1 h 35 min · 4,429 words · 18 April 2018
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim session on the three scopes of motivation, explaining that the paths of small, middling and great scope lead to one another and that the path of the small scope is the basis for practice. It stresses striving for higher rebirth as a spontaneous attitude, with contentment as its attainment, and then teaches that the self is imputed on body and mind and that the mind apprehending a self separate from the aggregates is a mistaken mind. Students are asked to reflect on the name of that mistaken mind and on coarse and subtle levels of self and antidotes.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 36m
UUID: d348b83d-e811-49a0-ba8a-bd9663113313
Date: 2018-04-18
Words: 4,425
So Geshe la has seen that you seem to become confused about the various motivations to be generated, so he would like to recapitulate. The motivation for the path shared with the being of the small scope is striving for a higher future rebirth. Motivation for the path shared with the being of the middling scope is striving for liberation from cyclic existence. And the motivation for the being of the path of the being of the great scope is striving for full and utter enlightenment. Were you confused or not?
The question seemed to indicate you were. Just as in society at large, when you gain an education, you start by going to kindergarten, then primary school, then high school, and eventually you go to university. And it is not possible to go to university if you haven’t finished your high school studies. Likewise, the procedure to move from the path shared with the being of the small scope to that shared with the being of the middling scope to that of the being of the great scope is similar. Or for instance, if you wish to go from Australia to India, you will have to transit either through Singapore or perhaps through Malaysia, to Kuala Lumpur.
Then, your ultimate goal is India, but you pass through Singapore or, through KL. Likewise, when you are proceeding in the training of the Lam Rim, you train first in the path of the being of the small, then in the path shared with the being of the middle, and finally in the path of the the being of the great scope. So in the Lam Rim, the principal goal is the attainment of full and utter and enlightenment for the sake of others. But as a prelude, as a preliminary to this, one generates a motivation shared with the being of the small scope, striving to attain a higher rebirth. And then on that basis, one generates the motivation to attain liberation before proceeding to the path shared or the path of the being of the great scope.
So to attain the uncommon realizations of the path of the being of the great scope, it is indispensable to have the uncommon realizations of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. If one does not have training in the path shared with the being of the middling scope, one will not attain the realizations of the path of the great scope. And to have these uncommon realizations of the path shared with the being of the middling scope, one must have those of the path shared with the being of the small scope. This is the procedure. The attainment of the path of the being of the great scope, which is full and utter enlightenment, is only possible on the foundation of the abandonment of all afflictions, which is the attainment of the path shared with the being of the middling scope.
The abandonment of all afflictions is only possible on the base of a higher rebirth, a physical base such as the one we have now. It is not possible or very difficult on a base of a lower realm rebirth. In this way, the path of the being of the small, middling, and great scope lead to each other. So please don’t get confused. As has been mentioned many times, when one has abandoned the afflictions, one has attained the state of an arhat.
Now when this is presented from the standpoint of the Mahāyāna, at which level, on which ground has one abandoned the afflictions and abandoned the ignorance grasping at a self? Geshe la believes you should be able to answer now. No. How how is that possible in the process of seeing? Abandoned.
No. No. No. I told you last year. According to the Mahāyāna, the path of the Bodhisattva, on which ground does one abandon the afflictions?
On the eighth ground. So therefore, on the Mahāyāna path, from the standpoint of the Prāsaṇgika School of Tenets, which is a school of tenets which we use in the Lam Rim, the afflictive obstructions are abandoned on the eighth ground. Then during the eighth, ninth, and tenth ground, one abandons the obstructions to omniscience. Don’t understand? How would it be possible to abandon this on the path of seeing?
On the path of seeing, one abandons imputed ignorance grasping at a self. Then if you were to abandon the afflictions on the path of seeing, during the path of meditation, there’d be nothing to do. So from the standpoint of the Mahāyāna presentation of paths, at which level are the afflictions abandoned? They are abandoned on the eighth ground. To be precise, they are abandoned at the time of the first instant of the eighth ground.
