Lam Rim — 2015-10-05

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2015-10-05
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. In this 124-minute teaching, Kyabje Rinpoche guides students through a practical investigation: find the “I” within your body and mind. By examining the five aggregates—form, sensation, discrimination, conditioning, and consciousness—he shows that although the “I” feels real within these, careful analysis reveals it cannot be found anywhere. This unfindability is emptiness itself. Rinpoche explains how this inquiry generates three deepening stages of wisdom: from hearing, from thinking, and from meditation. He frames the investigation within the Four Noble Truths, uses the moon-in-pond analogy to clarify how the “I” appears yet doesn’t exist inherently, and shows how weakening self-grasping automatically weakens anger and desire. Students meditate on the analysis and explore the four truths through Q&A. For practitioners who have received Anuttara Yoga Tantra initiation.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-10-05 – KR.mp3

Teacher: Kyabje Rinpoche

Collection: Tenets

Date: 2005-10-15

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Words: ~4,394

So Geshe-la says this is a Tibetan expression. Right? You sneeze, the devil comes out, he comes straight back. You sneeze, the devil comes out. Blessing.

It’s very, very witty, isn’t it? Yeah. So this morning, since it is the morning firstly, secondly, we aren’t stunned by a large lunch and finally the heat hasn’t started to pick up. I thought we would cover again the topic of dependent origination. It will be easier to understand in the morning.

So we will be covering the presentation of emptiness and interdependent interdependence in accordance with the teachings of the great pandits of ancient India who presented this in a large number of sections of their works. Now, this is a topic which has individual presentations in keeping with each school and there are presentations linked with death and impermanence and so forth. If we were to enter into detail of each presentation, I think we would probably be bored stiff and bored stiff as you know is a euphemism for falling asleep. Then obviously from your sides, if you are bored or stupefied by the topic, it has a stupefying effect on myself and I find it difficult to talk about it. On the other hand, the more interested you are in the topic, the more excited I will become and the more I will present.

Anyway. So let’s start. Listen carefully. Yeah. Let’s say carefully.

So we have covered the first two noble truths, noble truths of suffering and the origin of suffering and there is some material left to cover in the last two truths, the truth of cessation and of the path. Now generally speaking, the truth of suffering and the origin of suffering in as much as they exist within our own mind streams are easy to understand. We have direct experience of them. On the other hand, it is difficult to understand the noble truth of cessation and of the path precisely because they don’t exist within our mind stream and we have no direct of them. For instance, the wisdom realizing emptiness would be an instance of the noble truth of the path.

We have no experience of it. My teacher, my father, my mother, my brother, Initially, I would like you to think about your emotional reaction when you say I, my mother, my father, my teacher. It is not something which is emotionally felt up here in the head. We feel it here and it is not so much a movement of the hand, there is a natural feeling within the chest, within the heart. How is it for yourself?

Do you feel it like that? How do you feel it? Now within this presentation, the lower schools of tenets and we refer here to the lower Buddhist schools of tenets from Svatāntrika Mādhyamika downwards find the I within the aggregates. In truth, we are very lucky to cover topics such as the four noble truths and emptiness together. This is authentic dharma.

Then to turn the recitations of one’s commitments in authentic dharma, that is very difficult. Do you understand that? So, as was explained previously, can you see that when we say for instance my cup, my clock and so forth, that is subsidiary to this powerful sense of I within ourselves which seems to exist inside or within the aggregates. All of us experience this sensation of the I existing within the aggregates and in addition have the feeling that if we were to seek for it, we would get it, we would find it. So we therefore have this clear sense that when we seek for the I, it can be found.

It can be found within its ground of imputation. What is its ground or a basis of imputation? The five aggregates, the form aggregates, sensation, discrimination, composition of factors and consciousness. Now if we try to find the eye, the I within the form aggregate, in other words the body, then it’s obvious if we cut the hand, the eye is still there. If we cut our legs, the eye would be still there.

Same thing for the nose or the ears, then the head I don’t know. Now let us move on within our analysis and look at coarse consciousnesses such as the five sensory consciousnesses. The I we are seeking for within these five sensory consciousnesses is the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations. Can the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations be found within the five sensory consciousnesses? It is obvious that during deep sleep, the five sensory consciousnesses cease.

