Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. In this 48-minute talk, Kyabje Rinpoche uses a single diagram to bridge neuroscience and Buddhist doctrine: all happiness is a decrease in pain intensity, a thesis from Je Tsongkhapa’s analysis of the three sufferings. He illustrates with concrete examples—a finger on a hot oven, musical dissonance and its resolution, even a boil—to explain why meditators experience increased suffering as attention deepens. He then maps this insight onto the twelve links of dependent origination and the Four Noble Truths, showing how ignorance, karma, and craving perpetuate saṃsāra while their cessation opens the path to liberation. The teaching includes discussion of translation precision (renunciation versus definite emergence) and situates Buddhist practice within the broader Indian yogic traditions. Aimed at practitioners with foundational study.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-10-04 – KR.mp3
Teacher: —
Collection: Four Noble Truths
Date: 2004-10-15
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Words: ~6,372
For durably traumatizing everyone with my question. I, yes, but I see you have my crib sheets from my presentations. And I’m very grateful to Chris to have pointed that out because from now on, I give you no time to prepare. But, we had some questions yesterday during the break from Andy and from Richard regarding the three sufferings, specifically the suffering of change. Then I thought I would whip up a very very brief summary from some presentations I gave at TBI on those suffering, specifically the suffering of change which is problematical.
You know, just to give you an idea of what’s happening and then, you know, we’ll see what answers you found to the miniature quiz. So this was a quote Yes, this was a quote I mentioned to you yesterday. Sorry, I don’t have my laser pointer with me. It’s very interesting. It’s from a recent article in Nature Reviews Neuroscience.
This is 02/2008, so that’s basically seven years ago and the authors basically imply that there is a common underlying neurobiology for both pleasure and pain. Then I will not enter into the developments here. Sylvia Barber is a grand specialist in the field. If you have time and interest, you know, talk with her. You know, I’m sure she’s more aware than I am of the latest developments in the field.
But all this to show that the core Buddhist understanding of suffering and pleasure is not something which is totally alien. Then just to recap as you remember there are three types of suffering. The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and all pervasive suffering. The suffering of suffering is pain, physical or mental pain. The suffering of change is happiness.
All happiness is a suffering of change and all pervasive suffering is everything else. All the neutral sensations would qualify as all pervasive suffering. So you’ll see in a couple minutes that what seems like a very strong Buddhist dogmatic stance is actually rooted in a very profound analysis of how the mind functions. Then much of this now is my own work. We have basically a hierarchy of pleasures, from the basic pleasures which are recognized I would say, in modern biology, sexuality, food, urination, defecation, perhaps linked to limbic neural mechanisms towards more sophisticated leverage of pleasure, the social pleasures, conversation, which there seems to be a lot at TBI.
The more abstract pleasures, visiting a museum, listening to a concert and what certainly in Buddhism is considered the highest ordinary pleasure, the highest samsaric pleasure, which is the bliss risen from meditation. Now, it is precisely this bliss Geshe-la was talking about this morning when he talked of yogis who basically without any Buddhist teachings from their own side, just set out on a path to try to find a true and lasting source of pleasure other than worldly pleasures. Now, what precisely is the Buddhist understanding of the three types of sufferings we talked about previously? It’s very clear I think in this chart, as the intensity of an in abscissa you have time, ordinate you have the intensity of your pleasure, a painful stimuli. As the intensity of the painful stimuli increases, what we call pain, in other words, the suffering of suffering is present.
If heaven forbid you were to burn your finger on the oven, as you keep your finger on the oven, the intensity of the pain arise, increases. This is just a suffering of suffering, which we all understand. When there is a plateau and there is no real variation, we have a period of neutral sensation. This from a Buddhist standpoint is all pervasive suffering and we’ll talk about why in a couple of seconds. But what is really striking is that when the intensity of pain decreases, we experience something which we call pleasure.
