness or not during deep sleep? During that interval, there must be consciousness since consciousness and the I are interrelated. For instance, during that interval, there must be a consciousness within Chris because Chris does exist after all. He is human being that time.
During that interval of deep sleep, Chris is a sentient being, isn’t he? Then if we say he’s a sentient being, he must have consciousness. He is sentient. So this is why the subtle mind must exist during the state. If the subtle mind did not exist, the situation would be very strange.
Therefore, between the state of sleep and the dream state during deep sleep, the subtle mind is present. This is something which is based on experience, and it is not just extracted from space, if you wish. Why are we unconscious during this state? Simply because we are unable to use the subtle mind, But the subtle mind is nonetheless present in deep sleep. Mhmm.
You understand? Now whether the subtle mind is present right now in our mental continuum is a difficult question to answer. Basically, as the coarse minds disappear and dissolve, eventually, the subtle mind manifests. Then as the subtle minds coarsen, eventually, the coarse minds appear. To give an example, can we see the stars by day?
No. We can’t see them because of the intensity of the sunlight. But are the stars there or not? Yes. As the power or the intensity of the sunlight dwindles, then the stars become manifest.
Then believes that at present, since we are using our coarse consciousnesses intensively, all one can say is that the potency of the subtle consciousness is present. Then as these coarse consciousnesses dwindle and we fall into the sleep state, the subtle consciousness can become manifest. So at present, let us meditate And let us meditate on the topic of the eye. Let us investigate the eye. So we can see that we have this experience of the eye from the moment we door we rise in the morning until the moment we fall asleep, and this occurs cyclically over and again.
So initially, therefore, generate the motivation, which Geshe la explained in the first part of the teaching. And then we will meditate for ten minutes on the I. And please put effort. Ten minutes we can do.
Please open the page one. We recite one day, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three. So once one understands through one’s own experience the existence of such a subtle mind, And one understands that it is this subtle mind which proceeds from past lives through this life to future lives. Then one understands that this is how one reaps the rewards of practice and abandoning the nonvirtual and engaging virtue. When one practices, abandons nonvirtual, engages in virtue, there is little benefit in this life, but there is a reward in future lives mediated by the subtle mind.
Then, otherwise, if one does not have this understanding, then when one, speaks to someone and they say to us, just why on earth are you practicing? What’s the point of all of this? When you die, your body will be just cast in the fire. One can answer, that is not the case at all. Indeed, my aggregates, my body will be cast in the fire, but my subtle mind will proceed onwards.
It is that which carries the imprints of practice and so forth. Then, one is able to generate a conviction based on reasoning, not just any conviction, but a conviction based on reasoning. Now this is not explained in particular in the Lam Rim. There is there are no particular explanations about the existence of reincarnation. It is simply taken for granted.
Okay. So Geshe la suspects that when we investigated how precisely this I which we experience from the moment we rise in the morning until the moment we fall asleep exists, we all probably felt that it could be found somewhere deep within inside our body and mind.
So let’s set Prāsaṇgika Madhyamaka aside for the time being. It is precisely for this reason that the schools of tenets from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards give as instance of the I the mental consciousness. It is in keeping with our experience. Then, for the, Chitamatras who accept eight collections of consciousness is also the rationale for which, the I or the instance of the I which is given is the mind basis of all or the alaya vijnana. Now this is not to say that the various schools of tenets don’t have different modalities of presentation of the I.
They do. So when you try to see how you experienced or felt the eye, did you feel that there was something deep inside within body and mind which was your eye or not? So please present your way of thinking without trying to deceive Geshe la. Then, there will be some benefit to this presentation. Otherwise, there’s no point.
Please, when you give your answers, short answers. How do you feel this I to exist? Sure. Sure. Please.
My experience seems to be when I’m happy, then I’m not really aware of self. It’s when I’m under the afflictions of anger or jealousy or whatever that I really am aware then of a strong sense of I. And sometimes it can be felt actually physically. Okay. A short short no long, please.
