Emptiness — 2015-08-12

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)
Emptiness — 2015-08-12
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-08-12 – KR.mp3

UUID: 9b94c902-3b51-466a-a22a-f56f4de53be6

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Emptiness (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2015-08-12

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 31m

Words: 3,934

Within Lamrim and Chemo, the topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is definite emergence or renunciation. The more elaborate topic is the Four Noble Truths Noble Truths of suffering, the origin, cessation and of the path. In the most elaborate form it is the 12 links of dependent origination. The 12 links of dependent origination in the forward form refer to the first two noble truths of suffering and the origin of suffering. In the reverse form, they refer to the noble truths of cessation and of the path.

Even though the term definite emergence or renunciation is very short, when one expands it, it leads into the Four Noble Truths and when it expands it even further, it leads into the 12 links both in forward and in reverse sequence. So as was mentioned within Lamrim Cemo, the topic of the path of the being of the middling scope is definite emergence or renunciation. Definite emergence or renunciation has two forms: ordinary definite emergence or renunciation, which is already present at the level of the path of the being of the small scope and special definite emergence of renunciation which is present at the level of the path of the being of the middling The Tibetan term definite emergence has two syllables. What does one definitely emerge from? One emerges definitely from cyclic existence.

In other words, one emerges definitely from the first two truths, the truth of cessation and the origin of cessation. What does one definitely emerge into? One emerges definitely into liberation in other words to be more precise into the third noble truth, the noble truth of cessation. Now the means to access the noble truth of cessation is through the wisdom realizing selflessness. So what does one therefore definitely emerge from?

One emerges definitely from cyclic existence. In other words, the two first truths. What does one definitely emerge into? One emerges definitely into liberation. In addition, or definite emergence can also be translated as definite generation.

In this context it refers to definite emergence into liberation or the attainment of liberation. What then is generated within the reading definite generation? What is generated is liberation. What is that which definitely generates it? It is definite emergence itself.

This is the meaning of the stanza in Je Tsongkhapa’s three principles of the path when at that point, day and night, uncontrivably the thought of renunciation is generated it occurs spontaneously. So into what do we therefore definitely emerge? We emerge definitely into liberation and this liberation is a permanent form of happiness. It is a permanent mental form of happiness. It is unrelated to physical happiness which depends largely on exterior physical objects and therefore is not germane in this context.

This permanent state of mental happiness arises when the main source of mental suffering which are the afflictions and the seeds thereof are eliminated. So when we refer to the attainment of liberation, we refer to attaining the state of an Arhat. This is an extraordinary mental experience. It has no relation whatsoever to one’s body. Whatever body one had before becoming one Arhat one still retains after becoming an Arhat.

So in as much as Achatz have the same body before and after the attainment of Arhathood, do they die? Definitely they die. They die. They have a body of contaminated aggregates. What precisely happens after their death?

Arhats are definitely liberated from cyclic existence. They therefore do not take rebirth and psychic existence again. They are instead reborn in a pure land, no longer in a physical, but in a mental body and remain in a state of equipoise unselflessness. Position regarding what happens to Achatz at the end of their life depends on the tenet systems. Some tenet systems assert that since Achatz are liberated from cyclic existence, at the time of their death their mental continuum is severed and they cease to exist completely.

The majority of tenant systems however assert that they are simply reborn in a pure land in a mental body. So, WALL, the attainment of the path of the me being of the building scope is precisely a liberation, in other words, the end of rebirth in cyclic existence under the sway of karma and afflictions, the attainment of the path of the being of the small scope, is a higher rebirth. Now this higher rebirth cause is the practice of pure ethics. Whether we ourselves will gain such a higher rebirth in the future or not is something we should examine for ourselves. There is no guarantee because we have it at present that we will attain it in the future.

Then there are debates regarding this. For instance, it is clear that if we say that since the practice of the being of the small scope leads to the attainment of liberation from cyclic existence, and one is never reborn again in psychic existence, is it necessarily the case that someone who practices a path of the being of the small scope and whose main attainment is a higher rebirth whose cause is a practice of pure ethics would then only be reborn repeatedly in a higher rebirth and never be reborn in a lower rebirth or not. This is something you should investigate yourself through study and analysis. Do you understand? We are transmigrators.

What precisely transmigrates the contaminated aggregates? What causes transmigrations, karma and afflictions? We are therefore transmigrators. We transmigrate under the power of the afflictions which are karma and pleasure and what is precisely the base of transmigration, The base of transmigration is the higher and the lower realms. So this is how you should look into things.

