1 h 41 min · 4,673 words · 5 October 2011
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim course on Atisha’s Lamp for the Path, covering the greatness of the dharma: the teachings are non-contradictory, scriptures serve as instructions, and the intent of the victorious one is discerned. It explains abandoning the dharma as the gravest misdeed, and presents the Lam Rim’s three features: completeness, ease of practice, and superiority to other traditions. The talk closes with review questions to the audience.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 42m
UUID: 531000f0-a0fc-4e03-8093-717d311d1a54
Date: 2011-10-05
Words: 4,669
So what Geshe la would be teaching today will certainly not cover one hour and a half of teachings. At most with translation and so forth, it will be half an hour of teachings. Then how much we all understand that this is difficult to say. However, if we go over it again and again and we read the good English translation of liberation in the palm of your of our hand, we would understand. And there is no rush.
There is no hurry in studying such a profound topic. If a treatise of Lam Rim like this one was studied in the monastery, one would consider that one could only start studying it after finishing the teachings on Paramita, which take around seven years, and the teachings of Madhyamaka, which take four years of study. Then we would start studying such a such a great treatise. His Holiness the Dalai Lama has taught Lam Rim over and over again in the great monasteries as have the great teachers. And for ourselves, even though there is a risk that we might fall asleep while listening to these teachings, nonetheless, Geshe la hopes you will retain something.
He thinks it will take some two years to cover this text correct. And we ourselves through these teachings will become familiar as some of us have already with the concepts of the being of the small, the middling, the great scope and the three principles of the path, renunciation, bodhicitta, and the correct view of emptiness, which is of tremendous benefit. To give you an idea of how difficult it is to understand these topics correctly, His Holiness the Dalai Lama taught the great treatise on the stages of the path in in Dharamsala in nineteen ninety nine, two thousand. Geshe la had at that point already been studying for fifteen or sixteen years at the great seats. And when he attended His Holiness’s teachings, he cannot say that he had a clear understanding at the period with the three principles of the path.
He had heard of them but an understanding is something altogether different. So this will take a long time. Please think in this way, therefore. And therefore, I would like to encourage you to go to the outline section on page six seventy three of your English version. Geshe la will provide a very structured teaching relying on the outline.
We have covered the first outline, the greatness of the authors, and at present are covering the second outline, the greatness of the dharma given to increase one’s respect for the instructions. This is subdivided into four, the greatness of allowing one to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction, which has already been covered. The greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves as instructions, which has been covered. The greatness of allowing one to easily discover the true thought of the victorious one, the intent, which has already been presented, and what Geshe la will cover today, the greatness of allowing one to save oneself from the worst misdeeds. And how should one study these topics?
One should start with the first subdivision of the second outline, outline number 21, the greatness of allowing one to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction. Reflect on what Geshe la taught on this outline during the last teachings, and then go to page number 60 in one’s text and read what is written there and reflect on it. Then take the next outline, outline 22, the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to oneself as instructions. One should reflect on what Geshe laure has taught, then go to page 63 and read in the root text what is taught on the topic. Then the third outline, outline 23, the greatness of allowing one to easily discover the true intent of the victorious one.
We should again reflect on the oral teachings then go in the root text, English translation page 67 and read what was written there. And the fourth outline which we’ll be covering today is the greatness of allowing one to save oneself, the text adds naturally from the worst misdeed. The worst misdeed here from the standpoint of Lam Rim Cemo is the misdeed or the grievous thought of abandoning the dharma. And to understand precisely what abandoning the dharma means, we must identify clearly the object of negation involved. So initially, we must reflect carefully on the first three outlines Geshe la has already presented.
The greatness of allowing one to realize that all the teachings are without contradiction, the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to oneself as instructions and the greatness of allowing one to easily discover the true intent of the victorious one. If one has not done this carefully, if one has not reflected carefully on the three first greatnesses of the dharma, there is a very great risk that one will discriminate in the Buddha’s teachings within Sūtra and Tantra between components of the teachings which are to be practiced and components of the teachings which are not to be practiced. Saying this aspect of the teachings is beneficial and leads to liberation or full enlightenment. This, however, is unnecessary and is dharma which is not to be practiced. This is abandoning the dharma.
