1 h 29 min · 4,168 words · 11 May 2016
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim teaching on the three scopes of the path, reviewing the object of attainment, means, object of abandonment and object of meditation for each scope. It explains that bodhichitta, generated by extending definite emergence to all beings, is the main cause of full enlightenment, and teaches generating impartial empathy through the interchange of self and others. Student questions on organ donation, emptiness and Buddhist specificity are also addressed.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 29m
UUID: 5809f8f0-672e-4e72-8c08-cb53ad4e7956
Date: 2016-05-11
Words: 4,164
As is said, Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path albeit upheld by definite emergence should it not be upheld by bodhichitta, it will not become a cause for full enlightenment. The meaning of this stanza is very profound. The term albeit upheld by definite emergence implies that the mind of definite emergence has been generated. In other words, the striving for liberation has been generated but even though this has been generated without bodhichitta, it is insufficient to lead to full enlightenment. And therefore once one has generated definite emergence reflecting on the sufferings of cyclic existence, On this basis one must generate bodhichitta.
bodhichitta is therefore generated through extending definite emergence to all beings and thereby generating compassion. It is not the case that one when one trains in the great vehicle turns away from the practice of the being or the practice shared with the being of the middling scope. Instead, the practice shared with the being of the middling scope serves as foundation for the practice of the great vehicle. So when we reflect on this stanza of the three principles of the path in the context of our study of the path of the being of the great scope, we have to ask ourselves what is the object of attainment of the being of the great scope? What are the means to attain that object of attainment?
What is the object of abandonment or the obstacles if you prefer? And what are the objects of meditation? It is these four objects we have to identify. And therefore, I would like to ask you individually, what is the object of attainment of the path of the being of the great scope? Quick, quick, quick.
What’s the means? Principally bodhichitta but actually the inseparable union of method and wisdom, of method and wisdom. And therefore the principal cause for full enlightenment is bodhichitta but bodhichitta alone is not sufficient. It must be conjoined with a subsidiary helper which is wisdom. Wisdom alone is insufficient since independence on wisdom alone one can attain the states of a hearer or a solitary realizer.
Thank you so very much. Thank you very much. You gave precisely the object of attainment and the means. What’s the object of abandonment? Yes, indeed, self cherishing or egoism.
Then since the precise opposite of self cherishing or egoism is cherishing others or altruism and altruism is connected to bodhichitta, then bodhichitta indeed is the means for attaining full enlightenment. That’s very good. That’s precisely it. You’ve trained well in the long run. Alternatively, you can also see the object of abandonment of the great vehicle are the obstructions to omniscience, Jnanaavarana, which is an extension of the obstructions to afflictions, Kleśavarana.
Then indeed, the object of abandonment is either self cherishing or the obstructions to omniscience. What is the object of meditation? So the sevenfold causal instruction is actually a means for generating bodhichitta but here what I would like is the object of meditation. So the object of attainment is full enlightenment. The means is bodhichitta.
The object of abandonment as we said is self cherishing or the obstruction is permission, omniscience. What is the object of meditation? What do we familiarize the mind with? But emptiness, right? The nature of phenomena is emptiness.
So the object of meditation is emptiness or the selflessness of phenomena. As I said in the three principles of the path, if one is not endowed with an understanding of the mode of abiding of phenomena, albeit having realized a definite emergence in bodhichitta, one will be unable to sever the root of existence, therefore strive at realizing interdependence, emptiness. Then unfortunately, you didn’t get top grades for the object of meditation, all of you, sorry. Then apart from the object of meditation which is emptiness, you got a 100%. So the object of meditation is therefore emptiness or if you prefer the selflessness of phenomena.
Now, answer clearly, no blah blah. What is the object of attainment of the path shared with the being of the middling scope? The means to attain liberation. That’s the object of meditation. The means.
