Buddha House Adelaide
Audio recorded at Buddha House Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 05 2004 02 12 OCR.mp3
UUID: 907eeb95-d3fb-4bbb-92b9-3944cc7d2b79
Teacher: Geshe Pema Tsering
Collection: Ornament for Clear Realisations (Geshe Pema Tsering)
Date: 2004-02-12
Recorded at: Buddha House Adelaide
Duration: 45 min
Words: 3,618
And so in the Guide to the Bodhisattva’s Way of Life, Śāntideva said, no being wishes to experience suffering or abide in suffering, but they but we all chase after its causes or we all create its causes. And what this means is that although most of our thoughts are ways to avoid suffering, because we don’t know the way to avoid suffering, what causes suffering and what we need to do to abandon suffering and its causes, then everything we do or most of the thoughts we have are actually causes for suffering. So even though we don’t wanna experience suffering, because it’s so easy for us to create the causes for suffering, and because actually creating the causes for suffering is something we mostly consider a good thing or we consider that to be what we consider happiness or what we need to strive after to feel happy. And also because we are very strongly habituated towards striving for the causes of suffering. So, we’re very strongly, because of these strong habits, it’s very easy for us to create the causes for suffering.
It’s very easy for us to do negative things that are creating the cause of suffering. To do something positive on the other hand is very difficult. It’s something that we have to work hard at. And if we really want to work hard at it, it takes years before it becomes easy for us to try and develop positive causes. And Geshe-la said that, like, at least that’s from his perspective, the way it looks that it’s easy to do negative things and it’s hard work to do positive things.
So what’s happening is that although we want to experience happiness, we don’t know what the causes for happiness are, and we think that the causes for suffering are the causes for happiness. So we’re actually trying to experience happiness, but instead we’re striving in in striving what for what we perceive is the way to achieve happiness, we’re actually creating the causes for suffering. And through creating through doing negative things, create the cause for suffering, and then we have to experience the suffering. So none of us actually want to experience suffering, but because we have made this mistake, we then think that what what it is that we’re doing is going to create happiness for us, but instead, it’s creating suffering. In order for us to achieve this mind that is actually striving for the causes of true happiness as opposed to the causes of suffering that we perceive to be happiness, then we need to do a lot of mind training.
We need to train our mind to look at things differently to the way that they are, and we need to do this for many years until we start perceiving things in this way. Now the reason that it is so hard for us to do truly positive things and to not do negative things is because we don’t actually believe in cause and effect properly. We have we may have a vague idea of it, but we don’t believe in it strong enough to stop us doing negative things. We don’t perceive that the negative results of of a negative cause are actually going to be suffering. We don’t perceive that strongly enough in order to stop us doing it.
And if we don’t believe in cause and effect strongly enough, then we’ve got nothing to stop us from doing negative things. So what we need to do is to keep meditating and keep thinking about the cause cause and effect until we develop a belief in it or we analyze and see that it’s true, and that can stop us from if we believe in it strong enough, we can stop doing negative things. We’re a little bit like a moths or other types of bugs that get attracted to light and actually can end up dying from the from the flame by flying into it because they’ve become attracted to the light. We’re a bit like that. We keep seeing something that we’re attracted to and we don’t realize that we get attached to something or desire for something.
And we go after it even though we don’t realize that it could create us, that it will create us suffering. It’s the same way that when moths or other bugs fly into the light, they can bang themselves into it and they’re not thinking, they’re not going, oh, if I hit that with my head, it’s gonna hurt. They’re thinking there’s light and I’m attracted to the light and that’s all they’re thinking about. Or they’re attracted to a flame and they can fly right into it and burn themselves or hit their head on a light, whatever it is. And there’s suffering there from that action because they weren’t thinking about this could cause suffering while they’re flying at the light.
They’re just so attached to the light that they don’t think of anything else. There’s another example that’s given in the graduated path teachings. Graduated path teachings is that we’re like elephants who see really sweet grass or really grass that they’re really attracted to on the edge of a cliff. And they don’t think about the consequences of standing that close to the edge of a cliff that’s made from dirt when you’re a very heavy animal. And they just go out to eat the grass and the cliff caves away and they fall down and die, yeah, from the length of the fall.
