Lam Rim — 2015-04-03

Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)
Lam Rim — 2015-04-03
Loading
/

Audio recorded at Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide. Transcript auto-generated and AI-corrected; may contain errors.

File metadata (for organising)

File: 2015-04-03 – KR.mp3

UUID: 49130e15-8533-4760-b6be-7d2951c02bc7

Teacher: Geshe Jampa Gyaltsen

Collection: Lam Rim (Khensur Rinpoche)

Date: 2015-04-03

Recorded at: Tibetan Buddhist Institute, Adelaide

Duration: 1h 46m

Words: 4,737

Easter is an uncommon time of the year. It is a festival. And during this festival, this religious festival, instead of spending one’s time going on walks and so forth, wasting one’s time motivated by the wish to study dharma, you have chosen to attend this teaching. Then since during this festival, you have chosen to engage in meaningful and important activities, this is a source for rejoicing. During a festival such as this one, once one has generated a good motivation, then one should endeavor to engage in whatever virtuous activities one can engage in.

One should really view this period and these teachings as a retreat. Then when we refer to retreats, whether one engages in a retreat for two or three weeks, two or three months, or as is traditional, two or three years, in every single case, one initially generates a powerful virtuous motivation. And with this powerful virtuous motivation during the retreat, all one’s activities of body, speech, and mind turn into virtue. Our activities during these short teachings are not dissimilar to that. So if during these two or three days motivated by the wish to understand the graduated stages of the path, we focus with virtuous thoughts on the teachings.

This is in no way different from a retreat. This is what retreats are. If we combine the two reflections, first, out of a fear for being reborn in the lower balance to endeavor repeatedly to attain a higher rebirth. In other words, a rebirth as a deity or a human being. And in addition to this, if we repeatedly reflect on death and impermanence, then the prospect of a rebirth in the lower realms will become more and more distant.

This is a practice of the being of the small scope. Then if we reflect well on this, we cannot say this is something we can’t engage in. Then when one refers to abandoning or forsaking the 10 non virtues and engaging in the practice of the 10 virtues in this context, what are these 10 non virtues to be forsaken? They have already been explained. These are the three physical non virtues, the four verbal non virtues, and the three mental non virtues.

So what precisely is this practice we should engage in? It is simply the understanding that during a period such as this one, Easter, we should focus on practice keeping in mind death and impermanence. Then when we focus on these two cycles of meditation, we will see that time passes swiftly, a human life is fleeting. And understanding this, we will endeavor to find a means to attain the higher state of rebirth we aim for. What does this mean?

It is practicing in the light of causality. What is causality? This has been explicitly taught some two thousand five hundred years ago by our teacher, Buddha Shakyamuni. And this leads one to refuge. What precisely is meant by forsaking non virtue and training in virtue?

This is the means which enables us to attain liberation from the lower realms and to be reborn in the higher realms. If we view things in this way, then we will have engaged in the totality of the cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope, starting with the profound meaningfulness of a rebirth of leisure and endowment, which leads immediately to reflection on death and impermanence and on the importance of forsaking non virtue and training in virtue. Who precisely taught the means to forsake non virtue and train into virtue? Our teacher Buddha Shakyamuni. Through engaging in these practices, we will reap the result of these practices which is the attainment of a higher rebirth in future lives.

Therefore, this line of reflection ushers training in all seven of the cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope, the three preliminary cycles and the four main cycles of meditation. Then we have explained most of these meditations of the being of the small scope and it would be ideal if you could recollect them all. If you are unable to do so, you should recollect at least some. This is the basis or the foundation for the practice of the being of the middling scope without which it is impossible. Then we can see that anger, desire and envy arise consistently within our mind stream.

If we analyze what the object of abandonment for the various scopes, the beings of the various scopes are, we can see if we take first the being of the small scope, that the object of abandonment, what is what is to be abandoned by the being of the small scope, are those inappropriate or unsuitable actions motivated by afflictions such as anger. If these are abandoned, one has abandoned what one should abandon during the practice being of the small scope. However, the being of the small scope is not able to abandon anger and the afflictions. This is an important distinction. Then there is not a lot less to add regarding practice.

This covers the totality of the path of the being of the small scope. Then the main practices of the being of the small scope are the Four Noble Truths and the 12 limbs of dependent origination. And one’s understanding of these will arise on this basis. So at this point, one might wonder if one distinguishes between the practice and the attainments of the being of the small scope, if the practice is the attainment. This is not the case.

