2 h 3 min · 3,977 words · 20 July 2011
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. The talk opens with a good motivation for listening, then teaches that deeds become virtuous or non-virtuous according to the motivation behind them, and that the 10 non-virtues cause suffering. It explains the three scopes of practice, the precious human rebirth, and the subtlety of karma and causality, including three kinds of karma. It ends by discussing the lower realms, judgement after death, and how denying karma and rebirth is a grave wrong view.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 2h 4m
UUID: d47db271-10f1-43bd-a4b3-da1ad63eae8e
Date: 2011-07-20
Words: 3,973
So we will at present generate the motivation to listen to these teachings on the three principles of the path, which is the very essence of the Mahāyāna, and when we attend teachings, if we generate a good motivation, those teachings turn to virtue. If we generate a wrong motivation, those teachings turn to evil, and if we generate a neutral motivation, just attending the teachings, those teachings go to waste. Therefore we should generate a good motivation. What is this good motivation? We should reflect that mother sentient beings are infinite in number and as vast as space, and that every one of them, just like ourselves, wishes to attain happiness and to be freed from suffering.
Nonetheless, they are completely unaware of how to attain happiness and how to be freed from suffering. We ourselves must help them. At present we are unable to do so. How would we be able to do so? We would only be able to do so, if we were able to eliminate all thoughts within our mind stream, and to actualize all qualities.
Once we have done this, we can benefit them. Therefore, we strive to attain that state where all thoughts are eliminated and all qualities are actualized for the sake of others. And with this as a motivation, we will meditate for one or two minutes, and offer the seven limb prayer. Śākyamūni said, do not perform any non-virtues and practice virtue to the fullest, tame your mind. These are the teachings of the Buddha.
So we are all similar, and that we all wish for happiness and we wish to eliminate suffering. The root of suffering is sin, which is the 10 non-virtuous deeds, the three of the body, the four of speech, and the three of the mind. Through knowing these, and through dispelling these non virtues, we are in turn able to dispel suffering. None of us likes suffering, therefore we should eliminate its cause, which is non virtue. Now, virtue, virtue has a call.
Regarding happiness, happiness has a cause, which is virtue. To establish the cause of happiness, happiness, which which is is virtue, virtue, we we must abandon the 10 non virtues. Then in dependence on this, happiness will arise. As human ārya beings, we have good levels of intelligence, of wisdom, and we are able to understand this. Animals are not.
And therefore, we should understand that deeds of body and of speech become virtuous or non virtuous in function of the motivation which impels them. So if there is a good motivation such as love, empathy, or compassion, the deeds of body and speech become virtuous. If, however, there is a non virtuous motivation such as desire, anger, jealousy, competitiveness, then these deeds become evil deeds, which lead to rebirth in the lower realms. Understanding this, we should try to generate a good motivation. Sleep, for instance, can turn into a virtuous or non virtuous deed in a function of the motivation we generate before going to sleep.
If before going to sleep, we generate the motivation of faith in the triple gem, of love and of compassion, our sleep turns virtuous. If on the other hand, before going to sleep, dark thoughts dawn in our mind, then our entire sleep turns down virtuous and creates a causes for rebirth in the lower realms. So at present we are not accustomed to this, therefore it is not easy for us. But training incrementally day after day, year after year, we can progressively improve and increase the part of virtue within our And if we take refuge in the Buddha, Dharma and Sangha, seeing the Buddha as the teacher of the path to liberation, the Dharma as that which enables one to attain the path to liberation through eliminating suffering, and the Sangha as friends which help us in the path to liberation, and thereby abandon practice the 10 virtues, then we will progress progressively upwards. Abandon And then there are three paths, one trains it.
The path which is shared with the being of small scope, the path which is shared with the being of middling scope, and the path of the being of great scope. Initially, we train the path which is shared with the being of small scope. And this training entails taking refuge, which involves the abandonment of the 10 non virtues, a practice of the 10 virtues, independence on which in future lives one will obtain a human rebirth. Then, in addition, one conjoins us with the practice of giving, or generosity, which guarantees that we will obtain wealth and prosperity in future lives, and one creates through patience the conditions for obtaining good friends and for meeting a spiritual teacher. Therefore, the crux of the practice of the being of small scope is to think or to focus on future lives.
And at present, we have a profoundly meaningful human rebirth which has the eight factors of the eight freedoms and the 10 endowments. This human rebirth must be put to good use. This good use is to try to attain in future lives either, higher status or definite excellence. This is the reason for which one has to focus on training in the human rebirth, otherwise there is no attainment of dharma apart from this. So for this reason, a precious human rebirth is called profoundly meaningful.