So they’re not thinking about the fact that there’s a cliff there or what’s gonna happen if they fall. They’re just focused fully on the grass that they’re really attached to or really desirous to eat. And they’re not thinking about anything else. And through that, they can die because they’re not thinking about anything else but the thing they’re desirous of. And we’re the same with our attachment to saṃsāra pleasures or things that we construe as happy or pleasant, but aren’t actually by their nature like that.
They’re very temporary. And we chase after them and we don’t think about the consequences, which are going to be future sufferings when we do negative things in order to get those. And so we’re just like the elephant running to the edge of the cliff to eat the grass. We don’t think about things, and so we don’t see their faults. So it’s, for example, the same way that we try and we strive after things that we consider are going to give us happiness in this lifetime and think of them as being something that’s gonna give us real happiness when it’s truly not happiness and it’s not happiness by its nature and it’s going to turn to suffering.
So we strive after these things and in order to get these things we do all sorts of negative things. We may have intense desire or get angry about it, all these negative things in order to get something that we think is gonna make us happy. And in this process, all we’re doing is creating many, many causes or many, many different types of throwing karma or karma that’s gonna throw us into another sense our existence where we’re going to experience more suffering. So we have, we create all this negative karma through all this negative throwing karma and therefore have to experience more lifetimes in saṃsāra and more suffering because we’re mistaken about we we don’t focus on the shortcomings of the things that we are desperately think that we need to acquire or achieve. Mhmm.
Mhmm. So the thing is then that we don’t really know what true happiness is, and this is our problem. We think that the temporary happiness of saṃsāra are true happiness, and we don’t truly understand or we don’t have a a belief in the true happiness or the real happiness of nirvana or Buddhahood. So nirvana or Buddhahood aren’t something that we focus on or understand the happiness of because we’re too caught up in this idea of samsaric happiness or the happiness and the temporary happiness that we think is true happiness. And the reason for this is because we don’t have this strong enough belief in the true happiness of nirvana.
So what we need to cultivate is that understanding, is that belief. And if we don’t work at that, if we don’t concentrate on developing that understanding, then through lots of study and hard work, then what happens is that it’s really easy for us to become to do negative things. That’s something that comes so easy to us. And when we have to do something positive, when we have to do a virtuous action, it’s really hard work. It really feels like hard work.
Oh, no. I have to do something virtuous. And so and then to sustain that is very difficult, but then instantly, we get to do something unvirtuous. It’s easy. And it’s and we think it’s So once we develop understanding about what it truly means to have achieved nirvana or to have achieved Buddhahood, once we develop a strong understanding of that, then we are not going to want to do anything else but work towards that.
That’s going to be our sole focus. And we’re not going to develop attachment or attraction to anything that isn’t that because we’ll understand that that’s not going to help us and it’s not gonna truly make us happy or it’s not a happiness we can rely on. And therefore, once we’ve developed that understanding, then we will strive towards nirvana or Buddhahood with all our effort. And because of this, then we will achieve it. Once we’ve established this understanding through our study and contemplation.
And so this is why we’re doing this. This is why we’re bothering to do this study. So we can develop an understanding that’s gonna make us strive towards true happiness, the true happiness of liberation or the true happiness of Buddhahood. And it’s because it’s only after having achieved this that we will experience true happiness and not temporary fleeting happiness. So this this is why we’re studying.
So we should think, okay, this is why I need to know this so I can develop true happiness and not just for myself, but for all sentient beings who all want to be happy. May I achieve Buddhahood by by studying these texts. So we should meditate on that idea or contemplate that idea for a few minutes. Scared you by ringing the bell. Don’t think that was the idea.
Yeah. But, anyway Right. Okay. Okay. So we’re going through the subject aspects of the antidote class, and we were up to the subject of antidotes subject aspects of the antidote class that are aspects of neural paths.
Yeah? And we were going through the eight aspects of true origins within that section. Okay? Still with me? And the seventh of these is said to be the non existence of the referent object of the afflictive emotions of improper mental engagement.
Okay, so this is referring to the third aspect of you know, there’s the sixteen aspects of the four noble truths, right? The third aspect of the truth of the origin of suffering is said to be strong production. Now what that’s referring to is when is the gross production of afflictive emotions. Yeah? So that is when afflictive emotions are really strong in the mind when they produce really strongly and cause a causes negative actions.
