1 h 40 min · 4,157 words · 16 April 2014
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The teaching explains the Lam Rim practice for the being of small scope, including why the small and middling scopes are preliminaries to the great scope. It covers how to train the mind in the meaning of the outline, the role of recollection of death and impermanence, and the link between karma and causality and the path to liberation. It also considers why compassion and bodhicitta depend on earlier stages.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 41m
UUID: 69637bf4-f910-42c3-b1a2-6eee75f0b1f3
Date: 2014-04-16
Words: 4,153
In the oral instruction of the Kadampa Geshe of Yore, there was one stanza. Focus on the goal and fare on the way in a leisurely fashion. This is very profound advice. Focus on the goal refers to focusing on our goal. Our practice is the Mahāyāna, therefore our goal is to reach ourselves full enlightenment and lead all beings to this state.
As a preliminary, we engage in the practices of the beings of the smaller and middling scope. Travel in a leisurely fashion refers to the fact that such a vast goal cannot be achieved at once, and can only be achieved over time. Although our goal is the state of full enlightenment and our practice is that of the being of a great scope, there is no fully characterized practice of a being of the great scope without fully characterized practices of the beings of the small and middling scope as preliminaries. There is moreover no fully characterized practice of a being of the middling scope without a fully characterized practice of the being of the small scope. We must therefore engage in these preliminary practices.
At present, in the presentation of the Lamrim, we have reached the presentation of the practice of the being of the small scope. Keeping with the advice imparted by Śāntideva’s Bodhicaryāvatāra, we should generate the requisite motivation without allowing our mind to be distracted elsewhere. Specifically, whatever practices we engage in, whether we recite our commitments all morning or we recite the Vajrasattva mantra or any other mantra, we should engage in this without allowing our mind to be distracted. In the context of the practice of the being of the small scope, one’s goal is to attain happiness from the next life onwards. For that matter, this is the goal of all dharma practice of any type.
With this as a motivation, we should then focus on the practice of the being of the small scope and resolve to practice it sincerely. And let us generate now the motivation. Within the second outline of the fourth main outline of the presentation of the text, the stages of training the mind in after relying, it is important to try to understand the actual meaning of these terms which are quite profound. And here, the term training the mind is of great importance as well as the term relying. All of the outlines of the Lamrim are included within that one outline.
And this outline, the stages of training the mind after relying encompasses the totality of the lamrim. It does not merely encompass the totality of the terms of the words of the Lamrim, but the meaning. For instance, when we actually recited a say the outline without looking at the text, we are reciting the mere words, but this is not what is referred to here. What is referred to is the actual meaning of these terms. There is tremendous benefit for the likes of yourselves who have already received Lam Rim teachings to systematically refer to the outline which is at the back of Pabongka Rinpoche’s Liberation in the palm of your hand when you think of the Lamrim, either mentally before engaging in the practice or if you are unable to do so, have the outline open in front of you and refer to it periodically during your practice.
The totality of your practice must be integrated within the outline. Then how does one train the mind in the meaning? An example will make this clear. The definition of fire is that which is hot and burning. Now we must initially understand that which is hot and burning to be able to understand what fire is.
Once we have had direct experience of what is hot and burning, then as a result of that, we can have direct experience of fire. In our cases, we all know through experience that when we touch fire, it burns. However, let us take the case of Tenzin’s daughter Dece. Dece does not know or understand the definition of fire. She does not know that fire is hot and burning, And for this reason, she would she probably would play with fire and might easily hurt herself.
That’s not quite sure you’re getting it. Then probably a majority of you have received numerous Lamrim teachings, teachings on the Lamrim Chenmo, the greater Lamrim of Je Tsongkhapa, the middling Lamrim, the smaller Lamrim, the Abhisamayālamkāra, a liberation in the palm of your hand, and so forth. So you have heard the words over and again. As to the meaning, it is another affair. It is open to question whether the meaning of the Lamrim is in contact or touches your mind or not.
This is what has to happen. Then, in our cases, we have to basically connect the teachings to our minds. We engage in numerous practices, and if someone were to ask us what we are practicing, we might say, I’m offering mandala, I’m offering prostrations, some might make important financial donations. It is not to say that this is not good, one accumulates a vast amount of practice of merit through this, but whether this is practice or not is a very different question altogether. Practice transforms the mind, so these external activities must be brought inwards.
These alone therefore are not practiced, they are actually included within the six preliminaries of the Lamrim, they lead to practice. Then what should they lead to? They should lead to an eradication of the numerous thoughts of body and speech, that alone does not happen. The way to think about the six preliminary practices is as a means to eliminate obstructions to our focus on the topic of meditation of the Lamrim, when for instance we drift away or fall asleep. Then Geshela will ask a question from one of the older students who has studied well.
