1 h 28 min · 3,919 words · 20 June 2018
Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
About this talk. Commenting on Je Tsongkhapa’s two verses on leisure, endowment and impermanence, the teaching urges using time for Dharma and turning away from attachment to food, clothing and repute. Reflecting on death makes repute seem illusory. The talk then begins the presentation of the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons, comparing non-Buddhist Indian views of a permanent self with Buddhist tenets, and ends with questions.
File metadata (for organising)
Duration: 1h 28m
UUID: ab7f8e53-8182-405c-a435-22751618d19f
Date: 2018-06-20
Words: 3,915
As Je Tsongkhapa says in these three principles of the path, leisure and rebirth are profoundly meaningful and life is transient, reflecting on this turn away from the vanities of this life. So this is something we should therefore reflect upon. It is through meditating inseparably on, on the one hand, leisure leisure and endowment, in other words, the human base which we have at present, and on the other hand, on death and impermanence that we can turn away from the vanities of this life. So countering the vanities of this life or turning away from the vanities of this life refers specifically to turning away from attachment to food, to vestment or clothing, and to repute. So here, when one refers to leisure and endowment, one is referring to a human life.
Life in Tibetan is or time. Now this is the same root as which means time. So when we refer to a human life, it is the time of being human. And this is precious. It is recognized as precious throughout the world because actually it is impossible to buy time.
We can buy anything else, but we cannot buy time. If we could, things would be very odd indeed. For this reason, from Geshela standpoint, it is perhaps the most precious thing of all. So here, Geshela is not speaking specifically from a dharma perspective, but just from an ordinary mundane perspective. In an ordinary mundane context, probably the most precious, the most important thing in this world is time.
It is impossible to buy time and therefore we should use our time meaningfully. We should not waste it because if we waste it, then we shall indeed be beggars. So therefore, irrespective of whether one is a dharma practitioner or not, time is precious. Then, specifically, as Geshela was saying, time runs to an end. Therefore, we put effort.
Then if time did not run to an end, if we had just an open ended amount of time, we would indeed be very lazy because we would procrastinate continually thinking, I can do it tomorrow, I’ve got time. Then here, as we reflect carefully on the rebirth of leisure in endowment, in other words, the base, the human base which we have now or the time of being human, And on its profound meaningfulness, this will induce an understanding and an appreciation of death and impermanence. Then Geshela will not explain at once the complete meaning of Je Tsongkhapa’s two verses, through reflecting on the fact that a rebirth of leisure and endowment is profoundly meaningful and that, time is fleeting, turn away from the vanities of this life because if you were to do so at once, we would not catch the meaning. Do you understand these two verses? You know them?
Yes. Recite them, please. You know them, right? So here, it is not possible to give rise to an understanding of the meaning without first having appropriated the verses. In other words, retained these two verses of the three principles of the path to reflecting on the fact that leisure and endowment is profoundly meaningful and that this life is transient.
Turn away from the vanities of this life. Then if you haven’t memorized the verse, then how is it possible to give rise to an understanding of the meaning, let alone meditate? Initially, one must memorize a verse. It’s only two verses. You know the mark.
Leisure and endowment are difficult to find and life does not last. Meditating thus, turn from the vanities of this life. Therefore, we should try to memorize these two verses. There’s only two verses. Everyone in this room can do that.
And here, through initially reflecting on the rarity and profound meaningfulness of a rebirth of leisure and endowment, this would in turn induce an understanding of death and impermanence. And likewise, through reflecting on death and impermanence, this would induce an understanding of the rarity and the preciousness of a rebirth of leisure and endowment. These two are therefore seen as inseparable. So therefore, through meditating on death and impermanence also, this meditation induces an understanding of a rebirth of leisure and endowment and its preciousness. You can see that each of these induces an understanding of the other.
Check for yourselves when you meditate. This is why the verse says through meditating. Think about it. It’s extremely helpful. None of you doesn’t have the time.