Now, in the mind of an arhat, a foe destroyer, someone who has completely gotten rid of negative emotions. So in this case, a bodhisattva arhat, yeah, so someone who’s a bodhisattva and an arhat who has completely gotten rid of negative emotions and still has the knower of paths, which is in the bodhisattva’s continuum. Okay. Now for these people, they not only perceive the lack of negative emotions because they’ve been abandoned, but they also understand the non-inherent existence, the lack of inherent existence, of afflictive emotions. Okay?
The non-inherent existence of the lack of afflictive emotions. Get that? That’s what this is referring to. Number seven. And you guys have got in your notes that says a definition of improper mental engagement.
And so is a mental engagement that does not accord with the mode of an existence of an object. This is another way of saying mental, of of saying afflictive emotions because then they they’ve got no basis in reality. So the next one it says, the exalted wisdom of both sides for those related to the aspect of causal condition or just the causes. Alright? And it says directly realizing the nonexistence of an independent sentient being.
So what this is referring to is that when we’re focusing on conditions then we realize that sentient beings come into existence because of causes and conditions. There’s no inherent sub, there’s no inherent being there. They are labeled, a collection of causes and conditions brings a being into relative existence. But when meditating on this, the bodhisattva understands that this is not an inherently existent being or a truly existent being and sees the lack of that truly existent form. So that’s what the the the aspect is referring to here.
Okay. So with this number eight, nonexistence of a truly existent sentient being, the realization of that nonexistence is what’s called a truth of the path. It’s a true path. It’s a true realization. Now that’s the last of the eight aspects of the truth of the origin of suffering within the aspects of the knower of paths.
Then we’re on to the seven aspects of true paths, which is divided into the four generally referred to aspects of the truth of the path that is the path, suitability, achieving, and deliverer. Now the first of these are path. And the first, there’s two here. The first of which is the fact that in short form, it says it is the lack of immeasurability.
Right? And now what this is referring to is that one of the things that bodhisattvas meditate on is this idea of the immeasurables, immeasurable sentient beings, immeasurable compassion, and so forth. But they all might also must realize that that meditation on the immeasurables is not inherently existent. Yeah? So the aspect of the non inherent existence of the meditation on the immeasurables is this aspect.
So it’s a whole bunch of stuff that’s not inherently existence. It’s got different ways. It’s just different thing. Oh, okay. So this immeasurability is referring to many, many different things.
So you can have the immeasurability of sentient beings, you can have the immeasurability of compassion, you can have the immeasurability of time, the immeasurability of perceptions. And so therefore immeasurable and the emptiness of those understandings of immeasurability refers is the number nine, the first of the paths aspects. The second one, it says, it opens the opportunity for liberation to all sentient beings by not being based on the two extremes cyclic existence in nirvana. In the text it actually says just two extremes, yeah. And so there can be many different things.
You can have absence of two extremes of existence and nirvana but you could also have the absence of the two extremes of existence and non existence. So, So for starters when we think about a non inherently existent objects then we get rid of the by thinking by focusing on the fact that they’re not inherently existent then we get rid of the extreme of existence yeah and then by from there we may go into the extreme of okay if they’re not inherently existent then that means that they’re not there at all but then we establish that they are they’re based on causes and conditions just not inherently existent and in this way we say they’re not existent and they’re not non existent and the path between these two things is the middle way or the middle perspective for looking at things. So that middle perspective of looking at things is another way of saying emptiness. So the mind that realizes this middle perspective, which is emptiness, realizes this emptiness in the continuum of an ārya bodhisattva, and that ārya bodhisattva is the subject aspect of the antidote class focused on the lack of the two extremes.
Now the next one that’s the within the subset of suitability. Yeah? So that’s one of the aspects of the truth of the path. Number two is suitability. That has two different aspects to it.
The first one is saying that it’s has this aspect of not being different in being empty of true existence. And what this is referring to is the fact that in general, if we said we in general we would say that ultimate phenomena or also the ultimate truth and relative truth are different. One they’re different in terms of being different perceptions of things a different way of looking at it. But in actual fact, from the perspective of emptiness, in that they are both empty of true existence, then we say that ultimate truth and relative truth are the same and not or not different. Okay.