We have explained many times here the 12 links of dependent origination including the three embedding links and the completing links. It is through the power of these links that one transmigrates. Therefore, we transmigrate under the power of karma and of klesha, in other words of afflictions and of karma, and the basis of transmigration are the higher and the lower rebirths. For reincarnation within the higher rebirth, transmigration within the higher rebirth, probably the only affliction present will be beginningless ignorance. Neither desire nor hatred can cause transmigration into the higher realms.

Likewise, within the sequence of 12 links leading to rebirth in a higher realm, the main cause is the first link beginningless ignorance. For instance, when we think through the practice of generosity, I will obtain prosperity in a future life or through the practice of the protection of ethics, I will obtain a higher rebirth, in both cases that sense I is none other than the manifestation of beginningless ignorance. In other words, it is the first limb of beginningless ignorance which initiates the process both of giving in training and generosity and of protection in the protection of ethics and leads to a higher rebirth. On the other hand, when we examine the process of rebirth in the lower realms, we can see that for rebirth in the lower realms there are two categories of afflictions which must be present in addition to the initial beginningless ignorance, which is the first limb. A second affliction which derives from this, which can either belong to the family of desire or the family of hatred must be present and this in turn gives rise to engagement into physical and verbal non virtuous deeds which act as approximate cause for rebirth in the lower realms.

Now it is clear that if you wish to accumulate the requisite karma to be reborn in a higher realm, to do this you will engage in activities such as the practice of generosity or the protection of ethics motivated by concern for yourself. In other words, motivated by beginningless ignorance. This will lead to rebirth in a higher realm. However, when we train in the path of the being of the middling scope, our goal is no longer rebirth in the higher realms, it is actually liberation from cyclic existence and none of these can act as cause for liberation from cyclic existence? So I would like to ask whether the awareness of the issue is present within yourselves or not.

At the level of the path of the being of the small scope, whatever virtue we accrue, we accrue with the motivation of being reborn in a higher realm and it leads merely to that. None of these virtues whatsoever can lead to liberation from cyclic existence. Is this something you understand? So at the level of the path of the being of the small scope, whatever virtue we accumulate acts as cause for a rebirth in the higher realms, this is our object of attainment. At the level of the path of the being of the middling scope, we have a totally different object of attainment liberation.

None of the causes accumulated at the level of the path of the being of the small scope, in other words no virtue can act as a cause for liberation from psychic existence. So what precisely is the cause for liberation from psychic existence? So let us clarify things. At the level of the path of the being of the small scope, the object of attainment is a de higher rebirth. The means for that attainment is pure ethics.

The object of abandonment is non virtuous deeds. At the level of the path of the being of the middling scope, the object of attainment is liberation. The means is the noble truth of the path. The object of abandonment is cyclic existence. Do we have the causes for the attainment of liberation within our mind stream?

Yes or no? So in your opinion, what is the cause for the attainment of liberation? Can you identify? Please give a pure answer, in other words, a short answer. Another?

And you? So almost all of you gave good answers. Some said renunciation, then whether renunciation can actually be a cause of liberation or not is something which has to be investigated. It’s not obvious. Someone said emptiness.

Emptiness itself is a permanent phenomenon. So it can neither be cause nor effect. It is the wisdom realizing emptiness which is the cause for liberation from cyclic existence. Emptiness is merely its object. Many of you answered the wisdom realizing emptiness.

That is an extremely important assertion indeed. The wisdom realizing emptiness is the cause for liberation. Why? Because that which obstructs liberation is none other than the ignorance of self grasping. And the wisdom realizing emptiness is the antidote to the ignorance of self grasping.

They are contradictory and incompatible. The mode of apprehension of the object by the wisdom grasping at the self and by the wisdom realizing emptiness are directly contradictory. So this went very well. I had some major doubts about whether you would be able to answer this question. You answered it excellently, a solid 99%.

Basically said the wisdom realizing emptiness, that’s it. So for yourselves, you should examine whether the cause for liberation from cyclic existence, the wisdom realizing emptiness, is present within your mind stream or not. Here we do not necessarily refer to the complete realization of emptiness, this is very difficult to have, but some type of understanding of emptiness, is this present within our mind stream or not. If it is not present, there will be no liberation from cyclic existence. And this is explicitly what Je Tsongkhapa says in his Lamrim Chemo, In the Great Stages of the Path, in which he asserts that any virtue accrued with the motivation of being freed from cyclic existence, and here, if you do not understand what cyclic existence means, think of anger, of desire and all that, any virtue accrued with such a motivation becomes a cause for liberation.

