Lam Rim – 2018-06-27 – Lamrim

1 h 40 min · 4,886 words · 27 June 2018

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2018-06-27 - Lamrim
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. Students ask questions and the teacher distinguishes wish or aspiration from desire, which he describes as a biased, dissatisfied mind. He explains the subtle mind through the dream state and discusses the coarse and subtle grasping at a self of persons as the root of afflictions. Living and conscious beings are treated as synonymous, with plants a recurring question.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 40m

UUID: 6663b8e6-4efe-4bae-a312-fdf44b6379d6

Date: 2018-06-27

Words: 4,882

So Geshe la wanted to start by distinguishing, two terms which he thinks you confuse, which is translated English as wishing or aspiring to, and which is translated as desire. Then, generally, you seem to use them interchangeably. They are not. All wish is not necessarily a desire, but all desire is necessarily a wish. And in addition, faith and wishes or wish are synonymous.

Geshe la has noticed that you repeatedly state that the aspiration or the wish for full enlightenment is desire, then this implies that you are confusing aspiration or wish with desire. They are not the same. If they were the same, then since the wish for full enlightenment or the aspiration for full enlightenment exists in the mind stream of an ārya bodhisattva, desire would exist in the mind stream of an ārya bodhisattva. So on the one hand, the wishing and aspiration are synonymous, but wishing and aspiration are not the same as desire. If they were, then, for instance, great compassion, which is a wish for all sentient beings to be freed from suffering, would become desire.

For that matter, there is a risk that love would also become desire. Everything would become desire. So Geshe-la does not know for sure how you think about this, but he suspects this is an issue. So are you able to differentiate between wish and aspiration on the one hand and desire on the other or not? Do you consider that they are one?

It’s better if you express yourself sincerely in terms of what you see within your own minds instead of just replying in the light of what Geshe la said? See them No. Not sure, please. I see them as the same on one spectrum of virtuous desire to nonvirtuous desire. How can virtue and non virtue be on one continuum?

All over. They’re they’re different. So it is best to view desire as a biased, partial, or prejudiced mind. Then you must distinguish, therefore, between, wish and desire. Desire is characterized by dissatisfaction.

Now, for instance, in our cases, we need food. We need to eat. We need to drink. We need to sleep. If all of these wishes were desires, then everything would become a desire.

Now in Buddhist treatises, desire is described as biased or partially biased or partial consciousness. And we can see this best, with a worldly example, that of our love for our children. When our love for our children becomes so great, then that as a result of this love, we feel distant from other children, then at that point, that love has become a biased state of mind. It is desire. Then there is a difference in meaning and denotation and connotation of words in English and Tibetan.

Sometimes when one translates a word from English into Tibetan, it becomes a bit laughable or ridiculous from a Tibetan perspective. So for instance, the little, table in front of Geshe la, when it is, old and useless, we say in English that it is old. Now Tibetan has two words for old, one for persons and one for things. If we use the word, which is old for persons for the table in Tibetan, then it’s really ridiculous. Then in Tibetan, the word is only used for human beings or persons.

When the table becomes pretty much useless, we say that it is. This is the word old used for things as opposed to new. Then there are such linguistic differences, such slight differences. A second point Geshe would bring up would like to bring up is the distinction which is made in English and in Western languages between living and conscious, endowed with life and endowed with consciousness. Then, Geshe la noticed that Western students typically will say that there are living beings who are not conscious.

Not all living beings are conscious. In Buddhist scriptures, on the other hand, a living being and a conscious being are strictly synonymous. Then the example you give, typically, for a living being which is not conscious is a plant, a plant with leaves or a tree or whatever. Then, again, from a Tibetan perspective, this is very, very strange. So, Geshe-la, I suspect this is because we consider consciousness to be linked with the brain.

And then, obviously, not all living beings have a brain similar to us. So mind here refers to the main mental consciousness, and all living beings have it. For instance, dogs, cats, and so forth have minds. Then whether their minds are similar to ours is a different question. There are numerous gradations of coarseness and subtlety of mind.

So for instance, that we had a major discussion about this a month or so ago, but the distinction was between a living being and a conscious being. What instance did you give of a living being which is not a conscious being? Do you remember? Really? Oh.

So then why? Well, it was argued by Pamela very strongly that plants I gave the example of a of a living being as being a plant. I think that was argued very strongly by Pamela that, plants indeed do have consciousness. So, it’s a long learning curve. Okay.

Quick. Quick. Quick. Quick. Let’s quick, please.