After studying the practice, one must then engage in this practice and this engagement is the means for the attainment. So having explained what the practice of the being of the small scope is, what precisely are the results or the attainments of the being of the small scope? The results or the attainment is the relinquishment of one’s abode, of one’s garb, and of one’s enjoyment, as well as of one’s relatives. Then setting animals aside, how many human beings would there be in this world? Some 7,000,000,000 or so.

Perhaps not 100%, but almost 99% of all these human beings view as the sole means of happiness reliance on exterior physical phenomena. In other words, what can be seen, heard, smelled, tasted and touched. This is obvious. So this is an easy way of understanding things. Otherwise, if it is explained in terms of relinquishing one’s abode, one’s food, one’s enjoyments and one’s relatives, this will be something which will be inaccessible for you.

So when we refer to relying on exterior material or physical objects as a source of happiness, What do we mean by this? Generally speaking, happiness is subdivided in two, physical and mental happiness. Most of us are completely unaware of the very meaning of mental happiness. Therefore, for us happiness is physical happiness. In other words, reliance on the five sense objects which we understand through the five senses as a source of happiness.

Then when we are totally convinced that happiness arises exclusively in dependence on exterior material objects, this is a mistaken viewpoint. Why is it mistaken? Because happiness is not only physical happiness, it is also mental happiness. Then it is undeniable that physical happiness exists. Physical happiness, however, is temporary.

As has been explained many times here, physical happiness is what we know as the suffering of change. Then in our cases, we are totally focused on the exterior world and convinced to the innermost parts of our being that our happiness is totally dependent on exterior material phenomena. This is not the case And once one focuses inwards, one is able to understand this. Then to put it in really simple terms, happiness has two components, physical and mental happiness. While it is true that exterior physical objects, material objects are necessary for physical happiness, they are not and cannot contribute to mental happiness.

For that matter, we have not accumulated from our side the components, the causes for mental happiness. Once one understands this, one’s attachment to exterior material objects will dwindle. I believe this is the attainment of the being of the small scope. Please listen carefully and generate the motivation for receiving these teachings on this basis. And if there is something you haven’t understood, please take notes and ask questions afterwards.

This is a way to benefit from these teachings. Try to keep your mind within this building and not scattered on the outside. Otherwise, there’s a very high risk you will simply fall asleep. There are numerous quotes to this effect in Shantideva’s Bodhisattvacharyavatara, one of which reads, irrespective of the ascetic activities one engages in and the practices one engages in, there is no benefit if one’s mind is scattered outwards. Then the attainments of the being of the small scope are difficult.

We live in contaminated aggregates. These contaminated aggregates do need food. They do need clothing. They do need objects of enjoyment. So I am in no way saying that one has to give up food, clothing, and objects of enjoyment since we need them to survive.

However, as Shantideva says in Bodhisattva Acharya Avatara, pay your servant his due, but not a penny more unless he is of benefit. Therefore, our body, which is our servant, must be paid its dues, its salary, and then must be put to work. This body of ours is extremely important as is said in another quote, rely on the physical aggregates to accomplish your goal. So without entrusting ourselves completely to exterior material objects, exterior physical objects, we should begin to turn the mind inwards. When we begin to turn the mind inwards, the predilection for exterior physical objects will dwindle.

As this predilection dwindles, we will come closer to the realizations of the being of the small scope. This is easy to understand. Once we have turned the mind inwards and have striven to attain stable happiness from within the depths of the mind, and here from within the depths of the mind simply means from within the mind, then we will move towards the attainment of the being of the middling scope, which is none other than being freed from coarse afflictions such as anger under the sway of which we live at present. If we were to take anger as an example, let alone human beings, animals for that matter, are able to understand the faults or the defects of anger. We can see for instance in the animal realm that if an animal is extremely aggressive, other animals will fear that animal and avoid it.

It is clear that they see the thoughts of anger and aggressivity. Obviously, if animals can see the thought of anger and aggressivity, all the more so human beings. Otherwise, it would be very odd. Although we cannot see anger, we can clearly see its physical manifestations. When another person is overwhelmed with anger, their face completely changes and normal human interaction and dialogue is no longer possible.

So even though anger is not an exterior material phenomenon, we can nonetheless see its force within us. And therefore, we must understand the faults of anger or aggressivity. As Je Tsongkhapa says in his Canticle of Realizations, without understanding the faults of the truth of suffering, striving at liberation will not occur. Now here, the truth of suffering is none other than anger. This is cyclic existence.

