Lam Rim – 2018-04-11 – Lamrim

1 h 39 min · 4,801 words · 11 April 2018

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2018-04-11 - Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk explains how to examine whether Lam Rim study has transformed one’s mind, and gives guidance for ordained practitioners on restraining physical and verbal behaviour. It then introduces emptiness and the lower tenet schools, using the self and the aggregates (body and mind) to explain how the I is imputed. The talk closes with a brief question session and reading assignments for next week.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 40m

UUID: 97c53340-fdc5-4480-874c-06b16702fe20

Date: 2018-04-11

Words: 4,797

As Buddha Śākyamūni said, commit, no sin whatsoever. Engage in perfect virtue and thoroughly subdue your mind. Mhmm. These are the teachings of the muni. So here, when it is said, subdue thoroughly your mind, this is the teaching of the Muni or the Buddha.

It is not possible to subdue one’s mind at once. It takes time. One subdues it over time, and it is very helpful in this context to examine one’s mind after one has received Lam Rim teachings, literally after one has heard the dharma of the Lam Rim, and compare it with the mind before one had ever received Lam Rim teachings and see whether there has been a transformation. This is what is meant by the mind being subdued. Then, it is difficult for transformation to occur after just hearing one teaching such as this one.

So one should look back to the period when one had never received Lam Rim teachings at all and then compare with, a period at which one has received the totality of the Lam Rim and then check whether there has been some transformation of the mind or not. Then if there has been a transformation of the mind, at that point, one can rejoice, one can generate joy and think, this has really been of benefit to me. And all of us are students and practitioners of the So when we compare ourselves with people at large in society who are not students of the Lam Rim and when we meet with them, there should be some sort of a difference. Then, if there is some sort of a difference, this is a result of our practice of the Lam Rim. So for instance, when we encounter difficulties in life, we should be somewhat more relaxed than people at large in society who encounter the same difficulties.

So this is how one should look at it. This is our reward. So when or since Geshe la has come to Adelaide, when Khensur Rinpoche was still among us, he has taught the Lam Rim. Now there is no means to transform the mind which is superior to the Lam Rim, and this is why we should check whether our minds have been affected or not. And this is why everybody said if the Lam Rim cannot transform your mind, your mind cannot be transformed.

And here, we should check our minds not on a day to day, month to month basis, but on a yearly basis since from the beginning when we received Lam Rim teachings. Is that clear? Have you understood? So this is how one examines, whether one’s mind has transformed or not. One looks back to the period that when one had not received these teachings and one compares with now.

And one checks whether one’s own mind has improved or not. Then if it has improved, there is benefits. And for us at present, the attainments of the grounds and paths are, very far away. But if we continue in this this fashion, we definitely will reach them. So, Geshe la is explaining to you his way of looking at things.

Then he when he reflects back on his studies at the monastery, His himself and his classmates engaged in profound vast studies for many years. And it is true that during the study period, there was really little time to practice. But now with hindsight, when he looks at his own mind, this is his reward. Then when he looks back on his life, there were certainly, moments in his early life where his, behavior was laughable. But now he sees this was inappropriate.

And, this is the reward we have because at that point, we can choose to follow another path and to restrain ourselves. This is how Geshe la sees things. And this is why said, think of the Lam Rim. Focus on the Lam Rim. And then if one proceeds in this fashion with time, when one looks back on one’s past behavior, it is ridiculous and laughable, and one chooses to behave differently.

Then as for the grounds and paths, that is very, very far away for all of us. But eventually, we will reach them. Then, don’t despair when you look at the future. Look at your past and compare with your past to your present behavior, one’s laughable past behavior, and then one sees there’s been improvement and this leads to mental happiness. Then, among our audience tonight, there are four, persons who are ordained, monks and nuns.

Then for monks and nuns, those who are ordained, what is fundamental is a transformation of physical and verbal, behavior, to avoid, for instance, the non virtuous deeds of speech such as lying, harsh words, divisive speech, and gossip. So, for those who are ordained, it is critical to restrain physical and verbal behavior in society. This restraint of physical and verbal behavior eventually impacts mental behavior. The goal here is to eliminate an infantile mindset. Then when one is ordained, it is, vital to eliminate the outlook of a lay person.

In other words, this outlook, which is the one where when we wake up in the morning, we think about making breakfast, then we worry about our house, our real estate, our business, our friends, and so forth. This is a layperson’s mindset. It’s not a monks or a nun’s mindset. And one must focus on these three trainings. Then, it is excellent when one wakes up in the morning that one’s first thought be, I am ordained.