The reason I gave for an instance of a living being but not a sentient being being a plant is because in scientific common knowledge that’s how they are explained. But I do, but when I did say that, I do know that the Buddha referred to plants as one facultied beings who have, the faculty of sensation. So but I gave that I gave the the reason I gave it is because that’s how it’s known colloquially, the difference between living There’s no statement whatsoever in Buddhist scriptures that plants are endowed with sensation since sensation is one of the five aggregates. Okay. Then that is something we have to examine.

You have to examine. We don’t function here on the basis of hearsays. You must actually give the source. Okay. That’s okay.

Okay. Trouble. Trouble. Don’t. We can waste two hours like this.

You know?

So then in Buddhist treatises, living being and conscious beings are synonymous. And Geshe la, from his own perspective, considers that a suitable definition of a sentient being or of a living being, since he is synonymous, is a being, which moves towards the object it wishes for. Or more precisely, a being which is endowed with the activity of motion towards the object it wishes for and of countering the objects it does not wish for. Yep. So, Geshe la explained the importance of the term or motion in Tibetan because motion is the characteristic of the subtle winds.

Wind is defined as that which is light and moving. When we have motion in the definition of a sentient being, we have a linkage with the subtle mind and by extension with a topic covered on Tuesdays, which is. So here, when one, uses the term to move or to fluctuate in Tibetan, what is the meaning of this term? Setting tantra aside, it means that the mind fluctuates or moves. Which mind?

In Chitamatra, it alludes to the ālāyavijñāna, the mind, basis of all, a subtle mind. And in Madhyamaka, it alludes to the element of the Buddha lineage. How is is that explanation? Does that satisfy or help you? No.

Really? Okay. Okay. Thank you. Then please think about it, therefore.

And, obviously, this topic is linked with that of the subtle minds. Then since we have no experience of the subtle minds, it’s very easy to dismiss things offhand. But if one has experience, then it’s a bit ridiculous to do so. Then a subtle state of mind, is similar, albeit not identical, with either the ālāyavijñāna or with the element of the buddha nature is a dream consciousness. There is none of us who has not had the experience of the dream consciousness.

This is a consciousness which gives rise to a body separate from the aggregates. The proof for the existence of the subtle consciousness, which is used regularly by his holiness, the Dalai Lama, is precisely the existence of the dream state. It is something we have experience of. So in the case of the dream state, this is something we have direct experience of. We don’t need to rely on scriptural quotes to establish its existence.

And actually, the dream state is the grounds or the rationale for the existence of the bardo being state. So how do you feel about giving the dream state as example of subtle consciousness? How is it? Does it help? Now please be sincere, excuse me, for the term don’t deceive.

Don’t lie. So Geshe la is saying that the experience we have of the dream state establishes the existence of Geshe-la, sometimes our dreams are influenced by what we’ve been thinking during the day. So does that change the emphasis of the subtle mind in the dream state because we can’t access the subtle mind? Indeed, that is the case. What happens is that, whatever we have done during the day, causes imprints to be deposited within the mind stream, and these imprints mature in the dream state.

They manifest. So it’s fairly self evident. To dream, we must sleep. Then to to dream, we must initially enter the state of deep sleep. When we enter the state of deep sleep, all of our ordinary consciousnesses, the sensory consciousness, and so forth cease.

Something else is manifesting. This is something you should be able to figure out by yourselves. So you can see that when you go to sleep at or try to go to sleep at 11:30 or 12:00, whatever time it might be, if you are unable to put an end to conceptual discursiveness, thinking what you will do tomorrow and so forth, it is impossible for you to go to sleep. Therefore, it is impossible for you to dream. Okay.

Now once we have been able to identify what this subtle mind is, we understand that it is this which transmigrates, which reincarnates. And this is how one establishes the existence of past and future lives based on reasoning, not based on faith or naive conviction. Then it is in dependence on this that one understands the benefits of dharma. There is a benefit of dharma in this life because our mind will be at peace, and there is also a benefit of dharma in future lives because we will experience peace and happiness in future lives. That’s how it is.

And then please take good care of your health. If you take good care of your health, then you can hope to die a quiet, peaceful life as if you to to have a peaceful death as if you were falling asleep. Then otherwise, if you haven’t taken good care of your health, you will experience physical and mental suffering. So take care of your physical and mental health. Mental health is taken care of by practice.

Then let us at present generate the motivation for these teachings and meditate on altruism and benefiting other others, not some grandiose extravagant vision of altruism focused on people we have never met, but instead a practical vision of altruism focused on this community. That is the way to proceed. Please open the prayer book, Page one. We recite one b, two, three and four. Page five, number six, mandala offering verse one and three.