Nonetheless, we cannot say that the continuum of the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations has been severed, Therefore, the I cannot be found or predicated upon the basis of the five sensory consciousnesses. Now let us move onwards to more subtle consciousnesses such as the mental consciousness. The mental consciousness would include minds such as memories and so forth. Can the experiencer of pleasant and unpleasant sensations, in other words the I we are seeking for, be found within the mental consciousness? If it could be found within the mental consciousness, then that would mean that its continuum was severed during deep sleep, during which there is no manifest mental consciousness and when we fall unconscious and in a coma.

Yet it is obvious that during deep sleep when we fall unconscious, the person still exists. Therefore, the person cannot be predicated on this basis. So, we therefore can conclude that this I, this person, which is the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations cannot be found within the aggregates. This unfindability of the I within the aggregates is an unfindability of an I established from its own side or an inherently established I within the aggregates. So therefore, this unfindability within the aggregates of the experience of pleasure and pain of happiness and unhappiness.

This the fact that when we seek for it, it cannot be found. This and nothing else in this is emptiness. Therefore, when the I is sought for within the aggregates, within its basis of imputation, it is unfindable and this can be posited as emptiness. Through repeated reflection on this, one eventually generates a conception which understands that although the I seems to exist within the aggregates and to be findable, it is not. When this conception has been generated, at this point, the wisdom arisen from thinking focused on emptiness can be said to have been generated.

This is akin to the experience we have when we see the reflection of the moon in a pond. It is self evident that even though the reflection of the moon appears in a pond, that reflection is not the moon. So, I have endeavored to explain how this conception which thinks that the I can be found within the aggregates, that the I exists from its own side within the aggregates is mistaken and I have endeavored to show the method of analysis for seeking for the I within the aggregates, within the form aggregates and within consciousness. Then, I would like to ask you at present to meditate for a couple minutes on this carefully to see whether you can indeed find your I within your body or your mind or not. And after this we will discuss about this and I will address some questions to you.

Okay. Canada. How was it? Yeah. How was it?

Interesting. Really? Canada, Canada, Canada. So could you explain? Yeah.

So what I’m asking you is, did you find or did you not find this I which is the experience of happiness and unhappiness? Does it exist within you or not? Then I’d like your answers on this nothing else. Good. Then you found the object of refutation.

That is exactly It’s a mind which thinks I. That’s precisely the mind which imputes or superimposes the I on everything else. And Nada? Okay. So, yes.

I mistranslated you. So what you’re saying is that your I appears as a mere dependence-only conception. So, in dependence on that you should be able to understand that the I arises in dependence on a conception or that it is merely imputed by a conception. I’m not saying the I does not exist. I’m saying the mode of existence of the I must be investigated, it depends on conceptuality.

All of you have broadly speaking said the same thing. You have said the I arises in dependence on sensation. Then the terminology is a bit different. And mother? Yeah.

Sorry. So the seeker is the I when you seek for the I within your mental consciousness. You, the I is seeking for the I. He is seeking for himself. Who could be seeking for yourself but yourself?

It is certainly not some other party which is seeking for yourself. It is yourself who is seeking for yourself. So in Prāsaṇgika, the refutation of reflexive consciousness is based on this. This might be a bit difficult for us. Do you understand?

You understand? Reflexive consciousness does not exist. Yet. So the mistaken mind apprehending the self exists, the mode of apprehension of that mind is mistaken, its object does not exist. Emma.

Oh, Emma. Yep. That’s pretty much it. That’s not a bad way to think about it. And, Dinsdrog, I think.

So this is quite good basically I’d say on a scale of a 100, most of you were at 90. You all understood that the experience of pleasant and unpleasant sensations when it is searched for within the aggregates cannot be found. So this is very good. We should focus on this and not think about anything else. Otherwise it will generate confusion.

So this conception which understands that the I cannot be found within the aggregates basically is what we wish to foster. Then it is clear that the conception which thinks that the I exists within the aggregates is none other than beginningless ignorance. This must be countered. So one must therefore understand that this I does not exist within the aggregates and that the ignorance is that I which is that mind which thinks that when the I is searched for within the aggregates, it can be found. Therefore, when under repeated investigation, we can see that the I which is searched for does not exist within the aggregates, we can say that the wisdom generated from hearing has occurred.