So the object of attainment of the path shared with the being of the middling scope is liberation. The means, the means is the direct realization of emptiness. What’s the object of abandonment? Then you can either say that the noble truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering are the objects of abandonment or that cyclic existence is the object of abandonment or that the afflictions are the object of abandonment. All of those are appropriate.
No difference. But self cherishing would not be an appropriate object of abandonment since if it were then hearer and solitary realizer arhats would have abandoned self cherishing and self cherishing is obviously the object of abandonment of the being of the great scope. Do you understand? If you can keep this in your mind, it’s very good. So we’ve covered the object of attainment, the means, and the object of abandonment of the path of the being of the middling scope.
What’s the object of meditation? Middling scope. You can either give the full noble truths or you can give the selflessness of persons or you can give emptiness. Because if you meditate on the four noble truths, you must meditate on the selflessness of persons. If you meditate on the selflessness of persons, you must meditate on emptiness.
Now what’s the objective attainment of the path of the being of the small scope? The means of that objective attainment. Apart from that, what would be the other ones? You have to speak up because I can’t hear. So the object of attainment of the path of the being of the small scope is a higher rebirth.
The means to attain this is generally given as an ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues. You can also say training in virtue and abandoning non virtue. What’s the object of abandonment? Yes, you can say the non-virtues of this life or you could say the 10 non-virtues. 10 What’s the object of meditation?
Yes, it is the object of meditation of the path of the being of the small scope but it is also of great importance in the path of the being of the middling and the great scope. So you have answered clearly to my question regarding the object of attainment of the path of the being of the small scope, but there was a fair bit of waffling regarding the means to attain this. So what are the means? Small scope. The ethics which is an abandonment of the 10 non-virtues.
Do you understand? So what is the object of abandonment of the being of the middling scope? Then this is something you should try to generate an ascertainment of within your minds and if when you rise in the morning during a couple of minutes, you are able to go over the object of attainment, the means, the object of abandonment and the object of meditation of each of the paths of the beings of the three scopes, this would be of great benefit. So all the mode of study of secular studies, let’s say as university and of Buddhist studies is basically identical. How one proceeds after the studies is very different.
When you study let’s say at university, once you have finished studying the topics of one year, you move on to the topics of the next year and you basically do not return to the topics of the first year. You have probably no use for them. However, with Buddhist studies, if you do this, risk to forget the material and therefore you must constantly reappropriate the material which is being studied. So it’s different. So, we must therefore generate a pure thought of definite emergence within our mind stream and obviously if laziness is present within our mind stream then we will not be able to do so.
So we must discard laziness. So at this point, once one has generated within one’s mind stream a thought of definite emergence, one must put effort to generate the mind of the great vehicle or bodhichitta since this is the main focus of the Lamrim. Can we generate bodhichitta by means of ethics which protects one against the 10 non virtues with the numerous vows we have? No. bodhichitta is created through an inner transformation of the mind.
So to generate this bodhichitta which is focused upon all beings, we must generate, to generate such an uncontrived fully characterized bodhichitta an empathy, which to the difference of our present empathy is an impartial, unbiased empathy extended towards all beings. Then we can check for ourselves whether we have such an unbiased impartial empathy within our mind stream or not at present. So what are the reasons for which we are at present unable to generate such an unbiased empathy? The first reason is that we cherish ourselves and we discard others. The second reason which is found in the Lamrim is that we are unable to bear the decline of the Mahāyāna teachings.
Then it is said in the Lamrim that all living beings from insects upwards wish for their own happiness and wish to be separated from suffering. However, we ourselves are human beings far superior to insects. Then our goal must be superior to that of mere insects. Our goal must not merely be to free ourselves from suffering and to generate happiness for ourselves, but to free others from suffering and to generate happiness for others. Then this is a difficult way of thinking for us.
Is it? Little bit difficult, isn’t it? Then obviously the concepts of great compassion and bodhichitta are beautiful but it is a very different matter to be able to generate them within our mind stream. This calls for a lot of thought and effort. So what are the means for generating bodhichitta within our mind stream then?
