Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-07-22 – KR.mp3
UUID: 7b20e967-8a18-49c7-9ec2-f6051b8f1a3c
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-07-22
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 29m
Words: 3,831
What I shall explain at present, I have already explained. However, in as much as there are a substantial number of new students present today, I shall cover the material again. It is of benefit to them, and I think it will be of benefit to yourselves as well. It is extremely important when one rises in the morning, in other words, when one awakens to from the beginning turn one’s mind in a worthy direction. By worthy or good direction, we mean to turn one’s mind towards virtue and to prevent it from falling under the sway of the afflictions.
Then obviously there is this one percent of us who are totally unable to fall asleep. But for ninety nine percent of us, we do fall asleep and wake up in the morning. Then, it is important to analyze the state which precedes waking up in the morning, in other words, state of sleep. It is obviously impossible to sleep if the five sense consciousnesses function. Let alone the coarse sensory consciousnesses, but all our plans and fancies for so long as these are present in our mind, we cannot fall asleep.
It’s quite strange that nobody in this room would be able to answer a very simple question. At what time precisely did you fall asleep? It’s impossible for us to answer this question. We can answer the question, when did you lie down to bed? But when you fell asleep, nobody can answer.
So this is food for thought and for study. So clearly before we fall asleep, the five sensory consciousnesses, the five coarse consciousnesses of the five doors are operational. And before we fall asleep, for instance, we can hear a sound. At the instant we fall asleep, this stops and all sensory consciousnesses are eliminated. Then at this point, the dream consciousness arises.
I cannot say for sure that all persons dream, but in my own case, I dream a lot. I have good dreams, nightmares, neutral dreams, but many dreams. Dream consciousness is a subtle consciousness. In it, we experience happy dreams in which things go well for us and nightmares in which we experience travails. However, in either case, we are at present completely unable to utilize the continuum of such subtle consciousnesses.
Then the, dream consciousness is something we all understand irrespective of whether we have studied or not, irrespective of our analytical faculties. We understand it through direct experience. Something quite similar happens in the death process at the time of death, where the subtle mind manifests. This is once again a mind which we are unable to use at present, but its continuum continues all the way next down to the next life. If we analyze the process in which the continuum of the subtle mind continues, we can see how such a continuum leads into future lives and we can understand on this basis the existence of future lives.
And we can see in this way that this subtle mind eventually will be reborn either in a higher or in a lower rebirth. Now, independent of this, we can move also backwards in time and understand the necessity of the existence of previous lives. We have not only been born in this life due to the spermatozoa of the father and the ovum of one’s mother, but as well due to a previous consciousness. It is extremely important for us to understand the existence of past and future lives, not only based on scriptural authority, but based on reason and analysis. So this is the process of waking up in the morning.
Now it is important for us to understand that we are transitory beings, we are ephemeral and we last a very short period of time. For instance, it would be very easy for the conditions which lead to sleep to also lead to death. Should, for instance, the balance of the four elements during the sleep process or for that matter, the activities of a foe interfere with our life force while we are sleeping, we might very well not wake. Then when we wake up in the morning, we should think, could have died, but I have been reborn as a human being. I obtained the conditions for a human rebirth.
What shall I do with this rebirth? How shall I use it wisely? In our own case, all of us in this room are probably followers of Buddha Shakyamuni of the teacher. Therefore, we should say to ourselves, I shall use this life for dharma practice. Then instead of focusing on vast expanses of time, let us focus on the reasonable amounts of time at our disposal and ask ourselves, what should I do during one day, one week, one month?
How should I lead a meaningful human life? I shall lead a meaningful human life through the practice of dharma. If we are able to take the pledge or the oath, I shall not fall under the sway of anger and generate this as a motivation, even though none of us in this room can say definitely that during one day or for that matter during one hour, anger will not arise for sure within our mind stream. Nonetheless, such an oath, such a pledge is profoundly meaningful. In our minds, the anger is definitely present.
And therefore, we should target anger and we should take the resolve, I shall not fall under the sway of anger. I shall not be controlled by anger. Then undeniably, anger, envy, jealousy, competitiveness have arisen and will arise within our minds. It is however very important to understand their mode of horizon and how to gain control over them. In our cases, we are disciples.