I examined Geshe la’s questions if the eyes form and if not or if it’s mine or if not. And I found that I can’t say that my eye is my body, but I can’t say it’s not my body. I can’t say that my eye is my mind, but I can’t say that it’s not my mind. I feel the experience, like, in the morning when you wake up and your body is not feeling well, then your mind is not happy. The the the mind is you you feel the I, you know, you don’t want to be afflicted with you know, get you you’d likely to get angry.
During that ten minutes, I felt my I to be something separate from my body and mind, something that preceded sense data and thought, something that received sense data, and something to which thoughts appeared. I felt that my I had a very close relationship with my mental consciousness. Through the analytical meditation that we were doing, I found that I could not find the eye because I was questioning, is my eye the angry eye, the sick eye? Because it changes from moment to moment and from day to day, and the same with my form. Broadly speaking, all of you have said the same thing, which is that the sensation of I is at its most powerful when one experiences great happiness or greater happiness.
Then there is a sensation of the eye deep within, inside the body and mind, and this I seems to appear as the owner or the master of both body and mind. So you have said, and that is indeed the case, please listen carefully, that when one experiences these powerful feelings of happiness or unhappiness, of pleasure or suffering, the I appears to exist deep within body and mind as the owner of both body and mind. So this is not related to the presentation of the I as permanent one and independent, which Geshe-la gave previously. At present, we are examining the innate appearance of the I irrespective of whether one has been exposed to tenets or not. Now what we have to examine is whether this I which appears deep within ourselves as the master, as the owner of body and mind, whether this I is in keeping with reality or not.
Two examples are given for this in Buddhist scriptures. See which one is most meaningful for you. The first is that of the head of the merchants versus the merchants of whom he is the head. Now the head of the merchants is within the community of merchants. The second, if that example doesn’t help you, is of a general and his soldiers.
Now a general is within the soldiers, within war. So in the example of a general and his soldiers, the general does not depend greatly on the soldiers. But the soldiers depend very greatly on their commanding officer, on their general. Likewise, this is used an ex as an example for the relationship between the I, which is perceived deep within ourselves and our aggregates body and mind. This I is felt as not depending greatly on body and mind, whereas body and mind are felt to depend greatly on the I.
Question Geshele would like to ask is, is this sensation or feeling in keeping with reality or not? This is something we have to think about, all of us. So as you know, numerous minds appear to us, and we get numerous feelings, both true and false. Then the question here is, is this feeling, this sensation of such an I true or false? Is it in keeping with reality or not?
Is it in keeping with reality or not? No. Why? I think it’s not in keeping in reality because it’s very difficult to see how the I could exist independently from the aggregates. So I think that I depends, depends entirely on the aggregates.
Okay. And other? Answer you because he’ll be answering the question he asked you. So formerly, Geshe-la had explained that the person is a dependent origination. In other words, the person arises in dependence on causes and conditions.
Then there is nothing else to add to this. So the person, in other words, us, you and I, arises independence on causes and conditions. It is impermanent. But why is this the case? That is what calls for explanation.
In brief, this I, which we feel exists deep within our body and mind and which, as Geshe-la explained, we feel does not depend heavily on our body and mind, whereas our body and mind depend heavily on it, is not in keeping with reality. Simply because this I, which is the person, depends or exists in dependence on the aggregates. And the reason for this has been explained in great detail. Do you understand? So, nonetheless, what is this I which seems to exist as a controller of body deep in of body and mind deep within us?
It is the autonomous I or the autonomous self, which you have been taught is the object of negation. So
This is the mode of appearance of the autonomous self or the autonomous I. It appears as existing deep within us as the owner, the controller having power over body and mind. The channels is Is this resonating with you or not? Sure. Yes.
Yes. That way. That is excellent. Then if this is true, if you think about this, then there are great rewards for yourselves. This is why Buddhist treatises teach the nonexistence of this autonomous I.
So that feeling within us that the I exists deep within us as the controller, as the lord, as having power over body and mind is the autonomous self. The consciousness which grasps this is with the grasping or the apprehension of the person as autonomous. So what is the antidote? What is directly opposite to this apprehension which apprehends the person, as autonomous? Hopefully, you will get it.