So Asanga gives remarkable advice in his Abhidharma Samuchaya on health. And actually, are numerous instructions on health in the Buddhist sutras and treatises. Asaṇga, in particular, recommends measure in eating and the restraint of the sense doors not to watch and listen to just anything. And, actually, there are specific instructions for novices, and for that matter, for fully ordained monks to abstain from food in the evening. And indeed, if we eat too much, specifically if we eat in the evening, we risk to become overweight.

Then obviously, this doesn’t apply to people who engage in heavy physical work. Mhmm. Obviously, in Australia, be careful when you drive because all it takes is one car accident. Right? Then, obviously, in the summer, you’d like to swim in the ocean.

Right? And the ocean are filled with fish who wish you no good, such as sharks. All it takes is one. And in our cases, as human beings, we must rely on this coarse body. And, as a result, we must be careful and, take care of these bodies.

And later on, when we gain realizations and experience, we will need to rely less on the body. Then even if, we experience no particular suffering from lacking appropriate food, a housing, clothing and so forth, nonetheless, we do experience in this society mental suffering. The cause of mental suffering is what we call the afflictions. Afflictions such as desire, such as anger, such as jealousy or bitterness. Then the root of these afflictions, the cause of conditions out of which they arise is what we call the ignorance grasping at a self, which is present at present within our mind stream.

This is what we must target. What counters this ignorance? The wisdom realizing selflessness or emptiness. Then, that we do not have at present within our mind stream. Then as is said, take revenge on the one guilty for everything.

The one guilty for guilty for everything is this ignorance grasping at a self within our mind stream. Then you might wonder why precisely is this ignorance grasping at a self of persons or this ignorance grasping at an I, the root of affliction such as desire, anger, and so forth. It is a case because this ignorance is a mistaken mind. It is a mistaken mind because it apprehends its object in a mistaken way. Its way of thinking is wrong.

And as a result, everything which derives from it is wrong. If the cause is mistaken, then the results are mistaken as well, aren’t they? Then, please, listen carefully. Pay heed. Don’t be akin to the upside down vase.

Then Geshe la will know from your questions whether you’re a right side up or upside down vase. Then, in this context, Geshe-la knows by your questions and your behavior whether the three fourths of the vase are present or not. If you don’t have a clue what is being talked about, then you are upside down vases. If you ask questions today and a couple days later, you ask exactly the same question, then you are a pierced vase. You have forgotten everything.

And as to the final thought, a soiled vase, that refers to the motivation, then that is something Geshe la cannot discern easily. Then motivations are not things which can be seen or heard. So when we say to someone, please generate a good motivation, it’s up to them to do it. We have no way of knowing. So, what precisely is this ignorance grasping at a self of persons within our mind stream?

As Geshe la explained, previously, we have a coarse, apprehension of the self of persons, which is an apprehension of the person as permanent, one, and independent. And we have a subtle apprehension of the self of persons, which is the apprehension of persons as a substantially existed autonomous entity. Now in the case of the coarse selflessness of persons, persons being apprehended as permanent one and independent, since this is something which is not a priori present within our mind stream, it is difficult to understand. We must rely on pre cases to understand it. On the other hand, these subtle selflessness of persons, persons being apprehended as substantially existent autonomous entities is innately present within our mind stream.

Therefore, when we study treatises on the topic, we can link this with our own experience. So this apprehension of the person as autonomous is a mistaken apprehension. Then how precisely does this occur? When we check within ourselves, we can see when we say I that there is a sense deep within ourselves of something. Then, Christian, I would like to ask you, this I which we experience, all of us, from the moment we rise

In the morning. Where do you feel deep down it is? Where? Did you say where? Where?.

Uh-huh. Yes. These short questions. Mhmm. We seem to have to repeat this all the time.

Wherever the strongest mental or physical sensation is? That’s where my I seems to be. I did an experiment. I started tapping on my head and went down until I felt like the sensation was below me versus when it felt above me and there was a sensation that was directly between my ears and just behind my eyes and that was where a physical sense of myself was. But if something suddenly happens in the traffic, then there’s a very strong sense in my chest.

So it does change. Sometimes it feels like it’s in my around my brain, and other times it feels like it’s around my heart or the like, my emotional self. Same as Natalie, usually connected with thinking and feeling or sensation. When powerful emotions arise in the heart, is that what you’re saying? Okay.

Does this is it on? We’re done. In my middle. Like And then there’s more. Sorry.

I didn’t mean to interrupt you. It’s survival. I think you have to have I do understand that the I is about the ego and that we have to kind of drop that. But I do think you need something to survive. Does that make sense?

Okay. Another? It’s very similar to what others have said. By feeling a very strong positive emotion, I feel the I is in my heart. Other than that, it’s residing in my brain.