The last instant of the seventh ground does the abandoning. So here, on the level of the path shared with the, being of the middling scope, the goal of the path is liberation. Now, here, it is important to understand what liberation is, what one is striving for. And Geshe la noticed from your questions that you seem to think that liberation is something which concerns only hearers and solitary realizers. Mhmm.
So, therefore, to generate the special uncommon attainments of the path of the being of the great scope, one needs a special uncommon attainments of the path shared with the being of the middling scope. And to generate the special uncommon attainment of the past shared with the being of the middling scope, one needs the special uncommon attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope. So at this point, what arises as an issue is how does one generate these attainments? What is the measure of having generated them? What is the reward?
So therefore, let us take the path shared with the being of the small scope. What is the attainment? What is the main practice of the path shared with the being of the small scope? How do we know whether we have it or not? How do we identify where we stand?
Without the attainments of the path shared with the being of the small scope, it is not possible to gain the attainments shared with the path of the being of the middling scope. Without the attainments shared with the path of the being of the middling scope, it is not possible to gain the attainments of the path of the being of the great scope. So for in general, we study the paths of the being of the middling and the great scope. In terms of our own practice, we should focus on the path shared with the being of the small scope.
So to say that one has the realization shared with the being of the small scope because one knows by heart the four or the five cycles of meditation of the path shared with the being of the small scope would be very strange. Instead, one must gain certain realizations. To gain these realizations, one must generate these realizations. So what are these realizations and how are they generated? So the realizations the means is meditation on death and impermanence, and the realization is impermanence.
Realizations in impermanence. And having and giving up the vanities of this life. And the ethics of the abandonment of the 10 non virtues. And the fault is the suffering of the lower realms. Okay.
Lots and lots. What’s the reward? Okay. So it is therefore vitally important to identify the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small scope and how to generate them. Then it is wrong.
It is inappropriate to view dharma as something which is to be studied and one studies very advanced practices. And then in one’s daily life, one’s main goal is money. Right? So, obviously, let’s set money aside. There’s a reward to our practice.
What’s the reward? What’s the gift? Sure. Sure. No problem, please.
No. No. Please. Short. Short.
Short. Contentment. Ah, contentment. That’s it. So all of you have studied the path shared with the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope.
So do you have attainments? Okay. So as said many times, practice. Practice. Then the example which he always gave was that of someone who is severely ill and for whom only the best doctors are good enough and for whom only the best medicine is good enough, and this person holds all this medicine at home and never takes any of it, then there’s no benefit whatsoever for the disease.
So this is what happens to people who attend numerous teachings on Sūtra or Tantra and never practice anything. This example is from many times in Sūtra. In this example, the doctor is our teacher, the medicine is the dharma, and the disease is the afflictions. What is the uncommon attainment of the path shared with the being of the small scope? It is striving for a higher rebirth.
Now what is the measure of having attained that, attainment? It is when one has generated an uncontrived spontaneous striving for higher rebirth. How do we know whether we have this or not? If when we get up in the morning, at the moment of getting up in the morning, our first thought is to try to strive for a higher rebirth, probably we have it. Then in our own cases, our first thought is coffee.
Coffee. The first thought is what you get for breakfast. Right? Then for ordinary people, this is difficult to generate since the first thoughts seemed to be their children and so forth. It is difficult to difficult to break away from that.
But this is something which Geshe la understands. However, for those who are ordained, this should be the basics. Then this is something we have to check for ourselves. Geshe in his own case tends to recite manis when he gets up in the morning. Then falling asleep, he tends to recite manis and thinks a bit on the meaning of the text.
Then what happens in sleep, he really doesn’t know. But when he gets up in the morning, the manis tend to come naturally. It’s a matter of habit. So then when one falls asleep, sometimes there are very uncommon experiences. It’s hard to say that they are dreams because they are states of extreme clarity.