When in dependence on reasoning and repeated investigation, we are able to counter the conception or the predilection which thinks that the I can be found within the aggregate, aggregates when searched for, at that point, the wisdom generated from thinking can be said to have arisen. This is similar to the experience of the reflection of the moon in a pond, where the reflected moon appearing in the pond is not the moon. And therefore, as the conception which thinks that even though the I appears within the aggregates, it cannot be found increases in strength in turn, the ignorance which believes that the I can be found within the aggregates decreases in strength. These two are contradictory or mutually incompatible. Their mode of apprehension is different.

It is akin to the example of lamps and darkness. So as the conception which thinks that the I can be found within the aggregate dwindles, in turn the ignorance grasping at a self dwindles. And as this one decreases, desire decreases. As desire decreases, anger decreases. Then in turn, as this wisdom which understands that the I cannot be found within the aggregates increases, the ignorance decreases and eventually disappears.

This cessation of ignorance is the noble truth of cessation. So therefore, as this wisdom which understands that the eye cannot be found within the aggregates, in other words that the I is not inherently established arises, we can say that the ascertainment arisen from thinking has occurred. The major difference between the ascertainment or the wisdom arisen from thinking and the wisdom arisen from meditation is that within the wisdom arisen from thinking, the consciousness which understands that the I cannot be found within the aggregates and the I’s being unable to be found within the aggregates are experienced as different. Whereas within the wisdom arisen from meditation, the consciousness which understands that the I cannot be found within the aggregates and the I’s being unable to be found within the aggregates are experienced as one. This is known as non duality.

Please be careful, listen to me, please. So please listen carefully, this is not an easy topic, the wisdom arisen from meditation. It’ll be hard for you and for myself. So these wisdoms arisen from thinking, hearing, thinking and meditation provide an introduction to the noble truth of the path. So therefore here it is the wisdom arisen from meditation specifically which ushers the noble truth of the path.

Now once one has just understood that the I which is sought for within the aggregates cannot be found and is not inherently established, at that point, the wisdom arisen from thinking has occurred. This is not the wisdom arisen from meditation. For the wisdom arisen from meditation to arise, calm abiding must be present. This is why the Noble Lord Je Tsongkhapa says that in generating the wisdoms arisen from think from hearing, thinking and meditating, after hearing carefully and thinking, one should retreat into isolation. This is a powerful piece of advice.

The retreat into isolation is for the sake of meditation. So as Je Tsongkhapa says, once one has generated the ascertainment which has arisen from thinking and the mind is no longer troubled, then retire into solitude and meditate. So do understand that the mind which has arisen from thinking is So the wisdom arising from thinking occurs in dependence on a mind of the desire realm. Therefore, it is not possible to eliminate ignorance with such a mind. We need a more subtle mind, a mind which is based on calm abiding.

As I said in the last stanza of the three principles of the path, once you have understood this, retire in solitude and put effort in your practice. So therefore once one has generated a valid cognizer within the context of the wisdom arising from thinking which understands emptiness, then at that point one must give rise to a wisdom arisen from meditation which is only able to eliminate ignorance, the ignorance which grasps at the self. So most of you have received Anutara Yoga tantra initiations and you understand in the context of Anuttara Yoga tantra that it is necessary to eliminate ordinary appearances and conceptions. It is precisely the in the context of eliminating ordinary appearances and conceptions that this refutation of the inherent existence of phenomena or the existence of phenomena from their own side arises. And it is on this basis that irrespective of whatever deity one practices, one can generate what is known as divine pride.

So at present, I have explained what I wanted to cover regarding the generation of the wisdom arisen from thinking and the wisdom arisen from meditation. I hope from your side you will study carefully and give rise to these states of mind and at present, let us generate the motivation. Couple of minutes. So generate refuge in bodhicitta. Perform the invocation, generate the four immeasurables, seven-limb prayer, and then two mandala offering verses on page five, which is the first and the third of number six.

So this basically covers what I wanted to say about emptiness and dependent origination. Then these are not topics which can be understood at once and easily. It’s over time through repeated study and application that one will be able to understand them. So as one reflects over and again on emptiness and interdependence, eventually the wisdom arisen from thinking will arise and in dependence on this, eventually the wisdom arisen from meditating. When this happens, one will then see the all the exterior world as illusion like and in dependence on this, the afflictions such as desire and so forth will dwindle and eventually disappear.