He would like to ask Pamela a question. Where does the practice of Lamrim begin? Not It’s an iffy one. You have to think about the Practices such as offering mandala, offering prostrations, reciting the Vajrasattva mantra and so forth definitely are able to reduce the physical and verbal thoughts we have incurred, but they are unable to affect our mental thoughts in the slightest. Then it is very awkward after having offered numerous cycles of 100,000 recitations of Vajrasattva, hundreds of thousands of prostrations and mandalas, to realize that basically one’s mind is unchanged.
Then the question is what is happening to my practice? And therefore, within the outline of the Lamrim, which is subdivided into the root, relying on the spiritual teacher who is the foundation of the path, and the second outline, having relied upon the spiritual teacher, the stages of training the mind thereafter. That second outline in turn, as you remember, is subdivided into two. The first is identifying the basis of leisure and endowment for the sake of taking its essence, and the second is the manner of taking the essence thereof. In that second outline, the manner of taking the essence thereof is explicitly mentioned in the outline.
That second outline, the manner of taking the essence thereof, is subdivided, as you remember, into three. Training the mind in the stages of the path, which are shared with the being of small scope, which are shared with the being of the middling scope, and which are shared with the being of the great scope. And the first outline, training the mind in the stages of the path which are shared with the being of the great scope, the being of small scope, me, begins with a practice of recollection of death. If we meditate on recollection on death, thinking about it over and again, and passing from meditation to the consultation of scriptures and back, I can guarantee there will be mental transformation. And therefore, it is the practice of the being of the small, middling and great scope within this second outline, which does transform the mind.
If upon engaging in meditation on impermanence and death, we find nonetheless that our mind is not transformed, this is the result of obstructions and thoughts of body and speech. At this point, one engages in the preliminary practices to eradicate them. Then this famous topic of the Lamrim, which you have all heard about, must be understood clearly, one must clearly understand where the practice begins. It begins with a practice of the being of the small scope. When one has analyzed that and understood this by oneself, this is excellent.
Actually, would like to point out a specific term which is used in reference to the training of the being of the three scopes. It is the mode of transforming the mind. This term is not found in the previous outlines. You will find it specifically in Pabongka Rinpoche’s outline, the mode of training the mind in the stages of the path shared with the being of the small scope, the mode of training the mind in the stages of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, and the mode of training the mind shared with the path of the being of the great scope. We must understand clearly what the purpose or the rationale is for this sequential presentation of topics of meditation within the Lamrim.
In other words, why is there a practice of the small, the middling, and the great scope? Specifically in our case, we are purportedly practitioners of the great scope. Why precisely do we need to meditate on the practices of the being of the small and the middling scope? Two reasons can be advanced for this, the first is because through this incremental development in the practice of the being of the small and the middling scope, we are led to the great scope. The second reason is that these stages are presented for the beings of lower capacities, the Shravakas and the Pratyekabuddhas, the hearers and the solitary realizers, to lead them to the Mahāyāna.
It is indisputable that to attain full enlightenment and to become a being of the great scope, one must train in the Mahāyāna and in bodhichitta. However, to train in a fully characterized practice of the being of the great scope, it is indispensable to have trained in fully characterized practices of the being of the small and the middling scope. To train in a fully characterized practice of the being of the middling scope, one must before this have trained in a fully characterized practice of the being of the small scope. Then if one is trying to generate a fully characterized bodhichitta within one’s mind stream, and one starts reflecting on why after all it is necessary to have generated a fully characterized practice of the being of the middling scope before this, even if one had been falling asleep during one’s meditation, one would wake up at once, because this is a very intriguing question, which offers a lot of food for thought. It’s very good to ask oneself questions.
Why is this the case? Then it is said repeatedly in the Lamrim that to enter in a fully characterized practice of the being of the great scope, it is indispensable to have a fully characterized practice of the being of the middling scope. Then I would like to ask you, why is this the case? Yes, it is true. It’s very helpful to think on the fact that it is the stages of the path, but still it’s a little bit odd, isn’t it?
That before one could seriously contemplate developing bodhichitta, that one would first have to have absolutely decided, determined to be free of all of all future rebirths. And that you have to believe that was possible and that it was something that because developing bodhichitta is something that takes a while, I think. It is indispensable to generate bodhichitta to first have generated great compassion. As Maitreya says in the Mahāyāna Sutralamkara, I assert that its root is compassion. Now if we take bodhichitta, bodhichitta has two objects.
Its first object is a state of full enlightenment. Its second object are those for which one strives for the state state, which are all sentient beings. It is through compassion for all sentient beings that one strives for this state. Do you understand? What do we refer to by great compassion?