Then this is very uncommon. When you sleep, you dream. Right? During the day. Do you when in the middle of the day, do you do you dream?
I ask you during the day. No. Night. In the middle of the day, do you dream? Yes.
If you have a nap during the day, right, do you dream during that nap? Okay. Okay. So here, once one has generated this unconstrained, in other words, spontaneous striving for a higher rebirth, what is the attainment? The attainment is contentment.
What does contentment mean? It means that one is no longer interested or focused on the clothing, the food, and the conversation, of this life. Then as a result of this, one is happy because unhappiness comes, as you all know, from lack of contentment with the affairs of this life. Do you understand? These are the reasons which lead us in this direction.
Hardship arises from lack of contentment. When we have contentment, satisfaction, hardship is reduced. Alright? Then you do understand that it is not through reading the Lam Rim and cogitating on the Lam Rim that realizations are going to occur. One must meditate.
Then this is why what his holiness said referring to himself is of such significance. His holiness said, I have realized emptiness, but now I need to meditate. What this means is that the realization of emptiness alone is insufficient. One must generate a mind risen from meditation focused on emptiness. Now in our own cases, everyone in this room understands death and impermanence.
It’s self evident. But because we don’t think about it, there’s no habituation to it, then we have not attained the realizations of the path shared with the being of the small scope. Have you generated the realizations shared with the being of the small scope? So we need to generate these realizations, especially this realization of the path shared with the being of the small scope. And people seem to feel that realizations are like sitting on exams.
You sit on exam and you get a grade. Right? It’s not like that. So here, Geshe la, would like to say something Geshe la has said a couple times already. Practice means focusing on one’s own thoughts, on one’s own defects, on the desire, the anger, and so forth in one’s own mind.
Practice is not sitting back, looking at other people and saying, ah, he has no contentment. He is angry. So and so is jealous. That is not practice. Practice must focus on one’s own faults.
Looking at other people’s faults is no no benefit at all. So therefore here, one should focus on one’s own faults, one’s own defects, one’s own afflictions, reduce one’s own faults, defects, and afflictions. And then as a result of
This one gains a capacity to help others. This is Mahāyāna practice. Then as a result of this practice, we must generate contentment within ourselves. To have no contentment within oneself and to spend one’s time hectoring and lecturing lecturing other people saying, you should have contentment. This is not appropriate.
So it’s a little bit like the case of the frog who is staring in the sky at the beautiful voice of a stork, I believe, and tries to imitate it but can’t. Right? Something like a stalk. So, basically, this frog is mired in the mud Oh, no. Up to the neck.
He is looking at a bird, I think a stork in a tree, and basically thinks if he can sing like the stork, the stork will give him something. Peacock. A not a stork. Excuse me. What examples do we have in England in Western countries for this?
Cook. Cook. Cook, please. Cook. An example of looking at other people’s afflictions instead of one’s own would be, if I had a Christian one, it is when you see the splinter of wood in the other person’s eye and you don’t notice the plank of wood in your own eye.
. So you have received numerous teachings on the Lam Rim Lam Rim, and we will study further the path shared with the being of the middling and the great scope. But for practice, you should focus on the path shared with the being of the small scope, which is a level we are all at. And then as a result of this practice, at the time of death, there will be no fear. Many of you have minds who are troubled at the thought of death.
At the time of death, there’s no fear in this way. Now at present, we should understand that we will experience continually the four sufferings, the sufferings of birth, aging, sickness, and death for as long as the ignorance grasping at a self which exists within our own mind stream has not been severed. What severs this ignorance grasping at a self within our own mind stream? The wisdom realizing emptiness. So this ignorance grasping at a self that must be understood first on the basis of the lower schools of tenets moving upwards.
Now how is this ignorance grasping at a self abandoned? It is abandoned by applying an antidote which is opposite to it. What is this antidote which is directly opposite to it? It is the wisdom realizing interdependence or the wisdom realizing emptiness. So here, interdependence or dependent origination was presented from the to the subtler forms.