This is a case because when one reflects, on death and impermanence, one understands the uncertainty of the time of death. There is no way we can know when we will die. And when one understands the uncertainty of the time of death, this induces a profound appreciation for this human rebirth, which is profoundly meaningful. Then, if one does not turn it into something meaningful, what a beggar one will have been. Therefore don’t waste your time, it would be a great pity.
Then obviously we do need to do things to live, but apart from this one should endeavor to focus on dharma and one should not waste the time one has. After all, there are twenty four hours in the day. If one wastes a day, one has wasted those twenty four hours. Then at the end of it all, what a tragedy. Then it is completely in our control what we basically do day after day.
If day after day we put effort in this direction, then at the end of our life when we look back, we will say, well, my life was okay. I mean, it was alright. I did my best. And we will not feel it’s been a huge waste. It’s a good way to look at things.
And therefore, it is extremely important each day before going to sleep to recapitulate mentally what we did during the day. Our physical, our verbal, and our mental deeds mainly our physical and verbal verbal deeds, which are the causes. And then if we behaved in a meaningful way, well, then we should rejoice, and we should dedicate this to peace and happiness in this world. After all, that is what bodhichitta is all about. And if we didn’t behave well then what can be done?
We should confess and try to purify. Then there is nobody who wants ill for themselves. All of us want the good for ourselves, so we should lead good lives. Even bad people think that through leading bad lives, they’re accomplishing good things for themselves. So therefore, these two verses of the three principles of the path teach us how to counter the vanities of this life.
In other words, how to counter attachment to food, to vestment or clothing, and to talk, at least speech or repute in Tibet. Then the two first are self evident. The last one is difficult. It is difficult to counter attachment to repute because that ties up with the I. So please listen carefully, Geshela will explain how this counters attachment to repute.
If we take the case of a criminal who has been sentenced to death and will be executed within an hour. So now imagine that someone comes to see this criminal on death row who will be executed within the hour and says to him, don’t worry about a thing. I am going to give you thousands and thousands of dollars, and I will praise you greatly calling you calling you a hero. Is that going to assuage the mental suffering of the criminal at all? If not, why?
So if it is not going to assuage the suffering of the criminal on death row in the slightest, what is the reason for which giving thousands of dollars and praising will not assuage the suffering? In the same way as reflecting on death and impermanence reduces attachment to food and to clothing, to vestment. Also, it reduces attachment to repute because repute is seen as illusory, as a dream. So this is the reason for which meditating on death and impermanence counters attachment not only to food and to clothing, but also to repute. Simply because once one sees that life is transient short, then repute becomes illusory.
It’s difficult to see another way to counter attachment to repute apart from this one. It’s much easier to counter attachment to food and to vestment. But when it comes to repute to one’s good name with another person, that which we are so attached to is very difficult to So what other means to counter attachment to repute to one’s own good name can you propose? Yeah, you can, please. I was just thinking perhaps that repute isn’t inherently existent.
So one person might look at someone or like myself, look at me and to them I have a good reputation. Another person might look at me and actually think well you know she’s not very good at all. So it’s not an inherent characteristic. So maybe the impermanence and the repute, so it’s not inherent characteristic and that repute can change as well that you can have a good reputation one day and then you do something else and your reputation is bad. So that uncertainty and the changeability of repute and its impermanence and its lack of inherent existence could all be ways of countering attachment to one’s own repute.
So that is a good way of looking at it. One could also think that it would be inappropriate for one’s repute to be established by others and not by oneself. So therefore, one should reflect on this and one should also reflect on the fact that our own past and future lives exist, that they exist based on reasoning, based on analysis, and it is in dependence on the existence of our own past and future lives that practices such as turning away from the vanity of this life and practices such as the Lamrim are meaningful. And then we should generate the motivation reflecting on how we should endeavor to benefit others, not others in general in a different and far off country whom we have never met, because that is mere talk, verbiage, but instead others in the community we are a member of in this center that is profoundly meaningful. So let us therefore meditate during a couple of minutes on the motivation.