I am a monk or I am a nun. His holiness has said that one should generate the thought, I am a follower of the Buddha’s teachings. Then what does it mean to be a monk or a nun? The moment one thinks I am ordained, the question arises, what is the purpose of ordination? What does it mean to be a nun?

And then one behaves in this way. Please keep this in mind. Then if one proceeds in this fashion, one will generate a good mind of restraint.

So, please do keep this in mind. Then Geshe la is hampered by, his limited English, and must rely on a translator, but he thought he would speak frankly, to those of you who are ordained. It is difficult to be ordained in a society society such as this one, but, it is possible nonetheless, to, improve one’s practice. Then, for Tibetans, it is easier, to proceed in this way because they are accustomed. Then, obviously, this refers mainly to physical and verbal behavior.

Mental behavior is difficult to transform. For yourselves as Westerners, you are not accustomed, so it’s more difficult. You need these explanations. So at present, let us move on to the topics of bodhicitta and of the view of emptiness. In other words, method and wisdom.

Lam Rim is a means of explaining method and wisdom. So the topic of bodhicitta is explained in great depth in the Buddhist treatises. In brief, it is the motivation to benefit others. Then with this as a motivation, we engage in physical and verbal behavior such as, for instance, eating food. We eat with the motivation to strengthen our bodies so that we can be of benefit to others.

Then when we eat, we must generate such a motivation. We should eat for our health because if we don’t eat well, then we will be ill and we will not be able to benefit others. Whereas if we are hale and hearty, then we can help others. This is what is taught in Buddhist treatises. So, here, when one refers to benefiting others, this does not refer just to thinking about benefiting others.

It would amount to praying for the sake of others, which is of little or no benefit. It does not therefore refer to staying alone without any contact quietly at home. It refers to acting for the sake of others. This is how one improves forward and forward. So there is a lot to be thought about regarding Bodhicitta as his Holiness the Dalai Lama has said.

And as to emptiness, emptiness is the actual mode of existence of reality. So here, as His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said, after reflecting on Bodhicitta and gaining familiarity with it, we must apprehend emptiness since emptiness is the mode of abiding of reality, the actual mode of existence of reality. And in keeping with Śāntideva’s bodhisattva, Bodhicaryāvatāra, it is said pay your body its salary. And then Śāntideva adds, after all, it is the means for one to gain liberation. Then, obviously, if we eat too much, we will become overweight.

And then there’s a major impact on one’s one’s health, which is why Śāntideva adds, whatever you engage in, engage in moderation and not in excess. Mhmm. And there seems to be no one who’s overweight here. You seem all quite So at present, let us generate the motivation to receive these teachings by first meditating on bodhicitta and then on the wish to benefit others. When we meditate on bodhicitta, there is no possible loss for ourselves.

Please open the prayer book, page one. We recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, bundle offering, verse one and three. So our topic is emptiness in Tibetan. Then for a sound understanding of definite emergence at the level of the past shared with the being of the small scope, an understanding of emptiness is extremely helpful. It is difficult to get a good understanding of definite emergence without a good understanding of emptiness.

So when, one wishes to explain definite emergence or renunciation, one initially explains the four noble truths. And to explain the four noble truth, one must explain the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation. Then when one endeavors to explain this, people get confused. Cessation of what? Now to understand what the cessation is a cessation of, one needs an understanding of emptiness.

This is how the understanding of emptiness needs to an under leads to an understanding of definite emerge.

Then Warat is more straightforward to explain the first two noble truths, the noble truth of, suffering and of the origin of suffering. When one endeavors to explain the last two noble truths, things get very difficult. One tries to explain how the noble truth of the path, the fourth noble truth, leads to the noble truth of cessation, the third noble truth. So the topic of emptiness is not an easy topic. It is within the five topics which is studied in the Geluk tradition within Madhyamaka.

In the courses of studies in the great seats, one typically will study dura, in other words, an introduction to Buddhist logic, salam and tenets during three years. Then one studies, Parchin, in other words, Paramita, during seven years after that. And after the tenth year of study, one begins to study Madhyamaka for four full years nonstop from morning to evening. So it is not easy. You would not gain this understanding easily.

It’s not easy, and therefore, please don’t be in a hurry. Don’t rush. Take your time. So if we can gain the beginning of an understanding of emptiness, it is a very good thing. It is not an easy topic.

His Holiness the Dalai Lama has said this is the actual mode of reality of now. This is the way things are. It is not a coarse topic. Then in we said emptiness is a heavy topic. It’s a difficult topic.