How precisely does the wisdom realizing emptiness act as a cause for liberation from time to distance? Precisely because the more we reflect on emptiness, on selflessness, the more we weaken self grasping, grasping at a self and that in turn weakens the bonds to cyclic existence. In all of us, I is very powerful. Now we have to try to reduce it. Then it is not easy to establish the causes for liberation from cyclic existence but as much time as we have we should try to dedicate to this.

This is extremely important. Then obviously I can only imagine how difficult it must be if one has to work, if one has children to take care of and so forth. But whenever one has time, one should focus on this. This is most beneficial. Now regarding this motivation at this point of the teachings, we should say I will try to meditate on the attainment of liberation and engage in the three activities of hearing, thinking and meditating on this topic.

And therefore we should reflect on the thoughts of cyclic existence, on the object of attainment, of the path of the being of the middling scope, liberation and on the means to attain it, the wisdom, realizing emptiness and meditate on these. So in accordance with Lamrim Cemo, this is how any of the roots of virtue which is upheld or apprehended by renunciation turns into a cause for liberation. Now within the outline of the Lam Rim the process of death is subdivided into five. The first are the conditions for this death, the second is the actual mind of the death state, the third is the encounter with it, the fourth is the intermediate state or the Bardo and the fifth is the mode of birth. So the first outline, the causes or the conditions of death, clearly having accumulated the karma to be reborn in this life, we will not live forever.

This life has an end. It can come to a natural end. It can also come to an end due to famine, lack of food and so forth. There are numerous causes in this world. Now the second outline, the mind at the time of death, here the lamrim refers to the coarse mind at the time of death which can be virtuous or non virtuous, not the subtle mind which is always neutral.

Should the coarse mind at the time of death be virtuous, it is a mind which is bereft of fear, which is at ease as if one was moving to another place. On the other hand, if the coarse mind at the time of death is non virtuous, then there is great fear and anguish and one feels as if one is moving into darkness and clouds. Then regarding the subtle mind of the state of death, there is very little I can say. It is akin to the mind of the dream state and is neutral. Then obviously for those who have experience with this mind there would be an awful lot to explain.

Now regarding the third outline, the mode of dissipation of bodily heat. If one is involved in a non virtuous process of death then the heat will dissipate from the crown to the heart downwards in other words whereas if one is involved in a virtuous death process the heat will dissipate from the soles of the feet upwards to the heart. In both cases it will progressively disappear at the heart. This is definitely the case among the geshes in these three seats. There were some who practiced the meditations in the death state and indeed the bodily warmth disappeared progressively into the heart area.

The rest of the body was cold but this area was warm. Then the remaining two outlines, the establishment of the Bardo body and the mode of birth, I will explain next week. Stop here tonight. Then at present, I will take questions. Please ask few questions, concise questions and clear questions, one question per person.

And then after everyone has had their chance, if there is time, we will take second questions. Then what does it take to become a Rinpoche? So there are many ways of explaining Rinpoche, which in Tibetan means precious and one refers to lamas or teachers who in previous lives have taken the means to be reborn in this life in a human form for the benefit of others. The second refers to monks who have studied in-depth and practiced and eventually become abbots of the monasteries, they also are called Then there are two other terms, literally nirmanakaya and yang si literally one who is reborn. Yang si refers to someone who has just been reborn as a human being who technically should refer to an emanation being.

If a practitioner actually attains liberation and they’re alive and they leave Samsara, what actually happens to their body? When someone has attained liberation, in other words become an arhat, then what happens at the time of their death depends on the system of tenets or the explanation of the system of tenets. For Vaibhashika and Sautrantika, at the time of their death their continuum is severed. In other words, they literally their mind literally ceases to exist. On the other hand, for Chitamatra and the Madhyamika schools, at the time of their death they actually are reborn in a pure land in a mental body and stay in that state precisely because the causes for rebirth and cyclic existence which is karma and afflictions no longer exist.

So as Jean Gopin says in his golden rosary of good explanations, According to the two lower schools of tenets, the mind is severed upon death after becoming an arhat, whereas according to the two higher schools of tenets, it is not. How do we recognize a bodhisattva? Is there any feature that we can see if there’s a hidden one? So according to Buddhist treatises, beings who have generated bodhicitta have generated independence on great compassion or on such states of mind. Then these are beings who have practiced the profound and the vast aspect of the path repeatedly, repeatedly have offered their bodies, repeatedly have offered their blood and these are the signs which indicate bodhisattvas.