In the same same way, many say the Paramanavartika by Dharmakīrti was only written to refute the view of non Buddhist Hindu philosophers and it is not to be put in practice. This is a clear case of abandoning the dharma. There’s a very great danger of this arising if we haven’t meditated on the three first greatnesses of the dharma. And the heavy karma of accumulating the abandonment of dharma is explained in the sūtra condensing all of the liberations, the Samadhayagarbha Sūtra, in which it is clearly explained that abandoning the dharma is the activity of differentiating or dissociating dharma teachings. For instance, it would be for a practitioner of the great scope to say, this is Hīnayāna dharma.
It’s dharma which belongs to the lower vehicle. It is not something for me to practice. Or for a practitioner of the Hīnayāna to say, this is Mahāyāna dharma. It is not something which is to be practiced. And for this reason, it is said in the Sūtra of the King of Concentration, the Samadhyaraja Sūtra, to give an example of how grievous the thought of abandoning dharma is that even if one were to destroy all of these stupas erected in our world, and there are numerous stupas and the destruction of a stupa is an extremely heavy thought.
Nonetheless, the thought of abandoning dharma would be greater than that. Likewise, it is also said in the Samādhi Rāja Sūtra, even if one were to slaughter as many arhats as there are grains of sand in the Ganges River and killing an arhat in and of itself is already one of the five heinous crimes of immediate retribution. Nonetheless, the thought of abandoning dharma would be greater than that. And we might wonder why is this the case. There are numerous stupas in this world of ours and most probably the creation of these stupas was of benefit.
So how could it be that the karma of abandoning dharma is so much more grievous than destroying those stupas? Then if we reflect on this, we should ask ourselves a question Geshe la asks us. Do these stupas help or do these stupas create within our mind stream either the noble truth of cessation or the noble truth of the path or not?
Moreover, since the sutras of the Buddha are what enables for liberation and full enlightenment to occur within our mind stream, this is the reason for which differentiating within the Sutras of the Buddha between what is to be practiced and what is not to be practiced is so much heavier than slaughtering as many arhats as there were grains of sand in the Ganges River. And it is similar to the stanza in the eight stanzas for generating bodhicitta, which Geshe la taught this weekend, in which it is said that when bodhisattvas encounter beings who are of an extremely poor or evil disposition or afflicted with tremendous suffering, they cherish them more than any other beings. The reason for this, the reason for the Bodhisattvas cherishing these beings is a reason based on the benevolence of these beings. These beings are benevolent because it is thanks to their kindness, thanks to practicing on their basis that the bodhisattvas can attain the final attainment of full enlightenment. Likewise, this reason of benevolence is a reason which is advanced here.
And in this context, Geshe la would like to point out the tremendous difference between the Buddha’s body and the Buddha’s speech, for we owe veneration indeed to the Buddha’s body and to representations of the Buddha such as the statues on the altar. These statues cannot give us renunciation bodhicitta or the authentic view. And Geshe la would challenge you to propose a situation in which these statues could give such. On the other hand, the teachings of the Buddha, the speech of the Buddha is much more important than the representations of the Buddha’s body since it is the dependence on the speech of the Buddha that we gain realizations. For this reason, the scriptures which represent the speech of the Buddha are always put in a place of honor on the altar.
So do you think it is appropriate therefore to say someone who puts a statue of the Buddha on the floor next to him, that is very base and evil behavior, and to say nothing to the person who takes a text of dharma and puts it on the ground or even sits on it. It is important to think about this. And therefore, avoiding the deed of abandoning dharma and should it occur immediately countering it is made possible through understanding clearly the three first greatnesses and most importantly, the first greatness, the greatness of allowing one to understand all the teachings as non contradictory. Therefore, through understanding the greatness of relying on the spiritual teacher, we can naturally abandon all faults in respect to our behavior to the spiritual teacher through understanding the greatness of a precious human rebirth and meditation on impermanence and death. We can naturally abandon attachment to the vanities of this life. Through understanding clearly the sufferings of cyclic existence and renunciation, we can easily abandon attachment to all lives.
Through understanding the greatness of great compassion and bodhicitta, we can easily abandon self cherishing. And finally, through understanding the greatness of the view, we can easily abandon the innate sense or the innate ignorance which apprehends the existence of a true self. And Geshe la will give illustrations or examples of these three first greatnesses, the greatness of allowing one to realize all the teachings are without contradiction, the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves as instructions, and the greatness of allowing one to easily discover the true thought or the intent of the victorious one. He would like us to listen very carefully to his presentation of the examples because the examples are easier and the meaning is more difficult. Therefore, from the examples, we can move up to the meaning of these greatnesses.