Now the Buddhist contention is that there is no pleasure apart from this. All pleasure is merely a decrease in the intensity of painful stimuli and the sharper the decrease, the greater the pleasure. So here you can see a very sharp decrease in a short period of time, you would have an intense sensation of pleasure and as it levels out the pleasure basically decreases and eventually you have a neutral sensation again, which is the all pervasive suffering. Then once again, pain increases, we experience the suffering of some suffering and then it decreases and we experience pleasure. Now, what I’ve not included in this chart is the attention threshold.
So if we include the attention threshold, we end up with a slightly modified chart. Basically, everything beneath the threshold of attention is not experienced as suffering of any type. Everything above it is experienced either if there is an increase in the intensity of the painful stimuli as pain, if there is no change as a neutral sensation and if there is a sharp decrease as pleasure. Now you can see that if you were to engage in meditative practices which I mentioned to Andy yesterday, such as Satipatthana in which you basically decrease the amount of unperceived mental sensations, we say you lower the threshold of attention, eventually a large swathe of your experience would be pervaded with some type of suffering of suffering or suffering of change. And this is the experience Satipatthana meditators have.
As they increase their focus on the breath while remaining mindful of other mental activities, the first thing they experience is a very brutal, it’s really quite brutal, increase in physical suffering which has always been present. It just was hidden beneath the threshold of attention. And that’s why I gave to Richard yesterday the example of music since he’s musically inclined. Music is a classic case of alternates of the suffering of suffering or the suffering of suffering and the suffering of change. When you have two discordant notes in accord, the discordance generates the suffering of suffering, an auditory experience of pain.
The longer this is drawn out and the sharper the resolution of the discordance, the greater the subsequent experience of pleasure. I think much if not all of music can be explained like this. And that’s what I wanted to cover with you briefly. Do you have any questions about this? Yes.
The anesthetist. Yeah. The anesthetist. Remember you said that the that the I thought It’s still with you. That the anesthetist said that all happiness was related to pain and he’d seen it in suffering people.
Yes. There was another quote I didn’t bring today. But I mean, the basic problem with much of that research is some of it is so cutting edge. We’re not quite sure how stable it is. Is this going to be the final position in neurobiology or not?
I don’t know. One neurobiologist pointed out that he was stimulating an area of the brain. I believe it actually was a nucleus accumbens inside the brain stem which is linked to, it’s actually linked to, addiction mechanisms. And he found that it really the person’s reaction pleasurable, painful or extremely pleasurable did not depend on the location of the electrodes but depended exclusively on the frequency of the stimuli. At low frequency it was highly pleasurable.
At high frequency it was painful and at extremely high frequency extremely painful. Then as I said, the jury is out and Sylvia is a grand specialist. So you know see with her you know what the present state of research is. But I just thought this chart, these charts are not drawn from research. These are my own creation but they describe Je Tsongkhapa’s presentation of the three subjects.
Whether this is corroborated or not by neurobiology is another question but it seems to fit the experience of those who’ve looked into it. Then if you have no further question, questions, it’s quiz time. So Test. Please. Clarification of the question I asked yesterday about definite exit and definite emergence because I’m not clear.
Did Tsongkhapa, the translation you you have this is not your translation, definite emergence, is it? It’s a recognized other translation? I think there’s quite a few translators who use that now. Yes. Right.
Was always translated as definite emergence, or has it Not always. It’s generally translated as renunciation. Sorry? Generally translated as renunciation. Renunciation.
Which I do not like at all. Because definite exit has the connotation connotation to me of being quite intense, of quite intense. The person making quite definite renunciation. Renunciation is very strong, and the person is wanting to exit saṃsāra by any immediately, whereas definite emergence to me has a connotation. It’s some sort of gradual process, which in fact it may be, but for most a lot of people, particularly I think those of sharper minds, wouldn’t be fast enough.
You’d have to be looking for a process that’s really fast and effective. You want the, like, the cure to your pain. You wanna get out fast. You don’t wanna be hanging around. So So you want to find the method.