One really should have experience to teach it, but, obviously, one doesn’t. So emptiness being a dependent arising and dependent arising being emptiness is the crux of the prasanika viewpoint, that emptiness and dependent arising are of one nature but different isolates. Now to understand such a presentation, it is very helpful to understand the view of the lower schools of tenets, leads up to this. So one therefore should progress upwards from the presentation of the lower schools of tenets, which lead up to the presentation of the view of and Geshe la will therefore rely on a presentation of the tenets of the lower schools of tenets to lead to this. So the second most view of the lower schools of tenets, is the selflessness of persons.

In other words, that a person is empty of being a substantially existent autonomous entity. This is, something you have heard about many times now. Mhmm. So, one has to understand here the, relationship which exists between the person or the I on the one hand and the body and the mind. So Geshe la explained this many times here, and he would like to assume you have understood.

So let us begin with, the self evident statement that the I or the person exists. The I or the person, which is the basis of investigation, the basis of analysis exists. This is something which is rooted in experience. This is something which we have all decided already. So one does not need to advance many reasons or, numerous justifications for the existence of the I.

It is self evident. Children from the age of two or so onwards keep saying my, my, my, my. This is obvious. Then the Madhyamaka treatises investigate the mode of existence of this I.

You don’t have to teach children to say my. They they don’t say this is my book, but they do say this is my chocolate. This is my ice cream. So one, therefore, does not have to teach children to say this is mine. This is independent of being affected by tenets or unaffected by tenets.

The issue, however, is what is the mode of existence of this I? That is what we have to investigate. Then as a child grows older and reaches the age of nine, 10, and older and older, the scope of the my and the mind expands. But one talks of my things, my house, my car, my relatives, my boyfriend, my girlfriend, and so forth. So this I, this person, exists in relationship to the body.

It exists, therefore. It exists as something which is imputed on the body, as something which arises from the body, as something which exists in dependence on the body. These modes of existence were explained. Now what has to be explained is the mode of relation of the person to the mind. So, Laurence, so the, mode of establishment of this relationship between the, I and the body is clear.

Now what is the mode of establishment of the relationship between the eye and the mind? In other words, how is the I imputed on the basis of imputation, which is the mind? We do think I am happy. I am unhappy. My mind is happy.

My mind is unhappy. Now when we think my mind is unhappy, in dependence on thinking of that, we gain an understanding of my and I. That is enough to warrant the fact that the I is imputed on the mind. This is something we have to think about. So here, when we say, I am unhappy, my mind is unhappy, or I am happy, my mind is happy, it is through reflecting on this that we understand the mode of imputation of the I on the mind, the mode of the relationship which the I and the mind entertain.

So there is nothing more than this. It is something we ought to think carefully about to gain some type of experience. So here, the I, is imputed on sensations of happiness and unhappiness. Do you understand the mode of relationship between the eye and the mind? So here, when we say that the eye, exists in dependency on body and mind, we are summarizing the statement that the eye is imputed on a basis of imputation, which are the five aggregates.

Do you understand this? So here, this is the mode of the relationship between the I and the body and the mind. In other words, the I on the one hand and the ground of imputation, which are body and mind or the five aggregates, entertain an uncommon relationship. This is a relationship, as Geshe la explained, of being of one nature but different isolates. What is this uncommon relationship?

This uncommon relationships manifest in the fact that when the ground of imputation, the body and mind improve or increase, so does the I. When the basis of the ground of imputation, the body and mind deteriorate, so does the eye.

So let’s take an example. Let us take the case of, Chris. Then, Chris is an instance of an I, of a person. But we don’t say that Chris is his form aggregate, his body. It no one says that Chris is his head.

It would be a bit strange or that Chris is his hand. Right? Do you understand? What sort of feeling is arising about this? Do do you get it?

So Chris or I is not Chris’s body right. If Geshe la asks you, is Chris Chris’s head? How does that sound to you? It isn’t. Right?

You get it. Is Chris’s hand Chris? So then if you take, Chris’ body and you go from the top of Chris’ head, Chris’ crown, to the sole of his feet, None of any of those components is Chris nor is Chris any of those. Then what is the relationship between Chris and those components? That is the mode of imputation of Chris on the form aggregate.

Then Mhmm. Is the main mind within Chris’s mental continuum, Chris, Well, that’s a bit ridiculous because we don’t say that the main mind eats, yet Chris does eat. We don’t say that the main mind of Chris sleeps, yet Chris does sleep. How do you how do you feel about the notion that the main mind of Chris, Chris’s mind, is Chris? If what would be the thought?