So I’m not asking you for an answer out of the Lamrim or we have to train in the seven foot course of instruction or the equalization and need to change of self and other. I would like your own assessment of the situation based on your own experience. Being so selfish. That’s okay. Then let’s take the case of definite emergence.
To generate a definite emergence, we must first definitely emerge out of something. We must understand the thoughts of that we are wishing to emerge out of and those are the thoughts of psychic existence or if you prefer, the thoughts of the afflictions. Then if we didn’t understand the faults of the afflictions, let us say the afflictions which arise under the sway of anger, then there is no place to begin. We would not even be here. So initially, we must understand that.
Right now, our minds are relaxed and at ease and we can see clearly the defects of anger. We can see clearly the defects of jealousy. We can see clearly the defects of afflicted competitiveness, this mindset which thinks none is equal of me. Do you Do you understand? Understand the thoughts of anger, of jealousy, of competitiveness or not?
Can see the thoughts. Now, all of us therefore understand the thoughts of anger. Now, what exactly is the origin of anger? On the one hand, anger arises from self grasping and self cherishing. On the other hand, anger arises from discarding the welfare of others.
And we can clearly see this within ourselves when the afflictions arise and we say, what do others matter to me? Who are they to me? Now can you see clearly that if one generates altruism and cherishing others, this would counter such a mindset? Can you understand that? That’s our limit.
Then you have the answer of the reason for which we must generate empathy for others. Then we can see from a Buddhist standpoint that our familiarity with self cherishing or egoism is an ancient one. It goes back numerous lives in the past, infinite lives in the past and even in this life from when we were a little child, we were familiar with egoism and self cherishing. Then, if we look at the coarse afflictions under the sway of anger, we can see that there are two ways of analyzing their origin. On the one hand, we can say that they are ultimately to be traced to self grasping.
And therefore, self grasping is the object of abandonment. When we abandon self grasping, we abandon these coarse afflictions and this is the path of the hearers and the solitary realizers, the Shravakas and the Pratyekabuddhas. There’s another way to look at it, which is to say that all of these coarse afflictions, they arise from other persons, from the outside. And therefore, if we are able to eliminate our animosity towards others, egoism and to train an altruism, then this will naturally counter the arising of these afflictions. This is the path of the bodhisattvas.
Do you understand? You understand? Of course. Thank you. So, I’ll start from the beginning.
It’s simpler. It’s simpler. So there are two ways to analyze this. The first is to understand that the root of all of the afflictions, the coarse afflictions is the sway of anger is self grasping. And if self grasping is the object of abandonment, then this is what one must abandon and this is the path followed by the hearers and the solitary realizers, the Shravakas and the Pratyekabuddhas.
There is another path which is to see that all of the afflictions arise from others, from persons who are exterior to us and that they arise from our animosity and our egoism in our relation to these persons. And then to train in altruism which eliminates this animosity and this egoism. This is the path of Bodhisattvas. Then all we can do here is to give instructions on this way of thinking. It is not up to me to tell to you to practice or not, that is entirely up to you, you decide.
But what our task is, is to give instructions on this way of thinking. Then after that, it’s up to you. Now, there are two types of empathy. There is impartial or unbiased empathy which is what we must strive to generate and there is the empathy we experience at present which is biased or partial empathy. This is the empathy or the feeling a mother has for her child, it is the empathy I hear about when you all talk to me about boyfriend girlfriend problems.
It is partial empathy. Now, perhaps all mothers would be ready to die for their child. I do not know whether all children would be ready to die for their mothers. But this dedication of a mother which is ready to die for her child, this is partial empathy. This partial empathy which exists within us must be transformed and extended to all beings.