Great compassion is the uncontrived wish to free sentient beings from sufferings and suffering and its causes. Now how would it be possible for such a wish to free others from suffering and its causes to arise if it had not arisen with respect to ourselves? As Śāntideva says in the Bodhicaryāvatāra, if you are unable to accomplish even your own goal, how can you claim to accomplish that of others? And it is of extreme benefit to reflect on this over and again. This stanza of the Bodhicaryāvatāra is particularly powerful, but not at once.
At once it does not impact the mind. It is only through these preliminary reflections that it does. And it is precisely because it is indispensable to have generated an uncontrived mind which engages in freeing oneself from cyclic existence as a preliminary to generating great compassion that the path of the being of the middling scope is an indispensable preliminary to the path of the being of the great scope. This is how one should reflect on it, then this is not the forward progression of the path, it is the reverse sequence. So we have established, I hope to your satisfaction that it is indispensable to generate a fully characterized practice of the being of the great scope to have initially generated a fully characterized practice of the being of the middling scope.
However, to generate a fully characterized practice of the being of the middling scope, it is said that it is indispensable to generate a fully characterized practice of the being of the small scope. This is a difficult topic. Why so? What do you think about Then all of the great practitioners of the past, such as Asaṇga, his half brother Vasubandhu and so forth, based on experience, have clearly stated that it is indispensable to initially generate a an uncontrived path of the being of the small scope before being able to generate an uncontrived path of the being of the great scope. Why is this the case in your opinion?
Do you understand? Really? Behind you, Chris. I think there’s only one path, and it’s just broken up into three or two hiniana mahayana for the sake of making it more sense to students but I feel that the realisation of any part of the path includes the realisation of the preceding part and so you can’t realise one part without having realised the preceding part. You all understand what the path of the being of the middling scope is, and you all understand what the path of the being of the small scope is.
So let us stop for a couple of minutes, think by yourselves, and try to provide a good answer for why the first is indispensable for the second. What can I do? So it’s because if I do not realise that I will die in this life that I’m not getting off the planet in this life and that it’s uncertain I’m certain I’m going to die I’m uncertain when that is and only dharma can help if I don’t realise that in this life I’ll never be able to realise that it doesn’t matter how many future lives I have without the dharma I’ll just keep circling so that’s why one of the reasons I think why it’s important that I might not make it out of this room alive that’s don’t always think that but you know, but sometimes. And Nada? I just think it’s how the mind works.
I mean, we can’t have understanding and realizations without having done we have to start somewhere. And I think it’s set out that way because the mind is dependent arising. So certain realizations and concepts are understood and then the mind opens up to the next, next, next. So someone who’s in the lower scope, the whole concept of bodhichitta is not part of their consciousness. Once they train in a lower scope, it can become part of their consciousness.
I just think it’s how the mind evolves and that’s why it’s set out that way. If the foundations are not strong in the small scope then the walls will fall along with the great scope understanding. So one has to gradually build up an understanding of each one in order to achieve the next. Being of the small scope needs to develop the uncontrived wish to have a higher rebirth in the next and future lives. We need to have that uncontrived wish so that we can continue to practice in future lives so that because the goal of liberation let alone full enlightenment and bodhichitta is so vast, so huge.
So we need more time because this we need to recognize that this precious human rebirth is incredibly short and death is certain but the time is most uncertain. So we need some more time to be able to develop as beings of the middling scope. So it’s that wish to have the higher rebirth that is by understanding that in an uncontrived way that is the way that we develop to that is the cause and condition for developing as a being of the middling scope. Without an understanding of suffering of ourselves and others in saṃsāra, there would be no reason to strive for liberation from saṃsāra. And without an understanding of karma and causality, we would not see that it was possible to free ourselves from saṃsāra.
One of you guys understood something. One must realize the reality of our personal death, not some abstract idea, but our personal death. I will die. And then understand the sort of radical impermanence of everything that what we see is actually coming together and falling apart, and that nothing stays, and the inexorable workings of karma that we have made created all the causes for a great deal of suffering in the past, that we will experience in order to spur us to practice. And, having been spurred to practice, we realized that we haven’t we may not have enough time.
So, we work on creating the causes for continued practice in the future to wit a perfect human rebirth. And having attained a perfect human rebirth, we we then can explore further causes of suffering and how self centeredness, etcetera, brings that about so that we can then wish to be free. I think it is set out in this way because in the small and medium scopes we have to accept our own death and in accepting that we have a fear of being reborn in the lower realms and saṃsāra. Therefore we have to strive for enlightenment. Once we do this we can think about the great scope because within the great scope it is the ideal that we eliminate the suffering of others.
