Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.
File metadata (for organising)
File: 2015-05-20 – KR.mp3
UUID: 8f276f65-366d-41a8-b04f-0cc742f1cc9e
Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen
Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Date: 2015-05-20
Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide
Duration: 1h 33m
Words: 3,791
As is said in Madhya Makhavatara, as it is rooted in the mind, strive for definite emergence from suffering. Now this is evident all of us in this world from within the two mental and physical happiness, strive for physical happiness. So all of us, therefore, strive to eradicate physical suffering and to actualize physical happiness. However, no one in this world of ours has ever been able to generate immeasurable, boundless physical happiness. Even though we consider happiness which is related to the body as complete and so forth, we are unable to gain satisfaction from it.
And this is the case because this happiness is actually not immeasurable. This happiness is measured. It is finite. And therefore, after this happiness, there is suffering. Now regarding the sufferings which are related to the body, most probably the four sufferings of birth, aging, sickness and death would all be related to the body.
All the sufferings of heat, of cold, of hunger, and of thirst are all physical sufferings related to the body. Now, this is basically circular, a little bit like a wheel which rolls. Why is it the case that such physical happiness is not perfect? It is simply the case because this physical happiness can only give rise to physical happiness. And this physical happiness is not infinite, it is not immeasurable.
Instead, it is finite. And as a result, even though it is finite, we have infinite craving for it. We suffer from insatisfaction and lack of contentment and as a result we transmigrate. Then as a result of these two factors, the factor or the fact that physical happiness is not infinite, but is finite on the one hand. And on the other hand, the fact that we are never satisfied with the physical happiness we have, we lack contentment, we crave it.
As a result, we can never attain perfect physical happiness and engage therefore in physical and verbal actions. Then ordinary beings such as ourselves have to rely on this body of flesh and of blood, literally of flesh and of bone. But we should keep in mind, as Santideva says, that we should only pay it, it’s due, it’s salary. Precisely because we lack contentment, this is not how we behave. All of us are distracted by physical happiness.
This is probably a certainty. And in as much as physical happiness turns into suffering, this is a reason for which Shantideva says we should eradicate it. Then we have to rely on this body or these aggregates. However, our goal must be to generate mental happiness, and we must find the means to do this. We should put effort in this and understand that we must generate happiness from the depths of our mind and eliminate suffering from the innermost depths of our mind.
Now the causes of this mental happiness and this mental suffering are different. They are actually opposite or contradictory. Then I would like to reflect carefully on the fact that probably the causes for physical happiness and the causes for physical suffering are synonymous. They are synonymous because both derive from lack of contentment or insatisfaction. It is really quite important to understand that the origin, the cause of physical happiness and the origin or the cause of physical suffering are synonymous.
Whereas, the origin or the cause of mental happiness and the origin or the cause of mental suffering are opposite or contradictory. And therefore, the goal for our study of the Lam RIM should be precisely to generate this mental happiness from the innermost depths of our minds. So to give you one example, imagine that we have to ford or cross a large river on a bridge. Then, obviously, we want to get on the other side, And the other side is therefore our goal. But temporarily, we must rely on the bridge to get there.
So, it is exactly the same thing. If we want to reach the other side, we must rely on the bridge. Otherwise, it is impossible to do so. Our goal is to reach the other side, but temporarily we rely on the bridge. Likewise, if we want to give rise to happiness from the innermost depths of the mind, and here what I’m talking about is liberation, then this is something which arises from within the mind.
This is our goal. But to attain that goal, we must rely on this body. If we were to discard the body, then we would die. We would not attain the goal. Then it’s therefore absolute nonsense to say I will discard this body or the aggregates.
And for instance, if we were to stop eating, we would survive a couple days and if we were to stop drinking, let us say maybe two weeks at most. But in either case, this is the wrong way to view things. Instead, we should pay a Shantideva says to this body its salary, its due, and then use this physical base as the means to attain our goal. Then since we must put effort to generate this happiness from within the depths of our mind, we must strive as much as possible, as much as we can to hear, to think, and to meditate on the Lam Rim. If we look at reality at the actual situation, we can see that all of the favorable conditions for the study of Lamrim are assembled.
For instance, nobody here suffers from hunger nor thirst. If we were to suffer from hunger or thirst, then we would have to put effort to work for food, to try to gain drink, something to drink, and these are obstacles to the study of the Obviously, one of the major obstacles or contradictory factors for the practice of dharma are physical obstacles, bodily obstacles. We do not have this. Then if we have the time, we should spend half an hour, an hour, two hours every day reflecting on the Lamrim without allowing our mind to be distracted outwards. Then even if you do not have that times, I am sure there is no one in this room who does not have at least one hour a week whom which he or she can dedicate to such reflections.