If something which is profoundly meaningful is put to a minor purpose, then it is wasted. In the same same way as for instance, if we have to give away $5 to get $1,000, we will not hesitate to do so. And this is clearly explained on page 15 of the translation, which points out the differences in presentation of how to train the mind in the Lamrim and in the three principles of the path. Otherwise, this life basically goes to waste, and there is a great risk of falling in the lower realms in future lives. So if we do not practice at present, we will be caught up eventually by death and impermanence, and this body will go to waste.
Therefore it is at present that we must practice in trying to attain both high status and definite excellence. Otherwise, the years, which are composed of months, which are composed of days, would eventually pass by and our life would have been wasted. So, here, when we speak of abandoning or relinquishing the vanities of this life, what do we refer to for the beginners? We refer to giving up the food, the inclothing and preoccupation with reputation of this life. Worldly beings are exclusively preoccupied with this.
Dharma practitioners, on the other hand, focus on future lives, and wish to actualize their welfare in future lives. So independence on this preoccupation with clothing, with food, and with vestments, We only accumulate sin and non virtue and are reborn in the lower realms. The duration of this life of ours is short. The duration of future lives is extraordinarily long. We will go alone without father or mother, without friends, without our body, and whether we obtain food or not will depend on our behavior in this life.
So if we wish in future lives to get a good body, to get friends, we must reflect carefully. We must abandon the 10 non virtues, and focus on the wheel of future lives. In addition, we must practice generosity or giving. This does not refer to giving necessarily material things or objects. If it refers to the mind of giving, if we give only $1, but dedicating it to all sentient beings, we will have accumulated a gigantic amount of virtue.
In addition, we must meditate on forbearance or patience towards one’s family members, one’s male and female friends, and independence on this, one will obtain a beautiful body, good friends, and one will meet with a spiritual teacher. It doesn’t get better than this. If we focus on this life, then we are not dharma practitioners and everything we do is sinful. If we focus on future lives, we are dharma practitioners. So the being of small scope strives for happiness in future lives and turns away from the vanities of this life, or the being of middling scope turns away from the vanities of all lives.
And for instance, turns away from wishing to be reborn as Indra, as Brahma, or as a wheel turning monarch, a Chakravartin, and turns away from wishing for the body and the wealth of such a being. We have been reborn as such many times in the past, and there has been no benefit whatsoever in that. So one who strives for that, and accumulates virtue for that is actually striving for the vanities of future lives. This is of no benefit whatsoever. There is a limited amount of happiness, but it is not lasting.
It gives rise to desire, and independence on this one is reborn in the lower realms. Therefore, these aspirations for future lives are not stable. We need something which is stable, and therefore we must create the motivation which strives for liberation, reflecting on the fact that karma and causality must be protected well, that cyclic existence is filled with thoughts, and therefore striving for liberation from cyclic existence, and also going for refuge in the triple gem, triple gem. With this, we can then attain liberation, and protecting well, our practice from the 10 non-virtuous deeds, and training of the 10 virtuous deeds. Upon obtaining liberation, we will have obtained a state of complete happiness, and we will have completely turned away from the vanities of this life, which have no essence.
And it is said in addition that karma and causality are subtler than the subtlest. What this means is that from within the threefold divisions of karma, karma of great weight, middling weight and small weight. And within each of these threefold subdivisions to that of greater than great weight, middling great weight and smaller great weight. In a likewise three fold subdivision for each of the two remaining divisions. Each of these gives rise to a corresponding effect.
So there is not the slightest of the small effects which goes to waste. And if we do not attain liberation from cyclic existence, since karma is subtler than the subtlest of all phenomena, we will again and again suffer from rebirth. And therefore, on page 17 of your commentary by Pabongka Rinpoche, it is said, after pointing out that causality is extraordinarily subtle, and if one is not freed from it, one will transmigrate again and again within cyclic existence with the effect of sin, that in addition, on point two at the bottom of page seventeen, one must turn away from all the types of karma which are motivated by an ignorance of the means of turning away from cyclic existence. Turning away here means to destroy, so all the types of karma in question must be destroyed, and ignorance, which is the foremost root of cyclic existence, must also be destroyed. Ignorance is akin to a benightedness, a darkness of the mind.
When for instance we are traveling at night on a road, we don’t see anything. That is a form of ignorance. What is the ignorance which is referred to here? It is the ignorance of the actual nature of phenomena, emptiness. Because of that ignorance, we are unable to attain liberation.
We do not become liberated, and in turn that ignorance acts as the main cause of suffering. It is said in Dharmakīrti’s Pramānavārttika, all beings of the three realms of existence. The three realms of existence are the realm above the ground, the realm at the level of the ground, and the realm below ground. So the realm above ground refers to divine beings, the realm at the level of the ground refers to human beings, and the realms below the ground refer to lower rebirths. This therefore refers to the totality of psychic existence.