A course form of interdependence which was presented is the relationship, the imputation of the person on both body and mind. So listen carefully. We have some newcomers today, and Geshe will cover new topics as well. So when we say that the person entertains a relationship with body and mind, that the person depends on body and mind, this means that the person is imputed on body and mind. The meaning is the same.
So, Geshe la will not elaborate on this. The topic has been explained in detail previously. Now it is important as a preliminary to, state that the person exists. This is something which has been decided if you wish. It’s a given.
Just as for instance, this table exists. And if you ask what is the mode of existence of the person, you could ask as well what is the mode of existence of the table. It is reality. So often when one asks why the person exists, the press students become very hesitant. Now, it is exactly the same thing as the existential status of the table.
If Kesheera asks you, why does the table exist? What is your answer? Quickly. It exists as a imputation on a basis of imputation. And just could could, please?
It performs the function of a table. It’s established by a valid cognizer as a table. So all of you basically said the same thing in different words. One of you said, the table exists because I can put things on the table. Another said, because it can perform the function of a table.
So we all agree that the table exists. Then if someone says to you this table doesn’t exist, you look at him and say, have you lost it? So in society at large, this is indeed the attitude one looks at reality. Then as far as the mode of existence of the person is concerned, we should look at it the same way. What is the mode of existence of the person?
It forms the function of a person. So this is something you should feel free to express yourself upon. It is a very important topic because some of duller acumen, when the topic of emptiness is presented, tend to feel that the person actually doesn’t exist at all. This is an extremely dangerous position. So what is the mode of existence of the person?
The person exists nominally. Exist only. So speak in terms of your own experience. Look. Just as you spoke about the table, it’s a little bit bizarre if you can’t explain why you exist.
So why exactly do you why are you here? Why do you exist? Explain your mode of existence. I experienced pleasure and pain. Don’t we exist independence on our parents and that our name is imputed onto our aggregate?
I exist because people recognize me as a person. We exist dependent on the five compositional factors. You’re speaking of the five aggregates. Right? I have a birth certificate, so I have the paperwork to prove it.
So therefore, first, we do exist. Then we have to ask ourselves why we exist. Then it’s very strange since we are also terribly important to ourselves if we are unable to answer why exactly we exist. So the I, the person, oneself, after all, goes, walks, eats. Then from morning onwards, it performs activities.
It is on this basis that we can speak of the existence of the I. Subject, object. Then we say, I’ll do something. Obviously, it’s the I which does it. Then even in English grammar, you need a subject in a sentence. You could subject, verb, object.
Whether the subject, who basically performs what leads to the object.
So let us resolve that Chris and Hiro exist. After all, if you say Chris does not exist or Hiro does not exist in this society of us, people laugh at you. It’s silly. So it is now at present that So presently, let’s meditate a little bit. And it’s actually a practice akin to meditation on how our I appears to us.
Then some of you explained last time how you explained, how you experienced it. Some said that the I was akin to the inhabitant of a house. The others said that the I was within the aggregates. So check for yourselves how your I appears to you. So what we want to check is what the innate perception, the innate mind perceiving our I is like.
Now it is not because a mind is innate or spontaneous that it is correct. There are innate minds which are correct and innate minds which are false. So within these two examples, if we look at the one in which the I appears separate from the aggregates, is the mind perceiving an I separate from the aggregates mistaken or not? Is it a mistake? Yes.
Do you agree or kind of why? Why are you saying it’s a mistake in mind? Because if I remove my aggregates, I don’t perceive myself other than that. And other? I couldn’t say I’ve learned something because it would be completely separate.
So in brief, the I and the aggregates form a relationship. They entertain a relationship. Therefore, the mind which perceives the I as completely unrelated, completely separate from the aggregates is a mistaken mind. So in Buddhist texts, this innate mind, this innate mistaken mind is given an uncommon name. Now Geshe la would like you to say to him what this uncommon name is.