So, once we have generated the wisdom arisen from thinking, this coarse mind of the desire realm which focuses on emptiness is present. Such a mind is actually very powerful and at the time of the death process, when such a mind is focused on emptiness as that mind ceases, I suspect that the focus on emptiness might remain. So let us have a brief session of questions and answers on the four noble truths. Could you give me an example of the noble truth of suffering? Example Yeah.

Of the noble truth of suffering? Somewhat? Okay. Not too much, just one, you know. Generally speaking, while it is true that the examples you have given are instances of the noble truth of suffering within the four noble truths of presentation.

Nonetheless, the examples you ought to give are for instance the unpleasant sensation which arises from anger, the unpleasant sensation which arises from desire, the unpleasant sensation which arises from envy and jealousy. So the reason for this is because this provides an introduction into the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Now quickly quickly, give me examples of the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Give me examples of both noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering. First the one then the other.

Marika. Yeah. Sorry. Sushi. Now could you give me an example of the relationship between the noble truth of suffering and the noble truth of the origin of suffering?

What is the instance of the noble truth of cessation? So the noble truth of cessation, an example. You identify and you don’t find. That’s it. That’s good.

Oh, very good. Let’s almost It’s a pure answer. That is the truth of the path. It’s not the truth of cessation. So it’s rather mistaken.

So example of the truth of cessation. Cessation. That is good. That’s precisely it. No idea.

Yeah. So, yes, that’s a good point. What we’re speaking about here is the elimination of all the afflictions without exception. Then there are topics like nirvana’s with remainder and without remainder that’s different. Yes.

That’s okay. So quite a few of you said the cessation which is a cessation of afflictions. That is precisely it, the cessation which is a cessation of afflictions within one’s continuum is the noble truth of cessation. Then there was a fair bit of confusion between the noble truth of cessation and the noble truth of the path but that’s okay. The noble truth of the path is the means to attain the noble truth of cessation.

In other words, states of mind such as the wisdom which realizes emptiness. So examples of the noble truth of the path. So the noble truth of the path is not only a mind which realizes emptiness, it must also be a powerful mind arisen from meditation. The first part of your answer is correct. It is the mind realizing emptiness directly.

Then as to helping others, that’s something else. So I think that is it on the topic of the Four Noble Truths. I hope it was of benefit to you. It may have been a bit difficult. For myself, there was definite benefit and I was very touched to see that you attended and studied so consistently.

So this topic of the four noble truth is extremely important therefore, if you have time, please try to reflect on it. If you don’t have time, what can one do? It is the core topic of the path of the being of the middling scope. So we should put effort in these teachings since it is rare to have a translator who can translate correctly teachings on the view and therefore we should remember his kindness. Otherwise, if we don’t in the future, there may be no teachings on the view anymore.

So I myself am very comfortable and happy at the thought that I can teach and be translated by someone who has studied and who will not mistake, make mistakes and you yourself should be aware of this as well. Then most of you are attending teachings regularly, some the Tuesday teachings. The most important thing is to study continuously and regularly. Probably I have nothing left to Yes, at present we will dedicate the virtues. Yes, dedicate, you know, that’s left.

Now we’re gonna offer body, speech, and mind, and thanks for the teaching. And so it’s on page nine, the mandala offering eight b. We’re gonna do both verses slowly and then the rest of the prayers. Oh, sorry. Forgot the rest.

Now we dedicate. Sorry. His holiness, the Dalai Lama. And then yeah. No prostration.

Just say a few words. Thank you so much, Geshe-la, for such wonderful teachings in this very troubled age. It’s such a privilege, as you’ve said, to be able to have authentic Dharma teachings from a pure lineage going back through Gyaltsab Je Rinpoche all the way back to Buddha Śākyamūni. And so it is a great privilege that we can be addressing the very core essence of the Buddhist Dharma, and not just for this life, but for future lives and for the sake of all beings. And and as you said, we thank you, Ilya, for being such a wonderful loudspeaker for our teachers.

Without which, it would just be a lot of, words because we don’t understand the language. And so to have someone with such, personal direct experience and also able to, convey the meaning accurately, again, it is sad that the Gomper is not full of everybody in Adelaide, so we can be very privileged that that we are here. Yes. And I just have a little, extra thing. Shortly, we’ll be offering offering to Geshe-la in the traditional way.