I guess it’s through understanding the fact that we’re going to continue in cyclic existence that we’re going to be reborn again and we’re uncertain about how, where we’ll be in that rebirth. We need to understand that before we can want to be liberated from all of the cycle of existence. To understand why practicing the path of the being of the small scope is indispensable, to engage in the practice of the being of the middling scope, one has to understand the uncommon relationship between key elements of the practice of the being of the middling scope, and key elements of the practice of the being of the small scope. The key element of the practice of the being of the middling scope is renunciation or definite emergence. Definite emergence is definite emergence from saṃsāra.
What is saṃsāra? saṃsāra is not this house we are in, it’s not our clothing, it is our contaminated aggregates. What are contaminated aggregates? In other words, our body and mind. They are aggregates which are born from karma and klesha, karma and affliction.
What is the root of karma and klesha? If we move back we can see that this is directly connected with karma and causality, therefore it is impossible to understand the connection, the intimate between the practice of the being of the small scope and the middling scope without understanding correctly karma and causality. And therefore it is indispensable to have an understanding of karmic causality. Now we talked yesterday or the previous time about previous lives, and obviously future lives are on the same model. The reasonings which I gave, which demonstrate the establishment of previous lives, are reasonings which are difficult to endorse if one does not accept the existence of karma and causality.
It is difficult to envision a being arising exclusively from the union of the father’s spermatozoa and the mother’s ovum. Have you understood? 100% Maybe not 100%. Of what is being said and that sometimes comprehension sometimes sentence comprehension yes but understanding the full implications and that only comes about through hearing at the very least hearing reflecting studying and maybe some meditation I think Geshela is asking have we understood the implications not just have we comprehended the sentence. The reason for which the practice of the being of the middling scope or shared with the being of the middling scope must be preceded by the practice shared with the being of the small scope is due to an uncommon connection between these two practices.
It is this uncommon connection which must be identified, and one of you did identify it. It is karma and causality. So it is really at present through purifying obstructions and accumulating merit that one’s understanding of this will improve. As I said in the essence of nectar lamrim, without reflecting over and again on the faults of our present predicament, and present predicament refers here to cyclic existence, the mind wishing for liberation will not arise. Therefore, we should reflect over and again on the thoughts of cyclic existence and the intimate connection linking the path of the being of shared with the being of the middling scope and the path shared with the being of the small scope is precisely karma and causality.
So the four topics presented within the path shared with the being of the small scope, which is the meditations on death and impermanence, the precious human rebirth, taking refuge, excuse me, the meditations on death and impermanence, the sufferings of cyclic existence, karma and causality, and taking refuge are a preliminary to the practice of the being of the middling scope. Then through this presentation of the topics of the Lamrim, the practices of the beings of the three scopes, and through reflecting over and again on what past and future lives are, and karma and causality is, your understanding will deepen. Then I will take only one question at present. Does when Geshe-la says, has it touched your mind? Does that mean something other than have you had a realization?
Same thing. Has it touched your mind? Has it met your mind? And have you had a realization of the same thing? We will have the long Easter weekend teaching in two days, it is starting on Friday and lasts until Monday, on the Seven Point Mind Training attributed to Geshe Chekhawa.
If you have the time, it would be very good if you could come, so as not to waste your time during this period. If you do not have the time to attend the totality of the teachings, you are welcome to attend the teachings on the practice shared with the being of the small scope, which I will present on the first day, the practices shared with the being of the middling scope, which I will present on the second day, and the practices shared with the being of the great scope, which I will present on the last day. Then it would be a great pity if you wasted the long Easter weekend since once it is over, all you will be left with will be the regrets for a wasted opportunity. This center is uncommon. It has been blessed by the visit of His Holiness the Dalai Lama in person, who stated how much he appreciated what was happening here, and it has also been blessed by the numerous teachings of the holy teacher, Khensur Kangurwa Rinpoche.
Then all of us are disciples of Khensur Kangurwa Rinpoche, so if you attend these teachings, for sure there will be some impact on your minds.
Key terms in this teaching
- chulen
- Literally, “taking the essence.” Chulen pills are made of essential ingredients; taking but a few each day, accomplished meditators can remain secluded in retreat for months or years without having to depend upon normal food. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- perfect human rebirth
- The rare human state, qualified by eight freedoms and ten richnesses, which provide the ideal conditions for practicing Dharma and attaining enlightenment. LYWA
- preliminary practices ngondro (Tib)
- The practices that prepare the mind for successful tantric meditation by removing hindrances and accumulating merit. LYWA
- prostrations chag tsel (Tib)
- The act of showing respect to the objects of refuge, the Guru and the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha; the first of the seven-limb practice and one of the preliminary practices. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.