And the method, I mean, you know, I know what we’re doing here today is a bit different. But, you know, you’ve got to go down the road of emptiness. That’s the answer. I agree with you. I mean but you are giving a commentary on Nyen Jung.
Then my goal as a translator has been to try to stick as close as is possible with decent English obviously to the connotation of the Tibetan terms. And whenever I’ve gone back to the Sanskrit, I’ve always put it in footnote with one exception which is karmic imprints which I decided to retranslate as redolences because in redolence, smells. Redolence. Because in Sanskrit, the term Vāsanā means perfume. Then there has been a massive shift from Sanskrit to Tibetan with bag chags.
Nobody knows the etymology of bag chags but the English translation karmic imprint which make you think basically of the imprint of a hoof in the mental continuum in my opinion is extremely misleading. Misleading. Misleading because the Sanskrit when you think of what a karmic perfume is is very very different. So that’s the one case where Pamela encouraged me to retranslate some terms. I was very hesitant to do it But I think because of some habits which they already translated because frankly no one really understood what was happening in the sixties and seventies.
I mean, no one had the dictionaries and the facilities we have now. We in some sense senses have a misleading understanding of Buddhism because the English terms used to translate Buddhist concepts concepts have very heavy connotations, very heavy connotations. So that’s why I opted for definite emergence. Definite exit is just fine. Although exit again is really not present in the Tibetan but the meaning is the same.
Renunciation, if you say renunciation or speak of renunciation to someone with a classical western background, they think of a monk going to a monastery. Right? This is not what definite emergence is about. It can be trained in as a householder. It can be trained in as a monastic.
It’s a mental transformation. Then that’s pretty much that for translation. We do have to address the issue of the twelve twelve limbs and the two truths, don’t we? So are there volunteers? Anita?
Are there volunteers? Consciousness, name and form, six sources, contact, feeling, rebirth, aging, and death. But I wasn’t sure about the consciousness being the first one. Consciousness, name and form. Six sources or low, high.
Contact, feeling, rebirth or birth, aging, death. And which would be the noble truth of the origin of suffering? All of them. All of them? All of them.
Okay. Any other answers? Is what? Yes. Compositional factors.
Of action. Yes. Craving appropriation and existence. Yes. So you have my notes, don’t you?
Well, I was looking up. Yes. That’s correct. I checked. Does that is correct.
Why would that be the case? Because their predecessors, the those three six A Christmas to five, not six. Sorry. Okay. Ignorance is an affliction.
Yes. Saving is craving and appropriation is affliction. Yes. Very good. Existence is a karma.
Compositional factors is a karma. And I posit consciousness for the first three craving appropriation and existence as being origins because they’re of the nature of afflictions, karma and they are consciousnesses. They’re being consciousnesses is not a reason for being the noble truth of origin. Okay. Right?
That’s not a sufficient reason. Otherwise, you’re right. So what we have is we have two karmas and three afflictions. The two karmas are the second and the tenth link. Alright?
Compositional factors and existence which is a karma, the karma immediately inducing rebirth. So karma by definition is the noble truth of origin. Right? And then we have three afflictions which is ignorance and as you said very rightly, craving and appropriation, two forms of desire. Appropriation is an intensification of craving which leads to the maturation of existence.
Then afflictions also by definition are the second noble truth, the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Then everything else is the first noble truth. The seven remaining limbs. Right? Including consciousness.
Including consciousness. Yes. So you would have consciousness, name and form, the six sources, contact, sensation and then the last two limbs, birth and aging and death. Right? But these seven limbs are suffering.
Then the cessation of the noble truth of the origin of suffering, the five limbs I mentioned first, affliction and karma leads to the cessation of the noble truth of suffering, the remaining seven limbs. It’s very powerful way to train the mind this one. If you can, it’s not easy. I mentioned it because Geshe-la brought up the 12 limbs. If you can train a bit your understanding of the four noble truths in correlation with the 12 limbs, now that’s very powerful.
