1 h 26 min · 3,438 words · 30 March 2016
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Continues a Lam Rim teaching on why love and compassion are shared across traditions while views differ, and on how one progresses from renunciation to the Mahayana path. The teacher explains bodhichitta as what distinguishes the Mahayana, why Lam Rim teaching should stress the Mahayana, and the risk that arhats remain in nirvana. Students then discuss whether a person with uncontrived renunciation has entered the path.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 27m
UUID: 823ad4f2-0d94-4938-a3ca-9017cb8b5384
Date: 2016-03-30
Words: 3,434
As is said in the chapter and dedication of Śāntideva’s Bodhisattva, Caryā Avatara, for so long as space exists and for so long as there are sentient beings, may I remain for their sake. This is a very profound stanza since space itself is measureless and beginningless and it is for so long as this and sentient beings exist that one should remain and not merely remain but act for their benefit. So this prayer does not merely refer to the existence of this finite planet of ours and the beings on this planet. This planet will come to an end in a couple of million years and so will all the beings living on this planet. Instead it refers to the totality of sentient beings and the totality of space.
And therefore, this great prayer of bodhisattvas is a very powerful one and we should make it ours. So in this context when one refers to empathy, to love and to bodhichitta, these must be what enables or causes our behavior of body, speech and mind for the sake of others. It is therefore important to reflect on the fact that in this world of ours, while there may be debates between the various schools of tenets, the various philosophical and religious schools, there is no disagreement whatsoever regarding the importance of love, of compassion and of empathy. So warm, there is no meeting ground whatsoever as far as the philosophical and religious views are concerned for instance between Buddhist and non Buddhist and for that matter between the Buddhist schools of tenets, the four schools of tenets Vaibhāṣika, Sautrāntika, Cittamātra and Mādhyamika in disagreement with each other. On the other hand there is no disagreement whatsoever regarding love, compassion and bodhichitta.
This is quite strange isn’t it? It’s a question we should ask ourselves. Why precisely is there well nigh complete disagreement regarding the view between the various philosophical and religious schools and is there basically no disagreement whatsoever regarding the generation of love, compassion and bodhichitta? Why? What’s your answer?
The schools disagree with each other. You understand that the schools disagree completely with each other. So why are the views discordant between the schools? Buddhist and non Buddhist. Yeah.
That’s pretty close. This is my feeling. It’s pretty similar to the way I feel about it. Okay. Yes, some of you seem to me to be thinking on the right lines here.
Love and compassion are basically our nature. We find them in animals. They are present naturally. So check for yourself, do keep in mind however that here when we talk of love and compassion, we are not talking of love and compassion in the sense of the great Buddhist scriptures or treatises. For instance, when the Buddhist treatises talk of compassion in the Mahāyāna, they are referring to great compassion, which is the wish for all sentient beings without exception to be freed from suffering and the causes of suffering.
So the object of this great compassion is all sentient beings. So when it comes to the view, matters are different. The view is a conceptual imputation. Then we are all different and therefore our conceptual imputations are different. My conceptual imputations will be different of those of your translator, and your translators will be different from mine and from yours.
That is not the case for love and compassion which are innately present within us, the views or not. So there is much food for study and reflection here in the fact that there are a multitude of different presentations of the view in Buddhist scriptures and non Buddhist scriptures, scriptures, almost all discordant with each other, there is overwhelming concordance regarding both the development of love and of compassion, which are seen as innate. So, even though empathy is innate within us, this empathy is restricted. It is circumscribed to those who are close to us. It does not extend as empathy in the Buddhist sense of the term to all sentient beings without exception.
If it did, it would be akin to great compassion. So what is our task precisely? Our task is to extend, to expand, to increase the empathy which we have at present so that it extends to all sentient beings. So if it was possible to extend empathy to all living, all sentient beings in this world and for all sentient beings in this world to extend empathy to us, then the world would be a far more harmonious place. Far different from the world as we see it now which is beset with strife, which frankly is ridiculous.