But in the meantime, this is just to test Ilya’s definite renunciation. And of course, is fair trade. And also without having the wonderful food for the body, that Tenzin has so ably demonstrated his prowess in the kitchen, with aspirations to open a vegetarian restaurant. Thank you so much. And Carol is hiding somewhere, but oh, there she is.

And, of course, there’s been a lot of work behind the scenes, Tenzin’s able Assistant and, you know, doing a lot of the administrative work etc. Also to thank, those who have helped in many different ways towards the food and cleaning and preparation for the teachings and for Jill for ably leading us with wonderful meditations in the morning. Everybody else who I haven’t thanked, I thank you. And, if I can just quickly say that there’s a little story attached to this, gift. I bought these on Thursday, from Hakes chocolates in the city and then I promptly, I was doing my practice actually, and I promptly, left them on the tram.

And, so I thought, okay, somebody can enjoy them. Somebody else that is. So anyway, I thought, oh, well, why not try ringing up? And I rang up and they said ring tomorrow because that’s if they if anybody doesn’t eat them, they’ll hand them in. So I rang after lunch the following day on Friday and expecting not for them not to be there, somebody in the green grocer shop said, you’ll be lucky.

And, I rang up and said, oh, yes, they’re here. So I had to go to Glengarry to pick them up. So I thought, okay. That’s nice too. So there’s been a little bit of a teaching for me.

So thank you very much, everybody. Very quick one. Of course, I’d like to thank Geshe-la and Ilya and also our Geshes, you know, visiting Geshes, you know. They are very helpful. And not only that, they now start constructing a Medicine Buddha mandala.

It’s dedicated to His Holiness long life and all the holy lamas and reincarnation. And, of course, you know, the center is depend on the members and support and friends. So we dedicate that for all the members and their friends and their family. So during next until next Wednesday, you can come visit, you know, to see how the progress, you know, Mandala going on there. And public talk, this Saturday, 03:00, there is a lot of pamphlets left in there and you can take and give it to your friends or bring along, you know, and that would be helpful to to track them in the right path.

So it’s a great gift for you, a friend. And of course, I’d like to thank for venerable Tenzin Dhondrup and it’s great to be here and Jill as Chris already mentioned, you know, there’s Susan Sinclair, you know, she offered a beautiful lunch on a Saturday and and we have a beautiful salad, man. So Andrew, thank you very much, you know, and it’s last three days he provide salad and everybody enjoy it. There’s none always no left, you know? So that means it shows, you know, how beautiful and tasty.

And that’s basically it and thank you very much, you know, all the everybody. Then there is one person I would like to thank personally. She is always forgotten because of her humility. It’s my wife Mandy. Please come here.

Sorry. Oh, that’s alright. I’ve forgotten him. She baked cookies for and cakes for all of us in the heat with a wood oven at the last minute request of Tenzin. She has done this year after year.

Then humility has its own rewards. Come here, Mandy. I offer you my chocolates. I sincerely apologize that, you know, I totally forgot that and yeah, Mandy has done many times in the past and you know, it’s a beautiful cakes and cookies that she made, you know. Thank you so much, Mandy.

And not only that, you know, she’s always, you know, making sure Geshe-la and Ilya’s, you know, tea and drink there for ready. So thank you so much, Mandy. Yeah. Yes. Thank you everybody.

Key terms in this teaching

basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
desire realm kamadhatu (Skt); do kham (Tib)
One of the three realms of samsara, comprising the hell beings, hungry ghosts, animals, humans, asuras (demi-gods) and the six lower classes of suras (gods); beings in this realm are preoccupied with desire for objects of the six senses. LYWA
four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
Highest Yoga Tantra Anuttara Yoga Tantra (Skt); la na mä pä gyü (Tib)
The fourth and supreme division of tantric practice, sometimes called Maha-anuttara Yoga Tantra. It consists of the generation and completion stages. Through this practice, one can attain full enlightenment within one lifetime. LYWA
mandala khyil khor (Tib)
A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
mandala offering
The symbolic offering of the entire purified universe to the spiritual teacher (guru) and the visualized merit field. LYWA
Yoga Tantra näljor gyi gyü (Tib)
The third of four classes of Buddhist tantra, literally meaning "union" due to the increased emphasis on internal activities compared with the previous two tantras. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top