Cessation of the noble truth. You you said there were five. What were the first five? So the first you have five limbs which are the noble truth of the origin of suffering. Seven limbs which are the noble truth of suffering.
Are the five limbs which are the noble truth of the origin of suffering? Three limbs of afflictions and two limbs of karma. So the three limbs of affliction are respectively ignorance, craving and appropriation And the two limbs of karma are the second limb compositional factors and the tenth limb existence. It’s a very powerful way to train the mind. Jim, did anyone have a look at the 12 limbs in the reverse order and the two last truths?
Yes. Okay. That’s a difficult one. I won’t give you any answers today, but I thought you might want to have a look at it. Clearly if in the reverse order the cessation of ignorance leads to the cessation of the second limb compositional factor etcetera, etcetera, etcetera down to the twelfth limb is a description of the process of cessation of saṃsāra in other words liberation.
Then there must be a correlation between the cessation of the 12 limbs. In other words, we say the 12 limbs in the reverse order and the two last truths. But which goes into what? That is the question And why? I thought that the it was a bit along the lines of Jill’s reasoning as well that the ones that the origin, the second truth become the fourth truth because they’re mind and the ones that are the first truth that are suffering becomes cessation.
Was an All of you seem or some of you seem to labor under the under the delusion that because something is mind, it is a noble truth of the origin of suffering. Why? Who said that? Me. Ah.
Okay. I wasn’t there for discussion, so I wasn’t Okay. We found we found the source. Found the source. Source.
No. Path is consciousness. Path is Path is consciousness. That was where that logic came from was the path Then how does path being consciousness entail that all consciousnesses which are contaminated must be the noble truth of the origin of suffering? Yeah.
Because. It was late. You know? It was late. Okay.
That’s a very good reason. The better reason than most. No. There’s no correlation. Okay?
There’s no correlation. Noble truths of suffering are what? They are mainly but not exclusively sensations. All sensations are mind. Right?
So the Geshe gave a very nice example. When the delusion anger arises within our mind and as a result of this, the sensation of mental suffering, you know, the fretfulness which goes with anger arises. That sensation of fretfulness is a mind. Right? It is a noble truth of suffering.
Anger itself is a noble truth of the origin of suffering. Then cessation we leave aside, it’s a bit complicated, you know, most cessation are negative phenomena, as negative phenomena they are permanent. We want to enter into that now. Noble truths of the path, yes, our minds. Yes, that is correct, you know.
But the question and I just let you think about it is how to place the 12 limbs in the reverse order in the two last truths and the problem you face is that the third noble truth, noble truth of cessation includes permanent phenomena, right? So some cessation like the cessation of ignorance would qualify, whether others would or not you have to see. Then obviously does anything go in the noble truth of the path is the question, right? Because the noble truth of the path as consciousness includes only impermanent phenomena. So it’s it’s not an easy one but it’s interesting.
Well, just think about it. It’s not easy. Casually, we say the noble truth of the path is the cause of the noble truth of cessation. It’s an incorrect way to express oneself Because as a noble truth of cessation is a permanent phenomenon, it can have no causes. So it is in dependence of the noble truth of the path that noble truth of cessation is attained.
That’s the correct way to put it. You cannot establish a causal relationship between the two. Does anything go into the noble truth of the path or cessation? I just missed Noble truth of the path is for fitting the 12 limbs in is a problematical one. Right?
You have to see how to do it if it’s possible. It has to be possible. Right? If we’re going to say which is clearly asserted that the 12 limbs in the forward order fit in the two first truths then the 12 limbs in the reverse order have to fit somehow in the two last truths. That’s a logical necessity.
Well, yes. It’s also the fact that the two last truths depict the process of egress out of sense Yes. cyclic existence and the 12 noble the 12 limbs in the reverse order also describe the process of egress out of cyclic existence. So they have to be correlated. Remember Geshe-la said that’s really a very nice summary.