We are followers of the teacher of Buddha Shakyamuni. Therefore, we should take the resolve not to allow our mind to fall under the sway of the afflictions. And here, when I say the afflictions, I’m speaking mainly of anger. Then anger will arise within our mind, jealousy will arise, cupidity will arise, but what is critical is to say to ourselves, I will not allow them to dwell for long within my mind. I shall actually reduce their impact.
This is only possible if we understand clearly the force of anger. Once we understand the force of anger and the abnormal behavior we engage in under the sway of anger, we will feel a great feeling of shame and we will wish to avoid anger. As Shantideva in a marvelous line of reasoning, you perhaps know from Bodhisattva Charyavatara says, instead of covering the surface of the earth with leather, we cover the surface of our feet to protect them against stones and pebbles. Likewise, it is impossible to overcome enemies which are innumerable. Instead, let us subdue our mind.
Then there are in this world both people who are inclined towards dharma or the spiritual traditions and those who are not inclined towards dharma or the spiritual traditions. There has to be a difference between these two groups of people. The difference between one who practices dharma and one who does not practice dharma is not wealth or prosperity nor for that matter is it education. However, it relies on study. Then I would like you to ask yourselves what is the difference between a dharma practitioner and a non dharma practitioner?
A rosary is not the difference. It would be very difficult. Strange clothing, which is yellow and red, is not the difference either. So what is the difference? Then a Dharma practitioner is someone who targets the causes of the afflictions anger and the other afflictions such as jealousy and competitiveness, which are all present within our minds right now.
We don’t need to deny it. Then everything else is really irrelevant, isn’t it? Then when we speak of targeting anger, how precisely do we target anger? Anger is not a thing like a stone. It is a consciousness.
We target anger through techniques such as those taught in the Lamrim. Therefore, we must initially study the Lamrim. In afflictions such as anger, such as jealousy, such as envy, we understand they are powerful within our minds. And when we target them, it is with the intent to abandon them. Then to abandon them now is difficult.
To abandon them at once is perhaps impossible. But we have to find means to reduce their power. This is possible. Then, we have to see, how to address the issue of anger. That anger exists within our mind stream is a given.
It has already arisen in the past. So after understanding the thoughts of anger, we have to ask ourselves after analyzing and studying. Is anger something which is changeable or unchangeable? If it’s changeable, it is impermanent. It can be eliminated.
If it is unchangeable, it is permanent. We can’t do anything about it. We have to analyze this carefully. That anger is impermanent, it’s obvious, it is changeable, it is occasionally present and occasionally app absent. And therefore, it is something which can be eliminated.
We must seek the means to eliminate it. This is only possible through careful study. Do you understand? So in the context of the generation of the motivation, what motivation should we generate? When we wake up in the morning, we should take the resolve, I shall at least not fall under the sway of anger.
I shall not fall under the sway of the afflictions. To eliminate them is difficult, but at least we shall not fall under their control. And we shall take this resolve for one day, then for one week, then for one month, and in this way extend its range. And it’s a bit odd if you just rise in the morning and have breakfast. I suppose it’s okay if you generate the motivation while you’re having your breakfast.
And the best obviously would be if you could focus on generating the motivation just after getting up in the morning. And if this is unrealistic for those of you with an empty starving stomach, then I suppose you can do it while you’re having breakfast. Whether we stay at home or go outside to work, it is critical that we generate such a motivation. But this motivation must be generated of our own volition. It must not be imposed on us from the outside with someone saying, you’ve got to generate this motivation.
If we generate it of our own volition, it will be far more powerful. Then within the 100% of afflictive obstructions within our mind, anger, jealousy, competitiveness and all and so forth, I can guarantee we can abandon 20 to 30%. This is quite something, isn’t it? Then to forsake anger and the afflictions from the very root to eliminate them from our mind stream, then we need to understand selflessness. And therefore, the motivation we should generate is the following.
Since I fully understand the faults of anger and all of the afflictions and I wish not to fall under their sway and under their control. I pledge to dedicate myself to finding a means to eliminate them, to abandon them, and there is no other way to do this than to study and to study the supreme of all topics of study, the Lamrim. Let us generate this motivation. In the context of our topic, the path of the being or the path shared with the being of the middling scope. The object of abandonment, of such a path is cyclic existence.