This totality of cyclic existence is what the have abandoned. The themselves, even though they do have karma from the standpoint of the, nonetheless, are never reborn cyclic existence because they lack craving. Craving is akin to water in the relationship, in its relationship to a seed. If we plant seeds in a field without water, they cannot hope to sprout. Likewise without craving, even though karma is present within the mind stream of an arhat, it cannot give rise to karmic results because all afflictions have been abandoned.
And therefore, Ārya Vasubandhu says, one who has seen truth no longer experiences being impelled. Here, truth refers to the four noble truths or to selflessness, and being impelled refers in this context to impelling karma. So the quote from Vasubandhu indicates that once one has become an being, in other words, one has eliminated ignorance, one no longer accumulates karma. An ārya being is a being who has directly perceived selflessness or emptiness. In his being, resides the wisdom which has realized emptiness.
There is no longer ignorance in the mind of such a being. So Vasubandhu’s position is somewhat at odds with that of dharma kirti in the Pramānavārttika, since if we consider that impelling refers to impelling karma, then the world for Vasubandhu, there is no impelling karma in the mind of an ārya being. For dharma kirti, it would seem that there is. So the foremost root of suffering is ignorance, and without the realization of emptiness it is impossible to gain liberation from suffering and liberation in general. We therefore have to put effort in a comma and causality, in training in virtue, in abandoning the non virtues, and if we have committed non virtues, we should confess them.
In so doing, we engage in the training of ethics. On this basis, we can then give rise to the training of concentration, and on this basis, to the training of wisdom. This is why at the bottom of page 17 of Pabongka Rinpoche’s commentary, it is said, for that, one first needs to have conviction in causality, and for that, one must reflect on causality. So when we speak of causality, in Tibetan has two components, which means karma in Sanskrit, and which means the result of karma. So what is karma?
Karma is a mental deed which is performed intentionally by a person. This can be virtuous, non virtuous, or neutral. So if the motivation is virtuous, then a deed such as prostrating, practicing generosity, or protecting ethics becomes a mental activity which refers here to the mental accumulation of karma, and this eventually gives rise to happiness. On the other hand, with an evil motivation, with dark thoughts, such as anger or desire, a deed such as killing or stealing, killing for instance fish, killing deer, killing human beings, gives rise to a non virtuous karma whose result will be great suffering. Suffering.
Therefore, in a nutshell, karma is nothing else than deeds performed with intention. So, what actually within causality is the karmic causality we’re referring to here? When for instance, one sows seeds in a field and from these flowers arise, or when fruit trees give rise to fruits, this does not refer to karmic causality, because no intention is present. On the other hand, karmic causality arises when a human being, for that matter, an animal as well, a person, in other words, with an intention performs a deed. Animals, for instance, under anger will fight and so forth.
Then they accumulate non virtuous karma. So, there are three different categories of karma. Non meritorious karma, meritorious karma, and immutable karma. Non meritorious karma is the non virtuous karma accumulated through killing and so forth, which can lead to a rebirth in the hell realms as a hungry ghost or as an animal. Meritorious karma, he refers to contaminated virtuous deeds.
Contaminated virtuous deeds can lead to rebirth as a human being among others. While immutable karma refers to that karma which can give rise to rebirth as a god of the form or the formless realms. Generally speaking, virtue is divided into two, contaminated and uncontaminated virtue. So when one refers to contaminated virtue, this is virtue whose practice or whose generation is accompanied by the delusions. However, if one wants to subsume this, one can subdivide karma into two.
One can subdivide it into virtuous and non virtuous karma. Virtuous karma includes both contaminated virtuous karma and immutable karma. Non virtuous karma includes non meritorious karma. So, Rinpoche will stop here for today, and he would like to summarize what he taught. There are therefore three subdivisions of karma, non meritorious karma, meritorious karma and immutable karma.
And if they are subdivided into two for simplicity’s sake, we have two subdivisions of karma, virtuous and non virtuous karma. Virtuous karma includes meritorious contaminated karma and immutable karma. Non meritorious karma is non virtuous karma. And if you have one good question, I bet she will take it. Yes, You like the idea that there’s no hells?
No, I’m not saying that at all. Would it make you happy? And I’m gonna have problems translating this. Another part of the every impermanent phenomenon is the result of a cause. It’s the function of the cause that the impermanent phenomenon arises.
If the cause is great, the result will be great. If the cause is middling, the result will be middling. If the cause is small, the result will be small. So if one commits a great non virtue under the power of great anger or great desire, one will be reborn in the hell realms. If one commits a middling non virtue, one will be reborn in the hungry ghost realms.
If one commits a small non virtue, one will be reborn in the animal realms. Moreover, there are amplifications due to, for instance, the way in which a deed is performed. If one kills a large animal, which traditionally is said to suffer more, then one will be reborn in the hell realms. If one tortures a being one kills for a long time, then the deed is great through the power of the evil with which it is performed, and is also reborn in the hell realms. If after this one rejoices greatly in this, this also creates a cause for a rebirth in the hell realms.
