Lam Rim – 2015-09-23 – KR

1 h 29 min · 3,843 words · 23 September 2015

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim - 2015-09-23 - KR
Loading
/

Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

About this talk. The talk covers the four sufferings of birth, aging, sickness and death, arguing that the suffering of aging is mainly mental and rooted in self-cherishing. It then explains the self-grasping ignorance behind the afflictions, the self as a mere conceptual imputation on the aggregates, and emptiness with the example of the moon’s reflection in a pond. Questions and answers on individuality, autonomy, and composite and non-composite phenomena follow.

File metadata (for organising)

Duration: 1h 30m

UUID: e6e97824-1f4d-4f3c-a9dd-24db8e0cad4f

Date: 2015-09-23

Words: 3,839

Generally speaking in human society, we experience four types of suffering. The suffering of birth, of aging, of sickness and of death. Now all the suffering of sickness and of death are natural sufferings. In a sense, we create our own suffering of aging. Now regarding the suffering of birth, all of us have a mammalian birth in this world as human beings.

And while we do not remember it, there was suffering which accompanied the birth process for ourselves and our mother. Whereas the sufferings of birth and of sickness are physical sufferings, there is no relationship whatsoever between the suffering of age and physical suffering. The suffering of age is mainly mental suffering, it arises from fantasies fancies. So as we grow older indeed, there are particular physical problems associated with age but you can clearly see for instance when you hit a given age like the age of 40, it is not as if suddenly disease strikes you from the sky. Instead, when you hit the age of 40, there is an interior feeling of unhappiness which arises.

This is the suffering of age. All people are young 16, 17, 18 up to their twenties. You know, sufferings are not present and they talk about their age quite casually. By the time they reach 30 and even more so when they move on to 50, the topic of one’s age becomes taboo. This is a clear sign of the mental suffering which we call the suffering of age.

Then obviously society is deferred. In Tibetan society for instance, we are quite direct and quite blunt. So when we meet someone, we ask them first their name and they give you their name precisely and then we say, just how old are you? And they give you their age without any more to do about it. And if they are 70, 80, 81, 82 then we say, my goodness you’re really well preserved for your age.

Then 81, 82 back in the old days in Tibet was very rare. Now perhaps it is a bit more common. In Tibet, when we see someone who’s overweight, we say, hey, fatty. You must be happy. Then obviously, it is not how things are done here.

Right? Really, exactly. [unclear]

So we have to make the distinction between physical and mental suffering and however great physical suffering may be, mental suffering is greater and we must be aware of this. So where precisely does the suffering of old age arise from? What is its origin? Its origin is none other than self cherishing. This wish to remain a little bit longer.

Now regarding the state of our Arhathood or the state of liberation, this is a state which we definitely could attain within this life if we tried hard enough. We are unable to attain it because we do not try hard enough. If one were to attain the state of an Arhat, then most definitely one would not experience in that state the suffering of old age which is a mental suffering and I’m referring here to the impending existence within the 12 links. Now once one has attained the state of an Arhat on the basis of these contaminated aggregates, the physical component of the suffering of disease will definitely be present. Now once one attains the state of an Arhat, Arhat dependence on contaminated aggregates such as these, war indeed one continues to eat food and one continues to drink fluid whether there is craving with respect to food or to fluid is something which is definitely worth examining.

Now once one attains a state of an Arhat, progressively consciousness has become ever more subtle, one experiences consciousnesses which are no longer contingent on these contaminated aggregates. Now when one attains a state such as an Arhat dependence on these contaminated aggregates and by these contaminated aggregates, I literally refer to this body of flesh and blood, then for so long as we are in this world, one does experience experiences of heat, extreme heat and of cold, extreme cold. In our mind streams at present for all of us, we find the coarse afflictions such as desire, anger, jealousy, competitiveness. For so long as these coarse afflictions are present within our mind stream, for so long will we have to depend on coarse contaminated aggregates? War there is physical suffering, there can also be mental suffering but this mental mental suffering arises from the afflictions.

It arises from the condition of anger, the condition of desire, the condition of jealousy or the condition of competitiveness. Now, the first step is to identify the afflictions within our mind stream. To identify for instance anger as anger. And then one must investigate whether anger can be abandoned or not. In other words, whether anger can be expelled from our mental continuum or not.

Now anger is a form of consciousness, unlike earth and stone which can actually be carted out. So we must investigate the source, the origin of afflictions such as anger. And the source, the origin of these afflictions is none other than self cherishing or the ignorance which apprehends a self. This ignorance which apprehends at a self, in other words, the I must be eliminated. Then is this possible or not?