You need something whose mode of apprehension is directly opposite. Wouldn’t that be the realization of emptiness? Okay. Okay. Would that mode of apprehension be that the I and the aggregates are of one nature but different isolates?
Sort of. I think 70%. You know? No 100%. No clean.
No. I need clean. Clean. Shoot. Clean.
Okay. Would it be the apprehension of the person as being and the aggregates as being, dependent origination? So the antidote, I think so I think the antidote would be the realization of the nonexistence of an autonomous self, and then you would give various different reasons for that. Chris? Shoot.
I think along with what others have said, the I as empty of being an autonomous independent self. Okay. Okay. Please, therefore, reflect on the fact that from a Buddhist perspective, such an autonomous self does not exist. However, from the standpoint of the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, such an autonomous self does exist.
The person is said to be established as a self or as an Ātman. Most of you, said this in one way or the other. Since the person, in other words, the I, exists independence, exists through relying upon the body and the mind or the aggregates, then this counters the person or the I being autonomous. Precisely because this apprehension, which apprehends a person as autonomous, apprehends a person in a manner of not existing in dependence on body and mind. Then the apprehension of the person as existing in dependence on body and mind counters this.
It’s its direct opposite. It’s directly opposite. Then at this point, you should investigate what the difference is between the emptiness of the person being permanent, one, and independent, which is called the coarse selflessness of persons, and the emptiness of the person being a substantially existent autonomous entity, which is called the subtle selflessness of persons. Now these are quite similar, almost identical, yet one is said to be coarse and the other is said to be subtle. So Geshe la will explain this later on.
So we will meet in a couple of weeks. And during the interval, please reflect on the distinction between, the person being established as permanent one and independent and the person being established as a substantially existent autonomous entity and on the distinction between the emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent. In other words, the coarse selflessness of persons and the emptiness of the person being a substantially existent autonomous entity. In other words, the subtle selflessness of persons. Okay.
Thank you. Is it? To understand? Of course. Very good.
Geshe-la is explaining the view. The view is not easy. Then if we proceed quickly, everyone will get very confused. For this reason, it is very helpful to explain the coarse and the subtle surfaces of persons from the standpoint of the various schools of tenets from the lower to the higher. Please open the page 98b. Mandal offering.
Okay. We have a few announcement. This Friday is a very special day. He’s on his birthday, so we are going to help here at TBI morning recitation of some of the prayer, you know, and share lunch. And evening, guru puja, 06:00, and this this Friday.
And, also, you know, Tibetan community in SA going to help dinner at North Adlet to his honors celebration. So if you would if if you want to attend, please book. You can book it here at TBI. So only $25 for the dinner and all the Tibetan tradition dance and and everything else. And Geshe-la will be going to be there as well.
And there’s that. And also the this Sunday, we have a teaching. Geshe la is going to give teaching in morning. And then after that, there’s no teaching for two weeks, but Geshe la will teach Sunday. And July is very fantastic, you know, that Chamtrul Rinpoche accepted our request.
So he’s going to come here to give a mind training. Probably, you’ve seen many in Facebook. You know, please make sure book a bit. You have a great weekend on that day. And, of course, you know, July 16, Chokhor Düchen, We’re going to have a same, you know, the morning recitation and the share lunch, and evening, our guru puja.
So there we go. And if you want to book any of those weekend or Tibetan community night, we welcome. You can book at TBI or you can call us. And there’s a beautiful chai. And, Mark, you got a special chai there.
And Anila, soy chai. That’s right. Yeah. Two weeks. Yeah.
So there’s a hot tea, chai, fresh made. You can have come along. Yeah. And there’s biscuits, etcetera. Yeah.
Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- analytical meditation vicarabhavana (Skt); che gom (Tib)
- Of the two main types of meditation, this is a meditation where the subject is examined using logical reasoning, as opposed to single-pointed concentration or fixed meditation where the mind focuses on one single object. LYWA
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
- A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
- A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
- The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.