Over to page one. We recite one day, two, three, four, and also page five, number six, Mandal offering, verse one and three. Therefore it would be very good to study the cycles of meditation of the path shared with the small, with the middling, and of the path of the being of the great scope from now onwards. And if one is unable to study them, at least to understand them, to appropriate them, so that later on when the time comes to meditate, one will have thought about And therefore it will be ideal if you studied dharma at present, the lamrim at present, so that later on, when you are not burdened with family responsibilities, work, and so forth so forth in your sixties, seventies, eighties, maybe nineties, when you have free time, you have no work, the children have all left home, then you are able to do something with your time. You have a partner, a friend, an associate, which is the dharma.
Otherwise, without this, then you risk a total collapse of your mind, and you risk ending up with something like Alzheimer’s disease. And you walk around with a cane, right? So when we speak of dharma or lamrim, lamrim is dharma, then the reason, it is so beneficial is that it is a helper which helps us to get rid of the difficulties we encounter in daily life. When we encounter difficulties, we turn to dharma, we turn to lamrim to find a way to calm our mind. Without this, we have no way of calming our mind, and the difficulties Gisha talked about arise.
So at present, passing onwards to the view, Geshela will present the ultimate or final views, the view of the Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika system. And to do this, one must present the coarse and subtle selflessness of persons. As you remember, Geshela quoted the stanza of Ariadeva from Āryadeva’s Chatuhshataka, in which Ariadeva says, initially, counter the demeritorious. In the middle counter the self, finally counter all views. Finally counter all views, Geshela will explain later.
So this middle verse of the Chatuhshataka in the middle counter the self refers to countering the self of persons. As Geshela explained when commenting this verse, there are two forms of the self of persons, the coarse and the subtle self of persons. The person being empty of being permanent one and independent, and the person being empty of being a substantially existent autonomous entity. Now regarding the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent, this is probably an apprehension which can only exist in the mind stream of non Buddhist tirthikas, non Buddhist Indian practitioners. So as Geshela explained, one must understand the three characteristics of this apprehension of the self as permanent one in independent.
The impermanence of the self counters, the self being permanent. It’s being one means that it is partless. And in every case this view cannot be fully understood without understanding the view of the Sankhya school. So the the Sankhyas assert a self, a purusha, which which is And they assert that the self consciousness and cognition are synonymous. Have you read a little bit the Sankhya View?
So it’s inappropriate to try to understand this view of the self without understanding the presentation in Sankhya, which asserts that this person, this purusha, which is a self consciousness and cognition, pervades all beings. And because it pervades all beings, it is said to be partless. Then the presentation in Sankhya and Buddhism is surprisingly similar. Sankhya teaches that we transmigrate in cyclic existence because of our ignorance of the 25 objects of knowledge. Whereas Buddhism teaches that we transmigrate in cyclic existence through not understanding the 12 limbs of dependent origination.
Then Sankhya asserts only two of the 25 objects of knowledge to be ultimate truths, Prakrti and Purusha. Prakrti would be equated with ignorance in Buddhism. As to the remaining 23 objects of knowledge in Sankhya, they are taught by Sankhya to be conventional truths. Precisely because Purusha and Prakriti are ultimate truth, they are taught by Sankhya to be permanent. This is not easy, but then Geshela can’t only feed you easy broth.
He also has to feed you some difficult topics. So how do you understand the statement that it is partless within the Sankhya presentation of the 25 objects of knowledge. It is single without depending on parts. So how do you understand that? Then if you don’t know the 25 objects of knowledge, can’t answer the question.
I don’t know the 25 objects, but on the basis of what I remember of Geshela teaching, Okay. It’s partless because it is not dependent on the aggregates. Allah is asking you to explain the understanding, the sense, or the meaning of not depending on parts in a non Buddhist school of Indian philosophy. Then it’s inappropriate to explain the meaning of that in a non Buddhist school of Indian philosophy based on Geshela’s own understanding of this in a Buddhist school. This is Geshela’s outlook.