And more oddly you might think if I eliminate the ignorance apprehending the self, who exactly is going to feel things? Precisely because we have a very strong habituation to the apprehension of a self. We fear when we eliminate this apprehension of a self that we will be bereft of all sensation, we’ll be akin to a chunk of stone. This is not the case but it is due to our great habituation to the apprehension of a self that we experience these fears. So it is precisely because beings in this world of ours are so accustomed to sensory stimulation from exterior physical objects which are the sole source of sensory stimuli for the five sensory consciousnesses that we find it inconceivable to function within without such sensory stimuli and that when this sensory stimuli is eliminated, we sink into a comatous state.

Now once one has gained the experience of deep mental bliss from deep within, it is perfectly possible to put an end to sensory stimuli and remain aware. I am personally convinced that someone who has gained such experiences of mental bliss would not fall unconscious if one gave him an injection of morphine. I am profoundly convinced that it is possible to move beyond this fascination with sensory consciousnesses and as is said in a sūtra, that mind whose nature is of clear light which goes beyond mind. Now this is precisely the sort of mind we have no experience of but we could gain an experience of. So one should therefore understand clearly the four sufferings, the sufferings of birth, aging, sickness and death and the afflictions they arise as a condition of.

And then to understand this, one must listen very carefully. Otherwise, it is meaningless to receive advanced teachings such as teachings on emptiness and to be unable to understand them. So here we should abandon laziness in general and specifically these three types of laziness. So these three laziness. The three lazinesses are first, the laziness which says I do not understand.

I have no memory or no recollection of this. The second is the laziness of engaging in wrong deeds and the third is the laziness of ignorance. So when you attend teachings, you should concentrate on the meaning and listen with all the intensity you can and if you can retain 100% of the teachings that is perfect. That is not possible. However much you can retain 90%, 80%, 70% that is still okay.

What is not good is to be totally unaware of what is being taught and this is why one must put effort. From my own side, when I teach a topic and I have the impression that you don’t really understand what is being said, I feel tired. When on the other hand, I have the impression that probably most of you have a sense of what I’m saying, I feel inspired. Therefore, listen carefully. So in this context, we want to put effort at reflecting on these topics and specifically at reflecting on the topics which are mentioned in the Lamrim, the thoughts of the afflictions, the quality of liberation and the features of emptiness.

This is so that we will become able to eliminate the ignorance of self grasping. Now, this is only something which is possible through effort. Now, when we refer to ignorance, ignorance is a consciousness. But this ignorance of self grasping is a consciousness which is mistaken with respect to its object, which is mistaken with respect to its object of observation. In other words, its object of observation does not exist in reality.

So self grasping is a mistaken mind. As a mistaken mind, its object, its object of observation is also mistaken. In other words, it does not exist in reality and this can best be understood through an example. The example of the reflection of the moon in a pond. We all know that even though the reflection of the moon appears in the pond, the moon itself is not in the pond.

So when we address the issue of self cherishing, we can see that what is critical is to understand the mode of understanding of the self and regarding our own self we can see that our own self appears to exist within the aggregates and it appears to exist within the aggregates without depending on anything else. Be careful. Listen to me. So when this very powerful predilectional conception which sees an I within the aggregates arises, then independence on this a very strong pride, very strong competitiveness, contaminated competitiveness, very strong jealousy can arise. So as this sense of an I which is present within the aggregates and which is autonomous increases, this sense of autonomy itself increases and this sense of autonomy connects with the ignorance which grasps at a self.

This is the root of the afflictions. Do you understand? That’s good. Very important. Now this does not exist but it is not sufficient to give teachings or to explain this.

This is something which must be understood through one’s own experience. So this powerful sense of an I which exists within the aggregates and the predilection or the conception which grasps this are grasping a non-existent object. This autonomous, this independent I does not exist. What does exist is an I which is a mere conceptual imputation on the basis of designation which are the aggregates. So this independent, this autonomous I which we think exists within the aggregates, this is non existent.

This does not exist. How does the I exist? The I exists as a mere conceptual imputation. Now, when we say that this I arises dependently on a conception or in dependence on conceptuality, we’re referring to the actual mode of existence of phenomena. We’re referring to reality.

And when I asked you previously to listen carefully, if now you are listening to this teaching on emptiness and on the view and you think I am listening. Then in this thought, I am listening. In this conception, I am listening. That conception is connected to I, isn’t it? So this is, there is no other conception in this context than the conception which thinks I am listening.