When cyclic existence is expanded, you get the two first noble truths. When these are expanded, you get the 12 limbs in the forward order. When nirvana is expanded, you get the two last truths. When these are expanded, you get the 12 limbs in the reverse order. I just look into it.
It’s interesting and very good mind training. And do you have questions about what we covered today? Could you give us a little bit more explanation of the 12 limbs in reverse order to help us try and do the homework? Because I’m not sure that I actually understand that at all. The 12 limbs in the reverse order refer to the fact that since the 12 limbs in the forward order are a causal sequence, The first limb is a cause of the second limb which is a cause of the third limb, etcetera.
Then the cessation of the first limb leads to the cessation of the second limb, leads to the cessation of the third limb, etcetera. Right? But those are the 12 limbs in the reverse order. Then there is a more detailed way of presenting them over two or three lives. We won’t do that here.
Thought it was actually done. Yeah. Ignorance, aging, death, birth. If you want to do it precisely, that’s the way to do it. But that that you will have a bit of a hard time with.
That you have a hard time. That is the best way to do it. The cessation of the first order leads to the cessation of the second I’m sorry. The sec the cessation of the first limb leads to the cessation of the second through to the cessation of the twelfth, Then beyond the cessation of the twelfth, I mean, each of those is impermanent, but you’re then going from those 12 aspects of the path into a total permanent cessation. Yeah.
Cessation but permanent. As I say, it’s off the chart. nirvana is, you know But it’s inter permanence. Into permanence. You’re saying it’s been is a permanent state of cessation.
Secessions are all permanent phenomena. Yeah. All of them. You know? But accepting You’re saying that there’s a problem in perceiving how impermanence, impermanent, impermanent features along the impermanent limbs along the along the path can result in permanence.
It’s not a problem. It is just a way of expressing things. Casually in a in a center like this, we say the noble truth of the path leads to the noble truth of cessation. But if we want to be precise, Geshe-la mentioned it a couple times, we actually have to say in dependence on the noble truth of the path, one attains the noble truth of cessation. Just look into it quietly.
I don’t want to make you too dizzy with this one. You know, I can see that some of you are holding their heads which is kind of that we want to we want to go back to simpler topics. Do you have questions about today? Yeah. Yes.
I heard that the if you do the cessation of the craving, which is the easiest one Mhmm. That will break the change of the the the limb go on Because the ignorant, we don’t you know, usually, we everyone is beginningless ignorance, but the craving, you can spot it and, you know, decrease that change and then it will break the chain. Is it correct? It’s a very, very good question. Does anyone have an opinion about this one?
Susan was saying that she has credit said that if instead of trying to cease ignorance, one ceases the eighth limb craving then since craving craving is evident to us, this is a fast track. Fast track to liberation. Does anyone have a comment about this? Yes. My comment is from life experience in stopping smoking and the phrase used was what create why are why one smokes one cigarette is because of the is because you smoked the previous one.
It’s a continuum. Stop between the previous cigarette and the next. It’s it’s something about it’s crudely put, but it’s something about What did Geshe-la talk about this morning? That’s about calm abiding. Yes.
Exactly. And that’s stopping feeling, isn’t it? Yes. And he was talking about calm abiding. He never mentioned them by name.
Referring to whom? Yes. Hīnayāna. No. No.
No. No. He was referring to whom? He never mentioned them by name. Buddhist teachers.
Buddhist teachers. Yes. In other words, the great Indian yogis and pre Buddhist and post Buddhist practitioners. What he was saying was that there are people of exceptional capacity who have never like us received teachings of any type and through their own understanding of the vanities of this life turn away from these transitory pleasures and look inwards and looking inwards they they find stable mental happiness. What I show you the bliss, the joy of concentration and they view this as liberation.