In other words, the afflictions. These are the afflictions which are present within our mind stream. These contaminated aggregates, which are said to be of the nature of suffering are none other than cyclic existence. It is through understanding their thoughts that in turn we can give rise to the mind which wishes to be freed of them. And once we have done this, once we have generated the mind which wishes to abandon the contaminated aggregates and the afflictions, at this point, we will probably be able to identify it and to identify liberation.
To say that we have to abandon these five aggregates is a bit strange, however, because they are the basis on which we function, And there are numerous scriptural quotes to this effect. So what we must abandon therefore are the afflictions under the sway of which we have fallen and specifically anger under the sway of which we have fallen. It is for this reason that the outline of this topic is presented in terms of four sub outlines. Identifying the afflictions, understanding their sequence of generation, understanding their causes, and understanding their faults. The first about line identifying the afflictions has been completed last time with the presentation of the definition of the afflictions.
And the second is the sequence of generation of the afflictions that has broadly speaking been explained. As you remember, I pointed out that self grasping gives rise to desire and independence on desire, anger in turn arises. We have a subdivision of the 10 afflictions into a group which depends on the view and another group which does not depend on the view. All of us have direct experience if we analyze a sequence of generation of the afflictions that desire arises first and when it is spurned or counter, anger arises as a result. Then regarding the third outline, the causes of the afflictions, if we take the case of anger which we understand well, clearly at present hatred is not present within our mind stream.
But the potency of hatred is definitely present within our mind stream. Now regarding the object of anger, this is also self evident. It is the opposite of what we wish. It is independence on that that anger arises. And we all understand that coarse afflictions such as anger arise independence on incorrect motivations.
So this is the third outline, the causes which give rise to afflictions such as anger. The force is the thoughts of such afflictions. Now regarding the fourth outline, the thoughts of anger, as Shantideva points out in his Bodhisattva, Charyavatara, no affliction more than anger conveys the, its capacity to protect us and to protect our minds from harm, protecting us from others. Then we should check for ourselves whether anger is helpful or beneficial or not. After anger has completed its goal, are we in a state of ease and happiness or not?
Then we can see that when powerful anger occurs within our mind, definitely, we harm ourselves. Possibly, we may put an end to the life of another person or at least using incredibly cruel and harsh words, spiteful words, hurt them profoundly. Then the most important is to become aware of the thoughts of anger and this cause for analysis. We should ask ourselves basically, is anger a fortunate, helpful state of mind, in which case we should strive to generate it and cling to it. If on the other hand, anger is a destructive state of mind and we understand its faults through its results, then we should study to try to find the means to eliminate it.
Now anger and envy are the coarsest of the afflictions, so it is quite straightforward to understand their faults and strive to eliminate them. Desire is much more subtle in this respect. Perhaps anger and envy have no benefit whatsoever. And therefore, it is foundational to first understand the thoughts of the afflictions such as anger and envy, and then to strive not to fall under their power, under their sway. Then once one starts striving not to fall under their power or their sway, one must study.
It is difficult to avoid falling under the power of anger through offering mandala for instance. So for this, we must understand the origin of anger. The origin of anger is self grasping, the ignorance of self grasping, an ignorance which grasps its object mistakenly. And for this, in turn, we must understand this mistaken mode of apprehension of the object. This is emptiness.
This is a difficult topic which we shall study progressively. So I shall stop here for today. If you have questions, please ask your questions. Make your questions short and few. How do you deal with anger?
Do how long does anger last within you? Anger definitely arises within my mind stream. Fortunately, it doesn’t stay for long. I immediately apply the antidotes and therefore it stays for a minute or two. If you think of the thoughts of anger, it helps tremendously.
I wrote down something, I think I might have missed, written it down wrongly. It says faults, no affliction more than anger that protects us from others, protects us from harm. Was that wrong? Mm-mm. The gesture was saying was presenting our mistaken view.
So this is a mistaken way we think things, we think of things. When anger arises within our mind, we think anger is my friend. Anger protects me against others. This is a wrong way to look at things, but this is how we look at it. Then under the sway of anger, we think anger helps us.
Anger will protect us, but it is actually critical for us not to fall under the sway of anger. So I asked Geshela permission to, tell you a little story from my life in India. I was traveling from Mysore to Madras on a night train, when I was ordained, And, there was a Muslim gentleman on the train who, when he learned that I was American, lost all control of himself and grasped the knife and attacked me with the knife. Then, luckily, there was a Hindu friend with him, and I was able to talk to this Muslim gentleman and calm him down. And after an hour or so, he erupted again and grasped the knife again and jumped at me again.