Likewise, most of you are taking notes. When you take notes, you think I am taking notes. That conception thinking I is connected or blended with the I. This is what we refer to. In other words, the I arises as an imputation on the basis of imputation, the hand as well as the conception thinking I.

And therefore, if I take my own self, Geshela, myself exists not independently or not within the aggregates but it exists exclusively as a conception imputed on that basis. Okay. No worry. Do not worry. This is difficult indeed but it is something one will understand over time. After all, our teacher Buddha Śākyamūni accumulated merit during three countless eons to attain enlightenment and in our own sake, in our own case, excuse me, to attain enlightenment we need both method and wisdom and the wisdom component is none other than an understanding of emptiness.

This is not an understanding which we will gain in an hour or so attending a teaching, it is an understanding we will gain over the years. So as we understand that the I is a mere conceptual imputation and as our understanding of this increases in turn the sense that the I exists autonomously and independently within the aggregate aggregates dwindles. As it dwindles in turn the afflictions dwindle. So the sense that the I does not exist independently or autonomously within the aggregates, this is emptiness. So it is easier to understand something about emptiness when it is explained verbally like this.

It is somewhat more difficult to gain an experience of emptiness. So within the context of generating the motivation or meditating during a couple of seconds, let us reflect first on whether or not the I exists independently or autonomously within the aggregates and in addition, let us ask ourselves whether the I can exist only in dependence on conceptuality or not. These are important topics. Let us meditate during a couple of seconds. So within the outline of the Lamrim, we have reached the two sub outlines.

The mode of striving for liberation, in dependence on an understanding of the two truths, the truth of suffering and of the origin of suffering and the mode of striving for liberation through understanding the 12 links. These are summarized versions. Now as far as the mode of understanding or striving for liberation through understanding the 12 links is concerned, the root of the 12 links is the first link which is ignorance and this refers to the beginningless ignorance. Through eliminating the beginningless ignorance by the application of wisdom, we are able to put an end to the 12 links. So we shall now give a slow progressive commentary on beginningless ignorance, the ignorance which grasps at a self.

It is not possible to explain such a topic rapidly. So at present, I would like to say a couple of words about Aaron Trott’s situation. When Aaron was here, he started to try to study Tibetan and he put much effort into this and when Tenzin and myself saw this, we said to him that the best conditions for study which he had expressed an interest in were to be a monk in one of the great monasteries. This is something we have had direct experience of. There is nothing superior to studying in the Great Seat, Sera and Ganden and Drepung for someone who is intent on study.

Aaron repeatedly said that he was intent on study, that this was his sole focus and we were able to get him a five year visa. He said that he would study not for five years but ten or even fifteen years at that time, we were not aware of the sort of person he was. However, after arriving at Sera, he lasted only five days and after five days, he left the monastery without telling anybody what he was going to do and there were a large number of English speaking people he could have spoken to. There is a saying at the monastery, it is easy to rise but difficult to fall. In this case, it seems to have been the opposite.

Aaron did not follow the discipline and the rules of the monastery which he should have followed and left in discord with them. Then, Lopon Gaye, when he returned to Sera, discovered a letter announcing Aaron’s departure and informed Tenzin at once. Tenzin tried to get in contact with Aaron repeatedly by telephone, by email, using social chat like WeChat. Aaron never bothered to answer his attempts to contact him. There’s no benefit in saying much more on this topic at present.

I will take your questions on the I based on your experience. Yeah yeah yeah yeah. Then Tenzin asked me to say a couple words about Erin’s situation. I accepted to take Erin as a private Tibetan student after repeated entreaties even though I felt that because of his age it would be difficult for him to succeed. Then there are correct and incorrect ways to behave and there are very far reaching consequences when one behaves incorrectly as Aaron has done.

If which seems to have been the case, he was overwhelmed with the situation in the monastery, all it took was a telephone call to Tenzin to clarify the situation. So this has considerable consequences for us as a community. The first direct consequence is it will be very difficult in the future to get student visas for monastics from TBI who wish to study at CERA. Since the Indian government is aware that one of our students left India after having obtained a five year student visa within fourteen days. To obtain a student visa, the second consequence is the abbot of the monastery must sign the request.