And this therefore is what we should aim for. Now as far as empathy and compassion are concerned, these are things which we share. On the other hand, we are profoundly different regarding our views. These are individual matters. So if we take the example of a kingdom or a country, then the king of the kingdom or the president of the country really has to take the interests of all the inhabitants of the country or the kingdom to heart in an impartial, unbiased way.
This is extremely important. Then the same thing can be said for those who strive to develop empathy or compassion. And therefore, the king or the president of a nation should focus on the welfare of all the citizens of that nation in an unbiased fashion then obviously in his case that responsibility does not extend to other countries or other nations. Now this sort of commitment from the leader is very powerful. So now as far as the Mahāyāna is concerned and the development of love, empathy and compassion, When we develop love, empathy and compassion within our mind streams, for that period of time, the afflictions will be blocked.
They will not be abandoned with their seeds, but they will be blocked. Since if we analyze our situation, we can see that setting aside physical suffering, the main source of problems we face are mental suffering. And the foremost cause of mental suffering are the afflictions. Now, the feature which all the afflictions share is to emphasize self cherishing, or one’s own self, and to discard others, to deemphasize altruism. This is a core feature of all the afflictions.
So we can see that the source of our mental suffering, if we set aside physical suffering of the afflictions, course afflictions especially such as anger and so forth. Now, where does anger come from? Anger comes fundamentally from discarding others and focusing on ourselves. Now when we speak of the what is it which differentiates the Mahāyāna? The practice of the Four Noble Truths, the 37 factors of enlightenment or for that matter the 16 facets or the 16 characteristics of the Four Noble Truths, that is common.
What differentiates the Mahāyāna from the Hīnayāna, the practice of the hearers and the solitary realizers, is the fact that in the background or the backdrop of the Mahāyāna is bodhichitta. That is the only difference. Otherwise the foundation is the same. So, first, now we are engaged in the study of the Lam Rim of the graduated stages of the path. The graduated stages of the path include the paths of the being of the small, of the middling, and of the great scope.
And they also cover how to progress from the path of the small to the path of the being of the middling, and from the middling to the great scope. For instance, once we have generated definite emergence or renunciation, we are at that point able to progress to the path of the being of the great scope. Until we have generated definite emergence, it is not possible to generate bodhichitta and enter the path of the being of the great scope. So we are at present studying the Lam Rim but eventually we will practice it and gain the realizations ideally. We would practice and gain these realizations before we are studying it.
Now at present, we have entered in the study of the Mahāyāna of the path of the being of the great vehicle. But to enter the Mahāyāna, one must initially have generated a fully characterized definite emergence or renunciation. It is only in dependence on this that one can then progress to the Mahāyāna. There is however no certainty or no definiteness regarding this. Having generated definite emergence, one does not necessarily enter the So in your opinion, how does one progress upwards from the path of the being of the middling scope after generating renunciation to the path of the being of the great scope?
Do you understand? Chris, I think. How to progress from the path of the being of the middling to the path of the being of the great scope? Yes indeed. When one generates uncontrived bodhichitta, one will progress from the path of the being of the middling to the path of the being of the great scope.
So we must therefore reflect carefully on the progression from the path of the being of the middling scope once one has generated uncontrived renunciation or definite emergence, to the path of the being of the great scope, how one proceeds and why one proceeds. Now as was explained yesterday, once one has generated uncontrived renunciation, one has entered the path. One has entered one of three paths, the path of the hearer, of solitary realizers or of bodhisattvas. But there is no necessity in entering any one of these specific paths. Otherwise it would be rather odd.
So once we have generated a stable renunciation, how and why do we progress up to the Mahāyāna? We reflect on the afflictions which beset us and on the cause of these afflictions and we realize that the cause of these afflictions is none other than discarding others. If the cause of the afflictions is discarding others, then an empathy which wishes to free others from suffering and the causes of suffering will counter this self cherishing which discards others and will also counter the afflictions. There is a piece of advice which is given when one teaches the lamrim and it is at the beginning before proceeding in teaching the lamrim to explain repeatedly the qualities of the state of full enlightenment and the characteristics of the fully enlightened body, speech and mind. The reason for this is because otherwise, when one starts presenting the path, which is shared with the being of the small and of the middling scope, the disciple who is listening to the teachings may be distracted by this path.