Then I don’t know for us, our parents are very important in your society. It seems to me that this boyfriend girlfriend business is very important. Perhaps you become very accustomed to this from the age of 15 or 16 onwards. Let us therefore meditate during a couple of minutes on what we talked about that if we are able to extend an impartial empathy to all beings that this will act as a root of altruism and a very powerful force opposing the afflictions. Page five number six number of verse one, edit three.
Thank you. So as said in the Ratnasambhava, the great being asserted that the root of all qualities is bodhichitta. And therefore to generate bodhichitta there are two methods. There is the sevenfold causal instruction and the interchange of self and others. In the interchange of self and others, the root of compassion is none other than the practice of giving and taking or Tonglen.
So regarding the practice of the interchange of self and others, where precisely does it have to be integrated in the sevenfold causal generation of bodhichitta. It comes after one has generated the recognition of all sentient beings as one’s mothers of yore, recollecting their kindness and the wish to repay their kindness. So at this point, one engages in the practice of giving and taking, Tonglen. When one gives, or Tongwa, what does one give? One gives love.
When one takes, what does one take? One takes the suffering of beings, trained in compassion. Now when one refers to the equalization and interchange of self in others, what precisely does this mean? So when one therefore speaks of the equalization and the interchange of others, what precisely is meant by interchanging self and others? As is pointed out in the Lamrim, it is impossible to invert or introvert oneself and another, to become another and for another to become oneself.
What is said in Lam Rim Chenmo is that one interchanges the position of the mind of self cherishing and the mind of cherishing and the mind of discarding others. Now interchanging the position of self cherishing and discarding others is something which is possible. We can change the priorities of how we think. What interchanges the positions? So how precisely does one interchange self cherishing and discarding others?
What one does is that instead of cherishing oneself, one cherishes others. Then instead of discarding others, one discards oneself. Then if I take the example of hero for instance, and I try to generate cherishing for hero within my mind stream, it is not possible to do that without a reason, we need a reason to do that. So let us first take parts of our body such as our hand, then we cherish our hand, don’t we? Naturally.
You cherish, in other words, you like, you feel close to your hand. Why? What is the reason? My hand, my hand is beautiful, I cherish my hand. What is the reason for You can see if you look at your hand, think like that, right?
You cherish your hand, you value your hand, right? You gave the answer? Then that was exactly the answer. Your hand is of benefit to you, it is useful to you. Independence on your hand, you can make your own happiness.
Now the same is true for your leg. We cherish our legs. Why? Because independence on our legs, we can generate our own happiness, can’t we? Then for the same reason, we value this basis of happiness and suffering which we have, which is our body.
We have self cherishing for our body. Now, in the same way as we cherish our hands or our feet because independence on our limbs, we are able to generate our own happiness, to actualize our own happiness, we can see that others are the source of immeasurable, infinite happiness for us in the future and understanding this, it becomes very easy to generate cherishing for others. First, it is obvious in this world of ours that it is independence on others in this world that we are able to live, that we have prosperity. If we were autonomous, we would have no prosperity. We’d be miserable.
And the best way to look at it is to start by understanding why we cherish our limbs, hands and our feet and then extend this to others. So as I mentioned, the training in the equalization of the inter of self and others comes after one has generated the wish to repay the kindness, but the first step in the sevenfold causal generation of bodhichitta is a preliminary generating equanimity which arises when one realizes that all are equal in having equally helped and harmed us. Then I shall stop here and at present if you have questions, I’ll take your questions individually. I just had a question which doesn’t entirely relate to the teaching tonight. Is that okay?
Why not? I just wanted to ask, I understand and agree with liberation for self and all other sentient beings. And I think that that seems like a good thing. But why would I aspire to full enlightenment and Buddhahood? Are we going to cover that as a topic or?
So, the fully enlightened beings have eliminated all thoughts and they have actualized all qualities. As a result, they are able to understand precisely what will help individual sentient beings and lead them to liberation. This is why we ourselves should endeavor to become fully enlightened beings. Another? We’re talking about Tonglen, giving and taking suffering from others.