Now that’s exactly what your question is about. If and that is someone who focuses on the eighth limb actually would be an Indian non-Buddhist practitioner. Even though the 12 limbs are not presented in non-Buddhist Indian traditions, that is the outlook. There is craving. Craving is a source of suffering.
It’s already an exceptional person who understands this. Then the only way to eliminate craving is to turn the mind inwards from exterior objects. So they’re working directly at the level of the eighth limb And then it is clear that when you gain Samādhi and this is if you read Patanjali’s Yoga Sutras, it’s marvelous because these are the great beings of the past who were trying to understand how to get out of the mess we’re in And these are beings which are way above ourselves. They sincerely believe that Samādhi was liberation. So in Samādhi, there is no craving at all.
But there’s no feeling except this. Right? There’s no feeling. There’s no feeling. There’s no There’s nothing so there’s nothing that you’re responding to except the interior milieu.
Then the Samādhi is read in a special way. The Samādhi is read as the union of Ātman and Brahman. Yeah. The inside Ātman and the exterior God. But their answer to suffering is a very powerful one and that’s what the people you were talking about I think fell into the trap they fell into because during Samādhi, there are no afflictions of any type.
We say in the Buddhist text it is said they exist latently but the debate always runs well, how do you know they exist latently? Well, you know they exist latently because they can be triggered after if you try hard enough. It’s not terribly convincing. It’s not a permanent It’s not a permanent state. And it’s the mistaken.
It’s not liberation or Buddha Buddha or something. So it’s mistaken. Mhmm. And they have to stay in that state. If they come out of that state, then they revert to what they were before.
Yes. I mean, that’s a textbook answer. But what I thought was very impressive with Geshe-la’s presentation this morning is the degree of respect extended to these beings. I mean it’s all very nice and fine to say that they revert to the previous order. Nobody in this room has those attainments.
You know? Nobody. I mean, these are people who could Udraka Ramaputra, one of Buddha’s teachers who attained the fourth dhyana could stay in meditation for years, you know. And Buddha himself followed that path. That’s the key.
Buddha himself followed this path, attained those dhyanas and realized it was not enough, you see. And that is why the understanding that one has to counter ignorance is not an easy one. It’s not an easy one. Then I think generally speaking, most of us do not meditate. The people who do meditate, they gain when they start meditating seriously, very powerful experiences of bliss.
This bliss is highly addictive and it is a common pitfall for many young Buddhists to basically end up if you wish hooked on the bliss. Right? And in that case, one is really practicing like Udraka Ramaputra. Excuse me, Natalie. You wanted to ask something.
Yes. Just in response to what Susan said. I do think that my understanding is that quite a lot of Theravadin practitioners actually the strong core of their practice is to actually a type of renunciation where they remove themselves from worldly pleasures and so forth and take a more simplistic or simple lifestyle and basically to avoid craving. Well, that’s the basic problem with the term renunciation, which is that you’re reading definite emergence in terms of a lifestyle which it is not. The the lifestyle of the forest monks is one designed to enable them to protect their vows and you can ask my wife, she has considerable experience with the monasteries in Thailand.
And then they strive for renunciation for definite emergence excuse excuse me. And once definite emergence has been generated within their mind stream, then they strive for liberation relying on Satipatthana. In the contemporary Thai tradition, the practice of calm abiding is heavily discouraged and it’s basically becoming almost a secret tradition for various reasons. Yes. So based on what was just said, is that why the road to cessation is a combination of Samādhi and the wisdom realizing emptiness?
Because it directly attacks both the the feeling craving union and ignorance. Yes. That’s exactly it. Yeah. That’s exactly it.
Whether you presented from the standpoint of sūtra or tantra, full enlightenment is the result of a union of calm abiding and insight. Yes. Then it gets very complicated. It’s really worth reading over and again Tsongkhapa’s section on insight because Tsongkhapa points out drawing on the Samadhiniromochana Sūtra that all realizations of saṃsāra and nirvana and by realizations he obviously refers to the paranormal powers arise as a result of calm abiding and insight. That is something really worth investigating and whether there is in the Indian yogic tradition a union of calm abiding and insight that’s also worth investigating.