Is it correct that the afflictions are still present in the continuum of an ARIA but not in the continuum of an arahat? Yes, that is the case. The afflictions have been abandoned by an Ahat. Aryas refer to beings who have attained the path of seeing, the path of meditation and above. Such beings have therefore had direct experience of emptiness.

There still are afflictions within their mind stream but they no longer fall under the sway of these afflictions. So yours is an important question. It is something which will be covered in Salam in grounds and paths. Hopefully one day we will cover Salam here. This is really important because if you do not study grounds and paths, Salam in other words, then you will not understand the process of abandonment of the afflictions and will not know the difference between an Achat and an aria and reciprocal.

This is, just a clarification of something that I just didn’t quite hear, the end of Geshela’s statement when it was in response answers regarding what is the cause for liberation. And he said some of you said that emptiness was the cause. And he went on to say that emptiness is a permanent phenomena and then went on to say that it’s not something. And I didn’t quite catch that. Could guess you just please elaborate on what emptiness is.

So what is necessary to attain liberation is to reduce progressively and eliminate eventually self grasping. This can only be done through the repeated application of the antidote to self grasping. Now emptiness is a permanent phenomenon. If we analyze more subtly, emptiness is a non implicative negation. As a permanent phenomenon, emptiness alone itself is unable to eliminate self grasping.

It is the mind which thinks on emptiness over it again in other words the wisdom realizing emptiness which is able to do this. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Of course.

I’d like to talk about a Burma monk, the high priest in Burma. Mhmm. Yes. A little bit louder. I’m going to He may you know, he just talk about to generalize another race in Burma, you know, the other Muslim.

Mhmm. And is if he’s doing that, in doing this, so is he get a lot of, how you say, bad karma? What does he do, mister Huokinghu? He the way he talk about the Muslim, they should be out of this country, and they commit, you know, they talk about yeah. Yeah.

I know the situation. So everything depends of the motivation of this monk in making this statement. Clearly these refugees do not have the right to be in Burma. Then when he says that they should not stay in Burma but should be expelled from Burma, whether he accumulates sin or not depends on his analysis of the situation and his motivation. However, these Rohingyas are Asians just like the Burmese and therefore one should try to help them.

Then if one does so, the situation would improve and if one does not do so, it should deteriorate. I wasn’t quite clear on what the debate, the small debate was that Geshela was referring to when he said that, ‘Is it the case of one practising the small scope will only ever be reborn or the person practicing that will only ever be reborn in a higher rebirth or not? And I wasn’t quite sure what the particular debate was that Geshela was referring to. So it is a typical type of debate which is held in the great monasteries. You start by saying, at the level of the path of the being of the small scope, the object of attainment is liberation.

Once liberation is attained, one never falls from that state. Then the path of the being of the small scope is similar in some respects to the path of the being of the great scope. The object of attainment of the path of the being of the small scope is a higher rebirth and the means to attain it is pure ethics. Does that mean that once one has attained a higher rebirth on the path of the being of the small scope, one will keep on attaining higher rebirth indefinitely and never fall or not? Then to put it in simpler terms, what is being said is since at present we have attained a higher rebirth due to the practice of pure ethics in a previous life, does it mean that necessarily in the future we will continue attaining higher rebirths or not?

Another? Second question. Geshela, does the practice of hearing continue after you’ve left the room? I think it does. Is this correct?

Yes, when we say the practice of hearing, it doesn’t refer just to physically hearing things but it does refer for instance to reflecting on things after one has heard them. The boundary between what is arisen from hearing and what is arisen from thinking as far as emptiness is concerned is ascertainment of emptiness by a valid cognizer. Until one has ascertained emptiness by a valid cognizer, one is still within the realm of hearing. Once one has ascertained emptiness by a valid cognizer, one has entered into the realm of thinking. So when we speak of what is risen, the wisdom risen from hearing, this does not refer just to hearing but all of the related activities.

Key terms in this teaching

arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
grounds and paths sa lam (Tib)
Various advanced mental states that are achieved through meditation and practice. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
pure land kshetra-zhuddhi (Skt); zhingdag (Tib)
A pure land of a buddha is a place where there is no suffering. LYWA
self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top