It’ll be very difficult to ask the abbot in the future to sign the request for one of our students. And finally, Aaron was sponsored in his trip to India by a very generous sponsor of TBI. A large amount of money was dedicated to ensure that he could pursue his studies correctly. It’d be very difficult for Tenzin in the future to ask sponsors to help students when such an element of doubt exists regarding their sincerity. So the one thing which comes out very clearly in this very sad episode is a lack of honesty and a lack of sincerity and these are virtues which we as a community must cultivate.

It will not be possible for us to function as a community if we cannot trust the students. The immediate consequence from my standpoint is I have informed Jampel Kedrup and I will be informing the Geku of Sera Je, my teacher Geshe Kama Rinpoche that I will no longer provide language training to monastics who wish to study in India. From now on, monastics who wish to study in India will have to study Tibetan by themselves in India. This seems to be the only way to handle this situation. Yeah.

Question? Questions? I’m not sure if this is part of an I question, but what does Geshe-la see that generates motivation? So if you are not thinking about liberation or full enlightenment, then probably the origin of the motivation will be self cherishing. Otherwise, probably not.

And another, another question. Please forgive me if this is really a bit muddled. Autonomy arises from a sense of individuality. Are we not individuals? I mean, Richard will not experience my karma and my, you know, my putative, you know, I’m using the term with scare quotes around it, my.

My aggregates are my aggregates and my mind stream is singular, is it not? So the autonomy or the independence you are referring to is an autonomy and independence which arises in dependence on causes and conditions. That is not the autonomy or the independence we are referring to in the context of the discussions on the self where it is an autonomy and independence which does not arise in dependence on any conditions. This is not the autonomy or the independence we refer to in the context of the discussions on the self where it is an autonomy or independence which does not depend on any causes or conditions. The point that I’m trying to make is that in the first instance, all creatures have a sense of some autonomy simply because they are individuals.

Are we not individuals? I’m not saying we’re not independent. We’re we’re not dependent on everything else in the universe, in fact. I’m not disputing that at all. But is my mind stream an individual?

Do I share it with anybody else? And, you know, that doesn’t mean that it’s independent of an object. That doesn’t mean that it’s independent of a whole lot of things. But the experience of individuality is probably the beginning of a sense of autonomy. And I just want some clarification on whether we are in fact individuals.

Not independent individuals but individuals. That is reality, that is the way things are. We are different, we are separate, we are contradictory or incompatible. However, here we are speaking of a different type of independence or autonomy. We’re speaking of an independence or an autonomy which does not depend on anything else.

Ananda? Yeah. I’m sorry, I was not listening attentively enough. So I was just wondering if No problem. Yes, I’m sorry I wasn’t paying enough attention.

I heard towards the end, I arises on the basis of imputation as well as the conception thinking I and that these two are blended. But I don’t think I’ve I’ve written it down correctly. I was wondering if Geshe could repeat it. So the I arises principally in dependence on the conception which thinks I and in a subsidiary fashion, in dependence on the hand which is the basis of imputation. Okay and another question?

According to Lama Tsongkhapа Rinpoche, if I understand correctly, anything that is an object of dependent arising, it is an empty object. Is is this correct? If anything which is dependent arising is empty. Right? Yes, that’s a good way, it’s acceptable way to present it.

Whatever is a dependent arising is necessarily empty. Since it is because something is a dependent arising that it is not inherently established. [unclear] This is a hard topic.

Is emptiness is emptiness emptiness because of impermanence? Is that what makes it emptiness? You could present it like that but emptiness includes both composite and non composite phenomena. However, your line of reasoning is a good one because if one circumscribes emptiness to composite phenomena, then indeed the reasonings which understanding of emptiness lead to an understanding of impermanence and reciprocally since impermanence is defined as that which is momentary. In other words, that which disintegrates instant by instant.

Could Geshe-la please remind us what composite and non composite phenomena are? So composite phenomena are everything we perceive, everything we see is composite, it’s made of parts. Non composite phenomena are the empty components of that. Just one more? Is it possible to function conventionally while realizing emptiness?

So it is only through great habituation that one is able to gain a direct experience of emptiness. However, when one has a direct experience of emptiness, probably there is no person who can have the mode of appearance of this manifest as conventional phenomena. Thank you. Stop here tonight.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
basis of imputation dag zhi, tag zhi (Tib)
Also called “basis of designation” or “basis for labeling”, the object or valid base on which a label is placed as part of the third and most subtle level of dependent arising. LYWA
clear light ö sel (Tib)
The extremely subtle mind which is directly recognized as the culmination of successful tantric practice, and is also accessible or recognizable to ordinary beings at the time of death. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top