Excuse me, I wasn’t basing it on Geshela’s explanation of Buddhist position. I was basing it on what he said and I can quote it word for word on the June 6. That the third reason is exist. Okay, that’s okay, I know. It was it was you explaining about the non Buddhist view of partlessness that I gave that answer on the basis of that.
I think that some can say the person is one because the person of the past, present and future is the same person. So the issue here is have you read these books or not? If you haven’t read you can’t say anything, right? Yeah. Yeah.
Could I suggest something to you? Yeah. Please. In English, the Upanishads are very well translated by Patrick Olivelle in Penguin. It’s a short book, read the Upanishads, especially Chāndogya Upanishad and Brihadaranyaka Upanishad.
It explains the Hindu vision of the You see, this is very important. Their teaching is actually very beautiful. And if we don’t understand what they mean by an ātman, which is permanent one and independent, how can we understand the Buddhist assertion of the emptiness of such an ātman? So the Purusha is not attached in any way to the atma to the, sorry, to the Prakriti, to the Is that a question or a statement? Geshela is not able to answer your question because the Prakriti is the cause for transmigration in cyclic existence of Purusha.
Then he’d have to check-in these non Buddhist texts to be sure. Could you please just spell Bashishan so that we know what we’re looking for? U p a n I s h a d, Upanishads. The Upanishads. So the Sankhyas, therefore, when they speak of a self or a person which is permanent one and independent, are referring to a self or a person, a purusa, which pervades all sentient beings.
Are they actually referring to we as people who walk, eat and so forth? Probably not. So then can’t you see that if according to Sankhya, the or the Ātman pervades all sentient beings, we would say that the Ātman or the Purusha does not depend on thoughts. Does that become evident? There’s another reference I’d suggest to you in English.
We have it in the library, I believe. It is Shāntarakshita’s Tattvasangraha. It’s in two volumes. It’s the presentation by the greatest Buddhist scholar of the seventh century of all of the views of ancient India with their refutation, including Sankhya, the views of the Upanishads, Vedanta, and so forth. So I guess, Valerius has praised this book, this treatise a lot.
And Geshela says we have to understand the view of the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India. So, this asked me to explain my personal understanding of the topic. As I understand it, when Buddhist treatises refute the apprehension of the self as permanent one and independent, what they are refuting is a presentation of the ātman as taught in the Upanishads, which were broadly contemporaneous with Buddha Śākyamūni’s period, specifically Chāndogya Upanishad, Brihadaranyaka Upanishad, and so forth. Then in the Upanishad, the ātman, or the self is taught to be of the size of the thumb, existing at the level of the heart. It is permanent, it does not change, And when they say that it is one, my personal understanding is that this refers to the fact that for the Upanishads, to attain moksha or liberation means to understand that the ātman is one with the universal self, the Brahman.
Yes. And so death is to become one with Brahman, that No. At death, the ātman does not become one with the Brahman, so it’s nothing to do with Christianity. Here, the ātman can become one with the Brahman only through practice, and for Sankhya, through understanding the 25 objects of knowledge. Okay.
So this is therefore the non Buddhist philosopher’s understanding of the self as permanent one independent. Now what they actually understand as person is open to debate. However, from a Buddhist perspective, it is taught that the person is empty of being permanent one and independent. So this is for the apprehension of the person as permanent one and independent. The emptiness of the person being permanent one and independent is taught to be the coarse selflessness of persons.
Now the lower schools of Buddhist tenets teach that the emptiness of the person being a substantially existent autonomous entity is the subtle emptiness of persons. As of today, we will begin the presentation of the apprehension of the person as autonomous and the mode of this apprehension. So this topic of the apprehension of the person as autonomous is one developed in great detail in Buddhist topics, what this apprehension is and so forth. So we don’t have a lot of time. So in brief, if you investigate, you can see that there are two possible apprehensions of the person.