This is really important and if you don’t do it for yourselves, nobody will do it for you. Therefore, we should make time within our lives for this. And if we make time for the study of Lamrim, then we will experience happiness. This happiness will be mental happiness. Happiness does not come from food and clothing.
This is what we mean by doing retreats or approximation retreats. For however long we’re able to do them, days, weeks, months or longer, we basically strive at eradicating mental difficulties from within ourselves. And even if we are unable to engage in such retreats, who among us does not have an hour a week to practice? Then when we speak here of meditating on the Lamrim, what exactly are we talking about? We’re talking about meditating on the path of the being of the small, the middling, and the great scope, their topics of meditation, and the relationship between these topics.
Apart from that, what precisely is there as meditation? Then when we talk of studying and practicing the Lamrim, this is precisely what is talked about. We have all of the favorable conditions for this. This is a good country. Nobody in this room is hungry.
None of you is thirsty. None of you is destitute. So the possibilities are there. The possibilities to do what? The possibilities to eliminate suffering from the innermost depths of the mind and realize happiness from the innermost depths of the mind.
Apart from this elimination of the afflictions, what type of is there? And the sufferings which arise at this point are mental sufferings. Now it should be obvious that physical and mental sufferings are fundamentally different. Even though we have all of the favorable conditions and have totally eliminated physical suffering, nonetheless hardship and suffering still arise. Which hardship and which suffering?
Mental hardship and mental suffering. Now regarding mental suffering and mental happiness, we must analyze to find independence on which conditions these arise. It is obvious that independence on the afflictions such as anger and so forth, mental suffering does arise. So independence on what does mental suffering or do mental difficulties arise under the power, under the sway of the afflictions? So we should reflect as follows.
Even when exterior hardship, exterior difficulties are absent, nonetheless, interior hardship and difficulties, mental suffering does arise. Independence on what does it arise? It is obvious it arises independence on the afflictions. So we must therefore separate our mind from the afflictions. And to do this, we have to understand the thoughts or the defects of the afflictions foremost of which is anger.
Then when we speak of their defects, their defect is precisely that they lead into entry and cyclic existence. This is the case for all afflictions, anger, and so forth. Once we have understood the thoughts of anger and the afflictions, then a resolve to be free from them which is rooted in sadness arises within our minds. This is a wish for liberation. Then we can see that the suffering, which arises from anger, the suffering which arises from desire, the suffering which arises from envy and jealousy, all have one cause or have two causes, excuse me.
These causes are self cherishing and self grasping. If the root of all of the afflictions is self grasping, then to eradicate mental suffering and to in turn give rise to mental happiness. We need to generate a wisdom which realizes selflessness eradicating self cherishing and self grasping. So we should reflect on the fact that the origin of mental suffering from the innermost depths of the mind and the origin of mental happiness from innermost depths of the mind are contradictory and incompatible. On the other hand, the cause or the origin of physical happiness and the cause or the origin of physical suffering are actually probably one and the same.
I think we can say they are synonymous. Physical happiness gives rise in turn to physical suffering through lack of contentment and satisfaction, and this in turn gives rise to physical happiness like this. Then, this is quite interesting. On the one hand, mental suffering and mental happiness have radically different causes. On the other hand, physical suffering and physical happiness have the same causes.
It should be evident if it is scorching outside and wishing to cool off, we go indoors and turn the air conditioner on. That eventually, if we stay in this cool environment, we would eventually be cold. And therefore, the air conditioner or the coolness of the air conditioner, which was the cause of eliminating the suffering of heat, eventually becomes a cause for the suffering of cold. Then let us take the example of remaining in the cross legged position like this for two, three hours. This eventually becomes a source of suffering.
Then rising from this cross legged position is the cause of happiness. However, once we have risen, if we remain standing for another two or three hours, that cause of happiness turns into suffering and we wish to sit down again. This is something we all have direct experience of. Then we see the same thing with sleeping. When we sleep, we have the sleeping of suffering.
When we get out or wake from sleep, we have the sleeping of the suffering of awakening. And when we fall asleep, we have pain in the head, don’t Then probably we can say that physical suffering and physical happiness are one and the same. Actually, this is in keeping with the Lamrim, which refers to them as the suffering of change. Then physical happiness is finite. It has a limit or a boundary.