If that was the case, what would be the thought? So Chris’s mind is not Chris. After all, we say that Chris sleeps, Chris takes medicine. Chris’s mind can’t do these things. You understand?

Yeah. If you understood. So Chris does exist, but the question is what is the mode of existence of the of Chris? What is the mode of imputation of Chris on his aggregates? Are you beginning to understand?

So, we will proceed slowly, because it will be inappropriate to do explain this topic in great depth. And, here, Geshe la would like to present the person from the standpoint of the various schools of tenets progressing upwards. And to do this, we’re contrasting always their presentation of the person with our innate natural spontaneous sense of the person. A purely theoretical presentation is of limited benefit. So, we should therefore endeavor to gain an understanding of emptiness, but this understanding of emptiness is useless against the afflictions.

As his holiness has said, he himself gained an experience of emptiness, but that is insufficient. He must, as Geshe explained many times, generate a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness. In other words, a mind arisen from the inseparable union of calm abiding and insight focused on emptiness, that is what acts as an antidote to the afflictions. You remember that minds arisen from meditation focused on emptiness occur from the level of the path of preparation upwards. Within the five paths, from the second path, the path of preparation.

Then from Geshe la’s own perspective, once one has gained or generated a mind arisen from meditation focused on emptiness, the ignorance grasping at a self would be non manifest. For the ignorance grasping at a self to be manifest after one has generated a mind arisen from meditation, focus, and emptiness would be very strange. So the self is not the body and the mind nor are the body and the mind the self. Yet, they entertain an uncommon relationship. What is this relationship?

As the body and mind increase or are enhanced, so does the self. As the body and mind decrease or degenerate, so does the self. So therefore, the relationship entertained or which exists between the eye on the one hand and the base of imputation of the I, which is the body and mind, is one of being of one nature but different isolates. And the example which Geshe la would like to give here is that of a society, TBI, and the members of that society, the members of TBI. So TBI is not the members of TBI.

The members of TBI are not TBI. Yet when TBI situation improves, so does that of the members of TBI. When the man the situation of the members of TBI declines, so does that of TBI. They they have an uncommon relationship with each other. Does that example help you?

Just as a relationship between the eye on the one hand and body and mind on the other. When the eye improves, so do body and mind. When the eye declines, so do body and mind. So we’ve talked a lot about the topic of the I tonight. Okay.

So Geshe would like to ask you at present. So as Geshe la explained, previously, it is important for us to examine first how this innate sensation or feeling of the I appears. And once we have examined how this innate or spontaneous feeling of the I appears to contrast it with the presentations of the person. So, here, as Geshe la explained, what we have to do is examine how this innate sense of self within us, perceives itself. And when he asked the question last time, two broad answers emerged.

The first were those who said that the I was just the complex of body and mind. The others were those who said that the I was something akin to the lord or the master of the body. Now both of these senses of the eye are accounted for in Buddhist philosophy. So probably these two sensations of the I cover it. Do you have them within yourselves?

So is that sense really present within you? Are you sure of it? Because the way we must study Buddhist philosophy is that we must study what is taught in the great text text, and then we must check within ourselves whether this fits or not. Is this innate is this type of innate mind, this innate sense of the self present within yourselves or not? Sure?

And the present. So before we go any further, Geshe la would like to emphasize that we have many different types of innate minds within ourselves. Some are correct. Some are mistaken. That is not what we’re talking about now.

What Geshe la would like to make sure of is that we get the sense of this innate sense of the self within ourselves. Whether it is correct or mistaken will be examined later. So these are, broadly speaking, therefore, the two innate, senses of the self we tend to have. And at present, Geshe la would like to comment on the sense of the self, which is akin to the relationship entertained between the owner of a house and the house he owns. So within these two modes of appearance, let us talk about the first one.

So this sense that oneself, is akin to the owner of a house and that one’s aggregates are akin to the house which is owned, the objects of enjoyment of the owner of that house exists, doesn’t it? So let us set aside whether this is correct or mistaken. Is this mode of appearance real? Realistic? Is this reality?

Is this true? That’s what Geshe was asking. Is the when this mind looks at things in that way, is it true? Is it real? Speak.

And other. So Geshe la only wants you

To answer two questions. A, is this true or not? And if it is If it is not true, why? It isn’t reality, because the I and the aggregates do not exist apart from each other. So what you’re saying is that the I does not exist apart from the aggregates and the aggregates do not exist apart from the I.