The first is that the person is apprehended as separate and unrelated to its base of imputation, the aggregate’s body and mind. The second is that the person is felt to be within or inside the aggregates. And this is the rationale for which the lowest schools of tenets assert that the mental consciousness is the person. So we shall stop here for today. And if you have questions, Michel will take your questions.
Please short, clear, concise questions. Firstly, I’m sorry I was disrespectful earlier on when I interrupted Geshela. So with Sankhya understanding of the ātman as pervading all beings, it actually seems to be the same thing as Brahman. It’s just the understanding of what it is that is makes it different from Brahman. Is that is that the case?
Yes. That’s the the understanding in the Upanishads is exactly that. The ātman is one with Brahman. It is through not understanding that ātman is one with Brahman that we transmigrate. When we realize that Ātman is one with Brahman, we are jivanmukta, we are liberated in this life, we have attained moksha.
Geshela says there is a big difference because when one attains calm abiding, what does this mean? This means that one is able to focus on whichever object of meditation one chooses for as long as one wishes. There is no difference in the presentation of the attainment of calm abiding among the non Buddhist philosophers of Hinduism and the Buddhists. It’s shared. Apart from that, the tirthikas, the non Buddhist philosophers of ancient India, through attaining calm abiding, then gain a realization of Prakriti and generate the paranormal powers, which enable them to understand the existence of psychic existence.
Geshela, is the, do the Svatāntrika hold the subtle self of persons or the emptiness of being substantially autonomously existing. Yes. Because Geshela was referring to the lower schools, lower in the sense being lower than Prāsaṇgika So when Gesheera refers to, at present the topic is Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika. When Geshela refers to the schools beneath that, it’s from Svatantrika Madhyamika downwards. All Buddhist schools of tenets beneath Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika assert that the emptiness of the person being a substantially existent autonomous entity is the person’s subtle selflessness.
Okay. Okay. Yep. Just wanna ask a question about, repute. Many people over the ages have actually died in terms of defending their name and defending their honor.
In fact thinking that it will be a cause for them to live forever so to speak. So in Geshela’s example, depending on obviously the person that’s on death row, they may actually find that appealing. So given that’s the case, what would be the strongest method for countering repute for ordinary beings such as ourselves? So actually, it is not quite similar because when Geshela was referring to means to counter attachment to repute and fame, it was in the context of students and practitioners of the Lamrim. Then when you start referring to people in the military, then this is not terribly relevant to them.
Okay. Thank you.
Key terms in this teaching
- atman dag (Tib)
- Self; as opposed to anatman (no-self), the Buddha’s explanation of selflessness in the Four Noble Truths Sutra. LYWA
- bodhicitta jang chub sem (Tib)
- A principal consciousness that combines the two factors of wishing to free all beings from suffering and of wishing to attain enlightenment in order to achieve that; the spontaneous altruistic mind of enlightenment can be either aspirational or engaging. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
- Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- Madhyamaka u ma (Tib)
- The Middle Way school, one of the two Mahayana (Great Vehicle) philosophical schools. The Middle Way school does not assert true establishment even conventionally. There are two divisions of the Middle Way school: 1) Autonomists and 2) Consequentialists. LYWA
- shamatha zhi nä (Tib)
- Calm abiding; a state of concentration in which the mind is able to abide steadily, without effort and for as long as desired, on an object of meditation. There are nine stages in its development. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.
Questions answered in this teaching
Do the Svātantrika hold that the emptiness of a person being substantially existent or autonomous is the subtle selflessness of persons?
Yes. When the teaching refers to the lower schools, it means the schools lower than Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika, which is the topic at present. That reference runs from Svatantrika Mādhyamika downwards. All Buddhist schools of tenets beneath Prāsaṇgika Mādhyamika assert that the emptiness of the person being a substantially existent, autonomous entity is the person's subtle selflessness.