So the example Geshe la would like to give for the greatness of allowing us to understand that all the teachings are without contradiction is that of the creation of a tanka, a tanka of Mañjuśrī for instance. To create a tanka of Mañjuśrī, one needs initially a flat surface. And on this flat surface, one will spread out a base, for instance, of silk or fabric. Then one needs brushes, one needs liquid, one needs colors, one needs draftsmen, stencils. All of these are necessary for the creation of the thanka and not one of them is harmful to the creation of the thanka.
In the self same way, all of the teachings of the Buddha are non contradictory. And, Geshe la would like to develop again on this first greatness, the greatness of seeing all the teachings as non contradictory. As you remember, when Lhalama Yeshe Ö requested Jowo Je, Pandit Atisha, to come to Tibet to correct the deep misunderstandings in Tibet at the period. In Tibet, most of the practitioners saw Vinaya and Tantra as totally contradictory. It was not possible to practice Vinaya and Tantra.
If one practice Vinaya, one gave up Tantra. If one practice Tantra, one gave up Vinaya. This first greatness shows clearly that this is not the case. Not only are Vinaya and tantra not contradictory, they are totally harmonious. Now it is true that there are individual passages both in Vinaya and in Tantra which superficially seem to contradict each other.
For instance, in Vinaya, it is said one must be celibate and one must, for instance, give up alcohol. Whereas in tantra, there are passages in which the opposite is said. And the reason for which these two statements are not contradictory is because the totality of the teachings are none other than means for one person, one practitioner to progress all the way upwards to the state of full enlightenment. And once one understands that the totality of the Buddha’s teachings, the teachings of the Hīnayāna, of the Mahāyāna, of the Vinaya, of Tantra, are none none have no other goal but leading one person to the state of full enlightenment. There can be no differentiation in the Buddhist teachings between some which are superior and some which are inferior.
All are absolutely equal and identical. Now the example for the second greatness, the greatness of allowing all the scriptures to present themselves to US instructions is the following. Ward, the example of the first was collecting everything which was necessary to draw a of Mañjuśrī. The example for the second is actually using everything we have collected, the paintbrush, the colors, and so forth to draw the. What is meant here when one says that all of these scriptures are to see be seen as oral instructions for practice?
What is meant by the second greatness is that even individual letters in the scriptures such as such as the Tibetan letters and so forth, the a b c in English, are to be seen as instructions for training. And the third greatness is illustrated by the fact that the goal of drawing this thanka is to actually create a thanka of Mañjuśrī in the same same way as the goal, the general goal of all of the teachings of the Buddha is a presentation of the path of the beings of the three scopes, small, middling and great scope. But specifically, the goal is a presentation of the three principles of the path which are renunciation, bodhicitta and the correct view of emptiness. So in addition to the four greatnesseses, which are outlined
Two one, two two, two three, and two four in the outline of your text which have been presented. There are three additional features of the Lam Rim which are present in Atisha’s Bodipata Pradipa, which are outlines number two five, two six, and two seven on pages six seventy three and six seventy four. And these three features on pages six seventy three and six seventy four are first feature two twenty five or 2.5. The Lam Rim is complete because it contains all the subject matter of Sūtra and Tantra. All the topics of Sūtra and Tantra have been injected or placed within the teachings of the graduated stages of the path.
The following feature outline 2.6, it is easy to put into practice because it emphasizes the steps for taming the mind. The only focus of Lam Rim is taming the mind. Therefore, it is very easy to put into practice. And finally, outline 2.7 on page six seventy four. It is superior to other traditions because it contains instructions from the two gurus who were the traditions of the two great champions.
Refers to the fact that the Lam Rim contains the two lineages, the lineage of the vast which which extends from Asaṇga all the way down to Atisha through Guru Serlingpa and the lineage of the profound which extends from Nāgārjuna all the way down to Atisha through Vidyakokila the elder. These two lineages were fused in the person of Atisha and he summarized them in his Bodhipathapradīpa, the lamp for the path. So regarding the first of the features, feature 2.5, the Lam Rim is complete because it contains all the subject matter of Sūtra and Tantra. The Lam Rim in no way contains all the terms or all the words of Sūtra and Tantra. This would be impossible.