So you have understood what had to be explained. Mhmm. Mhmm. I would also say no. And my reasoning is because I have looked at the aggregates and I couldn’t find an owner.

So even though this is how things appear to us within ourselves, this mind is a mistaken consciousness. It is a wrong consciousness. Right? It’s a mistaken consciousness. It’s a wrong consciousness.

So in Buddhist treatises, this mind is given a very famous name, which Geshe la will not give you at once because you will immediately jump to conclusions, but you do know it. It is this mind. So, in relying on the example of the owner of the house and the house, as you remember, the house is the object of enjoyment of the owner of the house, but the owner of the house exists independently from the house. Now when, we apply this metaphor for to the feeling of the innate I, we do realize when we analyze that all the in the metaphor, the owner of the house exists independently from the house, this innate I does not exist independently of the aggregates. Therefore, the mind which sees it as the owner of the aggregates is a mistaken mind.

So here, Geshe la will not name this mind. You think by yourselves about it until next week, and then next week, he’ll give you the name. Then if you have questions, Geshe la will take one or two questions. I will stop for the evening. Please, concise questions.

During Geshe’s teachings, twice when speaking about the relationship with the I and the aggregates, it was put in terms that when the aggregates improve, the eye improves. Or when the aggregates increase, the I increases. I don’t really understand, those verbs within that context of increase, and decrease. So it’s it’s pretty self evident. If we take someone, when they improve their mind through studying, we say this person has improved, don’t we?

They’re a better person. Right? And then in Australia, obviously, you love sports. Then when somebody plays Aussie football and becomes extraordinarily fit, we say he’s doing better than before, don’t we? So we should think about this and, also practice it.

Okay. And? I’ve been trying to analyze the mode of imputation of myself within my own mind, and I’m trying to understand if there is first a discrimination of a sensation and then immediately subsequent to that, I impute I upon that sensation, or if the imputation I arises simultaneously with the discrimination of the sensation. So you’re thinking of the omnipresent mental factors here. Yeah.

This is something which has to be examined, but normally, the discrimination would arise after sensation. Now discrimination is what imputes, not sensation. Mhmm. Got it. Yeah.

Do we have? Okay. Are main minds and mental factors of one nature in different isolates. Yes. Mode of, procedures is same.

Okay. That’s okay. Thank you. Okay. So, Geshe la would like to comment next time two passages.

The first from Nāgārjuna’s Ratnāvalī, the Precious Garland, which reads as follows. Persons are not earth nor are they water. They are not fire nor are they air or space. They are not main minds. If they are none of these, how can they arise elsewise?

This is from Nāgārjuna’s root verses on the middle way. Alright. You got it? Otherwise. Then, from Nāgārjuna’s, the root verses of emptiness, Neither the aggregates nor other than the aggregates.

There are no aggregates, in that and, nor are there otherwise. The Tatagatas are not endowed with aggregates. What are the Tatagatas? Really? Excuse me.

Were you able to take these two stanzas in writing? At least some of you, hopefully. Then I will, prepare a careful translation of these for next week for you. You know? So Geshe la will explain the view based on these two stanzas.

This is how His Holiness does it. The question that she sorry. Okay. Yeah. Just going back to venerable Thokmey’s question as whether our my our main minds and mental factors of one nature but different isolates, to which Geshe replied, yes.

But I thought it was possible for the main mind to exist apart from the mental factors. That’s okay. Will explain this point. Thank you. Please open the prayer book page nine and eight b, dedication offering.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
five paths lam nga (Tib, Wyl)
The five stages of spiritual progress - the paths of accumulation, preparation, seeing, meditation and no more learning - set out for each of the three vehicles; the Mahayana five paths culminate in buddhahood. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mental factors chaita (Skt); sem jung (Tib)
Literally arising from the mind, a mental factor is a cognition that apprehends an attribute of its object and accompanies any principal consciousness that is concordant with it. LYWA
omnipresent mental factors sarvatraga-chaitta (Skt); sem jung kun dro (Tib)
One of the six groups of mental factors, these accompany every main mind. There are five: feeling, discrimination, intention, mental engagement and contact. LYWA
principal consciousness vijnana (Skt); nam shë (Tib)
The main cognition posited by means of apprehending the entity of its object. Synonymous with main mind, it is one of the two divisions of mind, the other being mental factors. LYWA
three trainings shiksha-traya (Skt); lab pa sum (Tib)
Ethics, concentration and wisdom. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top