Insight is not necessarily focused on emptiness. Insight is an analytical meditation which occurs within the framework of fixative meditation. You have a core of, excuse me, you have an envelope of fixative meditation like calm abiding and within that calm abiding focus let’s say on an object, it might be emptiness to the same, you have an inner core of analysis which does not trouble the mind enough to remove it from calm abiding. It is said to be akin, which is Tsongkhapa says it’s akin to a fish jumping in the water. The fish does not trouble the flow of the river.
Then for us this is difficult to conceive of. Difficult to conceive of. That’s just on purpose image. Of the fish. The fish.
Fish. And finding an insight. But it’s very helpful for us. All of us are really beginners in this field to go back to the foundations of Indian philosophy to understand what the great Indian yogis of the Upanishads were looking for. They were looking for Mokśa.
Why they were looking for Mokśa? Their reasons were the same as the reasons for which the Buddhists and the Jains are looking for Mokśa. So we have what I have called a Gangetic framework. The framework of the practitioners of the Ganges river valley arose around probably 700 BC from 700 to 400 BC and there are common features in Hinduism, certainly in the Upanishads, in the Jain, and in the Buddhist traditions. The answers they give are different but these common features are things we have to be familiar with.
The belief in reincarnation appears at this period. It is a shared belief. The belief in saṃsāra as a wheel of reincarnations appears also in this Gangetic milieu. The belief that saṃsāra is suffering appears at that time. It’s very striking.
There was a big shift in Indian thought. Ancient Indian thought in the Vedas like the Rig Veda does not view existence as suffering at all. Existence is seen as something very pleasurable. The Rig Veda, the Yajurveda, the Samaveda. Existence is viewed as pleasurable and really the Rig Veda in terms of sensitivity are rather close to the old testament.
The function of man is to maintain universal order through sacrifice. It’s a function of the priestly caste, the Brahmin. Then we have a movement which appears around the seventh century BC which contests the primacy of the Brahmin caste. This is a Gangetic movement, the Sanyasis who leave the householder state and say that they are the true Brahmins and to be a true Brahmin is to practice Brahmacharya, the conduct of the Brahmin which means celibacy. Now Buddha Śākyamūni is a direct product of that milieu.
If you read the Dhammapada, very striking. There’s a whole section where the Buddha says the true Brahmin is not the one who performs the sacrifices. The true Brahmin is the one who tames his mind. The true Brahmin is the one who practices celibacy. In other words, you have a redefinition of the Brahmin caste.
Now within that milieu, there was a consensus whether you look at the founder of the Jain tradition Mahavira who preceded Buddha by a century a bit less. Buddha himself, Buddhist teachers, there was a consensus. Everyone reincarnates. Reincarnation is suffering. It’s a dreadful state of affairs.
We must seek an end to this. The answer differs. Everyone agreed that there was a misperception of the nature of the self as Geshe-la said this morning. This is core consensus in Indian thought and by extension Asian thought. Then where the disagreement arose is that the Upanishads eventually led to the development much later of the Vedanta in which the misperception of the nature of the self is that the self is perceived as limited whereas it’s unlimited and godlike.
And in opposition to this Buddha taught the misperception of the nature of the self is that there is no such thing as a permanent one and independent self. But both agreed as you said Susan that the eighth limb must be ceased. It’s very helpful for us I think to look at these ancient Indian roots of Buddhism. Then I’m sorry I developed that one a fair bit, but do you have any questions? Please.
I was gonna ask before and what I was trying to get at with the anesthetist. The anesthetist. Yes. Yeah. Would you be able to show us on the board with your diagram what you meant?
Where did the anesthetist come up? I’m What we were talking about before, how you said that the pain well, it was the same as the diagram that the pain happiness is defined by pain. Well, that’s what I was showing just now. Shall I show it again to you? Yeah.