The Lam Rim, however, contains all the topics of Sūtra and Tantra because Atisha presented the path in a graduated way through presenting the paths of the being of the small, middling and great scope which contain all the topic matters of sūtra and tantra. And since the Bodhipathapradīpa, the lamp for the path composed by Atisha contains the paths of the beings of all three scopes, it presents the totality of the path leading to full enlightenment. And on this basis, understood that the totality of the teachings were included within the paths of the beings of the three scopes as composed by Atisha. And while there are numerous Lam Rim texts, the so called eight great Lam Rim texts, nonetheless, they can all be subsumed or resumed or grounded in Atisha’s lamp for the path. And this is why in the verse of which Geshe la quoted at the beginning of the course, that essence of all of the scriptures of the victorious ones, What is referred to is none other than the Lam Rim, which is the essence of all of the scriptures of the victorious ones since it resumes all of the scriptures which might be of existence in this world of ours.
And this is why a very great Kadampa Geshe, Geshe Tolungpa is supposed to have said after the Lam Rim was composed, this old monk has taken our heart. And for this reason, the graduated stages of the path of the teachings of the victorious ones can be compared to a key which enables us to open the door to all of the teachings. And this is why Geshe la gives you a very Tibetan example. Tibetans thought yaks were very beautiful, said, I have here a beautiful yak. Therefore, whether the Lamrims are extensive or very concise, They comprise the totality of the path ranging from the practice of relying on the virtuous friend as a foundation all the way up to the union of calm abiding and insight.
An example which is given for this, and this is drawn from Tibetan medicine, is that of a fundamental drug in Tibetan medicine called twenty five camphor. Twenty five camphor does not contain all of the medicinal substances known to Tibetan medicine, but it contains substances which have all of their activities. So it’s similar to some of the Chinese medicines which are compounds of 10 or more substances. And it is the same thing as with these composite medicines. If one of the drugs necessary for their creation is missing, then the medicine camphor twenty-five is not effective.
Likewise, if one of the components necessary to lead one all the way up to full enlightenment is missing, then it does not qualify as a Lam Rim treatise. And therefore, reflecting on the past of the beings of three scope, of the three scopes, the small, middling and great scope. If the path of the being of the small scope has not been well established, then to be frank, one is abandoning the path of the beings of the middling and the great scope. Therefore, Geshe la is going to emphasize heavily the practice of the being of the small scope. And don’t think that it is easy to reflect on the path of the being of the small scope.
Geshe la will develop it. And if after repeated explanations, we are able to generate this path of the being of the small scope in our minds, then this life will have become truly meaningful. Do you have it? Do you have it within your mind streams? So if we think carefully or if we think carefully about this, we can realize that it arises through fear.
If you have no fear, how can you have the path of the being of small scope? So you are afraid of the fire for instance of being hurt by fire now. What is the reason for that? And the second feature is that the Lam Rim is easy to put into practice because it emphasizes the steps for taming the mind. It encompasses all of the means for taming the mind.
Therefore, it is easy to put into practice. And the third feature of the Lam Rim on outlined on page six seventy four, it is superior to other traditions because it contains instructions from two gurus who were schooled in the traditions of the two great champions. Refers to the two lineages which Geshe la explained, ranging from Asaṇga to Atisha via Guru Serlingpa, the lineage of the vast on the one hand, and the lineage of the profound ranging ranging from Nāgārjuna to Atisha via Vidyakokila the elder, the two lineages being fused in Atisha. The other traditions which are referred to here and with respect to which the Lam Rim is superior are on the one hand
Maitreya’s Abhisamayālamkāra, the ornament of realizations, and on the other hand, the Guhyasamāja root tantra. Maitreya’s Abhishamaya Lamkara is the foundation of all of the Pāramitāyāna, the studies of the perfections. And even though it is said that the path of the being of the three scopes is presented within the Abhishamaya Lamkara, it is very difficult to find it within it. Likewise, it is said that the Guhyasamāja root Tantra is the royal Tantra, it is the foundation of Tantra, it is a very essence of Tantra, yet it does not present the path of the beings of the three scopes. Therefore, Lam Rim is superior to both these treatises.
And Atisha’s lamp for the path, his Bodhipattapradipa is therefore superior both to the Abhishamayalamkara and to the root tantra of Guhyasamāja. The it is superior to the Abhishamayalamkara because the Abhishamayalamkara does not present Tantric practice even though it presents the path of the being of the three scopes. And it is superior to the Guhyasamāja Tantra because even though the Guhyasamāja Tantra presents all of the Tantric grounds and paths, it does not present the practice of the beings of all three scopes which are all presented within Atisha’s treatise. So we will stop here for today with the presentation of these three features. So it would not be appropriate for Geshe la not to ask you questions at this point and he would like to cover again the fundamentals.