Then our mind lacks satisfaction. Our mind wants always more happiness. But this happiness is finite, and as a result, our mind falls into problems. Then as it is finite, as it is limited, what we need is mental contentment or mental satisfaction to accept its finiteness. Physical suffering is probably impossible to eradicate.
It is impossible to eradicate because one, as soon as something benefits, eventually it harms. So whatever benefits harms constantly. On the other hand, mental suffering can be eradicated. We can identify its causes and eradicate them from the root. So let us therefore generate the motivation to listen to these Lamrim teachings, reflecting on the fact that all we can rely on occasional transitory physical happiness.
Nonetheless, it is mental happiness which is durable and this mental happiness arises through not falling under the sway of these three poisons. To not fall under the sway of the three poisons, we must study the lamrim, which teaches us how to avoid this. As Shantideva says, all physical happiness will definitely turn to suffering and it is evident now that we can see that all physical happiness eventually turns into physical suffering. And Sattriyayama adds, freed from benightedness, one attains true happiness. This true happiness is none other than liberation, the freedom from ignorance.
So within the outline of the path of the being of the middling scope, we have probably completed the presentation of progress generating the mind wishing to be freed from liberation through reflecting on the truth of suffering and the origin of suffering. Then within the outline, we have the twin subdivision of reflecting on the general sufferings of psychic existence and reflecting on the specific sufferings of psychic existence. And as you remember, we have covered reflecting on the specific sufferings of psychic existence subdivided into three, reflecting on the sufferings of human beings, of demigods and of gods. It is important for us to understand that human beings, demigods and gods are all part of cyclic existence and share in its sufferings. Now regarding the noble truth of suffering, the five contaminated aggregates within our mind stream are the noble truth of suffering.
There are some problems in the statement that the truth of, excuse me, the aggregate of form within our mind stream is the truth of suffering. Then the origin of suffering is the afflictions, and indeed this leads us to the noble truth of the origin of suffering, which is the root or the cause of the noble truth of suffering, the afflictions. And here we must identify what the afflictions are. And in this context, in other words, the presentation of the noble truth of the origin of suffering, there are three subdivisions. The mode of generation of the afflictions, how they are accumulated, and how they are conjoined with us at the time of death.
So the cause of suffering and cyclic existence is both karma and the afflictions. However, it is principally the afflictions. Since should the afflictions be absent, however vast amount we may have accumulated of karma, thousands, tens, hundreds of thousands of karmic imprints, they will not ripen. In the same same way as should a seed be planted in the ground with manure and so forth, but not be watered, it will never give rise to a sprout. The afflictions are therefore the cooperative condition necessary for the maturation of karma.
Then who precisely is bereft of the afflictions, the Ahat. An Arhat is a being who irrespective of whatever vast amount of negative karma he may have, he or she may have, has completely eliminated the afflictions by targeting the root of the afflictions, ignorance, with its opposite, which is the wisdom realizing selflessness. Then the happiness which the Arhat attain is immutable mental happiness. This does not mean that they do not experience physical hardship. For instance, Achat grow old.
Don’t think for a moment that once you become Arhat, somehow you will be beautiful and will no longer age. This is not the case. You will age like everybody else. But you will cease to experience mental suffering and will experience unchanging mental bliss. So once one has become an arhat, irrespective of the vast amounts of karma which one has accumulated previously, since the afflictions are absent, this karma will no longer lead to contaminated rebirth.
However, for so long as one has not eliminated the afflictions, the karma we have accumulated previously can be led to maturation by these afflictions and lead to another rebirth. Now in this is the reason for which it is said that we must abandon the afflictions, and to abandon the afflictions, we must identify them. In other words, we must identify their nature or their characteristics. Now Aria Asanga says that the characteristic of the afflictions is to lead one into unsuitable behavior because of mental turbulence. So generally speaking, there is a tenfold subdivision of the afflictions, which I shall not enter into now, we’ll talk about it later.
We shall stop here tonight. So if you have questions, please ask your questions. Ask short, concise questions, one per person. Thank you for holding microphone to your chin so that everyone can hear including the transcribers. My question is about seeing our suffering we feel amidst sadness and this leads us to strive to eliminate self grasping and self cherishing.
Is it likely that when we see our suffering that we are also likely to see the suffering of all beings and therefore experience extreme sadness? Even though we realize the suffering of our own contaminated aggregates, it is not possible to immediately realize the suffering of all sentient beings in this world of ours. This calls for great effort. Did I understand correctly when you suggested that the suffering of change only relates to physical suffering? Because I was unaware that that was the case before tonight.