And without focusing on its faults, striving and being freed from it will not happen. So what is therefore the object of abandonment of the being of the small scope? The object of abandonment of the being of the small scope are these coarse exterior material and physical entities. The object of abandonment of the being of the middling scope, however, is the afflictions. So once this mind which wishes to be freed from anger, from envy, from coarse desire arises, then the interrogation, what precisely are the causes and conditions of anger, of desire, of envy will occur.

Anger, for instance, does not just arise spontaneously within the mind. And therefore, after first recollecting the object of meditation of the being of the small scope and its object of abandonment, we should then focus on the being of the middling scope and realize that the object of abandonment of the being of the middling scope are the coarse afflictions under the sway of which we live at present. Once one sees the faults of these coarse afflictions, one generates the mind wishing to be free from them, And then one endeavors to find the means to be freed from them. These means are explained in the Lamrim, the graduated stages of the path. If we generate such a motivation for listening to the teachings, it will cover or encompass both the practices of the being of the small and of the middling scope.

Let us therefore think, in other words, meditate on this and endeavor to generate a motivation wishing to be freed from this for a couple of seconds. This is most important. When the mind is focused single pointedly on the topic of observation, in this case, the path of the being of the small scope without being distracted towards anything else. This is what we call meditation. There is no other practice in this.

This is pure meditation. Then generally speaking, there are numerous subdivisions of meditation into fixative meditation and analytical meditation and so forth. What is the focus, the object of abandonment of the practice of the being of the middling scope? In a nutshell, it is cyclic existence. Specifically, these objects of abandonment are desire, they are anger, they are envy whose thoughts must be seen.

So how precisely do we see the faults of afflictions such as anger and so forth? We must initially focus on them and when we focus upon them, we will notice that when they arise, they trouble, they disturb the mind. If we take the instance, let us say, of envy or jealousy. When jealousy arises or envy arises within our mind, then the target, the person towards whom we feel envy, whom we see as being richer than us, happier than us, more handsome than us, generates feelings so intense within us that we are unable to sleep, we are unable to eat and so forth. If we take the case of coarse desire, and this is something we can all identify within ourselves, this is a powerful desire for forms, sounds, smells, tastes, and tactile objects.

When this coarse powerful desire arises with respect, let us say to an exterior beautiful object, we must counter it to reflecting on the thoughts of this object. Then once we have become aware of the thoughts of delusions such as desire and so forth, we must ask ourselves, is it actually possible to abandon them or not? Is this at all realistic? It is possible to abandon them because they are occasional. They do not arise continually within our mind stream.

There is no person who experiences continually desire, continually anger, continually envy. And we all know that from time to time we experience peace and happiness. Therefore, anger, desire and so forth arise from causes and conditions. Then if anger, for instance, were part of the very nature of our mind and was continually present, we’d probably be unable to sleep. So anger is an occasional phenomenon.

If it is occasional, it should be possible to eliminate it. Then if one trains in this way, one will be able to engage in stable study and one’s mind will improve. Then, in brief, the study, the training of the being of the small scope is to focus on the afflictions and to view the afflictions as one’s enemies. It’s very important to understand that more generally speaking, one can say that one should try to abandon the afflictions at the level of the practice of the being of the small scope. The object of abandonment of the being of the small scope is not the afflictions, but is the inappropriate physical and verbal behavior engaged in through the power of the afflictions.

Is it the case that the practice of the being of the middling scope is not easy? It is indeed the case since both the object of meditation and the object of abandonment, the afflictions are not easy to engage in and not easy to abandon. Whereas the objects of meditation and the objects of abandonment of the being of the small scope are easier. They focus on abandoning unsuitable or inappropriate exterior behavior under the influence of the afflictions. Therefore, they do focus mainly on exterior material phenomena.

So it is quite obvious that the practice as well as the goals of the being of the middling scope are more difficult than the practice, the goals and the cycles of meditation of the being of the small scope. And reciprocally, that the practice, the goals and the objects of meditation of the being of the small scope are more easy to engage in than those of the being of the middling scope. This is simply the case because the practice of the being of the small scope is focused outwards, whereas the practice of the being of the middling scope is focused inwards on the mastery of the mind. I remember many years ago before the holy elder, Kensukang Gyrinbache, passed on during his Lamrim teachings that he explained just this and told us this is the way it is, isn’t it? So in the context of the practice of the being of the middling scope, since our goal is to eliminate afflictions such as anger under the sway of which we labor, how precisely do we go about this?