That’s where I think it is. Everyone’s basically said the same thing. And it is precisely based on what you have all said that these schools of tenants from Svatāntrika Madhyamaka downwards, we set Satanika Madhyamaka aside, all state that this instance of the eye is either the mental consciousness or for Chitamatra, the ālāyavijñāna. So it is precisely for this reason that all of these schools assert the eye independence on on an innate mind. Some of you located it in the brain, some in the heart.

And most of you have actually said that when you try to identify deep down where this feeling or this sensation of an eye is, you find it in the heart. What does this ignorance apprehending a self or an eye observe? It observes the eye. How does it see it? It sees it as within the person, within its constituents.

So some of you said, let’s set aside the issue of the ignorance grasping at self for the timing. Some of you said that when they try to locate this sense of I, sometimes it was in the head, sometimes in the heart. Vishal, I would like to ask you, is this a mistaken or an unmistaken consciousness? Appreciate it. Well, because the head and the heart are material form, so that if the eye was located in the the head or the heart, then the eye would be material also.

I’m not sure. I’m not completely decided, but I think it might be unmistaken with regards to its appearing object. Okay. I’d say mistaken because if it resided in the head and the heart, that would mean there’d be two I’s. So obviously, it would be the case if they were simultaneous, but they’re not simultaneous.

Right? I would say mistaken because, when you identify it in the head or in the heart and you actually look for it, it it disappears. It’s unfindable. So we will proceed therefore in this fashion. From your side, think about the mode of abiding of the eye.

Think about the mode of existence of the eye, and Geshe-la will develop these topics later on. Mhmm. Then if you have questions, Geshe-la will take your questions. Please, short questions. So my question really has two parts.

I need an answer to the first part before I can proceed to the second part, which is the first part is one can be reborn as a cat or a dog, but can one be reborn as a plant? Well, that’s why I have trouble accepting that living beings and conscious beings are synonymous because you can be reborn as a cat or a dog, but you cannot be reborn as a plant. So as Geshe la explained, there is a difference between the Buddhist understanding of life and the scientific understanding of life. The Buddhist understanding of life is that life is linked to the subtle winds, and this is why Geshe la defined living beings as beings which engage in the activities of movement with respect to the object they wish for. Then in Abhidharma, life is equated with maturation, the maturation of virtue or non virtue, for instance.

Okay. Geshe la, I have a curiosity about the plants in my garden. Have plants that are vine that are growing into neighboring plants of a different species, and I’ve persistently cut them back. And they’re now no longer doing that. They’re growing in the opposite direction.

So? So how how is that explained if if it’s not a living creature that it’s it’s growing into the other plants, and now it’s not after me persistently cutting off its little pieces whether it’s grown into the plant next door. It’s now growing in the opposite direction away from the plants that I’ve trained it not to grow into. It used to be left wing, now the right wing. Right?

Okay. Don’t worry about it. Plants and trees are not living beings from the Buddhist sense. They’re not sentient beings. So if you believe that, plants are living beings and sentient beings, do you think that you incur a sin when you cut them?

Okay. So Geshe la says, obviously, if you consider plants as living being, if he were to consider plants as a living being, he could not cut it. Okay. Of attachment with desire. When you were speaking about the distinction between desire and a wish, I’m thinking desire involves attachment like the example of the too much desire for or love that turned into desire for your child and and wish does not involve attachment.

But perhaps that’s too simple to think of desire as with attachment and a wish is not with attachment. Could you explain more about how attachment relates to desire?

Attachment So part of the problem is using a term which is attachment, which is used synonymously for desire in Tibetan. Attachment and desire are both used to translate. Both are afflictions. Just like to ask, especially, the subtle mind that is working in the dream state. And is it the subtle mind appear before the deep sleep or after the deep sleep?

It appears after deep sleep. After deep sleep. This is about plants again. Sorry. Do you Geshe la, do you assert that Buddha did not teach in the Jātaka tales that he was born in as a plant in previous lives?

And do you also assert that he didn’t that Buddha did not teach that devas can be reborn Who? In plants. Buddha. But taught what? Devas gods.

Yeah. So yeah. Numerous passages like that, this does not mean that the Buddha was reborn as a flower, for instance. What it means is that he manifested a flower. I’m trying to distinguish between living things, once again plants and human beings.

The way I can make sense of it is that a plant cannot create karma or, create virtue or nonvirtue. Would that make sense? Yes. Indeed. For that matter, if plants were living beings, if they were sentient beings, then when we cut them, we would incur, from a Buddhist perspective, the non virtue of killing a living being.