Coming from your side, it’ll be more powerful than if he just keeps explaining. Not some. Geshe is asking about the mind. This mistaken What mind is the name of this mistaken mind in Buddhist texts? Please.
So some of you were on the right track, then please think carefully from your own side what the uncommon name given to this mistaken mind is in Buddhist texts. Okay. So at present, let us generate the motivation for receiving these teachings, the motivation to benefit others. And while generating this motivation this motivation after doing the recitations, let us try to think what exactly this mistaken mind is, what its name is, what its mistaken mode of apprehension is, and hopefully, you will remember the name. Please open the prayer book page one.
We shall recite one b, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three. Page five. So what name is given to that mind in Buddhist texts? Close. Close.
No 100%. Close. Please. . You see, Gesheera needs a forceful answer from you.
Mhmm. Not something tentative and hesitant. You’ve heard a lot of Yes. I think. Sorry?
Afflicted? Close. Close. Very close. Thank you.
Okay. Very close, but no 100%. You know? Before Geshe la tells you, how does this I appear in relation to your aggregates? Generally, how does it appear?
For yourself. Right? Right? For myself, I feel like this I is in
My aggregates. So set aside what you think you know about the topic. Geshe la would like to know how you feel within yourself about the relation between your eye and your body and mind or your aggregates if you prefer? My I seems to be something permanent as if I am the same eye now as I was when I was a child regardless of the fact that my aggregates have changed. Yeah.
So my I seems to be the observer of the aggregates? I’ve been watching it, and it seems to change. So sometimes it feels like it’s the owner of the aggregates and it’s controlling them. Other times it feels like the victim of the aggregates, like when I can’t make myself concentrate or when I get sick. So the way the I appears to me does change from time to time.
I feel like, I’m the owner of my aggregates, and I live in my body like it’s a little house. And I like to think that I have control over my aggregates, but I’m disappointed because I don’t. I feel like my aggregates are secondary to my mind. The sort of thing I don’t mind so much things happening to my physical body because I can go to hospital. I can have a leg replaced, whatever.
I just think when I lose my mind, the whole thing’s out the window. It’s quite scary. That the I exists from its own side and it’s unchanging. So broadly speaking, all of you have said very similar things, and these these descriptions are clearly given in Buddhist texts. Then you can see that this sense we have of the I is mistaken because clearly our I is related or linked to our aggregates.
So you can see that this mind apprehends the I as unrelated to the aggregates, to the body and mind. Right? Now which mind has a mode of apprehension which is opposite to this one? Which mind has a mode of apprehension which is opposite to that of this mind, mistaken mind, which sees the I as completely unrelated to body and mind? Is it compassion, which has an opposite mode of apprehension?
Is it love? So you do understand that neither love nor compassion have a mode of apprehension of its object, which is opposite to that of this mistaken mind. So which mind, therefore, do you give which has a mode of apprehension of its object directly opposite to that of this mistaken mind? So you have to think very carefully about your answers. The key is to distinguish between levels of the self, coarse and subtle selves, mistaken selves which are apprehended.
Then you will have coarser and subtler antidotes. So this is something we have to think about. When we think about this, then we will be able to progress in our understanding. So you have one week to think about these gradations in coarseness and subtlety of the self and the gradations in coarseness and subtlety of the antidotes to the mind apprehending this mind. And Geshe la will ask questions next week.
You have numerous levels of coarseness and subtleness of emptiness just as if you have numerous levels of coarseness and subtleness of the I or the self. What we’re talking about at present are very, very coarse levels of consciousness directly linked to the brain. When the brain decays, these levels of consciousness disappear. Thank you. Thank you.
Open the prayer book, page nine. Eight b Mandala offering. Yes. There’s there’s no teaching next Wednesday because it’s
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
- Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- mandala offering
- The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
- path of meditation bhavana-marga (Skt); gom lam (Tib)
- The fourth of the five paths leading to buddhahood. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.