So he’d like to ask you what examples are to be given for the first greatness, the greatness of seeing all the scriptures as non contradictory. What example is to be given for the second greatness, The greatness of seeing all of the teachings as instructions for practice. What example is to be given for the third greatness? The greatness of allowing one to easily discern the intent of the conqueror. What is the meaning on top of that?
How do you connect the meaning to the exam? You gave the ex example very well. Now as to the meaning. Since the meaning is the essence. So extending the example to the meaning is that all of the scriptures are non contradictory.
And here, when one says that all of the teachings are non contradictory, there are two broad subdivisions of teachings, scriptural teachings and teachings which are realizations. This context, we refer to scriptural teachings and scriptural teachings here refer specifically to the teachings of the Hīnayāna, of the Mahāyāna, the Vinaya, the Mantrayāna, none of which is contradictory even though there seem to be slight superficial contradictions since the intent, the goal of all of them is to lead one single person to the state of enlightenment. So now, there’s two questions. What is the second example, the example for all the scriptures dawning as oral instructions? And how do you connect it to the meaning?
That’s excellent. That is exactly it. You can also connect it with the example which Geshe la gave today. So let us try to give the examples connected with the tankas today. So what is the third example and how do you connect it with the meaning?
Indeed, it is setting oneself as a goal having assembled the requisites and started the work to create a thanka of Mañjuśrī which can be hung on the walls. And this is the example for the meaning of understanding easily the intent of all of the conquerors. The intent of all of the conquerors is for the paths of the beings of the three scopes, small, middling, and great, as well as their essence, the three principles of the path, renunciation, bodhicitta, and the view understanding emptiness to lead beings to the state of full enlightenment. There is time for one question. So the five crimes of immediate retribution are patricide, killing one’s father, matricide, killing one’s mother, killing an arhat, causing a schism, in other words, a break inside the Buddhist sangha, the monastic community and drawing blood with the intent to harm from the body of the Buddha.
Summing up, the five crimes of immediate retribution. And why is this the case? Generally speaking, murder is a grievous crime. However, to murder one’s father or one’s mother is an extraordinarily heavy criminal act because of the extraordinary kindness one’s father and one’s mother have shown to us. As for murdering an arhat, an arhat is a being who has progressed upwards on the grounds and paths and has great qualities.
So there are great waves of merit in reflecting on the practices of the beings of small, middling and great scope as well as reflecting on the three principles of the path. So at present we have covered the four greatness. The greatness of seeing all the scriptures as non contradictory, the greatness of seeing all of the teachings dawning as instructions for practice, the greatness of easily understanding the intent of the conquerors. And in addition to the four greatnesses, the three features, do you find it easier to understand when you read? It’s very good.
Really? Really? Then we didn’t waste our time today, and this one hour and a half wasn’t wasted for any one of us. One hour and a half stretching on two hours, it would see. Geshe la is very happy.
Otherwise, if you read the text and still didn’t understand anything, then Geshe la would wonder what he was doing here and feel very tired. And Geshe la suspects that all of us in this room understand the importance of time and of not wasting one’s time. So if we come here, it is to understand the meaning and if we understand the meaning and are able to reflect about on it, then we have not wasted our time. Are you a bit dizzy? And the goal is to change the mind, so that is good.
And Geshe la’s hopes will have been fulfilled if upon reflecting on the second greatness of Atisha’s Bodhipathapradīpa and the Lam Rim tradition in general, which is all of the teachings dawning instructions for practice, you resolve that everything you read in Buddhist text, you will put into practice at once. Yeah.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- graduated path of the three capable beings kye bu sum gyi lam gyi rim pa (Tib)
- The three levels of practice of the lower, middle and higher capable being, based on the motivations of trying to attain a better future rebirth, liberation or enlightenment. Also known as the three scopes. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- Hinayana theg mäen (Tib)
- Literally, Small, or Lesser, Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. The Hinayana practitioner's motivation for following the Dharma path is principally the intense wish for personal liberation from conditioned existence, or samsara. LYWA
- object of negation gag cha (Tib)
- An object to be refuted or eliminated. There are different objects of negation in different contexts, but when meditating on emptiness according to Prasangika (the Middle Way Consequence school), the object of negation is inherent existence. LYWA
- Paramitayana Pharchin thegpa (Tib)
- The Perfection Vehicle, another name for Bodhisattvayana or Sutrayana; the non-tantric Mahayana path. LYWA
- tantra gyü (Tib)
- Literally, thread, or continuity. The secret teachings of the Buddha; a scriptural text and the teachings and practices it contains. Also called Vajrayana or Mantrayana. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.