And instead of the path being a path shared with the being of the small and the middling scope, it becomes a path of the being of the small or the middling scope, and they end up by remaining at the level of the Hīnayāna. So for this reason, when one teaches Lamrim, whatever path one is teaching, one should repeatedly talk nonetheless of the Mahāyāna and the qualities of the Mahāyāna. Otherwise, since the main source of mental suffering which we experience are the afflictions, and once the afflictions are eliminated through meditation on the Four Noble Truths, one attains liberation which is a state of durable absence of suffering since there are precisely no afflictions, then these teachings become an obstacle to entering in the Mahāyāna, since one will remain for thousands of years, actually countless years in a state of nirvana without ever entering the Mahāyāna. So we have a scriptural source for this in the account of the life of the Arhat Kāśyapa, one of Buddha Śākyamūni’s foremost disciples. When Kāśyapa was teaching the four noble truths to 60 bhikshus, Aryamanjushri foreseeing the danger to these bhikshus initially gave them teachings on the Mahāyāna.
They achieved a state of an Ahat independence on the teachings on the four noble truths and because they were very dull capacities, developed strong wrong views regarding the Mahāyāna as a result of Ārya Mañjuśrī’s teachings and in the following life were reborn in the hell realms. However, after this, they had in their subsequent lives very powerful karmic imprints regarding the Mahāyāna. So it was the uncommon skill in means of Ārya Mañjuśrī which prevented these 60 Ahats from attaining the state they would have attained and falling in the hell realms. All our great teachers, His Holiness the Dalai Lama, Khensur Rinpoche have repeated this over and over again. This is a very profound piece of advice.
Moreover, those who have attained the state of an Ahad find it extremely difficult to enter the Mahāyāna because they are constantly distracted by the extraordinary bliss of liberation and even when they do enter the Mahāyāna, their progression is very slow because the main factor of progression in the Mahāyāna is empathy And empathy occurs when one understands the commonality between one’s own suffering and that of others. Arhats have no suffering. So there is very little ground for the development of empathy and compassion. So let us now try to generate the requisite motivation for these teachings by thinking as follows. After all, the root of all suffering within my mind stream is the afflictions And if I analyze the root of the afflictions is discarding others.
So is it the case or not that training in an empathy which wishes to free others from suffering and the causes of suffering should reduce this egoism which causes me to discard others. This is a motivation we should generate. Two, three, and four. And also page five, number six, number seven offering. So once we have generated an uncontrived renunciation which wishes liberation for our own sake from cyclic existence, we will have entered the path shared with the being of the middling scope.
How then do we proceed to move upwards to transfer to the path of the being of the great scope? If after this, we reflect on the suffering of the contaminated aggregates, which all cyclic beings in cyclic existence experience, at the point when we say to ourselves, why would it be inappropriate, why would it not be appropriate for all cyclic beings, for all sentient beings in cyclic existence to be freed from this suffering, at that point we will have entered the Mahāyāna. So we trained this well. So at present a doubt might arise. After all, once someone has generated uncontrived renunciation within their mind stream, have they entered the path or not?
Now some of you remember from yesterday the definition of the path, which is a sapience, which is upheld by uncontrived renunciation. So if someone who has generated uncontrived renunciation has entered the path, then at that point, they would have to be either a hearer or a pratyekabuddha or a practitioner of the Mahāyāna. Obviously the mere generation of uncontrived renunciation is not enough. They will be entering the Mahāyāna. So this is something you have to understand well now.
Do you understand? So that’s the question I’m asking you. So the question I I put it in debate form so otherwise it’s not clear. The question is, so the question is, otherwise it’s unclear if we talk like this. If you have generated uncontrived renunciation within your mind stream, are you necessarily a being who has entered the path or not?
Who says no? No. So those of you who are saying that there is no, who have said no, that is one position but Lilly is saying that yes, if you have generated uncontrived renunciation in your mind stream, you are necessarily a being which has entered the path. Then which path? So you understand you have not entered, right, the path?