I will I think yesterday have a copy of that as well. Could I have a printed copy of that? I’ll try to get one for you if you have a USB stick. I can bring one tomorrow. Well, yes, tomorrow.
I’ll bring my computer tomorrow then. Okay. I’ll give that to you tomorrow. Were you talking about the the Christian who deals with the dead people and or or with ill people and then meditates on on death impairments like Tsongkhapa? I think the crux of it was that happiness was defined by pain.
Yes that’s what I was showing on the chart there where basically the decline in pain is understood as happiness. And Tsongkhapa gives the example of a boil then it’s a bit awkward because I think as Westerners none of us have boils anymore. Right? The Tibetans had lots of boils. What are they?
Boils. But that’s boils are eruptions. So Tsongkhapa says, when a boil is inflamed and don’t do this, you hit it. This is the suffering of suffering. Then if you’ve had a boil, you’ll understand.
Then when the boil is not inflamed and you do nothing to it, this is all pervasive suffering. That was the boil is there, it is ready to lance you with pain. I used to have them because I lived in India. It’s ready to lance you with pain but you don’t do anything. And finally, if you are a masochist and you’ve just hit your own boil and it’s hurting like nothing and you pour freezing water on it, that is a suffering of change, happiness because you have a very sharp reduction in pain and that is experienced as great happiness.
So that’s with the anesthetist. That’s probably when they give them the medicine to dull their pain? Then I I don’t really know how anesthesia works myself. I’m not trained in the field. You know, I I can’t help you too much there.
But I’ll bring my computer tomorrow where you can copy. It’s in the presentation of the four noble truths. I think you’d find it helpful. Yeah. Very good.
Then I must apologize. It’s 02:15 unless you have a very, very short one. I just thought of a possible problem case for the pleasure is only the absence of pain in mice and rats who have been trained to respond who’ve who’ve been given up the opportunity to have limitless cocaine, they will press and press and press and press and press until they die. That seems like a more appetitive behavior than just avoiding pain. So Is I can tell I that a is that a possible possible problem for the theory?
I I’m very I’m very I have a lot of affinity with the theory. I think it’s a really good one. You’d have to look into the mechanism of addiction specifically to cocaine. Then I’m not quite sure it’s fully understood. It involves the mesolimbic system.
What exactly is happening, I think And dopamine. Yeah. Is still, you know, open to debate. There is a problem for this theory but it’s not that. Yeah.
Problem is the existence of nociceptors on the skin. Nociceptors, yes. That is the problem. Yeah. Yeah.
Yeah. So there are a series of sensation receptors on the body, on the epidermis which are receptive to various frequencies of stimulation. It’s astonishing how many receptors are. But there is one class of receptors called nociceptors which are only sensitive to pain. To pain.
Yeah. Then that has to be explained. That’s a problem. They’re mediated by substance P. That’s problem.
The others are not. Then as far as the visual auditory, other consciousnesses, no problem. As far as the tactile consciousness is concerned, nociceptors have to be explained. Then we have to stop here. Thank you very much.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- dhyana samten (Tib)
- An advanced form of concentration meditation after realizing shamatha (calm abiding). LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- samsara khor wa (Tib)
- Cyclic existence; the six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost, and animal - and three upper - human, demigod, and god. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
- three types of suffering dug ngäl sum (Tib)
- The suffering of suffering, the suffering of change and pervasive compounding suffering. LYWA
- twelve links of dependent origination pratitya samutpada (Skt); ten drel yen lag chu nyi (Tib)
- Also called the twelve dependent-related limbs or branches; the twelve steps in the evolution of cyclic existence: 1) ignorance; 2) karmic formation; 3) consciousness; 4) name and form; 5) sensory fields; 6) contact; 7) feelings; 8) craving; 9) grasping... LYWA
- two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
- The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.