It is suffering it is, excuse me, happiness which transforms into suffering, which is a suffering of change. Another? Could Geschler expand on why the suffering of change is only a physical suffering? I’m thinking mental change where somebody’s betrayed and things change. It’s not the case that all suffering of change is physical suffering.
The suffering of change comprises both physical and mental suffering. For instance, independence on physical happiness and the controlling condition of the sense organs, physical happiness can give rise to mental happiness. That mental happiness is an instance of the suffering of change. Did I hear correctly that the aggregate of form within the mind stream is the cause of suffering? And if I did hear correctly, what what does why is that the case?
The aggregate form within the mind stream is the cause of suffering. You can’t really say it’s a cause. The aggregate of form within our continuum is the base on which both physical and mental suffering and happiness arise. And nada? I’m not even sure what this question is.
If physical happiness is not infinite and mental suffering is not infinite, and only mental happiness is capable of being infinite. What does that say about the nature of the mind in terms of, like, its its natural state? Is does that mean is mental happiness consonant with the natural state of the mind of the underlying mind? Like I said, it’s not really clear. Yes.
It is the case that the mental happiness which is immeasurable and which arises independence upon hearing, thinking and meditating on the Lamrim, it obtains an uncommon connection with the mind. It basically qualifies the mind. Yet? We are told that we live in a time where the conditions are good to practice. I question this a little bit because when I see poor people overseas that don’t have these conditions they seem to have mental happiness.
So I question that our conditions are really that good to practice because we have more suffering. You have to distinguish between those countries where people are not too uptight about food and drink and make do with whatever there is, and those countries where people are really hungry, suffer from hunger or starvation. Then I doubt that in those countries where people suffer from hunger and starvation, they experience mental happiness since they must rely on their bodies just as we do. Another I was interested in when Geshe was saying that the causes for physical suffering and for physical happiness are the same. And it seemed to me that those two synonymous causes both amount to wanting something and amount to, you know, in other words, desire.
Would that be the case? No, the common cause is not desire. Desire is actually something within our mind stream. What relates physical suffering and physical happiness is dependence on exterior physical objects. This is their uncommon cause.
Thank you. Geshela, was it said earlier on tonight, particularly with mental happiness or no. Sorry. Mental suffering having contradictory causes. Could you elaborate?
So here, when we speak of mental happiness, it is mental happiness in accordance or independence on the Buddhist scriptures. This is indeed incompatible or contradictory with mental suffering since the root cause of mental suffering is none other than self cherishing or self grasping. Self cherishing or self grasping is grasping at a self which is perceived as autonomous. And the antidote to this is the wisdom realizing selflessness. This wisdom realizing selflessness is itself the root of all virtues.
As these two are incompatible or contradictory, their results are also incompatible or contradictory. Just, a follow-up question from the answer given to Jill’s question. I’m just wondering, with the reliance on exterior phenomena as the cause for both physical happiness and physical suffering, why is that called an uncommon cause? The main reason for which we say they are the uncommon cause of both physical and mental happiness is that they are the cause of physical, mental and mental happiness. And in addition, physical and mental happiness do not arise from within the mind.
They arise independence on these exterior physical objects. I’ll reach out. Geshela, I assume that infinite craving for physical happiness is a mental suffering. So in the absence of mental suffering, one will cease to once one’s eliminated mental suffering, I assume that one will cease to crave for physical happiness. And at that point, one will be satisfied at least in terms of one’s physical state, albeit that won’t one be satisfied with one’s physical state at that point?
A being who has generated mental happiness will have less craving for physical happiness. But that craving for a physical happiness which is rooted in physical wealth and so forth will still be present.
Key terms in this teaching
- arhat dra chom pa (Tib)
- The Tibetan translates as "foe destroyer." A person who has destroyed their inner enemy, the delusions, and attained liberation from cyclic existence. LYWA
- contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
- The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
- cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
- The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
- lamrim
- The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
- self-cherishing dag che par dzin pa (Tib)
- The self-centered attitude of considering one’s own happiness to be more important than that of others. LYWA
- self-grasping dag dzin (Tib)
- The mind that apprehends the self as inherently existent. This refers to both the self of persons and the self of phenomena. LYWA
- suffering of change viparinama-duhkhata (Skt); gyurwäi dug ngäl (Tib)
- What is normally regarded as pleasure, which because of its transitory nature sooner or later turns into suffering. LYWA
- three poisons dug sum (Tib)
- Attachment, anger and ignorance. LYWA
Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.