Alright. Sorry. Was just sorting that out because what Geshe was saying didn’t quite link up to what the notes say. So I was trying to figure out a way of Okay. Because he say he says that this is we’re talking about that this text is based on the perfection of wisdom yeah so all of these minds are comprehensions of the perfection of emptiness from different perspectives yeah and in this they said it’s a realisation for freedom from our elaborations without holding the hearers and solitary realizers paths to be supreme.
And he says it’s the realisation that although you hold all of the paths to be supreme and you hold Buddhahood to be the supreme realisation and so forth, you realize that that holding them to be supreme is not inherently existent, which is a bit different to this. All of the is it all of it refers to a different way of looking at emptiness? Because he reckons that these notes, whoever made these notes up, doesn’t quite fit with that because this is talking about the truth of the path and the truth of the path refers to realisations of emptiness. And so all of these have to be related to emptiness. So if they’re talking about the hearers and solitary realizers paths not being supreme, then that’s not a realisation of emptiness.
The emptiness of the non-inherent existence of the realisation — that is, that the hearers’ paths and solitary realizers’ paths are not supreme — is one thing, but saying that that’s the realisation and that’s what they’re referring to by “not being supreme” doesn’t make sense. And that’s the translation they’ve got: “realises that without holding the hearers and solitary realizers paths to be supreme.” Okay. Okay. So in this one, you get the first of the achieving aspects, which is okay.
That’s not going to fit either. Okay. Okay. The Mahāyāna path of seeing has the aspect of an achieving due to directly realizing all phenomena as non truly existent and not conceiving. It looks like you’re concentrating seriously, if you sit like this.
Okay, so the Mahāyāna path of seeing that has the aspect of an achieving due to directly realizing all phenomena as non truly existent and not conceiving them to be truly existent, right? Now, when it says not conceiving, it’s like it’s in a non conceptual understanding of emptiness. Yeah? A non conceptual understanding of emptiness is another way of saying another way of saying wisdom understanding emptiness, Right? But in this instance, the wisdom understanding emptiness is the object of meditation.
Right? And so wisdom of wisdom of understanding emptiness is a mind. Yeah? So it’s then figuring out that that mind itself is also not inherently existent. So it’s a wisdom that understands that the mind realizing non conceptually non inherent existence without any conceptual reality that mind itself is not in is not inherently existent.
Did you get that? Hey. No? Yeah. Oh, yeah.
But it’s Okay. So these are notes, right, that a guy who was doing the course in Pomaia made up. It’s not a direct translation of the text, the ones that you’ve in front of you. Yeah? So sometimes he’s picked up on one thing.
That’s an explanation, and then there’s different so so it doesn’t always fit with what’s here. And I keep plugging at it, don’t I? Okay. So it’s like that they they’re talking about the the thing that’s being focused on when in actual fact because this is referring to the the truth of the path then every mind that you talk about in a truth of the path is a mind understanding emptiness. Right?
So it’s a mind understanding the emptiness of whatever it is it’s been focused on And they’re only mentioning here the things that are being focused on. So, you have to take it that one step further and go, okay, there’s a things that are being focused on, then there’s a mind realizing the emptiness of the thing that’s being focused on and that mind itself as well is empty. Okay. Because when we are talking about the subject aspects of the antidote class with reference to the knower of bases, yeah, then we’re talking about the mind realizing the selflessness of objects.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- graduated path lamrim (Tib)
- A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. The lamrim was first formulated by the great Indian teacher Atisha when he came to Tibet in 1042. LYWA
- right-seeing path darshana-marga (Skt); tong lam (Tib)
- The third of the five paths to buddhahood; attained with the direct perception of emptiness. Also called the path of seeing. LYWA
- throwing karma phen jä kyi lä (Tib)
- Also called projecting karma, the karmic imprint that ripens at the time of death to propel us into the next rebirth. LYWA
- true existence den par yö pa (Tib)
- The concrete, real existence from its own side that everything appears to possess; in fact, both self and phenomena are empty of true existence. LYWA
- two extremes tha nyi (Tib)
- Eternalism, seeing things as having an intrinsic reality, and nihilism, seeing things as having no reality at all. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.