So you can now see the problem. The definition of a path as you remember from yesterday is a sapience which is upheld by uncontrived renunciation. So, if you say that having generated uncontrived renunciation within your mind stream, you have entered a path, but after all that’s a definition of a path, then you must have entered one of the three paths. If on the other hand you say you have not entered a path, what is the meaning of the definition of path? So this is something you have to think about by yourselves.
This is a difficult point. As Artemis has said, there are numerous difficulties here. So, what I would like you to think about is how a being or a person who has completed the path of the being of the small scope has generated uncontrived renunciations and all the realizations of a being of the small scope progresses upwards to the path of the being of the great scope. So, in a nutshell, the debate of the issue is the following. A being who has completed all the realizations of the path of the being shared with the being of the middling scope has obviously generated uncontrived renunciation.
Having generated uncontrived renunciation, we would say that such a being in keeping with the definition in grounds and paths has entered the path. This is a, but the question is, is this a being which has entered the path? Because if it is a being which has entered the path, then it is necessarily one of the three categories of beings, a hearer, a solitary realizer, or a bodhisattva. So this is the issue we have to think about. So we shall start here and I will take two questions at present.
Short, clear questions and if there’s time, I’ll take more. So just hold it to your chin. So in terms of the my question, When we renounce ourself and we renounce the part of the self cherishing and disregarding, I was just thinking in the process, do we fully just think about our compassion, our love, empathy for others? And does that include ourself? So actually, when you abandon self cherishing or egoism, not only do you accomplish the welfare of others, but you accomplish your own welfare as well.
However, that own welfare you accomplish is totally different from the own welfare you would accomplish through self cherishing or egoism. I’ve tried to make this question concise in my mind. I was thinking about it last night and thinking about the definition of a path and that being a mental factor, whereas a sentient being to whom the mental factor belongs to would be different. So I concluded that while the sapience which has entered the path, which is upheld by the sapience upheld by definite emergence would always be on the path because that is the definition of a path. The sentient being to whom the sapience belongs to would not necessarily always be on the path.
And then I then reached what I think is an uncomfortable conclusion because you know how dogmatic about scripture I am. Then I concluded that Tsongkhapa’s definition of the criteria of having generated definite emergence must not be correct because it is unceasingly day and night one strives for liberation. But I couldn’t conclude that there would always be unceasing striving for liberation. Do I understand your question correctly by saying that you’re asking whether persons can be on PAS and can be PAS, is that your question? No.
My thought was that while a sapience is always on a path, the sentient being that the sapience belongs to, because the sapience is a mental factor, is not necessarily always on the path. No, so I had to concise, reformulate your statement. A being in whose continuum there is a path is necessarily a being who has entered the path. Another? Sami.
I think according to the Lotus sūtra, an arhat will eventually enter the Mahāyāna path. According to which? The Lotus sūtra, I think. Or how how would develop compassion without the common ground for empathy? How would they eventually enter the Mahāyāna path?
So this is a very difficult issue. It is said to be a very difficult issue in the long run. It is also very difficult for the AHATs concerned to generate compassion without any personal experience of suffering left. However, the arhats also have the Buddha lineage, what some call the Buddha nature. And through being exposed over and again to teachings on bodhichitta, this will eventually be activated.
So the arhats are profoundly immersed in the bliss of liberation, but they are unlike us in that they have been exposed to vast amounts of teachings. Thank you. Thank you. We shall stop here for today.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
- Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Mahayana teg chen (Tib)
- Literally, Great Vehicle. It is one of the two general divisions of Buddhism. LYWA
- pratyekabuddha rang sang gye (Tib)
- A solitary realizer or self-realizer; a Hinayana practitioner who attains liberation from cyclic existence autonomously, without relying on an external teacher or teachings. Cf. shravaka. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
When we abandon self-cherishing and work for the welfare of others, does that also accomplish our own welfare?
Yes. When you abandon self-cherishing, or egoism, you do not only accomplish the welfare of others; you accomplish your own welfare as well. However, the welfare you accomplish this way is totally different from the welfare you would accomplish through self-cherishing or egoism.