What is the method? Let us give an example. Let us imagine that an area is awash in a gigantic flood. How do we address this issue to help the area? It is very difficult to eliminate the water.

How would we go about it of any way? Instead, the first step is to find the origin of the flood and to try to put an end to the flooding process. Do you understand? Really? That’s good.

Very important. So it’s important to understand the example. Independence on the example, you would understand the meaning. Otherwise, it’s difficult. It is extremely important to recollect the thoughts of the afflictions such as anger and so forth as much as one can.

As is said in the Lamrim, it is through recollecting recollecting the thoughts of cyclic existence that in turn one can give rise to the mind striving for liberation from it. And therefore, I would like to ask you to listen, to listen most carefully and to think on what you hear. When you don’t understand it, something, please write it down and take notes. Then you must ask the question during the question and answer session. Otherwise, our time here will be wasted.

If you proceed in this matter and you think profoundly again and again and ask questions whenever you have your doubts, then your own understanding will increase constantly. It is therefore very important to identify the origin, the source of afflictions such as anger and so forth, which we wish to get, to get rid of. And it is not sufficient for this to just repeat over and again as we do, it is ignorance. It is ignorance. It is indeed the innate apprehension of the self which is a source of this.

But this is something we must reach the conclusion of by our own thinking. Then whether one is referring to ignorance, to the innate apprehension of the self, or to the conception of the transitory collection. These are names referring to the same reality. It is this sense of I I. This is not something on the outside, this is something within or continuum.

What is precisely the mode of existence of this I? There is a passage in referring to this, which says this apprehension of the I is the root of all faults. And there are numerous quotes of such a nature. So what precisely is it? This sense of I and this sense of mine have been explained many times, it’s a profound topic, we will not enter in great detail because we will all get a bit dizzy, but this is what is referred to when we have this strong sense of independent or autonomous I and of things on one’s own side or one’s own party as opposed to the other team.

So based on this sense of I, the mine in turn arises. And we can see this at work when we think of my parents, my relatives, my child. From the I and the mine, in turn, the other and the theirs arise. An independence on my and mine on the one side, and other and theirs on the other side, anger and all of the afflictions arise. So this can best be under understood when seeing that the apprehension of the self is a mistaken mind.

This is very easy to understand. Independence on I and mine, others and theirs arises. And then in the next lives, all of us accept the existence of next lives, but what matters is not next lives in the abstract, but our own next lives, the mental continuum is not interrupted. Therefore, these afflictions, as well as the apprehension of a self, will still be there. If we are reborn in the lower realms, they will be far stronger.

If we are reborn in this type of realm, they will be there to the same degree. As Arya Nagarjuna says in the Ratnavali, for so long as the grasping itself has not been eliminated, for so long would we be enslaved by karma. Karma arises independent of on the grasping or the apprehension of a self. Says in the Three Principles of Path, enchained by the iron fetters of the apprehension of self, befuddled by ignorance, we transmigrate over and again. So thinking in this way, we can see how under the power of the apprehension of a self which unfolds in the 12 limbs of dependent origination, we transmigrate in cyclic existence.

Then at this point, it is important for you to memorize the 12 limbs of dependent origination, starting with ignorance, composition of consciousness and so forth. There are not that many and it is very helpful for this teaching. So what is the purpose of the explanation of the 12 limbs? This context and example will help. Let us imagine that we know somebody who drinks uncontrollably alcohol, beer literally, And this person eventually gets cancer of the liver.

Then we will ask ourselves, if we are rational people, why exactly did he get cancer of the liver? Did he or she get cancer of the liver just because he’s drinking beer or because he’s drinking beer uncontrollably? And this is something we would understand when we think a couple of my relatives have also died of liver cancer and I know that it was related to the uncontrolled consumption of alcohol. And then at this point, we will fear for our own situation, especially if we are a drinker and we will moderate our consumption of alcohol. Then clearly, if we don’t drink at all, this will not really have a big impact on our mind stream.

Now, if we take our present situation, we transmigrate in cyclic existence and this process of transmigration is described by the 12 links or the 12 limbs. We transmigrate under the power of ignorance and ignorance is present in the mind of every single one of us, without exception. And then analyzing the process, we will see that ignorance give gives rise to the link or the limb of compositional factors, karma, and independence on this we transmigrate. Understanding this, we will then endeavor to stop, to put an end to ignorance. As Jeff Van Goel says in his Canticle of Realizations, without reflecting on the noble truth of the origin of suffering, we will not understand how to forsake scientific existence.