I’m just thinking about the difference between the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons. And Geshe la was saying that with the coarse sense of self, that is something that we realize through study rather than something that’s obvious to us. Yet in terms of my own experience, if somebody insults me or get upset, I have a strong sense of this sense of self as existing independently and separate from my aggregate. It’s something there. And so I take that as to be the object to be negated.

But, you know, in terms of trying to think about or to capture where that exists and Geshe-la was saying that with a subtle sense of person, that’s that’s sort of an all pervasive feeling when I get up in the morning, you know, I’m gonna have a drink. Chris, this is a speech. It’s so Sorry. Okay. So so I guess it’s like it seems that the core selflessness of person is something that is obvious when, you know, I’m insulted or or have a shock.

And yet the subtle one is, by definition, would seem to be harder to to locate. Are you saying that, the three characteristics of the coarse self of persons, the person being permanent, one, and independent, arise together in your mind when someone offends you? Because that view of the person is a view of the Sankhya’s propounding existence of 25 objects of knowledge. Do all three arise? Well, I just have an experience of something that seems to be existing independently as separate from the aggregates?

Yeah. That different areas. But that is not the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent. That exists with an audience. So, indeed, when someone insults or offends you, the sense of an I which is separate from the eyes of its exist it existed or appears.

It exists in all our continuum. However, Geshe-la would be surprised if a sense of this I being permanent one and independent appeared at that moment to you. Yes. Maybe not permanent and one, but certainly independent. It definitely appears as independent.

So Geshe-la will explain these topics gradually, and, he will do so so that we can ask questions. In this way, we have a good hope to understand. Otherwise, if everything is explained suddenly, we risk not to understand what is being explained. If I can just add, that’s where the word course fits in my mind, you know, as a coarse as in an obvious appearance of a strong sense of I rather than in a philosophical sense. Yes.

That element of the coarse self self of persons exists within the continuum of beings whose minds are not contaminated by tenets, the independence. Lily? Okay. Just you, please. So my question is about causation within the Sankhya philosophy.

And I personally believe that there can be beginningless time and that there can be an infinity in the past and in the future. That’s not a problem for me, so I’ve never really had to address this argument. But it seems that there’s heaps and heaps of people who think that an infinite regress of causation is just completely illogical. And maybe, Ilya, you know the Kalam reasoning of for do you know that, Ilya? The the the Kalam syllogism for the universe.

So the universe has a cause. It must have a cause. Therefore, it has one cause, basically. Yeah. Yeah.

So what is the what’s an elegant way of refuting this belief that they’re that it’s completely logical that there cannot be an infinite regression of causes. So, actually, in Buddhist texts, one does refer to time, but one does refer to impermanent phenomena. In general, impermanent phenomena have no beginning. However, if one gives an instance, for instance, a table, then one can definitely say the table has an end. When I put the table in the fire, it is the end of the table.

But there is no beginning for the table if we try to trace the table back in time. Okay. Thank you. Please open the page nine, eight b, Mandala offering. Then you’re done.

You’re done. Announcement. It’s nearly June, and our retreat ten day retreat in October. If you would like to early bird, you know, it’s the end of the June. It’s the early bird time, so maybe you can book and pay.

And other things like Champa Rinpoche’s visit will be here in July 1415. If you would like to to attend the course, please book now. And yeah. And his holiness birthday is coming in July 6. We’re going to hell here Guru Puja in the evening, Friday.

And, also, the Tibetan community in South Australia requests support, and they’re going to help his son’s birthday celebration on the sixth, which is a Saturday. And so if you would like to go seventh. Sorry. Saturday, seventh. So you would like to go, please consider.

And there is a number here. You can take a book either that or book it here in TBI. Alright? Thank you very much.

Key terms in this teaching

Guru Puja Lama Chöpa (Tib)
A special Highest Yoga Tantra guru yoga practice composed by the fourth Panchen Lama, Losang Chökyi Gyaltsen. LYWA
Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
mind basis of all alayavijana (Skt); kun zhi nam shä (Tib)
A main consciousness posited by the Cittamatra school, the consciousness they say is needed to carry karmic imprints. LYWA
selflessness of person gang zag gi dag me (Tib)
According to the Prasangika Madhyamaka school, the most subtle view of selflessness of person is the lack of inherent existence of the person or self. LYWA
sentient being sem chen (Tib)
Any being who has not abandoned the two obscurations. LYWA
Svatantrika Madhyamaka u ma rang gyü pa (Tib)
The Middle Way Autonomy school, a sub-school of the Middle Way school of Buddhist philosophy. The Autonomy school accepts autonomous reasons and does not assert true establishment even conventionally. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top