And I have heard that people donate their organs when they, you know, alive. But when they die and, you know, they want to give the organ and this is not a common Buddhist practice because I heard that when you die, you have a lot of things going on and you don’t want people to touch your body when you die, isn’t it? And how can you achieve this sort of thing? So as far as giving organs you do not need to survive with like one kidney while you’re still alive to others, this in no way interferes with the practice of meditation in the death process. It is actually very virtuous.
Now when one has just died, if one has donated one’s organs, obviously the surgeon must immediately intervene to remove the organs. This might interfere with the practice of advanced death meditations. So this is something we have to analyze. Then if one is an advanced practitioner with great experience in the death meditations, then the removal of the organs will make no difference. If one is a beginner, it might make a difference.
My question is about the Buddhist specificity. And I have to say the arguments being presented over the last few weeks don’t really make sense to me. It’s been said that a non Buddhist can have a realization of emptiness, but that a person who has uncontrived definite emergence would necessarily have some sense of at least the coarse selflessness, a person’s being empty of being permanent one and independent. Now my well, my question or assertion is a non Buddhist having a realization of emptiness would surely have a sense of the emptiness of of the person being permanent one and independent. And so therefore, they would actually possess the Buddhist specificity and that would be odd.
So, wall it is possible for someone who is not formally a Buddhist to have a realization of emptiness. That is not a realization of emptiness by tenets, but a natural realization of emptiness and such a person actually is not a non Buddhist. Tashi Delek. Another? Yet.
Yet. And after you. I think it was last week we were talking about mental empathy, in distance and in closeness. Why is it easier to have empathy for someone who’s physically distant and it’s a lot more difficult when they might be in the room with you. So it is simply because when you live close with someone, if your mind is beset by the afflictions, then there is no empathy And it is as if they are very distant from you.
On the other hand, when they are far away, if you have no afflictions regarding them, then it is as if they are close to you and you feel empathy for them. Okay, should I define again what is cause and subtle selflessness of persons and what is selflessness of phenomena and what is emptiness? Those terms, because it did not attend tenets, those terms they merge together. And that’s a long story. It’ll take me at least at least one hour.
Who’s going to stay? But one day what we’ll do is we will cover just that. And could emptiness be defined again to me? I kind of think emptiness should be the selflessness of persons plus the selflessness of phenomena. However, when you talk about meditation in the great scope, emptiness is regarded as selflessness phenomena, which I think is not sufficient.
From the standpoint of the Prāsaṇgika School of Tenets, when we speak of emptiness we refer to both the selflessness of phenomena and the selflessness of persons, not just to the selflessness of phenomena. Another? Yes. So we’re striving for the great scope. Then would it be best to say that we can become organ donors?
We can become? Organ donors. For in general donating one’s organs, one’s lung, one’s heart, one’s liver and so forth is a vast and extremely virtuous practice. That alone is not sufficient to qualify for equalization and the interchange of others. To train in equalizing and interchanging self and others, one must change the way one thinks.
One must exchange our self cherishing and discarding other switch their positions. Page nine.
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- selflessness of phenomena chö kyi dag me (Tib)
- The absence of a self in phenomena - all things other than the person. In the Prasangika Madhyamaka view, the most subtle form is their lack of inherent existence: they do not exist from their own side. LYWA
- taking and giving tonglen (Tib)
- The meditation practice of generating bodhicitta by taking on the suffering of others and giving them happiness. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Why is it easier to feel empathy for someone who is physically far away than for someone in the same room?
The difference comes from the state of the mind, not from physical distance. When you live close to someone and your mind is beset by afflictions, there is no empathy, and it is as if that person were very distant from you. On the other hand, when someone is far away and you have no afflictions regarding them, it is as if they were close to you, and you feel empathy for them. Felt closeness depends on whether afflictions are present.