So at this point, it is indispensable to identify ignorance. Ignorance is the apprehension of a self. Actually, more precisely, apprehension of an I since there are numerous forms of apprehension of a self. And this beginningless ignorance is what we must counter. So when we refer here to beginning with ignorance, we are referring to the grasping or the apprehension of an I or the view of the disintegrating composite.

And the question which has to be addressed is in whose continuum is this present? It is present in the continuum of all beings who have not generated a path of abandonment. In other words, in the continuum of ordinary beings such as ourselves. So at present, because we have not identified the faults of the afflictions and because we are not convinced of the existence of a liberation from these afflictions, which is a permanent state of affairs, these lines of reasoning do not have a lot of effect on us. But ideally, we would be able to see this and to understand the benefit from future lives onwards.

Even if this is not possible, we would be able to understand the benefit in this life. So what is accumulated in dependence on being motivated by beginningless ignorance, both impelling and completing karma? So how therefore, independence from this apprehension of a self, this mechanism begin? The apprehension of a self gives rise to the sense of I and other, of mine and of others. Independence on this, we then focus, for instance, on our own benefit in future lives.

This aspiration for our own benefit in future lives gives rise to an intent to fulfill one’s own benefit. And in base independence on this intent, we act in keeping with the intent and this is what is understood as karma or deeds. This is somewhat difficult for you to understand, I think. So when motivated by the wish to gain a higher rebirth in future lives, we restrain from non virtuous deeds such as killing, and the intent of that restraint is the attainment of a virtuous rebirth in future lives, then that intent is none other than virtuous impelling karma. And to put it in brief, one will have accumulated impelling karma to be reborn in a higher realm when motivated by the wish to be reborn in that higher realm, motivated by that intent, one restrains from physical and verbal deeds causing, for instance, the death of another being.

This comma is called the impelling karma which gives rise to rebirth in a higher realm. Likewise, still motivated by the profound motivation of the apprehension of an I, when having given rise to this powerful sense of self and others, of mine and theirs, wishing for happiness in this life, one intentionally, verbally, or physically causes the death of another person, this is a non virtuous deed, which is a non virtuous impelling karma. So when, therefore, in brief, one wishes to understand what virtuous impelling karma is, one must distinguish between the profound and the superficial motivation which give rise to a deed of virtuous karma which can be either physical or verbal. So we shall stop here for this morning. And if you have a question, you can ask one question and please make it short.

After that, the other questions will be asked this afternoon. So the profound motivation is the apprehension of an eye or grasping at an I. The superficial motivation in the context of a deed, let us say, of killing or stealing is the intent to kill or to steal based on that profound motivation. So within the context of the presentation of the two truths, here the truth of suffering and the truth of the origin of suffering, which are the nature of cyclic existence. It would be helpful if you read in the great stages of the path, the three pages dedicated to how the truth of the origin of suffering leads one into cyclic existence.

I’ll point this out during the break. So we shall stop here for this morning. More applause, Jason.

Key terms in this teaching

completing karma drubje kyi lä (Tib)
Also called finishing karma, the karmic imprints that ripen to determine the type of experiences we have when we are reborn, as opposed to throwing karma that determines the actual rebirth. LYWA
contaminated aggregates zagchä kyi phung po (Tib)
The aggregates of an ordinary being that are contaminated by the seeds of delusion and therefore pervaded by suffering because they are controlled by delusion and karma. LYWA
cyclic existence samsara (Skt); khor wa (Tib)
The six realms of conditioned existence, three lower - hell, hungry ghost and animal - and three upper - human, demigod and god. LYWA
dependent origination pratityasamutpada (Skt); ten drel (Tib)
Also called dependent arising. The way that the self and phenomena exist conventionally as relative and interdependent. LYWA
higher realms
The higher realms comprise the more fortunate rebirths as a human, god or demi-god. LYWA
lamrim
The graduated path. A presentation of Shakyamuni Buddha’s teachings in a form suitable for the step-by-step training of a disciple. LYWA
lower realms ngen dro (Tib)
The three realms of cyclic existence with the most suffering: the hell, hungry ghost and animal realms. LYWA
two truths den pa nyi (Tib)
The two ways of relating to phenomena, as conventional or all-obscuring truth, the truth to a worldly mind, and ultimate truth, the truth to a mind engaged in ultimate analysis. LYWA

Definitions adapted from the Lama Yeshe Wisdom Archive glossary, as taught in the Gelug tradition.

Scroll to Top