And this went on for a couple hours. At the end, we became fairly good friends. And, he explained to me that anger made him strong and anger made him powerful. And he said to me, I will never forget, my son cannot beat my wife. Only I can beat my wife.
If my son tries to beat my wife, I beat him and then her. Then we talked a lot, and after this discussion, he eventually just took hours. He said to me, because of my anger, I have become manic depressive. I suffer from profound phases of depression which last weeks or months in which everything is dark around me. Then I could not speak to him of dharma.
He was Muslim. But I said that at the monastery, we had very good Tibetan doctors. Maybe he could come to see a Tibetan doctor and they could fix this elemental disruption. This is what happens when anger takes over. It was a night train I was not quite sure I would see the next day.
When anger arises within our minds, if we are not careful, we will go crazy, literally crazy. It is a mistaken state of mind and independence on this, we will engage in mistaken deeds. And another question. I just wanted to ask Geshe sorry. I haven’t I haven’t really thought about this that clearly.
But what I just wanted to ask Geshela what he thought of people who became who become extremely angry and violent as a result of out of passion for out of a compassionate attitude because they’re angry at someone who is being very cruel. The thing to keep in mind is if anger arises within your mind when you are protecting a dog from a savage beating, that dog derives no benefit whatsoever from your anger nor do you. Any other questions? In the West, we tend to think that anger is the result of chemical imbalance of physical matter. And in the dharma, we learn that anger is the result of wrong view or wrong thinking to be broad about it.
What is the relationship in dharma between anger and chemical imbalance? Is it under there’s some connection, but is it circular? So chemical imbalance creates wrong thought, but wrong thought is derived at through wrong thinking. So what is the connection between those two? In my opinion, we have to distinguish between two types of anger.
There is coarse anger, which is induced by the sensory consciousnesses. And this anger, I believe, has a strong biochemical basis, a strong connection with the brain. On the other hand, there is subtle anger. I don’t think that has a biochemical basis. In all due respect, we don’t consider science does not consider anger an imbalance.
Science considers anger an absolutely fundamentally necessary response to a threat that is actually, in its first instance, good and can become bad. That’s actually a problem. Yes. Definitely, this does happen. However, it is a contingent explanation.
At times, anger indeed enables one to protect one’s life. At other times, it is a profoundly inadapted response. So the point we have to analyze is the states of mind or the emotions within the dream state. Within the dream state, we know that sometimes we are happy and sometimes we are miserable and we can experience anger. If we experience anger in the dream state, is there a scientific explanation for this or not?
This is a topic to be analyzed. Just as there are numerous levels of coarseness and subtlety of consciousness, likewise, there are numerous levels of coarseness and subtlety of anger, of envy, and also of desire. This is why the dream consciousness is such an important topic. All of us have direct experience of the dream consciousness. On this basis, we can analyze this.
Otherwise, just to analyze on the basis of Buddhist texts is not very helpful for us. Can I ask you a question about, the teachings from a couple of weeks ago, please? Definitely. Regarding the five afflictions pertaining to the view and the five afflictions unrelated to the view, with the affliction of afflicted doubt, which is unrelated to the view and a doubt as Geshe said, toward a doubt with respect to the existence or nonexistence, veracity or nonveracity of the four noble truths, causality of the existence of past and future lives. That seems to me to be related to the view.
Could Geshela comment on that, please? Generally speaking, afflicted doubt has a strong relation with the view. However, doubt is twofold. We have, shall we say, non afflicted doubt and afflicted doubt. Generally speaking, non afflicted doubt is connected with that which is not related to to the view.
As doubt has two components, afflicted and non afflicted, it is put in the category of what is not related to the view. So we shall stop here for tonight. It’s a moment. You know?
Key terms in this teaching
- bodhisattva jang chub sem pa (Tib)
- One who possesses bodhicitta. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- four noble truths denpa zhi (Tib)
- The subject of the Buddha's first turning of the wheel of Dharma. The truths of suffering, the origin of suffering, the cessation of suffering, and the path to the cessation of suffering as seen by an arya. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- mandala khyil khor (Tib)
- A circular diagram symbolic of the entire universe. The purified environment of a tantric deity; the diagram or painting representing this. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.