So the result is proportional on the cause in the same way as in worldly matters, if someone commits a great crime, such as murder, he is assessed in function of the nature of the murder. Was it intentional murder with great savagery? Was it intentional murder, but expedited? Or was it an incidental, accidental killing? Punishment is proportionate to the intensity of the crime.
If the crime is extremely severe in some countries, it is a death sentence, or the person is put in prison for life. Otherwise the sentence is lower. So it is with karma and causality as with worldly matters. Matters. On And after death, we are examined by the king of the dead, by Yamaraja.
And Yamaraja has a precise tally of what the person did in this life. If the deeds of the person are very heavy, very sinful, then Yama Rāja instructs the helpers, the assistants of the Lord of Death to cast the being down in the hot or the cold hell realms, and to torture them appropriately. If on the other hand, the deeds of the being are lighter, and for instance are strongly connected with avarice or cupidity, then Yama Rāja sends them to the realm of the hungry ghosts. If the deeds of the being are yet lighter, then they are sent to be reborn as animals. Yamaraja has a mirror, the mirror of the king of the dead, within which the deeds of all beings, however small, can be seen.
In addition to this, every one of us throughout our life is accompanied by a deity of our body, a body protector if you want, who takes precise notes of what the person did, noting everything down, even the smallest deeds, and all of these are presented to Yama Rāja when we are dead and we are judged on this basis. One has to stay in whatever realm until the sin has been exhausted, until the karma has been exhausted, one cannot leave. So who overcame the lord of the dead? It is Manjushri, otherwise since beings in this world behave in any which way, then all beings would be reborn in the lower realms. So when we pass before, when we are examined by the king of the dead, by Yamaraja, then if we, if he sees in his mirror that we have behaved well, he congratulates us, and tells us, you will be reborn in the higher realms.
So it is exactly the same thing as far as dharma is concerned as it is in worldly matters. If you are examined by an examining magistrate and you have behaved well, you are allowed to leave, and if you have been a bad person, then you are cast in jail. Therefore either sends us to the higher realms or to the lower realms in function of what we have done. We can see this in representations of the 12 links of dependent origination where the lord of the dead, Kama Yama, is in the center of the wheel or contains the wheel? And in the center of the wheel, we have three animals, a cock, a pig, and a snake, which symbolize respectively desire, ignorance, and anger, and it is independence on these three that we transmigrate within cyclic existence.
This was taught by the arhats, the bodhisattvas and the Buddhas. Buddha himself taught that there were hell realms, that there were hot hells, that there were realms of the hungry ghosts and animal realms. Buddha abandoned lying, Buddha no longer lies. Then the word of the Buddha is So when one says that something which exists does not exist, when one says, for instance, that karma and causality, that liberation, that full enlightenment do not exist, this is called wrong views. This is an extremely heavy thought.
And within the 10 non-virtuous deeds, the three of the body, the four of speech and the three of mind, the three of mind are covetousness, ill will and wrong views. Wrong views is the severest of all, since wrong views is similar to anger, in that it annihilates the roots of virtue from their very depth. So if one says that past and future lives do not exist, karma and causality do not exist, the hot hells do not exist, liberation and full enlightenment does not exist. These are all wrong views. Rinpoche wonders when Pamela is looking at the vast ocean, if she wonders, was I a fish once upon a time or not?
It’s a very great thought, because Rinpoche knows this line of reasoning. Once one says there are no hell realms, and one says after all there are no lower rebirths, then if there are no lower rebirths, and there is no karma and causality, then there are no future, past or future lives, and there is no ethics, then one is indeed in the hells. If one accepts past and future lives in karma and causality, it is extraordinarily beneficial because on that basis, one practices dharma, one abstains from non virtue, practices virtue. Otherwise there is no foundation. Okay?
I would say I would like to add one thing. If there are no lower realms, if there are no ahats, there are no bodhisattvas, there are no buddhas, buddhas arise as a result of virtuous karma. Okay.
Key terms in this teaching
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- eight freedoms dalwa gyä (Tib)
- The eight states a perfect human rebirth is free of: birth as a hell being, hungry ghost, animal or long-life god; as a barbarian; in a dark age when no buddha has come; with wrong views; or with impaired faculties. LYWA
- higher realms
- The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
- hungry ghost preta (Skt); yi dag (Tib)
- The hungry ghost realm is one of the three lower realms of cyclic existence, exemplified by incredible insatiable hunger and thirst. LYWA
- lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
- The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
- three realms traidhatu (Skt); kham sum (Tib)
- The desire, form and formless realms. LYWA
- Yama shinchi dagje (Tib)
- The Lord of Death, seen on the Wheel of Life. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.